M/S. S N CHATTTERJEE AND COMPANY vs STATE OF WEST BENGAL AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Rajarshi Bharadwaj
And
The Hon’ble Justice Sudip Deb
FMA No. 1649 of 2025
With
CAN 1 of 2025
M/s. S N Chatterjee and Company
-Vs-
State of West Bengal & Ors.
For the Appellant : Mr. Abhratosh Majumdar, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Sayan Sinha
Mr. Kausheyo Roy
Mr. Gaurav Gupta
For the State : Mrs. Manju Agarwal, Sr. Adv.
Heard on : 14.10.2026
Judgment on : 19.11.2026
Sudip Deb, J.:-
th
1. This intra-Court appeal arises out of an order dated 25 August, 2025
whereby the Learned Single Judge disposed of the writ petition, inter alia,
th
directing that the order dated 24 April, 2024 passed by the Proper Officer
should be treated as show-cause notice. By the said impugned order, the
th
appellant was directed to respond to the said order dated 24 April, 2024 by
treating the same as show-cause notice within a period of three weeks from
2
date. It was also clarified by the said impugned order that in the event the
appellant responds to the show-cause within the aforesaid period or in the
alternative fails to respond the show-cause, the Proper Officer, upon giving
an opportunity of personal hearing to the appellant shall hear out and
dispose of the aforesaid matter within a period of four weeks thereafter.
2. It was further clarified by the said impugned order that if the appellant does
not respond to the show-cause within the period no further opportunity of
filing response to the show-cause shall be required to be given to the
appellant and in such case, the Proper Officer shall be obliged to decide the
same in accordance with law within the aforesaid period.
3. Being aggrieved by the said order the instant appeal has been preferred by
the appellant.
4. The learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant submitted that the
order impugned is perverse inasmuch as the order of the Proper Officer
could not be treated as show-cause notice and the same is contrary to the
provisions of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, which is
hereinafter referred to as “the said Act”.
5. He further submitted that the figure mentioned in the show-cause notice
and the final demand as contemplated under section 73 of the said Act are
at variance as the demand made in the said adjudication order has exceeded
the demand in the show-cause notice. It is also submitted that section 75(7)
of the said Act creates a bar to make any demand in the adjudication order
in excess of the amount specified in the show-cause notice. As such, it is
argued that the impugned order should be set aside.
3
6. The learned counsel appearing for the State submitted that the State does
th
not have any objection to treat the aforesaid order dated 24 April, 2024 as
show-cause notice.
7. Heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and perused the record.
8. The issues that fall for consideration are firstly, whether the order of the
Proper Officer can be treated as show-cause notice or not. Secondly, whether
demand in the order of the Proper Officer can exceed the demand in the
show-cause notice or not.
9. In order to decide the aforesaid issues, it is important to ascertain the facts
of the instant case, which are narrated hereinbelow:-
a) The appellant during the period from April, 2018 to March, 2019
had regularly filed monthly returns of outward supplies in Form
GSTR-1 under section 37 of the said Act, 2017 read with Rule 59
of the West Bengal Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017 along with
monthly return of self-assessment in Form GSTR-3B under section
39 read with Rule 61(5) and annual return/reconciliation
statement in Form GSTR-9/GSTR-9C under section 44 of the said
Act read with Rule 80 of the Rules.
b) During the said period from April, 2018 to March, 2019 the
th
appellant was awarded a work order dated 5 May, 2018 by M/s
Eastern Coalfields Limited (hereinafter referred to as “ECL”) for
loading of coal by payloader at MIC and transportation of coal from
MIC to POCP-I siding, Jhanjra Project Colliery, Jhanjra area. The
appellant completed the said work to the full satisfaction of ECL
4
th
and consequently ECL issued a completion certificate dated 20
January, 2020 in favour of the appellant.
th
c) The ECL also issued another work order dated 26 July, 2018 in
favour of the appellant for transportation of sand from Pirthanghat,
Ramnagarghat and Sidhaghat of Ajay River to Newkenda basjuri
sand bunker of Kenda area.
