SMT. L GEETHA vs SHRI. K PRABHU

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024







IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 17 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR

REGULAR FIRST APPEAL No. 2683 OF 2024 (EJE)

C/W

REGULAR FIRST APPEAL No. 650 OF 2020 (DEC/INJ)



IN RFA No. 2683/2024

BETWEEN:

SMT. L GEETHA
D/O SHRI V KUPPUSWAMY
AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
No.779, BDA ROW HOUSES
ND TH
DOMLUR 2 STAGE, 4 PHASE
BENGALURU-560 071.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI SHUJATH AHMED, ADVOCATE)

AND:

SHRI. K PRABHU
S/O V KUPPASWAMY
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
No.25, BOWBEE LANE
E –STREET, ASHOK NAGAR
BANGALORE-560 025.

…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI S K HEGDE, ADVOCATE FOR R1)








Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC,
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 04.09.2024
PASSED IN OS.No.1913/2020 ON THE FILE OF THE , XLII
ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE, BENGALURU
CITY, PARTLY DECREEING THE SUIT FOR EJECTMENT.

IN RFA No. 650/2020

BETWEEN:

SMT. K GEETHA
D/O SHRI V KUPPUSWAMY
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS
ND
No. 779, B.D.A ROW HOUSE, 2 STAGE
TH
4 PHASE, DOMLUR
BANGALURU – 560 071.
...APPELLANT

(BY SRI. NIKHIL KRISHNAMURTHY, ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. SHRI K PRABHU
S/O V KUPPASWAMY
AGED ABOUT 55 YERS
No. 71, BOVILAN MAKER ROAD
ASHOK NAGAR, BANGALORE.

2. VIJAYA BANK
TRINITY CIRCLE BRANCH
M G ROAD, BANGALORE – 560 001.
REPRESENTED BY IT’S MANAGER.
...RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. S K HEGDE, ADVOCATE CAV/R1
SRI NAARAJ DAMODAR, ADVOCATE FOR R2)

THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 R/W ORDER XLI
RULE 1 OF CPC, 1908 AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
DATED 15.10.2019 PASSED IN O S.No.8450/2012 ON THE FILE
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


OF THE XII ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE,
BENGALURU CITY, DISMISSING THE SUIT FOR DECLARATION
AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION.

THESE APPEALS HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR ORDERS ON 17.09.2026, THIS DAY, SHIVASHANKAR
AMARANNAVAR J , DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR

CAV JUDGMENT
RFA No.650/2020 is filed by the plaintiff challenging the
judgment and decree dated 15.10.2019 passed in
O.S.No.8450/2012 by the XII Additional City Civil and Sessions
Judge, Bangalore (CCH-27) where under suit of the
appellant/plaintiff came to be dismissed.
2. RFA No.2683/2024 is filed by the defendant
challenging the judgment and decree dated 04.09.2024 passed
in OS No.1913/2020 by XLII Additional City Civil and Sessions
Judge, Bengaluru City (CCH-43), where under the suit of the
respondent/plaintiff for ejectment came to be decreed.
3. The appellant in RFA No.650/2020 was the plaintiff,
and respondent No.1 was defendant No.1 and respondent No.2
was defendant No.2 before the trial Court in
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


O.S.No.8450/2012, and they will be referred to the rankings as
in the trial Court for the sake of convenience.
4. The appellant in RFA No.650/2020 has filed a suit in
O.S.No.8450/2012 seeking the following reliefs:

a) Declare that the Sale Deed dated 01.10.2007
executed by Plaintiff in favour of the Defendant
No.1 and registered as document
No.2543/2007-08 in Book-1 stored in
CD.No.SHVD-89 dated 01.10.2007, before
Sub-registrar, Shivajinagar, as fraudulent and
null and void;

b) Declare that the Mortgage Deed dated
19.10.2007, registered as document bearing
No.2741/2007-08, in Book-1 stored in CD
No.SHVD-90 dated 19.10.2007, before Sub-
registrar, Shivajinagar executed by Defendant
No.1 in favour of Defendant No.2, on the basis
of the said fraudulent Sale Deed is not binding
on the plaintiff.

c) Issue an order of permanent injunction to
restrain the Defendants or their henchmen or
anybody claiming under them from interfering
with the peaceful possession of the plaintiff of
the Schedule property;
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024



d) Issue an order of permanent injunction to
restrain the defendants or their henchmen or
anybody claiming under them from alienating
the Suit Schedule Property;

e) Pass such other orders as this Hon’ble Court
deems fit and necessary in the interest of
justice and equity.

5. The case of the appellant/plaintiff before the trial
Court is as under:
(i) The defendant No.1 is younger brother of
the plaintiff who was working with defendant
No.2/Bank. Plaintiff is absolute owner of the suit
schedule property. The suit schedule property was
initially allotted to the plaintiff's father
Sri.V.Kuppuswamy by Bengaluru Development
Authority vide allotment letter dated 19.03.1984.
Subsequently, BDA has executed lease cum sale
agreement dated 07.11.1984 in favour of plaintiff's
father and he was put in possession of the suit
schedule property. Thereafter on completion of the
tenure of the lease cum sale agreement, BDA has
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


executed absolute sale deed dated 02.04.2005
registered on 03.05.2005 in favour of
Sri.V.Kuppaswamy. Accordingly, BDA has transferred
Khata Certificate in the name of said Kuppuswamy.
After that Kuppuswamy out of love and affection
gifted the suit schedule property in favour of the
appellant/plaintiff under registered gift deed dated
25.02.2006. Subsequently, all the revenue records
were mutated in plaintiff's name and since then the
plaintiff is in possession and enjoyment of the suit
schedule property.
(ii) The plaintiff due to some financial
emergency had taken loan from M/s.BDA Housing
Co-operative Society to the tune of Rs.4,00,000/-
and mortgaged the suit schedule property in favour
of BDA Housing Co-operative Society as security for
the repayment of the loan amount. Thereafter the
plaintiff had repaid said loan to the tune of
Rs.2,00,000/-. However, due to monetary problems
the plaintiff was not able to pay the remaining
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


balance amount of Rs.2,00,000/- with the interest.
The plaintiff approached defendant No.1 for monitory
assistance and requested him to assist in clearing the
debt with BDA Housing Co-operative Society for an
amount of Rs.2,00,000/-. The defendant No.1 agreed
to support the plaintiff in clearing the debt of
Rs.2,00,000/-. Accordingly, during last week of
September 2007, defendant No.1 approached the
plaintiff and informed that he being employee of
defendant No.2/Bank will help the plaintiff in getting
the loan at a lesser rate of interest so that the
plaintiff can clear the loan of BDA Housing Co-
operative Society and requested the plaintiff to sign
few papers claiming to be loan application form etc.
Thereafter on 25.09.2007 the defendant No.1
handed over DD bearing No.936291 drawn on Vijaya
Bank at Trinity Circle Branch, Bangalore, for an
amount of Rs.2,74,254/- in order to clear the
plaintiff's debt in BDA Housing Co-operative Society
and requested the plaintiff to obtain a loan discharge
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


