United India Insurance Co Ltd vs Amarjit Kaur And Ors
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
FAO-4316-2002 (O&M) and
other connected matters
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
(Sr. No. 117)
FAO-4316-2002 (O&M)
(1) Reserved on : 12.11.2026
Pronounced on : 20.11.2026
Uploaded on: 21.11.2026
United India Insurance Company Limited ...Appellant
Versus
Amarjit Kaur and others ...Respondents
(2) FAO-4317-2002 (O&M)
United India Insurance Company Limited ...Appellant
Versus
Surender Pal Singh and others ...Respondents
(3) FAO-4190-2002 (O&M)
Amarjit Kaur and others ...Appellants
Versus
Rajinder Kumar Tandon and another ...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMARINDER SINGH GREWAL
Present: Mr. Gopal Mittal, Advocate, with
Mr. Simranjot Singh, Advocate,
for the appellant-Insurance Company
in FAO-4316-2002 and FAO-4317-2002.
Mr. Dheeraj Narula, Advocate,
for the appellants in FAO-4190-2002 and
for the respondents/claimants in FAO-4316-2002 and
FAO-4317-2002.
Amarinder Singh Grewal, J.
KANCHAN
2026.11.21 10:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-4316-2002 (O&M) and
other connected matters
2
1 This judgment shall dispose of the above-mentioned three
appeals, namely, FAO-4316-2002, FAO-4317-2002 and FAO-4190-2002, as
they arise out of a common award dated 07.05.2002 passed by the learned
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Sirsa (hereinafter referred to as 'the learned
Tribunal'). FAO-4190-2002 has been filed by the claimants seeking
enhancement of compensation awarded in MACT Case No. 57 of 1999,
whereas FAO-4316-2002 and FAO-4317-2002 have been preferred by
United India Insurance Company Limited (hereinafter referred to as 'the
Insurance Company'), challenging its liability under the awards passed in
MACT Case No. 57 of 1999 and MACT Case No. 58 of 1999, respectively.
2. For the sake of convenience, the facts are being taken from
FAO-4190-2002, and the parties shall be referred to hereinafter by their
respective status before the learned Tribunal.
3. The facts, in brief, are that on 15.08.1999 Sukhdev Singh took
his father Gian Singh on a scooter to Dabwali for treatment. On 16.08.1999,
at about 9 A.M., while they were returning to village Kanganpur, with
Sukhdev Singh driving the scooter and Gian Singh as the pillion rider, Car
No. DNH-5331, driven by respondent no.1 (Rajinder Kumar Tandon) in a
rash and negligent manner, came from the side of village Chormar Khera
and struck against the scooter near village Mithri. Both the occupants fell
down and sustained serious injuries. The accident was witnessed by
Surender Pal Singh, brother of Sukhdev Singh, and by Hardev Singh.
Sukhdev Singh died on the way to the hospital and Gian Singh also
succumbed to his injuries. FIR No. 48 dated 16.08.1999 was registered at
KANCHAN
2026.11.21 10:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-4316-2002 (O&M) and
other connected matters
3
Police Station Odhan. Sukhdev Singh was about 45 years of age, an
agriculturist who was also running a milk dairy. His widow Amarjit Kaur
and four children , namely Harjeet Kaur, Hardev Singh, Baljinder Kaur and
Harvinder Singh, filed MACT Case No. 57 of 1999 claiming Rs. 10,00,000/-
along with interest at 18% per annum. Surender Pal Singh, son of Gian
Singh, filed MACT Case No. 58 of 1999 claiming Rs. 3,00,000/-, in which
Amarjit Kaur and her children were also impleaded as legal heirs of Gian
Singh vide order dated 07.02.2001.
4. Respondent No. 1, the owner-driver, Rajinder Kumar Tandon,
and respondent No. 2, the Insurance Company, contested the claim petitions
by filing separate written statements. While respondent No. 1 denied his
involvement in the accident, respondent No. 2 disputed the negligence and
income of the deceased and denied its liability on the ground that the driver
did not possess a valid driving licence.
5. Both the petitions were consolidated vide order dated
30.07.2001 and the learned Tribunal framed three issues besides the relief,
relating to negligence and death, to the validity of the driving licence of the
driver, and to the entitlement of the claimants to compensation.
