GOVINDA SARKI vs The State Rep. by its Inspector of Police,

Court
Madras High Court

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Date of Reserving the Judgment Date of Pronouncing the Judgment
29.09.2026 13.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE M. NIRMAL KUMAR
CRL A No. 793 of 2025
CNR: {HCMA011302452025}
Govinda Sarki
S/o.Dalbahathoor Sarki,
No.1/12, Rice Mill Road, Jalladianpet,
Medavakkam, Kancheepuram - 600 100.
(Now confined at Central Prison, Puzhal-I)
..Appellant(s)
Vs.
The State Rep. By its
The Inspector of Police
W7, All Women Police Station,
Anna Nagar,
Chennai – 600 040.
(Crime No.201/2023)
..Respondent(s)
Prayer:- Criminal Appeal filed under Section 415(2) of B.N.S.S., to call for the
records and set aside the judgment passed by the learned Sessions Judge,
Special Court for Exclusive Trial of Cases under POCSO Act, Chennai, in
Special SC.No.198 of 2023, dated 21.03.2025.
For Appellant(s): Dr.S.Manoharan
For Respondent(s): Ms.Sharada Vivek
Additional Public Prosecutor
Assisted by
Mr.M.Arulraj
JUDGMENT
This Criminal Appeal is directed against the judgment dated 21.03.2025
passed in Special Sessions Case No.198 of 2023 by the learned Sessions Judge,
__________
Page 1 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
Special Court for Exclusive Trial of Cases under the Protection of Children
from Sexual Offences Act, Chennai (hereinafter referred to as “the Trial
Court”).
2 . Since the case involves offences under the Protection of Children from
Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (hereinafter referred to as “the POCSO Act”), the
identity of the child victim is not disclosed in this judgment. She is hereinafter
referred to as “the victim” or “PW2”.
3 . By the judgment dated 21.03.2025, the Trial Court convicted the
appellant/accused and imposed the following sentences:
Sl.No. Offence Sentence Imposed
1. Section 6 @ 4 of POCSO Act 10 years imprisonment and fine of
Rs.5,000/-, in default, to undergo one
month simple imprisonment
2. 366 of I.P.C. 3 years imprisonment and fine of
Rs.5,000/-, in default, to undergo one
month simple imprisonment
The sentences were directed to run concurrently, with the benefit of set-off
under Section 428 Cr.P.C. The Trial Court also directed payment of
compensation of Rs.1,00,000/- to the victim under Section 33(8) of the POCSO
Act.
__________
Page 2 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
4 . Prosecution case :-
4.1 . The case of the prosecution, in brief, is as follows:-
4.2 . PW2 is the victim, aged about 13 years at the relevant point of time.
She was residing with her parents and had three siblings, two of whom were
being brought up by their grandparents in Nepal. The victim and her youngest
sibling were residing with their parents at Anna Nagar, Chennai.
4.3 . On 18.06.2023, at about 4.00 p.m., the victim left her house to go to
Tower Park, Anna Nagar. There, she met the appellant, who had been known to
her for a few months. They had been communicating over the phone and
meeting each other regularly.
4.4 . On the same day, at about 6.00 p.m., the appellant took the victim to
a nearby shop, namely, Ganga Sweets, Anna Nagar, and bought her ice cream.
Thereafter, by using persuasive and affectionate words, the appellant compelled
the victim to accompany him and took her to S.M. Hospital, K.K. Nagar, where
he was working. Though the victim resisted, the appellant forced her to
accompany him.
4.5 . The appellant had projected himself as an unmarried bachelor and
represented that he was in love with the victim.
4.6 . Since the victim did not return home, PW1, her mother, started
searching for her. As PW1 was not conversant with Tamil or English, either
spoken or written, she contacted her brother, PW3. Thereafter, along with PW3,
she went to K4 Anna Nagar Police Station and lodged a complaint.
__________
Page 3 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
4.7 . PW6, the Sub-Inspector of Police, received the complaint and
registered a case in Crime No.201 of 2023. He thereafter visited the scene of
occurrence, prepared the Observation Mahazar (Ex.P4) and Rough Sketch
(Ex.P10) in the presence of the witnesses, Prem and Balaji, and examined the
parents of the victim and the mahazar witnesses.
