ALI FAWAS vs STATE OF KERALA
- Court
- Kerala High Court
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A. BADHARUDEEN
TH
FRIDAY, THE 13 DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026/22ND KARTHIKA, 1948
CRL.A NO. 313 OF 2017
CRIME NO.284/2013 OF KUNNAMANGALAM POLICE STATION, KOZHIKODE
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED IN SC NO.680 OF 2014 OF
ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT II, KOZHIKODE
APPELLANTS/ ACCUSED NO.1, 3, 6 AND 7 :
1 ALI FAWAS
AGED 24 YEARS
S/O.ABHAS, PULLOOTHICHALIL HOUSE, MADAVOOR P.O.,
KUZHIPRAMMEL, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT.
2 NAVAS ABOOBACKER
AGED 25 YEARS
S/O.ABOOBACKER, MODAYANIMEETHAL HOUSE,
MADAVOOR P.O., KOZHIKODE DISTRICT.
3 REMEES
AGED 22 YEARS
S/O.ABDUL NASER, THENAPOTH HOUSE, MADAVOOR P.O.,
KOZHIKODE DISTRICT.
4 UVAISE MUHAMMED
AGED 22 YEARS
S/O.MOIDEEN KOYA, POOTHANATH POYIL HOUSE,
MADAVOOR P.O., KOZHIKODE DISTRICT.
BY ADVS.
SRI.P.V.ANOOP
RESPONDENT/ COMPLAINANT AND STATE :
1 STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM, KOCHI 682 031.
SRI. M A SHIHAB, PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
11.11.2026, WITH CRL.A.317/2017 AND 397/2017, THE COURT ON
13.11.2026 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
2
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A. BADHARUDEEN
TH
FRIDAY, THE 13 DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026/22ND KARTHIKA, 1948
CRL.A NO. 317 OF 2017
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 28.03.2017 IN SC NO.680 OF
2014 OF ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT II, KOZHIKODE
APPELLANT S/5TH ACCUSED :
ABOOBACKER SIDHEEKH
AGED 25 YEARS, S/O.MUHAMMED,
MODAYANI, MADAVOOR, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT.
BY ADV SHRI.P.V.ANOOP
RESPONDENT/ COMPLAINANT & STATE :
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM-682031.
SRI.M.A.SHIHAB, PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
11.11.2026, ALONG WITH CRL.A.313/2017 AND CONNECTED CASES,
THE COURT ON 13.11.2026 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
3
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A. BADHARUDEEN
TH
FRIDAY, THE 13 DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026/22ND KARTHIKA, 1948
CRL.A NO. 397 OF 2017
CRIME NO.284/2013 OF KUNNAMANGALAM POLICE STATION,
KOZHIKODE
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED IN SC NO.680 OF 2014 OF
ADDITIONAL DISTRICT COURT II, KOZHIKODE
APPELLANTS/2ND AND 4TH ACCUSED:
1 ALI JESEEL
AGED 23 YEARS, S/O.MOOSA, THUNNAL KANDIYIL HOUSE,
MADAVOOR, KOZHIKODE DISTRICT
2 SHANIF
AGED 25 YEARS, S/O.SULAIMAN, VAYOLI HOUSE,
MADAVOOR KOZHIKODE DISTRICT
BY ADV SHRI.P.V.ANOOP
RESPONDENT/ COMPLAINANT & S TATE :
1 STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT OF KERALA,ERNAKULAM, KOCHI-682031
SRI.M.A.SHIHAB, PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
11.11.2026, ALONG WITH CRL.A.313/2017 AND CONNECTED CASES,
THE COURT ON 13.11.2026 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
4
CR
COMMON JUDGMENT
th
Dated this the 13 day of November, 2026
Crl.A.No.313/2017 has been filed by accused Nos.1, 3, 6
and 7 in S.C.No.680/2014 on the files of the Additional
Sessions Court-II, Kozhikode, challenging judgment dated
28.03.2017 in the above case. Similarly, Crl.A.No.317/2017 has
th
been filed by the 5 accused and Crl.A.No.397/2017 has been
filed by accused Nos.2 and 4, challenging the above judgment.
2. Heard the learned counsel for the appellants/accused
Nos.1 to 7 and the learned Public Prosecutor in detail. Perused
the judgment under challenge and the available records.
