M/S. Awadhesh Singh Gautam vs State Of Chhattisgarh
- Court
- Supreme Court
NON-REPORTABLE
2026 INSC 1072
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(@ S.L.P. (C) No. 10464 of 2026)
M/S AWADHESH SINGH GAUTAM ... APPELLANT
Vs.
STATE OF CHHATTISGARH & ORS. ... RESPONDENTS
WITH
CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(S.L.P. (C) No. 12766 of 2026)
AND
CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(@ S.L.P. (C) No. 12346 of 2026)
J U D G M E N T
ALOK ARADHE, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. These three appeals arise out of three orders, each dated
1
07.01.2026, passed by the High Court , whereby three writ
petitions instituted by M/s Awadhesh Singh Gautam, a
partnership firm ("the appellant"), were dismissed. Since the
three orders are, in substance, identical and the appeals turn
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
KAPIL TANDON
Date: 2026.09.30
17:41:28 IST
Reason:
upon a common question arising from a common factual
1
High Court of Chhattisgarh at Bilaspur
1
matrix, they were heard together and are disposed of by this
common judgment.
THE FACTUAL MATRIX
3.
The controversy has its genesis in three works awarded to the
appellant. Pursuant to notices inviting tenders issued by the
Chhattisgarh Rural Road Development Agency ("CGRRDA"), the
appellant was awarded three packages under the Pradhan
Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana ("PMGSY"), for which work orders
came to be issued on 01.09.2023 and 05.11.2024 ("the
subsequent works").
4. Having executed approximately 40% of the work under each of
the subsequent works, the appellant raised running bills
aggregating Rs.39,78,500/- (Rupees Thirty-Nine Lakh Seventy-
Eight Thousand Five Hundred only), Rs.45,62,000/- (Rupees
Forty-Five Lakh Sixty-Two Thousand only) and Rs.23,55,000/-
(Rupees Twenty-Three Lakh Fifty-Five Thousand only)
respectively. Reminders followed on 22.09.2025 and
25.09.2025, but the amounts billed remained unreleased.
5. The appellant had earlier, on 03.01.2023, been awarded two
separate contracts for construction of two roads at 10.10%
above the Schedule of Rates, at an approved cost of
2
approximately Rs.437.43 lakhs ("the earlier works"), under
which a substantial part of the contract value had already been
paid.
6.
Complaints of irregularity in execution of the earlier works led
the Collector, South Bastar, Dantewada, to constitute a five-
member committee. The committee, by its report dated
09.01.2024, found that although Rs.3,55,82,055/- (Rupees
Three Crore Fifty-Five Lakh Eighty-Two Thousand Fifty Five
only) had been paid to the appellant, the value of work actually
executed was only about Rs.1,54,75,938/- (Rupees One Crore
Fifty-Four Lakh Seventy-Five Thousand Nine Hundred Thirty-
Eight only), disclosing an excess payment of Rs.2,01,06,117/-
(Rupees Two Crore One Lakh Six Thousand One Hundred
Seventeen only). It recommended recovery of the said sum,
blacklisting of the appellant, a probe into its other works, and
departmental action against the concerned officers of the
CGRRDA.
7. Acting on this report, the Collector, by memo dated 03.06.2024,
directed the Tehsildar to recover Rs.2,01,06,117/- (Rupees Two
Crore One Lakh Six Thousand One Hundred Seventeen only)
from the appellant. The Tehsildar accordingly registered a
3
revenue case and issued a demand note dated 16.12.2024
under Section 146 of the Chhattisgarh Land Revenue Code,
1959, calling upon the appellant to pay the amount within ten
days.
8. The demand note was assailed in a writ petition. By order dated
05.03.2025, the High Court quashed it for want of notice or
hearing to the appellant, being violative of natural justice, while
reserving liberty to the respondents to act upon the committee's
report afresh, in accordance with law and after complying with
the principles of natural justice.
9. In the meanwhile, upon a complaint by an Assistant Engineer
of CGRRDA, a First Information Report came to be registered
against Mr. Awadhesh Singh Gautam, partner of the appellant
firm, and officers of CGRRDA, for offences under Sections 420,
467, 468, 471, 409 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
A chargesheet was filed on 30.12.2025 upon completion of
investigation.
