Digital 18 Media Private Limited vs RAJKUMAR THEATRES PVT LTD
- Court
- Madras High Court
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Order reserved on : 27-10-2026
Order pronounced on : 13-11-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P.B. BALAJI
A No. 4590 of 2026
in
C.S(COMM DIV) NO. 280 OF 2026
Digital 18 Media Private Limited
st
31 floor, Tower 4, One Unity Center,
Senapati Bapat Marg,
Prabhadevi, Mumbai 400 013.
..Applicant(s)
Vs
1. Rajkumar Theatres Private Limited,
Represented by its Director, Mr.Rajkumar
th
Sethupathy,27, 4 Main Road,
Raja Annamalai Puram, Chennai - 600 028.
2. Wide Angle Creations
Represented by its Partner,
Shoba George,62, Casa Major Road,
Egmore, Chennai - 600 008.
3. Aashirvad Cinemas
Represented by its Proprietor, M.J.
Antony,59/1047, Valakuzhi, Krishna Swamy
Road, Off Chittoor Road, Ernakulam - 682 035.
4. Jeethu Joseph
Valiyakandathil, Mutholapuram P.O.,Elanji,
Ernakulam - 686 665.
5. Panorama Studios
22nd Floor, Lotus Signature, Veera Desai Road,
Near Country Club, Andheri West, Mumbai -
400 053.
6. Ajay Devgn
__________
Page1 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
5/6, Sheetal Apartments, Ground Floor,
Opposite Chandan Cinema, Juhu, Mumbai -
400 049.
7. Jyoti Deshpande
Zion Biz World, Subhash Road A, Vile Parle
East, Mumbai - 400 057.
..Respondent(s)
To reject the plaint filed in C.S. Comm. Div.No. 280 of 2026
For Applicant(s): Mr.P.S.Raman
Senior Counsel
for Mr.Rahul Balaji
For Respondent(s): Mr.K.Ravi
Senior Counsel
for Mr.R.Murugan for M/s.Rugan & Arya for R1
Mr.Sathish Parasaran
Senior Counsel
for Mrs.Akshaya Ramadurai for RR3 & 4
Mr.K.Manoj Menon for R5
Ms.Sowjanya Shyam
for Mr.Sharath Chandran for R2
RR6 & 7 - dismissed as not pressed against RR6 &
7
O RDER
This application has been taken out by the fourth defendant seeking
rejection of the plaint.
__________
Page2 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
2. I have heard Mr. P.S. Raman, learned senior counsel for the
applicant/fourth defendant; Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel for the first
respondent/ plaintiff; Mr. Satish Parasaran, learned Senior Counsel for the
second and third respondents; and Mr. Manoj Menon, learned counsel for the
fifth respondent.
3. The crux of the submissions of Mr. P.S. Raman, learned Senior
Counsel, which were also echoed by Mr. Satish Parasaran, learned Senior
Counsel, and Mr. Manoj Menon, learned counsel appearing for respondents 2,
3, 4 and 5 respectively, are set out herein below:
Firstly, the applicant has not satisfied the mandate of the Section 12A of
the Commercial Courts Act, by exhausting the mandatory requirement of pre
institution mediation and therefore on this preliminary ground, the suit has to
fail. Secondly, it is contended that the applicant and the first respondent/
plaintiff cannot ride two horses at the same time and having voluntarily opted to
take the arbitration route by invoking Section 9 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, against all the respondents, now cannot reagitate the same
issue before the Civil Court. It is therefore contended that the suit itself is an
abuse and re-litigation and consequently the application has to fail and the suit
has to be nipped in the bud. Thirdly, the learned senior counsel contended that
the reliefs sought have been grossly undervalued and consequently improper
and deficit court fees have been paid on the plaint and on this ground as well,
__________
Page3 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
the suit is liable to be dismissed. Fourthly and lastly, the contention taken by the
fourth defendant and adopted by the other defendants 2, 3, and 5, is that the suit
itself does not disclose any cause of action and there is no case made out, on a
reading of the plaint that there is any nexus between the alleged 50% remake
rights claimed by the plaintiff and the exploitation by the defendant that is
sought is to be restrained.
