SRI. MADHU S N vs SMT. YASHASWINI

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023


IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU


ST
DATED THIS THE 1 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH

AND

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 8522/2023 (FC)

BETWEEN:

SRI. MADHU S N
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
S/O S.K. NARASIMHA MURTHY
TH
RESIDING AT NO 11-58, 12 MAIN,
BEHIND J.P.PARK, MATTIKERE,
MUTHYALANAGAR, BANGALORE – 560 054.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. KEERTI KUMAR D. NAIK, ADVOCATE)

AND:

SMT. YASHASWINI
W/O MADHU N,
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
TH
RESIDING AT NO.11-58, 12 MAIN,
BEHIND J.P.PARK, MATTIKERE,
MUTHYALANAGAR, BANGALORE - 560 054.

OFFICE ADDRESS: AEE, 220/66,
MUSS, KPTCL, DEVANAHALLI ROAD,
DODDABALLAPURA – 561 203.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SMT. T.R. RAJESHWARI, ADVOCATE)

THIS MFA FILED UNDER SECTION 19(1) OF FAMILY COURT
ACT, AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 17.07.2023
PASSED IN M.C.NO.5765/2017 ON THE FILE OF THE III ADDITIONAL
PRINCIPAL JUDGE, FAMILY COURT, BENGALURU, DISMISSING THE
PETITION FILED UNDER SECTION 13(1) (ia) OF THE HINDU
MARRIAGE ACT AND ALLOWING THE COUNTER CLAIM OF THE
RESPONDENT.










Digitally
signed by
MALA K N
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN

ORAL JUDGMENT

(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)

The present appeal is directed against the judgment and
decree dated 17.07.2023 passed by the III Additional Principal
Judge, Family Court at Bengaluru, in Matrimonial Case
No.5765/2017 (‘the Family Court’ for brevity) whereby the
petition filed by the petitioner-husband under Section 13(1)(ia)
of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (‘the Act’ for short), was
dismissed and the counter claim filed by the respondent-wife
under Section 9 of the Act came to be allowed and the
petitioner was directed to continue his matrimonial relationship
with the respondent.


2. For the sake of convenience, the parties shall be
referred to as they were arrayed before the Family Court.

(i) Facts pleaded by the petitioner:
3. The marriage between the petitioner and the
respondent was solemnized on 05.11.2008 at Sri Ranganatha

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

Swamy Kalyana Mantapa, West of Chord Road, Bengaluru, in
accordance with Hindu rites and customs. The marriage was
registered before the Registrar of Marriages, Jayanagar. The
parties are related to each other and, according to the
petitioner, the marriage alliance was brought about through a
common relative one Raghavan. A son, Adokshaja, was born to
them on 04.09.2009. The petitioner's case is that the
matrimonial relationship was not cordial from the beginning. He
referred to the respondent's alleged reluctance during the
engagement and marriage ceremonies and, more particularly,
to an incident during their honeymoon at Ooty in November
2008, when one Nagendra, stated to be a colleague of the
respondent in KPTCL, allegedly telephoned him and disclosed
that he had been in a relationship with the respondent even
before the marriage.
4. The petitioner claimed that the respondent more or
less confirmed the earlier relationship, though she denied its
physical aspect. He nevertheless stated that he consoled her
and decided to continue the marriage. According to him, the
subsequent conduct of the respondent towards his parents,

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

particularly his mother, gradually made the matrimonial home
difficult to live in.
5. It was further pleaded that the respondent
frequently quarrelled with his parents, did not cooperate in
household matters and humiliated them on several occasions.
The petitioner referred to disputes concerning cooking, the
birth and care of their son, the naming ceremony, the purchase
of a flat and the respondent's refusal to stand as a co-obligant
for a loan. He also alleged that the respondent was unwilling to
accompany him to the United States when he was deputed
there in 2015, and that she did not support his efforts to settle
there with the family. He returned to India after about a year.
The petitioner claimed that the respondent continued to speak
ill of his family even before their son and that the atmosphere
in the house affected his mental peace. He also relied upon the
legal notice dated 09.10.2017 and the reply dated 26.10.2017.
6. Alleging that the respondent had treated him with
cruelty and that there was no possibility of restoring the
matrimonial relationship, he instituted M.C.No.5765/2017

