Registered Partnership Firm M/S Sunder Singh Sher Singh Commission Agents vs Jasmer Singh And Anr.
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
I. RSA-2059-2022 (O&M)
M/S SUNDER SINGH SHER SINGH COMMISSION AGENTS
. . . . Appellant
Vs.
RAM PARSHAD
. . . . Respondent
II. RSA-2061-2022 (O&M)
M/S SUNDER SINGH SHER SINGH COMMISSION AGENTS
. . . . Appellant
Vs.
JASMER SINGH AND ANOTHER
. . . . Respondents
Reserved on: 16.11.2026
Pronounced on:17.11.2026
Pronounced Fully/Operative Part: Fully
CORAM: HON’BLE MR JUSTICE DEEPAK GUPTA
Present: - Mr.Abhinav Sood, Advocate, for
Mr.Vikram Singh, Advocate, for the appellant.
DEEPAK GUPTA, J.
By this common judgment, the aforesaid two regular second appeals,
filed by M/s Sunder Singh Sher Singh, a registered partnership firm, are being
disposed of, as both arise out of the common judgment & decrees dated
11.03.2022 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Kurukshetra, whereby
Civil Appeals No.146 and 145 of 2016, preferred by the appellant-firm, were
dismissed, affirming the judgment & decrees dated 22.03.2016 passed by the
learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Kurukshetra, in two consolidated civil suits.
2. The appellant-firm, carrying on the business of commission agency at
New Grain Market, Ladwa, instituted Civil Suit No.331 of 2013 against Jasmer Singh
and his brother Ram Parshad for recovery of ₹7,09,090/-, comprising ₹4,63,730/-
VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document
RSA-2059-2022 2026:PHHC:202036
RSA-2061-2022
towards principal and ₹2,45,360/- towards interest, besides seeking consequential
relief of permanent injunction. It was pleaded that both defendants were its
customers, who used to obtain advances for agricultural and domestic purposes
and sell their agricultural produce through the firm. According to the appellant, the
defendants maintained a joint account and, on 03.05.2007, acknowledged an
outstanding liability of ₹10,80,730/-, besides obtaining a further advance of
₹33,000/- on the same day. It was further pleaded that ₹6,50,000/- received
through cheque dated 19.11.2007 was adjusted towards the outstanding liability,
leaving the principal balance of ₹4,63,730/-.
3. The defendants contested the suit. Jasmer Singh denied the alleged
outstanding liability and disputed the genuineness of the relevant account entries.
Ram Parshad specifically pleaded that he had never maintained any joint account
with his brother and that the cheque for ₹6,50,000/- had been issued by him
independently as a loan advanced to the appellant-firm, and not towards discharge
of any liability of Jasmer Singh.
4. Ram Parshad also instituted Civil Suit No.419 of 2014 against the
appellant-firm, seeking recovery of ₹8,85,806/-, comprising the principal amount of
₹6,50,000/- advanced through cheque dated 19.11.2007 and interest thereon. The
appellant-firm resisted the suit, reiterating that the cheque amount had been
received towards adjustment of the outstanding dues of the two brothers.
5. Both suits were consolidated and decided by a common judgment
dated 22.03.2016. The learned trial Court partly decreed the suit filed by the
appellant-firm, holding it entitled to recover ₹33,000/- from Jasmer Singh alone,
along with interest at 6% per annum from the date of institution of the suit till
realization. The remaining claim was declined and the suit against Ram Parshad
was dismissed. Conversely, the suit instituted by Ram Parshad was decreed to the
extent of ₹6,50,000/-, along with interest at 6% per annum from the date of
institution of his suit till realization.
6. The appellant-firm preferred two separate first appeals, both of which
were dismissed by the learned First Appellate Court vide common judgment dated
11.03.2022. Hence, the present regular second appeals.
2 9
Page of
VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document
RSA-2059-2022 2026:PHHC:202036
RSA-2061-2022
7. Learned counsel for the appellant firm contends that the Courts below
have failed to appreciate the documentary evidence comprising the account books,
Rojnamcha and Bahi Khata entries, duly proved through the partner and
accountants of the firm. It is argued that Jasmer Singh had acknowledged the
outstanding amount of ₹10,80,730/- on 03.05.2007 by appending his signatures
and making an endorsement in his own handwriting. The handwriting expert
examined by the appellant also supported the genuineness of the signatures. It is
further contended that once the Courts below accepted the entry relating to the
advance of ₹33,000/- made on the same date, there was no justification for
discarding the acknowledgment of the larger outstanding amount.