4.8 . Subsequently, the investigation was taken over by PW7, the
Inspector of Police, K4 Anna Nagar Police Station. During the investigation, on
verification through the Cyber Crime Wing, it was ascertained that the victim
had frequently contacted the appellant through her mobile phone.
4.9 . On 21.06.2023, PW7 went to the appellant's residence and rescued
the victim from his custody. Thereafter, the victim was sent for medical
examination.
4.10 . PW5, the Doctor, examined the victim on 24.06.2023 and issued the
Accident Register (Ex.P6) and Medical Examination Report (Ex.P7).
4.11 . The appellant was subsequently produced before PW4, the Doctor,
who examined him on 20.07.2023 and issued the Potency Certificate (Ex.P5).
4.12 . Thereafter, a Bonafide Certificate relating to the victim was
obtained from PW9. PW7 also seized the mobile phone of the appellant (M.O.1)
under the Seizure Mahazar (Ex.P11). Subsequently, the relevant penal
provisions were altered through Alteration Reports (Exs.P12 and P13).
4.13 . Thereafter, PW8, the Inspector of Police, W7 All Women Police
Station, Anna Nagar, took up further investigation, altered the penal provisions
__________
Page 4 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
through Alteration Report (Ex.P14) and, upon completion of the investigation,
filed the final report against the appellant on 07.08.2023.
4.14 . During the trial, the prosecution examined PW1 to PW11, marked
Exs.P1 to P16 and produced M.O.1 and M.O.2.
4.15 . On the side of the defence, the appellant examined himself as DW1,
his sister as DW2 and a person from his native place as DW3.
4.16 . Upon completion of the trial, the Trial Court convicted the appellant
and imposed the sentences as stated supra.
5 . Submissions on behalf of the appellant:-
5.1 . The learned counsel appearing for the appellant submitted that PW1
is the mother of the victim. The Trial Court itself recorded PW1 knew only
Hindi and not conversant with any other language. Hence, her evidence was
recorded with the assistance of an interpreter/translator.
5.2 . PW1 admitted that her brother, PW3, who knew Tamil accompanied
her to the Police Station and had written the complaint (Ex.P2). Her evidence
was only to the effect that the appellant had pulled the victim by her hand and
forcibly taken her to his brother's house, where she was made to stay for three
days. Thus, the evidence of PW1 was confined to the alleged forcible abduction
of the victim and did not establish the commission of any sexual offence.
5.3 . PW3 is the brother of PW1. His evidence is that the Observation
Mahazar relating to the house where PW1 and PW2 were residing was prepared
in his presence. No Observation Mahazar was prepared either at the alleged
__________
Page 5 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
place of abduction, namely, Anna Nagar Tower Park, or at the room occupied
by the appellant at K.K. Nagar. His evidence was also confined to the victim
going missing and her subsequent rescue.
5.4 . PW4 is the Doctor who examined the appellant and issued the
Potency Certificate.
5.5 . PW5 is the Doctor who examined the victim on 24.06.2023 recorded
Accident Register (Ex.P6) that the victim was in a love relationship with the
appellant and had voluntarily accompanied him and stayed with him at K.K.
Nagar. Though the victim is stated to have disclosed that she had sexual contact
with the appellant during her stay, there is nothing in the medical record to
establish that the alleged contact was forceful penetrative sexual assault.
5.6 . The learned counsel further submitted that, in the Medico-Legal
Examination Report (Ex.P7), it was specifically recorded that there were no
external injuries, bite marks or scratch marks on the victim's body and that her
hymen was not intact.
5.7 . Though a scratch mark was referred to in Ex.P6, the same was relied
upon to infer that the appellant had committed forcible penetrative sexual
assault. The fact that the hymen was not intact could be attributable to various
reasons. Even PW5, in her final opinion, had only stated that there was a
possibility of sexual intercourse. Hence, the medical evidence did not establish
the commission of penetrative sexual assault.
__________
Page 6 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
5.8 . PW6 is the Sub-Inspector of Police who received the complaint,
registered the FIR and prepared the Observation Mahazar and Rough Sketch.
5.9 . PW7 is the Inspector of Police, K4 Anna Nagar Police Station, who
conducted a substantial portion of the investigation, arrested the appellant,
seized the mobile phone (M.O.1) and altered the penal provisions. He admitted
that Ex.P1 was furnished by PW1 and that he had not examined any school
authorities to ascertain the age of the victim.
