Mandeep Singh Chandi vs State Of Punjab And Another
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CRM-M-13573-2023 (O&M) 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
129
CRM-M-13573-2023 (O&M)
Date of decision : 19.11.2026
Mandeep Singh Chandi ...Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab and another ...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE MANISHA BATRA
Present:- Mr. Kartik Gandhi, Advocate
for the petitioner.
Ms. Ruchika Sabherwal, Sr. DAG, Punjab.
Mr. Kuldeep Sanwal, Advocate
for respondent No. 2.
MANISHA BATRA, J. (Oral)
1. This petition has been filed under Section 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short 'Cr.P.C.') for quashing of FIR No.110
dated 10.07.2022, registered under Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code,
1860 (for short 'IPC') at Police Station Majitha, District Amritsar (Rural), in
which Sections 420, 468 and 201 of IPC were added later on (Annexure P-1),
along with all the subsequent proceedings arising therefrom.
2. Brief facts of the case are that the aforementioned FIR was
registered on the statement of respondent No.2-Sohan Lal alleging therein
that he plies a Canter vehicle as a driver and has three children, the eldest of
whom was his son Raghav Sharma, aged about 21 years. The petitioner was
doing the work of DJ and sale and purchase of vehicles. Since the year 2005,
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.19 14:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-13573-2023 (O&M) 2
the DJ goods of the petitioner used to be transported in the vehicle of the
complainant and both of them were well acquainted and used to visit each
other's houses. About one and a half years earlier, the petitioner offered to get
his son Raghav Sharma a job in the Corporation at Amritsar and the deal was
settled for Rs.3,50,000/-. The complainant paid Rs.1,50,000/- to the petitioner
as advance in the presence of Parshotam Lal at his house, but no written
agreement was executed. The complainant also handed over to the petitioner
the Aadhaar card, PAN card and bank account details of his son, photocopies
of some documents bearing his signatures and his original matriculation and
senior secondary certificates. It was alleged that the petitioner misused these
documents and fraudulently got a Toyota Etios Liva car bearing registration
No.PB-38-E-1577 registered in the name of Raghav Sharma. The
complainant came to know about it when he received letter No.MTC/422
dated 27.06.2022 from the office of the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Patti
(Annexure P-3). On being asked, the petitioner could not give any
satisfactory reply. His son remained very tense on this account and he told
him that he would talk to the petitioner along with some respectable persons.
However, his son consumed some poisonous substance and was taken to
Floirem Hospital, Amritsar, where he was declared dead during treatment.
The complainant expressed his firm belief that his son had taken this step
being fed up with the petitioner. On this statement, the FIR was registered
under Section 306 of IPC.
3. During investigation, Sections 420 and 468 of IPC were added
vide report No.21 dated 10.07.2022. One empty tin box of 'Fieldphos'
containing three tablets was recovered from a nearby field. As per the report
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.19 14:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-13573-2023 (O&M) 3
of the Chemical Examiner, aluminium phosphide was found in the exhibits.
In his supplementary statement, the complainant stated that he had forgotten
to mention some facts due to shock. He stated that on 07.07.2022, he along
with his son, Parshotam Lal and Shamsher Singh had gone to the house of the
petitioner. There, the petitioner admitted his mistake of getting the car
registered in the name of his son without telling them. He promised to get the
registration cancelled from the office of the SDM, Patti on 08.07.2022, to
give an affidavit about his responsibility for the vehicle and to return the
money and documents. However, on 08.07.2022, the petitioner met them at
Amritsar and refused to get the registration cancelled or to return the money.
When they requested him, he told them that if they would initiate any legal
action, he would cause loss to their life and liberty. As per the complainant,
his son went into depression due to this and ended his life on the next day. On
30.07.2022, the complainant produced a pen drive containing audio
recordings of four conversations with the petitioner and his brother. Dalbir
Singh, Postman, stated that a parcel of the Transport Department addressed to
Raghav Sharma had been received at his branch post office and the petitioner
had collected it by claiming that the mobile number and the mail were his.
