Vishnu Vaghmare vs M.P. State Election Commission
- Court
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:77199
1 WP-16326-2015
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SANJEEV S KALGAONKAR
th
ON THE 28 OF SEPTEMBER, 2026
WRIT PETITION No. 16326 of 2015
CNR No.: MPHC010483992015
VISHNU VAGHMARE
Versus
M.P. STATE ELECTION COMMISSION AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Kunal Thakre - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Ritwik Parashar - Government Advocate for the respondents/State.
ORDER
This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is filed by the
petitioner feeling aggrieved of the order dated 30.01.2015 (Annexure P-11) passed
by the Collector, Balaghat whereby he has rejected the representation filed by the
petitioner for payment of his outstanding bills at the accepted rate in furtherance
of the tender dated 07.10.2023.
The petitioner has prayed for the following relief:
"(i) To issue a writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing the order dated
30.01.2015 (Annexure P-11), passed by the Collector, Balaghat.
(ii) To issue a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents
no.2 and 3 to make payment of balance amount i.c. Rs.15,70,700/ -
Rs.4,50,300/-= Rs.11,20,400/- with interest at the rate of 15% per annum
from the date of completion of work till actual realization.
(iii) Any other relief which this Hon'ble Court deems fit and proper may
also be awarded in favour of the petitioner and allow the petition, in the
interest of justice.
(iv) Cost of the petition may also kindly be awarded."
2. The exposition of facts giving rise to filing of this petition, in brief, is
as under:
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: KOUSHALENDRA
SHARAN SHUKLA
Signing time: 30-09-2026
17:11:54
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:77199
2 WP-16326-2015
(A) The Collector and District Election Officer, Balaghat
published notice inviting tender on 7th October 2013 for supply
and installation of projectors during Assembly Election, 2013. The
bidders were directed to provide projectors, sound system and
operator at headquarter -Balaghat and 10 other blocks of district -
Balaghat at the rate quoted by the bidder. The petitioner submitted
his offer (Annexure P-2). The offer of the petitioner was accepted
by the Collector and District Election Officer, Balaghat vide
acceptance letter dated 16/10/2013 (Annexure P-3). Thus, the rates
quoted by the petitioner for supply and installation of the
projectors for training and counting of votes during the Assembly
Election 2013 were approved by the Collector.
( B ) After conclusion of election, the petitioner submitted bills for
payment of an amount of Rs.15,35,655/- regarding supply and
installation of the projectors. But the office of the Collector/District
Election Officer, Balaghat cleared the payment of Rs.4,40,000/- only.
The petitioner submitted a representation. The Collector and District
Election Officer, Balaghat rejected the representation vide
communication dated 28/2/2014 (Annexure P-14) stating that the
petitioner had supplied projectors during first training for a period of 57
days; second training for a period of 31 days; and third training for a
period of 122 days, that is total 210 projector-days. The petitioner was
paid Rs.4,50,300/- at the rate of Rs.2,144/- per projector per day,
which is in consonance with the local market rate.
(C) The petitioner again submitted a representation (Annexure P-7)
and approached this Court by filing Writ Petition No. 14102/2014,
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: KOUSHALENDRA
SHARAN SHUKLA
Signing time: 30-09-2026
17:11:54
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:77199
3 WP-16326-2015
wherein the coordinate Bench of this Court, v i d e order dated
0412.2014, directed the Collector, Balaghat to consider and decide the
representation of the petitioner by a speaking order.
