SURESHA vs S SATHISHA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57277
WP No. 28492 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010623962026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K. V. ARAVIND
WRIT PETITION NO. 28492 OF 2026 (GM-CPC)
BETWEEN:
1. SURESHA
S/O SOMEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS,
R/AT DODDAMANE,
AGRICULTURAL FARM,
KAGGALIKAVAL, NAMBIHALLI VILLAGE,
DANDIGANAHALLI HOBLI,
CHANNARAYAPATNA TALUK 573116
(SENIOR CITIZEN BENEFITS NOT CLAIMED)
…PETITIONER
Digitally
signed by
VIJAYA P
Location:
High Court
of Karnataka
(BY SRI. K V NARASIMHAN, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. S SATHISHA
S/O SOMEGOWDA, MAJOR,
R/AT DODDAMANE,
AGRICULTURAL FARM,
KAGGALIKAVAL, NAMBIHALLI VILLAGE,
DANDIGANAHALLI HOBLI,
CHANNARAYAPATNA TALUK 573116
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57277
WP No. 28492 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010623962026
2. SMT. RADHA,
W/O NARASIMHA, D/O C. SOMEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 78 YEARS
R/AT DODDAMANE,
AGRICULTURAL FARM,
KAGGALIKAVAL, NAMBIHALLI VILLAGE,
DANDIGANAHALLI HOBLI,
CHANNARAYAPATNA TALUK 573116
C SOMEGOWDA, SINCE DEAD BY LRS,
DAYAMANI S, D/O LATE C. SOMEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 77 YEARS,
R/AT DOOR NO. 1290, MRHB COLONY,
VIJAYANAGARA MAGADI CHORD ROAD,
BENGALURU- 560040
4. ASHA S,
W/O MURTHY, D/O LATE C. SOMEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS,
R/AT DOOR NO.1290, MRHB COLONY,
VIJAYANAGARA MAGADI CHORD ROAD,
BENGALURU-560040
5. NEENA S,
W/O ANIL, D/O LATE C. SOMEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS,
R/AT DOOR NO.1290, MRHB COLONY,
VIJAYANAGARA MAGADI CHORD ROAD,
BENGALURU- 560040
6. SMT. LAKSHMAMMA,
S/O LATE G. R. RAMEGOWDA,
AGED 70 YEARS,
3.
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57277
WP No. 28492 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010623962026
R/AT GAGARA VILLAGE,
KUNDURU HOBLI,
KUNDUR POST, ALLOOR,
HASSAN TALUK-573218
7. SRI. JAMBUNATH,
S/O RAMABHADREGOWDA
AGED 58 YEARS,
8. SRI. B. S. PARMESH
S/O SHIVEGOWDA
AGED 62 YEARS,
9. SRI. A. B. CHENNABASAPPA,
S/O BASAVEGOWDA
AGED 61 YEARS,
10. SRI. A. B. NEELAKANTA,
S/O BASAVEGOWDA
11. SRI. JAYASHANKARA,
S/O RAMABHADREGOWDA
AGED 49 YEARS,
RESPONDENT NO.7 TO 11
ARE MAJORS. THEY ARE
R/AT AMALEPURA, KUNDUR HOBLI,
KUNDUR POST, ALUR TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT-573201.
12. SRI. MAJAPPAGOWDA,
S/O H.V. VEERESHA,
AGED 60 YEARS,
R/AT HIRIVATE GRAMA, BIKODU HOBLI,
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57277
WP No. 28492 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010623962026
BELUR TALUK, HASSAN DISTRICT 573215
13. SRI. RAJASHEKAR,
S/O SHIVAPPAGOWDA,
AGED 53 YEARS,
BIKODU VILLAGE AND HOBLI,
BELUR TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT 573215
14. SMT. BINDUMATHI,
W/O LATE JAMBUNATH,
AGED ABOUT 71 YEARS,
R/AT AMALEPURA VILLAGE,
KUNDURU HOBLI,
ALURU TALUK,
HASSAN DISTRICT 573201
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ALLAH BAKASH, ADVOCATE FOR R-2,
SRI. C S PRASANNA KUMAR, ADVOCATE FOR C/R-5)
THIS W.P. IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASHING THE ORDER
PASSED IN OS NO. 189/2002 C/W OS NO. 57/2013 BY THE
LEARNED ADDL. SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC AT
CHANNARAYAPATNA, HASSAN DATED 29.08.2026 AT ANNX-P
ON IA NO. NIL AT ANNX-L AND M.
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY
HEARING, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57277
WP No. 28492 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010623962026
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K. V. ARAVIND
ORAL ORDER
The present petition is filed impugning the order dated
29.08.2026 passed in the clubbed suits in O.S. Nos. 189/2002
and 57/2013, whereby the prayer to recall the evidence of
defendant No. 3 in O.S. No. 57/2013 and permission for cross-
examination was rejected.
2. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that
O.S. No.189/2002 was instituted seeking declaratory relief.
Subsequently, one of the defendants instituted O.S.
No.57/2013, arraying the petitioner as defendant No.3. It is
submitted that both the suits were clubbed after the evidence
of the petitioner in O.S. No.189/2002 had been closed. In view
of the written statement and counter claim filed in O.S.
No.57/2013, the petitioner is required to be permitted to lead
further evidence.
2.1 It is further submitted that, though the petitioner filed an
application seeking permission to adduce separate evidence in
the clubbed suits, the said application came to be rejected, and
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57277
WP No. 28492 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010623962026
the rejection was subsequently affirmed by this Court in W.P.