10. Independently of the criminal proceedings, and drawing upon
the inspection report of the District Level Investigation Team
dated 18.12.2024, the reinspection report of the Departmental
Supervising Engineer dated 28.10.2024, and a final re-
4
evaluation undertaken by the Departmental Sub-Engineer, the
Executive Engineer-cum-Member Secretary, Project
Implementation Unit K-01 ("the Executive Engineer"), passed
an order dated 27.09.2025 ("the recovery order"). By this order,
a sum of Rs.84,17,003/- (Rupees Eighty-Four Lakh Seventeen
Thousand and Three only) was blocked out of amounts
currently payable to the appellant, to be recovered by deduction
from the three subsequent works in the sums of Rs.28,00,000/-
(Rupees Twenty Eight Lakh only), Rs.38,00,000/- (Rupees
Thirty Eight Lakh only) and Rs.18,17,003/- (Rupees Eighteen
Lakh Seventeen Thousand and Three only) respectively.
11. The appellant's representation dated 09.10.2025 to the
Executive Engineer, pointing out that the deductions were
being made from bills payable under contracts wholly distinct
from the earlier works out of which the alleged liability arose,
and seeking a refund of Rs.84,17,003/- (Rupees Eighty-Four
Lakh Seventeen Thousand and Three only) within fifteen days,
elicited no response.
12. Three writ petitions came to be filed assailing the recovery order
and seeking release of the amounts deducted. By the impugned
common order dated 07.01.2026, the High Court held that the
5
relief claimed was contingent upon adjudication of disputed
questions of fact, which could not be undertaken in proceedings
under Article 226 of the Constitution, and dismissed the writ
petitions, reserving liberty to the appellant to pursue such
alternate remedy as may be available in law.
13. It is in this backdrop that these appeals fall for our
consideration.
RIVAL SUBMISSIONS
14. Mr. Gaurav Agrawal, learned senior counsel for the appellant,
submitted that the recovery order was passed without notice or
opportunity of hearing, in violation of Clause 4.1 of the Special
Conditions of Contract contained in the Standard Bidding
Document ("SBD"), which alone contemplates recovery
consequent upon technical audit and that too after hearing the
contractor. It was urged that appropriation of amounts payable
under one contract towards a liability alleged to arise under an
altogether different contract is impermissible, and that Clauses
43 and 53, dealing respectively with security deposit and
payment upon termination, have no bearing on the recovery in
question. It was highlighted that a sum of Rs.1,07,02,594/-
(Rupees One Crore Seven Lakh Two Thousand Five Hundred
6
Ninety-Four only) remained payable to the appellant under the
very earlier works out of which the alleged liability is said to
arise, yet the respondents chose to recover from three
unconnected and ongoing contracts instead. Reliance was
2
placed on a decision of this Court .
15. Mr. Bishwajit Dubey, learned Additional Advocate General for
the State, submitted that the power of cross-contract recovery
flows expressly from the contract. Reliance was placed on
Clause 7(iv) of the Pre-Contract Integrity Pact and Clause 38 of
the Conditions of Contract, both of which, it was submitted,
permit recovery of dues under one contract from sums payable
under another, and on Clauses 44.1 and 53.1(ii) of the General
Conditions of Contract in the SBD. It was submitted that the
allegation against the appellant is not a mere billing
discrepancy but one of manipulation of measurement books to
draw excess payments from public funds, that a contractual
set-off founded on agreement is enforceable on that basis alone,
and that the appellant cannot claim the benefit of the contract
while disowning the burden it places upon it. Reliance in
2
ABL International Ltd. & Anr. v. Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India Ltd.
& Ors., (2004) 3 SCC 553, paras 26-28
7
support of these submissions was placed on the decisions of
3
this Court .
16. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
POINTS FOR DETERMINATION
17. The following questions arise for determination in these
appeals:
(i) Whether the recovery order dated 27.09.2025 is
traceable to the contractual clauses relied upon by the
respondents?
(ii) Whether, even if so traceable, it satisfies the conditions
that such a clause prescribes and whether the recovery
order has been passed in violation of principles of
natural justice?
(i) WHETHER THE IMPUGNED RECOVERY IS TRACEABLE TO
THE CONTRACT?
