MOTHER INDIA CONSTRUCTION ND ANR vs INDIAN OIL CORPORATION LIMITED AND ORS

Court
Calcutta High Court

1


IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Shampa Dutt (Paul)

WPA 25161 of 2025
Mother India Construction & Anr.
Versus
Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. & Ors.


For the Petitioners : Mr. Dinesh Pani,
Mr. Sarajit Sen,
Ms. Sulagna Sen.

For the Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 : Mr. Soumya Majumder, ld. Sr. Adv.
Ms. Sharmistha Ghosh,
Ms. Sanjukta Dutta,
Mr. Ranit Ray.

For the Respondent No. 4 : Mr. Chirantan Dawn.


Judgment reserved on : 31.08.2026
Judgment delivered on : 01.10.2026
Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.:

1. The writ application has been preferred praying for recall/cancellation of
impugned notice/letter dated 03.11.2025, issued by the respondent
authority upon declaring the MOS arrived at the meeting held on
13.05.2025 as not binding upon the petitioners.
2. Vide the impugned notice dated 03.11.2025, the respondent company
asked for exclusion/encashment of Bank guarantee as the petitioner did

2

not pay the due wage/arrear of the contract labour, as agreed under the
MOS dated 13.05.2025.
3. The petitioners’ case is that the relation of employer and the workers
between the petitioner and its’ workers ceased on 31.08.2024, as the
tenure of the work contract was over much prior to the MOS dated
13.05.2025, to which the petitioner was not even a party and no
notice for meeting was even served upon him.
4. Thus the petitioners’ case is that the MOS is not binding upon it.
5. The petitioners offer for the subject tender was made/accepted on
30.08.2024 commencing from 01.09.2023 and ending on
31.08.2024.
6. The Bank guarantee required to be submitted was to remain valid
up to a period of 3(three) months beyond the end of the defects
liability period.
7. The petitioners state that it is on that ground, the MOS is not binding
upon it.
8. The petitioners relies upon the following judgments:-
(i) Bata Shoe Co. (P) Ltd. vs. D.N. Ganguly & Ors.
reported in AIR 1961 SC 1158;

(ii) Hochtief Gammon vs. Industrial Tribunal,
Bhubaneswar, Orissa & Ors. reported in AIR 1964
SC 1746;
(iii) Canara Bank & Ors. vs. Debasis Das & Ors.
reported in (2003) 4 SCC 557;
(iv) The Jhagrakhan Collieries (P) Ltd. vs. Shri G.C.
Agarwal Presiding Officer, reported in (1975) 3
SCC 613;

3

(v) Mahabir Auto Stores & Ors. vs. Indian Oil
Corporation Ltd. & Ors. reported in (1990) 3 SCC
752;
(vi) U.P. Cooperative Federation Ltd. vs. Singh
Consultants & Engineers (P) Ltd. reported in
(1988) 1 SCC 174;
(vii) U.P. State Sugar Corporation Ltd. vs. Sumac
International Ltd. reported in (1997) 1 SCC 568 .

9. In it’s report in the form of affidavit the respondent no. 4 has stated as
follows:-
“That the Assistant Labour Commissioner(C)
Kolkata issued a letter No. 8/60/2023 -E3 dated
07.12.2023 and Letter No. 8/60/2023-E.3 dated
25.01.2024 addressing the Petitioner No. 1,
Respondent No. 3 and Respondent No. 5 to attend
the Joint discussion under Section 12 of the
Industrial Dispute Act, 1947 on 18.01.2024 at 11:30
A.M. and on 12/03/2024 at 11.30 a.m. respectively
but the Petitioner No. 1 neither responded nor
participated in any of the conciliation meeting held
thereafter.”

10. The respondent nos. 1 to 3 (IOCL) on filing written notes has argued that
the Tripartite settlement though executed in 03.05.2025, that is after
discharge of the Contract, the said Tripartite Settlement has
retrospective effect from 01.07.2021 to 30.6.2026.
11. The said dispute over charter of demands was pending in conciliation
when Mother India was working as a Contractor of Haldia Township.
Therefore, the writ petitioner/contractor was aware of the existence of
industrial disputes at the relevant point of time. In fact, the earlier

4

Tripartite Settlement dated 19.01.2018 was signed by the writ petitioner,
which was in operation from July 2016 to June 2021.
12. The liability of the contractor towards 27+46=73 contract labourers
against estimated wage revision for 1 year is Rs.37 Lakhs . There is a
Security Deposit of Rs.43,45,000/-Lakhs and a Performance Bank
Guarantee of Rs.21,30,007/- Lakhs The Bank Guarantees have been
released in favour of the writ petitioner pursuant to the order of the
Hon'ble Court.
13. The amount payable to the workers was an assumed liability by the writ
petitioner in course of accepting the work order and he was fully aware
of such prospective liability towards such revision of workers wages
through Charter of Demand and tripartite settlements, during the
operative period of the contract, and also thereafter when he was
represented in the conciliation meeting through his representative.
14. A tripartite settlement is deemed to be fair and binds all parties. It is not
even the writ petitioner's case that he was not part of the Contractor's
who has represented the employers in relation to the dispute over
charter of demands. [National Engineering Industries Ltd.-Vs- State
of Rajasthan and Others reported in (2000) 1 SCC 371 (Para-24]
15. Non-payment of the revised arrear of wages to the contract labourers
during the period of denial of the writ petitioner will cause heavy impact
on the maintenance and ancillary works at the Haldia Township.
16. The writ petition should therefore be dismissed and the amount
deposited with the Registrar General should be allowed to be withdrawn

