Nenuram Hiraram Fulwariya And Ors vs State Of Maharashtra And Anr
- Court
- Bombay High Court
CNR No : HCBM010401622026
2026:BHC-AS:45632
APL.1550.2026.doc
Ajay
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO.1550 OF 2026
1) Nenuram Hiraram Fulwariya (Accused No.2)
2) Bhagchand Biyaram Fulwariya (Accused No.3)
(Accused No.4)
3) Pappu Pusaji Ujarpuria
(Accused No. 5)
4) Anwar Munnawar Shaikh .. Applicants
Versus
The State of Maharashtra and Anr. .. Respondents
....................
Mr. R.V. Gupta a/w. Mr. Rohit Vaishwa, Advocates for Applicants.
Ms. Shilpa G. Talhar, APP for Respondent No.1 – State.
Ms. Payoshi Roy, appointed Advocate for Respondent No.2
API – Rupali Chaudhari, Unit – 6, Crime Branch, DCB CID, Mumbai.
HC - Mulvekar, DCB, CID, Unit - 6, Chembur present.
...................
CORAM : MILIND N. JADHAV, J.
DATE : NOVEMBER 18, 2026
JUDGEMENT :
1.
Heard Mr. Gupta, learned Advocate for Applicants; Ms.
Talhar, learned APP for Respondent No.1 and Ms. Roy, learned
appointed Advocate for Respondent No.2.
2. By way of present Application, Applicants seek to quash
investigation and proceedings against them pending on the file of
Additional Sessions Judge, Mumbai bearing Sessions Case No.149 of
2024 on completion of investigation of C.R. No.226 of 2019 registered
at DCB CID Unit VI (C.R. No.355 of 2019 registered at Nehru Nagar
Police Station) for offences punishable under Sections 306 and 34 of
the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short "IPC").
1 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
3. It is prosecution case that present incident is preceded by an
earlier incident wherein, on 25.04.2019, the deceased lodged a
complaint at Nehru Nagar Police Station against Accused No.3 for
offence punishable under Section 363 IPC alleging that his minor
daughter was enticed and lured away by him. It is prosecution case
that deceased was under depression and mental distress on account of
his minor daughter staying with the accused persons and she being
prevented from contacting him. It is prosecution case that on
13.10.2019, owing to the mental agony, deceased committed suicide
by jumping in front of a running train on the railway tracks at Tilak
Nagar Railway Station. It is prosecution case that during course of
investigation, five chits were recovered from his pocket wherein he had
attributed his decision to commit suicide to the act of accused persons
enticing away his minor daughter and causing him mental agony. On
14.10.2019 Respondent No.2, wife of deceased and mother of the
minor daughter, lodged complaint at Wadala Railway Police Station
against Applicants having abetted commission of suicide of her
husband. Pursuant thereto, C.R. No.226 of 2019 was registered,
investigation was carried out and charge-sheet has been filed against
Applicants and Accused No.1 for offences punishable under Sections
306 read with 34 of the IPC. Accused No.1 is not before the Court. His
role assumes significance since his name alongwith his gang appears in
those five chits i.e. suicide note retrieved from the deceased alongwith
2 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
the name of the Senior Inspector of Police.
4. Mr. Gupta, learned Advocate for Applicants would submit
that Applicants are falsely implicated in the present crime. He would
submit that they have absolutely no nexus with the charge of
elopement of minor daughter of deceased and Respondent No.2 /
complainant or the subsequent unfortunate event. He would submit
that Applicant No. 2 was working with Applicant No. 1 and residing in
his workshop for the preceding (4) four years and left for his native
place on 31.03.2019. He would submit that on 02.04.2019, when
officers of Nehru Nagar Police Station, accompanied by deceased and
his relatives visited the workshop of Applicant No. 1 inquiring about
Applicant No. 2, Applicant No. 1 immediately furnished his address,
telephone number and other particulars and even facilitated a video
call with Applicant No. 2 in the presence of the police officers. He
would submit that Applicant No. 1 attended the police station on the
following day and cooperated with investigation and in furtherance to
this Applicant No. 2 also attended Nehru Nagar Police Station on
07.04.2019 pursuant to directions from the police.