8. It is further contended that the courts below failed to appreciate that
Jasmer Singh and Ram Parshad were brothers, jointly cultivating their agricultural
land and maintaining a common account with the appellant-firm. The cheque of
₹6,50,000/- issued by Ram Parshad was, therefore, rightly adjusted against their
outstanding liability. According to learned counsel, the finding that the said
amount constituted a loan advanced by Ram Parshad to the firm is contrary to the
evidence.
9. Learned counsel has additionally urged that the outstanding amount
against the respondents was duly reflected in the Income Tax Returns of the
appellant-firm. Reference is made to Ex.P26 to Ex.P31, being documents pertaining
to the income tax records of the firm. It is submitted that these documents
constitute independent corroboration of the account books and that the courts
below have failed to appreciate their evidentiary value.
10. It is also argued that the courts below have erred in rejecting the claim
on the ground of limitation despite the acknowledgment of liability and
subsequent payment.
11. I have considered the submissions advanced by learned counsel for
the appellant and examined the judgments of the courts below.
12. The main controversy concerns the evidentiary value of the account
entries relied upon by the appellant-firm, particularly Ex.P3, and whether the
3 9
Page of
VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document
RSA-2059-2022 2026:PHHC:202036
RSA-2061-2022
payment of ₹6,50,000/- made by Ram Parshad could lawfully be adjusted against
the alleged liability of Jasmer Singh.
13. It is not in dispute that the appellant-firm examined one of its partners
Suba Singh as PW1, handwriting expert Mani Jain as PW2, and its accountants
Suresh Kumar and Dharam Pal as PW3 and PW4, respectively. Besides the account
entries Ex.P3 to Ex.P25, the firm produced documents Ex.P26 to Ex.P31 relating to
its income tax records. On the other hand, Jasmer Singh and Ram Parshad
appeared as DW1 and DW2, respectively, and also examined handwriting expert
Ram Dhan Babbar as DW3.
14. The appellant-firm has placed considerable emphasis upon Ex.P3,
contending that Jasmer Singh acknowledged an outstanding amount of
₹10,80,730/- by appending his signatures and writing the amount in his own hand.
The legal proposition that a clear and duly proved acknowledgment of an existing
liability constitutes material evidence against its maker cannot be disputed. In Hira
Lal and others v. Badkulal and others, AIR 1953 SC 225 , the Hon'ble Supreme
Court recognized the evidentiary significance of an acknowledgment of liability
appearing in the account books. However, before such an entry can be acted upon,
its execution, contents and connection with the liability asserted must be
established to the satisfaction of the Court.
15. In the present case, the learned first Appellate Court has examined
Ex.P3 in detail and noticed that the entry did not disclose the relevant dates or
particulars of the transactions from which the alleged balance of ₹10,80,730/- had
arisen. The amount of ₹1,96,531.12 was shown against the name of Jasmer Singh,
followed by an entry of ₹10,80,730/- described as the balance outstanding.
However, the record did not satisfactorily explain the calculation or reconciliation
of these amounts. PW3 Suresh Kumar, accountant of the firm, admitted that he
was neither present when the transactions took place nor had he scribed the
entries. He was also unable to explain the amounts outstanding or paid. These
deficiencies were considered material by both courts below.
16. The distinction between the legal effect of a proved acknowledgment
and the proof of the acknowledgment itself is important. A creditor relying upon a
4 9
Page of
VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document
RSA-2059-2022 2026:PHHC:202036
RSA-2061-2022
clear admission of an ascertained debt may not invariably be required to prove
every earlier transaction independently. Nevertheless, where the very execution or
authenticity of the alleged acknowledgment is disputed, the Court is required to
evaluate the document in the light of the surrounding evidence. The courts below
have not rejected Ex.P3 merely because it forms part of the account books; rather,
they have found the entry unreliable upon appreciation of its contents, the
handwriting evidence and the testimony of the witnesses. The appellant has not
established that these concurrent findings are based upon a misreading of any
decisive document or are otherwise perverse.