5.10 . PW8 is the Inspector of Police, W7 All Women Police Station,
Anna Nagar, who received the case diary on 24.06.2023, completed the
investigation and filed the final report.
5.11 . The learned counsel further submitted that PW2 admitted that she
studied Classes I to V in Rajasthan, thereafter, studied Class VI in Nepal and
subsequently came to Chennai, where she continued her studies in Class VI.
5.12 . However, PW9, the Headmistress, admitted that the school
concerned offered classes only up to Class V. Therefore, the educational
particulars relied upon by the prosecution to establish the age of the victim is
doubtful.
5.13 . PW1 had categorically admitted that she knew only Hindi and was
not conversant with any other language. Ex.P1, the Bonafide Certificate, is in
English. Therefore, merely marking Ex.P1 would not establish the victim's date
of birth or age, in the absence of any corroborative material.
__________
Page 7 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
5.14 . The learned counsel also drew the attention of this Court to the
further investigation conducted after the completion of the evidence of the
prosecution witnesses.
5.15 . PW11 had produced the victim before the Government Rajiv
Gandhi Hospital, Chennai, for medical examination. PW10, the Doctor,
examined the victim and issued the report (Ex.P15). The Dentist's Report and
Age Estimation Report (Ex.P16) were also produced.
5.16 . Ex.P15 was issued by Dr.V.Parimala, who was not examined as a
witness. Though PW10 stated that an ossification test conducted and a report
had been obtained from the Radiologist, the relevant ossification test report and
radiological opinion not produced.
5.17 . The learned counsel further submitted that, on a perusal of Ex.P16,
it could be seen that there was no reference to any ossification test report or
radiological findings. M.O.2, the X-ray, was also produced without a study
report from the Radiologist. Therefore, the Trial Court was not justified in
fixing the age of the victim at 14 to 15 years on the basis of such insufficient
materials.
5.18 . The learned counsel further submitted that PW2 is the victim and
her evidence, in the absence of corroboration, requires careful scrutiny to
ascertain whether it possesses the sterling quality necessary to sustain a
conviction.
__________
Page 8 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
5.19 . PW2 admitted that she was in love with the appellant, that both of
them were in regular contact and that she used to meet him at Tower Park. On
18.06.2023, she herself called the appellant to come to the park. Both of them
spent time together, went to Ganga Sweets, had ice cream and thereafter,
proceeded to K.K. Nagar.
5.20 . Though the prosecution projected that the appellant forcibly taken
her in an autorickshaw, the victim neither raised any alarm nor shown any
resistance until she reached K.K. Nagar. She continued to stay with the
appellant for three days till the police came in search of her.
5.21 . PW2 further admitted that she stayed in the house of the appellant's
brother-in-law along with the appellant, his brother-in-law and sister. There
were three other inmates in the house, and she used to sleep along with them. In
such circumstances, the possibility of the appellant committing penetrative
sexual assault highly doubtful.
5.22 . To overcome this situation, prosecution projected that during
lunchtime on one of the days when the victim was allegedly alone with the
appellant, penetrative sexual assault committed. According to the learned
counsel, this allegation was not supported by the medical evidence in Exs.P6
and P7.
5.23 . The Forensic Science Laboratory Report (Ex.P8) not detected the
presence of semen or spermatozoa.
__________
Page 9 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
5.24 . The learned counsel further submitted that the appellant examined
himself as DW1, sister as DW2 and a person from his native place as DW3.
5.25 . DW1 and DW2 supported the defence version that the victim had
stayed with them happily and requested them not to inform her parents about
her whereabouts. According to the defence, the victim was not treated properly
by her parents, particularly her father, who was addicted to alcohol and used to
assault the victim and her mother while under its influence. Therefore, the
victim was unwilling to return to her parental home and was residing with the
appellant and his sister’s family voluntarily.
5.26 . The learned counsel further submitted that the prosecution had also
attempted to establish that the appellant had concealed the fact of his marriage
and had thereby, deceived the victim to develop an interest and affection
towards him.
5.27 . However, such an allegation, by itself, could not establish
kidnapping or commission of penetrative sexual assault, particularly, when the
medical evidence and other circumstances were contrary to the oral testimony
of the victim. Further, no evidence produced to show the appellant’s earlier
marriage.
5.28 . The victim initially stated that the appellant had committed
penetrative sexual assault on one occasion, but subsequently improved her
version by stating that it had occurred on two or three occasions. Such material
__________
Page 10 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
improvements rendered her evidence doubtful and unreliable, not supported
with medical evidence.
5.29 . The learned counsel reiterated that the age of the victim had not
been established in accordance with law. Ex.P1, the Bonafide Certificate, and
the evidence of PW9 did not conclusively establish her date of birth. PW1 does
not know English, whereas the certificate is in English.
5.30 . Further, the medical evidence not conclusively established that the
victim was a minor. Even assuming that the medical estimation placed her age
between 15 and 17 years, the permissible margin of two years ought to be
considered. Therefore, according to the learned counsel, the victim could not be
conclusively treated as a minor at the time of the alleged occurrence.
5.31 . It is further submitted that, after the prosecution completed its
evidence by examining Pws.1 to 8, further investigation was conducted to fill up
the lacunae pointed out by the defence. PW11 admits that, except for producing
the victim before PW10 for medical examination, she had not collected any
further evidence or examined any other witnesses. More particularly, the
incriminating circumstances emerging from the evidence of PW9 to PW11 not
put to the appellant during his examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C. The
appellant was questioned only with reference to the evidence of PW1 to PW8.
Therefore, the evidence of PW9 to PW11 could not be used against him without
affording him an opportunity to explain the same.
__________
Page 11 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
5.32 . On the above grounds, the learned counsel submitted that the
prosecution failed to establish the charges beyond reasonable doubt. On the
contrary, the appellant had probabilised his defence. However, the Trial Court
failed to consider the material contradictions, deficiencies in the investigation
and the inconsistencies between the oral and medical evidence. Hence, the
conviction and sentence are liable to be set aside.
6 . Submissions on behalf of the prosecution:-
6.1 . Per contra, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor strongly
opposed the contentions of the learned counsel for the appellant and submitted
that both the appellant and the victim hail from Nepal. The victim's father was
employed at Anna Nagar, Chennai, and her mother was engaged in household
work. The victim had three siblings, two of whom were being brought up by
their grandparents in Nepal. The victim was residing with her parents and
attending school at Chennai. Her date of birth was 28.12.2009, which stood
established through Ex.P1 and the evidence of PW9, the Headmistress.
Therefore, she was undoubtedly a minor at the time of the occurrence.
6.2 . The learned Additional Public Prosecutor further submitted that,
since both the appellant and the victim hail from Nepal, they got acquainted
with each other and developed a friendly relationship. They were in regular
communication and had been in a love relationship for a few months.
__________
Page 12 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
6.3 . On 18.06.2023, when the victim went to meet the appellant at Tower
Park, Anna Nagar, the appellant forcibly took her in an autorickshaw to K.K.
Nagar, where he stayed.
6.4 . Since the victim not returned home, her mother, PW1, went in search
of her. As PW1 was not conversant with Tamil or English, she contacted her
brother, PW3, and lodged a complaint before K4 Anna Nagar Police Station.
6.5 . PW6 received the complaint, registered the FIR, visited the scene of
occurrence and prepared the Observation Mahazar and Rough Sketch.
6.6 . Thereafter, PW7 took up investigation, recorded the statements of the
witnesses and, upon tracing the victim, rescued her from the custody of the
appellant at K.K. Nagar on 21.06.2023. The victim was brought to the Police
Station, her statement was recorded and she was thereafter sent for medical
examination.
6.7 . PW5 examined the victim and issued the Accident Register and
Medical Examination Report (Exs.P6 and P7 respectively). The victim was also
produced before the learned Magistrate, where her statement under Section 164
Cr.P.C. was recorded (Ex.P3).
6.8 . The appellant was thereafter produced before PW4, who examined
him and issued the Potency Certificate (Ex.P5). Swaps collected from the victim
were sent for forensic examination, and the Forensic Science Laboratory Report
was marked as Ex.P8. Subsequently, PW7 altered the penal provisions and filed
the Alteration Reports (Exs.P12 and P13), incorporating Sections 366A IPC and
__________
Page 13 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
Section 4 of the POCSO Act. Thereafter, PW8 took up further investigation,
collected the relevant materials and filed the Alteration Report (Ex.P14),
altering the provisions to Sections 366A IPC and Section 6 of the POCSO Act,
and filed the final report.
6.9 . During the trial, PW1 to PW8 examined and Exs.P1 to P14 marked.
Subsequently, further investigation was conducted pursuant to an application. In
the course of further investigation, PW9, the Headmistress, PW10, the Police
Surgeon, and PW11, holding Investigating Officer examined, and Exs.P15 and
P16 marked.
6.10 . PW9 confirmed the date of birth of the victim and stated that she
was a minor at the time of the occurrence. PW10 also spoke about the age
estimation examination, the Radiologist's report and the Dentist's report, which,
according to the prosecution, established that the victim was a minor.
6.11 . The learned Additional Public Prosecutor submitted that the defence
had examined the appellant as DW1, his sister as DW2 and a friend from his
native place as DW3. The prosecution produced M.O.1, the mobile phone, and
M.O.2, the X-ray.
6.12 . On a consideration of the entire evidence and materials on record,
the Trial Court rightly convicted the appellant. Hence, the learned Additional
Public Prosecutor sought dismissal of the appeal.
7. Discussion and findings:-
__________
Page 14 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
7.1 . I have considered the rival submissions made by the learned counsel
appearing for the appellant and the learned Additional Public Prosecutor and
perused the entire materials available on record.
7.2 . In the present case, PW2 is the victim and the primary witness to the
alleged occurrence. The central question that arises for consideration is whether
her evidence, in the absence of independent corroboration, inspires confidence
and possesses the requisite sterling quality to sustain the conviction.
7.3 . PW1 is the mother of the victim, and PW3 is her brother. Their
evidence is to the effect that, on 18.06.2023, the victim had gone to Tower Park,
Anna Nagar, not returned home. Thereafter, PW1, along with PW3, went to the
Police Station and lodged a complaint with PW6, the Sub-Inspector of Police.
7.4 . PW6 received the complaint, registered the case, visited the scene of
occurrence, prepared the Observation Mahazar (Ex.P4) and Rough Sketch
(Ex.P10), and recorded the statements of PW1 and PW3. Thereafter, the
investigation was handed over to PW7, the Inspector of Police, who recorded
the statements of the witnesses and subsequently traced the victim in the house
where the appellant was staying with his sister and brother-in-law. On
21.06.2023, the victim was rescued and brought to the Police Station.
Thereafter, she was sent for medical examination.
7.5 . PW5 is the Doctor who examined the victim on 24.06.2023 and
issued the Accident Register (Ex.P6).
7.6 . A perusal of Ex.P6 reveals that the victim admits that she was in a
__________
Page 15 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
love relationship with the appellant for about two to three months. The appellant
was working as a watchman in a nursing home at K.K. Nagar.
7.7 . It is recorded that the victim had voluntarily accompanied the
appellant and stayed with him and the family of his brother-in-law for two days.
She was subsequently identified and brought to the Police Station on
21.06.2023 at about 12 noon.
7.8 . The medical record further refers to the victim having disclosed that
sexual assault committed once during her stay with the appellant.
7.9 . The crucial question that arises is whether the sexual contact was
penetrative in nature and whether the prosecution has established the
commission of penetrative sexual assault.
7.10 . In the Accident Register (Ex.P6), there is a reference to nail scratch
marks over both breasts of the victim. However, PW5 admitted that such scratch
marks could also have been self-inflicted. The victim not informed the reason
for the nail scratch marks. Further, in the Accident Register, only cursory
remarks noted and detail examinations on the body is made subsequently.
7.11 . On a perusal of the Medico-Legal Examination Report (Ex.P7), it is
evident that no external injuries noticed on any part of the victim's body. More
particularly, no bite marks or scratch marks recorded on the breasts. There were
also no external injuries, contusions or bleeding.
7.12 . Though it is recorded that the hymen was not intact, such a
__________
Page 16 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
condition may arise due to various other reasons. The final opinion of the
Doctor was only to the effect that there was a possibility of sexual intercourse.
Therefore, the medical opinion is merely indicative of the possibility of sexual
intercourse and does not, by itself, establish that penetrative sexual assault had
taken place.
7.13 . It is true that the absence of injuries or the absence of seminal traces
cannot, by itself, rule out the commission of sexual assault. Equally, the
condition of the hymen cannot be treated as conclusive proof of sexual
intercourse or penetrative sexual assault. However, in the present case, the
medical evidence has to be considered along with the other circumstances and
the testimony of PW2.
7.14 . PW2 admitted that she had stayed with the appellant for about three
days in the house of the appellant’s sister and brother-in-law. She further
admitted that they were all staying together and sleeping together in the same
house.
7.15 . The appellant, to probabilise his defence, examined himself as DW1
and his sister as DW2. Their evidence is to the effect that the victim was staying
with them during the relevant period.
7.16 . The prosecution has not placed any independent material to
establish the incident of penetrative sexual assault.
7.17 . The only specific incident spoken to by the victim is that, on one
__________
Page 17 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
occasion, during lunchtime, when she was alone, the appellant came there and
committed penetrative sexual assault. However, when this allegation is
considered along with the medical records, the absence of external injuries and
the other circumstances, this Court finds that the prosecution evidence does not
inspire sufficient confidence to sustain the finding of penetrative sexual assault
in the manner alleged.
7.18 . The next important aspect to be considered is the age of the victim.
7.19 . The prosecution relied upon Ex.P1, the Bonafide Certificate, and the
evidence of PW9, the Headmistress, to establish that the victim's date of birth
was 28.12.2009. However, the evidence of PW1 assumes significance in this
regard. PW1 admitted that she knew only Hindi and was not conversant with
any other language. Ex.P1 is a certificate issued in English, and the prosecution
has not satisfactorily explained the circumstances under which the date of birth
was furnished and recorded in the school documents.
7.20 . PW9, the Headmistress, in her cross-examination, stated that the
victim's parents had furnished her date of birth and that the same was entered in
the school register. However, the school register itself was not produced and
proved before the Court.
7.21 . Further, PW2 stated that she had studied Classes I to V in
Rajasthan, thereafter, studied Class VI in Nepal and subsequently, came to
Chennai, where she continued her studies in Class VI. However, PW9 admitted
that the school concerned in Chennai offered classes only up to Class V and did
__________
Page 18 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
not have a Class VI.
7.22 . This material discrepancy cast serious doubt on the educational
particulars relied upon by the prosecution. In the absence of the school register
and other reliable supporting documents, Ex.P1 cannot be treated as conclusive
proof of the victim's date of birth.
7.23 . The prosecution thereafter sought to establish the age of the victim
through medical examination.
7.24 . In this regard, PW10, the Police Surgeon, examined and Exs.P15
and P16 marked.
7.25 . Ex.P15 was issued by Dr.V.Parimala, who was not examined as a
witness. PW10 relied upon the Dentist's Report and the medical materials
available for the purpose of age estimation. However, on a perusal of Ex.P16, it
is seen that there is no clear reference to the relevant ossification findings, the
radiological observations or the basis on which the final opinion of age was
arrived at.
7.26 . Though PW10 stated that an ossification test conducted and a report
obtained from the Radiologist, the relevant report and the corresponding
radiological findings not produced to satisfactorily establish the fact before the
Court.
7.27 . M.O.2, the X-ray produced, but without the supporting report of the
Radiologist.
7.28 . In such circumstances, Ex.P16 does not provide sufficient material
__________
Page 19 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
to conclusively establish the age of the victim.
7.29 . PW11, the holding Investigating Officer, who conducted the further
investigation, admitted that the further investigation was undertaken pursuant to
the orders passed by this Court in Crl.O.P.No.7638 of 2024, dated 05.04.2024.
She further admitted that her role was confined to producing the victim before
PW10 for medical examination and that she had not examined any other
witnesses or collected any further documentary evidence. Thus, even the
subsequent medical examination does not satisfactorily resolve the doubts
surrounding the age of the victim.
7.30 . In this regard, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, in Akula Raghuram v.
State of Andhra Pradesh , reported in 2025 INSC 185 , has considered the
permissible margin of error in determining age through ossification examination
and the necessity of taking into account the margin of two years on either side.
Applying the said principle to the facts of the present case, when the
documentary evidence regarding the victim's date of birth is doubtful and the
medical age estimation is not supported by the necessary materials, the
prosecution has not satisfactorily established the age of the victim.