4.1. He would submit that C.R. No. 131 of 2019 dated
25.04.2019 was registered for offence punishable under Section 363 of
the IPC against Applicant No. 2 alone and there is no allegation
whatsoever against the remaining Applicants therein. He would submit
3 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
that initially investigating agency filed charge-sheet against Applicant
No.2 only. However, after further investigation, it was revealed that
the minor daughter of informant had committed suicide on 30.03.2019
itself and she had not eloped with Applicant No. 2 as was initially
alleged and suspected by the deceased. He would submit that the
th
Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, 37 Court, Esplanade, Mumbai,
by order dated 23.06.2025 passed below Exhibits 01 and 03 in C.C.
No. 875/PW/2019, took note of the subsequent investigation and the
C-Summary report submitted by the investigating officer after filing of
the charge-sheet. He would submit that the Magistrate specifically
recorded that the prosecution material itself revealed that the minor
daughter of deceased and first informant had infact committed suicide
on 30.03.2019 and the complaint was lodged by deceased under the
mistaken assumption that she had eloped with Applicant No. 2.
4.2.
He would submit that the aforesaid order dated 23.06.2025
further records that the informant (deceased - father) also committed
suicide and his wife i.e. Respondent No.2 (First Informant) appeared
before the Magistrate and expressed no objection to closing the
proceedings. He would submit that the Magistrate, upon considering
the subsequent reports submitted by the investigating officer and
absence of sufficient material to frame charge, categorically held that
allegations against the accused persons were groundless and hence
there was no purpose in keeping the proceedings pending against the
4 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
remaining accused as well. He would submit that the Magistrate
accordingly discharged all the accused persons for the offences
punishable under Sections 363 and 368 read with Section 34 of the
IPC and cancelled their bail bonds. He would submit that the said
order is a material subsequent development which substantially
supports the Applicants' contention that the original allegation of
kidnapping and wrongful confinement / restraint were not
substantiated and proved during investigation.
4.3.
He would submit that the present case is founded upon the
alleged suicide note comprising five chits, the recovery and
genuineness of which are seriously disputed. He would submit that
although Respondent No.2, in her complaint dated 14.10.2019,
claimed that she was shown five chits of paper at Wadala Railway
Police Station, however the said suicide note was circulated in Nehru
Nagar area on 13.10.2019 at about 9:40 p.m. He would submit that
the inquest panchanama dated 14.10.2019 prepared at Sion Hospital
does not record recovery of those five chits of paper allegedly retrieved
from the pocket of the deceased and it therefore raises serious
questions regarding the manner in which the said 5 chits were
produced and handled by the Police Constable, particularly when all
articles were handed over to the son of the deceased.
5 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
4.4. He would submit that the absence of bloodstains on the
suicide note and discrepancies in its custody create serious doubts
regarding its authenticity. He would submit that mobile phone of the
deceased was produced on 13.11.2019 in a damaged condition with a
non-functional display despite the claim that the deceased had spoken
to his son at about 8:22 p.m. on the date of the incident. He would
submit that the investigating agency failed to explain these
circumstances or conduct any meaningful investigation into the
manner in which the 5 chits of suicide note were made viral on social
media and by whom. He would submit that the suicide note infact
contain allegations against the then Senior Police Inspector but no
investigation has been done in this regard.
4.5.
He would submit that neither the deceased nor Respondent
No. 2 made any grievance against present Applicants before any Senior
Police Officer between the initial incident in March 2019 and the
subsequent registration of FIR in November 2019 and that even C.R.
No. 131 of 2019 and C.R. No. 353 of 2019 do not disclose any specific
role attributed to present Applicants, except to the extent of the
allegation made against them in the FIR. He would submit that
Applicants have been subsequently implicated in the present crime on
account of alleged business rivalry and political pressure exerted by
certain interested persons. He would submit that the order dated
23.06.2025 passed by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, 37th
6 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
Court, Esplanade, Mumbai, discharging all the accused in C.C. No.
875/PW/2019, coupled with absence of specific allegations and
suspicious circumstances surrounding the suicide note, demonstrates
that the prosecution against Applicants is devoid of sufficient material.
He would therefore submit that continuation of the present
proceedings would amount to an abuse of the process of law and hence
the FIR and consequential proceedings deserve to be quashed and set
aside on merits.
5.