The then Motor Transport Clerk, Amandeep Singh, produced the offline
record of the registration of the vehicle. The registration of the vehicle was
later on cancelled by the Registering Authority. The admitted signatures of
the deceased were sent to the Forensic Science Laboratory for comparison.
4. The petitioner was arrested on 01.11.2022. On 02.11.2022, he
made a disclosure statement admitting that he had taken Rs.1,50,000/- and
the documents of Raghav Sharma for getting him a job. He further disclosed
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.19 14:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-13573-2023 (O&M) 4
that he had got the car registered in the name of Raghav Sharma after
purchasing it through dealers Robin Bawa and Manjit Singh Bhullar for
Rs.2,70,000/-. On the basis of his disclosure statement, the car was recovered
from a plot near his house. Since the amount of Rs.1,50,000/- and the original
certificates of the deceased were not recovered, Section 201 of IPC was
added vide report No.27 dated 02.11.2022. According to the reply filed by the
State, the car was originally registered in Uttar Pradesh. It was got re-
registered at Patti in the name of the deceased on the basis of forged
documents by tampering with its chassis number and by showing him as its
first owner. The Senior Superintendent of Police, Amritsar (Rural)
recommended disciplinary action against the then Registering Authority and
the concerned clerk on account of the irregularities noticed in the registration
process. The petitioner was granted regular bail by this Court on 10.02.2023.
The final report was presented against him under Sections 306, 420, 468 and
201 of IPC on 02.01.2023, and the case was committed to the Court of
Session on 10.03.2023.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that the petitioner
has been falsely implicated in this case to pressurise him into accepting the
unjustified demands of the complainant. Even if the allegations made in the
FIR and the final report are taken at their face value, no offence is made out
against him. The solitary allegation is that the deceased remained under stress
after receiving a letter from the office of the SDM, Patti, about a car
registered in his name. There is no allegation of any instigation, incitement or
intentional aid by the petitioner to the deceased to commit suicide, and no
mens rea can be attributed to him. The petitioner and the complainant were
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.19 14:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-13573-2023 (O&M) 5
known to each other and mere calls made before the occurrence cannot make
him liable. There is no proximate link between any act of the petitioner and
the suicide of the deceased. As per the final report itself, the documents for
registration of the vehicle were submitted by the then clerk Amandeep Singh,
who has not attributed any role to the petitioner. Neither the amount nor the
original documents of the deceased have been recovered and the case against
the petitioner rests only on the complaint. The documents now alleged to
have been forged were innocuous documents within the knowledge of both
the parties. The dispute is at best of a civil nature and the FIR has been
lodged to settle old scores. The case is covered by the categories laid down in
State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335 . To buttress his
arguments, learned counsel has relied upon the authorities cited as M.
Arjunan v. State represented by its Inspector of Police, (2019) 3 SCC 315 ,
Ude Singh and others v. State of Haryana, (2019) 17 SCC 301 , Ramesh
Kumar v. State of Chhattisgarh, (2001) 9 SCC 618 , S.S. Cheena v. Vijay
Kumar Mahajan and another, (2010) 12 SCC 190 , Geo Varghese v. State of
Rajasthan and another, 2021 SCC OnLine SC 873 , Gurcharan Singh v.
State of Punjab, (2017) 1 SCC 433 , Uma Shankar Gopalika v. State of
Bihar and another, (2005) 10 SCC 336 , Vijay Kumar Ghai and others v.
State of West Bengal and others, [2022] 1 SCR 884 , Prof. R.K.
Vijayasarathy and another v. Sudha Seetharam and another, (2019) 16
SCC 739 , Binod Kumar v. State of Bihar, (2014) 10 SCC 663 , Parminder
Kaur v. State of U.P. and another, [2009] 15 SCR 430 , Paramjeet Batra v.
State of Uttarakhand, (2013) 11 SCC 673 and Inder Mohan Goswami and
another v. State of Uttaranchal and others, (2007) 12 SCC 1 .