4. However, in the course of their arguments, Mr. P.S. Raman, learned
Senior Counsel and Mr. Satish Parasaran, learned Senior Counsel, would fairly
concede that the ground of improper valuation and payment of deficit court
fees, cannot be a ground for rejection of plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 Code of
Civil Procedure, since admittedly the said defect is curable. Therefore, they did
not persist with the said contention, though taken in the affidavit in support of
the application for rejection of plaint.
5. Per contra, Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel for the first
respondent/ plaintiff, would meet the arguments of Mr. P.S. Raman, learned
Senior Counsel for the fourth respondent; Mr. Satish Parasaran, learned Senior
Counsel for the second and third respondents; and Mr. Manoj Menon, counsel
for the fifth respondent, that when an urgent relief has been sought for to
restrain continuing infringement, then Section 12A of the Commercial Courts
Act, can be dispensed with. In support of his submissions, he relies on the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Novenco Building & Industry A/S v.
__________
Page4 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
Xero Energy Engg. Solutions (P) Ltd., (2026) 4 SCC 815 .
6. Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel for the first respondent/ plaintiff,
would further contend that the prayer for interim injunction is not a camouflage
for evading mandatory pre-institution mediation. He would further state that for
deciding the nature of the urgent interim relief sought for in the interlocutory
application, the courts should not go into the merits or the demerits of the relief
sought for in the interlocutory application. Therefore, it is his submission that
the non-compliance of Section 12A is not fatal in the facts and circumstances of
the present case, especially when the film has already been released in theatres
on 02.10.2026 and it is only the continuing infringement that is sought to be
prevented, especially with reference to the release of the film in OTT platforms.
7. As regards re-litigation and abuse, and there being no cause of action,
Mr. K. Ravi, learned Senior Counsel for the first respondent/ plaintiff, contends
that the dismissal of the Section 9 application would certainly not affect the
relief sought for in the suit. He would further contend that admittedly, apart
from filing of the Section 9 application, no further steps were taken towards the
conduct of arbitral proceedings and therefore, considering the nature of the
relief sought for in the plaint, it certainly cannot be characterized as re-litigation
and abuse, leave alone res judicata . Apart from Novenco Building case (referred
in supra), he has also relied on Aarthi Scans (P) Ltd. v. Konica Minolta Business
Solutions India (P) Ltd., in 2026 SCC OnLine Mad 2440 , and the decision of the
__________
Page5 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Marg Limited. v. Susil Lalwani and Ors. in 2026
SCC OnLine SC 647 besides my order in V. Ramathal v. B. Bagyalakshmi and
Anr. in CRP No. 1025 of 2025, dated 27.06.2025.
8. In reply, Mr. P.S. Raman, learned Senior Counsel for the fourth
respondent and Mr. Satish Parasaran, learned Senior Counsel for the second and
third respondents, contend that the applicant / fourth defendant, having admitted
to the factum of release of the movie in theatres, cannot feign ignorance of the
fact that there is a legal bar for the respondents to release the movie in OTT
platforms in about 8 weeks. The said period being close to 2 months, could have
certainly been utilized by the applicant/plaintiff to undergo pre - institution
mediation, and the applicant / fourth defendant cannot take shelter under the
ground that urgent interim relief has been prayed for and therefore the
mandatory compliance of Section 12A can be dispensed with, in the facts and
circumstances of this case.
9. I have carefully considered the submissions advanced by the learned
Senior Counsels on both sides and Mr. Manoj Menon, learned counsel for the
fifth respondent.
10.At the outset, in so far as rejection being sought on the ground of
improper valuation and court fees, as fairly conceded by Mr. P.S. Raman,
__________
Page6 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
learned Senior Counsel, as well as Mr. Satish Parasaran, learned Senior Counsel
and Mr. Manoj Menon, learned counsel, the question of deficit court fee is a
curable defect and an opportunity should be given to the applicant/ plaintiff,
even in the event of the court coming to a finding that there has been improper
valuation and payment of deficit court fees. Further, there is a separate
procedure contemplated under Section 12 of the Tamil Nadu Court Fees and
Suits Valuation Act, 1955, to address the grievances of the defendants in so far
as it relates to improper valuation of suit relief and payment of deficit court fees
consequently.