certificate. Accordingly, plaintiff closed the loan of
BDA Housing Co-operative Society and obtained the
loan discharge certificate from the said Society and
handed over all the original title deeds of scheduled
property to defendant No.1. Thereafter defendant
No.1 requested the plaintiff to come to Sub-Register
Office, Shivajinagar, on 01.10.2007 for registering
the loan agreement as well as mortgage deed in
favour of defendant No.2/Bank. Believing the said
representation of defendant No.1, on 01.10.2007,
plaintiff visited the Sub Register Office and signed
the papers furnished to the plaintiff by the defendant
No.1. However, plaintiff could not read the contents
of the same as the plaintiff is an illiterate except
affixing signatures. Upon registering, defendant No.1
requested to get the loan discharge certificate from
BDA Housing Co-operative Society. Accordingly,
plaintiff got loan discharge certificate registered from
BDA Housing Co-operative Society on 04.10.2007
and handed over the same to defendant No.1.
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


Thereafter, plaintiff used to pay the defendant No.1 a
sum of Rs.3,000/- in cash every month towards
repayment of the loan of defendant No.2/Bank as per
the instructions of defendant No.1. Such being the
case, recently defendant No.1 came to plaintiff's
house and created ruckus and galata with the
plaintiff and her family members and warned the
plaintiff that he will dispossess the plaintiff and her
family members and claimed to be the owner of the
suit schedule property. However, the plaintiff refused
to the statement of defendant No.1 that he is owner
of the suit schedule property. The defendant No.1
said that the plaintiff has executed sale deed in his
favour to close the loan taken from BDA Housing Co-
operative Society.
(iii) The plaintiff immediately thereafter on
25.10.2012 along with well wishers visited and
verified with the Sub- Registrar Office and came to
know the fact that defendant No.1 taking undue
advantage of the fact that plaintiff being illiterate
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


except signing has misrepresented the plaintiff that
she could be executing a loan agreement in favour of
defendant No.2/Bank and fraudulently obtained the
signature of the plaintiff on sale deed. The plaintiff
being illiterate and trusting defendant No.1 signed
the sale deed believing it to be loan agreement. In
the said sale deed, total sale consideration is
mentioned as Rs.8,00,000/-. However, the plaintiff
has not received any sale consideration either by
cash or cheque towards execution of the fraudulent
sale deed.
(iv) Defendant No.1 has fraudulently executed
sale deed and further defendant No.1 on the basis of
above said fraudulent sale deed has obtained the
loan from the defendant No.2/Bank and mortgaged
the original title deeds of the suit schedule property
with the defendant No.2/Bank behind the plaintiff
fraudulently.
(v) That even today plaintiff along with 7
family members has been in possession of the suit
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


schedule property. The plaintiff does not have any
property other than this suit schedule property and
the plaintiff's family is totally dependent upon the
plaintiff. The plaintiff has lodged police complaint
before the jurisdictional police i.e. Halsoor Police
against the defendants for these above said acts.
However, the jurisdictional police instead of initiating
action against defendant No.1 has issued
endorsement stating that complaint contents are civil
in nature and directed the plaintiff to approach
competent Court of law. With these pleadings the
plaintiff has sought the above said reliefs.
6. The defendant No.1 has filed a written statement and
contended as under:
(i) The plaintiff has not approached the Court
with clean hands and suppressed the material facts
and the suit of the plaintiff is liable to be dismissed
without going to the merits of the case.
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


(ii) The plaintiff who was owner of the suit
schedule property was in need of money to meet
her family necessities and also to celebrate her
daughter's marriage in the year 2007. Accordingly,
she wanted to sell the suit schedule property and
instead of selling the suit schedule property to third
persons plaintiff has agreed to sell the suit schedule
property to defendant No.1 who is her younger
brother. Accordingly, on 23.05.2007 a sale
agreement was entered into between plaintiff and
defendant No.1 under which plaintiff has agreed to
sell the suit schedule property for total
consideration of Rs.8,00,000/-.
(iii) Subsequently, defendant No.1
approached Vijaya Bank, Trinity Circle Branch, i.e.
second defendant for housing loan to purchase the
suit schedule property. The Bank after obtaining
legal scrutiny report about the title of the plaintiff
has sanctioned housing loan of Rs.7,00,000/- and
out of the housing loan of Rs.7,00,000/- since the
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


property was mortgaged to BDA Housing
Cooperative Society, a sum of Rs.2,74,254/- was
paid by way of a pay order No.936291 dated
25.09.2007 towards discharge of the balance loan
of the plaintiff with the Society and a sum of
Rs.3,25,746/- was paid by pay order bearing No.
92013593 dated 01.10.2007 in the name of plaintiff
and a sum of Rs.2,00,000/- was paid by cash.
Thus, the plaintiff has executed sale deed in favour
of the defendant in respect of suit schedule
property for total consideration of Rs.8,00,000/-
and was put in possession of suit schedule property
and also handed over all the original documents.
(iv) Since the plaintiff was in need of the
amount and wanted to sell the property instead of a
third party purchasing the property being original
allotted by BDA to the father of the plaintiff and
defendant No.1, it was mutually agreed and
decided that the defendant No.1 shall purchase the
property for valuable consideration.
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


(v) At the time of execution, the property was
in possession of the tenants on mortgage/lease
basis. The property consists of ground first, second
and third floors. Since the plaintiff was not able to
repay the advance amount, which was paid by the
respective tenants to her without there being any
rent payable by the tenant, defendant No.1 has
paid to the respective parties who were in
possession of respective portions and taken vacant
possession. The amount paid to the respective
tenants which were inducted by the plaintiff and
who were in possession on the date of purchase
was out of the total sale price fixed between the
plaintiff and defendant No.1. Defendant No.1 had
agreed to pay Rs.4,00,000/- which was paid to the
plaintiff by tenant R.Ramendra who is in possession
of first floor. Defendant No.1 has given ground floor
portion to his mother and brother Ashoka to stay
without rent and third floor to his brother Niranjan.
At the time of purchase one Sri. K. Eshwar was in
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


occupation of the third floor and defendant No.1
has paid Rs.1,29,500/- at the time of vacating the
house. The said amount was received by the
plaintiff. The lease amount and the amount repaid
at the time of quitting has also been considered as
sale consideration. Further prior to sale, the plaintiff
has taken the loan from defendant No.1 amounting
to Rs.1,50,000/- and the said amount was taken as
a sale value.
(vi) The plaintiff who was in need of the
house approached defendant No.1 with a request to
lease the second floor portion in her favour instead
of giving the property to some other third party.
Considering the said request of the plaintiff,
defendant No.1 instead of giving the property to
third party has decided to give it to plaintiff being
his sister. Therefore, lease deed was entered on
11.10.2007 to lease the property to the plaintiff
consisting of one bedroom, hall kitchen, bathroom
and toilet in the second floor of the suit schedule
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


property on monthly rent of Rs.4,000/-. The
plaintiff has paid the rent regularly till January,
2011 and since February 2011 she has failed to pay
the rent inspite of demand by defendant No.1.
(vii) Therefore, when the plaintiff No.1
demanded the plaintiff to pay the rent, plaintiff is
making allegations of fraud and misrepresentation
and has filed the case with malafide intention to
knock off the valuable property of defendant No.1.
(viii) The defendant No.1 is regularly paying
interest to the Bank and also amount towards
principal. Defendant No.1 got issued legal notice on
04.03.2013 terminating tenancy and directed the
plaintiff to hand over the portion of the property
which is in her occupation and said notice was duly
served on the plaintiff and she got issued reply
through her advocate on 22.03.2013.
(ix) The plaintiff voluntarily on her volition
executed sale deed for valuable consideration. The
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


amount of Rs.3,25,746/- given by way of DD was
credited to the account of plaintiff and she has
utilized the same from time to time by withdrawing
the amount. Further a sum of Rs.2,74,254/- paid
by way of a pay order dated 25.09.2007 towards
the discharge of the loan amount of BDA Housing
Co-operative Society was paid to the Society.
Therefore, there is no question of any fraud or
misrepresentation in obtaining the sale deed in
respect of plaint schedule property from the
plaintiff.
(x) Plaintiff has not given necessary evidence
and details about the allegations of fraud and
misrepresentation in plaint as required under the
provisions of Civil Procedure Code. With these
contentions the defendant No.1 had prayed to
dismiss the suit.
7. Defendant No.2 has filed written statement contending
as under :
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


(i) The defendant No.1 approached the
defendant No.2 for grant of financial assistance to
purchase the suit schedule property from the
plaintiff. Second defendant after obtaining legal
scrutiny report from the panel advocate and also
considering the title of the plaintiff has agreed to the
first defendant to purchase the suit schedule
property. Accordingly, housing loan was sanctioned
and out of the loan sanctioned a sum of
Rs.2,74,254/- was paid by way of deed in favour of
BDA Housing Co-operative Society as the plaintiff has
created charge in favour of the said society and
another sum of Rs.3,25,746/- was paid by way of DD
in the name of the plaintiff and the said DD was
credited to the SB account of the plaintiff at its
Branch.
(ii) Plaintiff was the absolute owner and after
sanction of the loan by the defendant No.2 to the
first defendant, she has executed absolute sale deed
in favour of the defendant No.1 and he has executed
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


registered memorandum of deposit of title deeds
registered on 19.10.2007. Accordingly, the title
deeds in the name of the first defendant and other
parent documents of the suit schedule property have
been deposited by the defendant No.1 with
defendant No.2. Second defendant has got charge
over the suit schedule property having advanced the
housing loan to the first defendant.
(iii) Second defendant has no knowledge about
the plaintiff approaching defendant No.1 in good faith
for monetary assistance and also he informed to get
a loan from second defendant for lower rate of
interest. The plaintiff has not approached the second
defendant for any loan. On the other hand, it is the
first defendant who approached the second
defendant for loan to purchase the suit schedule
property and the plaintiff has also executed
agreement of sale dated 23.05.2007 in favour of first
defendant agreeing to sell the suit schedule property
in favour of the first defendant. Accordingly, second
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


defendant has granted loan to purchase the schedule
property and first defendant has availed the housing
loan and purchased the suit schedule property. The
first defendant is paying monthly installments in
terms of the loan granted to him.
(iv) The plaintiff has voluntarily come to the
Sub-Registrar Office and executed sale deed and
subsequently the defendant No.1 has registered the
Memorandum of Deposit of Title Deeds. The
defendant suspects a collusion between defendant
No.1 and the plaintiff being brother and sister to
defraud the Bank which has advanced the loan to the
defendant No.1 on the security of the suit schedule
property.
(v) The statement that on the basis of
fraudulent sale deed the first defendant obtained a
loan from the defendant No.2 is also not correct. The
statement made in the plaint that the plaintiff being
illiterate and trusting the defendant No.1 signing the
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


sale deed believing it to be loan agreement is totally
false and the same is denied.
(vi) The plaintiff voluntarily on her own volition
executed the sale deed for valuable consideration.
The sale deed executed by the plaintiff in favour of
first defendant No.1 is legal and valid document and
it cannot be called as a fraudulent sale deed in any
manner and the defendant No. 2 has got valuable
right over the suit schedule property being a
mortgagee having advanced the loan.

8. On the basis of the above pleadings the following
issues have been framed:
1) Does the plaintiff prove that, she is the owner
of the plaint schedule property?
2) Does the plaintiff prove that, she was in
possession of the suit property on the date of
filing the suit?
3) Does the plaintiff prove that, defendants are
interfering in her possession over the same?
4) Does the plaintiff prove that, the sale deed
executed by her in favour of the defendant
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


No.1 on 01.10.2007 is not binding on her for
the reasons stated in the plaint?
5) Does the plaintiff prove that, the registered
mortgage deed executed by defendant No.1 in
favour of defendant No.2 with respect to the
schedule property on 19.10.2007 is not binding
on the plaintiff for the reasons stated in the
plaint?
6) Does the plaintiff prove that, she is entitled for
the relief prayed in the plaint?
7) What order or decree?