d) According to the appellant the supply of “Transport of Goods by
Road Services” falls under the category of “Goods Transport Agency
Services” (GTA) classifiable under SAC 9967 chargeable to tax @
5% (2.5% CGST + 2.5% SGST) and under Serial No. 1 of State
th
Notification No. 1137-FT dated 28 June, 2017 read with Serial
th
No. 11 of the State GST Rate Notification No. 1135-FT dated 28
June, 2017, issued by the Government of West Bengal, which is
payable by the recipient under reverse charge mechanism.
rd
e) In this regard ECL also issued a certificate dated 3 May, 2021
bearing Ref. No. GM/KND/AFM/720 declaring that ECL had duly
discharged the GST liability under reverse charge mechanism on
transportation of sand executed by the appellant as inwards
supply under GTA service. According to the appellant, it had also
discharged tax liability at 18% on loading contract, i.e., the part of
the contract that deals with that aspect of loading of coal and
sand.
f) According to the appellant, Sl. 21(b) of the Notification No.
th
12/2017, Central Tax (Rate) dated 28 June, 2017 exempts
5
payment of GST where consideration charged for transportation of
goods on a consignment transported in a single carriage does not
₹
exceed 1500/-. In this regard, ECL also issued a communication
th
dated 30 April, 2021 bearing Ref. No. GM/AFM/20-21/1185
clarifying that no GST is charged/paid on RCM on such
aforementioned transportation of coal within the specified
condition.
g) Thereafter, the Assistant Commissioner of State Tax, Durgapur
th
Charge, on 6 October, 2023 issued a notice in FORM GST ASMT-
10 under section 61 of the said Act for the period April, 2018 to
March, 2019 intimating the appellant of the discrepancies found in
the return after scrutiny which ultimately triggered the demand
and recovery proceedings in terms of section 73 of the said Act.
h) Although the appellant failed to submit a reply in FORM GST
th
ASMT-11 in response to the aforementioned notice dated 6
October, 2023, however, during the scrutiny the appellant had
duly submitted the requisite documents such as work orders,
inward and outward supply details, tax invoices etc. manually
before the Assistant Commissioner of State Tax, Durgapur Charge.
th
i) Thereafter, on 20 November, 2023 the Assistant Commissioner of
State Tax, Durgapur Charge issued FORM GST DRC-01A to the
appellant for the period April, 2018 to March, 2019 intimating the
appellant that tax/interest/penalty to the tune of
Rs.2,94,26,791.67/- under the head CGST and
6
Rs.2,94,26,791.67/- under the head SGST is payable by the
appellant in terms of Section 73(5) of the said Act on the ground of
the following discrepancies:-
a) The appellant allegedly claimed excess Input Tax Credit (ITC)
as there was mismatch between ITC availed in GSTR-3B
and GSTR-2A and import data from ICE GATE 2.
b) The appellant allegedly imposed a wrong rate of GST leading
to short payment of tax.
By virtue of these, the appellant was directed to make full
th
payment by 6 December, 2023.
th
j) Subsequently, on 26 December, 2023 the Deputy Commissioner
of State Tax, Durgapur Charge, Directorate of Commercial Taxes,
Government of West Bengal issued a show-cause notice to the
appellant in FORM GST DRC-01 under Section 73 of the said Act
for the period April, 2018 to March, 2019 on account of the
aforesaid discrepancies in the returns for the aforesaid period. The
appellant was also directed to submit a reply to the said show-
th
cause notice by 30 January, 2024. The date of personal hearing
th
of the aforementioned issues was scheduled on 10 January, 2024
at 2 p.m. at the office of the Deputy Commissioner of State Tax,
Durgapur Charge, Directorate of Commercial Taxes, Government of
st
West Bengal. Thereafter, on 1 January, 2024 the authorized
representative of the appellant appeared before the Deputy
7
Commissioner of State Tax, Directorate of Commercial Taxes,
Government of West Bengal and submitted that during financial
year 2018-2019 outward taxable supply of the appellant was
₹ 2,24,91,726.89/- and the corresponding CGST was
₹ 20,24,255.42/- and SGST was ₹ 20,24,255.42/-. The appellant
had paid the said tax amount within the stipulated time and the
authorized representative of the appellant submitted a copy of
GSTR-1 for the month of April, 2019 in support of his claim
wherein the mentioned outward supply invoice number
th
SNC/PL/18-19/26 dated 11 March, 2019 was reflected. He also
produced statements and relating supporting invoices at the time
of the personal hearing.
st
k) The appellant also on 31 January, 2024 submitted a reply in
response to the show-cause notice issued in FORM GST DRC-01.
