Dr. Sanjay Kumar Mishra vs State Of U.P. And 6 Others
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
WRIT - A No. - 19537 of 2022
Dr. Sanjay Kumar Mishra
…..Petitioner(s)
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
…..Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Siddharth Khare, Sr. Advocate,
A.k.s.parihar, Alok Singh, Abhishek
Mishra, Achal Singh, Adarsh Singh,
Aditendra Singh, Akhilendra Singh,
Alok Dwivedi, Anand Vikram
Singh, Anirudh Singh, Anjani
Kumar, Anmol Ratan, Anshul
Pathak, Anubhav Dwivedi, Anurag
Parihar, Anurag Shukla, Arvind
Kumar Verma, Awadhesh Kumar
Malviya, Bachchu Lal Yadav,
Bajrang Bahadur Singh, Bhawesh
Pratap Singh, Bheem Singh, Brijesh
Kumar, Brijesh Kumar Verma,
Dinesh Kumar Pandey, Gaurang
Dwivedi, Grijesh Tiwari, H.k
Asthana, Himanshi Srivastava,
Himanshu Upadhyay, Indra Raj
Singh, Jai Prakash Rao, Jitendra
Pratap Singh, Kailash Pati Singh
Yadav, Kunwar Aditya Pratap Singh,
Kunwar Akhilendra Singh,
Madhukar Maurya, Mahendra
Singh, Mahesh Sharma, Man Mohan
Singh, Manoj Kumar Dwivedi,
Mritunjay Mohan Sahai, Mukesh
Kumar, Nand Lal Pandey, Narendra
Singh, Neha Roy Choudhury, Om
Prakash Pandey, Pooja Kusum,
Prabhakar Awasthi, Prabhat Chandra
Sharma, Prabhat Kumar Singh,
2
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
Prashant Shukla, Praveen Kumar
Mishra, Purnendu Bajpai,
Raghvendra Tripathi, Rahul Jain,
Rahul Mishra, Rahul Singh Dahiya,
Rajendra Prasad Dubey, Ram
Krishna Yadav, Ram Prakash
Upadhyay, Ram Sakal Yadav,
Ramesh Chandra Dwivedi, Ravi
Pratap Singh, Rohit Singh, S.m.
Mishra, Sandeep Kumar, Sanjay
Kumar Kushwaha, Sanjay Kumar
Singh, Satish Chandra Dubey, Satya
Prakash Singh, Satyam Mishra,
Satyendra Chandra Tripathi,
Saurabh Tripathi, Shailesh Pandey,
Shashi Kant Mishra, Shilpi Singh,
Shivendu Ojha, Shyam Lal,
Siddharth Khare, Sneh Pandey, Sr.
Advocate, Sunil Kumar Srivastava,
Suyash Pandey, Vijay Singh Sengar,
Vinod Kumar Singh, Yogendra
Kumar Srivastava
Counsel for Respondent(s) : C.S.C., Krishna Kumar Chand,
Ramesh Kumar Tiwari,
A.k.s.parihar, Aditi Pandey, Anand
Kumar Srivastava, Anil Kumar
Yadav, Anubhav Dwivedi, Anurag
Kumar, Arvind Prabodh Dubey,
Ashish Malhotra, Babita Upadhyay,
Bajrang Bahadur Singh, Braj
Bhushan Singh Chauhan, C.S.C.,
C.s.c, CSC, D.k.ojha, Hari Kant
Shukla, Harikesh, Harish Chandra
Yadav, Hridai Narain Pandey,
Hritudhwaj Pratap Sahi, Jagannath
Maurya, Krishna Kumar, Krishna
Kumar Chand, Kushmondeya Shahi,
Manish Tiwari, Nikhil Pandey, P.k.
Upadhyay, Prabhakar Awasthi,
Prabhat Kumar Singh, Pradyumn
Kumar, R.r. Pandey, Rajendra
Prasad Dubey, Rakesh Kumar Patel,
Rakesh Kumar Singh, Ramesh
Kumar Tiwari, Rohit Upadhyay,
Samarath Singh, Sanjeev Kumar
Gaur, Sankalp Narain, Santosh
Kumar Yadav, Satya Prakash Singh,
Sharad Chandra Upadhyay,
Sheetendra Kumar Mishra, Shiv
Sagar Singh, Shobhit Chauhan, Sr.
3
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
Advocate, Triloki Nath, Umesh
Vats, Vashishtha Tiwari, Viajy
Kumar Sharma, Vibhanshu Vaibhav,
Vikrant Pratap Singh, Vishal Tandon
Along with:
Category-A
Writ - A No. 19762 of 2022:
Rakesh Kumar Shukla
1
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 20995 of 2022:
Sumit Kumar Tyagi
2
Versus
State of U.P.. and 5 others
3 Writ - A No. 21988 of 2022:
Hari Om
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
4
Writ - A No. 5 of 2023:
Narendra Kumar Singh
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
5
Writ - A No. 162 of 2023:
Vinod Prakash Singh
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
6 Writ - A No. 224 of 2023:
Anil Kumar
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
7
Writ - A No. 231 of 2023:
Dr. Ramjeet
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
8 Writ - A No. 308 of 2023:
Shiv Dutt Tripathi
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
9
Writ - A No. 347 of 2023:
Mukesh Yadav
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
10
Writ - A No. 386 of 2023:
Chandra Shekhar Singh
Versus
State of U P and 7 others
11 Writ - A No. 483 of 2023:
Kuldeep Kumar Garg
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
4
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
12 Writ - A No. 721 of 2023:
Shivendra Kumar Tripathi
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
13
Writ - A No. 802 of 2023:
Raj Kumar
Versus
State of U.P. and 5 others
14
Writ - A No. 1058 of 2023:
Anand Kumar
Versus
U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board and 4 others
15 Writ - A No. 1289 of 2023:
Shraddha Tondon
Versus
State of U.P. and 3 others
16
Writ - A No. 2382 of 2023:
Hari Om
Versus
State of U P and 4 others
17 Writ - A No. 3557 of 2023:
Jagdish Prasad
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
18
Writ - A No. 12606 of 2026:
Dr Krishna Kumar
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
19
Writ - A No. 12608 of 2026:
Mahendra Kumar Bhagat
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
20 Writ - A No. 12609 of 2026:
Dr. Jitendra Kumar
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
Category- B
21
Writ - A No. 20893 of 2022:
Bhanu Prakash
Versus
State of U P and 4 others
22 Writ - A No. 20914 of 2022:
Meenakshi Dua
Versus
State of U.P. and 8 others
23
Writ - A No. 21182 of 2022:
Drigpal @ Dragpal
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
5
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
24 Writ - A No. 21973 of 2022:
Vijendra Singh
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
25
Writ - A No. 201 of 2023:
Smt. Indu Kanchan
Versus
State of U P and 8 others
26
Writ - A No. 223 of 2023:
Satya Narayan Bajpai
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
27 Writ - A No. 304 of 2023:
Ram Lakhan Singh
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
28
Writ - A No. 573 of 2023:
Rajesh Sivach
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
29 Writ - A No. 777 of 2023:
Rajesh Singh
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
30
Writ - A No. 782 of 2023:
Shyamveer Singh
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
31
Writ - A No. 789 of 2023:
Ajay Mohan Sharma
Versus
State of U.P. and 5 others
32 Writ - A No. 1926 of 2023:
Dinesh Kumar Singh
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
33
Writ - A No. 192 of 2023:
Ajay Pal Sharma
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
34 Writ - A No. 127 of 2023:
Karam Singh
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
35
Writ - A No. 20014 of 2022:
Ram Chandra Singh Sengar
Versus
State of U P and 7 others
36
Writ - A No. 644 of 2023:
Ram Prakash Rathore
Versus
6
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
State of U.P. and 7 others
37
Writ - A No. 19725 of 2022:
Hari Prakash Narayan Dube
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Category- C
Writ - A No. 661 of 2022:
Sushil Kumar Yadav
38
Versus
U.P Secondary Education and 4 others
Writ - A No. 3159 of 2022:
Sushil Kumar Yadav
39
Versus
U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board and 4 others
Writ - A No. 3822 of 2022:
Abhishek Pratap Singh
40
Versus
U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board and 3 others
Writ - A No. 19192 of 2022:
Om Prakash Verma
41
Versus
The State of U P and 4 others
Writ - A No. 19584 of 2022:
Ruma
42
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 19589 of 2022:
Pawan Trivedi
43
Versus
State of U.P. and 8 others
Writ - A No. 19604 of 2022:
Rani Srivastava
44
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 19666 of 2022:
Jitendra Kumar Rahi
45
Versus
State of U.P. and 8 others
Writ - A No. 20075 of 2022:
Kavindra Shukla
46
Versus
State of U P and 4 others
Writ - A No. 20093 of 2022:
Dr. Satya Prakash Singh
47
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
7
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
Writ - A No. 20108 of 2022:
Smt. Rinu Bharti
48
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
Writ - A No. 20309 of 2022:
Mahendra Singh
49
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 21146 of 2022:
Satish Chandra Mishra
50
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 21435 of 2022:
Dr Dharmendra Kumar Singh
51
Versus
State of U.P. and 5 others
Writ - A No. 21545 of 2022:
Girja Shankar
52
Versus
State of U.P. and 5 others
Writ - A No. 21658 of 2022:
Uma Shankar Prasad
53
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 21662 of 2022:
Smt. Rashmi Asthana
54
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 21837 of 2022:
Narendra Singh
55
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 21894 of 2022:
Yatendra Kumar
56
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 21921 of 2022:
Deepti Singh
57
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 22077 of 2022:
Naresh Kumar
58
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
Writ - A No. 22079 of 2022:
Birendra Kumar
59
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
8
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
Writ - A No. 22087 of 2022:
Anil Kumar
60
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
Writ - A No. 22141 of 2022:
Awadhesh Kumar Singh
61
Versus
State of U.P. and 8 others
Writ - A No. 22253 of 2022:
Anil Kumar and another
62
Versus
State of U P and 8 others
Writ - A No. 50 of 2023:
Narsingh Bahadur Singh
63
Versus
State of U.P. and 3 others
Writ - A No. 99 of 2023:
Devendra Pal Singh
64
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 100 of 2023:
Raman Prakash
65
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 101 of 2023:
Jagbir Singh
66
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 106 of 2023:
Pramod Kumar Sharma
67
Versus
State of U.P. and 3 others
Writ - A No. 113 of 2023:
Akhilesh Chandra Yadav
68
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 116 of 2023:
Kailash Singh
69
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 146 of 2023:
Jitendra Kumar
70
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 158 of 2023:
Dinesh Kumar and another
71
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
9
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
Writ - A No. 196 of 2023:
Smt Mithilesh Kumari
72
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 228 of 2023:
Arvind Kumar
73
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 235 of 2023:
Baikunth Nath
74
Versus
State of U.P. and 8 others
Writ - A No. 290 of 2023:
Sushil Kumar Gupta
75
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 320 of 2023:
Prabhakar Mishra
76
Versus
State of U.P. and 8 others
Writ - A No. 333 of 2023:
Mithilesh Kumar Pandey
77
Versus
State of U.P. and 8 others
Writ - A No. 339 of 2023:
Chandrabhan Yadav
78
Versus
State of Uttar Pradesh and 6 others
Writ - A No. 344 of 2023:
Rajeev Kumar
79
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
Writ - A No. 394 of 2023:
Shishu Pal Singh
80
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 395 of 2023:
Bechan Ram Saroj
81
Versus
State of U P and 4 others
Writ - A No. 396 of 2023:
Rameshwer Dayal
82
Versus
State of U.P. and 8 others
Writ - A No. 409 of 2023:
Jainendra Kumar
83
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
10
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
Writ - A No. 414 of 2023:
Jitendra Kumar Chaudhary
84
Versus
State of U P and 5 others
Writ - A No. 417 of 2023:
Narendra Singh
85
Versus
State of U.P. and 5 others
Writ - A No. 423 of 2023:
Rakesh Kumar
86
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 489 of 2023:
Satendra Kumar
87
Versus
State of Uttar Pradesh and 7 others
Writ - A No. 490 of 2023:
Somesh Chandra Shatma
88
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
Writ - A No. 507 of 2023:
Dr. Krishna Kumar
89
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 526 of 2023:
Chunni Lal
90
Versus
State of U.P. and 8 others
Writ - A No. 527 of 2023:
Shri Pal
91
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 537 of 2023:
Neeraj Kumar Agarwal
92
Versus
State of U P and 6 others
Writ - A No. 677 of 2023:
Shashi Prakash Gautam
93
Versus
State of U P and 6 others
Writ - A No. 680 of 2023:
Indresh Kumar
94
Versus
State of U P and 6 others
Writ - A No. 689 of 2023:
Lekhraj Singh
95
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
11
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
Writ - A No. 737 of 2023:
Suraj Pal Singh
96
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 833 of 2023:
Chandradeep Kumar Singh
97
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 872 of 2023:
Adarsh Kumar Mishra
98
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 949 of 2023:
Smt. Praveena Yadav
99
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 1268 of 2023:
Dr Rajbali Singh
100
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 1338 of 2023:
Ender Kumar Vasman
101
Versus
State of U.P. and 8 others
Writ - A No. 1566 of 2023:
Rajpal Singh
102
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 1951 of 2023:
Sunil Kumar
103
Versus
State of U.P. and 6 others
Writ - A No. 2140 of 2023:
Sunita Singh
104
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 2190 of 2023:
Krishna Mohan Upadhyay
105
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 2406 of 2023:
Dr. Anshu Singh
106
Versus
State of U.P. and 7 others
Writ - A No. 4088 of 2023:
Shri Narendra Kumar
107
Versus
The State of U.P. and 5 others
12
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
Writ - A No. 4309 of 2023:
Abhimanyu Singh
108
Versus
State of U.P. and 8 others
Writ - A No. 12762 of 2026:
Dr. Shashi Shekhar Mishra
109
Versus
State of U.P. and 5 others
Writ - A No. 12920 of 2026:
Manoj Kumar
110
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
Writ - A No. 13719 of 2026:
Reena Devi
111
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
Writ - A No. 13779 of 2026:
Hira Lal
112
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
Writ - A No. 14464 of 2026:
Girija Shankar
113
Versus
State of UP and 4 others
Writ-A No.14542 of 2026
Pooja Rani
114
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
Writ - A No. 1322 of 2023:
Ravendra
115
Versus
State of U.P. and 4 others
AFR
Reserved
In Chamber
HON'BLE SIDDHARTH NANDAN, J.