9. The plaintiff has been examined as P.W.1 and got
marked Exs.P1 to P14. The defendant No.1 has been
examined as DW.1 and examined DWs.2 to 6 and got
marked Exs.D1 to D44. The trial Court after hearing the
arguments and appreciating the evidence on record has
answered issue Nos. 1, 3, 4, 5, 6 in the negative and issue
No. 2 in the affirmative and dismissed the suit of the
appellant/plaintiff by the impugned judgment. The said
judgment and decree dated 15.10.2019 has been
challenged by the plaintiff in RFA No.650/2020.
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


10. After dismissal of the said suit in
O.S.No.8450/2012, defendant No.1 - Sri.K.Prabhu, has
filed a suit against the plaintiff, Mrs.L.Geetha in
O.S.No.1913/2020 for ejectment and recovery of arrears of
rent, contending that the lease has been terminated by
issuance of legal notice dated 04.03.2013, with effect from
31.03.2013, and the suit filed by the plaintiff in
O.S.No.8450/2012 has been dismissed. The said suit has
been contested by Mrs.L.Geetha, who was the plaintiff, in
O.S.No.8450/2012. The said suit came to be decreed by
judgment and decree dated 04.09.2024. The said
judgment and decree passed in O.S.No.1913/2020 has
been challenged by the defendant of that suit in RFA
No.2683/2024. The said two appeals in RFA No.650/2020
and RFA No.2683/2024 have been tagged together for
disposal.
11. Heard arguments of learned counsel for appellant
in both appeals, learned counsel for Respondent No.1 in
RFA 650/2020, learned counsel for respondent No.2 in RFA
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


650/2020 and learned counsel for respondent in RFA
No.2683/2024.
12. Learned counsel for appellant in RFA
No.650/2020 and RFA No.2683/2024 would contend that
the appellant is the absolute owner of the suit schedule
property by virtue of the gift deed dated 25.02.2006
executed by her father in her favour and she had
mortgaged the said property in favour of BDA Housing Co-
operative Society under Mortgage Deed–Ex.P3 dated
25.04.2006. The appellant in order to repay the balance
amount borrowed from BDA Housing Co-operative Society
requested the respondent No.1/defendant No.1 to get a
loan from his bank at a lower interest and respondent
No.1/defendant No.1 in the guise of the same got the
signatures of the appellant/plaintiff on documents and
created a sale agreement, rent agreement and also asked
the appellant/plaintiff to come to Sub-Registrar Office on
01.10.2007 so as to execute mortgage deed in favour of
respondent No.2/Bank and believing the words of
respondent No.1, the appellant went to the Sub-Registrar
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


Office and without seeing/verifying the document affixed
her signature on it, believing that it is a mortgage deed.
Subsequently, she came to know that the document what
she has executed is not the mortgage deed, but it is a sale
deed when respondent No.1 asked her to vacate the suit
schedule property. The appellant had studied only up to
third standard in the Tamil medium and she is not able to
read and understand the sale deed which was in English
language. The signature of Sudhakaran in lease agreement
and sale deed are different. P.W.1, who is the appellant
herein, has stated that she has not read the contents of
Ex.P11-lease agreement. Even though the eviction notice
has been issued on 07.03.2013, but the suit for ejectment
has been filed in the year 2020. The appellant has got
issued reply to the said legal notice/eviction notice on
22.03.2013 under Ex.P4 contending that she is the owner
of the suit property. Even inspite of that, respondent No.1
kept quiet till the year 2020 without filing suit for ejection.
The trial Court has not given proper reasons while
answering issue No.1. D.W.2 is the brother of plaintiff and
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 26 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


defendant No.1 and D.W.5 is sister’s son of plaintiff and
defendant No.1 and son-in-law of defendant No.1. They
are interested in respondent No.1/defendant No.1. The
amount credited to the bank account of the
appellant/plaintiff has been withdrawn by cheques and on
back of one of the cheque- Ex.D25 is the signature of one
Mohan Raj. D.W.1 in his chief examination has stated that
the sale consideration is Rs.16,00,000/- but the sale deed
indicate the sale consideration has Rs.8,00,000/-.
Defendant No.1 put forth contention that he has paid the
said amounts to the tenants for refunding lease amount /
security deposit.
13. Learned counsel for appellant further contends
that there is a misrepresentation by respondent
No.1/defendant No.1 as to the nature of the document and
its contents and therefore, the said sale deed said to have
been executed by plaintiff in favour of defendant No.1 is
void. On that point he places reliance on the following
decisions:
•
1968 SCC Online SC 206
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 27 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


Ningawwa vs. Byrappa Shiddappa Hireknrabar
and
Others
•
1990 SCC Online SC 458
Dularia Devi vs. Janardan Singh and others
•

(2024) 18 SCC 677
Ramathal and others vs. K.Rajamani (dead)
through
LRs and another
•

1966 SCC Online SC 103
Subhas Chandr Das Mushib vs. Ganga Prasad
Das
Mushib and others

14. The learned counsel further submits that
respondent No.1 in his suit for ejectment has only claimed
damages from 01.03.2017 even though the eviction notice
has been issued in the year 2013 and reason for the same
has not been stated in the plaint. He submits that there is
no any reason for the appellant/plaintiff to sell her valuable
property only for repayment of balance loan amount of
Rs.2,00,000/- to BDA Housing Co-operative Society and
the illiteracy of the plaintiff has been misused by her
brother - defendant No.1 in getting executed the sale deed
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 28 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


misrepresenting the appellant/plaintiff. The trial Court has
not appreciated the evidence on record properly. With this
he prayed to allow the appeals.
15. Learned counsel for respondent No.1 in RFA
No.650/2020 and respondent in RFA No.2683/2024 would
contend that the plaintiff became defaulter of repayment of
the loan amount to the BDA Housing Co-operative Society
and auction notice has been issued to her. In order to
repay the amount due to BDA Housing Co-operative
Society and to perform the marriage of her daughter, the
appellant gave a proposal to defendant No.1 to purchase
the property and executed a sale agreement -Ex.D31 on
23.08.2007 for sale consideration of Rs.8,00,000/- and
received Rs.2,00,000/- in cash as advance sale
consideration. Respondent No.1/defendant No.1 on the
basis of the said sale agreement applied for a loan with
respondent No.2/Bank and respondent No.2/Bank has
granted the loan and out of the loan amount,
Rs.2,74,254/- has been paid to BDA Housing Co-operative
Society towards the balance loan amount of the
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 29 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


appellant/plaintiff and Rs.3,25,746/- has been credited to
the bank account of the appellant/plaintiff. The BDA
Housing Co-operative Society has executed a loan
discharge certificate dated 28.09.2007 and it has been
registered subsequently. The appellant/plaintiff was aware
of process of registration in Sub-Registrar Office as she
earlier was beneficiary of the gift deed and she has
executed mortgage deed in favour of BDA Housing Co-
operative society. The said aspect has been considered by
the trial Court by extracting her cross-examination. Even
after sale deed, the plaintiff continued in the possession of
the second floor of the property under lease agreement -
Ex.D12 dated 11.10.2007 and she has paid rent only for
some period and as she did not pay the further rent, notice
has been issued to her on 04.03.2013 as per Ex.P15 and
she sent a reply to the said notice stating that she has filed
suit seeking declaration and she has been defrauded by
defendant No.1. Sri.K.Eshwar was tenant in a portion of
the suit schedule property has executed Ex.D13 -receipt
for having received Rs.1,29,500/- from defendant No.1 and
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 30 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


