MAHESH KUMAR MODI vs ADDL. DIST. MAGISTRATE CUM DIST. REGISTRAR, CUTTACK
- Court
- Odisha High Court
WP(C)/2400/2026
ODHC010041802026
2026:OHC:313
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C). No. 2400 of 2026
CNR No. ODHC010041802026
(An application under Articles 226 and 227 of Constitution
of India)
AFR Mahesh Kumar Modi ....... Petitioner
- Versus-
Addl. District Magistrate-cum-
District Registrar, Cuttack &
Another ....... Opposite Parties
_______________________________________________________
For Petitioner : M/s. Soumya Mishra & Omkar
Panda, Advocates
For Opp. Parties : Mr. G. Mohanty, Standing Counsel
CORAM:
JUSTICE SASHIKANTA MISHRA
JUDGMENT
20.11.2026
SASHIKANTA MISHRA, J. The petitioner seeks to challenge the
order dated 07.07.2025 passed by the ADM-cum-District
Registrar, Cuttack, in Registration Appeal Case No.03 of
2021, whereby said appeal preferred by the petitioner under
Section 72 of the Registration Act, 1908, was dismissed,
1 23
Page of
affirming the order dated 21.06.2021 passed by the District
Sub-Registrar, Cuttack, in Refusal Case No.03 of 2021,
refusing registration of the Arbitral Award dated 31.03.2021.
2. The facts of the case, briefly stated, are that late
Hira Lal Modi, who owned immovable properties in the
districts of Cuttack and Sambalpur, was survived by eight
legal heirs, namely, six daughters and two sons, including
the petitioner. The legal heirs entered into an Arbitration
Agreement dated 25.08.2014, appointing Hon’ble Shri
Justice P.C. Mishra, a retired Judge of this Court, as the
Arbitrator for partition and allotment of the properties.
During the arbitral proceedings, the parties arrived at a
settlement, which was reduced into writing in a
Memorandum of Settlement dated 07.10.2016, providing for
allotment of the properties between the two sons. On the
basis thereof, the Arbitrator passed an Award dated
31.03.2021, dividing the properties into three lots,
comprising properties at Nayasarak and Pyari Babu Lane,
Bakhrabad, in Cuttack district, and another property in
Sambalpur district. The petitioner presented the Award for
2 23
Page of
registration before the District Sub-Registrar, Cuttack, who
by order dated 21.06.2021, refused registration on the
grounds that the property under Lot 3 was situated beyond
his territorial jurisdiction and the unit numbers of the
properties under Lots 1 and 2 had not been specified.
Aggrieved by the order, the petitioner preferred appeal before
the ADM-cum-District Registrar, Cuttack, who dismissed the
same, holding that, in view of the amendment to Section 28
of the Registration Act, 1908, the Sub-Registrar, Cuttack,
lacked territorial jurisdiction to register a document
comprising properties situated in more than one registration
district and the procedure provided under Section 65 of the
Act was no longer applicable. The appellate authority also
relied on the technical inability of the e-Registration system
in processing such documents and observed that the Award
could be modified district-wise for registration before the
respective registering authorities. Said orders are impugned
in this writ petition.
3. Counter affidavit has been filed by the ADM-
cum-District Registrar, Cuttack stating that in view of the
3 23
Page of
amendment to Section 28 of the Registration Act, 1908
(Odisha Amendment), he has no jurisdiction to register a
document comprising properties situated partly outside his
territorial jurisdiction and the procedure provided under
Section 65 of the Act has become inoperative. It is further
stated that the e-Registration system does not facilitate
registration of a document relating to properties situated in
more than one registration district. He also questions the
validity and registrability of the Award on the grounds that
the relinquishment of rights by the daughters was not
effected through a registered instrument, the Award is
compulsorily registrable and the particulars of the properties
are insufficient. Objection is also raised regarding limitation
under Section 23 of the Act as well as the availability of an
alternative remedy under Section 77.
4. Heard Mr. Soumya Mishra, learned counsel for
the petitioner and Mr. G. Mohanty, learned Standing
Counsel for the State.