Regarding issue number 1, the appellant stated that the appellant
did not claim excess ITC in GSTR-3B. The appellant clarified that
since a few suppliers had not seeded their tax invoice in their
GSTR-1 so the difference in CGST of ₹ 47,485/- and SGST of
₹ 47,485/- occurred. The appellant being the recipient of the
respective supplies is in possession of the tax invoice copies of
those suppliers. Regarding issue number 2, the appellant
submitted that during the financial year 2018-2019 outward
taxable supply was ₹ 2,24,91,726.89/ - , thus, CGST of
8
₹ 20,24,255.42/-, and SGST of ₹ 20,24,255.42/- had been paid by
the appellant within the stipulated time.
l) As per the work order, the appellant paid all applicable GST
liabilities as FCM. Therefore, according to the appellant the onus of
the recipient of services to pay tax under RCM. In view of such, the
appellant requested the Deputy Commissioner of State Tax,
Durgapur Charge, Directorate of Commercial Taxes to drop the
proceeding initiated under section 73 of the said Act.
th
m) Thereafter, on 18 April, 2024 FORM GST DRC-03 vide ARN
AD190424013885W was issued to the appellant for payment of tax
in terms of issue number 1 raised in the show-cause notice in
FORM GST DRC-01. The appellant reversed the excess claim of
ITC, i.e., CGST of Rs.93,731/- and SGST of Rs.93,731/- which is
inclusive of interest at 18%.
th
n) The appellant, thereafter, on 19 April, 2024 appeared through its
authorized representative before the said authority, namely, the
Deputy Commissioner of State Tax, Durgapur Charge, Directorate
of Commercial Taxes, Government of West Bengal and produced
th
GST DRC-03 vide ARN AD190424013885W dated 18 April, 2024.
th
o) Thereafter, on 24 April, 2024 the said authority, namely, Deputy
Commissioner of State Tax, Durgapur Charge, Directorate of
Commercial Taxes, Government of West Bengal issued an order
under section 73 of the said Act in GST DRC-07 for the period
April, 2018 to March, 2019 raising the demand of payment of tax
9
along with interest and penalty, i.e., CGST of Rs.3,03,88,943/-,
and SGST of Rs.3,03,88,943/- for the period April, 2018 to March,
2019.
p) It appears from the show-cause notice as well as the summary
order of the Proper Officer that the figures mentioned in the show-
cause notice are at variance with the figures mentioned in the
order of the Proper Officer as the demand in the adjudication order
exceeds the demand in the show-cause notice.
10. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid order of the Proper Officer, the appellant
had filed the writ petition, inter alia, making the following prayers:-
a. Declaration that the appellant engaged in supply of “Goods
Transport Service by Road” falling under the category of “Goods
Transport Agency Services” classified under SAC 9967 under Serial
th
No. 1 of Notification No. 1137-FT dated June 28 , 2017 read with
Serial No. 11 of the State GST Rate Notification No.1135-FT dated
th
28 June, 2017 and the GST for the same at the rate 5% payable
by the recipient of the service under the reverse charge
mechanism.
b. Quash, rescind and/or cancel the impugned show-cause notice
th
and summary of show-cause notice dated 26 December, 2023
th
and the impugned order dated 24 April, 2024 for the period
between April, 2018 – March, 2019.