(D In pursuance of the aforesaid order, the petitioners submitted
representations (Annexures P-9 and P-10). The Collector, Balaghat
considered the representations but rejected the same vide impugned
order dated 30.01.2015 (Annexure P-11) holding as under:
"3.2
उपरो ववरण से यह प होता है क आवेदक ारा ोजेटर के देयक ितदन ित ोजेटर क दर से
(
तुत कये गये है। आवेदक को ोजेटर लगाने हेतु िन वदा "येक िश$ण के %& पर स 'पूण) दवस अथा )त
)
िश$ण के कुल दनो क सं -या के िलए वीकृत क गई है। आवेदक को वीकृत िन वदा क ित ोजेटर लगाने
के पूव ) दाय क गई है। आवेदक ने अपने प $ समथ )न म 3 ऐसा कोई भी द तावेज तुत नह 6 कया है 7जसम3 यह
उ 8लेख हो क ोजेटर क िन वदा ितदन के मान से वीकृत है। उपरो ववेचना से प है क आवेदक को
2013
वधानसभा चुनाव के दौरान िश$ण थल पर ोजेटर लगाने हेतु "येक िश$ण के %& पर स 'पूण) दवस
( ) ,
अथा )त िश$ण के कुल दनो क सं -या के िलए वीकृत है ना क ितदन क दर से। उ %ह6 वीकृत दरो के
अनुसार आवेदक को उसके ारा लगाये गये ोजेटर के देयको का िनयमानुसार भुगतान कया गया है। अतएव
"
आवेदक का अ =यावेदन अमा %य कया जाता है।
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner, in addition to the facts and grounds
mentioned in the petition, submits that that the notice inviting tender did not
specify that the projector was to be supplied for entire period of training and the
lumpsum rate to be quoted for the entire period. Learned counsel for the petitioner
further referring to the details of work executed (Annexures P-4 and P-14) issued
by the Collector and District Election Officer, Balaghat, contends that the
Collector, Balaghat himself has mentioned that total numbers of projectors utilized
for training were 210. Thus, the petitioner is entitled to the amount claimed in his
bills, at the rate, which was already approved by the Collector. The impugned
order suffers from apparent error. The petitioner is deprived of his rightful claim
in furtherance of acceptance of his bid by the Office of the Collector. Therefore, it
is prayed that the impugned order be set aside and the Collector be directed to pay
the remaining amount with interest to the petitioner.
4. Per contra, learned counsel for the State submits that the petitioner did not
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: KOUSHALENDRA
SHARAN SHUKLA
Signing time: 30-09-2026
17:11:54
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:77199
4 WP-16326-2015
specify in the offer that he is quoting the rates for providing the projectors on per
day basis. Learned counsel for the State also referred to the acceptance letter and
submits that the rates quoted by the petitioner were accepted for all the days of
training and counting at a particular center. It was not accepted on 'per day' basis.
Therefore, the Collector, Balaghat committed no error in rejecting the claim of the
petitioner for payment of remaining amount of bills as claimed by the petitioner.
The petition is meritless and deserves to be dismissed.
5. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
6. The copy of acceptance letter dated 16/10/2013 (Annexure P-3) reads as
under:
,
काया )लय कले टर एवं 7जला िनवा )चन अिधकार 6 बालाघाट म. .
07632-240090, 240292, 07632-240250
दूरभाष फै स
E-Mail [email protected], Website, www.dmbalaghat.nic.in
// //
Cापन
/ 1226/ /2013. 16/10/2013
Dमांक िनवा )चन बालाघाट दनांक
,
ित
बजरंग डजीटल टुडयो
बालाघाट
:- 2013
वषय वधान सभा चुनाव म 3 लगने वाले ोजेटर के िन वदा क वीकृत दरे।
2013
वधान सभा चुनाव को संप %न कराये जाने हेतु मतदान दल F को िश$ण एवं मतगणना के दौरान
ोजेटर लगाने हेतु िन वदाएं आंम Gत क गई थी।