1. Heard Shri Ashok Khare, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Shri
Mohd. Yaseen, Advocate, holding brief of Shri Siddharth Khare,
Advocate (Writ-A Nos. 19537, 19578, 19589, 19604, 19666 and 20014
of 2022 and 304, 308, 333, 386, 489, 644 and 2406 of 2023, Writ-A No.
19725 of 2022 & Writ-A No. 339 of 2023); Shri P.K. Mishra, Advocate
(Writ-A No. 19762 of 2022); Shri Sanjay Kumar Kushwaha, Advocate
13
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
(Writ-A No. 21182 of 2022); Shri Anurag Shukla, Advocate (Writ-A
Nos. 21662 of 2022 and 2190 of 2023); Shri Raghvendra Tripathi,
Advocate (Writ-A No. 21837 of 2022); Shri Rahul Jain, Advocate (Writ-
A No. 22141 of 2022); Shri Sandeep Kumar, Advocate (Writ-A Nos.
113, 127, 146, 409, 689 and 737 of 2023); Shri Ram Sakal Yadav,
Advocate (Writ-A No. 507 of 2023); Shri Narendra Singh, Advocate
(Writ-A No. 949 of 2023); Shri Mahesh Sharma, Advocate (Writ-A No.
1655 of 2023); Shri P.K. Singh, Advocate (Writ-A No. 12762 of 2026);
Shri Nand Lal Pandey, Advocate and Shri Suyash Pandey, Advocate
(Writ-A No. 13719 of 2026); Shri M.M. Sahai, Advocate (Writ-A No.
21146 of 2022); and Shri Bheem Singh, Advocate and Shri Aalok Singh,
Advocate (Writ-A No. 20995 of 2022), learned counsels appearing on
behalf of the petitioners.
2. Counsels For the respondents: Shri G.K. Singh, learned Senior
Advocate, assisted by Shri Sheetendra Kumar Mishra, Advocate, for the
private respondent (Writ-A No. 19725 of 2022); Shri Satyendra Pratap
Singh, Advocate, holding brief of Shri Vishal Tandon, Advocate, for
respondent no. 8 (Writ-A No. 20093 of 2022); Shri Umesh Vats, Senior
Advocate, assisted by Shri Sheetendra Kumar Mishra, Advocate (Writ-A
Nos. 339 and 872 of 2023); Shri Umesh Vats, Senior Advocate, assisted
by Shri Vikrant Pratap Singh, Advocate, for the private respondent
(Writ-A No. 949 of 2023); Shri Vijay Kumar Sharma, Advocate, for O.P.
No. 8 (Writ-A Nos. 19537, 19578, 19589, 19604, 19666 and 20014 of
2022 and 304, 308, 333, 386, 489, 644 and 2406 of 2023); and Shri V.K.
Singh, Senior Advocate, assisted by Shri Triloki Nath, Advocate (Writ-A
No. 21146 of 2022) and learned Standing Counsel for the State-
respondents.
3. The present batch of writ petitions has been filed, challenging the
notification, publishing the select list, for the post of Principals,
published region wise on different dates that is 11.11.2022 and
13.11.2022; in pursuance of Advertisement No. 3 of 2013 issued by the
UP Secondary Education Service Selection Board, at the behest of senior
14
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
most lecturers of Intermediate Colleges, who are functioning as
officiating Principals in the Institution; and after having participated in
the interview, not being shown as selected candidates.
4. The writ petitions can be divided in three categories:
(A) By those “Officiating Principals/Headmasters”, who were not
eligible on the last date of submission of application form i.e.
25.02.2014. [Shown at Serial No.1 to 20, in the Cause Title]
(B) By those “Officiating Principals/Headmasters”, who have attained
the age of superannuation during the pendency of their writ petitions.
[Shown at Serial No.21 to 37, in the Cause Title]
(C) By candidates/officiating Principals/Headmasters, who have
participated in the Interview but due to lesser marks, they have not been
selected. [Shown at Serial No.38 to 115, in the Cause Title]
Facts of the Case
5. Region wise Advertisement was published on 31.12.2013, for the
appointment on the post of Principals/Headmasters, for four categories
of the Institutions. The said categories are as follows:-
(I). Category - 1 :- Intermediate Boys Institutions.
(II). Category - 2 :- Intermediate Girls Institutions.
(III). Category - 3 :- High Schools Boys Institutions.
(IV). Category - 4 :- High Schools Girls Institutions.
6. On subsequent verification, since some of the posts were not verified,
therefore an amended Advertisement, was published and the last date
fixed for Application was 25.02.2014.
7. The same became subject matter of challenge and this Court passed an
interim order; but however subsequently another corrigendum was
issued on 01.01.2022, to proceed with the selection process through
15
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
online mode. And the candidates were directed to verify and correct the
details, mentioned in the online application forms within a prescribed
period.
8. Thereafter in order to address the dispute in aspect of eligibility,
another corrigendum was issued on 02.01.2022, mentioning the last date
for submission of the application form, that being the date of eligibility.
9. The said corrigendum dated 02.01.2022 was also subjected to
challenge; and eventually the same was approved in Mohan Singh and
1
others vs. State of UP and others .
10. On the basis of the online information verified by the candidates, the
interview program was published, vide the communication dated
22.12.2022, with a direction to the candidates to download the interview
letter; and without any objections, the candidates participated in the
interview. Some petitioners though applied for being considered as a
general candidate; but they had chosen to appear and to be considered by
virtue of being the Senior Most Teacher, of the Institution. It is not
disputed that the claim of ‘Senior Most Teachers’ is confined to the said
Institution in question.
11. “The UP Secondary Education Services Selection Commission Rules
2
1983 ”, was replaced by a new set of Rules by the name of "UP
3
Secondary Education Service Selection Commission Rules, 1995 "; and
subsequently by the “UP Secondary Education Service Selection Board
4
Rules, 1998 .”
12. The validity of the said Rules, 1998 was decided by the Apex Court
in the case of Balbir Kaur and another vs. U.P. Secondary Education
5
Services Selection Board, Allahabad and others . It is not disputed
that the post of Principal is to be filled by direct recruitment and there is
no avenue by way of regular promotion to the said post; however there
1. Special Appeal No. 515 of 2022
2. Rules, 1983
3. Rule, 1995
4. Rules, 1998
5. 2008 (3) ESC 409 (SC)
16
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
are two sources from which the direct recruitment is to be made:- firstly
by way of direct candidates, who apply in pursuance of the
advertisement; and secondly ‘two senior most teachers’ of the
Institution; where the post of Principal is vacant and same has been
advertised by the Commission.
13. A Lecturer who is not amongst the ‘two Senior Most Lecturers’ of
the Institution, so as to fall within the ambit of Rule 11(2)(b) of the
Rules 1998, can apply for direct recruitment on the post of Principal.
14. The Uttar Pradesh Secondary Education (Services Selection Boards)
6
Act, 1982 [U.P. Act No.5 of 1982] (As passed by the Uttar Pradesh
Legislature and an Act to establish Secondary Education (Service
Selection Boards) [Substituted by U.P. Act No.25 of 1998, w.e.f.
27.07.1998] came into effect from 20.04.1998; and since then all the
selection of Teachers in Institutions recognized under the Act, 1921 to
the post of Principal/Headmasters of an Educational Institution, is to be
undertaken by the Board constituted under the Act 1982.
15. On 22.02.2022 the Board notified the schedule of Interview, on its
official website, which were scheduled to be held on different dates in
the month of March, 2022.
16. For ready reference, the detailed schedule as per the notification
dated 22.02.2022, is reproduced below:
क्र०सं० साक्षात्कारतिथि साक्षात्कारहोनेवालेमण्डलकानाम
1- 22.03.2022 23.03.2022
से लखनऊएवंअलीगढ़।
2- 24.03.2022 25.03.2022
से गोरखपुरसहारनपुरएवंचित्रकूट
3- 26.03.2022 27.03.2022
से प्रयागराजबस्तीबरेलीएवंअयोध्या
4- 28.03.2022 30.03.2022 , , ,
से आगरा मुरादाबाद वाराणसी मिर्जापुरएवं
झाँसी
17. The different Interview boards, were constituted and the interviews
accordingly took place as per the schedule notified on 22.02.2022.
18. It is also not disputed that candidates who were recommended, by
virtue of their being the two senior-most teachers, also applied as direct
6. Act, 1982
17
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
candidates, to be considered as such. On 11.11.2022 and 13.11.2022, a
select panel was notified region wise, by the UP Secondary Education
Services Selection Board, which is now the subject matter of challenge,
in the present batch of writ petitions.
Preliminary Objection
19. A preliminary objection has been raised on behalf of the respondents,
that petitioners having participated, in the selection proceedings without
any objections, are now estopped, from raising challenge to the
procedure adopted by the respondent-Commission being fully aware of
the same.
20. It is an admitted fact that the challenge in the writ petitions, to the
select list published by the Board, in pursuance of the Advertisement
No.3 of 2013, is at the instance of ‘Senior Most Lecturers’ of
Intermediate Colleges, who are functioning as officiating Principal of the
Institution; and after having participated in the interview and not having
been selected, has now filed the present writ petitions.
21. It is trite in law that the process of recruitment starts from the
issuance of Advertisement and ends with the filling up of notified
vacancies; and at the various steps like inviting applications, scrutiny of
the application, rejection of defective applications and eliminations of
ineligible candidates, conducting examination, interviews and
preparation of list of successful candidates for appointment, the
candidates participating in the recruitment process have a legitimate
expectation that the process of selection will be fair and non-arbitrary;
which is the basis of doctrine of legitimate expectation.
22. It is an established norm that a public authority’s promise or past
conduct, will give rise to a legitimate expectation, which is premised on
the notion that public authorities, while performing their public duties,
ought to honour their promises or past practices.
23. However, the doctrine of legitimate expectation does not impede or
hinder the power of the public authority to lay down a policy or
18
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
withdraw it; and what the courts have to determine is that, the public
interest is compelling and sufficient, to out weight the expectation of the
claimant.
24. A reference can also be made to the decision, in the case of
7
Shivnanda CT and others vs. High Court of Kerala and others wherein
the Apex Court in para-36 held as follows:-
“36. The doctrine of legitimate expectation does not impede or hinder
the power of the public authorities to lay down a policy or withdraw it.
The public authority has the discretion to exercise the full range of
choices available within its executive power. The public authority often
has to take into consideration diverse factors, concerns, and interests
before arriving at a particular policy decision. The courts are generally
cautious in interfering with a bona fide decision of public authorities
which denies a legitimate expectation provided such a decision is taken
in the larger public interest. Thus, public interest serves as a limitation
on the application of the doctrine of legitimate expectation. Courts have
to determine whether the public interest is compelling and sufficient to
outweigh the legitimate expectation of the claimant. While performing
a balancing exercise, courts have to often grapple with the issues of
burden and standard of proof required to dislodge the claim of
legitimate expectation.”
25. Shri Ashok Khare, learned Senior Counsel submits that in the present
case, the recourse which the authorities have adopted, deviates from the
previous norms, as per their case; and the petitioners were wholly
unaware of such discrepancy, at any earlier point of time; and for an
objection of estoppel, it is essential to demonstrate full knowledge of the
facts and according to him the discrepancies are so glaring, no estoppels
would apply. He has placed reliance upon the judgements of the Apex
Court in the case of Ramjit Singh Kardam and others vs. Sanjeev Kumar
8
and others . For ready reference paragraphs-33, 38 to 45 are reproduced
below:
“33. From the pleadings on the records and submissions made by the
learned counsel for the parties, following points arise for
consideration:-
7. 2023 INSC 709
8. 2020 (20) SCC 209
19
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
33.1. Whether the respondent writ petitioners who had participated in
the selection were estopped from challenging the selection in the facts
of the present case?
33.2. Whether the respondent writ petitioners could have challenged the
criteria of selection applied by Commission for selection after they had
participated in the selection?
33.3 Whether the decision dated 30.06.2008 to cancel the written
examination and the decision dated 11.07.2008 to call the candidates
for interview 8 times number of vacancies on minimum percentage of
marks as fixed therein and the decision dated 31.07.2008 to call all the
eligible candidates for interview were arbitrary decision to change
selection criteria published on 28.12.2006, which have effect of
downgrading the merit in the Selection?
33.4. Whether it was obligatory for the Commission as a body to take
all decisions pertaining to Selection on the post of PTI including
the decision of not holding written examination, decision to screen on
the basis 8 times of vacancies and decision to call all eligible candidates
and whether aforesaid decisions were taken by the Chairman alone?
33.5. Whether on 03.08.2008, a decision was taken by the commission
fixing the criteria for the selection on the post of PTI which was signed
by all the members on 03.08.2008 as claimed by the Commission?
33.6. Whether without there being any specific allegations of mala fide
against the Chairman and members of the Commission and without
they having been impleaded by name as party respondents, the writ
petitioners could have challenged the allocation of marks in viva- voce
and High Court was right in accepting the claim that candidates who
got highest marks for academic qualifications ranging between 40 to
48.74 marks have been awarded just 7 to 9 marks in the viva-voce and
as against it there are hundreds of selected candidates who have been
awarded 20 to 27 out of 30 marks in the viva-voce to ensure that they
outclass the academically bright candidates?