3. Here, the prosecution allegation is that the accused
persons in this crime formed into unlawful assembly with
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
5
deadly weapons, with knowledge that they were all members of
the said assembly, with intention to do away with PW6, PW7
and PW8. In pursuance of the said common object, they
assaulted them and caused multiple serious injuries to them,
though they survived. This is the base on which the prosecution
alleges commission of offences punishable under Sections 143,
147, 148, 447, 323, 324 and 307 r/w. 149 of the Indian Penal
Code (hereinafter referred to as ‘IPC’ for short) by accused Nos.
1 to 7/the appellants.
4. The learned Additional Sessions Judge framed
charge for the said offences and proceeded with trial. During
trial, PW1 to PW12 were examined, Exts.P1 to P10 and MO1
and MO2 were marked on the side of the prosecution. No
evidence was let in on the side of the defence.
5. On appreciation of the evidence, the learned
Additional Sessions Judge found that the appellants/accused
Nos.1 to 7 had committed the offences punishable under
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
6
Sections 143, 144, 147, 148, 447, 323, 324 and 307 r/w. 149 of
IPC. Accordingly, they were convicted for the said offences and
sentenced as under:
“ In the result of the accused are sentenced to
undergo rigorous imprisonment for 2 months each and
to pay a fine of Rs.2000/- each in default of payment of
fine they shall undergo simple imprisonment for one
month each for the offence under section 143 r/w.149
IPC.
The accused are further sentenced to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for 6 months each and to pay a
fine of Rs.3000/- each in default of payment of fine they
shall undergo simple imprisonment for 2 months each
for the offence under section 144 r/w. 149 IPC.
Further the accused are sentenced to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for 6 months each and to pay a
fine of Rs.3000/- each in default of payment of fine they
shall undergo simple imprisonment for 2 months each
for the offience under section 147 r/w.149 IPC.
Further the accused are sentenced to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for 1 year each and to pay a fine
of Rs.5000/- each in default of payment of fine they shall
undergo simple imprisonment for 3 months each for the
offence under section 148 IPC.
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
7
Further the accused are sentenced to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for 2 months each and to pay a
fine of Rs.1000/- each in default of payment of fine they
shall undergo simple imprisonment for 1 month each for
the offence under section 447 r/w 149 IPC.
Further all the accused are sentenced to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for 4 months each and to pay a
fine of Rs.1000/- each in default of payment of fine they
shall undergo simple imprisonment for 1 month each for
the offence under section 323 r/w 149 IPC.
Further the accused are sentenced to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for 1 year each and to pay a fine
of Rs.3000/- each in default of payment of fine they shall
undergo simple imprisonment for 3 months each for the
offence under section 324 r/w 149 IPC.
Further the accused are sentenced to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for 5 years each and to pay a
fine of Rs.10000/- in default of payment of fine they shall
undergo rigorous imprisonment for 6 months each for
the offence under section 307 r/w 149 IPC.
These accused are entitled to get set off under
section 428 Cr PC. The substantive terms of sentence
shall run concurrently. If the fine amount is realised a
sum of Rs.50000/- shall be given to PW6 as
compensation under section 357(1)Cr.PC. Further the
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
8
accused are acquitted tinder section 235(1) Cr.PC for
the offence punishable under section 294(b) r/w 149
IPC. MO1 and 2 will be destroyed”
6. The learned counsel for the appellants would submit
that the entire case is the outcome of political rivalry between
the accused persons and the injured persons. He also submitted
that the injuries sustained by the injured persons, viz., PW6,
PW7 and PW8, were trivial in nature. Therefore, the learned
Additional Sessions Judge went wrong in finding that accused
Nos.1 to 7 had committed offences punishable under Sections
143, 144, 147, 148, 447, 323, 324 and 307 r/w. 149 of IPC.
According to him, in order to prove Ext.P7, the accident register-
cum-wound certificate of PW6, PW11 examined was not the
doctor who had issued the same. It is pointed out that when
evaluating the entire evidence, false implication of the appellants
in this crime due to political rivalry could be discernible and in
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
9
such view of the matter, the appellants are entitled to acquittal,
enlarging the benefit of doubt.
7. The learned Public Prosecutor opposed the contentions
raised by the learned counsel for the appellants. According to him,
PW6 sustained very serious injuries and multiple fractures on vital
parts, as discernible from the evidence of PW11 and Ext.P7,
though PW7 and PW8 did not sustain very serious injuries, as
discernible from Ext.P1, supported by the evidence of PW1 and
Ext.P8, supported by the evidence of PW11. According to the
learned Public Prosecutor, on evaluating the evidence, the
ingredients for the offences could be found, and in such a case,
there is no necessity to interfere with the verdict impugned.