he has also given evidence as D.W.2 and stated that the
plaintiff offered to sell the suit schedule property to
defendant No.1 as she has to repay the loan to the BDA
Housing Co-operative society and to perform marriage of
her daughter. The amount paid by the plaintiff in a sum of
Rs.3,000/- per month is not towards loan installment but it
is towards rent of the portion of the property in which she
was residing. D.W.5 is one Sudhakaran and he is the
witness to the sale deed - Ex.P4 (Ex.D1) executed by
plaintiff in favour of defendant No.1 registered on
01.10.2007. He has also given evidence in that regard that
the plaintiff, after understanding the contents of the sale
deed, has executed it in favour of defendant No.1.
Learned counsel for respondent No.1 has placed reliance
on the decisions which are relied upon before the trial
Court and they are as under:
1. AIR 2009 SC page 3293
Bellachi (Dead) by L.R v. Pakeeran
2. AIR 1986 Madhya Pradesh 106
Hajra Bai and others v. Jadavba
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 31 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


3. AIR 1991 Gauhati 58
Asman Ali Laskar alias Jamir Uddin vs.
Forjan Ali Barbhuiya

4. AIR 2001 Allahabad 353
Ali Hasan Saifi v. Satish Kuma

16. The learned counsel for respondent No.1
further contended that the details of fraud have not been
stated in the plaint as required under the provisions of Civil
Procedure Code. The plaintiff has not established that
defendant No.1 has played fraud and got executed the sale
deed. The sale deed has been proved by the evidence of
D.W.5, who is one of the attesting witnesses and by
showing the passing of the consideration. The plaintiff has
withdrawn the amount credited to her bank account which
is credited by respondent No.2/bank to her bank account in
a sum of Rs.3,25,746/- and she has withdrawn the amount
several times. The plaintiff has not paid property tax of the
suit schedule property from 2007 and that itself clearly
indicate that she has executed sale deed in favour of the
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 32 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


defendant No.1 in the year 2007 and stopped paying the
property taxes. Considering all these aspects, the trial
Court has rightly dismissed the suit of the plaintiff in
O.S.No.8450/2012 and rightly decreed the ejectment suit
filed by the respondent No.1 in O.S.No.1913/2020.
17. Learned counsel for respondent No.2 would
contend that defendant No.1 has availed loan from the
bank for purchase of suit schedule property and loan of
Rs.6,00,000/- has been sanctioned and out of the same,
Rs.2,74,254/- has been paid to the BDA Housing Co-
operative Society for clearing the dues of the plaintiff and
Rs.3,25,746/- is credited to the bank account of the
plaintiff. Defendant No.1 now has repaid the said loan
amount borrowed by him from defendant No.2/Bank.
18. In reply, the learned counsel for appellant
would contend that the plaintiff was working as maid
servant and as she is illiterate she was not able to read
and understand the contents of the document which she
has executed. In the sale deed there is no endorsement
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 33 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


that the contents of the sale deed have been executed as
she is illiterate.
19. Having heard the learned counsels, the Court
has perused the judgment, decree and trial Court records.
20. The following points arise for consideration:

(i) Whether the appellant/plaintiff has
proved that respondent No.1(defendant
No.1) has misrepresented and played
fraud and got executed sale deed dated
01.10.2007 in respect of suit schedule
property in the guise of getting executed
mortgage deed in favour of respondent
No.2(defendant No.2/Bank)?

(ii) Whether the trial Court is justified in
dismissing O.S.No.8450/2012?

(iii) Whether the trial Court is justified in
decreeing O.S.No.1913/2020?

Re-Point Nos.1 and 2
21. The facts which are not in dispute are that the
father of appellant/plaintiff and respondent No.1/defendant
No.1 was owner of the suit schedule property and he
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 34 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


executed gift deed dated 25.02.2006 in favour of
appellant/plaintiff. The appellant/plaintiff got mutated her
name in revenue records and she has been in possession
of the suit schedule property as owner. The
appellant/plaintiff due to some financial difficulty took loan
of Rs.4,00,000/- from M/s BDA Housing Co-operative
Society and mortgaged the suit schedule property in favour
of M/s BDA Housing Co-operative Society as a security for
repayment of loan amount. The plaintiff repaid the said
loan to the tune of Rs.2,00,000/- and there was balance
amount of Rs.2,00,000/- along with the interest.
22. The case of defendant No.1 is that plaintiff in
order to repay the debt to M/s BDA Housing Co-operative
Society as it had issued auction notice had approached him
for sale of suit schedule property for the purpose of
repayment of the loan amount and also for performing
marriage of her daughter and he agreed to purchase the
suit schedule property for Rs.8,00,000/- and plaintiff
entered into sale agreement dated 23.08.2007 (Ex.D31)
agreeing to sell the suit schedule property for
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 35 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


Rs.8,00,000/- and received an advance of Rs.2,00,000/-
by cash. Thereafter defendant No.1 availed a loan of
Rs.6,00,000/- from defendant No.2/Bank and the Bank has
sanctioned a loan of Rs.6,00,000/- out of that DD has been
issued in favour of BDA Housing Co-operative Society for
Rs.2,74,254/- and another DD has been credited to the
bank account of the plaintiff in a sum of Rs.3,25,746/- and
the plaintiff has executed registered sale deed dated
1.10.2007 in favour of the defendant No.1 by registered
document. The plaintiff contended that she approached
defendant No.1 - her brother, to assist her in clearing the
debt with BDA Housing Co-operative Society for an amount
of Rs.2,00,000/- and defendant No.1 agreed to support her
in clearing the debt and he told her that he will get a loan
from his bank for lesser rate of interest and on 25.09.2007
handed over DD for Rs.2,74,254/- in order to clear the
debt of BDA Housing Co-operative society and asked her to
get loan discharge certificate and she closed the loan of
BDA Housing Co-operative society and obtained loan
discharge certificate and handed over all original title
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 36 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


deeds of the suit schedule property to defendant No.1.
Defendant No.1 requested her to come to Sub-Registrar
office on 01.10.2007 for registering loan agreement as well
as mortgage deed in favour of defendant No.2/Bank and
believing the representation of defendant No.1, she went
to the Sub-Registrar office and signed papers furnished to
her by the defendant No.1 and without reading the
contents, she affixed her signature on document furnished
by defendant No.1 and she got loan discharge certificate
registered from BDA Housing Co-operative Society on
04.10.2007 and handed over the same to defendant No.1
and she used to pay Rs.3,000/- in cash every month to
defendant No.1 for repayment of loan of defendant
No.2/Bank and she came to know the sale of suit schedule
property only after defendant No.1 came to her house and
created ruckus and galata and on getting the documents
from Sub-Registrar office.
23. Considering the said aspect, the contention of
the appellant/plaintiff is that the defendant No.1 has
misrepresented and played fraud against her and got
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 37 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


