Sudha Rakesh vs The State Of Karnataka
- Court
- Supreme Court
2026 INSC 1086
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
EXTRA-ORDINARY CRIMINAL JURISDICTION
SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CRL.) NO. 12638 OF 2022
SUDHA RAKESH ...PETITIONER
VERSUS
THE STATE OF
KARNATAKA & ANR.
...RESPONDENT(S)
J U D G M E N T
SATISH CHANDRA SHARMA, J.
1. The tendency of litigants to colourize civil disputes into
criminal offences is an open secret in the present times. The
courts have tried to put their foot down to prevent the litigants
from obliterating the fine distinction between the two. We have
done so to prevent the abuse of criminal process. The instant case
presents a similar opportunity.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
RAHUL KUMAR
Date: 2026.10.05
18:15:16 IST
Reason:
SLP (Criminal) No. 12638 of 2022 Page 1 of 9
2. The facts lie within a narrow compass. One Ganesh was
the owner of a piece of land bearing survey no. 115, admeasuring
4 acres 19 guntas, located in Channasandra Village, Karnataka.
He died intestate and after demise, the said land was inherited by
his wife and other legal heirs (“ landowners ”). The landowners
entered into an agreement for sale dated 05.10.2012 purporting
to sell the subject land in favour of the petitioner herein. They
also executed a General Power of Attorney ( “GPA” ) dated
05.10.2012 in favour of the petitioner. Thereafter, the
landowners, acting through their GPA holder/petitioner, entered
into another agreement dated 19.11.2012 with respondent no. 2
and one Kalpana Sure (“ prospective buyers ”) for sale of the
subject land.
3. As per this agreement, the prospective buyers were
required to pay the balance sale consideration and come forward
for execution of sale deed within 7 months from the date of
agreement. They never turned up. The petitioner and landowners
waited even beyond the period of 7 months and till the expiry of
the limitation period for seeking specific performance. The
prospective buyers took no action whatsoever and eventually, the
petitioner and landowners sold the subject land by executing a
sale deed dated 11.02.2016 in favour of one Gaffar Baig
(“ ultimate buyer” ).
SLP (Criminal) No. 12638 of 2022 Page 2 of 9
4. Immediately thereafter, the prospective buyers instituted a
civil suit for specific performance of the agreement for sale
executed on 19.11.2012. Subsequently, they also lodged a
criminal complaint on 13.05.2016, which was registered as FIR
No. 121/2016 under Sections 420, 423, 120-B read with Section
34 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (“ IPC” ). The petitioner was
named as an accused in the said FIR along with the landowners.
After the filing of final report, the Magistrate took cognizance of
the offences on 28.09.2017.
5. Against the said FIR and order of cognizance, the
landowners preferred a quashing petition before the High Court
of Karnataka. Vide order dated 22.11.2017 passed in Criminal
Petition No. 9095/2016, the High Court quashed the FIR qua the
landowners.
6. Thereafter, the petitioner also filed a quashing petition
before the High Court. However, his petition was dismissed on
merits vide order dated 19.09.2022 passed in Criminal Petition
No. 9470/2017 (“ impugned order” ).
7. Taking exception to the impugned order, the petitioner
submits that he was similarly placed with the landowners and the
coordinate bench ought to have followed the earlier judgment,
whereby the case against the landowners was quashed. He
submits that the dispute is purely civil in nature and there is no
SLP (Criminal) No. 12638 of 2022 Page 3 of 9
element of criminality to sustain the FIR in question. He further
submits that he was merely a GPA holder on behalf of the
landowners and the sale deed was executed by the landowners,
with the petitioner only being a confirming party. Therefore,
there is no reason to deprive the petitioner from similar
consideration.
8. Per contra , Respondent no. 2 submits that the High Court
has rightly distinguished the petitioner’s case from the
landowners. It is submitted that the petitioner was not merely a
confirming party, but a principal actor. To buttress, it is
submitted that the amounts were received by the petitioner
herself. It is further submitted that the sale deed dated 11.02.2016
was executed on the basis of material concealment of the pre-
existing agreement dated 19.11.2012 in favour of the respondent.
9. The State has also filed its objections against the prayer
sought in the present petition. The submissions of the State are
on similar lines and are not reproduced for brevity.
10. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and have
carefully gone through the record including the written
submissions.
11. The admitted position indicates that the agreement for sale
dated 19.11.2012 was supposed to be acted upon within 7 months
SLP (Criminal) No. 12638 of 2022 Page 4 of 9
of its execution. It is not denied that the same was not acted upon
within the stipulated time and even thereafter, till the execution
of sale deed on 11.02.2016. After the sale deed, respondent no. 2
woke up and instituted the suit for specific performance of the
agreement dated 19.11.2012. We consciously refrain from
expressing any observation regarding the merits of the said suit
or the elements of readiness and willingness. The same ought to
be adjudicated by the concerned civil court.