8. Having addressed the rival arguments, the points
arise for consideration are;
1. Whether the trial court went wrong in holding
that the accused persons committed offence
punishable under Section 143 r/w. 149 of
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
10
IPC?
2. Whether the trial court went wrong in holding
that the accused persons committed offence
punishable under Section 144 r/w. 149 of
IPC?
3. Whether the trial court went wrong in holding
that the accused persons committed offence
punishable under Section 147 r/w. 149 of
IPC?
4. Whether the trial court went wrong in holding
that the accused persons committed offence
punishable under Section 148 r/w. 149 of
IPC?
5. Whether the trial court went wrong in holding
that the accused persons committed offence
punishable under Section 447 r/w. 149 of
IPC?
6. Whether the trial court went wrong in holding
that the accused persons committed offence
punishable under Section 323 r/w. 149 of
IPC?
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
11
7. Whether the trial court went wrong in holding
that the accused persons committed offence
punishable under Section 324 r/w. 149 of IPC?
8. Whether the trial court went wrong in holding
that the accused persons committed offence
punishable under Section 307 r/w. 149 of IPC?
9. Whether the trial court verdict requires
interference?
10 The order to be passed.
9. Point Nos.1 to 10:
Here, the injured persons are PW6, PW7 and PW8, as
already mentioned. PW6 examined in this case is the de-facto
complainant as well as one of the injured witnesses. He
deposed that, at about 8.00 pm on 11.04.2013, when the local
committee meeting was going on in the party office at
Payimbalassery, he heard some tumult and annoyance from
outside. He came out of the party office to see what was going
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
12
on outside. All of a sudden, a mob consisting of these accused
persons attacked him. He further deposed that the first
accused, Ali Fawas, who carried an iron rod, beaten on his
head. The second accused, Ali Jaseel, hit him with a piece of
th
stone on his head. Then the 7 accused kicked him. In the
meantime, Ali Fawas was shouting to "kill him". PW6 further
deposed that Bhaskaran and Irshad (PW8 and PW7
respectively) came to his rescue. But they were also beaten by
the mob. Thereafter, he was taken to the road by Sreedharan
and Bhaskaran and then to the Medical College Hospital by
Abdurahiman, PW10. He further deposed that all of these
accused were the members of the said mob and they were
holding deadly weapons. He testified that he had prior
acquaintance with these accused persons. According to him,
he gave Ext.P5 statement to the police while he was
undergoing treatment pursuant to the injuries sustained in this
occurrence. He had identified MO1 and MO2, used by
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
13
accused Nos.1 and 2 respectively.
10. Another injured witness examined is PW7. He
deposed that at the time of incident, he was in front of the party
office. Hearing hue and cry from the party office, he rushed
there and then he found PW6 was laying in front of the
courtyard of the party office. When he attempted to take care of
him, he was also beaten by these accused. He further deposed
that Ali Fawas (A1), Ali Jaseel (A2), Navas (A3), Shanif (A4),
Aboobacker Siddick (A5), Ramees (A6) and Uvaise (A7) were in
the mob of assailants and they were holding iron rods and
stones. He was beaten by Navas (A3) with an iron rod. He
would further depose that two days prior to the occurrence,
there was an incident in which he sustained injuries, in the said
incident also, some of these accused were involved. In
paragraph No.18 of the judgment, the learned Additional
Sessions Judge was not inclined to accept the evidence of
PW7, holding that his evidence would be against the natural
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
14
human conduct.
11. Supporting the evidence of PW6 and PW7, PW8,
Sri.Bhaskaran, who also sustained injuries in this occurrence as
on 11.04.2013, gave evidence. According to him, when he had
reached the market, he heard a cry from the party office and
found PW6, Sri.Balan lying on the veranda of the office and he
tried to lift him. While he was doing so, a group of persons
attacked him, and they included Shanif (A4), Navas (A3) and
Ramees (A6). Consequently, he fell down and then they kicked
him. His version further is that he had sustained injuries in this
occurrence. He deposed that when more persons reached the
place, the accused persons ran away. He identified Navas (A3)
and Ramees (A6) at the dock. Similarly, while evaluating the
evidence of PW8, in paragraph No.19, the learned Additional
Sessions Judge found that the ocular testimony of PW8 also not
safely be reliable.
