Shankar Lal Patel vs State of U.P.

Court
Allahabad High Court

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
LUCKNOW
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. - 697 of 2012
Shankar Lal Patel
.....Appellant(s)
Versus
State of U.P.
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Surendra Singh, Manoj Kumar Singh,
Prabhakar Pandey, Pushkal Shukla
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Govt. Advocate
Court No. - 13
HON'BLE SUBHASH VIDYARTHI, J.
Amicus Curiae
1. Heard Sri Manoj Kumar Singh, appointed by the court
and Smt. Shikha Sinha, the learned AGA for the State.
2. By means of the instant appeal, the appellant has challenged the
validity of the judgment and order dated 26.08.2008 passed by Sri Ram
Adhar, the learned Additional Sessions Judge/Fast Track Court No. 2,
Court No. 8, Pratapgarh, in Sessions Trial No. 08 of 2008, arising out of
Case Crime No. 145 of 2007 under Section 304 IPC, Police Station
Manikpur, District Pratapgarh, whereby the appellant has been convicted
for the aforesaid offence and he has been sentenced to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for 10 years and to pay Rs. 2,500/- as fine.
3. The appellant was initially enlarged on bail by means of an order dated
13.03.2013. However, as his counsel was not appearing to advance
submissions in support of the appeal, a bailable warrant was issued
against him by means of an order dated 26.03.2026. The appellant
appeared before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Pratapgarh, and submitted
a personal bond and two sureties and gave an undertaking that he will
appear before this court on the date of hearing of the appeal, but thereafter
he did not appear before this court and, therefore, on 31.08.2026 this court
had passed an order issuing a non-bailable warrant against the appellant,
and in furtherance of the said order, the appellant is in custody since
06.09.2026.

CRLA No. 697 of 2012
2
4. Sri Prabhakar Pandey, the learned counsel for the appellant, had
advanced submissions in support of the appeal on 06.10.2026, whereafter
this court had passed the following order:
"Sri Prabhakar Pandey, the learned counsel for the appellant
has advanced his submissions but his submissions were
haphazard and he has not referred to the statement of a single
prosecution witness or a single document on the record of
learned trial court. This is not the way in which submissions
are to be advanced in an appeal against an order of conviction
and sentence.
In the interest of justice the Court appoints Sri Manoj Kumar
Singh, Advocate as Amicus Curiae to provide assistance in the
case to avoid miscarriage of justice.
List this appeal on 13.10.2026 showing name of Sri Manoj
Kumar Singh, Advocate as Amicus Curiae."
5. The aforesaid case was instituted on the basis of a written complaint
dated 11.08.2007 (Ext. A-1) given by the complainant Kamlesh Kumar
stating that his brother Suresh Kumar was a bosom friend of the appellant
Shankar Lal Patel and both of them used to drink liquor together. Both of
them were together since the morning of 11.08.2007. A quarrel had taken
place between them at about 8:00 PM due to some reason, due to which
the appellant assaulted the complainant's brother with a bamboo stick and
kicked on his testicles at about 9:00 PM due to which he died.
6. It was mentioned in the written complaint that the complainant
Kamlesh Kumar and his brother Awadhesh Kumar had reached the spot
and they had seen the appellant hiding the dead body of their brother in
the field of Jagannath Yadav. The bamboo stick had broken down in
several pieces. Upon seeing them, the appellant threw away the bamboo
stick and ran away. The complainant and his brother chased him for quite
some distance, but the appellant ran away taking benefit of the darkness.
7. On the basis of the aforesaid written complaint, an FIR bearing Case
Crime No. 145 of 2007 was lodged on 11.08.2007 at 4:30 AM. In-quest
proceedings were carried out in the agricultural field of Jagannath at 6:00