12. What is relevant for our consideration is that after the
institution of civil suit, respondent no. 2 also lodged an FIR for
the commission of offences mentioned above. While quashing
the said FIR qua the landowners in Crl. Petition No. 9095/2016,
the High Court observed thus:
“4…. Therefore, when the complainant has already
approached the civil court and in view of the long
delay in moving for getting the sale deed executed,
in my opinion, it is purely a civil transaction
between the parties which has been given a criminal
colour by the complainant (respondent herein) for
such type for proceedings, when the factual aspects
clearly disclose there is not even a tinge of criminal
attitude on the part of the petitioners.”
13. Evidently, the petitioner’s petition for quashing of the
same FIR was listed before a different bench. While denying
similar relief to the petitioner, the coordinate bench distinguished
SLP (Criminal) No. 12638 of 2022 Page 5 of 9
the petitioner’s case from that of the landowners by observing
that – the amounts were received by the petitioner; agreement
dated 19.11.2012 was signed by the petitioner as PoA holder;
petitioner was confirming party to the sale deed; land was sold at
a lesser value to the ultimate buyer; and existence of triable issue
whether the consideration received by the petitioner was
eventually transmitted to the landowners or not.
14. On a consideration of the distinguishing features noted in
the impugned judgment, we are of the clear view that the High
Court has fallen into error, and a grave one. The FIR alleges the
commission of offence by the landowners as well as the
petitioner. The allegation is based on the execution of sale deed,
and the sale deed was executed by the landowners themselves.
The petitioner was only a confirming party. If no criminality
could be attributed to the landowners by virtue of the execution
of sale deed, it cannot be sustained against the petitioner as well.
For, there is nothing to attribute any aggravated role to the
petitioner. The consideration was also received collectively by
the landowners and petitioner. Merely because it was physically
received by the petitioner on behalf of all of them, it does not
place him at a different pedestal. The agreement dated
19.11.2012 was, no doubt, executed by the petitioner only,
however, it was executed on behalf of the landowners and there
is no allegation that the petitioner executed the same in violation
SLP (Criminal) No. 12638 of 2022 Page 6 of 9
of the authority conferred upon him by the landowners or by
keeping them in the dark.
15. The fact that the property was eventually sold at a lesser
price should not have weighed with the High Court. It is purely a
speculative line of reasoning and cannot be treated as an
incriminating circumstance. Moreover, even if it is incriminating,
the same ought to have incriminated the landowners as well. For,
the property was sold by all the accused persons and not by the
petitioner alone. If the said fact has not weighed against the
landowners, it could not have been of any consequence against
the petitioner.
16. The High Court further erred in posing to itself a
hypothetical question i.e. whether the sale consideration was
transmitted by the petitioner to the landowners or not . The High
Court observed that it is a triable question, without regard to the
fact that the said question does not even fall within the ambit of
the allegations. The landowners have not raised any allegation
against the petitioner regarding misappropriation of sale
consideration meant for them. In order to distinguish the
petitioner’s case, the High Court has traversed beyond the scope
of the allegations.
17. Notably, the offence of cheating requires a deceptive act
which leads to inducement for delivery of property/money. Even
SLP (Criminal) No. 12638 of 2022 Page 7 of 9
on bare perusal of the allegations, it becomes clear that the
property (that is the amount transferred by respondent no. 2 at the
time of agreement for sale dated 19.11.2012) was not transferred
on the basis of any deception. At that time, the property could
have legitimately been transferred in favour of respondent no. 2
and there was no deception. The subsequent sale took place in
2016, almost 4 years after the alleged delivery of money by
respondent no. 2. Thus, the foundational ingredient of cheating is
missing. Section 423 IPC is also mis-invoked in the FIR. It
requires a false statement as to consideration in an instrument of
transfer. There is no such false statement in the agreement dated
19.11.2012 or in the sale deed. Even if there is any false averment
in the sale deed, it ought to have created a right in favour of the
ultimate buyer Mr. Gaffar Baig and not respondent no. 2 herein.
It is a classic case of casting the shadow of criminality on a pure
civil dispute.
18. In view of the above, we are of the considered opinion that
the FIR was rightly quashed by the High Court against the
landowners and there was absolutely no reason for the coordinate
bench to deprive the petitioner from the same relief. His
culpability could not have been stretched beyond that of the
landowners. The High Court, in the peculiar facts of the case,
ought to have adhered to the principle of judicial consistency and
propriety.
SLP (Criminal) No. 12638 of 2022 Page 8 of 9
19. Accordingly, the instant petition is allowed. The impugned
judgment dated 19.09.2022 passed by the High Court of
Karnataka in Criminal Petition No. 9470/2017 is set aside.
Consequently, the proceedings in FIR/Crime No. 121/2016 PS
Kadugodi, along with all consequential proceedings, stand
quashed.
20. The petition stands disposed of along with pending
application(s), if any.
....................................................................... J.
[SATISH CHANDRA SHARMA]
.......................................................................... J.
[NONGMEIKAPAM KOTISWAR SINGH]
NEW DELHI
October 05, 2026.
SLP (Criminal) No. 12638 of 2022 Page 9 of 9