6. The learned Tribunal held that the accident was caused by rash
and negligent driving of the owner-driver and that both Gian Singh and
Sukhdev Singh died in it. It noticed overwriting on the copy of the driving
licence (Mark RA), yet held that the Insurance Company was bound to
satisfy the claim of the third parties and could recover the amount from the
insured. It assessed the monthly income of Sukhdev Singh at Rs. 2,000/-,
KANCHAN
2026.11.21 10:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-4316-2002 (O&M) and
other connected matters
4
deducted one-third towards personal expenses and applied the multiplier of
11, awarding Rs. 1,76,000/-, and awarded Rs. 60,000/- for the death of Gian
Singh. Interest at 9% per annum was granted from the date of filing of the
petitions and the owner-driver and the Insurance Company were held jointly
and severally liable. Aggrieved by the award passed by the learned Tribunal,
both sides have preferred the present appeals.
7. Learned counsel for the claimants in FAO-4190-2002 contends
that the compensation awarded by the learned Tribunal is meagre and
inadequate. It is submitted that the deceased was an agriculturist who was
also running a milk dairy and earning Rs. 5,000/- per month or more,
whereas the learned Tribunal arbitrarily assessed his monthly income at Rs.
2,000/- only. Learned counsel further contends that the deduction of one-
third towards personal and living expenses is unjustified, particularly when
the deceased left behind a widow and children, and that, at the most, a
deduction of one-fourth ought to have been made. It is also argued that, in
view of the unrebutted evidence that the grandfather of the deceased had
died at the age of 105 years, the learned Tribunal ought to have applied a
multiplier of 20 instead of 11. Furthermore, it is submitted that, following
the death of the deceased, the family was compelled to engage two servants
to undertake the agricultural work, yet no compensation has been awarded
towards such expenses. Learned counsel lastly submits that no amount has
been awarded towards funeral expenses or the conventional heads and,
accordingly, the claimants are entitled to the compensation as claimed in the
claim petition.
KANCHAN
2026.11.21 10:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-4316-2002 (O&M) and
other connected matters
5
8. Learned counsel for the Insurance Company in FAO-4316-2002
and FAO-4317-2002 contends that the Insurance Company had established,
through the testimony of RW-1 Sanjeev Kumar, Clerk from the office of the
District Transport Officer, Faridkot, that driving licence No. 51991/FDK
(Mark RA) was issued on 24.12.1987 in the name of L.T. Tandon, son of
P.C. Tandon, and not in the name of the owner-driver. The said licence was
valid up to 23.12.1992 and was subsequently renewed from 15.09.1999 to
14.07.2004. It is further contended that both the said witnesses and the
learned Tribunal noticed overwriting on Mark RA, thereby rendering the
driving licence relied upon by the owner-driver doubtful. Learned counsel
submits that the owner-driver, therefore, did not possess a valid and effective
driving licence on the date of the accident and had consequently breached
the terms and conditions of the insurance policy. On this premise, it is
argued that the learned Tribunal erred in fastening liability upon the
Insurance Company, even by directing it to pay and recover the
compensation from the owner-driver. It is further urged that the impugned
awards are contrary to the mandatory provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988, as well as the settled position of law. Learned counsel, therefore, prays
that the impugned awards be set aside to the extent of the liability fastened
upon the Insurance Company and the appeals be allowed.
9. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents-claimants in
FAO-4316-2002 and FAO-4317-2002 submits that the offending car was
admittedly insured with the Insurance Company (Ex. R1), that the deceased
were third parties, and that the Insurance Company has neither established
KANCHAN
2026.11.21 10:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-4316-2002 (O&M) and
other connected matters
6
that the driving licence was fake nor proved any wilful breach of the policy
conditions on the part of the owner-driver. It is, accordingly, contended that
the direction issued by the learned Tribunal permitting the Insurance
Company to recover the amount from the owner-driver does not call for
interference.
10. On the other hand, learned counsel for the Insurance Company,
appearing in FAO-4190-2002 , submits that the claimants failed to produce
any documentary evidence to establish the income of the deceased; that
Amarjit Kaur (PW-1) herself admitted that she had no record of his income;
that the learned Tribunal had already assessed his income reasonably and
applied the appropriate multiplier having regard to his age; and that no
ground for enhancement of compensation is made out.