5. Mr. Mishra would argue that the registering
authorities have failed to consider the scope and
4 23
Page of
applicability of Section 65 of the Registration Act, 1908, in
the context of the amendment made to Section 28 of the Act
by the State Legislature. He submits that only because the
expression ‘or some portion’ has been omitted from Section
28 by way of the State amendment, the procedure
specifically provided under Section 65 cannot be rendered
redundant or treated as inoperative, particularly when no
corresponding amendment has been made to the said
provision. According to him, Sections 28 and 65 are required
to be construed harmoniously so as to give effect to both the
provisions, rather than adopting an interpretation which
renders one of them otiose. He further submits that the
appellate authority has mechanically relied on the
clarification issued by the Inspector General of Registration
and the technical limitations of the e-Registration system,
without independently examining the statutory scheme. An
administrative clarification or software limitation cannot
override the provisions of the Act or furnish a ground to
deny registration otherwise permissible in law. He also
argues that the registering authority is not competent to
5 23
Page of
adjudicate on disputed questions relating to title,
entitlement or the validity of the family arrangement
underlying the Award.
6. Per contra, Mr. G. Mohanty submits that
consequent upon the amendment to Section 28 of the Act,
the registering authority is competent to register a document
relating to immovable property only when the whole of such
property is situated within its territorial jurisdiction. Since
one of the properties covered under the Award is situated in
Sambalpur district, the Sub-Registrar, Cuttack, lacks
territorial jurisdiction to register the Award in its entirety.
He further submits that Section 65 of the Act cannot be
invoked independently of Section 28 so as to confer a
jurisdiction which is no longer available under the amended
provision. He also argues that the e-Registration system
does not provide for registration of a single document
covering properties situated in different registration districts.
He also submits that the Award is compulsorily registrable
under Section 17 of the Act, as it creates and declares rights
in immovable properties. He argues that the relinquishment
6 23
Page of
by the daughters is unsupported by any registered
instrument, the Memorandum of Settlement dated
07.10.2016 being unregistered and that the Award also
lacks complete particulars of the properties, including the
requisite unit numbers. He further submits regarding
availability of alternative remedy under Section 77 of the
Act.
7. Having heard learned counsel for the parties at
length, this Court is of the view that it would be apposite to
first deal with the question, whether Section 65 of the
Registration Act, 1908, which prescribes the consequential
procedure to be followed on registration of a document
relating to immovable properties situated in more than one
district, becomes otiose on account of the amendment to
Section 28 of the Act by omission of the words ‘or some
portion’. Much has been argued by Mr. Mishra on this point.
According to him, though Section 28 has been amended, in
the absence of any express deletion or corresponding
amendment of Section 65, the latter provision cannot be
held to have become inoperative only on the basis of a
7 23
Page of
clarification issued by the Inspector General of Registration,
which is, after all, an executive instruction.
8. It would be proper, first of all, to refer to Section
28 of the Act. Section 28 of the Act, as originally enacted, is
reproduced below:
“ 28. Place for registering documents relating to land.—
Save as in this Part otherwise provided, every document
mentioned in section 17, sub-section (1), clauses (a), (b),
(c) 2 [, (d) and (e), section 17, sub-section (2), insofar as
such document affects immovable property,] and section
18, clauses (a), (b) 3 [(c) and (cc),] shall be presented for
registration in the office of a Sub-Registrar within whose
sub district the whole or some portion of the property to
which such document relates is situate.”
[Emphasis added]
An amendment was effected on 07.05.2002, whereby the
words ‘or some portion’ were omitted from Section 28 of the
Act and the amended provision is reproduced below:
“28. Place for registering documents relating to land.—
Save as in this Part otherwise provided, every document
mentioned in section 17, sub-section (1), clauses (a), (b),
(c) 2 [, (d) and (e), section 17, sub-section (2), insofar as
such document affects immovable property,] and section
18, clauses (a), (b) 3 [(c) and (cc),] shall be presented for
registration in the office of a Sub-Registrar within whose
sub district the whole of the property to which such
document relates is situate.”
[Emphasis added]
9. The legislative intent behind such omission has
to be given its due effect. What, therefore, falls for
consideration is whether Section 65, which provides the
8 23
Page of
procedure to be followed where a document relates to land
situated in several districts, operates independently of
Section 28, which prescribes the place for registration of
documents relating to immovable property. We may now
refer to Section 65, which is reproduced below:
“65. Procedure where document relates to land in several
districts.
1) Every Sub-Registrar on registering a non- testamentary
document relating to immovable property situate in more
districts than one shall also forward a copy thereof and of
the endorsement and certificate (if any) thereon, together
with a copy of the map or plan (if any) mentioned in
Section 21 to the Registrar of every district in which any
part of such property is situate other than the district in
which his own sub-district is situate.
(2) The Registrar on receiving the same shall file in his
Book No.1 the copy of the document and the copy of the
map or plan (if any). and shall forward a memorandum of
the document to each of the Sub-Registrars subordinate to
him within whose sub district any part of such property is
situate; and every Sub-Registrar receiving such
memorandum shall file it in his Book No.1”
On a conjoint reading of the aforequoted provisions, it
becomes clear that Section 28 deals with the territorial
jurisdiction of the Sub-Registrar before whom a document
relating to immovable property is required to be presented
whereas, Section 65 essentially is a consequential provision.
Thus, where any part of the property covered by a document
is situated outside the territorial jurisdiction of the
concerned Sub-Registrar, the amended provision restricts
9 23
Page of
his authority to register such document. Consequently,
where the Sub-Registrar lacks the requisite territorial
jurisdiction to register the document, the procedure provided
under Section 65 cannot be set into motion. Though Section
65 has not been expressly amended or deleted by the
Legislature, it is implicit that, once the jurisdiction of the
Sub-Registrar is restricted by the amendment to Section 28,
the consequential procedural provision cannot be pressed
into service to overcome such restriction. To put it
differently, Section 65 can operate only in tune with Section
28 (as amended) and not independently or the other way
round. In such view of the matter, the omission of the words
‘or some portion’ from Section 28 has the effect of rendering
Section 65 inapplicable to a case of the present nature. The
maxim expressio unius est exclusio alterius, which means,
‘the expression of one thing is the exclusion of another’ can
also be pressed into service here to lend support to the
legislative intent underlying the omission of the words ‘or
some portion’.
10 23
Page of
10. While omission of the words ‘or some portion’
from Section 28 has restricted the territorial jurisdiction of
the Sub-Registrar yet, such restriction cannot be understood
to mean that where a single instrument relates to several
distinct properties situated in different registration districts,
the registering authority is precluded from considering its
registration even in respect of those properties which are
wholly situated within its territorial jurisdiction. The
expression ‘the whole of the property’ occurring in the
amended Section 28 has to be considered with reference to
the property in respect of which registration is sought before
the concerned registering authority. Where the document
relates to distinct properties situated in different districts,
the jurisdiction of the registering authority can be examined
with reference to the particular properties falling within its
territorial limits, without having to exercise its authority in
respect of properties situated outside such limits. Rule 47 of
the Odisha Registration Rules, 1988 can be referred to in
this regard which is reproduced below:
“47. Documents dealing with properties situated within
and outside the jurisdiction of the Act.
11 23
Page of
A document relating to immovable property which is
situated partly within and partly outside the area to
which the Registration Act applies may be registered in
the office of the Registering Officer within whose
jurisdiction any portion of the property is situate, but in
such a case, the certificate of registration recorded
under Section 60 shall show that the registration has
been effected only as regards that portion of the
property which lies within the areas where the
Registration Act is in force xx xx xx”
The Rule refers to a situation where a document relates to
immovable property situate partly within and partly outside
the area to which the Registration Act applies. It permits
registration of such a document in the office of the
Registering Officer within whose jurisdiction any portion of
the property is situated, subject to the certificate of
registration granted under Section 60 of the Act indicating
that registration has been effected. Though the Rule does
not directly govern the present case, the principle underlying
it can be referred to by way of analogy. Such reference is not
for the purpose of deriving jurisdiction from a Rule which is
otherwise inapplicable, but for adopting a harmonious
interpretation of the statutory provisions so that the
territorial limitation imposed on a registering authority does
not result in denial of registration altogether in respect of
properties falling within its jurisdiction. Reference to the
12 23
Page of
provision is only to illustrate that registration of a document
involving several properties is possible to be confined to only
a portion of such properties.
11. The position may also be appreciated by way of
an illustration. Suppose two brothers jointly own several
immovable properties situated in two different districts. They
enter into a written family partition arrangement whereby
specific properties situated in one district are allotted
exclusively to one brother and properties situated in the
other district are allotted to the other brother, thereby
creating and declaring their respective rights in such
properties. Such an instrument, by its nature and effect,
would attract the requirement of compulsory registration
under Section 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act, 1908. The
partition arrangement, being the outcome of a single
understanding between the parties for division of their joint
properties, would ordinarily be made in one composite
instrument. It would be neither necessary nor reasonable to
require the parties to execute separate partition deeds in
respect of each property or in respect of properties situated
13 23
Page of
in different registration districts merely to facilitate
registration. The requirement of registration cannot be
construed in a manner which compels fragmentation of one
composite instrument into several instruments solely on
account of the geographical location of the properties
forming its subject matter. If, thereafter, one of the brothers
seeks registration of such instrument, the mere fact that the
properties covered thereunder are situated in different
registration districts cannot be understood to mean that the
instrument must either be registered in its entirety before
one registering authority, irrespective of its territorial
jurisdiction, or remain incapable of registration altogether.
The territorial restriction applicable to the registering
authorities has to be respected, but the same should not, by
itself, defeat the statutory requirement of registration or
compel the parties to execute separate instruments to
achieve what was intended to be one composite partition. As
already stated, the principle underlying Rule 47, though not
directly applicable, furnishes an analogy for resolving this
situation. Registration may, therefore, be considered by the
14 23
Page of
respective registering authorities to the extent the
instrument relates to the distinct properties situated within
their respective territorial jurisdictions, subject to
compliance with the applicable statutory requirements.
Such an interpretation would preserve both the territorial
limitation under Section 28 and the requirement of
compulsory registration under Section 17(1)(b) of the Act,
without rendering the composite instrument incapable of
registration merely because the properties covered
thereunder are situated in different registration districts.
12. In the present case, the Award comprises
properties situated in Cuttack and Sambalpur districts. The
Sub-Registrar, Cuttack, undoubtedly cannot exercise
territorial jurisdiction over the property situated in
Sambalpur district and vice-versa. However, that, by itself,
could not have furnished a ground to refuse registration of
the Award even in respect of the properties situate within his
territorial jurisdiction. The registering authority ought to
have examined the request for registration to the extent the
Award relates to such properties only by determining the
15 23
Page of
registration fees payable in respect of such properties and
after compliance of the statutory requirements, proceeded in
accordance with law. In so far as the properties situate
within Sambalpur district, there is no bar in law for the
same document to be registered by the Registering Authority
of Sambalpur district to such extent only. This will not
contravene Section 28 of the Act and also be in line with
Section 17(1) (b). Thus, in effect, the arbitral award can be
registered at Cuttack for the Cuttack properties and at
Sambalpur for the Sambalpur properties. In such situation,
both registering authorities shall limit their respective
Certificates of Registration under Section 60 and Book-1
entry strictly to the schedule of property situated within
their territorial jurisdiction.
13. This Court is conscious that the above exercise
would entail payment of stamp duty and registering fees by
the executants twice but then, in so far as stamp duty is
concerned, same would be payable proportionately on the
benchmark valuation of only the property which is sought to
be registered and not the other portion of the property on
16 23
Page of
which proportionate stamp duty as admissible is to be paid
before the other registering authority. There would therefore,
be no duplication. Of course, registration fees shall have to
be paid before both authorities, which cannot be avoided.
14. This Court also takes note of the fact that the
ADM, while dismissing the appeal, has observed that the
petitioner may modify the Arbitral Award district-wise so as
to enable its registration before the respective registering
authorities. In the considered view of this Court, such an
observation is unsustainable in law. The registering
authority cannot ask a party to modify an Arbitral Award,
which has been passed pursuant to arbitral proceedings,
merely to facilitate its registration. The registering authority
is required to examine the document as presented and
determine its registrability in accordance with the provisions
of the Act.
15. There is yet another aspect which cannot be lost
sight of. Even though Rule 47 of the Odisha Registration
Rules, 1988, has no application to the facts of the present
case and the Registration Act does not provide registration of
17 23
Page of
a single instrument comprising properties situated in
different registration districts, the question that would still
arise is as to what would be the remedy available to a person
who seeks registration of such an instrument. In the present
case, the Arbitral Award, by virtue of its nature and effect,
requires registration under Section 17 of the Act. The Award
is the result of arbitral proceedings and cannot be
unilaterally altered or modified by one of the parties merely
to facilitate its registration. If the amended Section 28 is
construed as an absolute impediment to registration of the
Award before either of the registering authorities, the
consequence would be that an instrument which is
otherwise compulsorily registrable under Section 17 would
be rendered incapable of registration on account of the
territorial restriction introduced by the amendment. Such an
interpretation would place the person in whose favour rights
have been determined under the Arbitral Award in a peculiar
predicament, leaving him without any effective remedy to
obtain registration of the very instrument which the statute
requires to be registered. The maxim ubi jus ibi remedium
18 23
Page of
(where there is a right, there is a remedy) embodies a well-
recognised principle of law that a legally recognised right
ought not to be rendered incapable of enforcement by an
interpretation which leaves the person concerned without an
effective remedy. The Supreme Court has also recognised
1
this principle in Dhannalal v. Kalawatibai in the
following words:
“21. Reference to, or deriving aid from, certain legal
maxims will be useful. Ubi jus ibi remedium — there is no
wrong without a remedy. Where there is a right there is a
forum for its enforcement. According to Broom's Legal
Maxims (10th Edn., pp. 118-19), the maxim has been
considered so valuable that it led to the invention of the
form of action called an action on the case. Where no
precedent of a writ can be produced, the Clerks in
Chancery shall agree in forming a new one. The principle
adopted by courts of law accordingly is, that the novelty of
the particular complaint alleged in an action on the case is
no objection, provided that an injury cognizable by law be
shown to have been inflicted on the plaintiff, in which
case, although there be no precedent, the common law will
judge according to the law of nature and the public good. If
a man has a right, he must,
“have a means to vindicate and maintain it, and a
remedy if he is injured in the exercise and enjoyment
of it, and, indeed, it is vain thing to imagine a right
without a remedy, for want of right and want of
remedy are reciprocal”.
It is, therefore, difficult to attribute to the Legislature an
intention to create a situation where, on the one hand,
Section 17 mandates registration of an instrument and, on
1
(2002) 6 SCC 16
19 23
Page of
the other, the amendment to Section 28 operates to make
such registration impossible, without providing any
alternative mechanism for the same. In the considered view
of this Court, the principle underlying Rule 47, though not
directly attracted to the present factual situation, provides a
workable interpretative analogy to address this difficulty. By
applying the principle, the registration of the composite
instrument can be confined to the properties falling within
the territorial jurisdiction of each registering authority,
without extending the authority of either of them beyond its
territorial limits. Such an interpretation would harmonise
the requirement of compulsory registration under Section 17
with the territorial restriction under Section 28 and also
prevent the petitioner from being left remediless. The
provisions of the Act ought, therefore, to be construed in a
manner which gives effect to the statutory requirement of
registration without rendering the right of a party under the
instrument illusory.
16. Coming to the other grounds for refusal of
registration, namely, absence of a registered instrument
20 23
Page of
evidencing relinquishment of rights by the daughters,
insufficiency of the description of the properties and
limitation under Section 23 of the Act, this Court is of the
view that the objections cannot be sustained. As regards the
absence of a registered instrument of relinquishment, the
registering authority is not vested with the jurisdiction to
adjudicate on the title or entitlement of the parties to the
properties covered under the document. In K. Gopi v. Sub-
2
Registrar , the Supreme Court has held that the registering
authority cannot assume the role of a Civil Court to
determine whether an executant possesses valid title to the
property sought to be dealt with under the document or not.
Registration does not, by itself, confer title upon a person
who otherwise has none; it operates only to the extent of the
rights possessed by the executants.
17. As regards the description of the properties,
Section 21 of the Act requires the particulars to be sufficient
to identify the immovable property. On perusal of the Award,
this Court finds that the properties have been described by
2
(2026) 2 SCC 696
21 23
Page of
reference to their location, plot numbers and khata
numbers. Therefore, the mere omission of unit numbers, in
the absence of any ambiguity affecting identification of the
properties, cannot constitute a valid ground for refusing
registration. If any further clarification is considered
necessary, the registering authority can always call upon the
petitioner to furnish the same.
18. So far as limitation is concerned, the Award
bears the date 31.03.2021 and was presented before the
Sub-Registrar on 21.06.2021. The presentation having been
made within four months from the date of execution, there is
no violation of Section 23 of the Act.
19. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court
finds that the District Sub-Registrar, Cuttack, was not
justified in refusing registration of the Award in its entirety
merely on the ground that one of the properties covered
thereunder is situated in Sambalpur district. The registering
authority was required to consider the petitioner's request
for registration in respect of the properties situated within
22 23
Page of
its territorial jurisdiction, in accordance with the statutory
scheme.
20. In the result, the writ petition is allowed. The
impugned orders are hereby set aside. The registering
authority is directed to register the Arbitral Award, insofar
as it relates to the properties falling within its territorial
jurisdiction, within three days from the date of production of
a certified copy of this order, subject to compliance with all
statutory requirements. It is open to the petitioner to seek
registration of the document before the concerned
registering authority in so far as it relates to the other
properties.
.…..……….…………….
Sashikanta Mishra,
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack,
th
The 20 November, 2026/A.K. Rana, P.A.
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
Signed by: AJAYA KUMAR RANA
Designation: P.A.
Reason: Authentication
Location: HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK
Date: 20-Nov-2026 14:31:26
23 23
Page of