STATE OF HP vs ROOP SINGH

Court
High Court of Himachal Pradesh

1 ( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
High Court of H.P.
Cr. Appeal No. : 150 of 2015
Reserved on : 31.10.2026
Date of decision: 18.11.2026
Uploaded on : 18.11.2026
State of Himachal Pradesh …Appellant.
Versus
Roop Singh & Anr. …Respondents.
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge.
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bhupesh Sharma, Judge.
1
Whether approved for reporting? Yes.
For the Appellant : Mr. Raj Negi, Deputy Advocate
General.
For the Respondents : Mr. Ajay Kochhar, Senior Advocate,
with Ms. Swati Sharma, Advocate.

Bhupesh Sharma, Judge
The State of Himachal Pradesh is in appeal
before this Court against the judgment of acquittal dated
17.11.2014, passed by the learned Special Judge-1, Shimla,
District Shimla, H.P., in Sessions Trial No.3-S/7 of 2010,
titled, ‘State of Himachal Pradesh vs. Roop Singh & Anr.’,
whereby, the respondents (hereinafter to be referred to as the
‘accused persons’), have been acquitted for the commission of
1
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the Judgment? Yes
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

2
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
offences punishable under Sections 18 and 20 read with
High Court of H.P.
Section 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1985, after giving them benefit of doubt.
2. The accused persons were sent to face trial for
the commission of offences punishable under Sections 18
and 20 read with Section 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 by SHO, Police Station
Dhalli, Tehsil and District Shimla, H.P. in case FIR No.149 of
2009 dated 04.09.2009, under Sections 18 and 20 read with
Section 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1985. The accused persons were prosecuted
for the said offences and were subsequently acquitted by the
learned trial Court vide impugned judgment dated
17.11.2014, passed in Sessions Trial No.3-S/7 of 2010,
titled, ‘State of Himachal Pradesh vs. Roop Singh & Anr.’.
3. The case of the prosecution as set out against
the accused persons, in short, is as under:-
3(a). On 04.09.2009, at about 06:30 P.M., at place
near Hasan Valley, within the jurisdiction of Police Station
Dhalli, Tehsil and District Shimla, H.P., the accused persons
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

3
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
were found in joint and conscious possession of 4 kg 100
High Court of H.P.
grams of ‘Opium’ and 500 grams of ‘Charas’ (Cannabis).
3(b). On 04.09.2009, at 02:30 P.M., Inspector Tenzin,
Investigating Officer, CID, Crime Branch, Shimla, left for
routine patrolling and crime detection duty towards
Chharabra, Dhalli etc. vide Rapat No.3 dated 04.09.2009,
from his office. He was accompanied by other Police officials
namely Inspector Lal Singh, SI Rattan Singh and ASI Chet
Ram. The Police party was travelling in official Maruti Gypsy.
The Police party during the course of patrolling reached near
Hasan Valley at 06:30 P.M., where, they spotted two persons
coming on foot from forest road towards main road, out of
which, one person was carrying a white coloured plastic
Gunny Bag. On seeing the Police party, both the persons got
perplexed and frightened and tried to flee. The Investigating
Officer, Inspector Tenzin on seeing their act and conduct got
suspicious, hence, they were apprehended and nabbed. The
name and identity of both of them was ascertained. The
person carrying the Gunny Bag was identified as accused
Roop Singh (A-1) and the person accompanying him was
identified as Om Prakash (A-2). The white coloured Gunny
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

4
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
Bag in possession of the accused persons was searched,
High Court of H.P.
leading to recovery of three plastic containers, out of which,
two containers were of big size. The substance in both the big
containers was checked and found to be 4 kg. 100 grams
‘Opium’ and the small container was found to be containing
500 grams of ‘Charas’ (Cannabis). The accused persons could
not account for the contraband which was recovered from
their possession.
3(c). Pursuant to the recovery of the contraband i.e. 4
kg. 100 grams of ‘Opium’ and 500 grams of
‘Charas’(Cannabis), the Investigating Officer conducted codal
seizure formalities. Two samples of 50 grams each were
drawn from the containers containing ‘Opium’, and were
sealed in separate cloth parcels by affixing four (4) seals of
impression ‘H’. Similarly, two samples of 50 grams each were
drawn from the container containing ‘Charas’ (Cannabis),
which were also sealed in two separate cloth parcels by
affixing two(2) seals impression ‘H’. The remaining
contraband was put in the same ‘Gunny Bag’, which was also
sealed by affixing 12 seals of impression ‘H’. Sample seals
were taken on a separate cloth parcel and the seal ‘H’ after its
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

