Raziya Begum vs Nafisa Begum Abdul Hamid .

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 814
Non-Reportable

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Civil Appeal No. 7225 of 2011


Raziya Begum & Ors.
... Appellants


Versus

Nafisa Begum Abdul Hamid & Ors.
… Respondents


J U D G M E N T

K. VINOD CHANDRAN, J.

Concurrent findings of the Trial Court and the Appellate
Court were reversed by the High Court in a second appeal. The
legal heirs of the original sole defendant are before us, and the
respondents are the legal heirs of the original plaintiffs, a son and
his mother. The plaintiffs filed a suit for declaration of two sale
deeds, both dated 10.03.1975, as void and inoperative, to cancel
these deeds and declare the plaintiffs as the absolute owners of
the properties covered by the sale deeds. They further prayed for
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by a permanent injunction against the sole original defendant,
CHANDRESH
Date: 2026.08.07
18:08:25 IST
Reason:
Page 1 of 10

Civil Appeal No. 7225 of 2011

restraining him from interfering with the ownership and
possession of the plaintiffs.
2. The plaint averments were that the two sale deeds were
executed in the wake of debts accrued in the name of the plaintiffs
in various financial institutions and the government departments.
The original defendant came with a helping hand and agreed to
find a purchaser for the property. A purchaser was brought, who
left at the last minute, when the original defendant agreed to
purchase their lands. The entire consideration was not available
with the defendant, in which circumstances, he persuaded the
plaintiffs to execute the sale deeds with respect to both the
properties, handing over only part of the consideration. The total
consideration for each of the properties fixed was Rs.7,000/-
(Rupees Seven thousand), out of which Rs.2,500/- (Rupees Two
thousand and five hundred) was handed over, as evident from the
sale deeds itself. As per the clear recitals in the sale deeds, the
defendant had retained Rs.4,500/- (Rupees Four thousand and
five hundred) each, so as to settle the dues remaining against the
plaintiffs in the various institutions.
Page 2 of 10

Civil Appeal No. 7225 of 2011

3. The defendant failed to satisfy the dues and hence when the
plaintiffs repeatedly approached him, he executed an agreement
with respect to one of the properties promising to handover the
remaining Rs.4,500/- and with respect to the other property,
another agreement was executed, taking upon himself the
responsibility to repay all the loans. The sale deeds were
produced as Exhibit Nos.66 and 67 and the agreements were
produced as Exhibit Nos.60 and 63 before the Trial Court, and in
this appeal as additional documents along with translations.
4. The Trial Court after evaluating the evidence, found that the
agreements related to a concluded sale and, though, there was
only part payment of the sale consideration, even as per the
agreement, there is no condition incorporated in the sale deed
that refusal to pay the balance sale consideration would result in
the cancellation of the sale deed. The further agreements only
reaffirmed the obligation of the defendant to pay the balance
consideration as per the sale deed i.e. Rs.4,500/- each, totaling
Rs.9,000/-. A further contention taken by the plaintiffs that the
property had other co-owners, members of the plaintiffs’ family,
was rejected finding that so long as the first plaintiff was alive,
Page 3 of 10

Civil Appeal No. 7225 of 2011

there was no question of any of his sons taking a share in his
property.
5. On possession, it was found, based on the evidence led, that
the proceedings under the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973
specifically under Section 145, resulted in the Sub Divisional
Magistrate (SDM) taking over possession and later handing it over
to the plaintiffs. The Trial Court found that the defendant has to
pay the balance consideration with interest from 10.03.1975 to
perfect his title. The plaintiffs’ suit was dismissed with the finding
that the plaintiffs were not entitled to; cancellation of the sale
deeds, declaration of ownership or the injunction as prayed for.
Insofar as the possession, the Trial Court refused to interfere,
since it found that there was no claim for specific performance or
reconveyance. We would rather justify the refusal to interfere in
the possession to be, by reason of a counter claim not having been
raised. Be that as it may, the Trial Court dismissed the suit, and
the First Appellate Court affirmed it.
6. In second appeal, two questions of law were framed by the
High Court: whether the sale deeds executed, without the entire
sale consideration being paid especially in the wake of the
Page 4 of 10

Civil Appeal No. 7225 of 2011

subsequent agreements as also the dues of the plaintiffs
remaining unpaid, can be found valid and binding on the plaintiffs
and the second question as to whether the plaintiffs were entitled
to a declaration of ownership and an injunction to retain peaceful
possession.
7. The High Court found that the clear recitals in the sale deeds
indicated that the defendant was obliged to satisfy the dues
existing in the name of the plaintiffs before the Government
Departments, Co-Operative Banks and Co-Operative Societies.
The finding of the Trial Court and the Appellate Court that there
was no conditional reconveyance stipulated, on the balance
consideration not being paid, was found to be wrong. It was found
that there was no evidence produced by the defendant to indicate
the balance sale consideration having been paid or the dues
remaining unpaid against the plaintiffs, having been satisfied. The
plaintiffs having agreed to repay the amount of Rs.5,000/- (Rupees
Five thousand), it was directed that the same be paid with 9%
simple interest from 10.03.1975 till 31.03.2010 and the suit was
decreed declaring the plaintiffs to be the owner of the lands
covered by the sale deeds vide Exhibit Nos.66 and 67, since the
Page 5 of 10