PER CONTRA , Ms. Talhar, learned APP for Respondent -
State would submit that present Application deserves to be rejected as
investigation has been completed and charge-sheet has been filed
against Applicants. She would submit that prosecution case is founded
upon the five chits recovered from the pocket of the deceased, wherein
he has specifically attributed his mental agony and decision to commit
suicide to the conduct of the accused persons in enticing away his
minor daughter and preventing her from contacting her parents. She
would submit that the allegations contained in the suicide note,
coupled with the statements of witnesses and other material collected
during investigation, disclose a prima facie case against Applicants
which require consideration during trial.
5.1. She would submit that the order dated 23.06.2025 passed by
the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, 37th Court, Esplanade,
7 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
Mumbai, in C.C. No. 875/PW/2019, pertains to proceedings initiated
for offences punishable under Sections 363 and 368 read with Section
34 of the IPC and the same cannot ipso facto absolve Applicants from
the allegation of abetment of suicide of the deceased in the present
proceedings. She would submit that the offences involved in the
present case are distinct and arise out of the conduct of Applicants
which is stated to have driven the deceased to commit suicide. She
would submit that discrepancies regarding recovery and circulation of
the suicide note, condition of the mobile phone and allegations against
the then Senior Police Inspector are matters requiring appreciation of
evidence and cannot be conclusively determined in proceedings under
the inherent jurisdiction of this Court. She would therefore submit that
the present Application be dismissed.
6. Ms. Roy, learned appointed Advocate appearing for
Respondent No.2 would adopt the submissions made by Ms. Talhar
and would submit that Respondent No.2 is wife of the deceased and
suffered the unfortunate loss of her husband and daughter in quick
succession and circumstances forming the subject matter of the present
proceedings. She would submit that her husband - the deceased was
under severe mental agony on account of their minor daughter going
missing in March 2019 and it was his apprehension that she was
enticed away by accused persons. She would submit that the five chits
left behind by deceased specifically refer to the acts of accused persons
8 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
and the mental trauma suffered by him on account of the same. She
would submit that contents of the suicide note seen along with the
surrounding circumstances and statements recorded during
investigation, prima facie indicate involvement of Applicants and
precise role attributable to each of them can be examined and proved
only during trial.
6.1.
She would submit that the discharge order dated 23.06.2025
passed in C.C. No. 875/PW/2019 cannot be construed as a complete
exoneration of Applicants from the allegations forming the subject
matter of the present proceedings under Section 306 read with Section
34 of the IPC. She would submit that the said order was passed in
relation to allegations of kidnapping and wrongful confinement of the
minor daughter and the Magistrate was concerned with the sufficiency
of material to frame charge for those offences.
6.2. She would submit that the allegation relating to abetment of
suicide and circumstances in which the deceased took the extreme step
constitute a separate cause for investigation and adjudication. She
would submit that the alleged discrepancies in the suicide note and
other circumstances relied upon by Applicants are disputed questions
of fact which ought not to be examined in detail at the stage of
quashing. She would therefore submit that Applicants are not entitled
to seek quashing of the proceedings at this stage and hence the
9 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
Application deserves to be rejected.
7. I have heard Mr. Gupta, learned Advocate for Applicants,
Ms. Talhar, learned APP for Respondent No.1 and Ms. Roy, learned
appointed Advocate for Respondent No.2 and with their able
assistance perused the record of the case. Submissions made by
learned Advocates at the bar have received due consideration of the
Court.
8. At the outset, it is seen that the entire prosecution case
against Applicants emanates from the alleged kidnapping of the minor
daughter of deceased in March 2019 and the consequent mental agony
allegedly suffered by deceased which is alleged to have driven him to
commit suicide on 13.10.2019. However, it is revealed pursuant to
investigation that the minor daughter of the deceased was not
abducted at all. Rather it has come on record that the minor daughter
of the deceased had infact committed suicide on 30.03.2019 which
was not to the knowledge of the deceased. It has come on record that
deceased was under the mistaken impression that his minor daughter
was lured by Applicant No.2 and she had eloped with him and the
Applicants were preventing / precluding her from contacting him. Such
material brought on record fundamentally alters the very foundation of
the prosecution case. It is not in dispute that the minor daughter of the
deceased had gone missing on 30.03.2019 and that deceased lodged
10 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
C.R. No. 131 of 2019 on 25.04.2019 against Applicant No. 2 for the
offence punishable under Section 363 of the IPC. However, it is
revealed during investigation that the minor daughter had herself
committed suicide on 30.03.2019 and she had not eloped with
Applicant No. 2. Thus, the very premise on which the deceased is
alleged to have suffered mental agony on account of his daughter
having being abducted and wrongfully restrained by Applicants stands
substantially displaced by the subsequent investigation and cognizance
of the same having been taken by the Court while passing order dated
23.06.2025.