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

under Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955,
seeking dissolution of the marriage.
(ii) Defence of the respondent:
7. The respondent entered appearance and filed her
statement of objections, together with a counter-claim under
Sections 9 and 23-A of the Hindu Marriage Act, seeking
restitution of conjugal rights. She admitted the marriage, its
registration and the birth of their son. Her specific case,
however, was that she had entered the matrimonial home
willingly and had made genuine efforts to adjust to the family.
She denied the allegations of cruelty and stated that, after the
initial period following the marriage, she had taken
responsibility for cooking, serving food and attending to
household requirements. According to her, the petitioner's
mother was unhappy because the other members of the family
appreciated her cooking and began finding fault with her.
8. She also stated that she had purchased sarees and
jewellery for her mother-in-law and had taken care of her
during pregnancy when the latter suffered from a slip-disc

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

problem. The respondent attributed the growing differences to
the conduct of the petitioner and his family members, and
alleged that she was insulted and humiliated despite her efforts
to maintain cordial relations.
9. The respondent also disputed the petitioner's
version concerning the birth and care of the child. She stated
that her mother was unwell at the relevant time and, therefore,
she had to depend upon her relatives for post-natal care. She
denied that she had prevented the petitioner's mother from
touching the child. Her further case was that the petitioner had
developed an intimate relationship with his colleague, Reshma,
and that she had brought this matter to the notice of his
parents, but they had not supported her. She relied upon the
emails and photographs marked in evidence to substantiate her
allegation. According to her, the petitioner had been insisting
that she leave the matrimonial home or agree to a mutual
divorce. She referred particularly to the message dated
04.08.2017 and the incident dated 20.10.2017, when,
according to her, the petitioner forced her to leave the house.

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

10. She denied having withdrawn from the matrimonial
relationship and asserted that she continued to reside in the
matrimonial home with her son and the petitioner's parents.
She accordingly sought dismissal of the divorce petition and a
decree directing the petitioner to resume cohabitation and
discharge his matrimonial obligations.
(iii) Issues framed by the Family Court:
11. On the pleadings and the evidence placed on
record, the Family Court framed the following points for
consideration:
“(i) Whether the petitioner made out the ground for
dissolution of his marriage solemnized with the
respondent on 05.11.2008 at Sri Ranganatha Swamy
Kalyana Mantapa, West of Chord Road, Opposite ISKON,
Bangalore and marriage registered before the Registrar of
Marriage, Jayanagar in marriage No.JAY-HM 617-2008-09
dated 15.12.2005 stored in CD No.JAYM14, through the
decree of divorce under Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu
Marriage Act?
(ii) whether the respondent made out the ground for
restitution of conjugal rights under Section 9 of the Hindu
Marriage Act?
(iii) What order or decree?”
The Family Court answered the first point in the negative and
the second in the affirmative.

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

(iv) Grounds urged in the appeal:
12. The petitioner has questioned the judgment and
decree dated 17.07.2023, contending that the Family Court
failed to appreciate the oral and documentary evidence
adduced by him and ignored the alleged admissions made by
the respondent in her pleadings and evidence. It is urged that
proper points for consideration were not framed, that the
findings are contrary to the material on record and that the
Family Court accepted the respondent's allegations concerning
the petitioner's alleged relationship with other women without
sufficient proof.
13. The petitioner further contends that the documents
relied upon by the respondent were not duly admitted by him
and could not have been used against him in the manner
adopted by the Family Court. According to him, the
respondent's conduct amounted to mental cruelty, the marriage
had broken down irretrievably and the decree for restitution of
conjugal rights was not justified. On these grounds, he seeks
setting aside of the judgment and decree and a decree of
divorce.

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

14. We have heard Sri.Keerti Kumar D.Naik, learned
counsel appearing for the petitioner/husband and
Smt.T.R.Rajeshwari, learned counsel for the respondent/wife.
Upon consideration of the pleadings, the records placed before
this Court and the submissions advanced by the learned
counsel for the parties, the following point arises for our
consideration:
“ Whether the judgment and decree of the Family
Court suffers from any legal perversity or procedural
infirmity requiring interference by this Court?”