7.31 . Even assuming that the medical estimation indicates an age range of
15 to 17 years, the permissible margin of error has to be considered in assessing
the prosecution's case.
7.32 . The next question is whether the appellant had kidnapped the victim
__________
Page 20 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
within the meaning of Section 366 IPC.
7.33 . The evidence of PW2 is that she had known the appellant for a few
months and that both of them were in regular contact. She admitted that she had
called the appellant to come to Tower Park, Anna Nagar, on 18.06.2023. She
further admitted that both of them spent time together in the park, went to
Ganga Sweets and had ice cream before proceeding to K.K. Nagar.
7.34 . The prosecution has projected that the appellant forcibly took the
victim in an autorickshaw. However, the evidence of PW2, considered as a
whole, does not satisfactorily establish the alleged force or the circumstances in
which she was taken away.
7.35 . The victim did not raise any alarm, show any resistance, or make
any attempt to seek help or attract the attention of others during the journey to
show that she had been abducted. Instead, she stayed at the house of the
appellant's sister and brother-in-law for about three days without any resistance.
7.36 . Though the victim's age and consent are distinct legal
considerations, the circumstances surrounding her departure and subsequent
stay are relevant in assessing whether the ingredients of the offence under
Section 366 IPC have been established.
7.37 . The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in S.Varadarajan v. State of
Madras , reported in AIR 1965 SC 942 , has explained the distinction between
taking a minor away from the lawful guardianship of her parents and the minor
voluntarily accompanying another person.
__________
Page 21 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
7.38 . The principle laid down therein requires the Court to examine
whether the accused had actively taken or induced the minor to leave the lawful
guardianship, or whether the minor had voluntarily accompanied the accused.
7.39 . In the present case, the evidence regarding the victim's prior
acquaintance and relationship with the appellant, having called him to Tower
Park and the circumstances in which they proceeded to K.K. Nagar assumes
significance.
7.40 . On an overall assessment of the evidence, the prosecution has not
satisfactorily established the allegation of forcible taking or the necessary
ingredients of the offence under Section 366 IPC.
7.41 . The next issue is whether the testimony of PW2 can independently
sustain the conviction.
7.42 . The law is well settled that the evidence of a victim of sexual
assault does not require corroboration as a matter of rule. If the testimony is
reliable, trustworthy and inspires confidence, a conviction can be based upon
her sole testimony. However, where the evidence suffers from material
contradictions, improvements or inconsistencies, the Court has to carefully
examine whether the testimony is sufficiently reliable to form the basis of
conviction. In this regard, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, in Rai Sandeep v. State
(NCT of Delhi) , reported in (2012) 8 SCC 21 , explained the concept of a
sterling witness and the qualities expected of such testimony.
__________
Page 22 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
7.43 . In the present case, PW2 initially referred to one incident of sexual
assault. Subsequently, in her statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C., recorded on
01.07.2023, she gave further details regarding the penetrative sexual assault.
There are also variations in her account regarding the number of occasions on
which the sexual assault took place. These variations have to be considered
along with the medical evidence in Exs.P6 and P7, the absence of corresponding
external injuries and the circumstances, in which, the victim stayed with the
appellant and his family.
7.44 . The Forensic Science Laboratory Report (Ex.P8) does not disclose
the presence of semen or spermatozoa. Though the absence of such forensic
evidence cannot, by itself, disprove sexual assault, the totality of the
circumstances in the present case creates a reasonable doubt regarding the
prosecution version.
7.45 . The defence examined DW1, DW2 and DW3 to establish that the
victim had voluntarily accompanied the appellant and was residing with him
and his family willingly.
7.46 . The evidence of the defence witnesses cannot be discarded merely
because they are related to or acquainted with the appellant. Their testimony has
to be assessed on its own merits and in the light of the other evidence available
on record.
7.47 . In the present case, the evidence of DW1 and DW2 is consistent
__________
Page 23 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
with the circumstances admitted by PW2 regarding her stay in the house along
with the appellant's brother-in-law and sister.
7.48 . The defence version that the victim was unwilling to return to her
parental home also assumes relevance when considered with the evidence
regarding her prior relationship with the appellant and the circumstances of her
stay. Thus, the defence has succeeded in probabilising its version, thereby,
creating a reasonable doubt in the prosecution case.