5
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
use was handed over to SI Rattan Singh. The Investigating
High Court of H.P.
Officer, thereafter, filled relevant columns of NCB-1 Form in
triplicate and the entire case property was taken into
possession vide search, recovery and seizure memo in the
presence of official witnesses i.e. SI Rattan Singh and ASI
Chet Ram. The Investigating Officer, Inspector Tenzin after
completing the seizure formalities scribed rukka and sent the
same through ASI Subhash Chand to Police Station Dhalli,
Shimla for registration of FIR against the accused persons.
3(d). On the basis of disclosure of facts in the rukka,
case FIR No.149 of 2009 dated 04.09.2009, under Sections
18 and 20 read with Section 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 was registered against
the accused persons at Police Station Dhalli, Shimla, District
Shimla, H.P. The Investigating Officer prepared the spot map
and recorded the statements of witnesses under Section 161
Cr.P.C. as per their version. The accused persons were
arrested at 09:00 P.M. on 04.09.2009.
3(e). On 04.09.2009, at 10:00 P.M., Inspector Tenzin,
Investigating Officer produced the case property i.e. four
sealed sample parcels, sample seal impressions and sealed
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

6
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
‘Gunny Bag’ before Inspector Kundan Singh, SHO, Police
High Court of H.P.
Station Dhalli for resealing. The entire case property was
resealed by affixing three (3) seals of impression ‘A’ on each
parcel. The sample resealing impression ‘A’ was taken on
separate piece of cloth. Relevant entries regarding resealing
of the case property in columns No.9 to 11 in NCB-1 form in
triplicate were made and thereafter, the case property was
handed over to MHC, Police Station Dhalli in safe custody.
3(f). On 05.09.2009, the Investigating Officer,
Inspector Tenzin prepared Special Report under Section 57 of
the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985
and delivered the same to Superintendent of Police, Crime
Branch, State CID, Shimla. The requisite entry in this regard
was made in the Special Reports’ Register.
3(g). On 07.09.2009, the sealed samples containing
contraband along with relevant documents were sent for
chemical analysis to State Forensic Science Laboratory,
Junga vide RC No.176 of 2009 dated 07.09.2009. The case
property on being subjected to chemical examination at State
Forensic Science Laboratory was opined to be ‘Opium’ and
‘Charas’ (Cannabis).
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

7
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
3(h). Pursuant to completion of investigation, the
High Court of H.P.
accused persons were found in joint and conscious
possession of 4 Kg. 100 Grams of ‘Opium’ and 500 grams of
‘Charas’ (Cannabis), accordingly, they were found to have
committed the offences punishable under Sections 18 and 20
read with Section 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1985. Therefore, Final Report under Section
173(2) Cr.P.C. was prepared against them and the case was
filed before Learned Special Judge, Shimla. The accused
persons were prosecuted for the commission of offences
punishable under Sections 18 and 20 read with Section 29 of
the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 in
Sessions Trial No.3-S/7 of 2010, titled as ‘State of Himachal
Pradesh v. Roop Singh & Anr.’.
3(i). The learned trial Court after considering the oral
and documentary evidence led by the prosecution acquitted
both the accused persons for the commission of offences
punishable under Sections 18 and 20 read with Section 29 of
the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985
vide impugned judgment of acquittal dated 17.11.2014,
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

