Cholamandalam M.S General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs Shakuntala And 4 Others

Court
Allahabad High Court

A.F.R.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
FIRST APPEAL FROM ORDER No. - 2788 of 2026
Cholamandalam M.S General Insurance Co. Ltd.
.....Appellant(s)
Versus
Shakuntala And 4 Others
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Saurabh Srivastava
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Nand Lal Yadav
Court No. - 54
HON'BLE ANIL KUMAR-X, J.
1. Heard Shri Saurabh Srivastava, learned counsel for the appellant-
Insurance Company and Shri Nand Lal Yadav, learned counsel for the
respondent-claimants.
2. By means of the present appeal, the appellant has assailed the judgment
and award dated 15.06.2006 passed by the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal in MACP No. 48 of 2017 (Shakuntala & Ors. vs. Kamlesh
Yadav and Anr.), whereby compensation of Rs.24,86,912/- along with
interest at the rate of 7% per annum has been awarded in favour of the
claimant-respondents.
3. Learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that all the three
respondent-claimants are married daughters of the deceased, Champa.
The claim petition was instituted seeking compensation on account of the
death of Champa, who succumbed to her injuries sustained in a motor
accident dated 12.11.2016 while travelling as an occupant in Jeep No. UP
50F 4961.
4. It is submitted that although married daughters may fall within the
ambit of legal representatives of the deceased and may, in an appropriate
case, be entitled to compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act, they
cannot claim compensation under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act
merely by virtue of being legal representatives, particularly when they
were not dependent upon the deceased. According to learned counsel,

FAFO No. 2788 of 2026
2
being legal representatives, they could, at best, claim compensation under
Section 140 of the Motor Vehicles Act. In support of the aforesaid
submission, learned counsel for the appellant has placed reliance upon the
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Deep Shikha & Anr. vs.
.
National Insurance Company Ltd. & Ors., 2025 INSC 675
5. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent-claimants has
submitted that married daughters cannot be deprived of compensation
merely on the ground that they were married or were not financially
dependent upon the deceased. It is contended that, being legal
representatives of the deceased, they are entitled to maintain a claim
under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act. Reliance has been placed
upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in National Insurance
,
Company Limited vs. Birender and others, (2020) 11 SCC 356
wherein it has been held that even major married and earning sons of the
deceased being legal representatives, have a right to apply for
compensation in a case arising out of an accidental death.
6. Learned counsel has further relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Seema Rani and others vs. The Oriental Insurance
, wherein it has been
Company Limited & Ors., 2025 INSC 192
observed that there is no justification for excluding a married daughter
from the ambit of compensation. Reliance has also been placed upon the
judgment in Jitendra Kumar and another vs. Sanjay Prasad and
, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court
another, AIR Online 2025 SC 758
has held that even a major married and earning sons of the deceased,
being legal representatives, have a right to apply for compensation and
that it is the bounden duty of the Tribunal to consider such application,
irrespective of the fact whether the legal representative was wholly
dependent upon the deceased, and that the claim cannot be confined
merely to conventional heads.
7. I have considered the submissions advanced by learned counsel for the
parties and have perused the record.
8. The controversy involved in the present appeal is confined only to a
short question of law, namely, whether a married daughter or married son
of a deceased person, who died in an accident, merely by virtue of being

FAFO No. 2788 of 2026
3
a legal representative, is entitled to compensation under Section 166 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, or whether, in the absence of dependency, such
claim is liable to be confined to the extent permissible under Section 140
of the Motor Vehicles Act.
9. The expression “legal representative”, occurring in Section 166 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, came to be considered by the Hon'ble Supreme
Court for the first time in
Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation
vs. Ramanbhai Prabhatbhai and another , AIR 1987 SC 1690 . The
Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the expression “legal representative”
ordinarily means a person who, in law, represents the estate of the
deceased. At the same time, keeping in view the object and purpose of the
Motor Vehicles Act, the expression was held to have a wider connotation
and was not to be confined to the traditional concept of legal heirship.
10. The said definition of "legal representative" as discussed by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, if considered literally, each and every person,
who in either way is related to a deceased person, will come within the
meaning of "legal representative" and hence he could be considered for
grant of compensation. The said proposition was much clear in a later
judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Manjuri Bera vs. Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd. & Anr. (2007) 10 SCC 643 wherein it was held that
the expression “legal representative” is wider in scope than the expression
“legal heir” and cannot necessarily be confined to the wife, husband,
parent or child of the deceased. But in the said judgment, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court also discussed that while considering the claim of a legal
representative, a clear distinction shall be drawn between the right to
maintain a claim petition and the determination of the quantum of
compensation payable to such claimant. It was held that a Court, while
determining the quantum of compensation in case of legal representative
of a deceased, shall also decide the loss of dependency which has
occurred to the legal representative on account of the death of deceased.
11. Therefore, the concept, which has been repeatedly relied upon by
Hon'ble Supreme Court, cannot be ignored while considering the claim
for compensation by a legal representative. It is incumbent upon a court to
first determine, particularly in case of married sons and married
daughters, as to whether they are merely legal representatives or also have

FAFO No. 2788 of 2026
4
suffered any loss of dependency on account of the death of the deceased.
12. In respect to the issue involved in this case, it will be relevant to refer
to the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in (supra) where
Deep Shikha
the Hon'ble Supreme Court, while reiterating the same view as adopted by
earlier judgments of Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Ramanbhai Prabhatbhai
(supra) and Manjuri Bera (supra), held that ordinarily, upon marriage, a
daughter becomes a member of her matrimonial household and is
presumed to be financially supported by her husband or his family, unless
the contrary is established by evidence.
13. Thus, the said sequence of judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
since the year 1987 till the year 2025 has clearly held that “legal
representative” is one thing and the loss of dependency of legal
representative is another aspect, which has to be considered by the
Tribunal at the time of determining the compensation. The judgments
relied upon by the learned counsel for the respondent-claimants indicates
that the compensation to the legal representative has been granted
although they were married sons and married daughters by applying the
provisions of Section 166 MV Act, but none of the judgments has
discussed the scope of legal representative and the entitlement of a legal
representative who has suffered loss of dependency as has been
thoroughly discussed in (supra),
Ramanbhai Prabhatbhai Manjuri
Bera (supra) and Deep Shikha (supra).
14. Therefore, this Court is of the view that above judgments in
Ramanbhai Prabhatbhai (supra), Manjuri Bera (supra) and Deep
(supra) will prevail over the judgments relied upon by the
Shikha
respondent-claimants.
15. In the present case, it was not disputed that the respondent-claimants
were not in any way dependent upon the deceased mother. Therefore,
once it was proved that the respondent-claimants were merely legal
representatives and were not dependent upon the deceased, the
compensation awarded to them by applying the provisions of Section 166
MV Act is not sustainable in view of the law laid down by Hon'ble
Supreme Court in (supra). Thus, this Court is of the view
Manjuri Bera
that amount of compensation which the respondent-claimants are entitled

FAFO No. 2788 of 2026
5
shall be determined by the provisions of Section 140 of MV Act.
Accordingly, the amount of compensation awarded by the Tribunal
requires modification.
16. For the reasons recorded hereinabove, the present appeal is partly
. The judgment and award passed by the Tribunal is modified to
allowed
the extent that, instead of the amount of Rs.24,86,912/-, the respondent-
claimants shall be entitled to receive compensation of Rs.50,000/- under
Section 140 of the Motor Vehicles Act. The aforesaid amount shall be
apportioned equally amongst all the respondent-claimants.
(Anil Kumar-X,J.)
October 5, 2026
SK
Digitally signed by :-
SUSHEEL KUMAR
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad