THE MYSORE STONEWARE PIPES AND POTTERIES LTD vs STATE OF KARNATAKA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 9 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R. NATARAJ
WRIT PETITION NO. 18923 OF 2025 (LA-KIADB)
BETWEEN:
THE MYSORE STONEWARE PIPES
AND POTTERIES LTD.,
THE COMPANY HAVING REGISTERED OFFICE AT
TH TH
11 CROSS, 6 MAIN,
SADASHIVANAGAR,
BANGALORE-560080
REPRESENTED BY ITS EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR,
SRI RAJIV RAMOHALLI
IT IS A COMPANY UNDER COMPANIES ACT, 1913
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI.DHYAN CHINNAPPA, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI.MAHESH ARKALGUD, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. STATE OF KARNATAKA
DEPARTMENT OF INDUSTRIES AND COMMERCE
VIKAS SOUDHA,
BENGALURU - 560001
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
2. KARNATAKA INDUSTRIAL AREA
DEVELOPMENT BOARD (KIADB)
HAVING ITS OFFICE AT
NRUPATHUNGA ROAD,
BENGALURU - 560001
REPRESENTED BY ITS
SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER - 02
3. RAIL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT
COMPANY (KARNATAKA) LTD.,
Digitally
signed by
HEMALATHA J
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
HAVING ITS OFFICE AT
ST
1 FLOOR, "SAMPARKA SOUDHA",
OPP ORION MALL,
DR RAJKUMAR ROAD,
ST
RAJAJINAGAR 1 BLOCK,
BENGALURU - 560010
REPRESENTED BY ITS DIRECTOR
IT IS A COMPANY UNDER COMPANIES ACT
4. SRI. T.A. JAGADAMBA
W/O SRI. E. KRISHNAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS
NO.01, ADAKIMRANAHALLI VILLAGE,
ST
21 K M TUMKUR ROAD,
MAKALI POST,
BANGALORE-562123
5.
SHRI TEJAS KUMAR
FATHERS NAME NOT KNOWN TO PETITIONER
AGED MAJOR,
WORKING AS SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION
OFFICER - 2 - KIADB
NO.14/3, ARAVINDA BHAVAN
ST
1 FLOOR, NRUPATHUNGA ROAD,
BANGALORE - 560001
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI.D.R.RAVISHANKAR, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR
SRI.P.GANGADHAR, ADVOCATE FOR C/R4;
SRI.ASHOK NAIK, ADVOCATE FOR R2;
SRI.K.N.SUBBA REDDY, ADVOCATE FOR R5;
VIDE ORDER DATED 09.10.2026, NOTICE TO R1 AND 3 IS
DISPENSED WITH)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER
ND
PASSED BY 2 RESPONDENT BEARING FILE NO.C2/R/26/400/
BAW/04 DATED 27.05.2025, ANNEXURE-S AND ETC.
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING,
THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R. NATARAJ
ORAL ORDER
The petitioner has sought for a writ in the nature of
certiorari to quash the order bearing file
No.C2/R/26/400/BAW/04/ /2025-26 dated 27.05.2025 passed
by the respondent No.2. It has also sought for a writ in the
nature of certiorari to quash the order bearing file
No.C2/R/26/400/BAW/14/ /2025-26 dated 27.05.2025 passed
by the respondent No.2 and also to quash the order bearing file
No.C2/R/26/400/BAW/02/ /2025-26 dated 27.05.2025 passed
by the respondent No.2. It has sought for a writ in the nature
of mandamus to direct the respondent No.2 to disburse the
compensation amount in respect of the land acquired in
Sy.Nos.80/1, 80/3 and 81/2 of Chikkabanavara, Yeshwanthpur
Hobli.
2. (i) The petitioner claims that it is a company
registered under the provisions of the Indian Companies Act,
1913. During the year 1930's, the Government of His Highness,
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
the Maharaj of Mysore initiated a proposal for setting up a
manufacturing unit so as to manufacture huge quantities of
pipes and potteries required for the sewerage and sanitary
system in the State of Mysore. The petitioner contends that it
was established in the year 1937 with an objective of
manufacturing clay pipes and potteries required for the purpose
of sewerage and sanitary system in the State of Mysore. It
contends that His Highness the Maharaja Mysore passed an
order granting certain facilities and concession for the
manufacture of sanitary pipes and fittings to the petitioner vide
order No.D5644-54-I and C.183-36-3 dated 22.02.1937 in
Soladevanahalli, Chikkabanavara by allotting an extent of 118
acres of land.
(ii) Following the order of His Highness, the Maharaja
of Mysore, referred supra, the Development Secretary issued a
preliminary notification bearing No.D.9495-I & C 183-36-29
dated 24.06.1938 for acquiring land under Section 17 of the
Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (henceforth referred to as 'the Act,
1894'). The petitioner contends that it deposited the entire
compensation amount with the Government and thereafter, the
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
Government handed over 118 acres 24 guntas of land in
various survey numbers of Soladevanahalli to the petitioner for
its industrial use.
(iii) The petitioner established its factory in the lands
allotted to it in the year 1937 and employed hundreds of
employees. It commenced production of clay pipes, refractory
materials and potteries. It is contended that the entire 118
acres 24 guntas was used for industrial purposes. The name of
the petitioner was entered in the revenue records in respect of
the aforesaid land. Long thereafter, when the petitioner sought
to convert the land for residential purposes, the Deputy
Commissioner, Bengaluru District issued an endorsement dated
02.07.2004 stating that the land measuring 118 acres 24
guntas is acquired for industrial purposes and hence, the same
is not agricultural land and can be used for residential purposes
also.
(iv) The petitioner contends that it came to know that
as a joint venture of respondent No.1 and the Ministry of
Railways, a new project known as "K-RIDE" was launched. The
project was conceptualized to boost Rail Infrastructure in the
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
State of Karnataka and for the said purpose the respondent
No.1 had established the respondent No.3. For the purpose of
implementation of the Bangalore Sub Urban Rail Project the
respondent No.2 proposed to acquire the petitioner's land in
various survey numbers for the benefit of the respondent No.3.
The petitioner came to know that in respect of Sy.Nos.80/1,
80/3 and 81/2 of Chikkabanavara village, an acquisition
notification was issued under the Karnataka Industrial Areas
Development Act, 1966 (henceforth referred to as 'the KIAD
Act') which did not show the name of the petitioner as its
owner, but the name of one Smt.T.A.Jagadamba was shown.
(v) The petitioner contends that it is the owner of the
land bearing Sy.Nos.80/1, 81/2 and 80/3 of Chikkabanavara
Village and not Smt.T.A.Jagadamba. It contends that in respect
of the land in Sy.Nos.80/1 and 81/2, a person named
Narayanaswamy filed an application in the year 2005 before the
Tahsildar seeking for transfer of khata in his favour. He claimed
that the aforesaid properties were his ancestral properties. The
Tahsildar without considering the earlier acquisition allowed the
application and directed insertion of the name of
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
Narayanaswamy in the revenue records vide order dated
23.12.2006. Thereafter, the said Narayanaswamy executed a
sale deed in favour of one Smt.T.A.Jagadamba in terms of a
sale deed dated 11.01.2007.
(vi) The petitioner filed an appeal in R.A.No.115/2007-
2008 before the Assistant Commissioner, challenging the order
of Tahsildar which was dismissed vide order dated 01.07.2010
on the ground that the land bearing Sy.Nos.80/1 and 81/2
were acquired for industrial purpose and therefore, the appeal
under Section 136(2) of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964
(henceforth referred to as 'the Act, 1964') was not
maintainable.
(vii) The petitioner challenged the said order before the
Deputy Commissioner in R.P.No.207/2012-13, which was
allowed in terms of the order dated 14.12.2018. The said
Smt.T.A.Jagadamba challenged the order passed by the Deputy
Commissioner before this Court in W.P.No.2346-49/2019. The
said writ petition was dismissed in terms of the order dated
28.05.2024. A W.A.No.939/2024 was filed which too was
dismissed vide order dated 22.08.2024. The Division Bench
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
held that the acquisition of land in favour of the petitioner had
already attained finality and the same cannot be indirectly
challenged in revenue proceedings. The petitioner contends
that a suit is also pending consideration before the trial Court in
respect of the fraudulent sale deed executed by
Narayanaswamy in favour of Smt.T.A.Jagadamba.
(viii) The petitioner contends that as regards the land in
Sy.No.80/3, a person named Mr.Patel Anjinappa filed
application in the year 2001 before the Tahsildar seeking for
transfer of khata in his name on the ground that it belonged to
Mr.Patel Muniyappa and that he and his brothers were the legal
heirs of Mr.Patel Muniyappa. In the said proceedings, Mr.Patel
Anjinappa admitted that he had filed a suit in O.S.No.321/2001
before the II Additional Civil Judge, Bengaluru Rural District
and the same was withdrawn on 26.07.2005. Hence, his
application was rejected by the Tahsildar on 12.11.2003. The
said Patel Anjinappa filed appeal in R.A.No.177/2003-2004
before the Assistant Commissioner, which was dismissed on
13.05.2005.
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
(ix) In respect of the very same survey number, a
person named Mr.Srinivas Reddy filed an application seeking
entry of his name in the revenue records claiming that he was
the heir of Patel Muniyappa. Without considering the earlier
proceedings, the Tahsildar allowed the application and ordered
to include his name in the revenue records, consequent to
which, the revenue records were entered in his name. The said
Mr.Srinivas Reddy sold the land in Sy.No.80/3 to
Smt.T.A.Jagadamba in terms of a sale deed dated 03.04.2007.
(x) The petitioner challenged the order of the Tahsildar
before the Assistant Commissioner in R.A.No.440/2007-2008
which was dismissed vide order dated 01.07.2010 on the
ground that Sy.No.80/3 was industrial land and therefore an
appeal under Section 136(2) of Act, 1964 was not
maintainable. The petitioner challenged the said order before
the Deputy Commissioner in Revision Petition No.32/2015-16,
which was allowed vide order dated 14.12.2018. The said
Smt.T.A.Jagadamba challenged the order before this Court in
W.P.No.2346-49/2019, which was dismissed and
W.A.No.939/2024 filed there against was also dismissed. The
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
petitioner contends that the aforesaid facts establish that it is
the owner of the property and not Smt.T.A.Jagadamba.
Further, pursuant to the order of the Division Bench of this
Court, the name of the petitioner was restored in the revenue
records.
3. The petitioner contends that there were various
proceedings initiated by third parties and in all such
proceedings, this Court had confirmed its ownership of the land
bearing Sy.Nos.80/11, 81/2 and 80/3 of Chikkabanavara. It
referred to Form No.7 filed by a person named
Mr.T.C.Chikkanna Reddy claiming to be the tenant of petitioner,
before the Land Tribunal, which was rejected. The said order
was challenged by the legal heirs of T.C.Chikkanna Reddy in
W.P.No.32632/2002, which was dismissed in terms of an order
dated 16.01.2009. The legal heirs of T.C.Chikkanna Reddy filed
W.A.No.424/2009, which too was dismissed on 13.01.2010.
The petitioner contends that the acquisition notification dated
24.06.1938 was challenged before this Court in
W.P.No.30999/2009 which too was dismissed by this Court in
terms of an order dated 24.11.2009.
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
4. (i) The petitioner contends that the respondent
Nos.2 and 3 did not consider the representation given by it but
proceeded to issue notice under Section 28(6) of the KIAD Act,
where Smt.T.A.Jagadamba was shown as the owner. The said
notice was challenged by the petitioner in W.P.No.17590/2024.
This Court in terms of an order dated 03.03.2025 directed the
Special Land Acquisition Officer to take note of the orders
passed by this Court and then consider the claim of the
petitioner for release of compensation. This Court also directed
that if any request is made by the parties not to release the
compensation amount for a period of two weeks from the date
of passing the order, the Special Land Acquisition Officer shall
also consider the said request.
(ii) The petitioner claims that it furnished all the
documents stated above and also submitted a representation
requesting the respondent No.2 not to release the
compensation for a period of two weeks. However, the
petitioner received three letters all dated 02.06.2025 from the
respondent No.2 on 27.05.2025, which contained three orders
passed by the Special Land Acquisition Officer holding that the
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
respondent No.4 is the owner of the property and is entitled for
compensation and hence, ordered for release of compensation.
The petitioner claims that it was shocked to notice that the
orders were antedated and the same was sent by post on
26.06.2025, which was received by it on 27.06.2025.
(iii) The petitioner claims that the respondent No.2 has
passed the above orders under Section 29(2) of the KIAD Act,
by negativing the ownership of the petitioner on the ground
that the acquisition proceedings were not properly done as
there was no final notification to acquire the land and also that
MR No.4/1976-77 related to some other property and not in
respect of the property of the petitioner. The petitioner
contends that the respondent No.2 being a quasi-judicial
authority is bound to examine the rival claims and decide who
amongst them have a valid title over the acquired land and who
are entitled to receive the compensation. It contends that the
respondent No.2 without referring to the earlier litigation has
proceeded to hold that the respondent No.4 is the owner of the
acquired land and proceeded to pass three identical orders
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
dated 27.05.2025 holding that the respondent No.4 is entitled
to receive the compensation.
(iv) The petitioner contends that the respondent No.5
who is officiating as the Special Land Acquisition Officer
(henceforth referred to as 'SLAO') has passed the order with a
malafide intention only to help the respondent No.4 to
misappropriate the compensation. It contends that the
respondent No.5 was aware of all the orders passed by the
Courts from time to time, which clearly held that the acquisition
in favour of the petitioner in the year 1938 had attained finality
and that the petitioner was the owner of the property.
(v) The petitioner contends that this Court while
deciding W.P.No.17590/2024 suspected foul play by the
respondent No.5 and had specifically directed that if request is
made not to release the amount for 15 days, then the amount
should not be released so that the aggrieved party can seek
redressal before the appropriate forum. However, the
respondent No.5 abused his power by passing a backdated
order dated 27.05.2025, which was sent by post to the
petitioner on 26.06.2025, which was received on 27.06.2025.
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
The petitioner claims that it was shocked and on enquiry it
realized that the respondent No.5 is making hectic efforts to
release the compensation amount which is more than
Rs.100,00,00,000-00 to the respondent No.4. The petitioner is
therefore before this Court, challenging the three orders passed
by the respondent No.2 and has sought for a direction to the
respondent No.2 to disburse the compensation in its favour.
5. (i) A statement of objections is filed by the
respondent No.2 generally denying the averments made in the
writ petition. It contended that the State Government proposed
to acquire land in various survey numbers in Chikkabanavara
Village for the benefit of Bangalore Sub Urban Rail Project.
Before publishing the proposal for acquisition of various survey
numbers, the authorities have verified the RTC's as on the date
of the preliminary notification in respect of the land in
Sy.No.80/1, 80/3 and 81/2 of Chikkabanavara Village,
Yeshwanathpur Hobli, Bengaluru North Taluk. The revenue
entries in respect of the aforesaid land stood in the name of
Smt.T.A.Jagadamba. Accordingly, the State Government issued
the preliminary notification under Section 28(1) of the KIAD Act
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
on 18.07.2023. Consequently, a notice under Section 28(2) of
the KIAD Act was issued to Smt.T.A.Jagadamba. The Special
Land Acquisition Officer after considering the reply passed an
order under Section 28(3) of the KIAD Act on 29.09.2023.