CRLA No. 697 of 2012
3
AM on 11.08.2007. It mentions that the dead body was lying in the field.
The complainant was one of the witnesses of the in-quest proceedings. It
records the opinion of the witnesses, including the complainant, that the
complainant's brother died because of injuries suffered in beating.
8. The post-mortem examination of the dead body was conducted at 4:30
PM on 11.08.2007. The report mentions the following injuries:
"Injury No. 1: A reddish-blue contused mark with abrasion,
measuring 2.5 x 1 cm, situated on the right side of the
forehead, 2 cm away from the root of the nose.
Injury No. 2: A reddish-blue contused mark with abrasion,
measuring 1 x 0.5 cm, situated in the midline of the forehead,
1.5 cm above the root of the nose.
Injury No. 3: A reddish-blue contused mark with abrasion,
measuring 2 cm x 1.5 cm, situated on the lower part of the
nose.
Injury No. 4: A cut wound (incised/lacerated wound),
measuring 1.5 cm x 0.3 cm x deep up to subcutaneous tissue
(slightly below the skin), situated on the upper left side of the
nose.
Injury No. 5: A reddish-blue bluish contused mark with
swelling, measuring 8 cm x 6 cm, situated around the left eye.
Injury No. 6: A reddish-blue bluish contused mark, measuring
7 cm x 1 cm, situated on the left side of the neck, upwards and
backwards.
Injury No. 7: A reddish-blue bluish contused mark, measuring
8 cm x 1 cm, situated on the left side of the neck, 5 cm below
Injury No. 6.
Injury No. 8: A reddish-blue bluish contused mark, measuring
7 cm x 1 cm, situated on the left side of the neck, 0.5 cm below
Injury No. 7.
Injury No. 9: A bluish-red bruise measuring 6 cm x 1 cm,
located on the left side of the neck, 0.5 cm below Injury No. 8.
Injury No. 10: An abrasion/scratch mark measuring 0.5 cm x
0.2 cm, located at the angle of the left jaw.
Injury No. 11: An abrasion mark measuring 0.5 cm x 0.2 cm,

CRLA No. 697 of 2012
4
located at the angle of the right jaw, 1 cm outward from Injury
No. 10.
Injury No. 12: An abrasion mark measuring 5 cm x 0.1 cm on
the right side of the neck, located 1.5 cm outward/away from
Injury No. 12.
Injury No. 13: An abrasion mark measuring 0.3 cm x 0.7 cm on
the right side of the neck, located 1.5 cm outward from Injury
No. 12.
Injury No. 14: A bluish-red bruise with abrasion measuring 5
cm x 2.5 cm, located on the right side of the neck at the inner
margin of the right clavicle.
Injury No. 15: A bluish-red bruise with abrasion measuring 1
cm x 0.5 cm, located on the upper anterior and inner aspect of
the left arm."
9. The report also mentions that the larynx, trachea, and bronchi were
congested; hyoid bone of left side was fractured; both lungs were
congested deeply; the right chamber of the heart was full and the left
chamber was empty, and in the opinion of the doctor, the death occurred
due to asphyxia as a result of antemortem strangulation.
10. The investigating officer submitted the charge sheet on 21.10.2007
against the appellant for the offence under Section 304 IPC, and the
complainant was examined by the trial court as PW-1. He stated that his
brother Suresh (the deceased) was a friend of the appellant Shankar Lal.
Both of them used to spend time together and drink liquor together. When
the deceased did not return home, the complainant went out at about 8:30
PM to look for him, along with his brother Awadhesh. They were
carrying a torch. When they reached the shop of Moti, Moti and Ramman
told that a quarrel had taken place between the deceased Suresh and the
appellant Shankar Lal at about 8:00 PM and they had removed them from
that place. Thereafter, the complainant and his brother went towards the
east. They heard the sound of beating. They saw in the light of a torch that
the appellant was beating their brother with a bamboo stick, and thereafter
he kicked him on the testicles and then he was dragging him towards the
south. Upon seeing them, the appellant threw away the bamboo stick and
ran away. They chased him, but the appellant escaped. He stated that the