18. We deal with the clauses of the General Conditions of Contract,
the Special Conditions of Contract, the Pre-Contract Integrity
3
Caretel Infotech Ltd. v. Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited (HPCL) & Ors.,
(2019) 14 SCC 81, para 24 ; Bharti Airtel Ltd. & Anr. v. Vijaykumar V. Iyer & Ors.,
(2024) 4 SCC 668, paras 15-19 ; State of Gujarat & Anr. v. Amber Builders, (2020) 2
SCC 540, paras 20-21 ; H.M. Kamaluddin Ansari and Co. v. Union of India & Ors.,
(1983) 4 SCC 417, paras 29 and 31 ; Nabha Power Limited (NPL) v. Punjab State Power
Corporation Limited (PSPCL) & Anr., (2018) 11 SCC 508, para 72 and Union of India
& Ors. v. N. Murugesan & Ors., (2022) 2 SCC 25, para 26
8
Pact, and the Conditions of Contract on which the respondents
have placed reliance, to examine whether the recovery order can
be justified by reference to any of them.
19.
Clause 44.1 of the General Conditions of Contract in the SBD
reads thus:
" 44.1 In the event of failure on part of the
Contractor to achieve timely completion of
the project, including any extension of time
granted under Clause 27, he shall, without
prejudice to any other right or remedy
available under the law to the Employer on
account of such breach, pay as agreed
liquidated damages to the Employer and not
by way of penalty in a sum calculated at the
rate per week or part thereof as stated in the
Contract Data. For the period that the
Completion Date is later than the Intended
Completion Date, liquidated damages at the
same rate shall be withheld if the
Contractors fails to achieve the milestones
prescribed in the Contract Data. However, in
case the Contractor achieved the next
milestone, the amount of the liquidated
damages already withheld shall be restored
to the Contractor by adjustment in the
payment certificate. Both the Parties
expressly agree that the total amount of
liquidated damages shall not exceed 10%
(ten percent) of Initial Contract Price and
that the liquidated damages payable by the
Contractor are mutually agreed genuine pre-
estimated loss and without any proof of
actual damage likely to be suffered and
incurred by the Employer; and the Employer
is entitled to receive the same and are not by
way of penalty.
9
The Employer may, without prejudice to any
other method of recovery, deduct the amount
of such damages from any sum due, or to
become due to the Contractor or from
Performance Security or any other dues from
Government or semi Government bodies
within the state.
The payment or deduction of such damages
shall not relieve the Contractor from his
obligations to complete the Works, or from
any other of his duties, obligations or
responsibilities under the Contract.
The Contractor shall use and continue to use
his best endeavours to avoid or reduce
further delay to the Works, or any relevant
Stages.”
19.1 On a plain reading, this clause is confined to liquidated
damages for delay in achieving completion or contractual
milestones, capped at ten per cent of the initial contract price.
The recovery order has never been founded on a claim,
quantified or otherwise, for liquidated damages for delay; it
proceeds instead from an allegation of overpayment detected on
technical audit, a subject dealt with specifically, and
exclusively, by Clause 4.1 of the Special Conditions of Contract.
Clause 44.1, therefore, furnishes no foundation for the recovery
order.
20. We next consider Clause 53.1(ii) of the General Conditions of
Contract, which reads:
10
" 53.1(ii) If the Contract is terminated
because of a fundamental breach of contract
by the Contractor due to non compliance of
the requirements of clause 32 of GCC
regarding defects liability period and routine
maintenance of roads for five years, the
Engineer will assess the cost of having the
defect corrected. If the total amount due to
the Employer exceeds any payment due to
the Contractor, the difference shall be
recovered from the Security Deposit and
Performance Security. If any amount is still
left un-recovered, it will be recovered from
any dues payable to the Contractor from
State PMGSY works, any other State
Government works including State Public
Sector works executed by the Contractor. If
any amount still remains unrecovered, it
shall be recovered as arrears of land
revenue. "
20.1 This clause is attracted only where a contract is terminated for
the contractor's fundamental breach of its defects-liability and
five-year maintenance obligations under Clause 32, and only to
the extent the assessed cost of rectification exceeds what can
be recovered from the security deposit and performance
security of that very contract; recourse to dues under other
State works follows only in that residual contingency. There is
nothing on record to show that either the earlier works or the
subsequent works were ever terminated, still less terminated on
the ground of breach of defects-liability or maintenance
obligations under Clause 32. The recovery here rests on an
11
allegation of manipulation of measurement books during
execution, a ground altogether distinct from post-completion
default in defect-liability maintenance. Clause 53.1(ii) is thus
not attracted, and the cross-contract mechanism it contains
cannot be pressed into service to sustain the recovery order.