Thereafter, the State Government after being satisfied that the
land in the aforesaid survey numbers are required for the K-
RIDE project issued a final notification under Section 28(4) of
the KIAD Act on 01.12.2023. Since the land vested in the State
Government, the Special Land Acquisition Officer issued notice
to the Khatedar under Section 28(6) of the KIAD Act on
01.12.2023 and took possession of the acquired land from
Smt.T.A.Jagadamba after drawing a mahazar on 14.12.2023.
Hence, it is contended that the name of the respondent No.4
appeared in the revenue records as the Khatedar of the
aforesaid survey numbers.
(ii) It is contended that as per the direction issued by
this Court in W.P.No.17590/2024 the respondent No.4 heard
both the petitioner and the respondent No.4 and after verifying
the documents, sought a report from the jurisdictional revenue
authorities with regard to the revenue entries in respect of the
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
acquired land. The Tahsildar vide a letter dated 13.03.2025
forwarded the revenue records in respect of the acquired land.
The Special Land Acquisition Officer verified the revenue
documents and found that the records pertaining to the
acquired land stood in the name of the owners until 1967 and
there was no transfer of the land in favour of the petitioner as
claimed by them by virtue of the notification issued by the
Government of His Highness the Maharaj of Mysore. It
contended that the lands in question were never transferred to
the petitioner. It is claimed that the Land Acquisition Officer has
verified the documents pertaining to the acquisition made in
the year 1938 and found that the declaration under Section 6
of the Act, 1894 was not issued and in the absence of such
documents produced by the rival claimant it was clear that the
appropriate government under Section 4(1) of the Act, 1894
proposing to acquire the above land did not issue a final
notification under Section 6(1) of the Act, 1894. Accordingly,
the Special Land Acquisition Officer in terms of the order dated
27.05.2025 held that the petitioner is not entitled to the
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
compensation and that it is only the respondent No.4 who is
entitled.
(iii) It is therefore contended that after a month from
the date of pronouncement of the order the Special Land
Acquisition Officer released a sum of Rs.28,29,15,025/- to the
respondent No.4 after obtaining a bond from her. Therefore, it
is claimed that there is no lapse on the part of the respondent
No.2 in passing the order under Section 29(2) of the KIAD Act
and releasing part of the compensation in favour of the
respondent No.4.
6. (i) A statement of objections is also filed by the
respondent No.4 contending that the petitioner had claimed
that its name was entered in the revenue records pursuant to
MR No.4/1976-77. It contends that the total extent of 118
acres 24 guntas purportedly acquired was agricultural land
owned and possessed by various individuals. It is contended
that 70 acres of unoccupied waste land was handed over to the
petitioner at Soladevanahalli Pumping Station free of cost.
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
(ii) It is claimed that though the preliminary notification
under Section 4 read with Section 17(1) and 14(4) of the Act,
1894 was issued on 24.06.1938, no further proceedings took
place and neither the possession of the land was taken nor
award was passed. No final notification under Section 6(1) of
the Act, 1894 was issued. Therefore, it is contended that there
is no finality of acquisition proceedings in respect of 118 acres
24 guntas and the original owners continued in possession of
their properties.
(iii) It is contended that the dispute in this writ petition
relates to the land in Sy.No.80/1, 80/3 and 81/2 measuring 8
acres 13 guntas situate at Chikkabanavara Village. It is claimed
that the respondent No.4 had purchased the aforesaid lands
from the owners vide sale deed dated 11.01.2007 and
03.04.2007. It is claimed that based on the above sale deeds,
the respondent No.4 got her name entered in the revenue
records, which was challenged before this Court in
W.P.No.2346-49/2019. The said writ petition was allowed and
writ appeal filed by the respondent No.4 was dismissed on
22.08.2024.
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
(iv) It is contended that in the meanwhile the lands
were acquired by the respondent No.2 for the benefit of K-RIDE
and notices were issued to various individuals who were in
possession of the land. The respondent No.4 was one such
individual. The notice issued to the respondent No.4 was
challenged by the petitioner before this Court in
W.P.No.17590/2024, which was disposed of, directing the Land
Acquisition Officer to consider the claim of the petitioner for
release of compensation as determined in respect of the lands
acquired by the respondent No.2 for the benefit of the
respondent No.3. The Land Acquisition Officer was also directed
to hear the respondent No.4 before passing orders and
releasing compensation.
(v) It is claimed that pursuant to the above said order,
notices were issued by the respondent No.2. The respondent
No.4 procured the revenue records pertaining to the lands in
question from the date of the acquisition proceedings. She
claimed that she was surprised to learn that various revenue
records sought to be relied upon by the petitioner were not
available with the authorities and hence contended that the
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
same were fabricated to suit its convenience. It is contended
that the Record of Rights (for short 'R.R.') indicates that from
the year 1925 the R.R entries of Sy.No.80/1 and 80/3, the
name of Muniyappa was found at R.R.Nos.168 and 170. Later,
on the said lands were transferred in favour of his son
Narayanaswamy on 29.12.1958 in terms of M.R.No.14/1958-
59. Subsequently, new R.R.Nos.734 and 735 were generated.
It is claimed that on perusal of the Mysore revision settlement
register of the year 1965-1967 the name of Narayanaswamy is
found as Hiduvalidar. The very first index of land records drawn
by the revenue authorities tallies with the R.R. entries as the
original Hiduvalidar Muniyappa's name was rounded off and the
name of his son Naranaswamy was entered. Therefore, she
contends that it is clear that the records stood in the name of
the owners until 1967 and there is no transfer of the land in
favour of the petitioner as claimed by them by virtue of the
notification issued under Section 17 of the Act, 1894. It is
claimed that the lands were never transferred in favour of the
petitioner.
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
(vi) It is contended that in respect of Sy.No.80/3 the
name of Patel Muniyappa was found at R.R.No.170 and later, it
was transferred to the name of his son Kakanna alias Muniyapa
on 31.10.1941. Subsequently, R.R.Nos.589 was generated. On
perusal of the Mysore revision settlement register of the year
1965-1967, the name of Kakanna alias Muniyappa is found as
Hiduvalidar. The very first Index of Land Record (for short
'I.L.R') drawn by the revenue authorities tallies with the R.R.
entries as the name of original Hiduvalidar, Patel Muniyapa was
rounded off and the name of his son is entered. Therefore, it is
contended that the records stood in the name of the original
owners until 1967 and there was no transfer of this land in
favour of the petitioner as claimed by virtue of the acquisition
notification.
(vii) It is contended that by virtue of the acquisition of
the year 1937, the land was proposed to be acquired from its
original owners, but no records were transferred. After lapse of
40 years, for the very first time in the year 1976-77, on the
strength of M.R.No.4/1976-77, the RTC jointly started
appearing in the name of Kakanna and the petitioner.
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
(viii) It is contended that the proceedings in MR
No.4/1976-77 relates to some other property belonging to one
Mr.Gangadhar, who had transferred it to Shamanna of
Chikkabanavara Village. The respondent No.4 contends that the
petitioner fraudulently produced a false MR No.4/1976-77,
which was in respect of some other land transaction and got its
name entered in the revenue records of the land in question.
Likewise, it is contended that the petitioners concocted the
record of rights of the year 1977, which was not issued by the
office of the Tahsildar as no such record of rights is available in
the records.
(ix) It is next contended that a perusal of the Mysore
Revision Settlement Register/Faisal Patrike for Soladevanahalli
in Chikkabanavara Village clearly shows the name of the
petitioner for 70 acres of Government waste land at
Soladevanahalli and for all other alleged acquired lands, the
name of the individual owners is shown. Therefore, it is
contended that this demonstrated that except for the 70 acres
at Soladevanahalli Pumping Station that was handed over to
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
the petitioner by the Government of Mysore, no other land was
acquired and possession of the lands notified was taken over.