CRLA No. 697 of 2012
5
deceased had gone out with the appellant in the morning. He had got the
complaint inscribed by Dashrath.
11. During cross-examination, PW-1 stated that Suresh (the deceased) had
gone out of his home at 7:00 AM on 10.08.2007 without eating anything.
He did not know as to where did he remain for the entire day or what did
he eat. Moti Lal and Ramman had told him about the quarrel that took
place at 8:00 PM between the appellant and the deceased. Moti Lal had
not gone with him for searching out Suresh. Strangely, PW-1 stated that
the dead body of his brother was being dragged towards east of the canal
while his brother was alive, and he stated that he remained on the spot of
the incident for 2-3 hours. Persons present in his home started crying after
2-3 hours when he reached home. He stated that he had gone home and
not to the police station. He did not take his brother to anywhere. PW-1
denied the suggestion that when he saw his brother, the latter was already
dead. He stated that the police station is at a distance of 3 kilometers from
his home. He had started for the police station alone on a bicycle at 3.30
a.m. and had reached the police station at 4:00 AM. He had stayed at the
police station for about 2 hours.
12. Except for PW-1 and his brother, no person had gone to search for the
deceased. He stated that the deceased used to consume liquor since long.
There was no animosity between the appellant and the deceased. He did
not see his brother drinking liquor on the date of the incident. PW-1
denied the suggestion that his brother fell down in an inebriated condition,
suffered injuries and died.
13. Awadhesh Kumar, brother of the complainant and the deceased, was
examined as PW-2, and during examination-in-chief, he gave a statement
similar to the statement given by P.W.1. During cross-examination, PW-2
stated that he met Dashrath (the scribe of the FIR) at 6:00 AM. He stated
that he was not present when Dashrath Lal was inscribing the FIR. He
stated that his deceased brother had not consumed liquor in his presence
on the date of incident and he was not found drinking liquor. He also
stated that Motilal and Ramman had told about a quarrel between the
appellant and the deceased. PW2 stated that he did not know whether his
brother had gone out on the date of the incident after eating something,

CRLA No. 697 of 2012
6
but thereafter he stated that he knew that he had gone out after having his
meal.
14. The doctor who had conducted the post-mortem examination of the
dead body, was examined as PW3. He proved the post-mortem
examination report and the 15 injuries mentioned in it. He also stated that
the deceased would have died about one and a half day prior to
conducting the post-mortem.
15. During cross-examination, PW3 stated that the antemortem injuries
could have been caused in the night of 09/10.08.2007.
16. The investigating officer was examined as PW4, and he proved the
prosecution material. Nothing significant came out in his examination-in-
chief or in cross-examination.
17. The trial court held that the aforesaid prosecution evidence established
beyond reasonable doubt that the testimony of PW1 and PW2 established
that they had seen the incident. The trial court held that non-examination
of Motilal and Ramman, who had merely seen a quarrel between the
appellant and the deceased and who had not seen the incident itself,
would not be detrimental to the prosecution case.
18. Assailing the validity of the impugned order of conviction and
sentence, Shri Manoj Kumar Singh, learned Amicus Curiae has submitted
that as per the complaint, the appellant was a friend of the deceased. PW1
has categorically stated that there was no animosity amongst them. The
prosecution case is that a quarrel had taken place between the appellant
and the deceased at about 08:00 PM and for this reason, the appellant hit
the deceased with a bamboo stick and thereby caused his death.
Therefore, the motive for causing the injuries is the quarrel that took place
between the appellant and the deceased at about 08:00 PM. This quarrel
was allegedly witnessed by Motilal and Ramman and they have not been
produced as prosecution witnesses.
19. The second submission of the learned Amicus Curiae is that the only
witnesses of fact are the complainant (PW1) and his brother (PW2), and
no independent witness has been examined.