11. This Court has heard learned counsel for the parties and has
perused the paper books and the record of the learned Tribunal.
Appeals of the Insurance Company (FAO-4316-2002 and FAO-4317-
2002)
12. At the outset, it may be noticed that the findings of the learned
Tribunal on issue No. 1 regarding rash and negligent driving of the owner-
driver and the death of Gian Singh and Sukhdev Singh in the accident have
not been challenged in any of the appeals. These findings are based on the
statement of PW-2 Surender Pal Singh, the copy of FIR No. 48 registered at
Police Station Odhan on the date of the accident (Ex.PA), the final report
under Section 173 Cr.P.C. presented against the owner-driver (Ex.PC) and
the post-mortem reports of Sukhdev Singh (Ex.PB) and Gian Singh (Ex.PG).
KANCHAN
2026.11.21 10:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-4316-2002 (O&M) and
other connected matters
7
It is also not disputed that the car was owned by the owner-driver and was
insured with the Insurance Company (Ex.R1; cover note No. 898452 valid
from 07.12.1998 to 06.12.1999). The only question that remains is whether
the Insurance Company can escape its liability on the ground of the driving
licence. RW-1 Sanjeev Kumar deposed that driving licence No. 51991/FDK
(Mark RA) was originally issued on 24.12.1987 in the name of L.T. Tandon,
was valid up to 23.12.1992 and was subsequently renewed from 15.09.1999
to 14.07.2004. He further stated that a duplicate licence was issued on
15.09.1999. The witness admitted that the name of the licence holder on
Mark RA appeared to have been changed from L.T. Tandon to R.K. Tandon.
However, he did not produce the original licensing record, including the
application for issuance, renewal or grant of duplicate licence, nor could he
establish whether the correction in the name was authorised or unauthorised.
He was also unable to identify the photograph appearing on Mark RA or
confirm whether any application for correction of the name had been
submitted or an order passed by the licensing authority. It is further evident
that Mark RA is a photocopy of the duplicate licence issued on 15.09.1999,
i.e., after the accident, and the original licence allegedly held by the owner-
driver on the date of the accident has not been produced. Thus, the evidence
of RW-1, by itself, does not conclusively establish that the owner-driver was
not holding a valid driving licence on the date of the accident or that the
licence was forged. The legal position in this regard stands settled by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh ,
(2004) 3 SCC 297 , wherein it has been held that the insurer cannot avoid its
KANCHAN
2026.11.21 10:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-4316-2002 (O&M) and
other connected matters
8
liability towards third parties merely on the ground of absence, invalidity or
falsity of a driving licence unless the requisite breach of the policy
conditions by the insured is established. The burden of proving such breach
rests upon the insurer. Even where a breach is established, the insurer
remains liable to satisfy the award in favour of third parties, with liberty to
recover the amount from the insured in the same proceedings, wherever such
direction is warranted.
13. In the present case, the evidence led by the Insurance Company
leaves the matter inconclusive. The mere overwriting noticed on Mark RA,
in the absence of the original licensing record or any conclusive evidence
establishing forgery or unauthorised alteration, does not by itself prove that
the licence was fake or that there was a wilful breach of the policy conditions
attributable to the insured. In any case, even if it is assumed that the
Insurance Company has established that the owner-driver did not hold a
valid and effective driving licence on the date of the accident, as the licence
stood valid only up to 23.12.1992 and its renewal is shown from 15.09.1999,
i.e., after the accident, the same would, at the most, amount to a breach of
the policy condition by the insured. The deceased being third parties, the
Insurance Company, in view of Section 149 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
and the law laid down in Swaran Singh (supra), cannot avoid its liability to
satisfy the award and is entitled only to recover the amount from the insured,
i.e., the owner-driver, who himself was driving the car. The learned Tribunal
has already granted this right of recovery to the Insurance Company. In these
circumstances, no ground is made out for absolving the Insurance Company
KANCHAN
2026.11.21 10:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-4316-2002 (O&M) and
other connected matters
9
of its liability towards the claimants or for interfering with the direction
issued by the learned Tribunal.