(x) It is thus contended that the petitioner is setting up
a false claim placing reliance on the preliminary notification
which got frustrated as no further proceedings took place. The
petitioner has placed reliance on the judgment of this Court in
W.P.No.2346/2019 and W.A.No.939/2024, where it had set
aside the revenue entries of the respondent No.4 based on the
fraudulent documents produced by it. She contends that the
petitioner has relied on fraudulent documents in various Courts
and claimed that the revenue entry stood in its name from as
back as 1961 whereas by its own admission its name was
entered in the revenue records pursuant to M.R.No.4/1976-
1977.
(xi) It is also contended that the petitioner had filed
O.S.No.1144/2010 which was dismissed for non prosecution.
Thus, it is contended that the respondent No.4 has passed the
impugned orders after due verification of various documents
produced by the respondent No.4.
- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
7. (i) A rejoinder is filed by the petitioner to the
statement of objections filed by the respondent No.2,
contending that the respondent No.2 has deliberately chosen to
ignore the order passed by this Court, which not only upheld
the ownership of the petitioner but also rejected the contention
of the respondent No.4 regarding her ownership. However, the
same is brushed aside by the respondent No.2 on the ground
that respondent No.2 was not a party to the said order. It is
contended that while deciding the entitlement of compensation,
the respondent Nos.2 and 5 were bound to follow the orders
passed by this Court in W.P.No.2346-49/2019 and
W.A.No.939/2024.
(ii) Further, it is contended that in W.P.No.17590/2024,
this Court directed the respondent No.2 to take note of the
orders passed by it in W.P.No.2346-49/2019 and
W.A.No.939/2024. It was also directed that the compensation
shall not be released for two weeks if there is any request from
the parties. It is contended that despite there being a direction
of this Court, the respondent No.5, as the SLAO has disbursed
the compensation in favour of the respondent No.4 by passing
- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
an order which was pre-dated. The respondent No.2 has not
furnished the order sheet and also the procedure adopted by
him before disbursing the compensation in favour of the
respondent No.4.
(iii) It is contended that from Annexures - R12 and R13,
it is clear that respondent No.5 colluded with respondent No.4
and had disbursed the compensation. It is contended that the
impugned order was passed by the respondent No.5 on
27.05.2025. However, the stamp papers on which an indemnity
bond was drawn up (Annexures - R12 and R13) were dated
24.04.2025, which is much prior to the impugned order. Hence,
it is clear that all along the respondent No.5 had colluded with
the respondent No.4 and had determined to pay the
compensation to the respondent No.4.
8. (i) A rejoinder is also filed by the petitioner to
the objections filed by the respondent No.4, wherein it is
contended that there is a mutation entry in MR No.2/76-77 in
respect of Soladevanahalli (Annexure-V) which shows that
several survey numbers in Soladevanahalli were acquired for
petitioner and its name was ordered to be entered in the
- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
revenue records. It is also contended that sale deeds dated
11.01.2007 and 03.04.2007 in terms of which, the respondent
No.4 had allegedly purchased the properties in question are all
a product of fraud. It is claimed that the respondent No.4
despite knowing that the name of the petitioner appeared in
the revenue records set up the family members of the original
land owners to file an application before the Tahsildar and
conspired with the Tahsildar to get the revenue records entered
in the name of the original owners.
(ii) It is contended that there is apparent fraud and
collusion between the respondent Nos.2, 4 and 5, who have
deliberately ignored the orders passed by this Court in the writ
petitions referred supra . It is contended that the owners of the
land in question had received compensation and the same is
evident from the statement of acquisition of land in favour of
the petitioner and the amount of compensation paid to the
claimants (Annexure-W).
(iii) It is also claimed that the petitioner has mortgaged
the lands in question to the Bank of Mysore Limited in terms of
a deed of mortgage dated 03.04.1948. Thus, it is contended
- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
that the assertions made by the respondent No.4 are all
fraudulent, false and hence, the respondent No.5 could not
have passed an order in favour of the respondent No.4.
9. (i) The learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner
submitted that after the notification under Section 17 of the
Act, 1894 was issued, a preliminary notification bearing
No.D.9495-I & C 183-36-29 dated 24.06.1938 was published
but the preamble to this notification showed that it was a
notification under Section 4(1) of the Act, 1894. He submitted
that the declaration made by the State Government that the
land in question is needed for a public purpose, namely for the
petitioner, itself established that the notification at Annexure-C
was a final notification.
(ii) He contends that this Court in W.A.No.939/2024,
after perusing the notifications, had held;
"It was sought to be submitted on behalf of the
appellant that the preliminary notification and the final
notification were of same date, therefore, the acquisition
was bad. The contention remained meritless. In Vijaya
Cotton and Oil Mills Limited Vs. State of Gujarat
[(1969) 2 SCR 60] , it was held that it was lawful for
- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
the Government to publish both the notifications on the
same date, where the order was passed under Section
17(4) dispensing with the procedure under Section 5(A)
of the Act."
(iii) He therefore contends that the Division Bench had
held that both the notifications could be issued on the same
day and there is no error in the same. He thus contends that
the respondent No.5 deliberately ignored this finding of the
Division Bench of this Court. Besides this, he contends that the
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in W.P.No.17590/2024 had
specifically directed the respondent No.5 to hear not only the
petitioner but also the respondent No.4 and pass appropriate
orders in accordance with law. It was also stated that:
"If there is any request made by the parties not to
release the compensation amount for a period of two
weeks from the date when which the order is passed,
the Special Land Acquisition Officer shall also consider
the said request."
(iv) He contends that in order to overcome the above,
the respondent No.5 had ante-dated the order and thereafter
released the compensation of Rs.28,29,15,025/-(Rupees
twenty eight crores twenty nine lakhs fifteen thousand and
- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
twenty five only) in favour of the respondent No.4. This he
contends, is a clear case of collusion between the respondent
No.5 and the respondent No.4. He submits that the indemnity
bond of respondent No.4 were drawn on stamp papers that
were purchased on 24.04.2025, thereby establishing beyond
doubt that respondent Nos.4 and 5 conspired with each other in
passing the impugned orders and in illegally appropriating
portion of the compensation. He submits that the impugned
orders were allegedly passed on 27.05.2025 but were sent to
the petitioner by post on 26.06.2025 which was received on
27.06.2025 and compensation of Rs.28,29,15,025/- was
released to respondent No.4 on 24.04.2025. He contends that if
the impugned order was sent to the petitioner, soon after it
was passed, the petitioner would have appeared before
respondent No.5 and would have requested him not to release
the compensation as directed by this Court in WP
No.17590/2024. He therefore contends that respondent Nos.4
and 5 have acted in concert to ensure that the petitioner is
deprived of the compensation.
- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
(v) He further contends that the respondent No.5 has
deliberately ignored the orders passed by this Court from time
to time and has passed the impugned order which clearly
demonstrates that the respondent No.5 has played into the
hands of respondent No.4 for obvious extraneous
considerations. He submits that at any rate, the respondent
No.5 could not have decided complicated questions of fact and
must have relegated the petitioner and respondent No.4 to the
Civil Court. Hence, he prays that the impugned order passed by
the respondent No.5 be set aside and an order be passed
directing the respondent No.4 to reimburse the compensation.
10. The learned Senior Counsel for the respondent No.4
on the other hand contended that the notifications relied upon
by the petitioner is inconclusive as there is no final notification
issued in respect of the lands in question and hence, the
petitioner does not derive any title to the property.
11. (i) Elaborating on the above, the learned Senior
Counsel contended that the Government of His Highness
Maharaj of Mysore passed an order dated 22.02.1937 whereby
it decided that an extent of 70 acres of Government unoccupied
- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
wasteland would be given free of cost and another 112 acres of
private property in Soladevanahalli had to be acquired by the
Government and the cost of the acquisition had to be borne by
the petitioner. This was followed by an order dated 24.06.1938
where the Assistant Commissioner was authorized to perform
the functions of a Deputy Commissioner under the Act, 1894
for acquiring various properties including Sy.Nos.71/1, 71/2,
80/1, 80/3 and 81/2 amongst other survey numbers of
Chikkabanavara Village.