11. In light of the above, I am unable to find that the plaint is liable to be
rejected on the grounds of improper valuation of the suit reliefs and consequent
deficit payment of court fees.
12. Coming to abuse and re-litigation, in Namathal’s case (referred in
supra), I had an occasion to deal with an almost identical issue where estoppel
and res judicata were set up as grounds and forming the allegation of re-
litigation to seek rejection of a plaint. I held in no uncertain terms that the
questions of estoppel, res judicata and re-litigation cannot be pressed into
service in an application filed under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC for rejection of a
plaint, since the court deciding an application under Order 7 Rule 11 will have
to strictly confine its enquiry to the plaint averments and documents filed in
__________
Page7 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
support of the plaint and when issues involve mixed question of fact and law,
then the plaint cannot be rejected.
13. Coming to the last limb, namely, the non- compliance of Section 12 –
A of the Commercial Courts Act, no doubt a pre institution meditation is
mandatory under Section 12A. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Patil Automation
(P) Ltd. v. Rakheja Engineers (P) Ltd., (2022) 10 SCC 1, held that when a plaint
is filed under the Commercial Courts Act, with a prayer for an urgent interim
relief, then the commercial court should examine the nature and subject matter
of the suit, the cause of action and the prayer for interim relief, and find whether
the prayer for interim relief is not a disguise or mask to get over Section 12A of
the Commercial Courts Act. The Supreme Court further held that the
Commercial Court has to consider the issue holistically from the view point of
the plaintiff and mere non grant of interim relief at the interim stage will not
justify or require dismissal of the commercial suit under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC.
14. In Yamini Manohar v. T.K.D. Keerthi, (2024) 5 SCC 815 , the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, after taking note of the ratio laid down in Patil Automation case
(referred in supra), holding that Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act is
mandatory and cannot be dispensed with, unless the suit contemplates urgent
interim relief, clarified the legal position holding that the Plaintiff cannot claim
an absolute choice or right to paralyze Section 12A of the Commercial Courts
Act, by making a prayer for urgent interim relief, in order to camouflage and
__________
Page8 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
bypass the statutory mandate of pre litigation mediation. The Hon’ble Court
further held that it is for the Court to decide whether the resort to the procedure
under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, is to be satisfied, from the
nature of the urgent interim relief sought for depending on the plaint documents
and facts.
15. Keeping the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Patil
Automation and Yamini Manohar case (referred in supra), in mind, testing the
facts and circumstances of the present case, with regard to whether the
applicant/plaintiff has sought for any urgent interim relief, in order to avoid and
wriggle out of the mandate of Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act or not
the following factors became absolutely relevant. The parties have already been
litigating the very same issue, albeit, in a different forum, namely, before the
Arbitration Court, where a Section 9 application was taken out for interim
injunction to restrain exploitation of the very same film “Dhrishyam 3: The
Conclusion”. The Section 9 application came to be dismissed after due enquiry
and contest. The applicant / plaintiff accepted the order of dismissal against the
defendant herein and did not choose to prefer an appeal. However, making
specific averments and disclosures in the plaint as well as in the interlocutory
pleadings that, since the first defendant had made it explicitly clear that there is
no dispute, much less an arbitrable dispute between the plaintiff and the first
defendant, and the arbitration agreement being only between the plaintiff and
__________
Page9 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
the first defendant, there was no real purpose being served by pursuing the
arbitration channel, and since, taking advantage of the dismissal of the Section 9
application, the respondents 2 to 7, had gone ahead and released the film in
theatres, and the infringement was continuing, the applicant/ plaintiff has
straight away approached this court, filing the above commercial suit and also
renewing the prayer for interim injunction.
16. I am not concerned with the merits of the relief sought for in the
interim injunction application at this stage, and as to whether the applicant/
plaintiff has passed the trinity test before becoming entitled to grant of an
interim relief. As held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Yamini Manohar case
(referred in supra), my limited role is only to ensure that the application for
interim injunction is not to get over the process of pre institution mediation
contemplates under Section 12A, which has now been held to be mandatory by
the Supreme Court in Patil Automation case (referred in supra), on and from
20.08.2022. The view having been clarified and followed in Yamini Manohar
case (referred in supra) subsequently, with a rider that the role of the
Commercial Court in deciding whether the applicant /plaintiff had any urgent
interim relief to obtain was actually more relevant and significant.