8
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
passed in Sessions Trial No.3-S/7 of 2010, titled as ‘State of
High Court of H.P.
Himachal Pradesh vs. Roop Singh & Anr.’.
4. Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the
judgment of acquittal passed by learned trial Court vide
impugned judgment dated 17.11.2014, in Sessions Trial
No.3-S/7 of 2010, titled, ‘State of Himachal Pradesh vs. Roop
Singh & Anr.’, the appellant-State filed the instant appeal
before this Court on following various grounds:-

That the impugned judgment passed by
the learned trial Court is wrong on facts
as well as on law, hence, the same is liable
to be set aside.
 That the impugned judgment is based on
hypothetical reasoning, surmises and
conjectures, hence, liable to be set aside.
 That the learned trial Court has
appreciated the evidence on record in a
slip-shod and perfunctory manner and
has acquitted the accused on the flimsy
grounds.
 That the learned trial Court has not only
failed to view the prosecution evidence in
its proper perspective but at the same
time has set unrealistic standards to
evaluate the direct and cogent prosecution
evidence. The reasoning of the learned
trial Court is manifestly unreasonable and
unsustainable as there was warrant at all
for the trial Court to discard the well
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

9
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
reasoned and consistent testimony of the
prosecution witnesses on material points.
High Court of H.P.
 That the learned trial Court has discarded
the testimony of prosecution witnesses for
untenable reasons in the absence of any
proof of enmity no reasons whatsoever
have been assigned for discarding the
version of official witnesses. The acquittal
in this case is in disregard of material
evidence on record and as such, the same
is unreasonable, therefore, the impugned
judgment is liable to be set aside.
 That the learned trial Court has erred and
wrongly concluded that in the present
case, two view are possible, i.e. one in
favour of the prosecution and another in
favour of the accused. The learned trial
Court further wrongly observed that
because the independent witnesses have
not been associated by the police qua the
recovery of the opium and Charas,
preparation of papers Ext.PW1/A to
Ext.PW1/C, Ext.P-1 to Ext.P-13 and
Ext.DA to Ext.DE. On this ground, the
learned trial Court had given the benefit to
the accused persons despite the fact that
the prosecution witnesses had supported
the prosecution case, but their version
were not relied on the analogy that they
are police officials. It is submitted that
the prosecution has proved the case
beyond all reasonable doubts and thus
there is no question of two views. It is
submitted that the learned trial Court has
erred gravely while dividing evidence in to
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

10
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
pieces and did not read evidence together
to reach the rightful conclusion. It is
submitted that the minor contradictions
in the statements of the prosecution
witnesses are bound to be there owing to
the time taken for recording their
statements in the Court. It is submitted
that in the present case huge quantity of
contraband was recovered from the
accused persons and all the witnesses
have proved that said contraband was
recovered from the exclusive possession of
the accused persons.
High Court of H.P.
 It is submitted that the learned trial Court
has misread and misinterpreted the facts
regarding taking and depositing of the
case property to FSL Junga by PW3, C.
Prama Nand vide RC No.176 of 2009
dated 07.02.2009. PW5 Shiv Kumar has
categorically supported the version of PW3
that the case property was deposited in
FSL Junga vide RC NO.176 of 2009 dated
07.02.2009 and not vide RC No.76 of
2009. as ready by the learned trial Court.
The copy of Malkhana Register and RC are
Ext.PW5/A and Ext.PW5/B. Therefore, the
impugned judgment is bad in the eyes of
law and deserves to be set aside.
5. Therefore, on aforesaid grounds, it is prayed that
the present appeal be allowed and the impugned judgment of
acquittal be set aside.
6. We have heard Mr. Raj Negi, Deputy Advocate
General for the appellant-State, Mr. Ajay Kochhar, learned
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