33.7. Whether no fresh selection can be held as directed by learned
Single Judge since as per 2012 Rules, the post of PTI has been declared
as a dying cadre and the post has merged into the post of TGT Physical
Education?
38. Learned counsel for the appellant at very outset contended that the
writ petitions filed by the respondent challenging the select list dated
10.04.2001 ought not to have been entertained by the High Court since
the respondent having participated in the selection without any demur
or protest, they are estopped from challenging the selection. The
submission is refuted by the respondent contending that the above
principle of estopple is not applicable in the facts of the present case.
The petitioner being not even aware of the criteria, which was to be
applied for selection, which they came to know only after select list
20
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
was published, there was no occasion to make any challenge by the
respondents before the above date.
39. The preposition that a candidate, who participates in a selection
without a demur taking a calculated chance to get selected cannot turn
around and challenge the criteria of selection and the constitution of the
selection committee is well settled. The appellants have placed reliance
on judgment of this Court in Madan Lal and Others Vs. State of J&K
and Others, (1995) 3 SCC 486; K .A. Nagamani Vs. Indian Airlines and
Others , (2009) 5 SCC 515; Manish Kumar Shahi Vs. State of Bihar and
Others , (2010) 12 SCC 576; Madras Institute of Development Studies
and Another Vs. K. Sivasubramaniyan and Others , (2016) 1 SCC 454
and Ashok Kumar and Another Vs. State of Bihar and Others, (2017) 4
SCC 357.
40. In Madan Lal and Others(supra), this Court laid down following in
paragraph 9:-
“9. ……….It is now well settled that if a candidate takes a
calculated chance and appears at the interview, then, only
because the result of the interview is not palatable to him, he
cannot turn round and subsequently contend that the process
of interview was unfair or the Selection Committee was not
properly constituted. In the case of O m Prakash Shukla v.
Akhilesh Kumar Shukla , 1986 Supp SCC 285, it has been
clearly l aid down by a Bench of three learned Judges of this
Court that when the petitioner appeared at the examination
without protest and when he found that he would not succeed
in examination he filed a petition challenging the said
examination, the High Court should not have granted any
relief to such a petitioner.”
41. The above preposition has been reiterated in other judgments of this
Court noted above. In the present case, whether the respondents-writ
petitioners are estopped from challenging the selection? While noticing
the facts of the case, we have noted above that both appellants and the
respondents had submitted applications in pursuance of advertisement
dated 28.07.2006 No.6/2006. In advertisement, it was provided that the
Commission may shortlist the candidates for interview by holding a
written examination or on the basis of a rational criteria to be adopted
by the Commission. The Commission on 28.12.2006 published the
criteria for calling the candidates for interview. Notice dated
28.12.2006 provided that written examination shall be held for post of
PTI on 21.01.2007, on 100 objective type multiple choice questions,
each question carrying two marks. The notification also prescribed the
minimum qualifying marks- 50% for General category, SC BC and
ESM 45% and 25% marks was assigned to the viva voce. The above
criteria was implemented and written examination was conducted on
21
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
21.01.2007, which examination was cancelled citing complaints
regarding malpractices in the written examination.
42. Further notice dated 11.06.2008 was published fixing 20.07.2008
for written examination as per criteria earlier notified. Before the above
examination could take place, by public notice dated 30.06.2008, it was
cancelled. Another public notice dated 11.07.2008 was published where
Commission decided to shortlist eight times the candidates of the
advertised post with minimum weightage secured in each category. The
said shortlisting was also given up by notice dated 31.07.2009 when it
was decided to call all eligible candidates for interview. Commission
did not publish any criteria or marks on the basis of which interview
was to be held. The criteria, which was published by the Commission
on 28.12.2006, 11.06.2008 and 11.07.2008 were given up step by step
and no criteria was published for interview, which was scheduled to
take place in from 2nd September to 17th October, 2008. When
Commission had not published any criteria on the basis of which
candidates were going to be subjected for selection process and the
candidates participated in the selection without knowing the criteria of
selection, they cannot be shut out from challenging the process of
selection when ultimately they came to know that Commission step by
step has diluted the merit in selection. When candidate is not aware of
the criteria of selection under which he was subjected in the process
and the said criteria for the first time is published along with final result
dated 10.04.2010, he cannot be estopped from challenging the criteria
of selection and the entire process of selection. Further when the
written examination as notified earlier was scrapped and every eligible
candidate was called for interview giving a go bye to a fair and
reasonable process for shortlisting the candidates for interview, that too
only by Chairman of the Commission whereas decision regarding
criteria of selection has to be taken by Commission, the candidates have
every right to challenge the entire selection process so conducted. This
Court in R aj Kumar and Others Vs. Shakti Raj and Others , (1997) 9
SCC 527 held that when glaring illegalities have been committed in the
procedure to get the candidates for examination, the principle of
estoppel by conduct or acquiescence has no application.
43. Referring to judgment of this Court’s judgment in Madan Lal
(supra), this Court laid down following in paragraph 16:-
“16. …………The entire procedure is also obviously illegal. It is
true, as contended by Shri Madhava Reddy, that this Court in
Madan Lal v. State of J&K, (1995) 3 SCC 486 and other decisions
referred therein had held that a candidate having taken a chance to
appear in an interview and having remained unsuccessful, cannot
turn round and challenge either the constitution of the Selection
Board or the method of selection as being illegal; he is estopped to
question the correctness of the selection. But in his case, the
Government have committed glaring illegalities in the procedure to
22
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
get the candidates for examination under the 1955 Rules, so also in
the method of selection and exercise of the power in taking out from
the purview of the Board and also conduct of the selection in
accordance with the Rules. Therefore, the principle of estoppel by
conduct or acquiescence has no application to the facts in this case.
Thus, we consider that the procedure offered under the 1955 Rules
adopted by the Government or the Committee as well as the action
taken by the Government are not correct in law.”
44. One more judgment of this Court which supports the view taken by
the High Court is Bishnu Biswas and others Union of India and others,
(2014) 5 SCC 774. An advertisement was published calling applications
for appointment to the post of Group D staff. The Recruitment Rules
only provided for a written examination having 50 maximum marks.
After holding written examination notice was issued calling the
successful candidates for interview. Although such interview was not
part of the recruitment process, a select list was published which was
challenged in the Tribunal. The Tribunal returned a finding that the
manner in which marks have been awarded in the interview to the
candidates indicated lack of transparency. The High Court upheld the
reasoning of the Tribunal but modified the order to the extent of
continuing the recruitment process from the point it stood vitiated. This
Court laid down following in paragraphs 19 and 20:
“19. In the instant case, the rules of the game had been changed
after conducting the written test and admittedly not at the stage of
initiation of the selection process. The marks allocated for the oral
interview had been the same as for written test i.e. 50% for each.
The manner in which marks have been awarded in the interview to
the candidates indicated lack of transparency. The candidate who
secured 47 marks out of 50 in the written test had been given only
20 marks in the interview while a large number of candidates got
equal marks in the interview as in the written examination.
Candidate who secured 34 marks in the written examination was
given 45 marks in the interview. Similarly, another candidate who
secured 36 marks in the written examination was awarded 45 marks
in the interview. The fact that today the so-called selected
candidates are not in employment, is also a relevant factor to decide
the case finally. If the whole selection is scrapped most of the
candidates would be ineligible at least in respect of age as the
advertisement was issued more than six years ago.
20. Thus, in the facts of this case the direction of the High Court to
continue with the selection process from the point it stood vitiated
does not require interference. In view of the above, the appeals are
devoid of merit and are accordingly dismissed. No costs.”
45. The Division Bench of the High Court is right in its conclusion that
the selection criteria, which saw the light of the day along with
23
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
declaration of the selection result could be assailed by the unsuccessful
candidates only after it was published. Similarly, selection process
which was notified was never followed and the selection criteria which
was followed was never notified till the declaration of final result,
hence, the writ petitioners cannot be estopped from challenging the
selection. We, thus, hold that the writ petitions filed by the petitioners
could not have been thrown on the ground of estoppel and the writ
petitioners could very well challenge the criteria of selection applied by
the Commission, which was declared by the Commission only at the
time of declaration of the final result. We, thus, answer point Nos. 1 and
2 as follows:-
(i) The writ petitioners, who had participated in the selection are
not estopped from challenging the selection in the facts of the
present case.
(ii) The writ petitioners could have very well challenged the
criteria of selection, which was declared by the Commission
only in the final result declared on 10.04.2010.”
26. In the case of Ramjit Singh Kardam (supra), a specific issue of
‘Estoppel’ arose for consideration. The Courts though held that, who
participate in a selection without a demur, taking a calculative chance to
get selected, cannot turn around and challenged the criteria of selection
and the constitution of the selection committee, is well settled; but
concluded that in a circumstance where the selection criteria, saw the
light of the day, only along with declaration of the selection result, could
be assailed by an unsuccessful candidate, only after it was published. A
selection process which was notified, if never followed; and the selection
criteria which was followed, was never notified, till a point of time when
the stage of filing an objection had passed, a candidate cannot be
‘estopped’ from challenging the said selection. (Emphasis added)
27. Reliance has also been placed on the judgement in the case of
9
Rajasthan High Court and another vs. Rajat Yadav and others . Having
discussed the principle of estoppel, the Apex Court held in the facts of
the said case that the advertisement was a representation to the aspirants
for public employment and there was no indication that the meritorious
reserved category candidates would not be treated as General/Open
category candidates, even if they outscored the latter. Accordingly, the
9. 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2931
24
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
Court held that, since the petitioning candidates could not have possibly
visualized such an approach on the part of the recruiters, the question of
such candidates being ‘estopped’ from mounting a challenge to the
legality of the process does not and cannot arise. For a reference Para 41
to 47 is reproduced below:
“41. Our examination of the erudite arguments advanced by Mr. Gupta
must begin with consideration of the objection to the conduct of the
petitioning candidates based on applicability of the principle of
‘estoppel’.
42. There is a long line of decisions of this Court that candidates who
participated in a selection process cannot later challenge the procedure
adopted merely because the result is not palatable to them. It has been
held there, generally, that the principle of estoppel operates against such
a candidate who, having taken a calculated chance of selection by
participating in the selection process and failed to secure selection,
challenges the process of selection in Court on the ground of a flawed
procedure being adopted by the recruiting/selecting authority. Profitable
reference may be made to some of the decisions of this Court, viz. G.
Sarana v. University of Lucknow, (1976) 3 SCC 585, Om Prakash
Shukla v. Akhilesh Kumar Shukla, 1986 Supp SCC 285 , M adan Lal v.
State of Jammu & Kashmir, 1995 (3) SCC 486 , K.A. Nagamani v.
Indian Airlines, 2009 5 SCC 515, Manish Kumar Shahi v. State of
Bihar, 2010 12 SCC 576 , R amesh Chandra Shah v. Anil Joshi, 2013 11
SCC 309 and Ramjit Singh Kardam v. Sanjeev Kumar, 2020 20 SCC
209. .
43. However, this rule is not absolute. As elucidated in Meeta Sahai vs.
State of Bihar, (2019) 20 SCC 17, participation of a candidate in a
selection process implies acceptance of the prescribed procedure, but
not of any illegality in the conduct of the said procedure or
constitutional infirmity underlying it. Where the challenge pertains to a
misconstruction of statutory rules or violation of constitutional
principles, the plea of estoppel cannot operate as a bar.
44. This distinction was earlier recognised by a Bench of three Judges
in Raj Kumar v. Shakti Raj , (1997) 9 SCC 527 , where despite
participation, the Court held that glaring illegalities in the process
rendered estoppel inapplicable.
45. Having considered the precedents in the field, to our mind, a
candidate would be estopped from challenging a selection process post-
participation, unless he can show that despite due diligence, he could
not have known earlier of the illegality in the procedure that came to be
adopted or that the procedural flaw striking at the root of the selection
process was hidden and surfaced only after completion of the process
25
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
of selection; hence, no challenge could have been laid by him prior to
his participation in the process.
46. In the present case, the advertisement was a representation to the
aspirants for public employment that category-wise lists would be
prepared. None would question such a condition. There was, however,
no indication that meritorious reserved category candidates would not
be treated as General/Open category candidates even if they outscore
the latter. The illegality lies in the action of the appellants in not
treating the meritorious reserved category candidates as General/Open
category candidates, despite noticing that the former had outperformed
and outshone the latter. Since the petitioning candidates could not have
possibly visualised such an approach on the part of the recruiters by
projecting their own imagination and discover all facts and
circumstances that might be in their contemplation to be adopted while
drawing up the merit lists at the time they participated in the
preliminary written examination, the question of such candidates being
estopped from mounting a challenge to the legality of the process does
not and cannot arise. The petitioning candidates paid a price for their
merit and having challenged the very legality of the process alleging
violation of constitutional norms and legal principles, the plea of
estoppel could not have defeated such a challenge.
47. The Division Bench by entertaining the writ petitions and granting
relief of the nature noticed above cannot be held to have exercised
jurisdiction illegally.”
28. In the case of Desai Devabhai Geemarbhai vs. Information and
10
Broadcasting Department the Gujarat High Court, having considered
various precedents, held as follows which can be gainfully referred to:-
“76. In the case of Siraj (supra), the Kerala High Court has observed in
para 47 and 48 as under: "47. Mr. Giri had presented an argument that
on principles of estoppel, the petitioners had no right to challenge the
notification, when they had responded thereto. An after thought of
filing a Writ Petition, only when it was found that they could not get
through the selection process, could not have been entertained.
Adverting to certain decisions, the counsel contended that the
discretionary jurisdiction, in the case, should not have been exercised,
in favour of persons who were sitting on fence. 48. However, principles
of estoppel as such might not be applicable in such matters. In the case
of selection, option of an aspirant evidently is limited. If we accept the
suggestions of the appellant, the candidate had to take a risk of
abstaining from the selection and challenge itat the time of notification.