Civil Appeal No. 7225 of 2011

sale deeds were inoperative and the possession, if at all the
plaintiffs were deprived of it, was directed to be handed over.
8. Before us, learned Counsel for the appellants/legal heirs of
the defendant, specifically referred to two decisions of this Court
1
in Vidhyadhar v. Manikrao & Anr. and Dahiben v. Arvindbhai
Kalyanji Bhanusali (Gajra) Dead through Legal Representatives
2
& Ors.
9. Learned Counsel for the respondent on the other hand
emphasized that the view of the High Court flows from the findings
of the Trial Court itself. No fact finding of the Trial Court was
disturbed and it was merely on the aspect of law, the binding
nature of the sale deeds, in the absence of full consideration being
paid, the High Court reversed the Trial Court judgment and
decreed the suit. The High Court acted within the contours of the
jurisdiction conferred under Section 100 of the Civil Procedure
Code, 1908. It never reappreciated the evidence led or
substituted the findings of the Trial Court but merely gave legal
effect to the findings already rendered.

1
(1999) 3 SCC 573
2
(2020) 7 SCC 366
Page 6 of 10

Civil Appeal No. 7225 of 2011

10. In Vidhyadhar (supra), it was held so in Paragraph Nos.36,
37 and 38 with respect to Section 54 of the Transfer of Property
3
Act, 1882 :-
“ 36 . The definition indicates that in order to constitute a
sale, there must be a transfer of ownership from one
person to another, i.e., transfer of all rights and interests
in the properties which are possessed by that person are
transferred by him to another person. The transferor
cannot retain any part of his interest or right in that
property or else it would not be a sale. The definition
further says that the transfer of ownership has to be for a
“price paid or promised or part-paid and part-
promised”. Price thus constitutes an essential ingredient
of the transaction of sale. The words “price paid or
promised or part-paid and part-promised” indicate that
actual payment of the whole of the price at the time of the
execution of sale deed is not a sine qua non to the
completion of the sale. Even if the whole of the price is not
paid but the document is executed and thereafter
registered, if the property is of the value of more than Rs
100, the sale would be complete.
37 . There is a catena of decisions of various High Courts
in which it has been held that even if the whole of the price
is not paid, the transaction of sale will take effect and the
title would pass under that transaction. To cite only a few,
in Gayatri Prasad v. Board of Revenue [1973 All LJ 412] it
was held that non-payment of a portion of the sale price
would not affect validity of sale. It was observed that part-
payment of consideration by the vendee itself proved the
intention to pay the remaining amount of the sale price.
To the same effect is the decision of the Madhya Pradesh
High Court in Sukaloo v. Punau [AIR 1961 MP 176 : ILR
1960 MP 614].
38 . The real test is the intention of the parties. In order to
constitute a “sale”, the parties must intend to transfer the
ownership of the property and they must also intend that

3
Hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’
Page 7 of 10

Civil Appeal No. 7225 of 2011

the price would be paid either in praesenti or in future.
The intention is to be gathered from the recital in the sale
deed, the conduct of the parties and the evidence on
record.”

11. Dahiben (supra) also, while interpreting Section 54 of the
Act, held that actual payment of entire sale price at the time of
execution of sale deed is not an essential condition for completion
of sale. When a sale deed is registered, even upon part payment
of the sale price, title would pass to the transferee. The non-
payment of remaining part of the sale price would not invalidate
it and the remedy would be to recover the balance sale
consideration, but not cancellation of sale deed for non-payment
of balance sale consideration.
12. Section 54 of the Act squarely applies to the above case. A
reading of the translated sale deeds produced along with the
appeal, clearly indicates that the defendant had retained
Rs.4,500/- for clearing the dues of the plaintiffs. Obviously, the
same was not paid and later, by two agreements, the defendant
agreed to pay the full consideration and to repay all the
government loans.
13. The agreements were executed in the years 1975 and 1976.
The suit was filed in 1984, in which case, the question of limitation
Page 8 of 10

Civil Appeal No. 7225 of 2011

also arises. The plaintiffs, without filing a suit for recovery of
money; i.e., for balance sale consideration, attempted
cancellation of the sale deeds, after executing it on receipt of part
consideration, agreeing for the retention of balance consideration
with the defendant to satisfy the dues of the plaintiffs. The sale,
hence, has become final.
14. Even if we understand the High Court having not entered
into a reappreciation of facts, it is clear that the conclusion on the
available facts was wrong. The sale deed executed with full
knowledge of the part consideration alone having been passed,
cannot be rendered void or inoperative merely because the
balance consideration promised to be paid, which promise was
incorporated in the sale deed, had not been complied with. The
right of the plaintiffs was to file for recovery of balance sale
consideration and not to seek declaration that the sale deeds were
null and void; which they are not.
15. As has been noticed by the Trial Court, the appellants
herein would have to pay the balance sale consideration with
interest from 10.03.1975 at the rate of interest charged on the
Page 9 of 10

Civil Appeal No. 7225 of 2011

plaintiffs, by their creditors and seek possession of the property,
if at all they so desire.
16. The Trial Court and the First Appellate Court refused to
interfere with the possession of the plaintiffs, which we also are
not inclined to.
17. The Appeal stands allowed, reversing the judgment of the
High Court and restoring that of the Trial Court as affirmed by the
First Appellate Court.
18. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.


.……………………………... J.
(J. B. PARDIWALA)



..………….…………………. J.
(K. VINOD CHANDRAN)

NEW DELHI;
AUGUST 07, 2026.
Page 10 of 10

Civil Appeal No. 7225 of 2011