17. At this juncture, the Order passed by this Court in the Section 9
application, assumes great significance. It is already the contention of the
__________
Page10 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
applicant and the respondent/ defendants who are supporting the applicant in the
applicants request for rejection of plaint that the order passed in the Section 9
application is a bar for further relief, especially interim relief in favour of the
applicant/ plaintiff and that having opted and elected to proceed under the
provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, the plaintiff cannot abandon
the same mid -way and take recourse to filing of a commercial suit. In other
words, it is relying on these admitted facts that the defendants are praying for
rejection of the plaint on the ground of estoppel, res judicata as well as re-
litigation.
18. This Court by order dated 01.10.2026, 1 day prior to the release of the
movie “Dhrishyam 3: The Conclusion,” in theatres, after elaborately
considering the contentions advanced by the plaintiff as well as the defendants,
held that the plaintiff, at the interlocutory stage, has not made out a prima facie
case by establishing a subsisting enforceable right, which is threatened with
imminent infringement. This Court, in fact, held that the claims of the plaintiff
regarding the rights assigned in its favour would survive not withstanding a
subsequent transaction is a matter that would require examination of all
contractual documents and subsequent conduct of the parties. Ultimately, this
Court concluded that the applicant, at the interlocutory stage, did not establish
necessary foundation for grant of a sweeping restraint and compensation as
th
prayed for. This order came to be passed at the 11 hour, that is 1 day prior to
__________
Page11 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
the release of the movie that was already contemplated to be released on
02.10.2026. In the light of the dismissal of the application, the defendants
proceeded to release the movie in theatres and it is only with respect to further
release in OTT platforms that the urgent interim relief is pressed for before me
in O.A. No. 1114 of 2026, which I am proposing to decide immediately after
deciding the present application for rejection of plaint.
19. From the order passed by this Court, two things emerge:
Firstly, this Court found that the plaintiff was not entitled to any relief at
the interlocutory stage and that documents have to be examined in detail at the
stage of trial; and secondly, the counsel for the defendants themselves place
heavy reliance on the said Order passed by this Court on 01.10.2026 dismissing
the Section 9 application, where this Court has, in no uncertain terms, held that
the issues are contentious and have to be tested only at trial.
20. Pursuant to the dismissal of the application, the plaintiff has pleaded
that since there is no arbitrable dispute with the first defendant, with whom
alone the plaintiff has an arbitration agreement, the plaintiff had no other option
but to file the present suit having, coming to know than the defendants 2 to 7 are
not claiming under the first defendant in any manner, but independently.
Further, according to the plaintiff, the defendants are continuing to infringe the
alleged rights of the plaintiff and therefore the interim injunction application has
__________
Page12 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
been taken out to restrain the defendants from continuing with the acts of
infringement, by exhibiting the movie “Dhrishyam 3: The Conclusion”,
anywhere in the world, in any format whatsoever, including such exhibition and
exploitation on OTT platforms or in or through social media, pending the
disposal of the suit.
21. The affidavit for interim injunction has been sworn to on 05.10.2026,
which is four days after the dismissal of the Section 9 application which was
admittedly contested. Applying the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Yamini Manohar’s case (referred in supra) to the facts in the present
case, the plaintiff in my considered opinion has passed the test of urgent interim
relief and also being exempted from undergoing the mandatory pre-requisites
for pre institution mediation for more than 1 reason. It is not as if the parties are
litigating for the first time, they were already at loggerheads before the
Arbitration Court in the Section 9 proceedings and a contested Order came to be
passed, denying any interim relief to the applicant/ plaintiff. Therefore, even
though it is vehemently contended that by the senior counsels for the defendants
that the film cannot be released in the OTT platforms within a period of 55 days
from the theatrical release, this is not a case where the plaintiff can be
compelled to undergo mandatory pre-institution mediation when the suit and the
present application are only a fall out of the Order in the Section 9 application.
22. The plaintiff, in view of realizing that he could not pursue the
__________
Page13 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
arbitration proceedings any further, has filed the instant suit along with an
application for interim injunction prayer, which has already been discussed
herein above.
23. The plaintiff clearly alleges that the defendants are continuing to
infringe his alleged copyrights. Therefore, considering the issue holistically, and
also in the light of the fact that the defendants themselves rely on the Order
passed by this Court in the Section 9 application, which found that the parties
have to go in for elaborate trial, I do not see why the plaintiff should be non-
suited for failure to comply with the mandate of Section 12A of the Commercial
Courts Act.
24. Coming to the decisions that have been relied on in this regard, in
Marg Limited’s case (referred in supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that
under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC, a plaint cannot be rejected on the ground that it
does not comply with the provisions of the Court Fees Act. In Aarthi Scan’s
case (referred in supra), this Court considering the scope of Section 12A of the
Commercial Courts Act, held that whenever an urgent interim prayer is sought
for by the plaintiff and the suit is filed without exhausting the pre-institution
mediation procedure, then it is for the Court to see whether there is a real
contemplation of urgent relief and that the court is not concerned with the
merits of the urgent reliefs sought for. This Court also held that when the
pleading on the side of the plaintiff clearly explain the difficulties faced by
__________
Page14 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
them, it cannot be said that interim relief sought was a camouflage to bypass the
mandatory pre-institution mediation procedure. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Novenco Building case (referred in supra), after recognizing the legal principle
laid down in Dhanbad Fuels (P) Ltd. v. Union of India, (2025) 9 SCC 424 , held
that if the prayer for injunction cannot be characterized as a mere camouflage to
avoid mediation, but is a real grievance founded on the continuing nature of
infringement and irreparable prejudice likely to be caused by delay pending
litigation, then the Court must look beyond time lag and evaluate the substance
of the plea for interim protection. The Hon’ble Supreme Court further held that
institution of pre-institution mediation in a situation of ongoing infringement, in
effect, would render the plaintiff remediless, allowing the infringer to continue
to profit under the protection of procedural formality and that Section 12 A was
not intended to achieve such kind of anomalous result.
25. Applying the ratio laid down in Novenco ’s case (referred in supra) to
the present case as well, as already discussed and at the risk of repetition, I
reiterate the settled position that the object of Section 12A mandate if a pre-
institution mediation process before filing a commercial suit is only to see
whether litigation itself can be avoided by compelling the parties to go for
mediation, which may likely result in an amicable settlement. However, in the
present case, the parties, as late as 01.10.2026, have been battling out their
respective claims and contentions in the Section 9 application under the
__________
Page15 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, before this Court and alleging continuing
infringement, the suit has been filed within a period of four days.
26. Therefore, in my considered opinion, it is not a case where the
plaintiff has avoided mandatory compliance of Section 12A Commercial Courts
Act, with a view to get over the mediation process which has been held to be
compulsory/ mandatory in Patil Automation case (referred in supra), and
affirmed in Yamini Manoharan’s case (referred in supra) as well. Further it is
regardless of whether the plaintiff will succeed in the interim injunction
application or not, that the Court will have to test the urgent relief sought for.
27. Therefore, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, I do not
see the filing and seeking the urgent interim relief amounting to a mischievous
act on the part of the plaintiff, to bypass the mandatory compliance of pre-
institution mediation under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act.
28. In light of the above, I do not see this as a case requiring rejection of
the plaint for mere non -compliance of the mandatory procedure contemplated
under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act. For all the above reasons, I
do not find any merit, either on facts or on law, to entertain the application for
rejection of plaint.
29. In fine, the application is dismissed. However, there shall be no orders
as to costs.
__________
Page16 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )
2026:MHC:4573
A No. 4590 of 2026
13-11-2026
1/3
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
ATA
P.B.BALAJI J.
ATA
A No. 4590 of 2026
in
C.S(COMM DIV) NO. 280 OF 2026
13-11-2026
1/3
__________
Page17 of 17
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 03:58:33 pm )