executed a sale deed dated 01.10.2007 in respect of suit
schedule property in the guise of getting executed
mortgage deed in favour of respondent No.2(defendant
No.2/Bank).
24. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Ningawwa
(supra) has considered a case of fraud and
misrepresentation and observed as under:
“5.The legal position will be different if
there is a fraudulent misrepresentation not
merely as to the contents of the document
but as to its character. The authorities make
a clear distinction between fraudulent
misrepresentation as to the character of the
document and fraudulent misrepresentation
as to the contents thereof. With reference to
the former, it has been held that the
Transaction is void, while in the case of the
latter, it is merely voidable. In Foster v.
Mackinon(2) the action was by the endorsee
of a bill of exchange. The defendant pleaded
that he endorsed the bill on a fraudulent
representation by the acceptor that he was
signing a guarantee. In holding that such a
plea was admissible, the Court observed :
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 38 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


"It (signature) is invalid not merely
on the ground of fraud, where fraud
exists, but on the ground that the
mind of the signer did not
accompany the signature; in other
words, that he never intended to
sign, and therefore in contemplation
of law never did sign, the contract to
which his name is appended .... The
defendant never intended to sign
that contract or any such contract.
He never intended to put his name
to any instrument that then was or
thereafter might become negotiable.
He was deceived, not merely as to
the legal effect, but as to the ,actual
contents' of the instrument."
This decision has been followed by the
Indian courts-Sanni Bibi v. Siddik
Hossain(3), and Brindaban v. Dhurba
Charan(4). It is not the contention of the
appellant in the present case that there was
any fraudulent misrepresentation as to the
character of the gift deed but Shiddappa
fraudulently included in the gift deed plots
91 and 92 of Lingadahalli village without her
knowledge. We are accordingly of the
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 39 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


opinion that the transaction of gift was
voidable and not void and the suit must be
brought within the time prescribed under
Article 95 of the Limitation Act.”

25. The Hon'ble Apex Court in Dularia Devi(supra)
has observed as under:
“6. In Ningawwa v. Byrappa, this Court referred
to the well-established principle that a contract or
other transaction induced or tendered by fraud is
not void, but only voidable at the option of the
party defrauded. The transaction remains valid until
it was avoided. This Court then said:(SCR p. 801)
"The legal position will be different if there
is a fraudu- lent misrepresentation not
merely as to the contents of the document
but as to its character. The authorities
make a clear distinction between
fraudulent misrepresentation as to the
character of the document and fraudulent
misrepresentation as to the contents
thereof. With reference to the former, it
has been held that the transaction is void,
while in the case of the latter, it is merely
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 40 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


voidable. In Foster v. Mackinon, [1869] 4
CP 704, the action was by the endorsee of
a bill of exchange. The defendant pleaded
that he endorsed the bill on a fraudulent
representation by the acceptor that he was
signing a guarantee. In holding that such a
plea was admissible, the Court observed:
It, (signature) is invalid not merely on the ground
of fraud, where fraud exists, but on the ground that
the mind of the signer did not accompany the
signature; in other words, that he never intended to
sign, and therefore in contemplation of law never
did sign, the contract to which his name is
appended ..... The defendant never intended to sign
that contract or any such contract. He never
intended to put his name to any instrument that
then was or thereafter might become negotiable.
He was deceived, not merely as to the legal effect,
but as to the 'actual contents' of the instrument."
(emphasis supplied)
7. From the facts narrated above, about which, as
stated earlier, there is no dispute, it is clear that
this is a case where the plaintiff appellant was
totally ignorant of the mischief played upon her.
She honestly believed that the instrument which
she executed and got registered was a gift deed in
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 41 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


favour of her daughter. She believed that the
thumb impressions taken from her were in respect
of that single document. She did not know that she
executed two documents, one of which alone was
the gift deed, but the other Was a sale of the
property in favour of all the defendants. This was,
therefore, a case of fraudulent misrepresentation as
to the character of the document executed by her
and not merely as to its contents or as to its legal
effect. The plaintiff-appellant never intended to sign
what she did sign. She never intended to enter into
the contract to which she unknowingly became a
party. Her mind did not accompany her thumb
impressions. This is a case that fails within the
principle enunciated in Ningawwa v. Byrappa and it
was, therefore, a totally void transaction.
Accordingly, as stated in Gorakh Nath Dube, the
suit is not maintainable by reason of the bar
contained in the Act.”
26. The Hon'ble Apex Court in Ramathal and others
versus K Rajamani(supra) has observed as under:
“18. A plea of non est factum can be taken by an
executor or signatory of the deed to plead that the
said document is invalid as its executor/signatory
was mistaken about its character at the time of
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 42 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


executing/signing it. It is a latin maxim which
literally means “it is not the deed.” A plea of non
est factum is a defence available in Contract Law
allowing a person to escape the effect of a
document which she/he may have executed/signed.
19. As already noted above, the plea of non est
factum basically means, “it is not my deed.” The
said plea has been a subject matter of
consideration of this court in the case of Bismillah v
Janeshwar Prasad. In the said case, the
plaintiff/appellant therein had claimed herself to be
a Pardanashin lady and on the representation of the
defendant/respondents, had appointed them as
agent to manage the estate under a written
document which was drafted in Hindi, a language
not known to her. Later on, she discovered that it
contained an unauthorized clause empowering sale
of properties. Taking advantage of the same, the
said agents had executed fraudulent and elusive
sale of the said property. The said case set up the
plaintiff/appellant was considered and dealt with in
paras 12 and 13 of the report. A further issue
which this Court considered in the said case was a
distinction between fraudulent misrepresentation as
to the character of the document and fraudulent
misrepresentation as to the contents thereof. Such
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 43 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


defense of non est factum was held to be available
only where the mistake was as to the very nature
or character as to the transaction. This Court also
relied upon an earlier decision in the case of
Ningawwa v. Byrappa. This Court further placed
reliance upon the judgment of the House of Lords in
case of Saunders v Anglia Building Society13 to fine
tune the distinction between the document being
void or voidable.”
xxxxxx
22. The aforementioned test for a successful plea of
non est factum requires that:
(A) The person pleading non est factum must
belong to "class of persons, who through no fault of
their own, are unable to have any understanding of
the purpose of the particular document because of
blindness, illiteracy or some other disability". The
disability must be one requiring the reliance on
others for advice as to what they are signing. As
Lord Pearson had aptly put(Saunders case, AC
p.1034)
“In my opinion, the plea of non est factum ought to
be available in a proper case for the relief of a
person who for permanent or temporary reasons
(not limited to blindness or illiteracy) is not capable
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 44 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