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
15
12. Even ignoring the evidence given by PW7 and PW8,
for the reasons extracted in the judgment, the learned Additional
Sessions Judge believed the evidence of PW6 to find
commission of offences under Sections 143, 144, 147, 148, 447,
323, 324 and 307 r/w. 149 of IPC by the accused. In this
context, the medical evidence regarding the treatment underwent
by PW6 soon after the occurrence also is very relevant. PW11,
Dr.Chandrasekharan S., testified that while he was working as
Assistant Professor in General Surgery at the Government
Medical College Hospital, Kozhikode, he worked along with
Dr.T.V.Murali for the same period and was familiar with the
handwriting and signature of Dr.T.V.Murali. According to him,
Dr.T.V.Murali was not working in the Medical College Hospital
during the period of his examination and was doing higher
studies. Thus his presence for examination could not be secured.
He deposed that at 9.00 p.m. on 11.04.13, Dr.Murali examined
one Balan (PW6) on the allegation tha t '
ഒരു കൂട്ടം ആളുകൾ
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
16
8.30 pm on
ആക്രമിച്ച് ഉണ്ടായ പരിക്ക് മടവൂർ പൈമ്പാലശ്ശേ രി ന്
11.04.2013’ and he had noted the following injuries sustained to
Balan.
Injuries 6 x .5 x .5 cm lacerated wound frontal region.
Left eye, black eye / hematoma. C.T. Scan showed linear
hematoma. Fracture orbit medial wall, fracture frontal wall.
Fractural left maxillary sinuses fracture through thread sinuses.
It was through him, the certificate issued by Dr.T.V.Murali which
would bear his signature got marked as Ext.P7. According to
him, these injuries caused could be possible as alleged. PW1
deposed further that on the same day at 10 p.m., Dr.T.V.Murali
examined Irshad, 24 years old male, came with same allegation.
He deposed further that the injury is soft tissue contusion right
flank abdomen. No other injury. The wound certificate issued by
Dr.T.V.Murali, which would bear his signature, got marked as
Ext.P8. He opined that “ injuries mentioned in Ext.P7 are
grievous in nature and might have resulted in death, if not
medically attended properly”.
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
17
13. During cross-examination, possibility of sustaining
injuries by other means was also suggested and got answered
in the affirmative. On going through the evidence of PW11,
supported by PW6, very serious injuries, including multiple
fractures on the head and maxilliary region, to be found as far
as PW6 is concerned. Thus the evidence of PW6, supported by
the medical evidence, would establish the prosecution case.
14. In addition to that, PW1, Dr.Balaji Scaria, who had
examined PW8, also supported issuance of Ext.P1 wound
certificate. According to him, PW8 sustained injuries to the left
shoulder and arm. The patient was conscious and oriented at
the time of examination. During cross-examination, he stated
that X-ray did not show any bony injury. During further cross-
examination, he testified that the patient had made only
complaints of pain. It is true that, as far as the injuries sustained
by PW8 are concerned, the same are not serious injuries.
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
18
15. Now, it is necessary to address the ingredients
required to attract the offences under Sections 324 and 307 of
IPC. Section 324 of IPC reads as under:
“S.324 - Voluntarily causing hurt by dangerous
weapons or means.- Whoever, except in the case
provided for by section 334, voluntarily causes hurt by
means of any instrument for shooting. stabbing, or cutting,
or any instrument which, used as a weapon of offence, is
likely to cause death, or by means of fire or any heated
substance, or by means of any poison or any corrosive
substance, or by means of any explosive substance, or by
means of any substance which it is deleterious to the
human body to inhale, to swallow, or to receive into the
blood, or by means of any animal, shall be punished with
imprisonment of either description for a term which may
extend to three years, or with fine, or with both.”
16. The ingredients for the offence punishable under
Section 324 of the IPC are as under:
“(i) That the accused voluntarily caused hurt to another
person;
(ii) That such a hurt was in exception to cases provided
under section 334;
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
19
(iii) That such hurt was caused
(a) by means of any instrument for shooting,
stabbing or cutting, or any instrument
which used as a weapon of offence is
likely to cause death; or
(b) by means of fire or any heated substance,
or
(c) by means of any poison or any corrosive
substance, or
(d) by means of any explosive substance; or
(e) by means of any substance which is
deleterious to the human body to inhale,
to swallow, or receive into the blood; or
(f) by means of any animal.