(v) Appreciation of evidence, reasons and conclusion:

15. The petitioner examined himself as PW-1 and
produced Exs.P1 to P14. The respondent examined herself as
RW-1 and relied upon Exs.R1 to R13. The marriage between
the parties, solemnized on 05.11.2008, is not in dispute. Their
marriage invitation and photographs, marked as Exs.P1 to P3,
were also not disputed. It is equally admitted that the parties
were known to each other even before their marriage, that the
respondent joined the petitioner in the matrimonial home and
that a son, Adokshaja , was born to them on 04.09.2009.

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

16. The controversy, therefore, is not about the marital
relationship, but about the conduct of the parties and whether
the incidents narrated by the petitioner are sufficient to
constitute cruelty within the meaning of Section 13(1)(ia) of
the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
17. The petitioner's principal grievance is that the
respondent was not cordial towards his parents and that her
conduct made it difficult for him to continue living in the
matrimonial home. He referred to several incidents concerning
the respondent's alleged behaviour towards his mother, the
manner in which she attended to household work, the birth and
upbringing of their son and the differences that arose in the
family. However, the evidence has to be considered as a whole
and not merely on the basis of the allegations made in the
petition. In his cross-examination, the petitioner admitted that
he was residing with the respondent when he instituted the
divorce petition.
18. He further admitted that he left the matrimonial
home only in January 2018, after filing the petition. This
admission assumes significance because his case was that the

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

respondent had withdrawn from his company from July 2017.
His own evidence does not support that assertion. He also
admitted that he had no documents to show that he was
residing in a paying guest accommodation.
19. The allegation concerning one Nagendra, who was
stated to have informed the petitioner about the respondent's
alleged relationship before the marriage, also does not inspire
confidence. The petitioner admitted that he was not in
possession of the mobile phone on which the alleged calls had
been received. He had not retained Nagendra's contact
number, had not attempted to meet him and had not taken any
action against him. According to the petitioner, the information
received from Nagendra was serious. Yet, he continued the
matrimonial relationship without making any attempt to verify
the allegation.
20. The respondent conceived within about two months
of the marriage, and the petitioner admitted that he had taken
care of her during pregnancy and used to drop her to her
workplace. The respondent, in her cross-examination, also
admitted that the matrimonial relationship was cordial from the

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

date of marriage. Their conduct and the subsequent birth of a
child have to be considered in this background. The alleged
information received from a third person, without any attempt
at verification and without any contemporaneous action, cannot
by itself establish that the respondent had subjected the
petitioner to cruelty.
21. Much of the petitioner's grievance relates to the
relationship between the respondent and his parents. The
respondent, on the other hand, stated that she had attended to
household responsibilities and had taken care of her mother-in-
law during her illness. The petitioner admitted that his father
used to bring dry fruits for the respondent during her
pregnancy. He also admitted that the respondent participated
in the marriage of his brother and in the ceremonies connected
with it. Exs.R2 to R6, which were confronted to him in cross-
examination, are photographs relating to those functions. He
identified the photographs. They do not support his allegation
that the respondent had refused to participate in the family
ceremonies.

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

22. The disputes concerning the naming ceremony of
the child and the non-participation of the petitioner's uncle and
aunt were also referred to in the evidence. The petitioner
admitted that their absence had hurt him, but there was no
material to show that the respondent was responsible for their
non-participation. In fact, after the naming ceremony, the
respondent returned to the matrimonial home with the child
when the child was about five months old, and the parties
continued to reside together. These incidents, viewed in their
proper setting, cannot be treated as acts of cruelty.
23. The petitioner also alleged that the respondent was
not taking proper care of the child and was unnecessarily
restricting the food brought by his parents. The evidence,
however, discloses that the child was suffering from allergies
and had been taken to doctors for treatment. The petitioner
admitted that the doctors had advised organic food because the
child was allergic to certain food grains and other items. He
also admitted that the respondent used to administer medicines
to the child as advised by the doctors.