Appeal of the claimants (FAO-4190-2002)
14. The claimants seek enhancement only of the compensation
awarded in MACT Case No. 57 of 1999 on account of the death of Sukhdev
Singh. His age of 45 years is established by the post-mortem report (Ex.PB)
and the statement of PW-1 Amarjit Kaur, and he is survived by his widow
and four children. The compensation awarded for the death of Gian Singh in
MACT Case No. 58 of 1999 has not been questioned by the claimants.
15. As regards the income, PW-1 Amarjit Kaur deposed that her
husband and her father-in-law were agriculturists who were also running a
milk dairy jointly and that each of them was earning Rs. 5,000/- per month,
but she admitted that she possesses no record of the income of the deceased.
PW-2 Surender Pal Singh admitted that the land of Gian Singh was mutated
in equal shares in favour of himself and Sukhdev Singh (Ex.PD, Ex.PE and
Ex.PF), that after the death of Sukhdev Singh his share was inherited by the
claimants, and that Gian Singh used to divide his income in equal shares
between his two sons. These documents prove only the ownership of the
land. The learned Tribunal also noticed the suggestion put on behalf of the
Insurance Company that Gian Singh and his sons had two killas of land
which used to be leased out at Rs. 10,000/- to Rs. 12,000/- per killa per year,
which would be Rs. 20,000/- to Rs. 24,000/- per annum for the entire
holding [2 killas x Rs. 10,000/- to Rs. 12,000/-], i.e., Rs. 1,667/- to Rs.
2,000/- per month [Rs. 20,000/- / 12 to Rs. 24,000/- / 12], to be shared by the
KANCHAN
2026.11.21 10:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-4316-2002 (O&M) and
other connected matters
10
family. There is no document on record regarding the milk dairy or any other
source of income. The claim of Rs. 5,000/- per month is thus not
substantiated.
16. In the absence of proof of actual income, the income has to be
assessed notionally, keeping in view the nature of the work and the
minimum wages payable in the year of the accident, i.e., 1999. The
minimum wage payable to an agricultural worker in the State of Haryana as
on 01.01.1999 was Rs. 70.12 per day which works out to Rs. 1,823.12 per
month [Rs. 70.12 x 26 working days]. The monthly income of Rs. 2,000/-
assessed by the learned Tribunal for a person engaged in agriculture and
dairy farming is, therefore, higher than the notional income of an agricultural
labourer and cannot be said to be on the lower side so as to call for
interference. The income is accordingly retained at Rs. 2,000/- per month
[Rs. 24,000/- per annum].
17. The deceased was self-employed and 45 years of age at the time
of the accident, as established from the post-mortem report (Ex. PB).
However, the learned Tribunal did not make any addition towards future
prospects while assessing his income. In view of National Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi , (2017) 16 SCC 680 , an addition of 25% is to be made,
which brings the monthly income to Rs. 2,500/- [Rs. 2,000/- + Rs. 500/-
(25% of Rs. 2,000/-)], i.e., Rs. 30,000/- per annum [Rs. 2,500/- x 12].
18. As regards the deduction towards personal expenses, the
deceased left behind his widow and four children, i.e., five dependents [1 +
4]. As per Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation , (2009) 6 SCC 121 ,
KANCHAN
2026.11.21 10:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-4316-2002 (O&M) and
other connected matters
11
the deduction in such a case is one-fourth and not one-third. Deducting Rs.
7,500/- [1/4 of Rs. 30,000/-], the annual loss of dependency comes to Rs.
22,500/- [Rs. 30,000/- - Rs. 7,500/-].
19. As regards the multiplier, the age of the deceased at the time of
the accident being 45 years, the multiplier is 14 as per Sarla Verma (supra)
and not 11 as applied by the learned Tribunal. The contention of the
claimants that the multiplier of 20 should have been applied because the
grandfather of the deceased had died at the age of 105 years cannot be
accepted, as the multiplier depends upon the age of the deceased and not
upon the longevity of his ancestors. The loss of dependency thus comes to
Rs. 3,15,000/- [Rs. 22,500/- x 14].