CRLA No. 697 of 2012
7
20. Although it is true that a conviction can be based on the basis of
testimony of eye-witnesses, who happen to be brothers of the deceased,
their statements have to be scrutinized carefully to examine whether the
same prove the allegations beyond any reasonable doubt. The statements
of PW1 and PW2 are to the effect that they had seen the appellant beating
the deceased. They gave self-contradictory statements that the appellant
was dragging away the dead body of their brother, while they stated at the
same time that their brother was alive at that time.
21. Although PW1 stated that his brother was alive when they had seen
him, he also stated that he remained on the spot for about 2-3 hours and
he did not take his brother for getting him treated. He also did not go to
his house to inform others about the incident and he claims to have gone
to his house 2-3 hours after the incident. This conduct of PW1 is highly
unnatural and doubtful.
22. PW1 and PW2 both have categorically stated that they had seen the
appellant kicking on the testicles of the deceased, whereas the post-
mortem report does not mention any injury on the testicles of the dead
body. The post-mortem examination report mentions that the left hyoid
bone was fractured and the cause of death was strangulation, and although
PW1 and PW2, both of whom are brothers of the deceased and both of
whom claim to have witnessed the incident, none of them stated that they
had seen the appellant strangulating the deceased. These discrepancies
give rise to a reasonable doubt against the claim of PW1 and PW2 that
they had actually witnessed the incident. The incident allegedly took
place at about 09:00 PM. The two brothers of the deceased allegedly
witnessed the incident. The police station was at a distance of merely 3
kilometers. Besides not taking their injured brother to the doctor or to
their home, it is also strange that they did not go to the police station
promptly. The explanation that they did not go to the police station
because it was dark, would also not be available in the present case,
because PW1 claims to have gone to the police station at 03:30 AM and
reached there at 04:00 AM, which too were hours of darkness. This
conduct of the complainant is also unnatural and it gives rise to a doubt
against the correctness of his testimony.

CRLA No. 697 of 2012
8
23. As per PW1 and PW2, the incident took place at 09:00 PM on
10.08.2007. The post-mortem examination was conducted at 04:30 PM on
11.08.2007. The doctor assessed the time of death to be about 1 and 1/2
days ago, that is, about 36 hours ago. From the assessment of the doctor,
the injuries would have been caused at about 04:30 AM on 10.08.2007.
There would be an error margin of 6 hours on the either side and,
therefore, during cross-examination the doctor stated that the injuries
could have been caused in the night of 09/10.08.2007. The 6 hours margin
on the other side would take the time of injuries to about 10:30 AM on
10.08.2007. However, as per the prosecution case, the injuries were
caused at about 09:00 PM on 10.08.2007. This discrepancy in the time of
the incident as per the complaint and the statement of PW1 and PW2 and
as per the post-mortem examination report and the statement of PW3 also
gives rise to a reasonable doubt against the correctness of the testimonies
of PW1 and PW2. The trial court has convicted and sentenced the
appellant without taking into consideration the aforesaid aspects of the
matter, which vitiates the judgment and order.
24. In view of the foregoing discussion, I am of the considered view that
there is a serious doubt against the correctness of the statements of PW1
and PW2 that they had seen the appellant beating their brother due to
which he died. The prosecution has failed to establish the allegations
beyond reasonable doubt, hence, the appellant is entitled to be acquitted,
giving them benefit of doubt.
25. Accordingly, the appeal is allowed . The impugned judgment and
order dated 26.08.2008 passed by the learned Additional Sessions
Judge/Fast Track Court No. 2, Court No. 8, Pratapgarh, in Sessions Trial
No. 08 of 2008, arising out of Case Crime No. 145 of 2007 under Section
304 IPC, Police Station Manikpur, District Pratapgarh, is hereby set aside
. The appellant is acquitted of the charges, giving him the benefit of
doubt.
26. The amount of fine deposited by the appellant be refunded to him.
27. The appellant is directed to be released from custody upon his
furnishing a personal bond and two sureties as per the provision contained

CRLA No. 697 of 2012
9
under Section 437 A, Cr.P.C., for his appearance before the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in case an appeal is filed against this order and the
Hon'ble Supreme Court issues notices to him.
28. The Court puts on record its appreciation for the valuable assistance
provided by the amicus curiae Sri Manoj Kumar Singh in deciding this
appeal.
29. The learned A.G.A. is directed to communicate this judgment to the
jail authority for ensuring its compliance.
( Subhash Vidyarthi,J. )
November 17, 2026
A.Nigam
Whether the judgment is speaking: Yes.
Whether the judgment is reportable: No.
.
( Subhash Vidyarthi, J. )
Digitally signed by :-
ANUJ NIGAM
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad,
Lucknow Bench