of both reading and sufficiently understanding the
deed or other document to be signed. By
“sufficiently understanding” I mean understanding
at least to the point of detecting a fundamental
difference between the actual document and the
document as the signer had believed it to be.”
(B) The "signatory must have made a fundamental
mistake as to the nature of the contents of the
document being signed", including its practical
effects. Lord Wilberfore has succinctly put this
aspect: (Saunders case, AC p.1026)
“….In my opinion, a document should be held to be
void (as opposed to voidable) only when the
element of consent to it is totally lacking, that is,
more concretely, when the transaction which the
document purports to effect is essentially different
in substance or in kind from the transaction
intended”
(C) The document must have been radically
different from one intended to be signed. As Lord
Reid Remarked in the judgement: (Saunders case,
AC p.1017)
“There must, I think, be a radical difference
between what he signed and what he thought he
was signing — or one could use the words
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 45 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


“fundamental” or “serious” or “very substantial.”
But what amounts to a radical difference will
depend on all the circumstances.”
27. The Hon'ble Apex Court in Subhas Chandr Das
Mushib (supra) has observed as under:
“4. Under Section 16 (1) of the Indian Contract Act
a contract is said to be induced by undue influence
where the relations subsisting between the parties
are such that one of the parties is in a position to
dominate the will of the other and uses that position
to obtain an unfair advantage over the other. This
shows that the court trying a case of undue influence
must consider two things to start with, namely, (1)
are the relations between the donor and the donee
such that the donee is in a position to dominate the
will of the donor and (2) has the donee used that
position to obtain an unfair advantage over the
donor'?
5. Sub-section (2) of the section is illustrative as
to when a person is to considered to be in a position
to dominate the will of another. These are inter alia
(a) where the donee holds a real or apparent
authority over the donor or where he stands in a
fiduciary relation to the donor or (b) where he makes
a contract with a person whose mental capacity is
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 46 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


temporarily or permanently affected by reason of
age, illness, or mental or bodily distress.
6. Sub-section (3) of the section throws the
burden of proving that a contract was not induced by
undue influence on the person benefiting by it when
two factors are found against him, namely that he is
in a position to dominate the will of another and the
transaction appears on the face of it or on the
evidence adduced to be unconscionable.
7. The three stages for consideration of a case of
undue influence were expounded in the case of
Ragunath Prasad v. Sarju Prasad and others(1) in
the following words :-
"In the first place the relations between the
parties to each other must be such that one is in a
position to dominate the will of the other. Once that
position is substantiated the second stage has been
reached-namely, the issue whether the contract has
been induced by undue influence. Upon the
determination of this issue a third point emerges,
which is that of the onus probandi. If the transaction
appears to be unconscionable, then the burden of
proving that the contract was not induced by undue
influence is to lie upon the person who was in ,I
position to dominate the will of the other.
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 47 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


Error is almost sure to arise if the order of
these propositions be changed. The
unconscionableness of the bargain is not the first
thing to be considered. The first thing to be
considered is the relations of these parties. Were
they such as to put one in a position to dominate the
will of the other?"
28. Considering the above said decisions it is to be
ascertained whether the plaintiff has executed sale
agreement, sale deed and lease agreement under
misrepresentation and fraud played on her by defendant
No.1.
29. Defendant No.1 is brother of plaintiff. The
plaintiff claims that she is illiterate. D.W.1 in his cross-
examination has stated that the plaintiff has studied up to
th th
8 standard and he has studied up to 4 standard. P.W.1
in her cross-examination on being shown Exs.D1, D2, D3,
D4 to 6, D7 to 9, 10 and 11 has perused them, identified
those documents and given answers admitting the said
documents. The said evidence of plaintiff/PW1 clearly
indicate that she is not an illiterate lady, but she is
educated and can identify the documents.
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 48 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


30. The appellant/plaintiff earlier to the alleged sale
deed dated 01.10.2007 had visited the Sub-Registrar office
twice, one at the time of her father executing gift deed
dated 25.02.2006 in her favour and on another occasion at
the time when she executed mortgage deed dated
25.04.2006 in favour of BDA Housing Co-operative Society.
Since the plaintiff has visited the Sub-Registrar office she
is aware of the process and procedure of registration of the
documents in the Sub-Registrar office.
31. Ex.D31 is agreement of sale dated 23.08.2007
said to have been executed by plaintiff in favour of
defendant No.1 agreeing to sell the suit schedule property
in favour of defendant No.1 for sale consideration of
Rs.8,00,000/- and received a sum of Rs.2,00,000/- as
advance by way of part payment of sale consideration.
D.W.6 is one of the witnesses to the said sale agreement -
Ex.D31. DW.6 has given his evidence with regard to the
execution of the said sale agreement by plaintiff in favour
of defendant No.1.
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 49 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


32. The defendant No. 1 on the basis of the said
agreement of sale- Ex.D1 has availed a loan of
Rs.6,00,000/- from defendant No.2/Bank. Out of the said
loan amount of Rs.6,00,000/-, a sum of Rs.2,74,254/- was
issued in the form of a demand draft in favour of BDA
Housing Co-operative Society. The plaintiff admits receipt
of the said DD for Rs.2,74,254/- and handing over the said
DD to BDA Housing Co-operative Society for clearing the
loan availed by her and getting certificate from the said
Society. Thereafter the plaintiff got Ex.P4- loan discharge
certificate dated 28.09.2007 issued by BDA Housing Co-
operative Society and got it registered on 04.10.2007. The
said registration of loan discharge certificate – Ex.P14 is
after alleged the sale deed dated 01.10.2007. The plaintiff
has not disputed the registration of the said loan discharge
certificate – Ex.P14 by her on 04.10.2007.
33. The original absolute sale deed dated 01.10.2007
is at Ex-D11 and it is executed by plaintiff in favour of
defendant No.1 in respect of suit schedule property for sale
consideration of Rs.8,00,000/-. DW.6 - Sudhakaran is one
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 50 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


of the witnesses to the said sale deed and he has given
evidence with regard to execution of the sale deed by
plaintiff in favour of defendant No.1 in respect of the suit
schedule property. There is an endorsement of the Sub-
Registrar on the back of first page of the said sale deed
that the plaintiff has admitted that she has executed the
sale deed in favour of defendant No.1.
34. A total consideration of Rs.8,00,000/- of the said
sale deed dated 01.10.2007 has been paid by defendant
No.1. Out of the said sale consideration, Rs.2,00,000/- has
been paid by way of cash under Ex.D31 - Agreement to
Sell. Rs.2,74,254/- has been paid by way of DD by
respondent No.2/Bank out of the loan sanctioned to
defendant No.1 in favour of BDA Housing Co-operative
Society for closure of the loan of the plaintiff.
Rs.3,25,746/- has been paid by way of DD to the plaintiff
and the said DD has been credited to her bank account.
The copy of the said DD is at Ex.D43. The plaintiff has
operated her bank account to which Rs.3,25,746/- has
been credited by withdrawing Rs.50,000/- on 05.10.2007
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 51 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


