Kulbir Singh vs The New India Ins.Co.Ltd.

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH

1. FAO-2293-2005
KULBIR SINGH
......... Appellant
VERSUS
THE NEW INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
AND OTHERS
..... Respondents
2. XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M) in FAO-2294-2005
KULBIR SINGH
......... Appellant
VERSUS
THE NEW INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
AND ANOTHER

..... Respondents
3. FAO-2295-2005
KULBIR SINGH
......... Appellant
VERSUS
THE NEW INDIA INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
AND OTHERS
..... Respondents
1. Judgment reserved on 04.08.2026
2. Judgment pronounced on 21.09.2026
3. Judgment uploaded on 23.09.2026
4. Whether only operative part of the judgment is
pronounced or whether the full judgment is Full
pronounced.
5. The delay, if any of the pronouncement of full Nil
judgment and reason thereof.
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -2-
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHVIR SINGH RATHOR
Argued by : Mr. Maneet Kaushik, Advocate
for respondent No.2/cross-objector.
Ms. Vibhuti Narania, Amicus Curiae
for the appellant (Through V.C).
Mr. Puneet Sharma, Advocate with
Mr. Pavit Sohal, Advocate and
Ms. Oshin Swami, Advocate
for respondent No.1 in FAO-2295-2005.
Mr. Deepak Goyat, Advocate for
Ms. Veena Ashwani Talwar, Advocate
for respondent No.1-Insurance Company
in FAO-2293-2005.

YASHVIR SINGH RATHOR , J.
CM-19579-CII-2018
1. The present application has been filed under Section 5 of the
Limitation Act to condone the delay of 83 days in filing the cross-
objections.
2. In view of the reasons mentioned in the application, the same
is allowed and the delay of 83 days in filing the cross-objections is
condoned.
Main Cases
3. This judgment shall dispose of above noted three appeals
along with cross-objections, as the same have emanated out of the same
accident.
4. FAO-2293-2005 and FAO-2294-2005 have been instituted
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -3-
by the owner/insured against the Award dated 29.11.2004 passed by
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kaithal ( for short “Tribunal” ) in the
petitions under Section 166 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short
“Act”) , in MACT Case No.25 of 2002 and MACT Case No.59 of 2003
vide which a sum of Rs.2,73,000/- has been awarded as compensation to
the claimants Jabar Singh and others on account of death of Sompal and a
sum of Rs.40,000/- has been awarded as compensation to claimant
Chameli Devi on account of injuries suffered by her in a motor vehicular
accident due to the rash and negligent driving on the part of driver of jeep
bearing No.HR08-3278 ( hereinafter referred to as offending vehicle ),
resulting in the death of driver as well, which was owned by Kulbir
Singh-respondent No.1/appellant and insured with respondent No.2-New
India Insurance Company Limited. However, the Insurance Company has
been exonerated of its liability to indemnify the insured and respondent
No.1 has been held liable to pay compensation to the claimants. In FAO-
2294-2005, cross-objections bearing No.XOBJC-197-CII-2018 have been
instituted by injured namely Chameli Devi seeking enhancement of
compensation awarded to her vide Award dated 29.11.2004 in MACT
Case No.59 of 2003.
5. FAO-2295-2005 has been instituted by the owner/insured
against the Award dated 28.09.2004 passed by Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Kaithal in claim petition No.4 of 2002 vide which a sum of
Rs.40,000/- has been awarded as compensation to claimants Kamlesh and
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -4-
Naman on account of injuries suffered by them in the same accident due
to rash and negligent driving on the part of driver of the offending
vehicle. However, Insurance Company has been exonerated of its liability
to indemnify the insured but it has been directed to pay the amount to the
claimants and has been given a right to recover the same from the owner
of the offending vehicle.
6. From the pleadings of parties, following issues were framed
by learned Tribunal in MACT Case No.25 of 2002 and MACT Case
No.59 of 2003:-
1. Whether the accident in question took place due to
rash and negligent driving of jeep No.HR08-3278 by
its driver? OPP
2. Whether the petitioners are entitled to compensation,
if so to what amount and from whom? OPP
3. Whether the jeep in question was being driven against
the terms and conditions of insurance policy? OPR.