(ii) On 24.06.1938, a notification was issued under
Section 4(1) of the Act, 1894 together with the notification in
terms of Section 17(4) of the Act, 1894 by dispensing with the
provisions of Section 5-A of the Act, 1894 thereof. This
preliminary notification included the following properties
namely Sy.Nos.80/3, 81/2, 71/1 and 71/2. He contends that
another notification was issued on the same day under Section
17(1) of the Act, 1894 that the lands would be possessed after
expiry of 15 days from the date of publication of the notice
mentioned under Section 9(1) of the Act, 1894 as amended by
the Mysore Land Acquisition Act, I of 1927. He contends that
- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
the provisions of Mysore Land Acquisition Act, as it stood then
was amended by Act No.I of 1927 by incorporating various
amendments and took the Court through Section 17 of the Act,
1894.
(iii) He contends the notice of the Chief Secretary of the
Government of Mysore shows that he had passed an order on
18.09.1941 dropping the acquisition proceedings at the stage
of Section 17(1) of the Act, 1894 itself, since they failed to take
possession of the properties within 15 days. There is a specific
reference that the Government Order directing the land
acquisition proceedings had failed for the reason that in-time
procedure was not followed and there is a specific reference
that final declaration was not issued by the Government and so
the land acquisition was rejected and the Government had
sanctioned the note of the Revenue Commissioner. On
12.10.1941 the orders of the Chief Secretary were notified by
the Deputy Commissioner to the Amaldar, Bengaluru Taluk and
ordered that the lands will have to be continued in the name of
the Khatedars as reflected in the notifications compulsorily and
that the landowners will have to continue in possession.
- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
(iv) He contends that the revenue entries as per
M.R.No.1/1941-42 will indicate that the entries were made in
the name of the landowners including the properties concerned.
He contends that the revenue entries had continued in the
name of the Khatedars and subsequently, their legal
representatives and at no point of time the name of the
petitioner was entered in the revenue records. He therefore
contends that though there was an order passed for acquiring
112 acres of private land in Soladevanahalli and
Chikkabanavara, the preliminary notification issued under
Sections 4(1) and 17(1) of the Act, 1894 and a
contemporaneous simultaneous notification of the like date i.e.
24.06.1938 was issued under Section 4(1) and Section 17(4) of
the Act, 1894. He contends that mere issuance of a notification
under Sections 4(1) and 17(1) and Section 17(4) of the Act,
1894 is only an intention to acquire the lands by bypassing the
usual process of acquisition. He submits that Section 17(1) of
the Act, 1894 enables taking possession of the property after
publishing Section 9(1) of the Act, 1894 notice and Section
17(4) of the Act, 1894 dispenses with the enquiry under
- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
Section 5-A of the Act, 1894. The vesting of the property under
Section 17(1) of the Act, 1894 is only if actual and physical
possession is taken after 15 days from the date on which
Section 9(1) of the Act, 1894 notice has been issued.
(v) He submits that the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Nandeshwar Prasad and Others vs. U.P. Government and
Others - 1963 SCC OnLine SC 245 held, while explaining the
scheme of Sections 4, 5-A, 6 and 17 of the Land Acquisition
Act, 1894 as follows:
"It will be clear from this scheme that compliance
with the provisions of Section 5-A is necessary before a
notification can be issued under Section 6. As soon as the
preliminary notification is issued under Section 4, the
officer authorised by Government may enter upon the
land to survey it and to do all other necessary acts to
ascertain whether the land is adapted for the purpose for
which it is to be acquired, and this action, if taken, will
give sufficient notice to those interested to object. If
objections are made the Collector will consider those
objections and make his recommendation thereon in his
report to Government, If no objections are made the
Collector will report that no objection has been made and
the Government then proceeds to issue a notification
under Section 6. In either case however, the Collector has
- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
got to make a report with his recommendations on the
objections if they are filed, or inform the Government that
there are no objections filed in pursuance of the
notification under Section 4 and it is thereafter that the
Government is empowered under Section 6 to issue a
notification. This, as we have said, is the usual procedure
to be followed before the notification under Section 6 is
issued. To this usual procedure there is however an
exception under Section 17, and that is why in Section 6
we find the words "if any" in the clause "after considering
the report, if any, made under Section 5-A". When action
is taken under Section 17(4), it is not necessary to follow
the procedure in Section 5-A and a notification under
Section 6 can be issued without a report from the
Collector under Section 5-A. Section 17(1) gives power to
the Government to direct the Collector, though no award
has been made under Section 11, to take possession of
any waste or arable land needed for public purpose and
such land thereupon vests absolutely in the Government
free from all encumbrances. If action is taken under
Section 17(1), taking possession and vesting which are
provided in Section 16 after the award under Section 11
are accelerated and can take place fifteen days after the
publication of the notice under Section 9. Then comes
Section 17(4) which provides that in the case of any land
to which the provisions of sub-section (1) are applicable,
the Government may direct that the provisions of Section
5-A shall not apply and if it does so direct, a declaration
may be made under Section 6 in respect of the land at
any time after the publication of the notification under
- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
Section 4 (1). It will be seen that it is not necessary even
where the Government makes a direction under Section
17(1) that it should also make a direction under Section
17(4). If the Government makes a direction only under
Section 17(1) the procedure under Section 5-A would still
have to be followed before a notification under Section 6
is issued, though after that procedure has been followed
and a notification under Section 6 is issued the Collector
gets the power to take possession of the land after the
notice under Section 9 without waiting for the award and
on such taking possession the land shall vest absolutely in
Government free from all encumbrances. It is only when
the Government also makes a declaration under Section
17(4) that it becomes unnecessary to take action under
Section 5-A and make a report thereunder."
(vi) He therefore submits that the acquisition is still
born as the notification under Section 6 of the Act, 1894 is not
issued. In support of this contention, he relied upon the
judgment of the Apex Court in Delhi Airtech Services Private
Limited and Another Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and
Another - (2024) 17 SCC 610 , where it was held that no
divesting of rights takes place unless it is shown that actual and
physical possession is taken up in a manner known to law and
when there is no Section 6 of the Act, 1894 notification, there
will be no award and the acquisition would not be concluded.
- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
He therefore contends that in the instant case too, the
acquisition is not complete and therefore, the petitioner does
not get any right in respect of the land in question. He also
relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Mohan
Singh and Others vs. International Airport Authority of
India - (1997) 9 ACC 132 , where it was held that it is a
mandatory requirement that a declaration of Section 6(1) of
the Act, 1894 is published. He therefore contends that there is
nothing on record to indicate that either Section 9(1) of the
Act, 1894 notice was published or the actual and physical
possession of the properties were taken from the landowners
by drawing a mahazar.
(vii) He further contends that this also falsifies the
Government order dated 18.09.1941 since the acquisition was
not concluded in all respects. He submits that one document
which is relied upon by the petitioner emanates from the office
of the Sub-Registrar, which shows that which bears a reference
that certain amounts were paid to the landowners as
compensation. He contends that this document has no sanctity
in the eyes of law, as it is coming from a source from where it
- 38 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
ought not to have come and it does not form part of the land
acquisition papers leading to passing of an award and this by
itself cannot be treated as a substitute to an award. He
contends that no documents is placed on record to show that
there was an award and even the list generated by the office of
the Sub-Registrar does not contain the signatures of the
erstwhile Khatedars to claim that there was any payment of
compensation and there are no receipts and this document runs
contrary to the Government Orders dated 18.09.1941 and
12.10.1941 and M.R.No.1/1941-42. He therefore contends that
there is no acquisition of the land in question in favour of the
petitioner and hence, the petitioner does not derive right title
or interest in the lands in question.