This will be too rigid, not to say impractical, as an objection could be
raised that a person who had not even responded to the selection had no
10. (2022 SCC online Guj 654)
26
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
locus standi. On this point, we are in agreement with the law laid down
by a Division Bench of this Court in Sathi v. Cochin University of
Science and Technology, (2000) 2 KLT 871. In appropriate cases, when
a candidate finds that there was sufficient justification for him to
challenge the process of selection, on grounds available to him,
participation in the selection as such would not have annulled his rights,
since resort to constitutional remedies could not have been defeated or
discarded. The observation contrary to the above principle in Remani's
case has to be understood in the above background alone."
77. In the case of E.P. Royappa (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court has
observed in para 85 as under: 85. The last two grounds of challenge
may be taken up together for consideration. Though we have
formulated the third ground of challenge as a distinct and separate
ground, it is really in substance and effect merely an aspect of the
second ground based on violation of 14 and 16. Art. 16 embodies the
fundamental guarantee that Arts. 14 as there shall be equality of
opportunity for all citizens in matters relating to employment or
appointment to any office under the State. Though enacted as a distinct
and independent fundamental right because of its great importance as a
principle ensuring equality of opportunity in public employment which
is so vital to the building up of the new classless egalitarian society
envisaged in the Constitution, Art. 16 is only an instance of the
application of the concept of equality enshrined in Art. 14. In other
words, Art. 14 is the genus while Art 16 is a species. Art. 16 gives effect
to the doctrine of equality in all matters relating to public employment.
The basic principle which, therefore, informs both Arts. 14 and 16 is
equality and inhibition against discrimination. Now, what is the content
and reach of this great equalising principle? It is a founding faith, to use
the words of Bose J., "a way of fife", and it must not be subjected to a
narrow pedantic or lexicographic approach. We cannot countenance
any; attempt to truncate its all-embracing scope and meaning, for to do
so Would be to violate its activist magnitude. Equality is a dynamic
concept with many aspects and dimensions and it cannot be "cribbed
cabined and confined" within traditional and doctrinaire limits. From a
positivistic point of view, equality is antithetic to arbitrariness. In fact
equality and arbitrariness are sworn enemies; one belongsto the rule of
law in a republic while the other, to the whim and caprice of an
absolute monarch. Where an act is arbitrary it is implicit in it that it is
unequal both according to political logic and constitutional law and is
therefore violative of Art. 14, and if it affects any matter relating to
public employment, it is also violative of Art. 16. Arts. 14 and 16 strike
at arbitrariness in State action an (ensure fairness and equality of
treatment. They require that State action must be based on valent
relevant principles applicable alike to all similarly situate and it must
not be quided by any extraneous or irrelevant considerations because
that would be denial of equality. Where the operative reason for State
27
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
action, as distinguished from motive inducing from the antechamber of
the mind, is not legitimate and relevant but is extraneous and outside
the area of permissible considerations, it would: amount to malafide
exercise of power and that is hit by Arts. 14 and 16. Mala fide exercise
of Power and arbitrariness are different lethal radiations emanating
from the same vice: in fact the matter comprehends the former. Both
are inhibited by Arts'. 14 and 16”.
29. The Apex Court, while considering the principle of estoppel, in the
11
case of Dr. (Major) Meeta Sahai v. State of Bihar , (para16 & 17),
held as follows:-
“16. It is well settled that the principle of estoppel prevents a candidate
from challenging the selection process after having failed in it as
iterated by this Court in a plethora of judgments including Manish
Kumar Shahi v. State of Bihar, observing as follows: (SCC p. 584, para
16) "16. We also agree with the High Court7 that after having taken
part in the process of selection knowing fully well that more than 19%
marks have been earmarked for viva voce test, the appellant is not
entitled to challenge the criteria or process of selection. Surely, if the
appellant's name had appeared in the merit list, he would not have even
dreamed of challenging the selection. The [appellant] invoked
jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India only after he found that his name does not figure in the merit list
prepared by the Commission. This conduct of the appellant clearly
disentitles him from questioning the selection and the High Court did
not commit any error by refusing to entertain the writ petition."The
underlying objective of this principle is to prevent candidates from
trying another shot at consideration, and to avoid an impasse wherein
every disgruntled candidate, having failed the selection, challenges it in
the hope of getting a second chance.
17. However, we must differentiate from this principle insofar as the
candidate by agreeing to participate in the selection process only
accepts the prescribed procedure and not the illegality in it. In a
situation where a candidate alleges misconstruction of statutory rules
and discriminating consequences arising therefrom, the same cannot be
condoned merely because a candidate has partaken in it. The
constitutional scheme is sacrosanct and its violation in any manner is
impermissible. In fact, a candidate may not have locus to assail the
incurable illegality or derogation of the provisions of the Constitution,
unless he/she participates in the selection process.”
30. From the perusal of the aforesaid judgments it can be deciphered,
that the crucial question is, whether the candidates can be said to be
11. (2019) 20 SCC 17
28
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
aware of the procedure, so as to make an objection prior to their
participation in the process or not; and whether the process notified was
followed or changed during the ongoing stages, is also to be seen.?
31. The legitimate expectation, which an incumbent may have, is
premised on a settled principle of law that the process of selection will
be fair and also that the doctrine prescribing change of rules, midway to
the game or after the game is played, is predicated on rule against
arbitrariness enshrining in Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The
authorities performing their public duties, are to honour the promise or
the past practice.
32. The contention or the objections of the petitioners, is premised on a
guideline, which was considered by this Court in the case of Indra Raj
12
Singh Yadava Vs. UP Madhyamik Shiksha Sewa Ayog and others , and
as such this Court had approved the guidelines of the Commission viz-a-
viz the Rules 1983; and if it is to be considered at this stage, prior to the
said consideration, it cannot be said that the petitioners are estopped
from raising a challenge to the procedure adopted by the Commission,
contrary to the guidelines which was upheld by this Court in the case of
Indra Raj Singh Yadav (supra), and as such the preliminary objection
raised by the respondents has no merits and the petitioners cannot be
thrown out of the Court, at this stage itself without examining the issue
raised by the petitioners; and the preliminary objection is accordingly
rejected.
Issue No. 1:- Whether the Chairman of the Board, was justified in
declaration of the result of the selection, in pursuance of the decision
taken by the Committee on 11.11.2022 and 13.11.2022, in absence of the
members of the Board, in view of Rule 12(10) of the Rules, 1998 ?
33. It has not been disputed that at the time of holding the interview, the
Commission was fully functional; as the term of five Members of the
Board only expires subsequently, as recorded in the proceedings of the
Commission dated 28.03.2022; but however at the time of declaration of
12. 1984 SCC OnLine All 1054
29
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
the result, all the Members of the Board had retired, but for the
Chairman of the Board.
34. It has been contended on behalf of the petitioners that the preparation
and declaration of the result, is contrary to the Act, 1982 and Rules and
Regulations framed thereunder. They submit that the Board is a multi
Member Board consisting of Chairman and ten Members.
35. For ready reference Section 4 of 1982 Act is reproduced below:
“4. Composition of the Board.— (1) The Board shall consist of a
chairman and ten members who shall be appointed by the State
Government.
(2) A person shall not be qualified for appointment as chairman unless
he—
(a) is or has been a Vice-Chancellor of any University established by
law; or
(b) is or has been in the opinion of the State Government an
outstanding officer or the Administrative service not below the rank of
secretary to the State Government or Director of Education, Uttar
Pradesh.
(c) is in the opinion of the state government an eminent person having
made valuable contribution in the field of education.
(3) Of the members,—
(a) two shall be persons who are educationist having made significant
contribution in the field of education;
(b) two shall be persons who are or have been, in the opinion of the
State Government, an outstanding officer of the State Educations
Service not below the rank of Additional Director;
(c) other shall be persons who,—
(i) have worked as a professor in any university established by
law in Uttar Pradesh or as a Reader of any Degree College
recognised by or affiliated to such university for a period of not
less than ten years; or
(ii) have worked as a Principal of any institution recognized
under the Intermediate Education Act, 1921 for a period of not
less than ten years; or
(iii) are, in the opinion of the State Government, an eminent
educationist having made valuable contribution in the field of
education.
(iv) "is interested in the field of Education and a graduate from a
recognized University."
(4) Every appointment under this section shall take effect from, the date
on which it is notified, by the State Government."
30
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
36. Section 9 of the Act, 1982 provides the powers and duties of the
Board; and Section 9(d) specifically states that the recommendations
regarding the appointment of selected candidates, fall within the powers
and duties of the Board.
37. Section 9(d) is reproduced below:
“9.Powers and duties of the Board. The shall have the following powers
and duties namely:
a. ……
b. ……
c. ……
d. to make recommendations regarding the appointment of selected
candidates;
……...”
38. The procedure for selection by direct recruitment has been provided
under Section 10 of the Act, 1982; which is also reproduced below:
“10. Procedure of selection by direct recruitment.— (1) For the purpose
of making appointment of a teacher, by direct recruitment, the
management shall determine the number of vacancies existing or likely
to fall vacant during the year of recruitment and in the case of a post
other than the post of Head of the Institution, also the number of
vacancies to be reserved for the candidates belonging to the Scheduled
Castes, the Scheduled Tribes and other Backward Classes of citizens in
accordance with the Uttar Pradesh Public Services (Reservation for
Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes) Act,
1994 and notify the vacancies to the Board in such manner and through
such officer or authority as may be prescribed.
(2) The procedure of selection of candidates for direct recruitment to
the post of teachers shall be such as may be prescribed:
Provided that the Board shall, with a view to inviting talented persons,
give wide publicity in the State to the vacancies notified under sub-
section (1).”
39. In the light of the aforesaid, it has been submitted that the power of
the Board is to be exercised in accordance with the Regulations framed
under Section 34 of the Act, 1982; and the applicable Regulations, 1998
which provides for the procedure to be followed by the Board, for
discharging its duties and performing its functions, under the Act.
31
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
40. Regulation 4 of “U.P. Secondary Education Services Selection Board
13
(Procedure and Conduct of Business) (First) Regulations, 1998 ”
envisages meeting of the Board, to be convened in accordance with the
said provision; and Regulation 4(6) states that the quorum for a meeting
shall be one half of the total number of Members for the time being.
41. For ready reference Regulation 4(6) is reproduced below:
“4(6)- The quorum for a meeting shall be one half of the total number
of members of the time being:
Provided that no quorum shall be necessary for a meeting adjourned for
want of quorum.”
42. Thereafter Regulation 4(9)(a), requires that as far as possible, the
decision in a meeting shall be unanimous.
43. For a ready reference Regulation 4(9)(a) is reproduced below:-
“4(9)(a) - The decision in a meeting shall, as far as possible be
unanimous. In case of any difference of opinion, the decision shall be
taken by a majority of votes of the members present and voting and if
no decision can be taken due to equality of votes, the Chairman or the
Vice Chairman or the member presiding over the meeting shall have
and exercise a casting vote.
44. In view of the aforesaid the contention of the learned counsel for the
petitioners, is that the aforesaid statutory provision clearly demonstrates
that the Board exercises its functions on the basis of a decision taken in
"meeting"; and there cannot be a meeting of a single person.
45. Reliance has also been placed on Chapter 6 of "Shackleton on the
th
Law and Practice of Meetings" (9 Edition) published by "Sweet &
Maxwell" to submit that the word “quorum” denotes the number of
Members of a ‘body of persons’, whose presence at a meeting is
requisite, in order that business may be validly transacted.
46. The word "quorum" means “of whom”. It has further been submitted
that the word “quorum” is referable to ……
13. Regulation, 1998
32
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
(i) the concept that a "meeting" must usually consist of more than one
person; and
(ii) the necessity, imposed by the regulations of the body concerned, that
a minimum number of persons must be present.
47. The said ‘number of persons’ is to be prescribed under the Rules of
that body. However, the aforesaid Rule may not apply, when the Rules
are either silent or specifically prescribes that the quorum of one person
is sufficient; but however the said exception is generally unknown in
local government practice; and as such the declaration by the Chairman
alone, violates the mandates of the Rules and Regulations, as referred to
herein above.
48. Per contra, Shri G.K. Singh, Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of
the respondents and Shri K. Shahi, Advocate appearing on behalf of the
respondent Commission have made submissions, by placing reliance on
a decision of this Court in Deepak Kumar Agarwal vs. State of U.P.
14
Through Secretary (Secondary Education) U.P. Lucknow , to the effect
that the Chairman alone could constitute the Board; and it is an admitted
fact that at the time when the interviews were held, the other Members
were available in the Board, they being also present in the Interview
Board. The declaration of the result based upon those interviews, was
simply a ministerial act and was performed by the Board, at the time
when only the Chairman was available.
49. The fact that the Chairman was assisted in that work by the Secretary
and the Deputy Secretary of the Board, is of no consequence.
50. It is no doubt that the “quorum” for a meeting was required to be
one-half of the total number of members and it is the Chairman who
shall preside over the meeting of the Board. It also cannot be deciphered
from the Regulations, 1998 that the meeting of the Board could be held
with the quorum of only the Chairman; but at the same time there is no
embargo otherwise also.
14. (Writ A No. 133 of 2022)
33
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
51. A co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the case of Deepak Kumar
Agarwal (Supra) was seized with a matter, wherein also due to an
exigency, the Chairman alone had acted as a member, when there existed
no other appointed Member of the Board. The aforesaid judgment
demonstrate that a decision for according approval to the punishment
against an employee was to be taken; and the Court having considered
the doctrine of necessity, gave it’s approval in the backdrop that any
interpretation otherwise, in absence of availability of Members, the
entire functioning of the Board would come to a standstill.
52. In the case of Election Commission of India and another vs. Dr.
15
Subramanian Swamy and others , the ‘doctrine of necessity’ was
expounded; and it was held that it is well settled that the law permits
certain things to be done as a matter of necessity, which it would
otherwise not countenance on the touchstone of judicial propriety.