9.
It is further significant to note that there is a considerable
time gap between the incident of alleged kidnapping of the minor
daughter and suicide committed by the deceased. It is seen that the
minor daughter went missing on 30.03.2019 and deceased committed
suicide on 13.10.2019, after a lapse of more than six (6) months. It is
seen that during this intervening period, Applicants cooperated with
the investigating agency. It is seen that Applicant No. 1 furnished all
particulars and details of Applicant No. 2 to the police officers and had
even facilitated a video call with him in their presence. It is seen that
Applicant No. 2 also attended the Nehru Nagar Police Station pursuant
to directions of the police and cooperated in investigation. It is seen
that the initial complaint dated 25.04.2019 was directed only against
Applicant No. 2 alone and no specific allegations were levelled against
11 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
any of the remaining Applicants. The material on record does not
indicate any specific overt act on the part of Applicants including
Applicant No.2 during the intervening period which could be said to
have instigated or intentionally aided the deceased to commit suicide.
Mere existence of an earlier complaint alleging kidnapping without any
further material demonstrating intentional instigation or aid cannot by
itself constitute abetment of suicide.
10. In my considered opinion an important subsequent
development which cannot be overlooked is the judicial order dated
th
23.06.2025 passed by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, 37
Court, Esplanade, Mumbai, below Exhibits 01 and 03 in C.C. No.
875/PW/2019. Perusal of the said order reveals that after filing of the
charge-sheet, the investigating officer submitted a C-Summary report
disclosing that the minor daughter of the deceased had committed
suicide on 30.03.2019 and original complaint was lodged under the
assumption that she had eloped with Applicant No. 2. In this order
Magistrate also took note of the fact that the deceased who was the
informant in the previous case had subsequently committed suicide
and his wife - Respondent No. 2 appeared before the Court and
expressed no objection to closing the matter. Upon considering the
subsequent reports and the material before the Court, it concluded that
there was no sufficient evidence to frame charge against the accused
person i.e. Applicant No.2 and accordingly it discharged all accused
12 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
persons for the offences punishable under Sections 363 and 368 read
with Section 34 IPC. Though the said order pertains to distinct offences
and cannot, by itself, determine the Applicants' liability under Section
306 of the IPC, however in my opinion the findings and the subsequent
investigation referred to therein constitute relevant circumstances
which cannot be ignored while examining the continuation of the
present prosecution.
11. I have also examined the circumstances surrounding the
recovery of five chits stated to constitute the suicide note of the
deceased. It is seen that Respondent No. 2, in her complaint dated
14.10.2019, claimed that she was shown those five chits at Wadala
Railway Police Station. However, Applicants have pointed out that the
contents of the suicide note were circulated in Nehru Nagar area on
13.10.2019 at about 9:40 p.m. It is seen that the inquest panchanama
dated 14.10.2019 prepared at Sion Hospital does not contain a clear
reference to recovery of five chits from pocket of the deceased. The
circumstances recorded in the panchanama regarding production and
subsequent handling of the said 5 chits by Police Constable particularly
when all articles of deceased were handed over to son of the deceased,
raise questions regarding their custody and preservation. However I am
conscious of the fact that these circumstances, taken individually, may
not be sufficient to discard the suicide note at this stage. However,
when considered cumulatively they create a serious doubt regarding
13 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
the circumstances in which the said 5 chits were recovered, preserved
and subsequently circulated / relied upon.
12.
Another circumstance which requires consideration is the
delay in production of the mobile phone of the deceased. It is seen that
the said mobile phone was produced by the complainant only on
13.11.2019, almost a month after the incident and that too in a
damaged condition with a non-functional display. This assumes
significance in view of the claim that the deceased had spoken to his
son at about 8:22 p.m. on the date of the incident and had forwarded
the suicide note to other persons. It is seen that the investigating
agency has not satisfactorily explained the circumstances in which the
mobile phone was not recovered at the time of the incident and how it
was subsequently produced after one month in the aforesaid condition.