4. Relief.”
7. From the pleadings of parties, following issues were framed
by learned Tribunal in claim petition No.4 of 2002:-
1. Whether the accident dated 15.12.2001 at about
11.15 A.M. in the area of village Teek resulting into
injuries on the persons of the claimants took
place due to rash and negligent driving of jeep
no.HR08-3278 driven by respondent no.1? OPP
2. If issue No.1 is proved, whether the claimants are
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -5-
entitled for compensation, if so to what amount and
from whom? OPP
3. Whether the claim petition is not maintainable in the
present form? OPR
4. Whether respondent no.1 was not possessing valid
and effective D.L. at the time of alleged, as alleged?
OPR.
5. Relief.”
8. Thereafter, the parties led evidence in support of their
respective cases.
9. After hearing the parties and on going through the material
on record, learned Tribunal, while deciding Issue No.1, held that the
accident in question had taken place on account of rash and negligent
driving on the part of driver while driving the offending vehicle, owned
by Kulbir Singh and insured with New India Insurance Company
Limited. Under Issue No.3 in MACT Case No.25 of 2002 and MACT
Case No.59 of 2003, it was held that the insured has violated the terms
and conditions of the insurance policy. The vehicle in question was meant
for private use but at the time of accident, it was being used for
commercial purposes as passengers were being carried for hire and the
Insurance Company was exonerated of its liability to indemnify the
insured and claim petitions against the Insurance Company were
dismissed.
10. Under Issue No.4 in claim petition No.4 of 2002 also, the
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -6-
Insurance Company was exonerated of its liability to indemnify the
insured on the same ground but the Tribunal has held that after making
payment of the compensation amount to the claimants, Insurance
Company can recover the same from the owner/insured.
11. Feeling aggrieved, the appeals have been preferred by
owner/insured against the exoneration of Insurance Company to
indemnify the insured and cross-objections have been filed by cross-
objector/claimant for enhancement of the compensation. The material on
file has been perused and parties have been heard.
12. Learned counsel for the appellants-Amicus Curiae argued
that the Award passed by the learned Tribunal whereby the Insurance
Company has been exonerated of its liability to indemnify the insured is
based on conjectures and surmises. The facts of the case and evidence on
file have not been appreciated in the correct perspective. Learned counsel
further contended that the jeep in question was not involved in any
accident and false claim petitions have been instituted. Learned counsel
next contended that the Insurance Company has failed to establish that
the passengers had boarded the jeep for hire and paid fare and in the
absence of evidence to this effect, the Insurance Company could not have
been exonerated of its liability. Learned counsel next contended that even
as per law laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in (2004) 1 ACC 259,
National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Baljit Kaur and others , it is the
Insurance Company which is liable to satisfy the award at the first
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -7-
instance and it can be given the right to recover the same from the
owner/insured but learned Tribunal gravely erred in exonerating the
Insurance Company. Learned counsel next contended that in the absence
of evidence to prove fundamental breach of the violation of terms and
conditions of the insurance policy, the Insurance Company is liable to
indemnify the insured and appeals in hand be accepted and the Insurance
Company be held liable to pay compensation to the claimants.
13. Learned counsel for cross-objector-Chameli Devi in
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 contends that Tribunal has not appreciated the
facts of the case and evidence on file in the correct perspective while
assessing the compensation which is grossly inadequate. The claimant
had suffered 17% permanent disability and he has been awarded a total
compensation of Rs.40,000/- for the expenses incurred on treatment, pain
and suffering and permanent disability. Learned counsel further argued
that adequate compensation has not been awarded under pecuniary and
non-pecuniary heads and same is liable to be suitably enhanced. In
support of his contentions, learned counsel for the appellant has relied
upon 2014 (1) RCR (Civil) 914 Sanjay Verma Vs. Haryana Roadways,
2009(6) SCC 121 Sarla Verma and others Vs. Delhi Transport
Corporation and Another and 2017 (16) SCC 680 National Insurance
Co. Ltd Vs. Pranay Sethi and Others.