17. This conclusion is also consistent with Section 34 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872, which makes entries in books of account regularly kept in the
course of business relevant, but expressly provides that such entries alone shall not
be sufficient to charge any person with liability. In Chandradhar Goswami and
others v. The Gauhati Bank Ltd., AIR 1967 SC 1058, the Hon'ble Supreme Court
explained the necessity of evidence supporting the liability sought to be
established through account entries. The principle does not diminish the effect of a
separately proved admission of debt; it applies where the creditor relies upon its
own entries without satisfactory proof of the liability recorded therein.
18. The finding regarding Ex.P4 stands on a different footing. The said
entry relates to a specific advance of ₹33,000/- allegedly made to Jasmer Singh on
03.05.2007. Both courts below, after considering the entry and the evidence
relating to its execution, accepted the advancement of this amount. Consequently,
the claim of the appellant-firm was decreed to that extent. This distinction itself
indicates that the courts below did not discard the account books in their entirety,
but evaluated the individual entries on the basis of the evidence supporting them.
No ground is made out for disturbing the finding regarding the amount of
₹33,000/-.
19. The next contention concerns the income tax documents Ex.P26 to
Ex.P31. Learned counsel for the appellant has argued that the respondents were
shown as debtors in the Income Tax Returns of the firm and that this circumstance
has not been given due consideration by the courts below. The contention
5 9
Page of
VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document
RSA-2059-2022 2026:PHHC:202036
RSA-2061-2022
deserves examination because income tax records maintained and furnished in the
ordinary course of business may have corroborative evidentiary value.
20. However, there is a material distinction between the disclosure of a
receivable in the Income Tax Returns of a creditor and an acknowledgment of
liability by the person shown as debtor. The returns are prepared and furnished by
the appellant-firm itself. Even if the disputed amount is reflected therein as
recoverable from the respondents, such disclosure remains a statement made by
the firm concerning its own claim. It does not establish that the respondents
accepted the correctness of the entry or that the underlying transaction stood
proved. Nor does the mere filing or acceptance of such returns by the taxation
authorities amount to an adjudication of the civil liability of the respondents.
21. The income tax records may lend assurance to an otherwise
established transaction, particularly where the corresponding accounts are duly
proved and supported by independent evidence. They cannot, however, cure the
material deficiencies noticed in Ex.P3 or establish the alleged joint liability of
Jasmer Singh and Ram Parshad. Significantly, the dispute is not confined to
whether the appellant-firm recorded an outstanding amount in its accounts. The
crucial questions are whether the liability was established against the respondents
and whether Ram Parshad authorized adjustment of his cheque towards the
alleged debt of Jasmer Singh. The income tax documents do not, merely by
showing an amount as outstanding, establish either of these facts.
22. Thus, even assuming that Ex.P26 to Ex.P31 reflect the respondents as
debtors, their evidentiary value must be considered along with the remaining
evidence. The failure of the first Appellate Court to discuss these documents
separately does not, in the circumstances, render its findings perverse, since the
documents do not independently establish the disputed liability. The contention
raised on this aspect is, accordingly, rejected.
23. Equally untenable is the contention that the payment of ₹6,50,000/-
by Ram Parshad necessarily represented part-payment of the outstanding liability
of Jasmer Singh. The appellant-firm pleaded that the two brothers were jointly
cultivating their land and maintaining a common account. However, the courts
6 9
Page of
VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document
RSA-2059-2022 2026:PHHC:202036
RSA-2061-2022
below have concurrently found that the alleged joint account and joint liability
were not established by reliable evidence. The mere fact that Jasmer Singh and
Ram Parshad are brothers does not create a presumption that one is liable for the
debts of the other or that a payment made by one may be appropriated towards
the liability of the other.
24. The payment of ₹6,50,000/- through cheque No.009821 dated
19.11.2007, issued by Ram Parshad and encashed by the appellant-firm, is
admitted. The dispute concerns the purpose for which the payment was made. The
appellant-firm relied upon Ex.P8 and Ex.P14 to contend that the amount had been
credited against the outstanding account. However, the learned first Appellate
Court specifically noticed that these entries did not disclose that the cheque
amount had been paid towards the liability of Jasmer Singh or adjusted against the
alleged previous balance of ₹10,80,730/-. No reliable evidence of authorization by
Ram Parshad for such adjustment was produced.
