Amrik Singh And Ors. vs State Of Pb. And Ors.

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M) 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
th
Reserved on 27 of August, 2026
th
Pronounced on 17 of November, 2026
th
Uploaded on 17 of November, 2026
Whether only operative part of the judgment is pronounced? No
Whether full judgment is pronounced? Yes
CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M)
Amrik Singh and others ....Petitioners
Versus
State of Punjab and others .....Respondents
CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PANKAJ JAIN
Present : Mr. R.M. Sharma, Advocate for the petitioners.
Mr. H.P.S. Ishar, Addl. A.G., Punjab.
Mr. P.C. Choudhary, Advocate
for the respondents No.4 to 7.
Mr. Tarunveer Vashist, Advocate and
Mr. Shoryaveer Vashist, Advocate
for the applicant/proposed respondent No.8.
Mr. K.K. Saini, Advocate
for the applicant/proposed respondent No.9
PANKAJ JAIN, J.
The present writ petition filed under Section 226/227 of the
Constitution of India, is directed against sanction of mutation qua the land
belonging to Dera Sadhan Baba Bihari Gir (hereinafter referred to as ‘Dera’)
in favour of State with a further prayer seeking a writ in the nature of
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M) 2
mandamus directing respondents No.1 to 3 not to auction the land of Dera
on lease and not to interfere in the possession of the Dera over the land in
dispute in any manner.
2. Dera Sadhan Baba Bihari Gir founded by Baba Bihari Gir, who
had a considerable following in the area during his lifetime. is considered as
one of the revered places in Tehsil Sunam. Dera owns land including 414
Kanal 7 Marlas. The produce and income from the land was being utilized
for organizing meals for poor persons and maintaining Dera.
2.1 After Jagdish Gir, his Chela Bharpur Gir was appointed as
Mohtamim. Admittedly, Bharpur Gir proved to be a man of vices and could
not maintain the dignity of Dera. He left Dera and subsequently died at his
native place. For management of the Dera, a Committee comprising of all
the Lambardars of village including petitioner No.1 and Sarpanch, was
constituted on 11.12.1975. Vide resolution (Annexure P-1), on 10.03.1994
Gram Sabha under the presidentship of Sukhdev Singh Sarpanch
unanimously decided to transfer the ownership of the land, in question, in
favour of Punjab Government.
2.2. On the basis thereof, mutation (Annexure P-2) was sanctioned
on 16.03.1994. The order, Annexure P-2, was passed by Assistant Collector
nd
2 Grade on 21.03.1994
2.3. The petitioners, who claim to be the devotees of Dera, have
challenged the resolution and the consequential mutation of land in favour of
State Government raising objection against the competence of the Managing
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M) 3
Committee to transfer the property of the religious institution and the right
of the Government to acquire ownership without payment of compensation.
3. Counsel for the petitioners has reiterated the grounds raised in
the writ petition contending that neither the Managing Committee has any
right to alienate/transfer the property owned by the Dera, nor the
Government has any right to usurp ownership thereof without paying any
compensation. He further submits that even the Polytechnic College, on the
pretext of which the land was sought to be acquired, has already been
constructed at some other village and not in the village where Dera is
located. He thus submits that the resolution passed by the Committee and
the consequent mutation being illegal, cannot be sustained.
4. Counsel for respondents No.1 to 3 questions the locus of the
petitioners. Mr. Ishar while relying upon the ratio of law laid down by
Supreme Court in the case of ' Sital Das vs. Sant Ram and others', 1954
AIR Supreme Court 606 contends that it is only the Mahant appointed by a
Bheikh, who can invoke the writ jurisdiction of this Court against alienation
of the suit property owned by Dera. There being no Mahant appointed by
Bheikh, the Committee constituted has full authority to take decision w.r.t.
property owned by Dera. He submits that the petitioners are estopped from
their own conduct and acquiescence from assailing the mutation. Mutation
was sanctioned on the basis of unanimous resolution dated 10.03.1994 and
the order was passed in presence of General Body of the village. He further
submits that the mutation entries in the revenue records are made solely for
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M) 4
fiscal purposes. They neither create nor extinguish any title. He relies upon
ratio of law laid down in the case of ‘ Jitendra Singh vs. State of Madhya
Pradesh’, 2021 SCC OnLine SC 802 .
4.1. Lastly, Mr. Ishar submits that the dispute involves disputed
questions of fact. Rival claim regarding Mohtamimship of the Dera cannot
be adjudicated upon in the writ jurisdiction without evaluating evidence.