13. Further, it is seen that the suicide note is stated to contain
allegations against the then Senior Police Inspector yet the
investigation does not appear to have meaningfully examined the said
allegations. These circumstances, when considered along with the
discrepancies in recovery of five chits, cast a shadow on the manner in
which the investigation has proceeded.
14.
The essential requirement for attracting Section 306 of the
IPC is the existence of abetment within the meaning of Section 107 of
the IPC. There must be material indicating instigation, intentional aid
14 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
or engagement in a conspiracy to bring about the commission of
suicide. The mere fact that a person has committed suicide and has
referred to certain persons in a suicide note would not in every case be
sufficient to attract the offence of abetment of suicide. In the present
case, even if the suicide note is taken into consideration, the
prosecution is required to establish a proximate and live link between
the alleged acts of Applicants and suicide committed by the deceased.
15. The kidnapping of the minor daughter was the subject
matter of an earlier complaint dated 25.04.2019, whereas the
deceased committed suicide on 13.10.2019. During this intervening
period, the subsequent investigation revealed that the minor daughter
had not been abducted but had committed suicide on 30.03.2019
itself. There is no material placed on record to demonstrate any fresh
act of instigation or intentional assistance on the part of Applicants
which could have driven the deceased to take the extreme step after
such a considerable lapse of time. The mere reference to Applicants in
the suicide note, particularly in the backdrop of the subsequent
findings of the investigating agency, would not by itself satisfy the
ingredients of Section 306 read with Section 34 of the IPC.
16. It is settled law by the Supreme Court in the case of Lovely
1
Salhotra and Anr. Vs. State of NCT Delhi and Anr. that there is no bar
under either Section 482 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 or
1
Criminal Appeal No.670 of 2017 decided on 10th April 2017
15 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
Section 528 of BNSS, 2023 that prevents quashing of FIR against
certain accused persons only neither is there any requirement by law to
quash FIR / proceedings as a whole against all accused persons as
provided by the case of Applicants before me is clearly covered by the
aforementioned decision of Supreme Court hence there can be no
impediment in allowing the present Application for quashing the
Complaint qua the Applicants before me.
17. In view of the aforesaid observations and findings, I am of
the considered opinion that continuation of the prosecution against
Applicants would not serve any meaningful purpose and would
amount to permitting criminal proceedings to continue in the absence
of material satisfying the essential ingredients of the alleged offence.
The subsequent investigation and the order dated 23.06.2025 passed
by the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, the considerable time gap
between the alleged kidnapping and suicide of the deceased, the
absence of any specific act of instigation or intentional aid attributable
to Applicants and serious circumstances surrounding the suicide note,
when considered cumulatively, do not disclose a prima facie case
warranting Applicants to undergo the ordeal of a criminal trial. The
present Application therefore deserves to be allowed.
18. In view of the above observations and findings, investigation
and proceedings against Applicants pending on the file of Additional
16 of 17
APL.1550.2026.doc
Sessions Judge, Mumbai bearing Sessions Case No.149 of 2024 on
completion of investigation of C.R. No.226 of 2019 registered at DCB
CID Unit VI (C.R. No.355 of 2019 registered at Nehru Nagar Police
Station) for offences punishable under Sections 306 and 34 of the IPC
are hereby quashed and set aside insofar as the present four (4)
Applicants are concerned. All consequential proceedings arising out of
the aforesaid FIR and charge-sheet stand quashed and set aside qua
the Applicants.
19. It is clarified that the observations made in this order are
confined to the case of the present four (4) Applicants and shall not
affect the proceedings against the remaining accused persons.
20. This Court appreciates the assistance rendered by Ms. Roy,
learned Advocate appointed through the Legal Aid to espouse the
cause of Respondent No. 2. Her fees are to be paid by the High Court
Legal Aid Services Authority as per rules on production of a server copy
of this order and other compliances in accordance with the decision of
this Court in the case of Sanjyot Nitin Telharkar v. The State of
2
Maharashtra & Anr. and the Schedule under Regulation 18(1) of the
Maharashtra State Legal Services Authority Rules, 1998.
21. Resultantly, the Criminal Application is allowed.
Ajay
[ MILIND N. JADHAV, J. ]
Digitally signed
by RAVINDRA
MOHAN
AMBERKAR
Date: 2026.11.18
13:01:17 +0530
RAVINDRA
MOHAN
AMBERKAR
2
Judgment dated 25.09.2024 passed in Misc. Civil Application No. 134 of 2024
17 of 17