21. Clause 7(iv) of the Integrity Pact, described as a sanction for its
violation, reads as follows:
“ 7. SANCTIONS FOR VIOLATIONS
7(iv) To recover all sums already paid by the
BUYER, and in case of the Indian BIDDER
with interest thereon at 2% higher than the
prevailing Prime Lending Rate. While in case
of a BIDDER from a country other than India
with interest thereon at 2% higher than the
LIBOR. If any outstanding payment is due to
the BIDDER from the BUYER in connection
with any other contract such outstanding
payment could also be utilized to recover the
aforesaid sum and interest.”
21.1 This clause does contemplate recovery, with interest, from dues
payable under any other contract; but its invocation necessarily
presupposes a prior determination, arrived at through whatever
process the pact itself prescribes, that the bidder has in fact
violated the pact in relation to the contract in question. The
recovery order neither refers to the Integrity Pact nor records any
finding that it stands violated. It cannot, therefore, be said that
12
the recovery has in fact been made under Clause 7(iv) of the
Integrity Pact.
22. Clause 38 of the Conditions of Contract, reads as follows:
“ CONDITIONS FOR CONTRACT
Clause 38- On the breach of any term or
condition of this contract by the contractor
the said Governor shall be entitled to forfeit
the Security deposit or the balance thereof
that may at the time be remaining, and to
realise and retain the same as damages and
compensation for the said breach but
without prejudice to the right of the
Governor to recover further sums as
damages from any sums due or which may
become due to the contractor by Government
or otherwise howsoever.”
22.1 The language of Clause 38 is undoubtedly wide enough, once
validly invoked, to permit recovery of sums payable under other
contracts. But its invocation is conditional upon breach of a term
or condition of the contract being first ascertained, and upon
forfeiture being effected as damages and compensation for that
breach; this in turn obliges the Government to ascertain the
breach and to apprise the contractor of it, so that he may meet
the allegation. The recovery order records no finding of breach,
and no notice preceded it. The action in question cannot,
therefore, be said to have been taken under Clause 38.
13
23. This brings us to Clause 4.1 of the Special Conditions of
Contract, which alone answers the description of what the
respondents purported to do, namely, a technical audit of the
earlier works resulting in a finding of overpayment and
consequential recovery. It reads:
4.1 Technical Examination
“The Government / CGRRDA /C.E. /C.E.O
/S.E./ Engineer-in-charge shall have the
right to cause Audit and Technical Examina-
tion of the works and the final bills of the
contractors including all supporting vouch-
ers, abstracts etc., to be made as per pay-
ments of the final bills and if as a result of
such Audit & Technical Examination any
sum found to have been overpaid in respect
of any work done by the contractor under the
contract or any work claimed by him to have
been done under the contract and found not
to have been executed, the contractor shall
be liable to refund the amount of over pay-
ment and it shall be lawful for the Govern-
ment of Chhattisgarh /CGRRDA/ Engineer-
in-charge to recover the same from the secu-
rity deposit of the contractor or from any
dues payable to the contractor from the En-
gineer-in-Charge account. If it is found that
the contractor was paid lesser than what
was due to him under the contract in respect
any work executed by him under it, the
amount of such under payment shall be duly
paid by the Engineer-in-Charge to the con-
tractor.
In the case of any audit examination and re-
covery consequent on the same the contrac-
tor shall be given an opportunity to explain
14
his case and decision of the government/em-
ployer shall be final binding and conclusive.
In the case of Technical Audit, consequent
on which there is a recovery from the con-
tractor, no recovery should be made without
orders of CEO, CGRRDA whose decision
shall be final. All action under this clause
should be initiated and intimated to the con-
tractor within a period of twelve months from
the date of completion.”
