HEMANTA KU.LENKA vs SATYA NARAYAN NAYAK
- Court
- Odisha High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
MACA No.753 of 2013
CNR No.ODHC010007292013
(In the matter of application under Section 173(1) of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988).
Hemanta Kumar Lenka Appellant
…
-versus-
Satya Narayan Nayak and
another
Respondents
…
For Appellant : Mr. B.K. Rath, Advocate
For Respondents : Mr. A.A Khan, Advocate
(for R-2)
CORAM:
JUSTICE G. SATAPATHY
DATE OF HEARING : 24.09.2026
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 29.09.2026
G. Satapathy, J.
1.
This is an appeal U/S.173(1) of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 (in short, “the Act”) by the
claimant-appellant against the impugned judgment
dated 04.05.2013 passed in MAC Case No.240/312 of
rd
2004, by which the learned 3 Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Bhubaneswar (in short, the “Tribunal”)
directed the Respondent No.2 (R-2)-Divisional
Manager, Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd.,
MACA No.753 of 2013 Page 1 of 8
Bhubaneswar (in short, “the insurer”) to pay a sum of
Rs.1,15,000/- only with simple interest @ 7% w.e.f.
date of filing of the claim on 11.05.2004 till its actual
realization to the appellant-claimant.
2.
The short facts in background are that on
13.11.2003 at about 7.30 AM, the claimant while
travelling on a Moped allegedly hit by a Hero Honda
Motor Cycle bearing Regd. No.OR-02-Y-5517 (in short,
“the offending Motor Cycle”) at Cuttack road near
Chintamaniswar Petrol Pump resulting in him
sustaining grievous injuries in the accident. An FIR
being lodged on this incident came to be registered in
Laxmisagar PS Case No.196 of 2003 with
commencement of investigation therein resulting in
submission of charge-sheet against the rider of the
offending motor cycle for rash and negligent riding the
Motor Cycle.
2.1.
On a claim being preferred by the injured
(appellant) to the learned Tribunal, the same was
registered in the present claim and the owner and the
MACA No.753 of 2013 Page 2 of 8
insurer of the offending Motor Cycle were noticed, but
the owner of the offending Motor Cycle did not contest
the claim and was, accordingly, set ex-party on
06.10.2005, but the insurer appeared and contested
the claim raising inter-alia various pleas including the
plea that the offending Motor Cycle had never caused
any accident and the claimant sustained injuries due
to his own fault or some other reason and, thereby,
there is delay of 44 days in lodging the FIR after the
accident by planting the offending Motor Cycle.
Accordingly, the insurer prayed to dismiss the claim.
3.
On the rival pleadings between the
parties, necessary issues were framed regarding
question of claimant sustained injuries in the accident,
causing of the accident by rash and negligent riding by
the rider of the offending Motor Cycle and the
entitlement of the claimant to the compensation
together with other relief, if any. The learned Tribunal
accordingly allowed the parties to lead evidence, but
only the claimant-appellant led oral and documentary
evidence by examining himself as PW1 and exhibiting
MACA No.753 of 2013 Page 3 of 8
the police papers and his medical certificates including
discharge certificate together with his income
particulars under Exts.1 to 6, but the insurer only led
documentary evidence under Exts.A to C. The learned
Tribunal by the impugned judgment granted
compensation to the claimant indicated supra, but
being aggrieved with the quantum of compensation,
the claimant preferred this appeal.
4.
Heard, Mr. Bibudhendra Kumar Rath,
learned counsel for the appellant and Mr. Adam Ali
Khan, learned counsel for R-2 in the matter, but none
appears for R1-cum-owner of the offending Motor
Cycle despite valid notice of the appeal.
5.
After having considered the rival
submissions upon perusal of record, it appears that
the claimant has only challenged the quantum of
compensation, but the insurer has not challenged any
of the findings of the learned Tribunal, however, the
learned Tribunal has granted right to recovery to R-2
by satisfying the award, however, on perusal of the
impugned judgment, no where this Court finds any
MACA No.753 of 2013 Page 4 of 8
discussion about violation of policy conditions by the
R-1, nonetheless, the insurer in its Written Statement
(WS) had admitted the validity of the driving license
by pleading inter-alia that the driving license of the
rider of the Motor Cycle bearing No.5795 dated
13.11.1987 was valid up to 07.08.2008 covering the
date of accident. The insurer had, however, pleaded in
its WS that it is not liable to pay the compensation,
since the applicant sustained injuries due to his own
fault or some other reason and the vehicle was
planted, but there is no evidence, much less either
documentary or oral evidence led by the insurer to
establish such plea. In this situation and circumstance,
especially when there is no evidence led by the insurer
to establish its plea and the impugned judgment being
totally silent as to the violation of policy conditions by
R-1, this Court does not consider it proper to confirm
such finding of the learned Tribunal about giving right
of recovery to the insurer, merely because the
impugned judgment states that the right of recovery is
granted to the insurer to realize the compensation
MACA No.753 of 2013 Page 5 of 8
from the owner of the offending vehicle and, thereby,
such finding of the learned Tribunal being contrary to
law, cannot sustain and is accordingly set aside in this
appeal.
6.
On reverting back to the challenge of the
appellant-claimant to the quantum of compensation, it
needs to be reminded here, that the present matter
was placed in different National Lok Adalats, but in the
last National Lok Adalat, the parties in fact have
settled the compensation amount with a consolidated
sum of Rs.1,50,000/-, but the said settlement could
not be processed in the Lok Adalat because of absence
of the claimant-appellant as well as his counsel. In this
situation, after making a thorough negotiation and
discussion with the learned counsel for the parties, this
Court proposes to the parties a consolidated sum of
Rs.1,50,000/- as negotiated earlier by them without
any interest as full and final settlement in the case and
seeks the response of the learned counsel for the
parties, to which Mr. Bibudhendra Kumar Rath,
learned counsel for the claimant-appellant agrees and
MACA No.753 of 2013 Page 6 of 8
accept the proposal, whereas, Mr. Adam Ali Khan,
learned counsel for R-2-insurer without disputing such
proposal leaves it to the discretion and conscience of
this Court.
7.
In the aforesaid facts and situation and
taking into account the law laid down by Apex court in
Taslim Parvin & Another vrs. (Smt.) Usha Devi &
Another; 2018(2) TAC 22 (SC) , since the claimant-
appellant agrees to the proposal of the Court through
his counsel and the counsel for the R2-insurance
company without disputing to such proposal leaves it
to the discretion of the Court, it is considered that
interest of justice would be best served, if the
compensation amount is fixed at a consolidated sum of
Rs.1,50,000/- (Rupees One Lakh Fifty Thousand)
which shall be paid by the insurance company-R-2 to
the claimant-appellant.
8.
In the result, the appeal is, accordingly,
disposed of with direction to R2-cum-Divisional
Manager, Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd.,
MACA No.753 of 2013 Page 7 of 8
Bhubaneswar to pay a consolidated sum of
Rs.1,50,000/- to the claimant-appellant within eight
weeks hence. In case of deposit of the compensation
amount, the same shall be disbursed to the appellant-
claimant in cash. Needless to say, proper court fee be
realized from the appellant.
(G. Satapathy)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack,
th
Dated the 29 day of September, 2026/Subhasmita
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SUBHASMITA DAS
Designation: Sr. Stenographer
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 29-Sep-2026 17:39:30
MACA No.753 of 2013 Page 8 of 8