14. On the other hand, learned counsel for appellant in
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 in FAO-2294-2005 argued that the award in
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -8-
question is well reasoned and justified. The material on file has been
appreciated in the correct perspective while assessing the compensation
and no interference in the same is thus called for.
15. Learned counsel for Insurance Company contended that the
learned Tribunal has rightly appreciated the facts of the case and evidence

on file while coming to the conclusion that it was a private vehicle and
was being used for commercial purposes for carrying passengers for hire
and reward and the insured has thus violated the terms and conditions of
the insurance policy and in these circumstances, the Insurance Company
cannot be held liable to indemnify the insured. Learned counsel next
contended that the Insurance Company cannot be directed to satisfy the
Award and then to recover the amount from the insured as judgment
rendered by Hon’ble Supreme Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs.
Baljeet Kaur’s case (supra) has been recently distinguished by a
Division Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court in (2025) INSC 1219,
Amudhavalli and others Vs. HDFC Ergo General Insurance
Company Ltd. and others. Learned counsel has also relied upon (2023)
ACJ 1546, Balu Krishna Chavan Vs. The Reliance General Insurance
Company Limited and others.
ISSUE OF RASH AND NEGLIGENT DRIVING
16. So far as rash and negligent driving on the part of driver of
the offending vehicle is concerned, the Tribunal has arrived at a
conclusion that the vehicle in question was being driven at a high speed
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -9-
by its driver and it went out of control and dashed against the roadside
trees resulting in the accident and thereafter it turned turtle resulting in
the death of driver of the vehicle as well as Sompal and injuries to several
passengers. The very fact that the jeep struck against the roadside trees
and turned turtle itself goes to show that the same was being driven at a
high speed and in a rash and negligent manner and principle of res ipsa
loquitur will come into play i.e. the facts speak for themselves and
learned Tribunal while appreciating the testimony of eye-witnesses
examined by the claimants rightly came to the conclusion that accident in
question had taken place due to rash and negligent driving on the part of
the driver of the said jeep who himself died in the accident. There is thus
no reason to take a contrary view as the facts of the case and evidence on
file have been appreciated in the correct perspective while returning
finding on issue No.1 and same is accordingly affirmed.
ISSUE OF LIABILITY
17. So far as question of liability is concerned, Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Amudhavalli Vs. HDFC Ergo General Insurance Company
Ltd.’ case (supra) has held that a goods vehicle is not allowed to carry
passengers for hire or reward and in case, a gratuitous passenger is
carried in a commercial vehicle, it is a fundamental breach of the policy
conditions and insurer is not liable to indemnify the insured. It has been
further held that the principle of “pay and recover” is generally adopted
to avoid hardship to claimants when there is a breach of policy conditions
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -10-
but not in cases of fundamental breaches like carrying fare-paying
passengers in a goods vehicle. While distinguishing law laid down in
National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Baljeet Kaur , Hon’ble
Supreme Court has held as under:-
“8. In considering the measure of pay and recover, this
Court in Saju P. Paul (supra) noticed a number of decisions
where such measure was employed. National Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. Baljit Kaur and Others [4] was a case in which the
Tribunal and the High Court proceeded in terms of the
decisions of this Court in New India Assurance Company v.
Satpal Singh and Others[5] which was overruled in Asha
Rani (supra). Since the Tribunal and the High Court had
allowed the compensation based on Satpal Singh (supra),
the measure of pay and recover was adopted in the said
case. National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Challa Bharathamma &
Ors. [6] is yet another case in which 'pay and recover' was
ordered. Therein the breach of condition of policy was
projected insofar as the vehicle having not been covered by
a permit to ply for hire or reward. The finding of the High
Court as to the absence of permit not leading to violation of
policy condition, was reversed by this Court. Therein also
the measure of pay and recover was adopted.