11
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
senior counsel with Ms. Swati Sharma, Advocate for the
High Court of H.P.
accused persons and have also carefully gone through the
records as well as the findings recorded by the learned trial
Court while passing the impugned judgment dated
17.11.2014.
7. Mr. Raj Negi, Deputy Advocate General, has
strenuously argued that the findings rendered by the learned
trial Court are unsustainable, since, oral and documentary
evidence led by the prosecution was not well appreciated. The
official witnesses of search, recovery and seizure, namely SI
Rattan Singh (PW1), ASI Chet Ram (PW2) and Inspector
Tenzin (PW10) Investigating Officer have fully supported the
prosecution case proving the factum of recovery of 4 Kg. 100
Grams ‘Opium’ and 500 grams of ‘Charas’ (Cannabis) from
the possession of the accused persons. The material
documentary evidence led by the prosecution clearly
established the complicity of the accused persons for being
in possession of the contraband. The learned trial Court
failed to appreciate the oral and documentary evidence in
right perspective, leading miscarriage of justice. Therefore,
the findings of acquittal recorded by the learned trial Court
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

12
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
are perverse and void in the eyes of law and liable to be set
High Court of H.P.
aside.
8. Per contra, Mr. Ajay Kochhar, learned senior
counsel for the accused defended the judgment of the
acquittal passed by the learned trial Court and submitted
that the oral and documentary evidence led by the
prosecution is not sufficient to secure conviction of the
accused persons. Learned counsel for the accused persons
submitted that the link evidence in the present case to
connect the contraband with the State FSL Report (Ext.PX),
the alleged proceedings, sealing of the case property and the
samples is also not beyond the shadow of doubt. It has
further been submitted that ASI Subhas Chand (PW9), who
delivered the Rukka at Police Station Dhalli, never remained
associated during the course of investigation since his name
does not figure in the official record being present on the spot
at the relevant time. Learned counsel for the accused persons
in support of his contentions placed reliance on various
judgments of Hon’ble Supreme Court i.e. State of Rajasthan
vs. Daulat Ram AIR 1980 (SC) 1214, Valsala vs. State of
Kerala, 1993 Supp. 3 SCC 665, State of Gujarat vs.
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

13
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
Ismail U Haji Patel, 2003 (12) SCC 291, State of
High Court of H.P.
Rajasthan vs. Gurmail Singh, 2005 (3) SCC 59, State of
Rajasthan vs. Tara Singh, 2011 (11) SCC 559, State of
Uttar Pradesh vs. Hansraj alias Hansu (2018) 18 SCC 355,
Vijay Pandey vs. State of U.P. 2019 (SC) 3569, Ashok
alias Dangra Jaiswal vs. State of Madhya Pradesh, (2011)
5 SCC 123 as well as the judgments passed by this Court in
case titled ‘Sansar Chand vs. State of H.P. Cr. Appeal
No.93 of 2017’ and ‘Murari Lal vs. NCB, Cr. Appeal
No.389 of 2022’ .
9. Perusal of the record evidently shows that the
learned Trial Court, on considering and evaluating the
material and evidence, found material discrepancies in the
statements of the official witnesses i.e. SI Rattan Singh
(PW1), ASI Chet Ram (PW2) and Inspector Tenzin,
Investigating Officer (PW-10) and on the basis of the said
material contradictions and discrepancies, proceeded by
acquitting the accused persons for the commission of
offences punishable under Sections 18 and 20 read with
Section 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1985.
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

14
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
10. Since, the present appeal has been filed against
High Court of H.P.
the judgment of acquittal, therefore, the scope of powers of
the Appellate Court in the case of an appeal against acquittal
needs to be considered before embarking upon the factual
matrix.
11. The scope of the powers of the Appellate Court in
case of an appeal against acquittal has been elaborately dealt
with by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Muralidhar alias Gidda &
another vs. State of Karnatka reported in (2014) 5 SCC
730 . and Rajesh Prasad vs. State of Bihar & another,
(2022) 3 SCC 471 .
12. Similarly in H.D. Sundara & others vs. State of
Karnataka, (2023) 9 SCC 581 , the Hon’ble Supreme Court
has observed that the appellate court cannot overturn
acquittal only on the ground that after reappreciating
evidence, it is of the view that the guilt of the accused was
established beyond a reasonable doubt.
13. It is more than settled that the powers of
Appellate Court while hearing the appeals against the
acquittal are not unbridled. There is a clear caveat that in
case the view arrived at by the trial Court is a possible one
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