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

24. In these circumstances, the respondent's insistence
that the child should not be given food which could aggravate
the allergy cannot be held against her. A mother taking
precautions in accordance with medical advice cannot be said
to have subjected her husband to cruelty merely because her
approach differed from that of the other members of the family.
25. There is yet another circumstance concerning the
child's health which deserves notice. The petitioner admitted
that the child had once collapsed at school and was taken to
Aster CMI Hospital. The doctors suspected that the child might
have suffered mental trauma and referred him for psychiatric
consultation. The petitioner also admitted that the doctors had
associated the child's mental health condition with the
matrimonial disputes. He was present when the child was taken
to the psychiatrist, and he admitted that the psychiatrist had
not advised that the child should stay separately.
26. The petitioner nevertheless stated that he was not
interested in reconciliation. This evidence cannot be brushed
aside, particularly when both parents were aware that their
matrimonial differences were affecting the child. The

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

respondent's conduct in continuing to reside in the matrimonial
home and taking care of the child is also relevant while
considering her counter-claim for restitution of conjugal rights.
27. The petitioner further contended that the
respondent refused to accompany him to the United States
when he was deputed there on official work in 2015. He
claimed that she was unwilling to resign from her employment
in KPTCL and join him. The respondent denied that there had
been any such discussion. The petitioner admitted that the
respondent and the child had visited him in the United States in
April 2016 and that the child was admitted to a school near
their place of stay. He also admitted that he did not remain in
the United States for the entire period of his deputation, that
he returned to India after about one year and that he had not
applied for a green card.
28. His explanation was that he was homesick and his
health had been affected. The respondent's evidence that there
was no discussion regarding her resignation from service was
not displaced. The petitioner subsequently rejoined the same
Company and was holding a higher position. There is no

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

satisfactory material to conclude that his professional prospects
were affected because of any refusal on the part of the
respondent to accompany him.
29. The financial allegations also do not advance the
petitioner's case. He complained that the respondent refused to
stand as a co-obligant for a loan which he intended to obtain
for purchasing property. In cross-examination, however, he
admitted that he had availed a personal loan without offering
the respondent as a co-obligant or surety. The respondent, on
the other hand, had purchased a site at Mysuru. The petitioner
admitted that he was present at the time of execution of the
sale deed, marked as Ex.R7, and had signed it as a witness. He
also admitted the entries in Ex.R8, the respondent's bank
passbook, showing the amount of Rs.5,38,000/- transferred by
her mother towards the purchase.
30. The evidence thus shows that the respondent had
financial assistance from her mother for acquiring the property.
The petitioner's allegation that she had refused to support him
in his financial dealings cannot be accepted merely on the basis

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

of his assertion, particularly when his own admissions disclose
that he had proceeded with the loan transaction independently.
31. The allegation concerning the respondent's alleged
non-cooperation in the marriage of the petitioner's brother is
contradicted by the photographs marked as Exs.R2 to R6. The
petitioner admitted that the respondent had participated in the
marriage and the family functions. It was also brought out that
the respondent had been suffering from a slip-disc problem.
The petitioner pleaded ignorance when questioned about the
extent of her back pain and the medical advice said to have
been given to her. The respondent was also employed as an
Assistant Executive Engineer in KPTCL and was required to
discharge her official duties.
32. She had the responsibility of looking after the child,
who was suffering from health issues, and was also attending
to her mother, who was residing separately and had age-
related health problems. In such circumstances, the petitioner's
expectation that the respondent should attend to the entire
household work in a joint family consisting of several members,
without assistance, cannot be accepted as a reasonable basis

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

for alleging cruelty. The Family Court was justified in examining
these circumstances instead of treating every domestic
disagreement as a matrimonial offence.
33. The evidence relating to Reshma, however,
assumes particular importance because the respondent had
specifically alleged that the petitioner was maintaining an
intimate relationship with her. During his cross-examination,
the petitioner identified Exs.R9 and R10 as emails sent by
Reshma to his personal and official email addresses. The
documents contained photographs which the Family Court
found to be objectionable. Though the petitioner denied having
an affair with Reshma, he did not offer a satisfactory
explanation as to why such photographs had been sent to his
email accounts. His suggestion that the respondent had access
to his email ID and password was not supported by any specific
statement in his evidence.
34. The Family Court considered these documents along
with the answers given by the petitioner and found that his
denial could not be accepted. It is not necessary for this Court
to record any finding beyond what the material warrants. It is

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

sufficient to notice that the petitioner's explanation regarding
Exs.R9 and R10 was unsatisfactory and that the documents
lend support to the respondent's defence that the matrimonial
differences were not attributable to her alone.
35. The respondent also relied upon Ex.R11, which she
stated contained an apology tendered by the petitioner for the
pain and suffering caused to her. The petitioner identified the
document but failed to provide a satisfactory explanation
regarding the circumstances in which the apology was
tendered. Further, he admitted having sent a message dated
14.08.2017 asking the respondent to leave the matrimonial
home and stay with her parents.
36. Though he denied that he had called upon her to
agree to a mutual divorce so that he could marry another
woman, the admitted message is relevant. The respondent also
spoke about an incident dated 20.10.2017, when, according to
her, the petitioner broke open the bathroom door, dragged her
outside and asked her to leave the house. The Family Court
noticed that the evidence concerning this incident had not been
effectively disputed. These circumstances, read together, do