5. I have heard counsel for the parties and have carefully gone
through records of the case.
6. Apart from this writ petition, Regular Second Appeal No.5343
of 2015 is also tagged, which primarily relates to rival claims of the alleged
Mohtamims, who claimed to have been appointed by Bheikh.
7. It appears from the record of the RSA that a Civil Suit No.464
of 16.08.1996 was instituted by one Raj Gir claiming himself to be Chela of
Jagdish Gir. In the said civil suit, he claimed to have been appointed as
Mohtamim by Bheikh after Bharpur Gir who expired on 12.08.1982 without
leaving behind any Chela. He submits that he being other Chela of Jagdish
Gir the erstwhile Mohtamim of the Dera, was appointed as per rituals of the
Bheikh in the gathering of Saints. In the said Civil Suit challenge has also
been raised w.r.t. illegal interference of the Panchayat with the Dera land.
Civil Suit was tried on following issues :
“1. Whether the plaintiff is Mohtmim of Dera Sadhan Bihari
Gir, Khandebad? OPP.
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M) 5
2. Whether the mutation no.2801 and the order of Assistant
st
Collector 1 Grade, Moonak dated 3.5.90 are illegal null
and void? OPP.
3. Whether the plaintiff is in possession of the suit property
being Mohtmim? OPP.
4. Whether the plaintiff has no locus-standi to institute the
suit? OPD.
5. Whether the suit is not maintainable in the present form?
OPD.
6. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder and mis-joinder of
necessary parties? OPD.
7. Relief.”
8. No finding was recorded by the Civil Court on Issues No.2 and
3 giving reference to the present writ petition. Deciding Issue No.1, the
Court of the First Instance decreed the suit filed by plaintiff vide judgment
and decree dated 15.10.2003.
9. The judgment was assailed by defendant No.1 namely Bagga
Singh @ Puran Gir in Civil Appeal No.53 of 08.07.2015. The appeal was
accepted by the Lower Appellate Court vide judgment and decree dated
08.07.2015.
10. The same has been challenged before this Court in RSA
No.5343 of 2015.
11. This Court while admitting the appeal vide order dated
09.12.2015 observed as under:
“The second appeal is admitted on the following substantial
questions of law for consideration:-
(i) Whether the lower Appellate Court was not in error in
finding against the maintainability of the suit as one
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M) 6
instituted without inference to Section 92 CPC, failing to
note that Section 92 CPC is not the sole repository for
rights to religious office but confined only to the specific
reliefs provided under the said Section?
(ii) Whether the right of declaration to religious office is
not a matter of civil nature that could be adjudicated by an
ordinary civil suit by resort to Section 9 CPC if there was
no other statutory bar or condition to secure such an
adjudication in any other forum?
The appellant says that the revenue entries in respect of the
property of the Dera record the plaintiff as Mohatamin as person in
management of the properties of the Dera. There shall be an
interim restraint against the respondents from in any manner
interfering with the appellant's possession during the pendency of
suit. The respondents will be at liberty to approach this Court for
any modification of this order.”
12. The order dated 09.12.2015 was later on modified vide order
date 01.12.2016, observing as under:
“This application has been moved by respondent No.1 for
vacation of the injunction order dated December 9, 2015. Learned
counsel for the appellant stated that with respect to the same suit
property, a division bench of this Court in CWP No.7980-1994 has
already ordered to maintain status quo with respect to possession.
This fact has not been disputed at bar by learned counsel for the
applicant-respondent No.1.
Learned counsel for both the parties have stated that the
injunction order dated December 9, 2015 may be modified and
parties may be ordered to maintain status quo with respect to the
possession as ordered by the division bench of this Court in CWP
No.7980-1994.
So, the present application is hereby disposed of with the
modification of the injunction order dated December 9, 2015, in
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M) 7
terms of the order passed by the division bench of this Court in
CWP No.7980-1994.
Application stands disposed of.”
13. It further seems that another lis travelled to this Court in RSA
No.2702 of 2014 which was filed by Abad Gir, another person, claiming to
be Mohtamim of the Dera in question. The same was decided vide order
dated 01.12.2016. The matter was remanded back to the First Appellate
Court to decide the appeal along with the application for additional
evidence. As per counsel for the parties, the said appeal was dismissed for
non-prosecution vide order dated 29.09.2017.