20. The learned Tribunal granted nothing towards loss of estate,
funeral expenses and consortium, which is contrary to law. In Pranay Sethi
(supra) the Hon'ble Supreme Court fixed Rs. 15,000/- each for loss of estate
and funeral expenses and Rs. 40,000/- for loss of consortium, with an
enhancement of 10% in every three years. Applying the increase of 10%
twice, the claimants are held entitled to Rs. 18,150/- each for loss of estate
and funeral expenses and to Rs. 48,400/- for loss of consortium to the
widow. Further, in view of Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu
Ram , (2018) 18 SCC 130, each of the four children is entitled to Rs.
48,400/- towards parental consortium, aggregating to Rs. 1,93,600/- [Rs.
48,400/- × 4]. The claim towards expenses incurred on engaging two
servants has not been substantiated by any documentary or oral evidence and
is, therefore, declined.
KANCHAN
2026.11.21 10:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-4316-2002 (O&M) and
other connected matters
12
21. The compensation payable to the claimants is thus Rs.
5,93,300/- [Rs. 3,15,000/- (loss of dependency) + Rs. 18,150/- (estate) + Rs.
18,150/- (funeral) + Rs. 48,400/- (widow's consortium) + Rs. 1,93,600/-
(parental consortium)] as against Rs. 1,76,000/- awarded by the learned
Tribunal, resulting in an enhancement of Rs. 4,17,300/- [Rs. 5,93,300/- - Rs.
1,76,000/-]. The comparative position is as follows:
Heads Awarded by the Assessed by this Court
learned Tribunal
Monthly income Rs. 2,000/- Rs. 2,000/- (retained)
Future prospects (self- Nil 25% [Rs. 500/- (25% of Rs. 2,000/-)]
employed, age 45)
Monthly income after Rs. 2,000/- Rs. 2,500/- [Rs. 2,000/- + Rs. 500/-]
future prospects
Annual income Rs. 24,000/- [Rs. Rs. 30,000/- [Rs. 2,500/- x 12]
2,000/- x 12]
Deduction towards 1/3 [Rs. 8,000/-] 1/4 [Rs. 7,500/-]
personal expenses
Annual loss of Rs. 16,000/- [Rs. Rs. 22,500/- [Rs. 30,000/- - Rs.
dependency 24,000/- - Rs. 8,000/-] 7,500/-]
Multiplier (age 45 11 14
years)
Loss of dependency Rs. 1,76,000/- [Rs. Rs. 3,15,000/-
16,000/- x 11] [Rs. 22,500/- x 14]
Loss of estate Nil Rs. 18,150/- [Rs. 15,000/- + 10% +
10%]
Funeral expenses Nil Rs. 18,150/- [Rs. 15,000/- + 10% +
10%]
Loss of consortium Nil Rs. 48,400/- [Rs. 40,000/- + 10% +
(widow) 10%]
Parental consortium Nil Rs. 1,93,600/- [Rs. 48,400/- x 4]
(four children)
Total compensation Rs. 1,76,000/- Rs. 5,93,300/- [Rs. 3,15,000/- +
18,150/- + 18,150/- + 48,400/- +
1,93,600/-]
Enhancement - Rs. 4,17,300/- [Rs. 5,93,300/- - Rs.
1,76,000/-]
KANCHAN
2026.11.21 10:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
FAO-4316-2002 (O&M) and
other connected matters
13
22. In the result, FAO-4190-2002 is allowed and the award dated
07.05.2002 in MACT Case No. 57 of 1999 is modified to the extent that the
claimants shall be entitled to a total compensation of Rs. 5,93,300/-, i.e., an
enhancement of Rs. 4,17,300/-, along with interest at the rate of 7.5% per
annum on the enhanced amount from the date of filing of the claim petition
till its realisation. The remaining terms and conditions including liability as
recorded in the award passed by the learned Tribunal shall remain unaltered.
23. Consequently, FAO-4316-2002 and FAO-4317-2002 filed by
the Insurance Company are dismissed. Pending applications, if any, also
stand disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs.
24. A photocopy of this judgment be placed on the files of the
connected appeals.
November 20, 2026 (AMARINDER SINGH GREWAL)
kanchan JUDGE
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes
Whether reportable : No
KANCHAN
2026.11.21 10:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document