15
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
borne from the material on record, the same cannot be
High Court of H.P.
viewed differently, even if, there is a possibility of any other
view. Reference in this regard can be made to the judgment
passed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in Jafarudheen and
others vs. State of Kerala (2022) 8 SCC 440 , wherein it has
been held as under:
“Scope of Appeal filed against the Acquittal:
25. While dealing with an appeal against
acquittal by invoking Section 378 of the Cr.PC, the
Appellate Court has to consider whether the Trial
Court's view can be termed as a possible one,
particularly when evidence on record has been
analyzed. The reason is that an order of acquittal
adds up to the presumption of innocence in favour
of the accused. Thus, the Appellate Court has to
be relatively slow in reversing the order of the
Trial Court rendering acquittal. Therefore, the
presumption in favour of the accused does not get
weakened but only strengthened. Such a double
presumption that enures in favour of the accused
has to be disturbed only by thorough scrutiny on
the accepted legal parameters.”
14. The present appeal has been filed against a
judgment of acquittal. It was laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Surendra Singh v. State of Uttarakhand,
2025 SCC OnLine SC 176: (2025) 5 SCC 433 that the
Court can interfere with a judgment of acquittal if it is
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

16
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
patently perverse, is based on misreading/omission to
High Court of H.P.
consider the material evidence and reached at a conclusion
which no reasonable person could have reached. It was
observed at page 440:
“12. It could thus be seen that it is a settled legal
position that the interference with the finding of
acquittal recorded by the learned trial judge
would be warranted by the High Court only if the
judgment of acquittal suffers from patent
perversity; that the same is based on a
misreading/omission to consider material
evidence on record; and that no two reasonable
views are possible and only the view consistent
with the guilt of the accused is possible from the
evidence available on record .”
15. Thus, the law on the issue can be summarized to
the effect that in exceptional cases where there are
compelling circumstances, and the judgment under appeal is
found to be perverse, the Appellate Court can interfere with
the order of acquittal. Further, if two views were possible on
the basis of the evidence on record, the Appellant Court
should not disturb the findings of acquittal recorded by the
Trial Court, merely, because the Appellate Court could have
arrived at a different conclusion than that of the Trial Court.
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

17
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
16. The burden of proof in a criminal trial never
High Court of H.P.
shifts and it is always the burden of the prosecution to prove
its case beyond reasonable doubt on the basis of acceptable
evidence. In fact, it is a settled principle of criminal
jurisprudence that more serious the offence, the stricter the
degree of proof required, since a higher degree of assurance is
required to convict the accused.
17. The perusal of the record reveals that it is a case
of chance recovery by the Police party headed by Inspector
Tenzin (PW10) Investigating Officer during routing patrolling
and crime detection duty on 04.09.2009 at about 06:30 P.M.,
at place near Hasan Valley, within the jurisdiction of Police
Station Dhalli, Tehsil and District Shimla, H.P. The Police
party apparently had no prior information regarding the
movement of the accused persons along with the contraband.
Therefore, considering the aforesaid evidence, the provisions
of Section 42 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1985 are neither applicable nor attracted.
Similarly, since the alleged recovery of contraband was
effected from the ‘Gunny Bag’, in possession of the accused
persons, therefore, the provisions of Section 50 of the
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

18
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 are
High Court of H.P.
also not applicable.
18. Now coming to the recovery of the alleged
contraband from the possession of the accused persons.
19. It is the case of the prosecution that the
contraband was recovered from the white coloured ‘Gunny
Bag’, in possession of the accused Roop Singh (A-1). The
contraband i.e. 4 kg. 100 grams ‘Opium’ was recovered from
two big plastic containers and 500 grams ‘Charas’ (Cannabis)
was recovered from the small plastic container. In this
regard, search, recovery and seizure memo Ext.PW1/A can
be referred. As per the prosecution case, recovery of
contraband was effected in the presence of the official
witnesses namely SI Rattan Singh (PW1) and ASI Chet Ram
(PW2). Apparently, Investigating Officer, during the course of
search, recovery and seizure proceedings did not associate
any independent witnesses and the reason assigned for the
same is that the accused persons were apprehended at a
deserted place in a forest area with no locality in the nearby,
therefore, the presence of independent witnesses could not be
secured during the course of proceedings. Therefore, the
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