53. It has also been contended on behalf of the petitioners that the said
‘doctrine of necessity’ can be invoked in cases of bias, where there is no
other authority or Judge to decide the issue; and in the present case the
Commission being defunct, the Chairman was not justified in
discharging the duties of the Board i.e. the declaration of the panel alone,
especially when there was not even a single Member functioning. For
ready reference Para-16 of the said judgment is reproduced below:
“16. We must have a clear conception of the doctrine. It is well settled
that the law permits certain things to be done as a matter of necessity
which it would otherwise not countenance on the touchstone of judicial
propriety. Stated differently, the doctrine of necessity makes it imperative
for the authority to decide and considerations of judicial propriety must
yield. It is often invoked in cases of bias where there is no other
authority or Judge to decide the issue. If the doctrine of necessity is not
allowed full play in certain unavoidable situations, it would impede the
course of justice itself and the defaulting party would benefit therefrom.
Take the case of a certain taxing statute which taxes certain perquisites
allowed to Judges. If the validity of such a provision is challenged who
but the members of the judiciary must decide it. If all the Judges are
disqualified on the plea that striking down of such a legislation would
benefit them, a stalemate situation may develop. In such cases the
doctrine of necessity comes into play. If the choice is between allowing
15. 1996 (4) SCC 104
34
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
biased person to act or to stifle the action altogether, the choice must fall
in favour of the former as it is the only way to promote decision-making.
In the present case also if the two Election Commissioners are able to
reach a unanimous decision, there is no need for the Chief. Election
Commissioner to participate, if not the doctrine of necessity may have to
be he invoked.”
16
54. In Lalit Kumar Modi Vs. Board of Control of Cricket in India , the
doctrine of necessity was invoked to rule that, the law did not
contemplate a vacuum and a solution had to be found, rather than
allowing the problem to boil over. For ready reference Para-38 is
reproduced below:
“38. The doctrine of necessity is a common law doctrine, and is applied
to tide over the situations where there are difficulties. Law does not
contemplate a vacuum, and a solution has to be found out rather than
allowing the problem to boil over. Otherwise, as proposed by Shri
Jethmalani one will have to wait for one more year for a new President
to be elected, which submission cannot be accepted.”
55. The doctrine of necessity, was further considered in the case of
Babasaheb Wasade and others vs. Manohar Gangadhar Muddeshwar and
17
others .
56. For ready reference paragraphs 15, 16, 17, 18, 19 and 20 are
reproduced below:-
“15. There is a doctrine of necessity where under given circumstances
an action is required to be taken under compelling circumstances. One
of the earlier proponents of the doctrine of necessity in Common Law
was William Blackstone, who in his book, Commentaries on the Laws
of England, “Book I Of the Rights of Persons”, discusses the meeting
of the convention—Parliament before Charles II's return, noting that it
was an extraordinary measure taken out of necessity. He describes the
use of the doctrine of necessity to justify actions that would otherwise
be outside the norm due to the urgent need to restore order. He
describes another instance during the Glorious Revolution when the
Lords and Commons assembled and acted without the usual royal
summons, justified by the extraordinary circumstance of a perceived
vacant throne and the urgent need to address the governance of the
country.
16. 1996 (4) SCC 104
17. (2024) 11 Supreme Court cases 705
35
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
“It is also true, that the convention—Parliament, which restored
King Charles the Second, met above a month before his return;
the lords by their own authority, and the commons in pursuance
of writs issued in the name of the keepers of the liberty of
England by authority of Parliament: and that the said Parliament
sat till the twenty-ninth of December, full seven months after the
restoration; and enacted many laws, several of which are still in
force. But this was for the necessity of the thing, which
supersedes all law; for if they had not so met, it was morally
impossible that the kingdom should have been settled in peace.
And the first thing done after the king's return, was to pass an act
declaring this to be a good Parliament, notwithstanding the
defect of the king's writs. So that, as the royal prerogative was
chiefly wounded by their so meeting, and as the king himself,
who alone had a right to object, consented to wave the objection,
this cannot be drawn into an example in prejudice of the rights of
the crown. Besides we should also remember, that it was at that
time a great doubt among the lawyers, whether even this healing
act made it a good Parliament; and held by very many in the
negative: though it seems to have been too nice a scruple.
It is likewise true, that at the time of the revolution, AD 1688,
the Lords and Commons by their own authority, and upon the
summons of the Prince of Orange, (afterwards King William)
met in a convention and therein disposed of the crown and
kingdom. But it must be remembered, that this assembling was
upon a like principle of necessity as at the restoration; that is,
upon an apprehension that King James the second had abdicated
the government, and that the throne was thereby vacant: which
apprehension of theirs was confirmed by their concurrent
resolution, when they actually came together. And in such a case
as the palpable vacancy of a throne, it follows ex necessitate rei,
that the form of the royal writs must be laid aside, otherwise no
Parliament can ever meet again. For, let us put another possible
case, and suppose, for the sake of argument, that the whole royal
line should at any time fail, and become extinct, which would
indisputably vacate the throne: in this situation it seems
reasonable to presume, that the body of the nation, consisting of
Lords and Commons, would have a right to meet and settle the
government; otherwise there must be no government at all. And
upon this and no other principle did the convention in 1688
assemble. The vacancy of the throne was precedent to their
meeting without any royal summons, not a consequence of it.
They did not assemble without writ, and then make the throne
vacant; but the throne being previously vacant by the king's
abdication, they assembled without writ, as they must do if they
assembled at all. Had the throne been full, their meeting would
36
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
not have been regular; but, as it was really empty, such meeting
became absolutely necessary. And accordingly it is declared by
statute 1 W & M. st. 1. c. 1. that this convention was really the
two Houses of Parliament, notwithstanding the want of writs or
other defects of form. So that, notwithstanding these two capital
exceptions, which were justifiable only on a principle of
necessity, (and each of which, by the way, induced a revolution
in the government) the rule laid down is in general certain, that
the king, only, can convoke a Parliament.”
16. The doctrine of necessity has been elucidated by a Constitution
Bench of this Court in Charan Lal Sahu v. Union of India [Charan Lal
Sahu v. Union of India, (1990) 1 SCC 613, para 105] as follows: (SCC
pp. 694-95, para 105)
“105. The question whether there is scope for the Union of India
being responsible or liable as a joint tortfeasor is a difficult and
different question. But even assuming that it was possible that
the Central Government might be liable in a case of this nature,
the learned Attorney General was right in contending that it was
only proper that the Central Government should be able and
authorised to represent the victims. In such a situation, there will
be no scope of the violation of the principles of natural justice.
The doctrine of necessity would be applicable in a situation of
this nature. The doctrine has been elaborated, in Halsbury's Laws
of England, 4th Edn., p. 89, Para 73, where it was reiterated that
even if all the members of the Tribunal competent to determine a
matter were subject to disqualification, they might be authorised
and obliged to hear that matter by virtue of the operation of the
common law doctrine of necessity. An adjudicator who is subject
to disqualification on the ground of bias or interest in the matter
which he has to decide may in certain circumstances be required
to adjudicate if there is no other person who is competent or
authorised to be adjudicator or if a quorum cannot be formed
without him or if no other competent tribunal can be constituted.
In the circumstances of the case, as mentioned hereinbefore, the
Government of India is only capable to represent the victims as a
party. The adjudication, however, of the claims would be done
by the court. In those circumstances, we are unable to accept the
challenge on the ground of the violation of principles of natural
justice on this score. The learned Attorney General, however,
sought to advance, as we have indicated before, his contention
on the ground of de facto validity. He referred to certain
decisions. We are of the opinion that this principle will not be
applicable. We are also not impressed by the plea of the doctrine
of bona fide representation of the interests of victims in all these
proceedings. We are of the opinion that the doctrine of bona fide
representation would not be quite relevant and as such the
37
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
decisions cited by the learned Attorney General need not be
considered.”
17. The applicability of the doctrine of necessity was further clarified
by this Court in Election Commission of India v. Subramaniam Swamy
[Election Commission of India v. Subramaniam Swamy, (1996) 4 SCC
104] as follows: (SCC pp. 117-18, para 16)
“16. We must have a clear conception of the doctrine. It is well
settled that the law permits certain things to be done as a matter
of necessity which it would otherwise not countenance on the
touchstone of judicial propriety. Stated differently, the doctrine
of necessity makes it imperative for the authority to decide and
considerations of judicial propriety must yield. It is often
invoked in cases of bias where there is no other authority or
Judge to decide the issue. If the doctrine of necessity is not
allowed full play in certain unavoidable situations, it would
impede the course of justice itself and the defaulting party would
benefit therefrom. Take the case of a certain taxing statute which
taxes certain perquisites allowed to Judges. If the validity of
such a provision is challenged who but the members of the
judiciary must decide it. If all the Judges are disqualified on the
plea that striking down of such a legislation would benefit them,
a stalemate situation may develop. In such cases the doctrine of
necessity comes into play. If the choice is between allowing a
biased person to act or to stifle the action altogether, the choice
must fall in favour of the former as it is the only way to promote
decision-making. In the present case also if the two Election
Commissioners are able to reach a unanimous decision, there is
no need for the Chief Election Commissioner to participate, if
not the doctrine of necessity may have to be invoked.”
18. In the present case, had the Working President not convened the
meeting, the elections of the Executive Body would have been in limbo
for an unreasonable amount of time. The convening of the meeting by
the Working President upon the requests by the 16 surviving members
was a “necessity” at the time.
19. There is one more aspect of the matter to be discussed here with
respect to the duties of the “Working President”. Clause 11 of the Bye-
laws recognises a Working President and also defines his rights and
duties. The same is reproduced below:
“11. “Working President”—
The Rights and Duties of Working President:
1. To complete the work as per the written instructions of the President
of the Shikshan Prasarak Mandal, the Executive Body of the Mandal
and the General Body of the Mandal.
38
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
2. Make efforts from the point of extending the area of operation of the
Shikshan Prasarak Mandal.”
As per the above clause, the “Working President” was to act on the
directions of the President, Executive Body and the General Body. In
the present case, the recognition was by almost all the members of the
General Body. He had no option but to call for a general body meeting
in accordance with the rights and duties conferred upon him.
20. In the present case, it was not only appropriate but also legal for the
surviving members to request for convening a meeting. Further in the
present case, as many as 16 members had requested in writing for
convening the meeting. If the submission of the objectors is to be
accepted that the Working President could not convene the meeting,
then no alternative has been suggested by the objectors as to who could
convene the meeting. Alternatively, the President and Secretary who
were authorised under the bye-laws had died and no election had been
held for replacing them. Even the Vice-President and the Joint
Secretary had also passed away and they had also not been replaced by
any fresh elections. The only person who could be said to be managing
the affairs of the Society was the Working President Mr Wasade, and in
particular, when all the 16 surviving and valid members had made a
request for convening a meeting, no fault could be found with the
decision of the Working President Mr Wasade to convene the meeting.
The other option could have been that all the 16 members could have
themselves nominated any one of the members to chair the meeting of
the Executive Body and thereafter they could have proceeded to take
appropriate decisions. In such situation, we are of the view that the
convening of the meeting for holding the elections on 8-9-2002 cannot
be faulted with. Question 1 is answered accordingly in favour of the
appellants.”
57. In the facts of the present case, there existed an administrative
exigency and it is no doubt that it is the power and duty of the Board to
make recommendation, regarding the appointment of selected
candidates; but however there exist no provision under the Statute or the
Regulation, containing a negative clause, to prevent the Chairman alone
to act as a Board when there exists no other Member appointed to the
Board. In case the doctrine of necessity is not invoked, the entire
exercise which was initiated in the year 2013 and was sought to be
concluded in the year 2022, would have become a futile exercise, since
admittedly the Members of the Board were not present.
39
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
58. Though the argument of the learned counsel for the petitioners
appears to be attractive at the first blush; that the doctrine of necessity
can be invoked only when the facet of bias is present; but after careful
considerations, in the opinion of the Court, the doctrine of necessity
cannot be curtailed, to have its applicability only when there is a facet of
bias; but it has also to be seen in a proper spectrum, when in cases of
administrative exigencies and in performance of a public duty by any
authority, a situation arises when there is a possibility of a vacuum and
the entire administrative exercise to be rendered as a futile exercise, in
order to save the process, the doctrine of necessity can very well be
invoked, as has been done in the present case, where though at the time
of interview, members were available and only by the time Select Panel
was to be declared, the exigency arose and the Chairman alone had to
declare the same; and merely the presence of ministerial and
administrative staff, alone would not vitiate the entire exercise.
59. In the present case, when the interviews were held and the results
were collated, the members of the Board were present in the interview
Board and made recommendations; and thereafter though it was the
onerous duty of the Board to make recommendations of the selected
candidates also; but on account of all the Members having been retired
till that point of time, the declaration of the result by the Chairman alone,
cannot be said to be beyond the spectrum of the doctrine of necessity;
and any interpretation to the contrary may hamper the vital functionary
of the States and in the special facts and circumstances of the case, it
cannot be said that by merely including certain officers of the
Commission, the declaration/recommendation of the selected candidates,
by the Chairman in the capacity of the Board, stands vitiated.
Accordingly, the issue stands decided in favour of the Commission.
Issue No.2:- Whether the guidelines which were framed by the
Commission and as upheld in the case of Inderraj Singh Yadav (Supra)
were required to be followed in the scheme of the Regulations, 1998;
40
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
and a departure from the same would breach the legitimate expectations
of the candidates ?
60. Shri Ashok Khare, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioners, contends that the provisions of the Act, 1982 and the Rules
framed thereunder, from time to time provides for the selections and the
procedure to be followed; and one of such requirement, even as per the
guidelines of the Commission, was to consider the ‘two Senior-Most
Teachers’ of the Institution, along with five candidates for each
individual Institution, who were thereafter subjected to interview along
with the said two Senior-Most Teachers. He submits that such a
provision, which stands incorporated in the guidelines of the
Commission and as approved in the case of Indra Raj Singh Yadav
(supra), also exist under the U.P. Intermediate Education Act, 1921
[hereinafter referred to as Act 1921].