12. He contends that the acquisition was purportedly
for a company and therefore, whenever acquisition is for a
company the requirement under Chapter-VII of the Mysore
Land Acquisition Act as amended by Act, of 1927 had to be
complied with. He submits under Sections 38 and 39 of the Act,
1894 specifies that no such acquisition can be initiated unless
the requirements of (i) consent by the Government, (ii) an
- 39 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
agreement executed by the company is fulfilled. In this regard
he has relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in
R.L.Arora vs. State of Uttar Pradesh and Others - AIR
1962 SC 764. Where it was held that land cannot be acquired
under Part-VII unless two conditions are fulfilled namely the
consent of the Government to the acquisition and the execution
of an agreement by the company providing for the matter
specified in Section 41 of the Act, 1894. He also relied upon the
judgment in Shyam Nandan Prasad and others vs. State of
Bihar and others - (1993) 4 SCC 255 that the provisions of
Sections 6 to 37 of the Act, 1894 cannot be put in force to
acquire land for any company unless the previous consent of
the appropriate Government has been obtained and the
company has executed the agreement contemplated under the
Act, 1894. Likewise, he has relied upon the judgment of the
Hon'ble Apex Court in Anil Agarwal Foundation Etc. vs.
State of Orissa - 2023 INSC 361 . He therefore contends that
the acquisition in favour of the petitioner is not concluded and
is not in the manner prescribed under law and therefore, the
petitioner cannot rely upon the said acquisition.
- 40 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
13. As regards the revenue entries, he contends that by
acceptance of mutation in M.R.No.1/1941-42, the names of all
the landowners including the owners of land in Sy.Nos.71/1,
71/2, 80/1, 80/3 and 81/2 was reflected. At no point of time,
there was any mutation in the name of the petitioner nor
revenue entries were carried out in its name. He contends that
the findings recorded in the revenue proceedings will not affect
the title to the property and title has to be decided
independently. In this regard, he relied upon the judgment of
the Hon'ble Apex Court in Jitendra Singh vs. The State of
Madhya Pradesh and others - (2021) SCC OnLine SC 802
where it was held that mutation entry does not confer any
right, title or interest in favour of a person. He also contends
that the petitioner filed O.S.No.1143-1146/2010 for
cancellation of the sale deeds in favour of the respondent No.4.
However, the said suit was contested by the defendants but the
suits were dismissed for non-prosecution and Miscellaneous
Petition No.119-121/2017 are pending consideration. The
petitioner filed another suit in O.S.No.1075/2017 which too is
dismissed as withdrawn. He therefore submits that the
- 41 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
respondent No.3 had correctly appreciated the documents and
rightly returned a finding that the respondent No.4 is entitled to
the compensation in respect of the aforesaid survey numbers
and hence, no interference is warranted with the orders. He
therefore prays that the writ petition be dismissed.
14. I have considered the submissions of the learned
Senior Counsel for the petitioner, the learned counsel for the
respondent No.2 and the learned Senior Counsel for the
respondent No.4. I have also perused the voluminous records
placed before me.
15. (i) The land in question are Sy.Nos.80/1, 80/3
and 81/2 of Chikkabanavara Village, Yeshwanthpur hobli,
Bengaluru North Taluk. The petitioner claims that the above
survey numbers along with land in other survey numbers were
acquired for it by the Government of His Highness, the
Maharaja of Mysore. Annexure - A filed along with the writ
petition is an order bearing No.D-5644-54-I & C.183-36-3
dated 22.02.1937 whereby the Government agreed to give 70
acres of unoccupied waste land near Soladevanahalli Pumping
Station. It also agreed that private land measuring 112 acres in
- 42 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
Soladevanahalli lying contiguous to the wasteland would be
acquired, the cost of which had to be borne by the petitioner.
Following this, a notification bearing No.D.9495-I & C. 183-36-
29 dated 24.06.1938 was published which reads as follows:
“Whereas, it appears to the Government of His
Highness, the Maharaja Mysore that the under mentioned
land situate in Soladevanahalli and Chikkabanavara
Villages, Bangalore Taluk, Bangalore District be needed
for a public purpose, viz., for Mysore Stoneware Pipe and
Potteries Ltd., notice to that effect is hereby given to all
whom it may concern, in accordance with the provisions
of Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act of 1894, as
amended by the Land Acquisition Amendment Act No.I of
1927, and the Government hereby authorized the
Assistant Commissioner, in charge of Bangalore Sub-
division to exercise the powers conferred by Section 4(2)
of the Act. Under sub-section (4) of Section 17 of the
Land Acquisition Act of 1894, as amended by Act No.1 of
1927, the Government direct that, in view of the urgency
of the case, the provisions of Section 5-A of the Act shall
not apply to the acquisition of the lands noted below. "
16. (ii) The land bearing Sy.Nos.80/1, 80/2, 80/3 and
81/2 of Chikkabanavara Village was also mentioned in the said
notification. Later, a notification bearing No.9495-I & C. 183-
36-29 dated 24.06.1938 was published which reads as follows:
- 43 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
"Under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894
as amended by the Land Acquisition Amendment Act No.I
of 1927, the Government of His Highness the Maharaja
Mysore declares that the lands mentioned in
Soladevanahalli and Chikkabanavara Village, be the same
a little more or less, are needed for a public purpose to
wit, for Mysore Stoneware Pipe and Potteries Ltd., and
under Section 4 and 7 of the same Act, the Assistant
Commissioner, Bangalore Sub-Division is appointed to
perform the functions of a Deputy Commissioner under
the Act and directed to take orders for the acquisition of
the said lands. Under sub-section (1) of Section 17 of the
Act, the Government further directs that the possession of
the said lands may be taken on the expiry of fifteen days
from the date of publication of the notice mentioned in
Section 9(1) of the Act. A plan of the lands is kept in the
office of the Assistant Commissioner in charge of
Bangalore Sub-Division Office, and may be inspected at
any time during office hours."
(ii) This notification also was in respect of Sy.Nos.80/1,
80/2, 80/3 and 81/2 of Chikkabanavara Village. Annexure-W is
a statement showing the particulars of land acquired in favour
of the petitioner and the amount of compensation paid to the
claimants in Cr.No.13/1938-39 on the file of the Land
Acquisition Officer, Bangalore Sub-Division. This statement is
purportedly signed by the Land Acquisition Officer and was
- 44 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
registered at the office of the Sub-Registrar as Document No.
44, Book - I, Volume 553 at page 157.
(iii) Annexure - Z is a simple mortgage deed dated
03.04.1948 executed by the petitioner in favour of the Bank of
Mysore Limited, which was registered as Document No.
4853/1947-48, Book I, Volume 964 at pages 98 to 108. This
document shows that the petitioner had mortgaged land
bearing Sy.Nos.80/1, 80/3, 81/2 of Chikkabanavara Village
amongst other survey numbers for raising the loan of
Rs.1,00,000/-. The schedule to this mortgage deed shows that
the infrastructure that existed on the land in Soladevanahalli
and Chikkabanavara Village were as follows:
“Water works consisting of masonry and erg round
tank of 60,000 gallons capacity and the mallhigh level
tank of 1200 gallons capacity attached to the machine
shed, 3 machine shed drying shed and other buildings
consisting of (1) a pakka building 260' feet long by 50'
feet wide and 18' feet height above plinth with steel roof
covered over with corrugated 22 gauge iron sheets etc.,
(2) a power house built of masonry walls and R.C. roofing
20' feet into 15', feet (3) a pump house (4) a number of
temporary sheds, housing, the mould room, fire-brick
manufacturing section etc., (5) a temporary office and
- 45 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
stores shed of nearby nearly 100' feet X 20' feet (4)
Kilns:- 2 big kilns 20 feet diameter and 2 small kilms (5)
machinery: -Mather & Platt pump direct coupled with
motor 15 HP, 2 stones, 2 stone breaker 6 HP, (3) Ball Mill
10 ½ HP (4) Crushing Mill 7½ HP (5) Cyclene Separator
3½ HP, (6) Horizontal mixing spinal through 10 HP, (7)
PNG Mill 20 HP, (8) Automatic piece enter, (9) Worm
socket pipe press small 24 HP, (10)worm socket pipe
press big 56 HP, (11) Portable stoneware socket pipe
dressing and grooming machine 2 HP, (12) Automatic
sacking of seal, (13) Serving elevator 7 ½ HP, (14)
Revaling stone press 10 HP and 26 HP, (15) Rectrive
revolding spindle 1 HP, (16) wet grinding dan 15 HP (17)
Glaze grinding 1 HP, (18) 15 glaseive spot machines
excepting the motor of item (19) 350 KVA transformers,
(2) Main switches disturbing panels for motors, 6 quarries
at Thammanahalli, Sasveghatta and Bhimasamudra etc
and the uncalled capital of the petitioner."