19
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
entire prosecution case hinges around the evidence of official
High Court of H.P.
witnesses, as referred herein above i.e. SI Rattan Singh
examined as PW1 and ASI Chet Ram examined as PW2.
Therefore, the statements of both these witnesses require
close consideration and scrutiny in order to ascertain the
recovery of the contraband from the possession of the
accused persons.
20. PW-1 SI Rattan Singh, being member of the
Police team has testified that on 04.09.2009, at 02:30 P.M.,
the accused persons were apprehended for being in
possession of a ‘Gunny Bag’ of white colour, which contained
three plastic containers i.e. two big containers containing 4
kg. 100 grams of ‘Opium’ and one small container containing
500 grams of ‘Charas’ (Cannabis). He further testified that
pursuant to the recovery of the contraband, samples were
drawn and the sealing of the case property and sampling
were carried out and the entire contraband was taken into
possession vide recovery and seizure memo Ext.PW1/A in his
presence and in presence of ASI Chet Ram (PW2).
21. PW-2 ASI Chet Ram has also supported the
version of SI Rattan Singh (PW1) on all the material points
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

20
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
and has further supported the contents and recitals of the
High Court of H.P.
recovery and seizure memo Ext.PW1/A.
22. The Investigating Officer, Inspector Tenzin (PW-
10) has deposed that on 04.09.2009, at about 02:30 P.M.,
he along with Inspector Lal Singh, SI Rattan Singh (PW1) and
ASI Chet Ram (PW2) left State CID Crime Branch Office in
official Gypsy towards Chharabra for routine patrolling and
crime detection duty and at about 06:30 P.M., when he was
present near Hasan Valley, he apprehended the accused
persons coming from forest road towards main road i.e. NH-
22. They were in possession of one polythene bag of white
colour with red strips, which was searched on suspicion
leading to recovery of three plastic containers, out of which,
two big containers were containing 4 kg. 100 grams of
‘Opium’ wrapped in polythene papers and third small
container was containing 500 grams of ‘Charas’ (Cannabis)
wrapped in polythene papers. Subsequently, the samples of
‘Opium’ and ‘Charas’ (Cannabis) were drawn, which were
sealed in cloth parcel by affixing sample seals of impression
‘H’ and the entire case property was taken in to possession
vide recovery memo Ext.PW1/A in presence of SI Rattan
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

21
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
Singh and ASI Chet Ram. The Investigating Officer has
High Court of H.P.
further testified the post recovery investigation proceedings
conducted by him.
23. The careful perusal of the evidence of the official
witnesses i.e. SI Rattan Singh (PW1), ASI Chet Ram (PW2)
and Inspector Tenzin (PW10) reveal that there are material
contradictions in their respective statements regarding the
mode and manner, in which, the proceedings were carried
out, which rendered the prosecution version vulnerable and
unbelievable, thereby giving benefit to the accused persons.
24. As per the evidence of SI Rattan Singh (PW1) the
accused Roop Singh (A-1) was carrying a ‘Boru’ (Plastic
Gunny Bag) of white colour, having red strips, in his right
hand, which contained plastic containers containing
contraband. As per the statement of ASI Chet Ram (PW2) the
accused Roop Singh (A-1) was carrying / holding a ‘Gunny
Bag’ having red strips in his right hand and as per the
statement of Inspector Tenzin (PW10), the accused Roop
Singh (A-1) was carrying one polythene bag of white colour
having red strips. On considering the aforesaid evidence, it is
evident that there is no consistency in the statements of
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