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.19 14:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-13573-2023 (O&M) 6
6. Per contra , learned State counsel has opposed the petition by
relying upon the reply filed on behalf of the State. It is argued that the
petition is not maintainable since the final report has already been presented
and the case has been committed to the Court of Session. The petitioner can
raise all his pleas at the stage of framing of charge. The allegations against
the petitioner are specific. He took money and documents from the
complainant on the pretext of getting a job for his son. He misused the
documents of the deceased and got a car registered in his name on the basis
of forged documents by tampering with the chassis number. The car has been
recovered at his instance. The judgments relied upon by the petitioner do not
apply to the facts of this case. Hence, it is urged that the petition is liable to
be dismissed.
7. Learned counsel for respondent No.2 has adopted the arguments
of the State. He has further argued that the petitioner first cheated the
complainant of his money and then misused the identity of his son. On
08.07.2022, the petitioner refused to undo the wrong committed by him and
threatened them when they asked him to do so. The deceased ended his life
on the very next day, which shows a close link between the conduct of the
petitioner and the suicide. The evidence collected by the investigating
agency, including the recorded conversations, has to be tested during trial.
Therefore, the petition deserves to be dismissed.
8. This Court has heard learned counsel for the parties and has
gone through the record.
9. At the outset, the objection raised by the State about the
maintainability of the petition may be dealt with. The petition was filed on
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.19 14:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-13573-2023 (O&M) 7
13.03.2023 and further proceedings were stayed by this Court on 23.03.2023,
so the charge is yet to be framed. The mere fact that the final report has been
presented and the case has been committed to the Court of Session does not
take away the power of this Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C. In Anand
Kumar Mohatta and another v. State (Government of NCT of Delhi),
Department of Home and another, (2019) 11 SCC 706 , the Hon'ble Supreme
Court held that the High Court can examine whether the offences are prima
facie made out from the FIR, the charge-sheet and the documents, even after
the charge-sheet has been filed. The relevant observations are as under:-
"17. There is nothing in the words of this Section which restricts
the exercise of the power of the Court to prevent the abuse of
process of court or miscarriage of justice only to the stage of the
FIR. It is settled principle of law that the High court can
exercise jurisdiction under Section 482 of Cr.P.C even when
the discharge application is pending with the trial court.
Indeed, it would be a travesty to hold that proceedings initiated
against a person can be interfered with at the stage of FIR but not
if it has advanced, and the allegations have materialized into a
charge sheet. On the contrary it could be said that the abuse of
process caused by FIR stands aggravated if the FIR has taken the
form of a charge sheet after investigation. ..."
10. Therefore, the availability of the remedy of seeking discharge
before the trial Court is no bar to the examination of the matter by this Court.
The material collected in the final report shall also be looked into for this
purpose.
11. Section 306 of IPC provides punishment for abetment of suicide.
Abetment, as defined in Section 107 of IPC, requires instigation, engaging in
a conspiracy or intentional aid. To bring a case within Section 306 of IPC,
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.19 14:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-13573-2023 (O&M) 8
there has to be a clear mens rea on the part of the accused to push the
deceased to commit suicide. There has also to be a positive act on his part,
close in time to the occurrence, which leaves the deceased with no option but
to take his life. In Mahendra Awase v. State of Madhya Pradesh, 2025
INSC 76 , the Hon'ble Supreme Court reiterated these principles. It was held
that a word uttered in a fit of anger or emotion without intending the
consequences to follow is not instigation. It was further held that even heated
exchanges with the deceased shortly before the occurrence would not attract
Section 306 of IPC unless they were intended to leave him with no option but
to commit suicide. The Hon'ble Supreme Court also cautioned the
investigating agencies and the trial Courts against the casual invocation of
this provision. The relevant observations are as under:-
"18. As has been held hereinabove, to satisfy the requirement
of instigation the accused by his act or omission or by a
continued course of conduct should have created such
circumstances that the deceased was left with no other
option except to commit suicide. It was also held that a word
uttered in a fit of anger and emotion without intending the
consequences to actually follow cannot be said to be instigation.