25. The fact that the appellant-firm received and encashed the cheque
does not, by itself, confer a right upon it to appropriate the amount towards a
disputed liability of another person. The principle governing appropriation of
payments presupposes the existence of debts and a payment made by or on behalf
of a debtor in circumstances attracting the applicable rules of appropriation. In the
absence of proof that Ram Parshad was himself liable for the alleged debt or had
authorized payment on behalf of Jasmer Singh, the firm could not justify the
adjustment merely by making corresponding entries in its own books.
26. The learned trial Court, upon considering the rival versions and the
evidence, accepted Ram Parshad's case that the amount of ₹6,50,000/- had been
advanced by him as a loan to the appellant-firm. The said finding was affirmed by
the first Appellate Court. The admitted receipt and encashment of the cheque, the
absence of any established joint liability and the failure to prove authorization for
adjustment constitute the material circumstances supporting that conclusion. The
appellant has not pointed out any evidence of such significance as would render
the concurrent finding unsustainable.
7 9
Page of
VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document
RSA-2059-2022 2026:PHHC:202036
RSA-2061-2022
27. As regards limitation, learned counsel for the appellant has relied
upon the alleged acknowledgment in Ex.P3 and the subsequent payment of
₹6,50,000/-. Sections 18 and 19 of the Limitation Act, 1963, prescribe the
circumstances in which an acknowledgment of liability or part-payment may give
rise to a fresh period of limitation. For the benefit of these provisions to be
available, the statutory requirements regarding the nature, execution and timing of
the acknowledgment or payment must be satisfied.
28. In the present case, the alleged acknowledgment in Ex.P3 has not
been accepted as duly established by the courts below. Likewise, the payment of
₹6,50,000/- by Ram Parshad has not been found to be a payment towards the debt
claimed by the appellant-firm. In the absence of these initial facts, the appellant
cannot successfully invoke the provisions relating to acknowledgment or part-
payment to overcome the finding on limitation.
29. It is also necessary to bear in mind the limited scope of interference in
a regular second appeal. Under Section 100 CPC, this Court is not required to
undertake a fresh appreciation of the entire evidence merely because another view
may be possible. In Kondiba Dagadu Kadam v. Savitribai Sopan Gujar, (1999) 3
SCC 722; Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari (Dead) by LRs, (2001) 3 SCC 179;
and Hero Vinoth (Minor) v. Seshammal, (2006) 5 SCC 545 , the Hon'ble Supreme
Court has explained that interference with concurrent findings of fact is
permissible, where such findings suffer from perversity, disregard of material
evidence or an error of law giving rise to a substantial question of law.
30. In the present case, both courts below have considered the competing
claims arising from the same transactions and have assigned reasons for accepting
the claim of the appellant-firm to the extent of ₹33,000/- while rejecting the
remaining claim. They have also concurrently accepted the claim of Ram Parshad
for recovery of ₹6,50,000/-. The findings are founded upon appreciation of the
documentary and oral evidence. The appellant's reliance upon its income tax
records does not prove that the conclusions reached by the courts below are
contrary to any established legal principle or are unsupported by evidence.
8 9
Page of
VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document
RSA-2059-2022 2026:PHHC:202036
RSA-2061-2022
31. The submissions advanced on behalf of the appellant essentially seek
reconsideration of the evidentiary value of Ex.P3, the other account entries, the
income tax documents and the circumstances surrounding the payment of
₹6,50,000/-. Such reconsideration would amount to reappreciation of evidence,
which is impermissible in the absence of a substantial question of law. No such
question arises for determination in either appeal.
32. Consequently, finding no illegality or perversity in the concurrent
judgments and decrees of the courts below warranting interference under Section
100 CPC, both regular second appeals are dismissed. The judgment and decrees
dated 11.03.2022 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Kurukshetra,
affirming the judgment and decrees dated 22.03.2016 of the learned trial Court,
are upheld.
33. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall also stand disposed
of. A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of connected case.
(DEEPAK GUPTA)
17.11.2026 JUDGE
Vivek
Whether Speaking/reasoned Yes
Whether reportable No
Uploaded on:17.11.2026
9 9
Page of
VIVEK PAHWA
2026.11.17 17:44
I agree to specified
portions of this document