[4] (2004) 2 SCC 1
[5] (2000) 1 SCC 237
[6] (2004) 8 SCC 517
9. National Insurance Company Limited v. Kaushalaya
Devi and Others [7] was a case in which an identical
condition of gratuitous passenger being carried in a good
carriage vehicle had resulted in the liability being mulcted
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -11-
on the owner and the insurer absolved of its liability to
indemnify. Therein it was directed that the amount deposited
by the insurer if withdrawn, it would be recovered from the
owner and if not returned, it would be refunded to the
insurance company, and the claimants would be entitled to
proceed against the owner for recovery of the award
amounts.
[7] (2008) 8 SCC 246
10. This is a case in which there was a fundamental
breach noticed and the deceased claimant, being a person
who travelled in the goods carriage after paying fare, the
damages for his death was not entitled to be indemnified by
the insurer. There was no amount deposited or paid by the
insurance company. In the above circumstances, we find
absolutely no reason to interfere with the order of the High
Court, especially, when it was passed before Satpal Singh's
case (supra) which stood overruled in Asha Rani (supra).
Shamanna (supra) was a case in which the driver did not
have a valid driving licence at the time of the accident in
which the pay and recover direction was issued, relying on
the decision in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh
and Others[8].
[8] (2004) 3 SCC 297”
18. In the present cases, the Tribunal while exonerating the
Insurance Company has held as under:-
“17. The learned counsel for the insurance company Shri
C.S. Gupta, Advocate argued that the jeep in question in
which the deceased and the injured/petitioners were
travelling was being driven on hire and reward as the
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -12-
passengers were loaded in the said jeep, as such, the jeep in
question was being driven against the terms and conditions
of the insurance policy.
18. The learned counsel for the petitioners and
respondent No.1 argued that there is no evidence that the
deceased and injured/ petitioner boarded the jeep as
passenger on payment of hire charges and even there is no
evidence that any charges were paid to the driver of the jeep
by the passengers, so the jeep was not being driven for hire
and reward and was not driven in contravention of the
insurance policy.
19. Ex.R4 the copy of insurance policy proves that jeep in
question was insured with the New India Assurance
Company, respondent no.2 but was no insured to be driven
for hire and reward carrying passengers.
20. The statement of Pawan Kumar PW-2 who was
travelling in the jeep at the time of accident proves that there
were 14-15 other passengers in the said jeep. He deposed
that he boarded the jeep from Dhand along with 12 others.
Two passengers boarded the jeep from Khanoda. The
statement of Subhash PW-4 who also boarded the jeep
proves that he boarded the jeep from Bus Stand Dhand. His
statement further proves during the course of cross
examination that the driver of the jeep was asking the
passengers to board the jeep. His statement further proves
that jeep was stopped at the way at Teek and other villages.
Thus it is proved that the driver of the jeep was boarding the
passengers in the said jeep after stopping the jeep on the
way wherever the passengers were found standing in wait of
bus or other vehicle. Non of the witness have deposed that
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -13-
they boarded the jeep free of costs and nothing was to be
paid by them to the driver of the jeep. Thus, the statement of
witnesses even produced by the petitioners are sufficient to
indicate that the driver of the jeep was picking the
passengers on the way and there could be no reason for him
to board the passengers free of costs without charging
anything as the jeep was over loaded with the passengers.
Thus, this evidence itself is sufficient to prove that the jeep
was being driven for hire and reward and the driver of the
jeep was carrying the passengers on payment of charges of
fare. So, it is proved that the jeep in question was being
driven against the terms and conditions of the insurance
policy. The jeep was not insured with the insurance company
to carry the passengers for reward, so the driver of the jeep
contravened the terms and conditions of the insurance policy
and jeep was being 'driven against the terms and conditions
of the insurance policy. As such, the insurance company is
not liable indemnify to insurer the respondent No.1. The
reliance can be placed on United India Insurance Co. Ltd
versus Ram Rati and others, 1997 ACJ 1124 where in that
case the owner-insured used the jeep for earning hire
charges in breach of terms of the insurance policy, it was
held that insurance company is not liable. Even the reliance
can be placed on Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. versus
Banamali Lenka and others AIR 1998 Orissa 163 wherein
that case the vehicle covered by police claimed to be car at
the time of accident, passengers and goods carried in it, it
was held that insurer is not liable for covering liability of
owner of vehicle because of contravention of provisions.