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

not support the petitioner's case that it was the respondent
who had withdrawn from the matrimonial relationship.
37. It is also relevant that, even after the petitioner left
the matrimonial home in January 2018, the respondent
continued to reside there with the petitioner's parents and their
son. The evidence indicates that she did not prevent the child
from maintaining contact with his grandparents. The petitioner
admitted that the respondent was still residing with his parents
along with their son.
38. The Family Court also noticed that the child had
been taken by the petitioner's parents on trips to Manipal,
Udupi and Sringeri, and that the respondent had permitted the
child to accompany them. Ex.R12, the family photograph, was
also considered in this context. These circumstances do not
support the allegation that the respondent had deliberately
severed the relationship between the child and the petitioner's
family. On the contrary, her conduct is consistent with her
assertion that she was willing to continue the matrimonial
relationship.

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

39. The petitioner has relied upon the fact that the
parties have been living separately and contended that the
marriage has broken down irretrievably. But the separation, on
the evidence available, followed the petitioner's decision to
leave the matrimonial home after institution of the petition. His
own admission that he was residing with the respondent when
the petition was filed, and that he left only in January 2018,
assumes significance. Further, irretrievable breakdown of
marriage is not, by itself, an independent ground for dissolution
under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act.
40. The Court cannot grant a decree of divorce merely
because one spouse has lost the desire to continue the
relationship. The statutory ground of cruelty must still be
established. In the present case, the petitioner's allegations,
when tested in cross-examination, have not been substantiated
to the degree required by law.
41. The Family Court has considered the evidence of
both parties and the documents produced by them. The
petitioner's grievances regarding the respondent's conduct
towards his parents, the child's food, the family functions, the

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

financial transactions and the visit to the United States were
examined with reference to the admissions elicited in cross-
examination. Several of the allegations were contradicted by
the petitioner's own answers or by the documents identified by
him. The Family Court was therefore justified in holding that
the incidents relied upon by the petitioner were, in the
circumstances of the case, differences and disagreements
arising in the course of matrimonial life and did not establish
cruelty under Section 13(1)(ia) of the Act.
42. So far as the counter-claim is concerned, the
respondent had consistently maintained that she was willing to
continue the marriage. She continued to reside in the
matrimonial home with the petitioner's parents and their son,
and there is no satisfactory evidence that she had withdrawn
from the society of the petitioner. Her willingness was not
confined to a statement made before the Court; her conduct, as
borne out by the evidence, was also relevant.
43. The petitioner, on the other hand, admitted that he
was not interested in reconciliation. Having regard to the
pleadings, the evidence of RW-1, the admissions made by PW-1

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

and the documents marked as Exs.R1 to R13, the Family Court
was justified in allowing the counter-claim under Section 9 of
the Hindu Marriage Act.
44. On an overall assessment, this Court does not find
that the Family Court has ignored any material admission or
proceeded on conjectures. The findings are based on the
evidence of the parties and the documents brought on record.
The petitioner may have had grievances in the matrimonial
relationship, but those grievances, in the facts of this case, do
not establish the statutory ground of cruelty nor has he shown
that the respondent was disentitled to the relief of restitution of
conjugal rights.
45. The grounds urged in the appeal do not disclose
any error warranting interference with the judgment and
decree dated 17.07.2023.
dismissed
The appeal is accordingly .
The judgment and decree dated 17.07.2023 passed by
the III Additional Principal Judge, Family Court, Bengaluru, in
M.C.No.5765/2017, dismissing the petition filed by the

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:54898-DB
MFA No. 8522 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010640312023

petitioner under Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act,
1955, and allowing the respondent's counter-claim under
affirmed
Section 9 of the Act, are .
There shall be no order as to costs.
Pending I.A. stands disposed of.

Sd/-
(D K SINGH)
JUDGE


Sd/-
(H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)
JUDGE

KNM
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 35