7.49 . Another important aspect requiring consideration is the examination
of the appellant under Section 313 Cr.P.C.
7.50 . It is not in dispute that PW9 to PW11 were examined subsequently,
pursuant to the further investigation. Their evidence related substantially to the
age determination of the victim and the medical materials collected during the
further investigation. However, the incriminating circumstances emerging from
their evidence were not put to the appellant during his examination under
Section 313 Cr.P.C.
7.51 . The appellant was questioned only with reference to the evidence of
PW1 to PW8.
7.52 . The object of examination under Section 313 Cr.P.C. is to afford the
accused a fair and reasonable opportunity to explain the circumstances
appearing against him in the evidence.
7.53 . Any incriminating circumstance which is proposed to be relied upon
__________
Page 24 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
against the accused must ordinarily be put to him so that he may offer his
explanation.
7.54 . In the present case, the evidence of PW9 to PW11 not put to the
appellant, and he was not afforded an opportunity to explain the circumstances
emerging therefrom. In such circumstances, this part of evidence cannot be used
against the appellant to his prejudice without complying with the mandatory
requirement of Section 313 Cr.P.C.
7.55 . On a cumulative consideration of the oral and documentary
evidence, this Court finds that the prosecution has failed to establish the age of
the victim beyond reasonable doubt through reliable documentary or medical
evidence.
7.56 . Further, the allegation of forcible taking has not been satisfactorily
established. The evidence of PW2 regarding the alleged penetrative sexual
assault suffers from material inconsistencies and is not sufficiently supported by
the surrounding circumstances.
7.57 . The medical evidence, the forensic report and the other materials on
record do not provide the necessary assurance to sustain the conviction.
7.58 . The failure to put the incriminating circumstances emerging from
the evidence of PW9 to PW11 to the appellant under Section 313 Cr.P.C. is also
a material infirmity.
7.59 . It is well settled that the prosecution must establish its case beyond
__________
Page 25 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
reasonable doubt. The accused is entitled to the benefit of every reasonable
doubt arising from the evidence on record.
7.60 . In the present case, the cumulative effect of the deficiencies in the
proof of age, the inconsistencies in the testimony of PW2, the medical evidence
and the circumstances surrounding the occurrence creates a reasonable doubt
regarding the prosecution case.
7.61 . Accordingly, this Court is of the considered view that the Trial
Court failed to properly appreciate the material evidence and the legal principles
applicable to the facts of the case. The conviction and sentence imposed upon
the appellant cannot, therefore, be sustained.
8 . Result:-
8.1 . In the result, this Criminal Appeal is allowed.
8.2 . The conviction and sentence imposed upon the appellant by the
judgment dated 21.03.2025 in Special Sessions Case No.198 of 2023, on the file
of the learned Sessions Judge, Special Court for Exclusive Trial of Cases under
the POCSO Act, Chennai, are hereby set aside, and the appellant is acquitted of
all the charges.
8.3 . The fine amount, if any, paid by the appellant, shall be refunded to
him upon proper application and in accordance with law.
__________
Page 26 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
8.4 . The appellant shall be released forthwith from the Central Prison,
Puzhal-I, unless his custody is required in connection with any other case. The
bail bonds, if any, executed by the appellant shall stand cancelled.
8.5 . The direction issued by the Trial Court for payment of compensation
of Rs.1,00,000/- to the victim under Section 33(8) of the POCSO Act is also set
aside. However, any amount already disbursed to the victim shall not be
recovered from her.
13-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
smn2 / VV-2
__________
Page 27 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
To
1.The Sessions Judge,
Special Court for Exclusive Trial of Cases under the POCSO Act,
Chennai.
2.The Inspector of Police
W7, All Women Police Station,
Anna Nagar, Chennai.
3.The Superintendent,
Central Prison, Puzhal – I,
Chennai.
4.The Public Prosecutor,
Madras High Court,
Chennai.
5.The Section Officer,
Criminal Records,
Madras High Court,
Chennai.
__________
Page 28 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )

CRL A No. 793 of 2025
M.NIRMAL KUMAR, J.
smn2 / VV-2
CRL A No. 793 of 2025
13-11-2026
__________
Page 29 of 29
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 18/11/2026 03:36:41 pm )