61. Regulation 10(dd)of Chapter II of Regulations framed under the Act,
1921 reads as follows:
“(dd) Where the post advertised under Clause (a) is that of Principal of
an institution the two seniormost teachers of such institution in the
Lecturer's grade and where the post advertised is that of Headmaster for
an institution the two seniormost teachers of such institution in the L.T.
Grade who possess the prescribed minimum qualification for such post
and have to their credit a mini-mum of ten years continuous service in
the respective grade, including the period, if any, during which they
have worked temporarily as principal/ Headmaster shall also be entitled
to be called for interview for that post even if they do not come within
the first seven places under Clause (d).”
62. The said procedure was even followed after the enforcement of Act,
1982 and continued under Rules, 1983 and Rules, 1998; and at no point
of time there existed any provision, as to how the inter-se comparison of
two senior-most teachers would be made, with reference to the direct
applicants.
63. By placing reliance on para-21 of the Indra Raj Singh Yadav (supra),
the learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the method required
preparation of a list of five candidates for each individual Institution,
41
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
who were thereafter subjected to interview along with two Senior Most
Teachers.
64. In case of ‘Senior Most Teacher’ secures the highest marks amongst
such seven persons, he was declared selected, failing which the
Institution was thrown open and was to be filled up from amongst direct
applicants, on the basis of merits and preferences expressed by them.
65. He further submits that the aforesaid guidelines were issued with a
view to balance the competing claims of direct applicants and the two
Senior Most Teachers. However, in the impugned selection process, no
such pool of seven candidates, including the two Senior Most Teachers
of the Institution in question, was prepared; rather, in material departure
from the aforesaid guidelines, the respondents prepared an overall merit
list comprising of all the candidates, including the two Senior Most
Teachers; and based on such merit list, the final select list was published.
As a result, very few or none of the ‘Senior Most Teachers’ were
included in the select panels of the different divisions, for e.g. in the case
of Aligarh Division, not even a single Senior-Most Teacher was selected.
66. Shri Ashok Khare, learned Senior Counsel, vehemently submitted
that the procedure approved by the Division Bench judgment in the case
of Indra Raj Singh Yadav (supra) has consistently been followed even
after the enforcement of the Rules, 1998, namely, by making an inter se
comparison between the ‘Senior-Most Teacher’ and the ‘direct
applicants.’
67. He further submits that no subsequent guidelines have been brought
on record by the Commission, envisaging the procedure which has been
followed, and the proceedings of the Commission dated 17.11.2021,
16.12.2021, 02.03.2022 and 28.03.2023, upon which reliance has been
placed by the respondents, do not indicate any such departure from its
earlier guidelines. As a matter of fact, the decisions dated 02.03.2022
and 28.03.2023 are subsequent in point of time and, as such, no reliance
can be placed upon the same, as the law is well settled that the rules of
42
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
the game cannot be changed midway. (Reference: Tej Prakash Pathak v.
18
Rajasthan High Court, )
68. Per contra, Shri K. Shahi, learned Advocate appearing on behalf of
the Commission, submits that the petitioners were well aware of the said
procedure and were given 21 days' notice of the interview programme,
which was published vide communication dated 22.02.2022. After
downloading the interview letters from the official website, they
participated in the selection process without raising any objection. He
further submits that the claim of the Senior-Most Teacher is confined
only to the Institution in question and that, in case he secures higher
marks than the other candidates who have applied through direct
recruitment, having given the first preference to the said Institution, he
would have an opportunity to be considered for appointment in the said
Institution.
69. In response to the argument, pertaining to the guidelines framed by
the Commission and as considered by this Court in the case of Indra Raj
Singh Yadav (supra), he submits that under Rules 4, 6 and 7 of the Rules,
1983, and Regulations 6 and 8 of the Regulations, 1983, there was no
provision for the preparation of a merit list or for prescribing any
guidelines for conducting Interviews. Therefore, in the aforesaid
circumstances, the Commission framed guidelines for conducting the
then selection process, which were approved by this Court in the case of
Indra Raj Singh Yadav (supra). The Rules, 1995 were thereafter framed,
whereby the criteria for selection was changed in the following manner:-
(a) Quality Point Marks were prescribed in Appendix 'E', as
contemplated under Rule 12(2), which had not been prescribed under the
Rules, 1983.
(b) After conducting the interview, the options exercised by the
candidates were to be considered for preparation of the panel, as
contemplated under Rule 12(3).
70. The selections made by the Commission under the Rules, 1995 were
challenged by the Officiating Principals in the case of Balak Singh
18 (2025) 2 SCC 1
43
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
19
Kushwaha vs. State of U.P. which challenge was dismissed, and the
criteria prescribed under Rule 12 of the Rules, 1995 was upheld.
71. By way of U.P. Act No. 25 of 1998, a new set of Rules, 1998 was
framed, and the validity thereof was also upheld up to the stage of the
Apex Court in the case of Balbir Kaur (supra). The criteria for selection
was approved in the following manner:-
(a) Region-wise selection is permissible.
(b) The experience prescribed under the Regulations framed under the
U.P. Intermediate Education Act, is not applicable in view of the proviso
contained in Rule 12(5) of the Rules, 1998.
(c) Reservation is not applicable to the post of Principal.
Under the Rules, 1998, a detailed procedure has been prescribed in the
following manner:
“A. Publication of advertisement
B. Preparations of merit list in accordance with the provision
mentioned in Clause i to iv of Sub Rule 5 of Rule 12 for short listing
the five times candidates.
C. Experience other than mentioned in the Note of Clause iv of Sub
Rule 5 of Rule 12 has been excluded.
D. Detail guidelines for providing the marks in interview has been
mentioned in Clause v of Sub Rule 5 of Rule 12
E. Thereafter preparation of merit after adding the marks provided in
clause iv and v of Sub Rule 5 of Rule 12
F. Sub Rule 7 of Rules 12 provides the non disclosure of the merit.
G. Thereafter panel shall be prepared after considering the options
submitted by the candidates in accordance with the provision contained
in Sub Rule 8 of Rule 12.
H. Thereafter a detail procedure has been prescribed for allocation of
the Institution under Sub Rule 10 of Rule 12. H.
I. Therefore the selection has been made on the basis of the provision
contained under Rule 12.”
72. In view of the aforesaid, he submits that the guidelines which find
mention in the case of Indra Raj Singh Yadav (supra) are not applicable
19 1998 SCC Online All 674
44
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
after the enforcement of the Rules, 1995 and the Rules, 1998, the
validity of which has been upheld up to the stage of the Apex Court in
the cases of Balak Singh Kushwaha (supra) and Balveer Kaur (supra),
respectively.
73. He maintains that the procedure which has been followed emanates
from the Rules, 1998; and the petitioners have not been able to point out
any provision contained in the Rules, 1998, which has been changed
during the selection process. As regards the guidelines framed by the
Commission, he submits that the same was issued under the framework
of the Rules, 1983; and were confined to a particular selection, which
was the subject matter of consideration before this Court, in the case of
Indra Raj Singh Yadav (supra). The said guidelines, therefore, cannot be
said to be applicable to the present selection as well or construed as a
promise.
74. The petitioners participated in the selection proceedings without
raising any objection. Therefore, in view of the settled principle of law,
the present writ petition is not maintainable.
75. Sri G.K. Singh, learned Senior Advocate, who also appears on behalf
of the selected candidates in the connected petition, submits that certain
candidates (Civil Misc. Writ-A No. 19725 of 2022, Hari Prakaash Narain
v. State of U.P.) have already superannuated and are continuing as
Officiating Principals, under the extension granted to teachers/Principals
under the Regulations.
76. He further submits that the said candidates could officiate as
Principals only until a regularly selected candidate from the Board was
appointed, and that no candidate has a vested right to continue in the
post till the end of the academic session. He has placed reliance upon the
20
decision in the case of R.L. Prasad v. State of U.P. and others .
77. He further submits that once a regularly selected candidate has been
appointed to the post of Principal and the incumbents have attained the
age of superannuation, no further appointment can be granted to such
20 1987 EWC 1314
45
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
candidates, as held by this Court in the case of Committee of
Management, Jagdish Saran Rajvanshi Kanya Inter College, Meerut &
21
Anr. v. Joint Director of Education & Ors. . For ready reference para 12
is reproduced below:-
“From the aforesaid discussions it is clear that once a teacher has
attained the age of superannuation, in other words age of 60 years or 58
years, as the case may be, he has no vested right to continue in service.
The order of appointment, thus, could not be issued in favour of such
teacher though selected for the post by the Commission, after attaining
the age of superannuation. In our opinion, the educational authorities as
well as committee of management were not justified in issuing the
letter of appointment in favour of teacher for the post of Principal who
had already attained the age of superannuation. Under no provision of
the Act or the Rules or the Regulations such action can be justified as
the panel became ineffective and it was not required to be implemented
in respect of candidate who had already attained the age of
superannuation. The only step required by the authorities of the
education department and the committee of management was to issue
the letter of appointment in favour of the next candidates shown in the
order of preference.”
78. In view of the aforesaid, he submits that a challenge to the selection
process at the behest of such a candidate cannot be maintained, and the
said writ petition has become infructuous. In support of the aforesaid
proposition of law, he has placed reliance upon the decisions reported in
the case of Kumari Chitra Ghosh and another v. Union of India and
22
others
“12. The other question which was canvassed before the High Court
and which has been pressed before us relates to the merits of the
nominations made to the reserved seats. It seems to us that the
appellants do not have any right to challenge the nominations made by
the Central Government. They do not compete for the reserved seats
and have no locus standi in the matter of nomination to such seats. The
assumption that if nominations to reserved seats are not in accordance
with the rules all such seats as have not been properly filled up would
be thrown open to the general pool is wholly unfounded. The Central
Government is under no obligation to release those seats to the general
pool. It may in the larger interest of giving maximum benefit to
candidates belonging to the non-reserved seats release them but it
cannot be compelled to do so and the instance of students who have
applied for admission from out of the categories for whom seats have
21 (2000) 2 UPLBEC 1161
22 1969 (2) SCC 228
46
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
not been reserved. In our opinion the High Court was in error in going
into the question and holding that out of the nine seats filled by
nomination to had been filled contrary to the admission rules and these
would be converted into the general pool. Since no appeal has been
filed against that part of the order we refrain from making any further
observations in the matter.”
23
79. In the case of Dr. N.C. Singhal v. Union of India and others, the
Supreme Court held as below:-
“21. Having examined the challenge to the promotion of respondents 4
to 24 on merits, it must be made clear that the appellant is least
qualified to question their promotions. Each one of them was promoted
to a post in supertime grade II in a speciality other than Ophthalmology
and appellant admittedly was not qualified for any of these posts. Even
if their promotions are struck down appellant will not get any post
Incidentally High Court also upheld their promotions observing that by
the time the petition was heard each one of them had requisite service
qualification and, therefore, the promotions could not be struck down.
Once the challenge on merits fails the second string to the bow need not
be examined. Having said all this appellant is least competent to
challenge their promotions. In a slightly comparable situation this Court
in Chitra Ghosh v. Union of India (1970) 1 SCR 413 at p. 420 : (AIR
1970 SC 35), observed as under :
"The other question which was canvassed before the High Court
and which has been pressed before us relates to the merits of the
nominations made to the reserved seats. It seems to us that the
appellants do not have any right to challenge the nominations
made by the Central Government. They do not compete for the
reserved seats and have no locus standi in the matter of
nomination to such seats. The assumption that if nominations to
reserved seats are not in accordance with the rules all such seats
as have not been properly filled up would be thrown open to the
general pool is wholly unfounded".”
80. In the case of Khalid Hussain (Minor) v. Commissioner and
Secretary to Government of Tamil Nadu, Health Department, Madras
24
and others, the Supreme Court held as under:-
“7. The remaining contention does not merit consideration. The learned
Judges although inclined to the view that respondent No. 6 had really
not participated in a National tournament, were entitled to take the view
that the Court ought not to, in the facts and circumstances of the case,
exercise its discretionary powers under Art. 226 of the Constitution at
the instance of the petitioner who was not entitled to any relief merely
23 AIR 1980 SC 1255
24 AIR 1987 SC 2074
47
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
because the Selection Committee was wrong in its view that respondent
No. 6 had played in a National tournament although he had in fact
played in a zonal tournament. Any other view would have been
manifestly unjust as respondent No. 6 though admitted to the Regional
Engineering College, Kurukshetra had given up his seat there on his
being admitted to the M.B.B.S. course and had already undergone his
course of studies for more than six months. The learned Judges rightly
observe that it is not obligatory for the Court to interfere in all cases
unless justice of the case so demands.”
81. Shri G.K. Singh, learned Senior Advocate, while responding to the
arguments advanced by the counsel for the petitioners, submits that the
judgment in the case of Indra Raj Singh Yadav (supra), having approved
the guidelines framed by the Commission, is not required to be followed
by the Board while making the present selection, as the Rules, 1998
themselves lay down a detailed procedure, which was not available
under the Rules, 1983.
82. While placing reliance upon Rule 6 of the Rules, 1983, he submits
that only broad parameters were provided under the said Rules, on the
basis whereof the selections were to be made. However, the said
provision lacked necessary details. It is for this reason that a set of
guidelines was framed by the Commission for making selections to the
post of Principal. These guidelines were under consideration before this
Court in the case of Indra Raj Singh Yadav (supra), which fact would be
evident from a bare perusal of paragraph 6 onwards of the said
judgment.
83. Shri G.K. Singh, learned Senior Counsel, submits that the selection
under challenge has been made in accordance with the Rules, 1998. Rule
11 provides that the names of the two Senior-Most Teachers shall be
forwarded by the Committee of Management to the Board, who would
be considered for appointment to the post of Principal along with the
direct applicants. The procedure for direct recruitment has been laid
down under Rule 12 of the Rules, 1998. For ready reference Rules 11 &
12 of Rules, 1998 are reproduced below:-
“11. Determination and notification of vacancies.--
48
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
(1) For the purposes of direct recruitment to the post of teacher, the
Management shall determine the number of vacancies in accordance
with sub-section (1) of Section 10 and notify the vacancies through the
Inspector, to the Board in the manner hereinafter provided.