14. On the basis of the aforesaid civil litigation, few applications
had been filed by the persons who claimed to have been appointed as
Mohtamim of the Dera.
15. Be that as it may, for adjudication of the writ petition in
question, this court finds that it is not necessary to go into the issue of
Mohtamimship of the Dera, which is pending consideration before the Civil
Courts. The issues that require adjudication at the hands of this Court, in the
present writ petition, are:
(i) Whether the interim committee formed to manage the
Dera or Gram Panchayat had the competence to transfer
the land owned by Dera in favour of the Government by
passing impugned resolution?
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M) 8
(ii) Whether the Revenue Authorities could mutate the land in
favour of the Government on the basis of such
resolution?
16. Concededly, the land is owned by Dera. In 'History of
Dharamasastra' by Dr. P.V. Kane, Volume II Part II while dealing with
administration of temple property, it has been opined as under:
“In modern times courts in India have laid down that an idol is a
juridical person capable of holding property, though from the very
nature of the case the possession and management of the property
rests with a manager or a trustee. A matha is in the same position
as an idol.”
17. Privy Council in the case of 'Prosunno Kumari Debya and
another vs. Golab Chand Baboo', (1875) 2 IndApp 145 while dealing
with the powers of a committee managing property of a religious institute,
observed as under:
“ xxx xxx xxx
But it is to be observed that this Committee, whilst
considering that the grant of such a pottah by a sebait would be
prima facie a broach of trust, expressed an opinion that if the grant
had been affirmed by a judgment, the succeeding sebaits would
have been bound by it; probably for the reason that after a
judgment it must be assumed either that such, a pottah was
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M) 9
warranted by the terms of the original endowment, or by usage, or
was in some way beneficial to the interests of the trust. It is said:
"If the decrees appealed against stood unreversed, the title
to hold at a fixed invariable rent would, on the pleadings,
and especially on the judgments, be viewed as res judicata,
binding on the parties, and those claiming under them."
But, notwithstanding that property devoted to religious purposes is,
as a rule, inalienable, it is, in their Lordships' opinion, competent
for the sebait of property dedicated to the worship of an idol, in the
capacity as sebait and manager of the estate, to incur debts and
borrow money for the proper expenses of keeping up the religious
worship, repairing the temples or other possessions of the idol,
defending hostile litigious attacks, and other like objects. The
power, however, to incur such debts must be measured by the
existing necessity for incurring them. The authority of the sebait of
an idol's estate would appear to be in this respect analogous to that
of the manager for an infant heir, which was thus defined in a
judgment of this Committee, delivered by Lord Justice Knight
Bruce:
"The power of the manager for an infant heir to charge an
estate not his own is, under the Hindu law, a limited and
qualified power. It can only be exercised rightly in a case of
need or for the benefit of the estate. But where, in the
particular instance, the charge is one that a prudent owner
would make in order to benefit the estate, the bona fide
lender is not affected by the precedent mismanagement of
the estate. The actual pressure on the estate, the danger to
be averted, or the benefit to be conferred upon it, in the
particular instance, is the thing to be regarded.
xxx xxx xxx”
(Emphasis supplied)
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M) 10
18. The same sentiment was echoed by a Division Bench of this
Court in 'State of Punjab and others vs. Mahant Jatinder Dass Chela
Mahant Narotam Dass, Mahant, Mandir Dun, Patiala', 2015(3) R.C.R.
(Civil) 476 holding that a Manager has no authority or power to alienate the
property of a religious institution in any manner whatsoever and such
property vests exclusively in the religious institution only.
19. In view of above, this Court finds that the Managing Committee
formed in the absence of Mohtamim after Bharpur Gir was removed, only
had a right to manage the Dera having stepped into the shoes of Mohtamim.
The Committee had no right to exercise any power not vested with
Mohtamim. Thus, Issue No.1 culled herein-above is answered in favour of
the petitioners.
20. The issue raised by Mr. Ishar w.r.t. locus of the petitioners is
misconceived. Admittedly, the Dera had no Mohtamim. In these
circumstances, the worshipers of the Dera have right to maintain the present
writ petition.
21. So far as reliance placed by Mr. Ishar on ratio of law laid down
in Sital Das's case (supra) is concerned, the same is also result of misreading
of the judgment. The judgment deals with the mode and manner in which
the matters of succession to Mahantship in the Bairagi institutions operate.