(as per Ex.D25), Rs.2,00,000/- on 11.10.2007 (as per
Ex.D26), Rs.75,000/- on 12.10.2007 (as per Ex.D27) and
Rs.1,000/- on 17.01.2008 (as per Ex.D28). The withdrawal
of the said amount which is part of the sale consideration
itself clearly indicate that the plaintiff was aware of
payment of that part sale consideration by way of DD
credited to her bank account.
35. The plaintiff on 11.10.2007 has executed a lease
deed as per Ex.D12 in favour of the defendant No.1 for
continuing in the second floor of the suit schedule property
as a tenant on monthly rent of Rs.4,000/- and has paid
Rs.1,15,000/- as refundable security deposit. The stamp
paper of the said lease deed has been purchased on
09.10.2007. Therefore, it cannot be said that she affixed
signature on it on 01.10.2007 as on the date of executing
the sale deed.
36. DW.2 is one Eshwar and he is brother of plaintiff
and defendant No. 1. He has given evidence with regard to
sale of suit schedule property by plaintiff in favour of
defendant No.1. DW.3 is the sister of plaintiff and
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 52 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


defendant No.1 and she has also given evidence with
regard to plaintiff executing sale deed in respect of suit
schedule property in favour of defendant No.1.
37. The defendant No.1 got mutated his name in the
property records of BBMP and Khata has been transferred
in his name. As the plaintiff asserts that she has not
executed sale deed and only she has executed mortgage
deed in favour of defendant No.2/Bank, she ought to have
paid property tax of the suit schedule property from the
year 2007 till filing of the suit in the year 2012. The
plaintiff has not produced any tax paid receipts for having
paid the property tax of the suit schedule property which
also indicate that plaintiff after the sale deed- Ex.D11 by
executing lease deed-Ex.D12 dated 11.10.2007 continued
in the suit schedule property as a tenant.
38. The plaintiff has admitted that she has a
daughter and her marriage was not performed as on the
date of sale deed dated 01.10.2007 and subsequently, her
marriage has been performed and she has spent money for
her marriage. One of the reason for the sale of the suit
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 53 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


property is that she required money for performing
marriage of her daughter. The husband of plaintiff died
prior to the year 2007 and the responsibility of performing
marriage of the daughter was on the plaintiff. The plaintiff
being a maid servant had a meager source of income
which is not sufficient for performing the marriage of her
daughter and also for repayment of loan availed by her
from BDA Housing Co-operative Society.
39. All these circumstances clearly indicate that the
plaintiff was not misrepresented by defendant No.1 for
executing the sale deed in the guise of the mortgage deed.
The said circumstances clearly indicate that the plaintiff
knowingly and understanding the contents of sale deed
dated 01.10.2007 executed it in respect of the suit
schedule property in favour of defendant No.1 for
consideration. The said consideration has been passed to
the plaintiff and it is paid by the defendant No.1 partly by
paying by cash and partly by availing a loan from
defendant No.2/Bank. Considering the said aspect, the
appellant/plaintiff has failed to prove that respondent No.1
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 54 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


(defendant No.1) has misrepresented and played a fraud
on her and got executed sale deed dated 01.10.2007 in
respect of suit schedule property in the guise of getting
executed mortgage deed in favour of respondent No.2
(defendant No.2/Bank). Considering the said aspect, the
trial Court is justified in dismissing the suit of the plaintiff
in O.S.No.8450/2012. Accordingly, point number 1 and 2
are answered.
Re-Point No.3
40. After dismissal of the suit in O.S.No.8450/2012,
a suit came to be filed in O.S.No.1913/2020 seeking
ejectment of the defendant of that suit on the ground that
she is a tenant in the suit schedule property under lease
deed dated 11.10.2007 and she has not paid rent and her
tenancy has been terminated by legal notice.
41. The said legal notice has been issued by the
plaintiff of that suit on 07.03.2013, but the suit has been
filed in the year 2020. In reply to the said legal notice got
issued by the defendant of that suit dated 22.03.2013, the
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 55 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


defendant of that suit contended that she is owner of the
suit property in which she is residing and the plaintiff of
that suit has played a fraud on her and got executed sale
deed in the guise of executing mortgage deed to the bank
and she has filed a suit in that regard in
O.S.No.8450/2012. As the said suit in O.S.No.8450/2012
was pending the plaintiff of O.S.No.1913/2020 did not file
the suit immediately and he has filed a suit only after
dismissal of the suit in O.S.No.8450/2012.
42. The tenancy of the defendant - Geetha has been
terminated by issuance of legal notice dated 07.03.2013
which has been served on defendant - Geetha for which
she has issued reply dated 22.03.2013. The plaintiff has
claimed damages in the said suit from 01.03.2007. The
plaintiff has not claimed the damages since the year 2013.
It might be because the claim for that damages is not
within the period of limitation. The plaintiff has claimed
damages only for 03 years prior to the date of filing of the
suit. The suit of Geetha in O.S.No.8450/2012 has been
dismissed, wherein she had a claim to declare her as
Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA
AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

- 56 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:63646
RFA No. 2683 of 2024
C/W RFA No. 650 of 2020


CNR: KAHC010703002024


owner of the property and sale deed dated 01.10.2007 as
null and void. The dismissal of the said suit and the said
sale deed dated 01.10.2007 clearly establishes that the
plaintiff of O.S.No.1913/2020, namely - Prabhu, is owner
of the suit schedule property and defendant - Geetha is
residing in the second floor of the said suit property as a
tenant under lease deed dated 11.10.2007. Considering
the said aspect, the trial Court has rightly decreed the said
suit in O.S.No.1913/2020. Accordingly, Point No.3 is
answered.
43. In view of the foregoing reasons, both appeals
filed deserves to be dismissed. Accordingly, RFA
No.650/2020 and RFA No.2683/2024 are dismissed .

Digitally Signed By:
SHIVASHANKAR BASAPPA

AMARANNAVAR
JUDGE, HIGH COURT OF KARNATKA

(SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR)
JUDGE

DKB
List No.: 3 Sl No.: 43
Ct.sm