Therefore, the insurance company has no liability to
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -14-
indemnify the insurer. Hence, only respondent No.1 is liable
to pay compensation and respondent No.2 insurance
company is not liable. Accordingly, the issue no.2 is decided
in favour of the petitioners against respondent no.1 and
issue No.3 is decided in favour of the respondent no.2 and
against the petitioners as well as against the respondent no.
1.”
19. Learned Tribunal thus rightly held that the driver while
carrying passengers was stopping the vehicle whenever some more
passengers were found on the roadside and was allowing them to board
the jeep in question and the only inference in these circumstances that can
be drawn is that the driver was carrying the passengers for hire or reward
and he was not merely giving lift to the persons standing on the bus stop
or on the roadside. As such, from the evidence led on file, it is established
that the driver was asking the passengers to board the jeep from various
bus stops where they were waiting for the bus and Tribunal thus rightly
came to the conclusion that there is violation of terms and conditions of
the Insurance policy and exonerated the Insurance Company of its
liability to indemnify the insured.
20. Insurance Company has also been exonerated of its liability
to indemnify the insured in claim petition No.4 of 2002 decided vide
Award Dated 25.09.2004 against which FAO-2295-2005 has been
instituted. However, Insurance Company has been directed to satisfy the
award but has been given a right to recover the same from the insured.
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -15-
The Insurance Company has already paid the amount to the claimants and
it shall thus be entitled to recover the same from the insured in view of
the findings recorded above.
Analysis and assessment of compensation in XOBJC-197-CII-2018 in
FAO-2294-2005, arising out of MACT Case No.59 of 2003 :-
21. Coming to the assessment of compensation, the law is well
settled that the compensation to be awarded for injuries suffered by
victim in a motor vehicular accident should be just and equitable. Courts
have consistently held that while money cannot erase the pain, suffering,
or trauma but it is the only legal means to provide restitution and restore
the victim to his previous position as far as possible for which ‘just
compensation’ has to be assessed. It is also well settled that while it is
impossible to fully compensate for the loss of limb, life, or quality of life,
the compensation must be ‘Just’, meaning thereby, that it should be fair,
reasonable, and equitable based on the evidence and not merely a
‘Windfall’ or a ‘Pittance’. The core objective is to put the injured/victim
in the same position he would have been if the accident had not taken
place, to the extent money can do so. This approach ensures that the law
provides a realistic recompense for the trauma endured, rather than just
providing normal relief.
22. Hon'ble Supreme Court in 2013 (3) RCR (Civil) 934 -
G.Ravindranath @ R. Chowdary Vs. E. Srinivas and another , has
held that in a case of accident resulting in injuries to the victim, the
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -16-
compensation in personal injury cases should be determined under the
following heads:-
Pecuniary damages (Special damages)
(i) Expenses relating to treatment, hospitalization, medicines,
transportation, nourishing food and miscellaneous expenditure.
(ii) Loss of earnings (and other gains) which the injured would
have made had he not been injured, comprising:
(a) Loss of earning during the period of treatment;
(b) Loss of future earnings on account of permanent
disability
(iii) Future medical expenses.
Non-pecuniary damages (General damages)
(iv) Damages for pain, suffering and trauma as a consequence of
the injuries.
(v) Loss of amenities (and/or loss of prospects of marriage).
(vi) Loss of expectation of life (shortening of normal longevity).
In routine personal injury cases, compensation will be awarded
under heads (i), (ii) (a) and (iv) It is only in serious cases of injury, where
there is specific medical evidence corroborating the evidence of the
claimant that compensation will be granted under any of the heads (ii)
(b), (iii), (v) and (vi) relating to loss of future earnings on account of
permanent disability, future medical expenses, loss of amenities (and/or
loss of prospects of marriage) and loss of expectation of life.
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -17-
23. As per version of claimant Chameli Devi, she had suffered
multiple injuries including fractures in her head, collar bone, arm and
legs and she has spent huge amount on her treatment. She tendered in
evidence her MLR Ex.PB and the following injuries were found on her
person:-
1. Angulation of left wrist, advised Ortho, Surgeon
2. diffused swelling over left hip.