ाH िन वदा के आधार पर ोजेटर लगाने हेतु आपक िन वदाएं इस शत ) पर वीकृत क जाती है क
10
आप वयं के Jयय से िनधा )Kरत थान बालाघाट मु -यालय एवं वकासखLड पर स 'पूण) िश$ण हेतु अपने
,
तर से ोजटर लगाकर देग 3 आपके ारा िन वदा म 3 भर 6 गई िन 'न दर 3 स 'पूण) िश$ण हेतु वीकृत क जाती
( )
है. आपके ारा द 6 गई दर "येक िश$ण के %& पर स 'पूण) दवस अथा )त िश$ण के कुल दनF क सं -या के
िलये मा %य होगी।
ोजेटर उपल Mध कराने क दर
िन वदा. दर
1 2 3
1 6500.00
ोजेटर लगाने क थानीय दर बालाघाट मु -यालय पर
2 7500.00
ोजेटर लगाने क वकासखLड वार दर लालबरा
3 7200.00
ोजेटर लगाने क वकासखLड वार दर वारािसवनी
4 7500.00
ोजेटर लगाने क वकासखLड वार दर कंटगी
5 7500.00
ोजेटर लगाने क वकासखLड वार दर खैरलांजी
6 7500.00
ोजेटर लगाने क वकासखLड वार दर कनापुर
7 7800.00
ोजेटर लगाने क वकासखLड वार दर लांजी
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: KOUSHALENDRA
SHARAN SHUKLA
Signing time: 30-09-2026
17:11:54
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:77199
5 WP-16326-2015
8 8000.00
ोजेटर लगाने क वकासखLड वार दर बैहर
9 8300.00
ोजेटर लगाने क वकासखLड वार दर बरसा
10 8300.00
ोजेटर लगाने क वकासखLड वार दर परसवाडा
7. Neither the notice inviting tender nor the acceptance letter stipulates that
the rates for the supply and installation of projectors during the training and
counting for the Assembly Election, 2013, were accepted as a lump-sum
amount for the entire period, irrespective of the number of projectors
deployed and the duration of their deployment. Although, the acceptance
letter states that the approved rates would remain applicable for the entire
training period, it does not stipulate that payment would be confined to a
single installation at each centre or exclude computation on the basis of
actual projector-days. On the contrary, the details of work furnished by the
Collector and District Election Officer (Annexure P-4) separately states the
place, training dates, number of projectors required and the total no. of
projector on calculation of the number of projectors and the days of
deployment. The work schedule suggests quantification of work on a
projector-day basis. The details of work and deployment schedule is
reproduced for reference as under :
थम िश$ण
कुल
ोजेटर क
सं -या
वकास खंड ोजेटर क
Dं. िश$ण थल िश$ण दनांक िश$ण सं -या
का नाम सं -या
/
कुल दन कुल
ोजेटर
19.10.2013
21.10.2013
22.10.2013
23.10.2013
1 1.
बालाघाट शा.उ.उ.मा. व. बालाघाट का हाल
04 01 04 12
दन
19.10.2013
21.10.2013
22.10.2013
23.10.2013
2.
शा.म.ल.बा.उ.मा. व. बालाघाट का
हाल
04 01 04
दन
19.10.2013
21.10.2013
22.10.2013
23.10.2013
3. डाईट बालाघाट का हाल
04 दन 01 04
19.10.2013
2 1. 02 01 02 04
लालबरा सामुदाियक भवन लालबरा ) का हाल दन
21.10.2013
19.10.2013
2. 02 01 02
जनपद पंचायत का हाल दन
21.10.2013
19.10.2013
21.10.2013
04 01 04 07
दन
22.10.2013
3 1.
वारािसवनी आ 'बेडकर मंगल भवन का हाल
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: KOUSHALENDRA
SHARAN SHUKLA
Signing time: 30-09-2026
17:11:54
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:77199
6 WP-16326-2015
23.10.2013
2.
टहली बाई मा.शा. व. का हाल
19.10.2013
21.10.2013
22.10.2013
03 01 03
दन
19.10.2013
21.10.2013
22.10.2013
4 कटंगी 1. शा.उ.उ.मा. व. का हाल
03 दन 01 03 06
19.10.2013
21.10.2013
22.10.2013
2.
जनपद पंचायत का हाल
03 01 03
दन
19.10.2013
5 1. 02 01 02 03
खैरलांजी आ 'बेडकर भवन का हाल दन
21.10.2013
2. जनपद पंचायत का हाल 21.10.2013 01 दन 01 01
19.10.2013
21.10.2013
22.10.2013
6 1.
बैहर टाउन हाल नगर प Kरषद
03 01 03 06
दन
19.10.2013
21.10.2013
22.10.2013
2. बी आर सी काया )लय
03 दन 01 03
19.10.2013
21.10.2013
22.10.2013
7 1.
बरसा सामुदाियक भवन का हाल
03 01 03 03
दन
19.10.2013
21.10.2013
22.10.2013
8 1.