11. As stated hereinabove, the Learned Single Judge had disposed of the writ
petition directing the order of the Proper Officer to treat it as show-cause
10
notice for the petitioner to respond the same. While doing so, the Learned
Single Judge had taken into consideration that ordinarily a demand under
section 73(9) of the said Act can only be confirmed provided a demand cum
show-cause in this regard be made under section 73(2) of the said Act having
regard to the provisions of section 75(7) of the said Act as also that penalty
had been enhanced without informing the petitioner. Based on these, the
Learned Single Judge came to the conclusion that the order of the Proper
th
Officer dated 24 April, 2024 should be treated as show-cause notice for the
petitioner to respond to the same. The Learned Single Judge by this
impugned order fixed a timeframe for the petitioner to respond to the show-
cause notice and other consequential directions had also been given.
12. As stated hereinabove, the principal question that arises for consideration is
whether the Learned Single Judge was justified in directing that the
adjudication order passed by the Proper Officer be treated as a show-cause
notice.
13. Undoubtedly, the order of the Proper Officer is an order of a quasi-judicial
authority. The order of a quasi-judicial authority cannot be treated as show-
cause notice as the same is final or substantive adjudication. It is the result
of a proceeding where the authority has applied his mind to the facts and the
law, recorded reasons and determined the rights of the parties, liabilities or
penalties. Show-cause notice is the initiation of a proceeding based on which
Proper Officer being a quasi-judicial authority proceeded and came to its
finding. A show-cause notice initiates the adjudicatory process by informing
the noticee of the allegations and the proposed demand, thereby affording an
11
opportunity to respond thereto. An adjudication order, on the other hand, is
the culmination of such process, whereby the competent authority upon
consideration of the material facts and submissions of the parties
determines the liability, if any, of the noticee. The two instruments are,
therefore, distinct in their nature, purpose and legal effect. An adjudication
order, therefore, cannot be converted to a show-cause notice.
14. Therefore, we are of considered view that the finding of the Learned Single
Judge by directing to treat the order of the Proper Officer as show-cause
notice cannot be sustained in law and is accordingly set aside.
15. The next question that falls for consideration is whether the Proper Officer
was competent to confirm a demand in excess of the amount specified in the
show-cause notice.
16. Section 75(7) of the said Act expressly provides that the amount of tax,
interest and penalty demanded in the adjudication order shall not exceed the
amount specified in the notice. The provision further stipulates that no
demand shall be confirmed on grounds other than those specified in the
notice.
17. Section 75(7) of the said Act is quoted hereinbelow:-
“ 75. General provisions relating to determination of tax. - …
xxx
(7) The amount of tax, interest and penalty demanded in the order shall
not be in excess of the amount specified in the notice and no demand shall
be confirmed on the grounds other than the grounds specified in the
notice.”
12
18. In the present case, it appears from the material on record that the amount
specified in the show-cause notice and the amount confirmed by the Proper
Officer are at variance. The show-cause notice, as stated hereinabove,
quantified the proposed liability at ₹ 2,94,26,791.67/- under each of the
th
heads of CGST and SGST, whereas the adjudication order dated 24 April,
2024 confirmed a demand of ₹ 3,03,88,943/- under each of the said heads.
19. Therefore, the Proper Officer had acted contrary to the aforesaid provision of
law while making excess demand in the adjudication order. It would be
impermissible for an authority to confirm a demand in excess of the amount
specified in the show-cause notice in view of the express bar contained in
section 75(7) of the said Act.
20. In view of such, we are also of the considered view that the order of the
4th
Proper Officer dated 2 April, 2024 is not sustainable in law and
accordingly, we set aside the same.
21. We make it clear that the adjudication order is set aside solely on the ground
that the demand confirmed therein exceeds the amount specified in the
show-cause notice in contravention of section 75(7) of the said Act. We have
not expressed any opinion on the merits of the allegations contained in the
show-cause notice or on the substantive tax liability of the appellant. We
also make it clear that though the adjudication order of the Proper Officer is
set aside but that does not invalidate the show-cause notice. The
respondents shall, however, be at liberty to proceed further strictly in
accordance with law subject to the statutory limitations and observations
13
made hereinabove. The instant appeal is allowed to the extent as indicated
hereinabove. CAN No. 1 of 2025 is also disposed of accordingly.
22. There shall be no order as to costs.
23. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be given to the
parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
I Agree.
(Rajarshi Bharadwaj, J.) (Sudip Deb, J.)