In the present case also, there is no dispute to the fact that the Mahant has to
be appointed by Bheikh (Congregation of Saints). However, this Court does
not wish to go into the said question lest it may prejudice rights of person
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M) 11
raising rival claims over Mahantship of Dera as the same is pending before
the Civil Court.
22. Likewise, the reliance placed upon Jitendra Singh's case is also
misconceived. In the present case, the challenge is not only to the mutation
but also to the resolution, on the basis of which mutation has been passed in
favour of State of Punjab divesting Dera of its property.
23. Article 31A of the Constitution of India reads as under:
“ 31A. Saving of laws providing for acquisition of
estates, etc. —[(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in
article 13, no law providing for—
(a) the acquisition by the State of any estate or of
any rights therein or the extinguishment or modification of
any such rights; or
(b) the taking over of the management of any
property by the State for a limited period either in the
public interest or in order to secure the proper management
of the property; or
(c) the amalgamation of two or more corporations
either in the public interest or in order to secure the proper
management of any of the corporations; or
(d) the extinguishment or modification of any rights
of managing agents, secretaries and treasurers, managing
directors, directors or managers of corporations, or of any
voting rights of shareholders thereof; or
(e) the extinguishment or modification of any rights
accruing by virtue of any agreement, lease or licence for
the purpose of searching for, or winning, any mineral or
mineral oil, or the premature termination or cancellation of
any such agreement, lease or licence,
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M) 12
shall be deemed to be void on the ground that it is inconsistent
with, or takes away or abridges any of the rights conferred by
[article 14 or article 19]:
Provided that where such law is a law made by the
Legislature of a State, the provisions of this article shall not apply
thereto unless such law, having been reserved for the consideration
of the President, has received his assent:]
[Provided further that where any law makes any provision
for the acquisition by the State of any estate and where any land
comprised therein is held by a person under his personal
cultivation, it shall not be lawful for the State to acquire any
portion of such land as is within the ceiling limit applicable to him
under any law for the time being in force or any building or
structure standing thereon or appurtenant thereto, unless the law
relating to the acquisition of such land, building or structure,
provides for payment of compensation at a rate which shall not be
less than the market value thereof.]
(2) In this article,—
[(a) the expression “estate” shall, in relation to any
local area, have the same meaning as that expression or its
local equivalent has in the existing law relating to land
tenures in force in that area and shall also include—
(i) any jagir, inam or muafi or other similar grant
and in the States of [Tamil Nadu] and Kerala, any janmam
right;
(ii) any land held under ryotwari settlement;
(iii) any land held or let for purposes of agriculture
or for purposes ancillary thereto, including waste land,
forest land, land for pasture or sites of buildings and other
structures occupied by cultivators of land, agricultural
labourers and village artisans;
(b) the expression “rights”, in relation to an estate,
shall include any rights vesting in a proprietor, sub-
proprietor, under-proprietor, tenureholder, [raiyat, under-
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M) 13
raiyat] or other intermediary and any rights or privileges in
respect of land revenue.]
24. Gazing at the facts of the present case through the prism of
Article 31A, this Court finds that the State cannot claim any right over the
property in the absence of there being any acquisition by the State and
without paying compensation to Dera. That apart, as per law mere
resolution passed by the Managing Committee cannot amount to transfer of
immovable property vested in Dera. It either can be done by way of
registered contract of transfer as contemplated in the Transfer of Property
Act, 1882 or by way of acquisition as per law. Reference can be made to
ratio of law laid down in K.T. Plantation Pvt. Ltd. & another vs. State of
Karnatka, (2011) 9 SCC 1 Suraj Lamp and Industries (P) Ltd. Thru.
DIR vs. State of Haryana and Anr., (2009) 7 SCC 363
25. State has a duty to protect property vested in religious institutes
from being misappropriated but has no right to usurp the same on the pretext
of proper utilization. Property vested in religious institutes is to take care of
needs of deity or Dera as the case may be. It is for Dera or deity through
Mahant or Manager to decide what the need is. Objective howsoever
charitable it may appear, cannot be said to be need of Dera/deity till Dera
opines so.
26. Thus, the resolution passed by the Managing Committee and the
consequential mutation deserve to be quashed being unsustainable in law.
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

CWP No.7980 of 1994 (O&M) 14
27. Consequently, the present writ petition is allowed .
28. Pending application, if any, shall also stand disposed off.
November 17, 2026 (Pankaj Jain)
Dpr Judge
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes
Whether reportable : Yes
DEEPAK KUMAR
2026.11.17 17:07
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document