19. Applying the above principle to the facts of the present
case, we are convinced that there are no grounds to frame
charges under Section 306 IPC against the appellant. This is so
even if we take the prosecution's case on a demurrer and at its
highest. ... Viewed from the armchair of the appellant, the
exchanges with the deceased, albeit heated, are not with
intent to leave the deceased with no other option but to
commit suicide. This is the conclusion we draw taking a
realistic approach, keeping the context and the situation in
mind. ...
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.19 14:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-13573-2023 (O&M) 9
20. ... Section 306 IPC appears to be casually and too readily
resorted to by the police. While the persons involved in genuine
cases where the threshold is met should not be spared, the
provision should not be deployed against individuals, only
to assuage the immediate feelings of the distraught family of
the deceased. ... The trial courts also should exercise great
caution and circumspection and should not adopt a play it safe
syndrome by mechanically framing charges, even if the
investigating agencies in a given case have shown utter
disregard for the ingredients of Section 306."
12. Reference can also be made to Mohit Singhal and another v.
State of Uttarakhand and others, (2024) 1 SCC 417 and Prakash and others
v. State of Maharashtra and another, 2024 INSC 1020 , wherein the same
principles were reiterated. In Geo Varghese's case (supra) , relied upon by
learned counsel for the petitioner, it was also observed that if the act
attributed to the accused is not ordinarily expected to induce a similarly
situated person to take the extreme step of committing suicide, it would be
unsafe to hold him guilty of abetment of suicide.
13. Coming to the facts of the present case, there is no suicide note
left by the deceased. In the FIR, the complainant did not attribute any specific
act to the petitioner which could have instigated his son to commit suicide.
He only stated that his son remained tense because of the car registered in his
name and expressed his belief that his son had taken this step being fed up
with the petitioner. The only act close in time to the occurrence is the incident
of 08.07.2022, which finds mention for the first time in the supplementary
statement of the complainant. Even if this version is taken at its face value
and at its highest, the petitioner had refused to get the registration of the car
cancelled and to return the money. He also told the complainant and his son
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.19 14:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-13573-2023 (O&M) 10
that he would harm them if they initiated any legal action against him. Such
conduct, if proved, may show a design on the part of the petitioner to retain
the money and to deter the complainant from approaching the authorities. It
does not show any intention on his part to drive the deceased to take his own
life. The refusal of the petitioner to undo the wrong allegedly committed by
him did not leave the family without any remedy. They were free to approach
the police and the Registering Authority, as was in fact done later on. Close
proximity of time between the incident and the suicide would not by itself be
enough when the intention to instigate the suicide is missing, as held in
Mahendra Awase's case (supra) . The act attributed to the petitioner cannot
be said to be such as would ordinarily induce a similarly situated person to
end his life.
14. The recorded conversations produced by the complainant do not
improve the case of the prosecution under Section 306 of IPC. The final
report does not refer to any portion of these conversations in which the
petitioner is shown to have instigated or provoked the deceased to commit
suicide. The conclusion in the final report regarding this offence rests on the
statements of the complainant discussed above. Thus, even if the entire
material collected by the prosecution is accepted as it is, the basic ingredients
of abetment of suicide are not made out against the petitioner. Requiring him
to face trial for this offence would be an abuse of the process of the Court.
The authorities relied upon by learned counsel for the petitioner on this
aspect, namely M. Arjunan's case (supra) , Ude Singh's case (supra) ,
Ramesh Kumar's case (supra) , S.S. Cheena's case (supra) and Gurcharan
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.19 14:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-13573-2023 (O&M) 11
Singh's case (supra) , also lay down the same principles and support the
petitioner to this extent.
15. Section 201 of IPC makes it an offence to cause any evidence of
an offence to disappear, or to give false information about it, with the
intention of screening the offender from legal punishment. As per the final
report, this offence was added only because the amount of Rs.1,50,000/- and
the original certificates of the deceased could not be recovered. Mere non-
recovery of the amount or of the documents does not show that the petitioner
caused any evidence to disappear with the intention of screening himself
from legal punishment. No other material has been collected in this regard.