लांजी सामुदाियक भवन का हाल
03 01 03 06
दन
19.10.2013
21.10.2013
22.10.2013
2.
बी आर जी एफ का हाल
03 01 03
दन
19.10.2013
9 1. 02 01 02 04
करनापुर शा.उ.मा. व. का हाल दन
22.10.2013
19.10.2013
2. 02 01 02
जनपद पंचायत का हाल दन
22.10.2013
19.10.2013
21.10.2013
22.10.2013
10 1. – 1
परसवाड़ा शा.उ.उ.मा. व. का हाल
03 01 03 06
दन
19.10.2013
21.10.2013
22.10.2013
2. शा.उ.उ.मा. व. का हाल – 2
03 दन 01 03
dqy 20 57
dysDVj ,oa ftyk fuokZpu vf/kdkjh]
ckyk?kkV
f}rh; izf’k{k.k
/
कुल दन
कुल
ोजेटर
कुल
ोजेटर क
सं -या
वकास खंड िश$ण
Dं. िश$ण थल
का नाम दनांक
िश$ण
सं -या
ोजेटर
क सं -या
01
1. 'kk- m-m ek-fo ckyk?
kkV dk gky
06-11-2013
02 fnu
07-11-2013
02
03 fnu 01
2. 'kk- m-m ek-fo ckyk?
08
1 ckyk?kkV
06-11-2013
07-11-2013
08-11-2013
kkV dk gky
03
06-11-2013
07-11-2013
08-11-2013
03 fnu 01
3- gkbZV ckyk?kkV dk gky
03
1- lkeqnkf;d Hkou ykycjkZ dk
gky
02 fnu 01
06-11-2013
07-11-2013
02
03
2 ykycjkZ
2- tuin iapk;r dk gky 06-11-2013 01 fnu 01 01
1- vEcsMdj eaxy Hkou dk 01 fnu 01
06-11-2013 01
gky
06-11-2013
07-11-2013
02 fnu 01
3 okjkflouh
03
2- fVgyh ckbZ ek-'kk- fo dk
gky
02
06-11-2013
07-11-2013
02 fnu 01
1- 'kk-m-m-ek-fo- dk gky
02
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: KOUSHALENDRA
SHARAN SHUKLA
Signing time: 30-09-2026
17:11:54
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:77199
7 WP-16326-2015
4 dVaxh 03
06-11-2013
2- tuin iapk;r dk gky
01 fnu 01
01
1- vEcsMdj Hkou dk gky
01 fnu 01
06-11-2013 01
5 [kSjykath
03
2- tuin iapk;r dk gky
06-11-2013
07-11-2013
02 fnu 01
02
06-11-2013
07-11-2013
02 fnu 01
1- lkeqnkf;d Hkou dk gky
02
6 ykath
03
06-11-2013
2- ch-vkj- th- ,Q dk gky
01 fnu 01
01
06-11-2013
07-11-2013
02 fnu 01
1- 'kk-m-m-ek-fo- dk gky
02
7 fdjukiqj
03
06-11-2013
2- tuin ipk;ar dk gky
01 fnu 01
01
1- Vkmu gky uxj ifj"kn
06-11-2013
01 fnu 01 01
8 cSgj
02
06-11-2013
2- ch-vkj-lh- dk;kZy;
01 fnu 01 01
1- lkeqnkf;d Hkou dk gky
06-11-2013
01 fnu 01 01
9 fcjlk
02
06-11-2013
2- tuin iapk;r dk gky
01 fnu 01 01
06-11-2013
10 ijlokM+k 1- 'kk-m-m-ek-fo-dk gky&1
01 fnu 01 01
01
dqy 20 31
dysDVj ,oa ftyk fuokZpu vf/kdkjh]
ckyk?kkV
r`rh; izf’k{k.k
Øa- fodkl [kaM dk
uke
izf’k{k.k LFky izf’k{k.k
fnukad
izf’k{k.k la[;k izkstsDVj dh
la[;k
dqy fnu
dqy
izkstsDVj
dqy
izkstsDVj
dh la[;k
1 cSgj ¼4 d{kks esa½ 1- 'kk-e-y-ck-
m-ek-fo ckyk?