(iv) Therefore, it can safely be held that the petitioner
had established its unit for the manufacture of stoneware and
potteries in the land in question at an undisputed point of time.
(v) The document at Annexure - W establishes the
payment of compensation to the land losers, which included the
land bearing Sy.Nos.80/1, 80/3 and 81/2 of Chikkabanavara
Village. The owners of the land in question did nothing from the
- 46 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
year 1937-38 onwards to call in question the acquisition and
therefore, to expect the petitioner to preserve the acquisition
records for nearly a century is extremely ludicrous.
17. The contention of the learned Senior Counsel for
the respondent No.4 that the acquisition was not concluded by
issuing a final notification and that the Government of Mysore
had cancelled the acquisition proceedings was a ground raised
by the respondent No.4 in W.P.No.2346-49/2019 and a Co-
ordinate Bench of this Court while answering this contention
held as follows:
“This Court cannot lose sight of the fact that
several orders have been passed by this Court negating
the contentions of the land owners and subsequently their
legal heirs who sought to contend that they acquired title
in terms of the orders passed by the Land Tribunal or the
competent authority conferring occupancy rights or
regranting land in their favour. In one writ petition, a
challenge raised to the acquisition proceedings were also
considered and rejected. Therefore, this Court does not
find any infirmity in the impugned orders passed by the
Deputy Commissioner."
- 47 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
18. The Division Bench of this Court in
W.A.No.939/2024, while answering the said contention, held as
follows:
“5.2 The appellant-petitioner indirectly challenged
the acquisition proceedings which were finalized in the
times of Maharaja of Mysore, in the guise of challenging
the mutation entries. The mutation in the revenue records
was entered in the name of the respondent No.4
(petitioner herein). It is running a factory since years on
the land acquired for it.
5.3 It was sought to be submitted on behalf of
the appellant that the preliminary notification and the
final notification were of the same date, therefore, the
acquisition was bad. The contention remained meritless.
In Vijay Cotton and Oil Mills Limited Vs. State of
Gujarat [ ( 1969) 2 SCR 60], it was held that it was
lawful for the Government to publish both the notifications
on the same date, where the order was passed under
Section 17(4) dispensing with the procedure under
Section 5(A) of the Act."
(ii) This apart, the respondent No.4 has tried to place
on record in this writ petition several documents that were not
placed before the respondent No.5, who was considering the
claims of the petitioner and the respondent No.4 to the
- 48 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
compensation in respect of the acquisition of the lands in
question.
19. The respondent No.4 claims to have purchased the
land in question from the representatives of the erstwhile
owners based on revenue entries which are all set at naught by
the Deputy Commissioner and this Court in W.P.No.2346-
49/2019 and W.A.No.939/2024. In the meanwhile, a notice for
drawing an award was issued to the respondent No.4, which
was challenged before this Court in W.P.No.17590/2024 where
this Court directed the respondent No.5 to take note of the
orders passed in W.P.No.2346-49/2019, W.A.No.939/2024 and
then pass orders.
20. When a Land Acquisition Officer sits as an
adjudicating authority to decide who amongst the claimants has
a better right to receive the compensation, he does not have an
absolute power to do so, but if the dispute is not very hazy or
complicated, he may decide it one way or the other. However,
when the dispute is complicated and he is not equipped to deal
with it, he is bound to refer the dispute to the Civil Court. In
this regard, it is apposite to refer to the judgment of a Co-
- 49 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
ordinate Bench of this Court in S.Venkatashamappa vs.
State of Karnataka - [2003 SCC OnLine KAR 50] , where it
was held as follows:
"9. Thus, by a conjoined reading of Section 29 of
the Development Act and Section 11 of the Act, the
Deputy Commissioner has to hold an enquiry regarding
the entitlement of a person to claim and receive
compensation. In the process of conducting an enquiry
regarding the entitlement as held by the decision of the
Andhra Pradesh High Court by Justice Chinnappa Reddy,
as he then was, cited by the learned Counsel for the
contesting respondent in Afzal Bee v. Spl. Deputy
Collector (supra), the Land Acquisition Officer has
jurisdiction to decide even the question of title if it is
raised before him. But, if he feels that the ‘question of
title’ is a complicated one, he may refer the matter to a
Civil Court. The process of deciding the claim of the
claimant necessarily carries with if the obligation of
applying his mind to the material produced or available on
record in a fair manner, fairness means that if the land
Acquisition Officer wants to use any adverse material or
document adverse to the interest of claimant, it can only
be done after drawing the attention of the claimant to the
adverse material and soliciting his comments or
objections, etc. By not doing so, he would be violating the
elementary principles of natural justice. Similarly, while
conducting the enquiry as stated above, the Land
Acquisition Officer will be performing statutory functions
- 50 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
and therefore, has to independently take a decision on the
basis of records available before him and cannot act on
the dictates of any authority however superior he may
be."
21. Contrarily, the respondent No.5 has arrogated to
himself the powers of a Civil Court while passing the impugned
orders. He has scoured through several documents and held:
“The documents produced by MSPPL along with the
reply dated 06.02.2025 does not disclose of taking over
possession of the acquired lands as mentioned in the
preliminary notification. When the Government exercising
its special powers in cases of urgency U/s. 17(1) of the LA
Act, after exercising such powers under Section 17(4) of
the LA Act, the appropriate Government must issue a
declaration U/s. 6 of the LA Act in respect of the acquired
lands after publication of the notification U/s. 4(1) of the
LA Act. However, the rival claimant did not produce any
such document to show that declaration under Section 6
of the LA Act was issued in respect of the LA Act. In the
absence of such document produced by the rival claimant
it is clear that the appropriate Government only issued
preliminary notification U/s. 4(1) of the LA Act proposing
to acquire the above said lands which did not culminated
into issuing final notification U/s.6(1) of the LA Act.”
22. (i) He perused the Index of Land, Record of Rights
at SL.Nos.1044-1053, mutation in M.R.No.4/1976-77, Mysore
- 51 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
Revision Settlement Register/Faisal Patrike and MT 14/58-59
and held as follows:
“The documents summoned from the office of the
Tahsildar clearly indicates that the land bearing
Sy.Nos.80/1 and 81/2 were recorded in the name of
Muniyappa S/o Kullaiah since 1925 at R.R.Nos.168 and
172. The said lands were later transferred in favour of his
son Narayanswamy on 29.12.1958 through Mutation
Transfer No. 14/58-59. Subsequently the new RR Record
Numbers 734 & 735 were recorded. These records were
continued till 1967. The records discloses that the name
of MSPPL said to have been entered in the revenue
records as per MR No.4/76-77 in the RR records. The said
entry was made under Nos.1044 to 1053. The copy of the
RR extracted above clearly indicates MSPPL name was not
recorded in the RR records as per RR records 1044 to
1053 which was kept blanks, no entries were recorded.