Evidence.- To bring home an offence punishable under
section 324, the prosecution is to prove: (a) that the
accused caused hurt i.e., caused bodily pain, or disease or
infirmity (vide section 319 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860)
to another; (b) that it has been caused voluntarily i.e., with
knowledge or intention to cause; (c) that it has been caused
by any instrument for shooting, or stabbing or cutting, or by
any instrument which qua weapon of offence is likely to
cause death, or by means of fire or any heated substance
or by means of any poison or any corrosive substance or by
means of any explosive substance or by means of any
substance which is deleterious to the human body to inhale
to swallow or to receive into blood or by means of any
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
20
animal, and (d) that the offence does not attract section 334
IPC.”
17. Section 307 of the IPC reads as under:
“ 307. Attempt to murder. —Whoever does any act with
such intention or knowledge, and under such circumstances
that, if he by that act caused death, he would be guilty of
murder, shall be punished with imprisonment of either
description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall
also be liable to fine; and if hurt is caused to any person by such
act, the offender shall be liable either to imprisonment for life, or
to such punishment as is hereinbefore mentioned.”
18. Similarly, the ingredients for the offence punishable
under Section 307 of the IPC are as under:
“(i) That the accused did an act;
(ii) That the act was done with intention or knowledge and
under such circumstances to cause a bodily injury as
the accused knew to be likely to cause death or that
such bodily injury was in the ordinary course of nature
to cause death, or that the accused attempted to cause
such death by doing an act known to him to be so
imminently dangerous that it must in all probability
cause death or such bodily injury a is likely to cause
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
21
death; and
(iii) That the accused had no excuse for incurring the risk of
causing such death or injury.
In other words, the ingredients are;
(i) that the death of a human being was attempted;
(ii) that such death was attempted to be caused by, or in
consequence of the act of the accused; and
(iii) that such act was done with the intention of
causing death; or that it was done with the intention of
causing such bodily injury as:
(a) the accused knew to be likely to cause death; or
(b) was sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to
cause death, or that the accused attempted to
cause death by doing an act known to him to be
so imminently dangerous that it must in all
probability cause (a) death, or (b) such bodily
injury as is likely to cause death, the accused
having no excuse for incurring the risk of causing
such death or injury. The first part makes any act
committed with the intention or knowledge that it
would amount to murder if the act caused death
punishable with imprisonment up to ten years.
The second part makes such an act punishable
with imprisonment for life if hurt is caused
thereby. Thus even if the act does not cause any
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
22
injury it is punishable with imprisonment up to 10
years. If it does cause an injury and therefore
hurt, it is punishable with imprisonment for life.”
19. Coming to the offence under Section 149 of the IPC,
Section 149 of the IPC provides as under:
“ S.149 Every member of unlawful assembly guilty
of offence committed in prosecution of common
object. - If an offence is committed by any member of an
unlawful assembly in prosecution of the common object of
that assembly, or such as the members of that assembly
knew to be likely to be committed in prosecution of that
object, every person who, at the time of committing of that
offence, is a member of the same assembly, is guilty of that
offence.”
20. In order to constitute the offence provided under
Section 149 of the IPC, the following essentials have to be
established.
“1. There must be unlawful assembly.
2. Commission of an offence by any member of an
unlawful assembly.
3. Such offence must have been committed in
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
23
prosecution of the common object of the assembly;
or must be such as the members of the assembly
knew to be likely to be committed.”
In Debashis Daw v. State of West Bengal [(2010) 9 SCC 111 :
AIR 2010 SC 3633 : 2010 (9) SCR 654], the Supreme Court,
after referring to the decision in Akhtar Alam v. State of West
Bengal [(2009) 7 SCC 415 : 2009 (6) Scale 745) observed that
the prosecution is required to establish whether the accused
persons were present and whether they shared a common
object. The relevant question to be examined by the court is the
common object of the assembly. Mere presence in an unlawful
assembly cannot render a person liable unless there was a
common object. The common object has to be definitely found
and has not to be a matter of conjecture or inference.
It is not correct to say that section 149 of the IPC does not
constitute a substantive offence, that it was only an enabling
section for imposition of vicarious liability and the conviction on
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
24
vicarious liability can, therefore, be altered by the appellate
Court to conviction for direct liability, though there was an
acquittal by the trial Court of the direct liability of the offence.