5

with accrued interest and the same may be allowed to be disbursed
amongst the concerned contract labourers towards revised arrear wages.
17. The following judgment has been relied upon by the respondent/IOCL:-
i. National Engineering Industries Ltd.-Vs- State of Rajasthan
and Others reported in (2000) 1 SCC 371 (Para-24).
18. Respondent/IOCL has also filed the documents in support of their case
against the petitioners, which are part of the record and includes copies
of tripartite settlement, work order, charter of demand etc.
19. From formats dated 19.01.2018, which is a MOS between the parties, it
appears that the petitioners have admittedly accepted the same.
20. Special conditions of contract dated 30.08.2023 includes the following
clauses being no. 2 and 3 as follows:-
“2.Monthly basic salary to be paid by contractor
to MoS/other contract workers/casual labourer in
addition to allowances like Travel allowance,
Uniform allowance, EL encashment, Gratuity,
Bonus etc. & Contractor's contribution towards
PF/ESI etc as per MOS agreements (Annexure 1
for MOS workers only) signed on 19.01.2018.
This agreement is due for revision w.e.f. 1st July
2021 onwards. Contractor shall have to fulfil all
the requirements as per the new Charter of
Demands (MOS agreement) including payment of
arrears etc (if any) on account of revised MOS
without any extra cost to IOCL. Contractor has to
note that the new Demands (MOS agreement),
which may be signed at a later date but the same
will be effective from 01.07.2021, and hence the
entire financial liability arising on account of

6

revised MOS for the entire contractual period
shall have to be fulfilled by the contractor,
without any extra cost to 1OCL, although the
contract is either running or completed before
signing of new Charter of De agreement).
3 . In case the contractual period is completed
before the new Charter of Demands (MOS
agreement) is signed, contractor shall be required
to submit a notarized undertaking stating that the
contractor shall fulfil all the requirements as per
the new Charter of Demands (MOS agreement)
including payment of arrears etc. (if any) on
account of revised MOS without any extra cost to
IOCL and also deposit a Bank guarantee for 12
months (which shall be extended if required) of
necessary amount, as per direction of EIC, to
cover the financial liability on account of pending
revision of MOS agreement for the entire
contractual period. On failing to submit above
documents, IOCL will be entitled to
witheld/deduct necessary amount, as per
discretion of EIC, from any amount due from IOCL
to the Contractor under this &/or any other
contract. Further, IOCL at the risk and cost of the
contractor, will also be entitled to fulfil the
requirements of the new Charter of Demands
(MOS agreement) including payment of arrears
etc. (if any), either directly or through a third
party, in case the contractor falls to do so.
Contractor is advised to take into consideration
financial liability arising on account of revised
MOS for the entire co period and quote
accordingly.”

7

21. Again on 12.03.2024, in a meeting regarding dispute on the issue of
Charter of Demands, the petitioner was also a party.
22. The (MOS) meeting held on 13.05.2025 the petitioner was not present.
23. Thus admittedly the petitioner’s contract was from 01.09.2023 till
31.08.2024 .
24. Form H dated 19.01.2018 and contract dated 30.08.2023 and the
meeting dated 12.03.2024, had the petitioner’s presence.
25. The said meetings and attendance were related to the MOS entered into
from time to time regarding the Charter of Demands of the employees.
26. Clause 3 of the Contract dated 30.08.2023, binds the petitioner to pay
the arrear dues of the workers as follows:-
“ 3 . In case the contractual period is completed before the
new Charter of Demands (MOS agreement) is signed,
contractor shall be required to submit a notarized
undertaking stating that the contractor shall fulfil all the
requirements as per the new Charter of Demands (MOS
agreement) including payment of arrears etc. (if any) on
account of revised MOS without any extra cost to IOCL
and also deposit a Bank guarantee for 12 months (which
shall be extended if required) of necessary amount, as
per direction of EIC, to cover the financial liability on
account of pending revision of MOS agreement for the
entire contractual period. On failing to submit above
documents, IOCL will be entitled to withheld/deduct
necessary amount, as per discretion of EIC, from any
amount due from IOCL to the Contractor under this &/or
any other contract. Further, IOCL at the risk and cost of
the contractor, will also be entitled to fulfil the
requirements of the new Charter of Demands (MOS
agreement) including payment of arrears etc. (if any),
either directly or through a third party, in case the
contractor falls to do so. Contractor is advised to take
into consideration financial liability arising on account of
revised MOS for the entire co period and quote
accordingly.”

8

27. Thus the petitioner is bound by the terms and conditions of MOS and
contract, as the petitioner has been working with the respondent (IOCL)
Establishment as a contractor since 19.01.2018 and even when another
contract was entered into on 30.08.2023.
28. The writ petition is thus dismissed, as no grounds for interference
in the impugned orders is made out.

29. Learned Registrar General shall release the amount deposited in
compliance of this Court’s order dated 28.11.2025 along with interest at
once, to the respondent/IOCL who shall in turn disburse the same to
the workers entitled to it within 3 (three) months from the date of this
order.
30. Applications, if any, connected thereto stand disposed of consequently.
31. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
32. Photostat certified copy of this Judgment, if applied for, be given to the
parties on priority basis upon compliance of all formalities.

(Shampa Dutt (Paul), J.)