(2) (a) The statement of vacancies for each category of posts to be
filled in by direct recruitment including the vacancies that are likely
to arise due to retirement on the last day of the year of recruitment,
shall be sent in quadruplicate, in the pro forma given in Appendix
"A" by the Management to the Inspector by July 15 of the year of
recruitment and the Inspector shall, after verification from the record
of his office, prepare consolidated statement of vacancies of the
district subject wise in respect of the vacancies of lecturer grade, and
GroupWise in respect of vacancies of trained graduates grade. The
consolidated statement so prepared shall, along with the copies of
statement received from the Management, be sent by the Inspector to
the Board by July 31 with a copy thereof to the Joint Director:
Provided that if the State Government is satisfied that it is expedient
so to do, it may, by order in writing, fix other dates for notification
of vacancies to the Board in respect of any particular year of
recruitment:
Provided further that in respect of the vacancies existing on the date
of the commencement of these rules as well as the vacancies that are
likely to arise on June 30, 1998, the Management shall, unless some
other dates are fixed under the preceding proviso, send the statement
of vacancies by July 20, 1998 to the Inspector and the Inspector shall
send the consolidated statement in accordance with this sub-rule to
the Board by July 25, 1998.
Explanation.--For the purposes of this sub-rule the word GroupWise
in respect of the trained graduates grade means in accordance with
the following groups, namely :
(a) Language This group consists of the subjects
of Hindi, Sanskrit, Urdu, Persian
and Arabic;
(b) Science This group consists of the subjects
of Science and Mathematics;
(c) Art and Craft
(d) Music
(e) Agriculture
(f)Home Science
(g) Physical
Education
(h) General This group consists of the subjects
49
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
not covered in any of the foregoing
groups.
(b) With regard to the post of Principal or Headmaster, the
Management shall also forward the names of two seniormost
teachers, along with copies of their service records (including
character rolls) and such other records or particulars as the
Board may require from time to time.
Explanation.--For the purpose of this sub-rule "seniormost
teacher" means the seniormost teachers in the post of the
highest grade in the institution, irrespective of total service
put in the institution.
(3) If, after the vacancies have been notified under sub-rule (2), any
vacancy in the post of a teacher occurs, the Management shall,
within fifteen days of its occurrence, notify to the Inspector in
accordance with the said sub-rule and the Inspector shall within ten
days of its receipt by him send it to the Board.
(4) Where, for any year of recruitment, the Management does not
notify the vacancies by the date specified in sub-rule (2) or fails to
notify them in accordance with the said sub-rule, the Inspector shall
on the basis of the record of his office, determine the vacancies in
such institution in accordance with sub-section (1) of Section 10 and
notify them to the Board in the manner and by the date referred to in
the said sub-rule. The vacancies notified to the Board under this sub-
rule shall be deemed to be notified by the Management of such
institution.
12. Procedure for direct recruitment.—
(1) The Board shall, in respect of the vacancies to be filled by direct
recruitment, advertise the vacancies including those reserved for
candidates belonging to Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, Other
Backward Classes and other reserved categories as applicable to
Government service from time to time, in at least two daily
newspapers, having wide circulation in the State; and call for the
applications through online or offline (OMR Application form) or
both for being considered for selection in the Pro-forma
published in the advertisement. The pro-forma of the application
shall be on OMR sheet which shall be sold through Nationalized
bank or post office. For the post of Principal of an Intermediate
College or the Headmaster of a High School, the name and place of
the Institutionshall also be mentioned in the advertisement and the
candidates shall be required to give the choice of not more than
three institutions in order of preference for any particular
Institutionor institutions and for no other institution, he may
mention the fact in his application.
50
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
(2) The Board shall scrutinize the applications and in respect of the
post of teacher in Lecturers, Trained Graduates Grade and attached
primary section shall conduct written examination. The written
examination shall consist of one paper of general aptitude test of
two hours, based on the subject. The centres for conducting written
examination shall be fixed in district headquarters only and the
invigilators shall be paid honorarium at such rate as the Board may
like to fix.
(3) The Board shall evaluate the answer sheets through examiner to
be appointed by the Board or through Computer and the examiner
shall be paid honorarium at the rate to be fixed by the Board.
(4) The Board shall, having regard to the need for securing due
representation of the candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes,
Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes of citizens, call for
interview such candidates who have secured the maximum marks
under sub-clause (2) above in such manner that the number of
candidates shall not be less than three and not more than five times
of the number of vacancies.
(5) The Board shall, having regard to the need for securing due
representation of the candidates belonging to Scheduled Castes,
Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes of citizens, in
respect of the post of Principal/Headmaster, call for interview such
candidates who have secured maximum marks under the quality
points specified in Appendix 'D' in such manner that the number of
candidates shall not be less than three and not more than five times
of the number of vacancies.
(6) The Board, having regard to the need for securing due
representation of the candidates belonging to the Scheduled
Castes/Scheduled Tribes and Other Backward Classes of citizens in
respect of the post of teacher in Lecturers and Trained graduates
grade, call for interview such candidates who have secured the
maximum marks under sub-clause (4) above/and for the post of
Principal/Headmaster, call for interview such candidates who have
secured maximum marks under sub-clause (5) above in such
manner that the number of candidates shall not be less than three
and not more than five times of the number of vacancies:
Provided that in respect of the post of the Principal or Headmaster
of an Institution, the Board shall also in addition call for interview
two senior-most teachers of the Institution whose names are
forwarded by the Management through Inspector under clause (b)
of sub-rule (2) of Rule 11.
(7) The marks obtained in the quality points as referred to in sub-
rule (5) by the eligible candidates shall not be disclosed to the
members of the interview board.
51
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
(8) The Board then, for each category of post, prepare panel of
those found most suitable for appointment in order of merit as
disclosed by the marks obtained by them after adding the marks
obtained under sub-clause (4) or sub-clause (5) above, as the case
may be, with the marks obtained in the interview. The panel for the
post of Principal or Headmaster shall be prepared institution-wise
after giving due regard to the preference given by a candidate, if
any, for appointment in a particular Institutionwhereas for the posts
in the Lecturers and Trained graduates grade, it shall be prepared
subject-wise and group-wise respectively. If two or more
candidates obtain equal marks, the name of the candidate who has
higher quality points shall be placed higher in the panel and if the
marks obtained in the quality points are also equal, then the name
of the candidate who is older in age shall be placed higher. In the
panel for the post of Principal or Headmaster, the number of names
shall be three-times of the number of the vacancy and for the post
of teachers in the Lecturers and Trained graduate grade, it shall be
larger (but not larger than twenty-five per cent) than the number of
vacancies.
Explanation.— For the purposes of this sub-rule the word “group-
wise” means in accordance with the groups specified in the
Explanation to sub-rule (2) of Rule 11.
(9) In the case of Lecturer grade, the Board shall at the time of
interview after showing the lists of institutions which have notified
the vacancy to it, require the candidates to give, if she/he so desires,
the choice of not more than five, such institutions in order of
preference where if selected, he/she may wish to be appointed and
in the case of teachers in Trained Graduate grade and attached
primary teachers such choices shall be given to candidates after
preparation of merit list on the basis of written examination by the
Board.
(10) The Board shall after preparing the panel in accordance with
sub-rule (8), allocate the institutions to the selected candidates in
respect of the posts of teachers in Lecturers and Trained graduates
grade in such manner that the candidate whose name appears at the
top of the panel shall be allocated the Institutionof his first
preference given in accordance with sub-rule (9). Where a selected
candidate cannot be allocated any of the institutions of his
preference on the ground that the candidates placed higher in the
panel have already been allocated such institutions and there
remains no vacancy in them, the Board may allocate any Institution
to him as it may deem fit.
(11) The Board shall forward the panel prepared under sub-rule (8)
along with the name of the Institution allocated to selected
candidates in accordance with sub-rule (10) to the Inspector with a
52
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
copy thereof to the Joint Director and also notify them on its notice
board. ”
84. A perusal of the aforesaid Rule would indicate that Rule 12(2),
provides that the Board shall scrutinize the applications in respect of the
posts of Teacher and Lecturer and shall conduct a written examination,
whereafter a list of candidates in each category of post shall be prepared
on the basis of the marks obtained in the written examination and the
marks for special merit, as provided under Rule 12(4). Thereafter, under
sub-rule (5), the selection for the post of Headmaster/Principal shall be
made, with 60% of the marks being awarded on the basis of the Quality
Point Marks specified in Appendix 'A'.
85. It is noteworthy that the Rules, 1983 did not provide for the manner
in which Quality Point Marks were to be awarded in the case of a
Principal, whereas the Rules, 1998 make specific provision in this
regard. Not only this, the Rules, 1998 further provide for the marks to be
awarded during the interview, which are divided into three categories,
namely, 6% on the basis of subject/general knowledge, 4% on the basis
of personality test, and 5% on the basis of ability of expression.
86. Sub-rule (6) provides for the interview of candidates who have
secured the maximum marks under sub-clause (v), and stipulates that the
number of candidates to be called for interview shall not be less than
three times and not more than five times, the number of vacancies.
87. The proviso to the said Rule further lays down that the two Senior-
Most Teachers, whose names have been forwarded by the Management,
shall also be called for interview. Rule 12(7) provides that the marks
obtained on the basis of Quality Point Marks, as referred to in sub-rule
(5), by an eligible candidate shall not be disclosed to the members of the
Interview Board. Rule 12(8) further requires a panel of candidates found
suitable for appointment to be prepared in the order determined on the
basis of the marks obtained under clauses (iv) and (v). The said panel for
the post of Principal/Headmaster is to be prepared Institution-wise,
having due regard to the preferences indicated by the candidates.
53
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
88. In view of the aforesaid, he submits that once the Rules, 1998
provide for an elaborate procedure, which was absent under the earlier
Rules, 1983, there remains no occasion for the Commission to continue
with the guidelines which were framed under the Rules, 1983. He further
submits that the aforesaid procedure provides a wider spectrum of
opportunity to candidates who deserve to be selected on the basis of
merit.
89. He submits that, in case the argument of the petitioners is accepted,
by balancing the competing interests of the two Senior-Most Teachers
with those of the five direct-recruitment candidates, the same procedure
would be detrimental to the remaining candidates, who would be
excluded even before the interview. In such an eventuality, the marks
obtained in the Interview would become redundant, as such candidates
would not get an opportunity to be allotted an Institution of their choice,
even if they secure higher marks than the said five candidates who,
according to the petitioners, are required to be called for interview vis-à-
vis the Institution in question.
90. The preference cannot be determined merely on the basis of Quality
Point Marks; rather, all candidates who have opted for a particular
Institution should be given a fair opportunity to compete for a position in
the said Institution on the basis of their Quality Point Marks and the
marks obtained in the interview. He submits that there is a difference of
almost 99 marks between respondent No. 7 and the Petitioner, namely,
Hari Prakash Narain Dubey, and, as such, the Petitioner is no match for
the selected candidate.
91. In response to the aforesaid argument, Shri Ashok Khare, learned
Senior Advocate appearing for the Petitioners, submits that the
guidelines clearly required the competing interests of the two senior-
most candidates to be considered vis-à-vis the five direct recruits.
However, in a case where all the direct-recruitment applicants give their
first preference to the Institution from which the two Senior-Most
Teachers have been recommended, there would be no occasion to accord
54
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
any preference to the candidature of the said two Senior-Most Teachers.
On the contrary, the said two Senior-Most Teachers would be placed at
an inequitable position, since their candidature would be considered only
against the said Institution and not against any other institution.
92. As a matter of fact, if the Senior-Most Teachers apply through direct
recruitment, giving their first preference to the Institution in question,
they would not only be considered for the said Institution on the basis of
their preference but also for other Institutions in respect of which they
have exercised a preference. As such, he submits that, if the arguments
advanced by the respondents are accepted, there would be no preference
whatsoever in favour of the Senior-Most Teachers of the Institution in
question vis-à-vis the said institution.
93. In view of the aforesaid rival contentions of the parties, the core
issue that primarily requires examination is whether the guidelines
formulated under the Rules, 1983 and approved by this Court in the case
of Indra Raj Singh Yadav (supra) are required to be followed
notwithstanding the subsequent enforcement of the Rules, 1998. For
determining the aforesaid issue, it would be necessary to examine the
Rules, 1983 and the decision of this Court in the case of Indra Raj Singh
Yadav (supra).
94. The Division Bench of this Court, upon consideration of the matter,
found that the methodology adopted by the Commission by way of the
guidelines in question, after the occurrence of a vacancy in an Institution
and intimation thereof by the Management to the Commission, as
required under Rule 4 of the Rules, 1983, was as follows:
“All requisitions made by the Institutions for filling up the posts of
Heads of Institutions falling within the region were pooled
together and, upon receipt of applications from the general
candidates, a graded list was prepared on the basis of Quality
Point Marks. The applications submitted by the candidates
included their preferences in respect of particular Institutions, each
Institution being treated as a separate unit. Thereafter, five
candidates were selected from the top of the graded list prepared
for each such unit, along with the “teacher candidate” of the
55
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
concerned unit, and they were required to appear before an
Interview Board constituted for that unit, the candidates being
selected by lottery on the date of the interview. ”
95. From the aforesaid, it is evident that, along with the two Senior-Most
Teachers, only five candidates from the top of the graded list were
permitted to participate in the interview. In case one of the two Senior-
Most Teachers secured the highest marks, he would stand selected, and
only thereafter would the other candidates have an opportunity to be
considered.