The contents of MR No.4/76-77 reveals that the
said entry pertaining to the property measuring 40X28
feet Sy No.92/3 of Chikkabanavara Village. The details of
entry discloses that the first son of B. Veeranna namely V.
Gangadhar purchased the said property from S.
Shamanna S/o. Subbaiah. The contents of the MR 4/76-
77 does not refer to the properties said to have been held
by MSPPL. The way in which these entries were found in
the revenue records referred above clearly indicates that
the entries have been manipulated and created in
- 52 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
connivance with the then concerned revenue authorities
and the representatives of MSPPL.”
(ii) The respondent No.5 was clearly oblivious of the
fact that the revenue entries which stood in the name of the
erstwhile landowners, were the basis of an order passed by the
Tahsildar to enter the names of the legal heirs of the erstwhile
owners which was ultimately set at nought by the Deputy
Commissioner and this Court in W.P.No.2346-49/2019,
W.A.No.939/2024. Therefore, the respondent No.5 could not
have relied upon the very same revenue records to hold that
respondent No.1 had derived title to the properties in question.
The question whether the notification dated 24.06.1938 itself
was a final notification or not was something that was beyond
the comprehension of respondent No.5. The least the
respondent No.5 must have done even before venturing to
decide the claims of the petitioner and respondent No.4 was to
conduct a spot inspection to find out the status of the property.
When the erstwhile owners had purportedly received the
compensation in the year 1938, many records may not be
traceable to clarify certain lapses which are now pointed out
after nearly 100 years. The complicity of the respondent No.5
- 53 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
with the respondent No.4 in ensuring release of portion of the
compensation is strikingly evident from the fact that though
this Court had specifically directed that the orders passed in
W.P.No.2346-49/2019 be taken note of before considering the
claims of the petitioner and the respondent No.4, the
respondent No.5 merely referred to the order in W.P.No.2346-
49/2019 but did not consider the findings recorded therein.
This Court had specifically directed that after determination of
the claims of the petitioner and the respondent No.4,
compensation shall not be released for fifteen days if a request
is made by either party. In order to overcome this, the
respondent No.1 passed an order on 27.05.2025 and belatedly
sent the certified copy of the order to the petitioner by post on
26.06.2025 along with a covering letter dated 02.06.2025
which was received by the petitioner on 27.06.2025 by which
time, the respondent No.5 had released the compensation to
the respondent No.4. To make matters worse, for the
respondent Nos.4 and 5, the indemnity bond was executed by
the respondent No.4 on 24.04.2025 even before impugned
orders were passed. The respondent No.4 certainly could not
- 54 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
have the clairvoyance to foresee that respondent No.5 would
pass an order in her favour. This therefore establishes beyond
doubt that respondent No.5 did so, in order to ensure that the
respondent No.4 received the compensation even before the
petitioner could make a request not to release the
compensation to the respondent No.4. The respondent No.5
therefore is clearly guilty of misconduct of taking sides with a
party who is litigating before him and hence, suitable
disciplinary proceedings shall be conducted against him and
until then the official superior of the respondent No.5 shall
place the respondent No.5 in a non-executive post. As a fallout
of the above, as the respondent No.4 has received portion of
the compensation, she is bound to re-deposit it before the
respondent No.2 in view of indemnity bond submitted by her
undertaking to re-deposit the compensation whenever directed.
23. As far as the documents placed on record before
this Court by the learned counsel for the respondent No.4, a
crucial document is a document dated 18.09.1941, which
shows that the land acquisition for the petitioner had failed for
not taking in time procedure and that the payment records
- 55 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
were not available and a final declaration was not issued.
Likewise, a letter addressed by the Deputy Commissioner,
Bengaluru District to the Amaldar, Bengaluru Taluk Office dated
12.10.1941 shows that on the order of the Chief Secretary to
the Government after canceling the acquisition of the land to
the extent of 118 acres 24 guntas in Chikkabanavara and
Soladevanahalli and ordered the landowners of the said lands
to bring the Khatha, Kandaya and also at the same time issued
an order to the Amaldar of Bengaluru Taluk to bring the Khatha
Kandaya of the above lands compulsorily. However, these
documents were not placed before the respondent No.5 at the
time of enquiry. The authenticity of these documents is yet to
be established. Therefore, this Court cannot look into those
documents to consider the claims of the petitioner and the
respondent No.4 to the compensation in respect of the
acquisition of land in Sy.Nos.80/1, 80/3 and 81/2 of
Chikkabanavara.
24. It is noticed that the petitioner had filed a suit in
O.S.Nos.1143/2010, 1145/2010 and 1146/2010 for declaration
that the sale deed in favour of the respondent No.4 is null and
- 56 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
void. The said suit is dismissed for non-prosecution and
Misc.P.Nos.119/2017, 120/2017 and 121/2017 are pending
consideration. Therefore, the petitioner also is not entitled to
receive the compensation, but the respondent No.5 after
recovering the compensation from the respondent No.4, shall
refer the claim to the Civil Court or await the outcome of the
proceedings in O.S.Nos.1143/2010, 1145/2010 and 1146/2010,
if they are restored and thereafter pass appropriate orders.
25. In view of the above, the following order is passed:
ORDER
i. The petition is allowed ;
ii. The impugned orders bearing file Nos. C2/R/26/
400/BAW/04//2025-2026, C2/R/26/400/BAW/14/
/2025-26, C2/R/26/400/BAW/02/ /2025-2026 of
even date 27.05.2025 passed by the Special Land
Acquisition Officer-2 of the respondent No.2 are
quashed. The respondent No.2 is directed to
initiate disciplinary action against the officer who
passed the impugned orders and until such
- 57 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
initiation he shall be posted in a non-executive
cadre;
iii. The respondent Nos.2 and 5 are directed to
recover the compensation of Rs.28,29,15,025/-
(Rupees Twenty Eight Crores Twenty Nine Lakhs
Fifteen Thousand and Twenty Five only)from the
respondent No.4. They shall conduct a money trail
to ascertain how the respondent No.4 had
withdrawn the money and they shall take steps to
attach any movable or immovable properties
purchased out of the money received in her
account as compensation. If a request is made by
respondent Nos.2 and 5 to any concerned bank to
furnish documents relating to the transaction of
respondent No.4, the same shall be furnished by
the concerned bank;
iv. Until the recovery as stated in (iii) above, the
respondent No.4 is restrained from alienating,
encumbering or transferring any properties that
stand in her name;
- 58 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
v. The petitioner and the respondent No.5 are
permitted to make appropriate application for
freezing the bank accounts of the respondent No.4
anywhere in India and if an application is filed, the
concerned bank shall freeze the amount lying in
the account of the respondent No.4;
vi. The respondent No.2 shall take immediate steps
to notify the general public against dealing with
the respondent No.4 regarding any properties that
stand in her name;
vii. The compensation that may be recovered from
the respondent No.4 and the balance
compensation that is lying with respondent
No.2/respondent No.5 in respect of the land
bearing Sy.Nos.80/1, 80/3 and 81/2 of
Chikkabanavara shall be kept in an interest
earning fixed deposit in any Nationalized Bank for
a period of three years or until the disposal of
Misc.P.Nos.119/2017, 120/2017 and 121/2017
and O.S.Nos.1143/2010, 1144/2010 and
- 59 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:59241
WP No. 18923 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010425892025
1146/2010 pending consideration before the Civil
Judge, Senior Division, Bengaluru Rural,
Bangalore. The compensation shall be released to
whoever succeeds in the litigation, referred
above;
viii. The Civil Judge, Senior Division, Bengaluru Rural
District is directed to take up
Misc.P.Nos.119/2017, 120/2017 and 121/2017
preferably on a day to day basis for early disposal,
which shall at any rate not be beyond six months
from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
ix. List on 17.12.2026 for compliance of the above.
Sd/-
(R. NATARAJ)
JUDGE
BKN/List No.: 1 Sl No.: 11