Therefore, the offence under Section 201 of IPC is also not made out against
the petitioner.
16. However, the position is different with regard to the offences
under Sections 420 and 468 of IPC. The allegations in the FIR are specific.
The petitioner induced the complainant to part with Rs.1,50,000/- and the
documents of his son on the promise of a job in the Corporation, and no job
was provided. The documents of the deceased were then used to get a car
registered in his name without his knowledge. As per the material collected
during investigation, the car was originally registered in another State and
was re-registered in the name of the deceased on the basis of forged
documents by tampering with its chassis number and by showing him as its
first owner. The car has been recovered on the basis of the disclosure
statement of the petitioner from a plot near his house. The postman has stated
that the petitioner collected the parcel of the Transport Department addressed
to the deceased by claiming it to be his own. The irregularities in the
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.19 14:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-13573-2023 (O&M) 12
registration process have also led to a recommendation for disciplinary action
against the officials concerned. This material, taken at its face value, prima
facie discloses dishonest inducement from the very inception and the making
of false documents for the purpose of cheating.
17. The pleas of the petitioner that the documents were submitted by
the clerk concerned, that the original documents have not been recovered and
that the documents were innocuous and within the knowledge of both the
parties, raise disputed questions of fact. Their truthfulness can be tested only
during trial. While exercising jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C., this
Court cannot hold a mini trial or examine the reliability of the material
collected by the investigating agency, as held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in Neeharika Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra and others,
(2021) 19 SCC 401 . The fact that the complainant himself paid money to
secure a job for his son does not wipe out the alleged deception by the
petitioner. Moreover, the allegation of forgery relates to the registration
record maintained by a public authority. The case, therefore, does not fall
within any of the categories laid down in Bhajan Lal's case (supra) so far as
these two offences are concerned.
18. The other authorities relied upon by learned counsel for the
petitioner do not help him on this aspect. Uma Shankar Gopalika's case
(supra) , Vijay Kumar Ghai's case (supra) and Binod Kumar's case (supra)
were cases in which there was no allegation of deception at the very
inception, and the disputes were found to be essentially of a civil nature
arising out of commercial dealings. Prof. R.K. Vijayasarathy's case (supra)
dealt with the requirement of entrustment for the offence of criminal breach
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.19 14:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CRM-M-13573-2023 (O&M) 13
of trust, whereas Section 406 of IPC does not form part of the final report in
the present case. In Paramjeet Batra's case (supra) , a dispute of a civil
nature had been given the cloak of a criminal offence. In Parminder Kaur's
case (supra) , the alleged forgery was only an innocuous alteration of dates in
an affidavit without any dishonest intention. Here, the allegations are of
misuse of the identity documents of the deceased and of registration of a
vehicle in his name on the basis of forged documents. Such allegations can
neither be described as a civil dispute nor as an innocuous alteration.
19. In view of the above discussion, the present petition is partly
allowed and FIR No.110 dated 10.07.2022 registered at Police Station
Majitha, District Amritsar (Rural), the final report dated 18.12.2022 and all
the subsequent proceedings arising therefrom are quashed qua the petitioner
insofar as they relate to the offences under Sections 306 and 201 of IPC. The
proceedings against the petitioner for the offences under Sections 420 and
468 of IPC shall continue in accordance with law. The interim order dated
23.03.2023 stands vacated. The trial has remained stayed since March 2023,
so the learned trial Court shall make an endeavour to conclude it
expeditiously.
20. It is made clear that nothing observed herein shall be construed
as an expression of opinion on the merits of the case regarding the offences
under Sections 420 and 468 of IPC.
19.11.2026 (MANISHA BATRA)
Waseem R. Ansari Waseem R. Ansari Waseem R. Ansari Waseem R. Ansari
JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether reportable Yes/No
MOHAMMAD WASEEM ANSARI
2026.11.19 14:13
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document