24. She also led in evidence the X-ray report, Ex.PC, which
shows that she had suffered fracture of radius bone deep, fracture of
pelvis and fracture left clavicle. She was also examined by Dr. Ranjeet
Ahlawat, who deposed that claimant was admitted in his hospital as an
indoor patient on 06.12.2001 and was discharged on 29.12.2001. She had
suffered multiple fractures of pelvis, fracture of left radius, fracture left
clavicle, fracture both bones left leg and fracture right tibia. Blood was
transfused and he had charged Rs.11,500/- from the patient. He also
tendered the discharge card Ex.PA. Besides this, claimant has also led in
evidence her disability certificate Ex.PD, issued by Board of Doctors of
Government hospital, Kaithal, which reads as under:-
"Chameli wife of Amar Singh, resident of Teek examined
today i.e. 29.4.2004 in Board with X-ray and treatment
report.
1. The patient is O/C right tibia with delayed union in non
functional position with steel patient is having pain,
tenderness 6% six
2. Patient is O/S fracture polvin left pelvic rami with pain
while sitting 3% Three.
3.O/C fracture calvicle with non union (left) 3% three.
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -18-
4. Restriction of left wrist joint flexion 5 Five with respect to
limbs.
Total 6+3+3+5=17 Seventeen.”
25. As such, claimant also suffered 17% permanent disability.
Besides this, she also produced medical bills worth Rs.6,000/- and in all,
she had spent Rs.17,500/- on her treatment. Tribunal awarded her a total
compensation of Rs.40,000/-under following heads:-
Sr. No. Head Amount
1. Expenses incurred on treatment Rs.20,000/-
2. Pain and suffering Rs.5,000/-
3. Future loss of earning due to Rs.15,000/-
disability
26. Claimant, in all, had suffered five fractures. It is a matter of
common knowledge that pain component in such injuries is enormous
and such injuries take a considerable time to heal. Taking into
consideration the severity of injuries and long duration of treatment,
claimant is held entitled to a sum of Rs.40,000/- on account of pain and
sufferings as against Rs.5,000/- awarded by the Tribunal.
27. Claimant had produced bills worth Rs.17,500/- for the
expenses incurred on treatment and tribunal has awarded her a total sum
of Rs.20,000/-for the expenses incurred on treatment and special diet etc,
which too is inadequate. It is a matter of common knowledge that patients
or their attendants do not preserve all the bills and some amount of
guesswork has to be applied while assessing the ‘expenses incurred on
treatment’. Therefore, taking into consideration the nature of injuries,
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -19-
claimant is held entitled to a sum of Rs.25,000/- for the ‘expenses
incurred on treatment and future treatment’ .
28. It must have taken at least six months for the injuries to heal,
as claimant remained admitted in the hospital for around one month. No
proof regarding income and occupation of claimant has been brought on
record. However, Hon'ble Supreme Court in (2022) 1 SCC 198, Chandra
alias Chander alias Chanda Ram and another Vs. Mukesh Kumar
Yadav , has held that merely because claimants are unable to produce
documentary evidence to show the monthly income of the deceased is not
a ground to discard the oral evidence and in such cases, the Court is
required to ensure just compensation based on preponderance of
probabilities. Minimum wage notification may serve as a yardstick but
cannot be the sole basis for assessing the income. Moreover, it is also
well settled that where the injured belongs to unorganized sector, strict
proof of income is not mandatory and notional income can be reasonably
assessed based on the social status and facts and circumstances of the
case. As such, some amount of guess work has to be applied while
assessing the income and since the accident had taken place in the year
2001, her monthly income is assessed as Rs.3,000/-.