kkV
14-11-2013
15-11-2013
16-11-2013
18-11-2013
20-11-2013
05 fnu 04 20 23
19-11-2013 01 fnu 03 03
2 Ykkath ¼4 d{kks esa½ 1- 'kk-m-m-ek-
fo ckyk?kkV
14-11-2013
15-11-2013
16-11-2013
18-11-2013
04 fnu 04 16 22
19-11-2013
20-11-2013
02 fnu 03 06
3 ijlokM+k ¼4 d{kks
esa½
1- fo-'kk-nq-m-
ek-fo ckyk?
kkV
14-11-2013
15-11-2013
16-11-2013
18-11-2013
04 fnu 04 16 18
19-11-2013 01 fnu 02 02
4 Ckkyk?kkV ¼4 d{kks
esa½
1- deyk
usg: d-ek-fo-
ckyk?kkV
14-11-2013
15-11-2013
16-11-2013
05 fnu 04 20 25
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: KOUSHALENDRA
SHARAN SHUKLA
Signing time: 30-09-2026
17:11:54
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:77199
8 WP-16326-2015
18-11-2013
20-11-2013
20-11-2013 01 fnu 04 04
5 okjkflouh ¼4 d{kks
esa½
1- ftyk f’k{kk
vf/kdkjh
MkbZV ckyk?
kkV
14-11-2013
15-11-2013
16-11-2013
18-11-2013
19-11-2013
05 fnu 03 15 17
20-11-2013 01 fnu 02 02
6 dVaxh ¼4 d{kks esa½ 1- ek-xka-u-ik-
m-ek fo
ckyk?kkV
14-11-2013
15-11-2013
16-11-2013
18-11-2013
04 fnu 04 16 17
19-11-2013 01 fnu 04 01
dqy 122
dysDVj ,oa ftyk fuokZpu vf/kdkjh]
ckyk?kkV
8. The note-sheet (Annexure P-14) of the Office of the Collector and
District Election Officer proceeds on the same method of computation and
records that the petitioner had supplied and installed an aggregate of 210
projector-days. On that basis, payment was proposed at the rate of Rs.2,144/-
per projector per day, stating to be in consonance with the prevailing market
rate [communication dated 28.02.2014 (Annexure P-6)]. Thus, the work was
quantified by multiplying the number of projectors deployed, by the number
of days for which they were utilised. The accepted tender rates, the
particulars of the work executed and the departmental note-sheet, read
conjointly, would establish that the parties understood and acted upon the
contract on the basis of the actual deployment of projectors for the respective
number of days. The respondents could not, at the stage of payment,
retrospectively construe the accepted "rates" as a lump-sum amount for the
entire training period. Such a unilateral alteration of the basis of payment,
after performance of contract, is contrary to the previous office-note and
renders the rejection of the petitioner’s claim arbitrary. Any ambiguity in the
tender conditions or the petitioner’s offer ought to have been clarified before
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: KOUSHALENDRA
SHARAN SHUKLA
Signing time: 30-09-2026
17:11:54
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:77199
9 WP-16326-2015
acceptance of the bid and commencement of the work. The impugned order
dated 30.01.2015 (Annexure P-11) is inconsistent and irreconcilable with
earlier office- note and determination. It suffers from improper exercise of
jurisdiction and manifest arbitrariness therefore, cannot be sustained.
9. Consequently, the impugned order dated 30.01.2015 (Annexure P-11),
passed by the Collector, Balaghat, is set aside. The Collector and District
Election Officer, Balaghat, is directed to determine and release the balance
amount payable to the petitioner, by applying the rates accepted vide letter
dated 16.10.2013 (Annexure P-3) to the aggregate of 210 projector-days
recorded in the departmental note- sheet (Annexure P-14), within one month
from the date of production of a certified copy of this order.
10. Accordingly, the writ petition is disposed of.
(SANJEEV S KALGAONKAR)
JUDGE
ks
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: KOUSHALENDRA
SHARAN SHUKLA
Signing time: 30-09-2026
17:11:54