23.1 This clause permits recovery from the security deposit of the
contractor, or from dues payable to the contractor, from the
account pertaining to the very work audited, that is, the earlier
works. It is not in dispute that a sum of about Rs.1.07 crore
remained due to the appellant under the earlier works
themselves, yet the respondents took no step to appropriate that
amount; they chose instead to recover from three unconnected
and ongoing packages. Clause 4.1 further makes it obligatory
that the contractor be given an opportunity to explain his case
before any recovery consequent on audit, and mandates that "no
recovery should be made without orders of CEO, CGRRDA whose
decision shall be final". It is common ground that no such
opportunity was afforded, and the recovery order, issued by the
Executive Engineer alone, does not disclose that the approval of
the Chief Executive Officer, CGRRDA, was ever obtained. The
clause additionally requires that action be initiated and
15
intimated to the contractor within twelve months of completion
of the audited work, and no material has been placed before us
to establish the date of completion of the earlier works. Clause
4.1, therefore, also cannot sustain the recovery order.
24. It follows that none of the clauses relied upon by the
respondents, whether read singly or cumulatively, authorises
either the deduction of the disputed amount from the three
subsequent contracts, or the manner in which it was effected.
(ii) WHETHER THE RECOVERY ORDER SATISFIES THE
CONDITIONS THAT THE CLAUSE PRESCRIBES AND
WHETHER THE RECOVERY ORDER HAS BEEN PASSED IN
VIOLATION OF PRINCIPLES OF NATURAL JUSTICE?
25. We are not unmindful that the allegations against the appellant
in respect of the earlier works are of a serious character and are
already the subject of departmental inquiry and of criminal
proceedings arising out of Chargesheet No. 87 of 2025; nothing
said in this judgment touches upon their merits. That, however,
does not answer the second question framed above, namely,
whether the manner of recovery satisfies the conditions Clause
4.1 itself prescribes. Clause 4.1 incorporates within itself,
certain principles of natural justice. As already noticed, the
recovery order was passed without notice, consent and sanction,
16
and no other clause, nor any provision of law, permits the
amount said to be due under the earlier works to be adjusted
against sums payable under a separate and subsisting contract
without the contractor's consent. Until the alleged overpayment
is established in accordance with law, it remains, a disputed and
4
unadjudicated claim for damages and not a debt presently due ;
and a party to a contract cannot, merely because it also holds
amounts otherwise payable under it, treat such a claim as
though it were an ascertained debt and appropriate those
amounts in satisfaction of it. Therefore, the recovery effected by
the recovery order was not only in contravention of the
conditions prescribed in the clause but also in flagrant violation
of principles of natural justice.
26. The High Court fell into error on the ground that the relief
claimed was contingent upon resolution of disputed questions of
fact touching the earlier works, which could not be gone into
under Article 226 of the Constitution. The question before it was
whether the respondent-State was justified in appropriating that
very disputed amount from money admittedly payable to the
4
Union of India v. Raman Iron Foundry, (1974) 2 SCC 231
17
appellant under the three subsequent contracts, contracts that
have nothing to do with the earlier works.
27. For the reasons set out above, neither the agreement governing
the contracts consented to by the contractor nor any provision
of law permits such appropriation, and that question turns
entirely on the construction of the contract and compliance with
its terms, not on the resolution of the disputed facts pertaining
to the earlier works.
CONCLUSION AND DIRECTIONS
28. For the foregoing reasons, the recovery order dated 27.09.2025
cannot be sustained in law and is quashed and set aside. The
respondents are directed to release to the appellant the sum of
Rs.84,17,003/- (Rupees Eighty-Four Lakh Seventeen Thousand
and Three only), together with interest thereon at the rate of 6%
per annum from 27.09.2025 till the date of actual payment.
29. We clarify that this judgment shall not preclude the respondents
from taking recourse to appropriate proceedings, in accordance
with law, for recovery of any amount that may ultimately be
found due from the appellant in respect of the earlier works. We
further clarify that the observations contained in this judgment
18
are confined to the legality of the manner in which the impugned
recovery was effected, and shall have no bearing on: (a) the
pending criminal proceedings arising out of Chargesheet No. 87
of 2025; or (b) the correctness or quantum of the alleged
overpayment in respect of the earlier works, both of which shall
be examined and decided independently and strictly on their own
merits.
30. The appeals are allowed in the above terms. There shall be no
order as to costs.
31. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
........................................................J.
[PAMIDIGHANTAM SRI NARASIMHA]
........................................................J.
[ALOK ARADHE]
NEW DELHI;
SEPTEMBER 30, 2026.
19