29 . The age of the claimant was 40 years and as such, 25%
amount has to be added to her monthly income towards future prospects
in view of the law laid down in Sanjay Verma’s case (supra) and Pranay
Sethi’s case (supra) , which brings her income to Rs. 3,750/- (Rs.3,000/-
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -20-
+ Rs.750/-). However, in view of the nature of injuries suffered by the
claimant and the fact that she has suffered 17% permanent disability,
claimant would have difficulty in walking, running and sitting and will
not be able to lift any weight. As such, permanent disability to the extent
of 17% suffered by the claimant will certainly diminish her earning
capabilities. The compensation under the head ‘loss of income’ thus has
to be assessed keeping in view the percentage by which her earning
capability has been diminished and by applying a suitable multiplier in
view of law laid down by Hon'ble Supreme Court in 2010(4) PLR 242
Yadava Kumar Vs. The Divisional Manager, National Insurance
Company Limited . Since, claimant has suffered 17% permanent
disability, the monthly loss of income will thus come to Rs.638/-
(Rs.3,750/- × 17%) and the annual loss of income will come to Rs.7,656/-
(Rs.638/- × 12) and in view of law laid down in Pranay Sethi’s case

(supra) and Sarla Verma’s case (supra), multiplier of 15 has to be
applied as per Sarla Verma’s case (supra) , which takes the
compensation to Rs.1,14,840/- (Rs.7,656/- × 15).
30. It must have taken at least six months for the injuries to heal.
During this period of six months, the claimant would not have been able
to do any work and accordingly, she is held entitled to a sum of
Rs.18,000/- for loss of income during the period of treatment .
31. Claimant remained under treatment for six months and
during this period, she must have spent some amount on her nutritious
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -21-
diet, in engaging an attendant and on transportation. Accordingly, she is
held entitled to a sum of Rs.7,500/- for the expenses incurred on special
diet , a sum of Rs.9,000/- for engaging an attendant and a sum of
Rs.7,500/- on account of expenses incurred on transportation .
32. The claimant was 40 years of age at the time of the accident
and had suffered multiple fractures of pelvis, fracture left radius, fracture
left clavicle, fracture both bones left leg and fracture right tibia, besides
17% permanent disability. The injuries suffered by her were of serious in
nature and will adversely impact her normal life and day-to-day
activities. Considering the nature and severity of the injuries and the
permanent disability suffered by the claimant, she is held entitled to a
sum of Rs.20,000/- under the heads of ‘loss of amenities of life i.e.
discomfort, inconvenience, hardship and loss of expectancy of life’.
33. Resultantly, the compensation to be awarded to the claimant-
Chameli devi is assessed as under:-
Compensation Assessed by
Sr. No. Head of Compensation
this Court
1 Pain and sufferings Rs.40,000/-
2 Expenses incurred on treatment Rs.25,000/-
3 Loss of income during treatment Rs.18,000/-
4 Attendant charges Rs.9,000/-
5 Special diet Rs.7,500/-
6 Transportation charges Rs.7,500/-
7 Loss of amenities Rs.20,000/-
Loss of future income due to
8 Rs.1,14,840/-
permanent disability
Rs.2,41,840/- (rounded off
Total
to Rs.2,42,000/-)
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-2293-2005
XOBJC-197-CII-2018 (O&M)
in/and FAO-2294-2005
FAO-2295-2005 -22-
34. The enhanced compensation thus comes out to Rs.2,02,000/-
( Rs.2,42,000/- - Rs.40,000/- ).
35. As a result of afore-said discussion, appeals bearing
FAO-2294-2005, FAO-2293-2005 and FAO-2295-2005 filed by the
owner are dismissed while Cross-Objection bearing XOBJC-197-CII-
2018 filed by claimant-Chameli Devi is partly accepted with costs.
36. Claimants Chameli in XOBJC-197-CII-2018 in FAO-2294-
2005 is held entitled to a sum of Rs.2,02,000/- as enhanced compensation
over and above the compensation awarded by the Tribunal along with
interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of filing of claim
petition i.e. 02.01.2003 till realization payable by owner/respondent No.1.
37. Pending misc. application (s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
38. A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of connected
cases.
21.09.2026 (YASHVIR SINGH RATHOR)
Priyanka Thakur JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned Yes/No
Whether Reportable Yes/No
PRIYANKA THAKUR
2026.09.23 17:38
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document