22
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
these witnesses whether the accused Roop Singh (A-1) was
High Court of H.P.
carrying one ‘Gunny Bag’ or ‘Polythene Bag’, which allegedly
contained plastic containers with the contraband.
25. It may be pertinent to refer to the recovery and
seizure memo Ext.PW1/A, which describes that the accused
Roop Singh (A-1) was carrying one plastic ‘Boru’ of white
colour with red strips, Rukka Ext.PW6/A refers that the
accused Roop Singh (A-1) was carrying a plastic ‘Boru’ of
white colour. Therefore, considering the oral evidence and
the documents referred, there is material contradiction as to
the description of the ‘Gunny Bag’/Plastic ‘Boru’/Polythene
Bag (Ext. P2).
26. As per the prosecution case, rukka Ext.PW6/A
was scribed and prepared by Inspector Tenzin, Investigating
Officer (PW-10) and was sent to SHO, Police Station Dhalli
along with NCB-1 form in triplicate (Ext.PW6/D) through ASI
Subhash Chand (PW-9) for registration of FIR against the
accused persons under the relevant provisions of law. From
the perusal of the statement of Inspector Tenzin (PW10), he
had entrusted Rukka Ext.PW6/A and NCB-1 form in
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

23
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
triplicate Ext.PW6/D to ASI Subhash Chand (PW-9) for
High Court of H.P.
transmission to Police Station Dhalli.
27. As per the statement of Inspector Kundan Lal
(PW-6), SHO, Police Station Dhalli, on 04.09.2009, at 08:15
P.M., ASI Subhash Chand, who was posted in CID, Shimla,
handed over him Rukka Ext.PW6/A, on the basis of which,
he got registered FIR Ext.PW6/B. At about 10:00 P.M.,
Inspector Tenzin came to the Police Station Dhalli and
handed over to him four sealed sample parcels having four (4)
th
seals of seal impression ‘H’ and 5 parcel which was having
12 seal impressions of seal ‘H’ along with sample of seal ‘H’.
He stated that he resealed all the abovesaid 5 parcels by
affixing three seals of seal impression ‘A’ on each parcel. He
also obtained three samples of seal impression ‘A’ on a piece
of cloth. Inspector Tenzin also handed over to him NCB-1
form in triplicate along with the said case property. He
thereafter filled columns No.9 to 11 of NCB-1 form in
triplicate, which is Ext.PW6/D.
28. As per the evidence of Subhash Chand (PW-9),
he handed over the Rukka Ext.PW6/A and NCB-1 form in
triplicate to SHO, Police Station Dhalli for registration of FIR.
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

24
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
29. Having considered the aforesaid evidence, there
High Court of H.P.
is material contradiction regarding the fact as to when and
who handed over NCB-1 form in triplicate Ext.PW6/D to
Inspector Kundan Singh (PW-6). If the statement of Inspector
Kundan Singh (PW-6) is to be believed then, the said
document was handed over to him by Inspector Tenzin (PW-
10) when he produced the case property and the samples of
contraband for resealing. The aforesaid fact completely
contradicts the statements of ASI Subhash Chand (PW-9) and
Inspector Tenzin (PW-10) in this regard.
30. There are also material contradictions in the
statements of prosecution witnesses as to the exact place
where the accused persons were apprehended and searched
as well as the time of completion of proceedings at the spot
and whether the said proceedings were conducted in the
natural light or in the torch lights.
31. After carefully considering and scrutinizing the
oral and documentary evidence led by the prosecution, the
case of the prosecution as set out against the accused
persons is liable to be discarded for want of clear, cogent and
convincing evidence. The material contradictions, as
::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS

25
( 2026:HHC:49565-DB )
discussed herein above in the prosecution case, are
High Court of H.P.
insufficient for securing conviction of the accused persons.
The learned trial Court has elaborately dealt with all the
material aspects of the prosecution case on the basis of
material and evidence adduced before it and by discarding
the same. This Court does not find any fault with the findings
recorded by the learned trial Court, which are based on
proper appreciation of oral and documentary evidence.
32. In view of the above, the present appeal fails and
it is dismissed.
33. A copy of this judgment along with the record of
the learned Trial Court be sent back forthwith.
34. The appeal is, accordingly, disposed of, so also
the pending miscellaneous application(s), if any.
(Vivek Singh Thakur)
Judge
(Bhupesh Sharma)
Judge
th
18 November , 2026
(Sanjeev)

::: Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:00:18 :::CIS