No.2644/2022 dated 08.06.2026. Learned counsel submits that
permitting the petitioner to lead further evidence in
O.S. No.189/2002 is necessary to establish the defects in
O.S. No.57/2013 and to substantiate the counterclaim.
2.2 It is submitted that, though the applications impugned
herein were filed by the plaintiff in O.S. No.189/2002, reference
was made therein to affording defendant No.3 an opportunity
to lead evidence, which, in effect, was the evidence of the
plaintiff in O.S. No.189/2002. Learned counsel further submits
that any misunderstanding of the procedure or the permissible
course of action by the counsel representing the parties ought
not to result in depriving the petitioner of the right to establish
the defence.
Per contra
3. , learned counsel appearing for caveator-
respondent No.5 submits that, after the suits were clubbed and
the petitioner herein filed the written statement in O.S.
No.57/2013, the petitioner was afforded an opportunity to lead
evidence. However, the petitioner expressly declined to avail
the said opportunity. Instead, the petitioner unsuccessfully
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57277
WP No. 28492 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010623962026
pursued the request for recording separate evidence before this
Court in W.P. No.2644/2022. It is submitted that entertaining
the present applications would be contrary to the judgment of
this Court in W.P. No.2644/2022. Learned counsel further
submits that, once this Court has held that recording separate
evidence is impermissible, entertaining the present applications
would indirectly grant the very relief that was denied by this
Court.
3.1 Learned counsel, inviting the attention of this Court to the
order sheet in the clubbed suits, submits that the petitioner
was afforded more than two opportunities to lead evidence.
However, the petitioner declined to avail those opportunities by
filing a memo. It is submitted that, at this stage, after a lapse
of more than one and a half years, granting a further
opportunity to the petitioner would enable the petitioner to
delay the proceedings in the suits.
4. Learned counsel appearing for respondent No.2 reiterates
the submissions made by learned counsel appearing for
respondent No.5 and supports the same.
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57277
WP No. 28492 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010623962026
5. Considered the submissions made by learned counsel for
the parties and perused the material on record.
6. O.S. No.189/2002 was instituted by the petitioner herein
seeking a declaration and permanent injunction. Defendant
No.3(c) in O.S. No.189/2002 subsequently instituted O.S.
No.57/2013 seeking partition and separate possession.
6.1 The suit schedule properties in the two suits are not
identical. While the suit schedule property in O.S. No.189/2002
comprises only 8 items, the suit schedule in O.S. No.57/2013
comprises 15 items.
6.2 The list of dates furnished to this Court is not in dispute.
As on the date of clubbing of the two suits in 2021, the
petitioner had completed adducing evidence in O.S.
No.189/2002. The petitioner filed the written statement in O.S.
No.57/2013.
6.3 In view of the clubbing of the suits and the subsequent
filing of the written statements and counterclaim, the Trial
Court, by its proceedings dated 07.04.2025, directed the
petitioner herein to lead further evidence. However, the
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57277
WP No. 28492 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010623962026
petitioner filed a memo stating that evidence has already been
adduced, and reserve his right to adduce rebuttal evidence
after closure of defendants' evidence. In the meanwhile, the
petitioner also filed an application seeking permission to adduce
separate evidence, which came to be rejected by the Trial
Court. The said order was the subject matter of W.P.
No.2644/2022 before this Court.
6.4 It is also evident that, despite the Trial Court having
afforded the petitioner an opportunity to lead further evidence
in relation to the written statement in O.S. No.57/2013 and the
counterclaim in O.S. No.189/2002, the petitioner declined to
avail the said opportunity.
6.5 The submission of learned counsel for respondent No.5
that the applications have been filed with the intention of
delaying the proceedings cannot be readily rejected,
particularly having regard to the manner in which the
applications, which are the subject matter of the impugned
order, have been filed. Though the applications are stated to
have been filed by the plaintiff in O.S. No.189/2002, the prayer
therein is to reopen the evidence and permit defendant No.3 to
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57277
WP No. 28492 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010623962026
adduce evidence. The affidavits accompanying the applications
are also to the same effect. Similar averments are made in all
the applications that are the subject matter of the impugned
order.
6.6 If the said applications are entertained at this stage, it
would be contrary to the judgment of this Court in W.P.
No.2644/2022. While deciding the challenge to the order
rejecting the request for recording separate evidence, this
Court observed that the petitioner would be entitled to urge
contentions regarding the self-acquisition of the properties in
view of the written statement filed in O.S. No.57/2013. Similar
observations were also made by the Trial Court in its order
dated 03.06.2025.
6.7 A memo has now been filed seeking permission to
withdraw the said applications, with liberty to file an application
seeking reopening of the plaintiff’s evidence in O.S.
No.189/2002. In view of the observations made by the Trial
Court and this Court in W.P. No.2644/2022, the petitioner was
already permitted to urge the aforesaid contentions. However,
the impugned applications, filed subsequent to the observations
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57277
WP No. 28492 of 2026
CNR: KAHC010623962026
made by the Trial Court and this Court, are not in conformity
with the said observations. Rather, they appear to be an
attempt to re-agitate the claim that was already rejected.
6.8 In view of the above, this Court finds no justification or
bona fides in permitting the petitioner to withdraw the
applications that are the subject matter of the impugned orders
and thereby granting a further opportunity. Accordingly, this
Court finds no error or infirmity warranting interference in the
dismissed
present petition. Hence, the petition is .
SD/-
(K. V. ARAVIND)
JUDGE
DDU
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 15