There is a legal distinction between a charge under section 302
IPC and a charge of constructive liability under sections 302/149
IPC i.e., being a member of an unlawful assembly, the common
object of which was to kill the deceased. Section 149 was
certainly not otiose, for in any case it created a specific and
distinct offence. It postulated an assembly of five or more
persons having a common object, as named in section 141 of
the IPC and then the commission of an offence by one member
of it in prosecution of that object. Nor it is correct to say when
dealing with an offence under section 149, that all the persons
must combine together or help one another at the time of the
assault.
Section 149 requires presence of unlawful assembly of five
or more persons with any of the five objects enunciated in
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
25
section 141 of the IPC. Even if any of the members of unlawful
assembly commits an offence in prosecution of the common
object of the assembly, every member of such assembly is guilty
of such offence.
Section 149 incorporates the principle of vicarious liability.
The section is declaratory of the circumstances under which that
principle could be applied. As per this Section, the liability of the
members other than the principal offender rests upon the fact
whether those members knew that the offence actually
committed was likely to be committed in prosecution of its
common object, the knowledge which they had of the purpose
for which an unlawful assembly was formed, the conduct of its
members, the nature of arms with which they armed themselves
and whether the common object underwent any change prior to
or at the time of occurrence. If such knowledge may not
reasonably be attributed to other members of the assembly,
their liability for the offence committed during the occurrence
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
26
does not arise.
21. Here, the specific allegation of the prosecution is that
accused Nos.1 to 7 formed into unlawful assembly, armed with
deadly weapons, with knowledge that they are all members of
the said assembly, sharing a common object to do away with
PW6 and assaulted him with the said intention. The evidence of
PW6 would go to show that he was attacked at 8.00 p.m. on
11.04.2013 by the accused persons, who had formed unlawful
assembly, armed with deadly weapons, and spoke about the
overt acts done by them with common object being part of the
unlawful assembly. Even though the learned Additional Sessions
Judge disbelieved the evidence of PW7 and PW8, PW7, another
injured person, who came to rescue PW6, deposed that A1 – Ali
Fawas, A2 – Ali Jaseel, A3 - Navas, A4 – Shanif, A5 – Aboobacker
Sidheekh, A6 – Remees and A7 - Uvaise were members of the
rd
unlawful assembly and out of which the 3 accused beat him by
using an iron rod. Coming to the evidence of PW8, he deposed
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
27
that among the unlawful assembly of seven accused persons, Shanif
(A4), Navas (A3) and Ramees (A6) attacked him, and in consequence
thereof, he fell down after identifying them. Serious injuries were
sustained to PW6 and the injuries sustained to PW7 and PW8 were
extracted to corroborate the evidence of PW1. The learned Additional
Sessions Judge was not inclined to accept the evidence of PW7 and
PW8, but their evidence would suggest that they also sustained injuries
in this occurrence.
22. Thus, even ignoring the evidence of PW7 and PW8,
it is held that the prosecution has succeeded in establishing that
accused Nos.1 to 7 formed into unlawful assembly with knowledge that
they are all members of the said assembly, after sharing common
object and intention to do away PW6 and thus they attacked
PW6 to do away with him, though PW6 survived. On evaluating the
evidence discussed in detail, with the necessary ingredients to
prove the offences alleged to be committed, this Court is of the
view that the learned Additional Sessions Judge is right in finding that
accused Nos.1 to 7 had committed offences punishable under
Sections 143, 144, 147, 148, 447, 323, 324
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
28
and 307 r/w. 149 of the IPC. therefore, the conviction is liable to
be confirmed.
23. Coming to the nature and circumstances of this case,
the sentence imposed against the accused persons is found to
be very reasonable. In such view of the matter, no interference
in the sentence also is warranted. Therefore, the verdict
impugned is liable to be confirmed.
In the result, these appeals fail and the same are
dismissed.
The orders suspending sentence and granting bail to the
accused persons stand cancelled and the bail bond executed by
the accused persons also shall stand cancelled. The
appellants/accused Nos.1 to 7 are directed to surrender before
the Additional Sessions Court, forthwith to undergo the
sentence, failing which, the Additional Sessions Judge is
directed to execute the sentence, without fail.
CNR : KLHC010127852017
2026:KER:87246
CRL.A.Nos.313,317 & 397 OF 2017
29
Registry is directed to forward a copy of this judgment to
the Additional Sessions Court, forthwith, without fail, for
information and compliance.
Sd/-
A. BADHARUDEEN
JUDGE
nkr