96. However, under the present scheme, it is not only the top five direct-
recruitment candidates who are called for the interview; rather, a merit
list is prepared in respect of all candidates who have given their first
preference to the Institution in question. Thus, a broader field of
consideration is taken into account, instead of limiting the consideration
to the top five candidates in the graded list.
97. For ready reference, paragraphs 26, 27, 28 and 29 of Indra Raj Singh
Yadav (supra) are reproduced below:-
“26. Having given the matter a careful consideration we find that the
above contentions are devoid of any substance. The methodology
adopted by the Commission has been elaborated in the short counter-
affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents referred to above according
to which after the occurrence of a vacancy in an Institution and
intimation of the same by the Management to the Commission as
required under Rule 4, all the requisitions made by various institutions
for filling up the posts of heads of institutions falling in a region are
pooled together and the various applications received by the general
candidates are processed and a graded list prepared on the basis of
quality point marks, the details of which are given in Annexure-CA-1
and have been outlined hereinabove. These quality point marks are
determined with reference to the criteria as regards the academic
record, teaching and administrative experience and the marks allocated
are worked out on the basis of the methodology and guidelines
indicated in the said annexure. The preference given by each applicant
in respect of an Institution treating it as separate unit is also noted. This
process is thereafter computerised according to the information
supplied by the candidates in their respective formats. After that first
five candidates are picked up from the top of the graded list prepared in
the unit in the manner indicated above, these along with the teacher
candidates of the unit are required to appear before the interview board
56
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
constituted for the unit on lottery system on the date of the interview.
The board is manned by three experts drawn in accordance with the
rules and two members of the Commission. Every candidate is then
interviewed by the Board, the interview lasting on an average fifteen to
twenty minutes for each candidate. Marks are allotted by individual
members of the Board by the method of grading at the end of the
interview on the basis of the criteria which has been indicated in
Annexure-CA-2 which reads thus:—
"Madhyamik Shiksha Ayog.
The candidates called for interview have to be adjudged by
members of the Board for 75 marks, keeping in view the
following factors.
1. Personality,
2. Knowledge of the subject,
3. Knowledge of current ideas and problems of the educational
work and diagnostic attitude towards them.
4. General knowledge.
5. Administrative ability regarding school management.
6. Self expressive and impressive views.
7. Achievement in curricular activities of the regional and State
levels."
27. After the seven candidates referred to have been interviewed the
average of the marks given by the members of the Board is calculated
and the average for each general candidates is assigned as their
respective marks in the interview.
28. In the case of teacher candidates the methodology adopted for
computing the marks obtained, by them at the interview may be set out
in the own words of the respondents as disclosed in paragraph 4(e) of
the short counter-affidavit:-
"In case of two teacher candidates their service record and
experience is evaluated by the two members of the commission
in the Board on the basis of the guidelines fixed by the
Commission. According to which some marks in a definite
proportion are availed of the maximum marks fixed for the
interview and the service record and experience of the teacher
candidate is evaluated against such marks in a manner prescribed
by the Commission. The marks obtained thus by the teacher
candidates is modulated in the same proportion with the marks
obtained by the teacher candidates in interview along with the
general candidates. On doing so, of the two marks obtained by
the teacher candidates that which stands to the advantage of the
teacher candidate is taken into account and accordingly marks so
57
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
obtained are assigned to the teacher candidates as their marks in
the interview.”
29. As a result of the marks allocated to the seven candidates if it is
found that the teacher candidate secured the top position he is selected
as the head of the Institution straightway. In case the teacher candidate
does not secure the top position, the Institution is thrown open for the
general candidates. In the latter case for every Institution so opened for
general candidates a graded list is prepared for the unit on the basis of
the total marks arrived at by adding the quality point marks to the
marks obtained by them at the Interview and the preference given by
the general candidates in the category. The first three candidates on the
top of such a list are set out in the panel of the Institution and the same
is sent to the Deputy Director of Education and the District Inspector of
Schools in accordance with the provisions of the Act and the rules made
thereunder.”
98. I may also refer to the notification dated 01.01.2022.
For ready reference, paragraph 11 thereof, extracted in the form of
paragraphs 4 and 5, is reproduced below:-
“4. -
प्रश्नगत विज्ञापन में संस्था प्रधान पदों के सापेक्ष आफलाइन प्राप्त आवेदन पत्रों को बोर्ड द्वारा
आनलाइन किया गया है तथा उसमें अंकित सूचनाओं का सत्यापन सम्बन्धि त अभ्यर्थियों से कराये
जाने का निर्णय बोर्ड द्वारा लिया गया है। आफलाइन आवेदनों के आनलाइन संस्करण के सत्यापन
, /
हेतु चयन बोर्ड की वेबसाइट पर विस्तृत अनुदेश यूजर मैनुअल प्रक्रिया तथा पोर्टल का लिंक
प्रदशित है।
5.
सम्बन्धि त अभ्यर्थी कृपया अनुदेशो का भली भांति अध्ययन कर यूजर मैनुअल में निर्दिष्ट प्रक्रिया
/
का पालन करते हुये अपने आवेदन की सूचनाओं की सत्यता का सत्यापन कर लें। किसी त्रुटि
मिन्नता की दशा में उसे साक्ष्य सहित अद्यतन करते हुये आवेदित मण्डल के विज्ञापित संस्थाओं में से
03
यथाआवश्यकता नियमानुसार संस्थाओं की अधिमानता का विकल्प भी पोर्टल पर भरें। इस हेतु
08.01.2022
पोर्टल दिनांक तक ही क्रियाशील रहेगा”
99. A perusal of the aforesaid indicates that the applications were
submitted online and were required to be verified by the candidates. The
website also contained the user manual and the procedure to be
followed, and the candidates were required to verify the details and
indicate three preferences on the portal by 08.01.2022.
100. It is not the case of the Petitioners that they had not exercised any
preference on the online portal or that the consideration was confined to
the candidature of the two senior-most lecturers.
58
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
101. In view of the aforesaid, the contention that the Petitioners were not
aware of the procedure adopted by the Commission after the
enforcement of the Rules, 1998 cannot be accepted.
102. It is also necessary to examine whether there has been any
departure from the Rules, 1998. Under the Rules, 1998, the manner in
which vacancies are to be notified to the Board has been prescribed, and
the procedure for selection of candidates for direct recruitment to the
post of Principal/Headmaster has also been prescribed. As per Rule 10,
the post of Principal of an Intermediate College or Headmaster of a High
School is to be filled by direct recruitment.
103. Rule 11 provides for the determination and notification of
vacancies. Rule 11(2)(a) deals with the statement of vacancies, whereas
Rule 11(2)(b) provides that the Management shall forward the names of
the two Senior-Most Teachers, along with copies of their service records,
etc., and that they may also apply for direct recruitment to the post of
Principal.
104. A reading of Rule 11(2)(b) makes it evident that, while forwarding
the statement of vacancies for the posts of teachers, including the post of
Principal/Headmaster, as referred to in sub-rule (2)(a), the Management
shall also forward the names of the two Senior-Most Teachers. The use
of the words “may also” makes it clear that the names of the two Senior-
Most Teachers are required to be sent along with the statement of
vacancies. The entire exercise has to be undertaken at the
commencement of the year of recruitment. It naturally follows that the
two Senior-Most Teachers, as existing at the relevant time, when the
requisition is sent during the year of recruitment, fall within the zone of
consideration under Rule 11(2)(b) of the Rules, 1998, just as was the
position under Rule 4(2) of the Rules, 1983. The said position has not
been altered; and it is also not the case, that the names of the two Senior-
Most Teachers were not forwarded.
105. However, in the context of Rule 4(1) of the Rules, 1983, there was
no Appendix 'A' prescribing the manner in which Quality Point Marks
59
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
were to be awarded, and it was for this reason that the guidelines were
framed by the Commission, as discussed herein above. It is also not the
case of the petitioners that the names of the two Senior-Most Teachers
were not forwarded by the Management. Their objection, in essence, is
that, instead of confining the consideration to the top five candidates in
the graded list, all candidates who had given their first preference to the
Institution in question, were considered. Further, under the Rules, 1998,
the manner in which Quality Point Marks are to be awarded has been
specifically detailed in the Appendix. Not only this, three categories
have also been prescribed as guidelines, for the allocation of marks
during the interview. Thereafter, in terms of Rule 12(8), the Board is
required to prepare a panel of candidates found suitable for appointment
in the order of merit, as determined on the basis of the marks obtained by
them, after adding the marks obtained under sub-clause (iv) or sub-
clause (v), as the case may be, to the marks obtained in the interview.
106. The said panel for the post of Principal/Headmaster is prepared
Institution-wise, after giving due regard to the preference, if any,
expressed by the candidate for appointment to a particular Institution. In
terms of the aforesaid criteria laid down under Rule 12, the Commission
prepared the panel for the post of Principal/Headmaster Institution-wise,
after giving due regard to the preference expressed by the candidate.
107. In view of the aforesaid mandate of the Rules, 1998, the argument
advanced by learned counsel for the petitioners that the guidelines
framed by the Commission require only the top five candidates from the
graded list to be invited for interview cannot be sustained, as Rule 12(8)
clearly provides that the panel is to be prepared Institution-wise, after
giving due regard to the preference expressed by a candidate for
appointment to a particular Institution. As such, restricting the panel to
the top five candidates in the graded list would be contrary to, and in
contravention of, the mandate of Rule 12(8) of the Rules, 1998.
108. In view of the aforesaid, another argument that, if the two Senior-
Most Teachers apply directly, giving first preference to the Institution in
60
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
question, they would also be considered only on the basis of merit, and
that no preference would thereafter remain in their favour by virtue of
their names being recommended by the Management along with the
statement of vacancies on the basis of their seniority, also requires
examination in the light of Rule 12(8) of the Rules, 1998.
109. It is no doubt, true that the requirement for the Management to
forward the names of the two Senior-Most Teachers of the Institution at
the time of notifying the vacancies is also a mandate of the Rules, 1998.
However, merely on the basis of the said requirement, it cannot be said
that any preference is to be given to such candidates. Their candidature
is to be considered irrespective of whether they exercise a preference for
the Institution in question. As regards the option available to such
candidates, to be considered against other Institutions, there is no bar
under the Rules, 1998 preventing them from making an application for
consideration against the three preferences, as is required of a direct
candidate.
110. Accordingly, the apprehension of the petitioners that they would
only be considered on the basis of the merit and no preference would
thereafter remain in their favour by virtue of their names being
recommended by the Management, is also misplaced; as the Rules
specifically provides that the Management shall forward their names, by
virtue of them being the two senior-most Lecturers in the Institutions;
and in case they desired to be considered for any other Institution, in the
said case also there is no embargo upon such candidates to appear as
direct candidates; and their application shall be considered according to
their preference.
111. However in view of Rule 12(8) of the Rules, 1998, the Board is
required to prepare a panel of candidates in order of merit, as determined
on basis of the marks obtained by them, after adding the marks obtained
under Sub-Clause (iv) or Sub-Clause (v), as the case may be; and
therefore no preference can be accorded vis-a-vis the direct applicants,
for the said preference contrary to the Rule 12 of the Rules, 1998 as
61
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
claimed by the petitioners, who are amongst the two senior-most
Lecturers and any interpretation to the contrary shall do violence to the
statutory provision.
112. The said option was available to the candidates and, admittedly, the
Senior-Most Teachers have also submitted their applications online in
pursuance of the notification dated 01.01.2022, while complying with
the guidelines notified thereunder. It, therefore, cannot be said that they
were unaware of the procedure emanating from the Rules, 1998.
113. In view of the aforesaid, the challenge to the selection in question
cannot be sustained on the premise that the Commission was required to
follow the guidelines which were upheld in the case of Indra Raj Singh
Yadav (supra), as the said guidelines pertained to the selection which
was under challenge before this Court at a time when the Rules, 1983
were in vogue.
114. The present selection, admittedly, is governed by the Rules, 1998
and, therefore, cannot be faulted in view of the scheme of the Rules,
1998, as discussed herein above. As such, no good ground has been
made out for interference in exercise of the power under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India.
115. I, may also refer to the three categories of writ petitions, which
were mentioned at the inception.
116. The batch of writ petitions categorized as “Category-A” has been
filed by the candidates who were not eligible on the last date of filing of
the application, i.e. 25.02.2014; and the objection which was being
raised by the counsel for the respondents regarding the maintainability of
the writ petitions has also not been refuted by any of the counsels
appearing in the batch of writ petitions from serial no. 1 to 20 in the
cause title. The eligibility is to be seen on the last date of application and
as such the said petitioners being not eligible, has no cause of action to
challenge or assail the impugned Select List.
117. Sri G.K. Singh, learned Senior Counsel, had also raised a precise
contention that the candidates who had reached the age of
62
WRIA No. - 19537 of 2022
superannuation or are working on the extension granted, under the
regulations also do not have a vested right to continue till the end of the
academic session, and further, no appointment can be granted to such a
candidate, as held by this Court in the cases of Hari Prakash Narain
(supra), R.L. Prasad (supra), and Km. Chitra Ghosh (supra). This Court
finds force in the argument.
118. There was no contention to the contrary raised by the petitioners in
the batch of writ petitions which has been shown under Category-B,
from serial no. 21 to 37 in the cause title; and as far as the claim of the
candidates under Category-C, i.e. from serial no. 38 to serial no. 115 in
the cause title, is concerned, their arguments and contentions having
been considered, this Court is of the view that the said writ petitions
deserve to be dismissed, likewise, on the facts and circumstances stated
herein above.
119. Before parting with the judgment, this Court deems it appropriate to
place on record its appreciation for the research undertaken by Ms.
Pratibha Verma, Research Associate.
120. In view of the above, the entire batch of Petitions, stand dismissed;
and the consequences shall follow, while the selection which was
initiated in the year 2013, shall be brought to it’s logical end. However,
there shall be no order as to costs.
(Siddharth Nandan,J.)
October 5, 2026
S.Prakash/Piyush
Digitally signed by :-
SHASHI PRAKASH
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad