Hemant Kumar vs The State Of Haryana
- Court
- Supreme Court
2026 INSC 878
REPORTABLE
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPEAL NOS. OF 2026
(Arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) Nos. 12017-12018 OF
2023)
HEMANT KUMAR & ORS. APPELLANT(S)
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA RESPONDENT(S)
WITH
CIVIL APPEAL NOS. OF 2026
(Arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) Nos. 7597-7600 OF
2023)
CIVIL APPEAL NOS. OF 2026
(Arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) Nos. 7506-7508 OF
2023)
CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(Arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) No. 8142 OF 2023)
CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(Arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) No. 8004 OF 2023
CIVIL APPEAL NOS. OF 2026
(Arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) Nos. 20961-20967 OF
2024
CIVIL APPEAL NOS. OF 2026
(Arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) Nos. 19938-19941 OF
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
IRAMNAZ
Date: 2026.08.18
17:11:39 IST
Reason:
2023
AND
CIVIL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(Arising out of Special Leave Petition (C) No. 18809 OF 2023
J U D G M E N T
UJJAL BHUYAN, J.
Leave granted.
2. Since the issues involved in all the appeals are
inter-related, arising out of the same subject matter, those
were heard together and are being disposed of by this common
judgment and order.
3. The core issue involved in this batch of appeals is
the legality and validity of the deputation of four officers of the
Development and Panchayat Department, Government of
Haryana viz. Shri Pradeep Atri, Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Shri
Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia in the cadre of Sub-
Divisional Officer to the Public Works Department (Building
and Roads), Government of Haryana, briefly ‘the PW (B&R)
Department hereinafter, and the subsequent absorption of the
aforesaid four officers in the PW (B&R) Department in the
cadre of Assistant Engineer (Civil)/Sub-Divisional Engineer.
2
An associated issue is the seniority position assigned to the
aforesaid four officers upon their absorption in the PW (B&R)
Department.
4. The High Court of Punjab and Haryana (High
Court) vide the impugned judgment and order dated
15.03.2023 disposed of nine writ petitions filed by the
contesting parties holding that the deputation to and
absorption of Shri Pradeep Atri, Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Shri
Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia in the PW(B&R)
Department, Government of Haryana as Assistant Engineer
(Civil) is bad in law. However, the High Court took the view that
these four officers no longer had lien in their parent
Department i.e. the Development and Panchayat Department,
Government of Haryana and further as they have been in
service since the year 2005, their deputation and absorption
as Assistant Engineer in the PW (B&R) Department,
Government of Haryana was not disturbed. But the High Court
declared that they (deputationists) cannot claim seniority over
the direct recruits appointed on 07.12.2007 or over persons
promoted against vacancies which arose before 01.07.2006 or
3
2009 in the cadre of Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the PW (B&R)
Department.
5. This finding of the High Court is under assailment
by the rival parties in the present batch of appeals.
6. Before we embark on a narration of the relevant
facts, it would be appropriate to note the trajectory of the
present batch of appeals.
6.1. Civil Appeal Nos. __________ of 2026
(Arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 12017-12018 of 2023)
6.1.1. The related special leave petitions have arisen out
of two writ petitions i.e. CWP. No. 18515 of 2012 and CWP No.
5465 of 2018.
6.1.2. Appellants are direct recruits in the cadre of
Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the PW (B&R) Department and
were the writ petitioners in the two related writ petitions before
the High Court. In CWP No. 18515 of 2012, the challenge was
to the absorption and seniority of the four deputationists. The
writ petitioners sought for a direction to repatriate the
deputationists to their parent department or in the alternative,
to assign them seniority positions below the writ petitioners
4
who are directly recruited. Thus, the direct recruits sought
seniority over the deputationists.
6.1.3. In the other writ petition i.e. CWP No. 5465 of
2018, the challenge was to the seniority assigned to Shri
Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia (deputationists) and their
consequential promotions. Further challenge was made to
their absorption in the PW (B&R) Department.
7. Civil Appeal Nos. __________ of 2026
(Arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 7597-7600 of 2023)
7.1 The related special leave petitions have arisen out
of four writ petitions i.e. CWP No. 12882 of 2020, CWP No.
11848 of 2020, CWP No. 18515 of 2012 and CWP No. 585 of
2021.
7.1.1 Appellant Shri Praveen Chaudhary is one of the
four officers of the Development and Panchayat Department,
Government of Haryana who was sent on deputation to the PW
(B&R) Department, Government of Haryana in the cadre of
Assistant Engineer (Civil) and subsequently absorbed in the
PW (B&R) Department.
5
7.1.2. In CWP No. 12882 of 2020, the writ petitioners,
who are the direct recruits, challenged the seniority assigned
to the deputationist Shri Praveen Chaudhary on absorption in
the PW (B&R) Department particularly his placement above
the direct recruits.
7.1.3. CWP No. 11848 of 2020 was filed by a direct
recruit assailing the seniority assigned to one of the
deputationists Shri Praveen Chaudhary in the cadre of
Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the PW (B&R) Department etc.
7.1.4. As already noticed above, the writ petitioners in CWP
No. 18515 of 2012 are direct recruits in the cadre of Assistant
Engineer (Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department. They challenged the
absorption of the four deputationists in the cadre of Sub-Divisional
Engineer/Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the PW (B&R) Department
and also sought for quashing the final seniority list in the cadre of
Sub-Divisional Engineer to the extent that the deputationists were
placed above the direct recruits in the seniority list.
7.1.5. CWP No. 858 of 2021 was filed by two direct
recruits challenging the seniority assigned to one of the
deputationists Shri Praveen Chaudhary over the direct recruits
in the PW (B&R) Department.
6
8. Civil Appeal Nos. __________ of 2026
(Arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 7506-7508 of 2023)
8.1. The related special leave petitions have arisen out
of three writ petitions i.e. CWP No. 18075 of 2011, CWP No.
18515 of 2012 and CWP No. 7706 of 2011.
8.1.1. Appellant in this appeal is Shri Pradeep Atri who
is one of the four officers of the Development and Panchayat
Department, Government of Haryana and sent on deputation
to the PW(B&R) Department in the cadre of Assistant Engineer
(Civil). He was subsequently absorbed in the PW(B&R)
Department.
8.1.2. In CWP No. 18075 of 2011, the writ petitioners are
the direct recruits in the cadre of Assistant Engineer (Civil) in
the PW(B&R) Department. They have challenged the seniority
assigned to the appellant Shri Pradeep Atri who was on
deputation to the said Department and thereafter absorbed
therein. On absorption, he was assigned seniority position
above the direct recruits selected in the year 2006 which came
to be challenged in CWP No. 18075 of 2011.
8.1.3. The writ petitioners in CWP No. 18515 of 2012 are
direct recruits in the cadre of Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the
7
PW(B&R) Department. They had challenged the absorption of
the four deputationists including the appellant in the cadre of
Sub-Divisional Engineer/Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the
PW(B&R) Department. They sought for quashing the seniority
list in the cadre of Sub-Divisional Engineer/Assistant
Engineer (Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department to the extent that
the deputationists on absorption were assigned seniority
position above the direct recruits.
8.1.4. CWP No. 7706 of 2011 was filed by the direct
recruits challenging the absorption of the deputationists as
Sub-Divisional Engineer in the PW(B&R) Department and
sought for their repatriation to their parent Department.
9. Civil Appeal No. __________ of 2026
(Arising out of SLP (C) No. 8142 of 2023)
9.1. The related special leave petition has arisen out of
writ petition CWP No. 18515 of 2012.
9.1.1. Appellant is Shri Jagbir Singh who was also the
writ petitioner in CWP No. 18515 of 2012. He is a direct recruit
in the cadre of Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the PW(B&R)
Department. In the writ petition, he alongwith another had
challenged the absorption of the four deputationists in the
8
cadre of Sub-Divisional Engineer/Assistant Engineer (Civil) in
the PW(B&R) Department and assigning them seniority
position above all the direct recruits.
10.
Civil Appeal No. __________ of 2026
(Arising out of SLP (C) No. 8004 of 2023)
10.1. The related special leave petition has arisen out of
writ petition CWP No. 7706 of 2011.
10.1.1. Shri Sukhbir Singh, Shri Abhishek, Shri Vikas
Kumar, Shri Sandeep Kumar Goel and Shri Bhupinder Singh
are the appellants. They were also the writ petitioners in CWP
No. 7706 of 2011. The appellants are direct recruits in the
cadre of Sub-Divisional Engineer/Assistant Engineer (Civil)
in the PW(B&R) Department. In the related writ petition,
appellants had challenged the absorption of the four
deputationists as Sub-Divisional Engineer/Assistant Engineer
(Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department.
11. Civil Appeal Nos. __________ of 2026
(Arising out of SLP (C) No. 20961-20967 of 2024)
11.1. The related special leave petitions have arisen out
of seven writ petitions. These writ petitions are: CWP No.
18515 of 2012, CWP No. 15685 of 2017, CWP No. 18075 of
9
2011, CWP No. 5465 of 2018, CWP No. 12882 of 2020, CWP
No. 858 of 2021 and CWP No. 11848 of 2020.
11.1.1. In these appeals, State of Haryana and its officers
in the PW(B&R) Department are the appellants.
11.1.2. We have already given the gist of CWP No. 18515
of 2012 in the preceding paragraphs. Similarly, we have also
given the gist of CWP No. 18075 of 2011, CWP No. 5465 of
2018, CWP No. 12882 of 2020, CWP No. 858 of 2021 and CWP
No. 11848 of 2020.
11.1.3. In so far CWP No. 15685 of 2017 is concerned,
this case was filed by Shri Kamaldeep Singh Rana, Shri
Ashwani Kumar, Shri Varun Gupta, Shri Sandeep Singh and
Shri Tilak Raj Gupta assailing the seniority position assigned
to Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia on their
absorption over the writ petitioners in the cadre of Sub-
Divisional Engineer/Assistant Engineer(Civil) in the PW(B&R)
Department.
12. Civil Appeal Nos. _________________ of 2026
(Arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 19938-41 of 2023)
12.1. There are four special leave petitions in this batch
of civil appeals. The related special leave petitions have arisen
10
out of four writ petitions, which are: CWP No. 18515 of 2012,
CWP No. 15083 of 2010, CWP No. 15685 of 2017 and CWP No.
5465 of 2018.
12.1.1. In these appeals, two of the four deputationists i.e.
Shri Pankaj Gaur and another are the appellants.
12.1.2. Brief outlines of CWP No. 18515 of 2012, CWP No.
15685 of 2017 and CWP No. 5465 of 2018 have already been
mentioned in the preceding paragraphs.
12.1.3. In so far CWP No. 15083 of 2010 is concerned, Shri
Praveen Chaudhary and others are the writ petitioners. They
have questioned the restrictions imposed on them qua their
seniority in their absorption orders. They have also challenged
the proviso to Rule 12(5) of the Punjab Service of Engineers,
Class II, P.W.D.(Buildings and Roads Branch) Rules, 1965, as
made applicable to the State of Haryana.
13. Civil Appeal No. _______________ of 2026
(Arising out of SLP (C) No. 18809 of 2023)
13.1 This civil appeal arises out of SLP(C) No. 18809 of
2023. The said special leave petition has arisen out of the
contempt proceedings being COCP No. 1519 of 2023 filed by
few of the direct recruits.
11
13.1.1. The contempt petition was filed alleging wilful
disobedience to the impugned judgment and order dated
15.03.2023 passed by the High Court in CWP No. 18515 of
2012 and other connected writ petitions. Appellants were the
petitioners in the related contempt petition.
13.1.2. By the order dated 17.07.2023, the High Court
dismissed the contempt petition by taking the view that all the
parties have filed special leave petitions before this Court and
till such time those were decided, it could not be said that the
State and the other respondents are in wilful disobedience of
the judgment and order dated 15.03.2023.
Facts
14. Following a regular recruitment process, Shri Pradeep
Atri was appointed on 06.12.2004, on a temporary basis, as Sub-
Divisional Officer (Panchayati Raj) in the Development and
Panchayat Department, Government of Haryana, alongwith others
on the recommendation of the Haryana Public Service Commission.
However, it was mentioned that he would be on probation for a
period of two years, extendable by a further period not extending
one year, if considered necessary.
12
14.1. Even before completion of one year’s probation, Shri
Atri wrote to the Engineer-in-Chief, PW(B&R) Department,
Government of Haryana on 14.07.2005 to take him on deputation
in the said Department. On 03.08.2005, the case of Shri
Pradeep Atri for deputation to the PW(B&R) Department was
recommended by the Engineer-in-Chief of the said Department
to the Financial Commissioner and Principal Secretary on the
ground of shortage of Sub-Divisional Engineers(Civil) in the
Department. It was proposed that Shri Atri’s deputation may be
against one of the posts earmarked for direct recruits and such
deputation should be till joining of the direct recruits. No
objection to such recommendation for the deputation of Shri
Pradeep Atri to the PW(B&R) Department was given by the parent
Department i.e. Development and Panchayat Department.
14.2. However, it appears that Shri Pradeep Atri’s
request for deputation was ‘filed’ by the State Government on
24.08.2005.
14.3. Even before completion of one month of such
‘filing’, Shri Pradeep Atri again on 12.09.2005 made a request
to the PW(B&R) Department that he should be taken on
deputation. He reiterated his request on 15.09.2005 saying
13
that he was very keen to serve in the PW(B&R) Department to
utilize his full potential. On the same day, i.e. on 15.09.2005,
case of Shri Pradeep Atri was recommended by the PW(B&R)
Department for deputation purely as a stop gap arrangement,
till the joining of direct recruits, considering about 50
vacancies of Sub-Divisional Engineers earmarked for direct
recruits.
14.4. By a file noting dated 19.10.2005, Shri Pradeep
Atri’s case for deputation was accepted as a stop gap
arrangement subject to the condition that he could be sent
back to his parent Department at any time.
14.5. Accordingly, on 16.11.2005, Shri Pradeep Atri was
relieved from the Development and Panchayat Department for
joining the PW (B&R) Department on deputation vide the order
dated 16.11.2005 issued by the Financial Commissioner and
Principal Secretary, Development and Panchayat Department.
It was stated therein that services of Shri Pradeep Atri was
placed at the disposal of the PW(B&R) Department for a period
of one year. However, it was mentioned that the terms and
conditions of deputation would be issued separately.
14
14.6. Immediately thereafter, on 17.11.2005, Shri
Pradeep Atri joined the PW(B&R) Department on deputation
for a period of one year.
14.7. On 24.02.2006, Shri Pradeep Atri requested the
PW(B&R) Department through the Engineer-in-Chief that he
should be absorbed in the said Department. This was just after
three months of him coming to the said Department on
deputation. Shri Atri stated that about 40 posts of Sub-
Divisional Engineer were lying vacant; he was keen to serve
the PW(B&R) Department so as to utilize his energy and
potential in an effective manner. According to him, it would not
only increase his experience and knowledge but would also
prove to be an asset to the PW(B&R) Department.
14.8. A requisition was sent to the Haryana Staff
Selection Commission on 03.03.2006 for filling up 44 vacancies
of Sub-Divisional Engineer in the PW(B&R) Department.
14.9. A file noting was made by the Superintending
Engineer of PW(B&R) Department on 24.03.2006 regarding the
request of Shri Pradeep Atri for absorption. It was noted that
requisition for direct recruitment to 44 posts was under way.
There was no vacancy to accommodate Shri Atri. However, it
15
was mentioned that if vacancy arose in future, the case of Shri
Pradeep Atri for absorption may be considered after obtaining
permission of the Haryana Staff Selection Commission.
14.10. The file regarding Shri Pradeep Atri’s absorption
progressed and the Joint Secretary, PW(B&R) Department
made a file noting on 17.04.2006 to the effect that Rule 10 of
the Punjab Service of Engineers, Class II, P.W.D. (Building and
Roads Branch) Rules, 1965 (briefly ‘the 1965 Rules’ hereinafter)
allows such appointment in special circumstances. It was
noted that while the process of direct recruitment was
initiated, the procedure would at the very least take six
months. In addition, there would be vacancies in the near
future. Therefore, Shri Pradeep Atri could be absorbed as the
PW(B&R) Department was facing acute shortage of staff.
14.11. In the meanwhile, PW(B&R) Department issued
advertisement dated 07.05.2006 for filling up 44 posts of Sub-
Divisional Engineer/Assistant Engineer(Civil) by way of direct
recruitment through the Haryana Staff Selection Commission.
14.12. On 12.06.2006, the Finance Commissioner
directed that opinion of the Legal Remembrancer should be
taken to avoid any litigation. The Legal Remembrancer in turn
16
opined on 12.06.2006 itself that appointment of Shri Pradeep
Atri by way of transfer is permissible, if special circumstances
existed; however, the Staff Selection Commission should
approve such appointment. This was followed by a file noting
dated 07.08.2006 wherein the Joint Secretary stated that Shri
Pradeep Atri was a competent officer and could be appointed
in the PW(B&R) Department.
14.13. The Finance Commissioner on 25.09.2006
conveyed to the Minister-in-Charge of PWD that there was no
legal impediment to the absorption of Shri Pradeep Atri. On
29.09.2006, the PWD Minister recommended the absorption of
Shri Pradeep Atri on the basis of the note forwarded by the
Finance Commissioner. However, on 04.10.2006, it was noted
that before issuing order of absorption of Shri Pradeep Atri,
prior approval of the Staff Selection Commission was required.
However, considering that the endorsement of the Minister had
already been made, it was noted that the absorption order
could be issued subject to the approval of the Staff Selection
Commission.
14.14. On 06.10.2006, Shri Pradeep Atri was absorbed in
the PW(B&R) Department against one of the vacancies of Sub-
17
Divisional Engineer (Civil) under the direct recruitment quota
(arisen on 01.07.2006) vide the order dated 06.10.2006 issued
by the Financial Commissioner and Principal Secretary,
PW(B&R) Department. However, his absorption was made
subject to the approval of the Haryana Public Service
Commission/Haryana Staff Selection Commission. The
absorption order made it clear that Shri Pradeep Atri would be
absorbed against one of the resultant vacancies of direct
recruit quota arisen on 01.07.2006 due to retirement of senior
officers.
14.15. It may be mentioned that the Haryana Public
Service Commission vide the communication dated 14.11.2006
informed the Financial Commissioner and Principal Secretary
to the Government of Haryana, PW(B&R) Department that
Haryana Public Service Commission had considered the case
of absorption of Shri Pradeep Atri in the PW(B&R) Department
as proposed by the Government and thereafter approved such
absorption of Shri Pradeep Atri.
15. Following a regular recruitment process, Haryana
Public Service Commission recommended Shri Pankaj Gaur,
Shri Arun Bhatia and Shri Praveen Chaudhary for
18
appointment as Sub-Divisional Officer (Panchayati Raj) in the
Development and Panchayat Department, Government of
Haryana. Thereafter, Financial Commissioner and Principal
Secretary to the Government of Haryana, Development and
Panchayat Department issued letter dated 18.10.2005
appointing Shri Pankaj Gaur, Shri Arun Bhatia and Shri
Praveen Chaudhary amongst others as Sub-Divisional Officer
(Panchayati Raj). It was mentioned therein that they would be
on probation for a period of two years, extendable for a further
period not exceeding one year, if considered necessary.
15.1. Within one month of appointment as Sub-
Divisional Officer (Panchayati Raj) in the Development and
Panchayat Department, the Revenue Minister wrote to the
Financial Commissioner and Principal Secretary to the
Government of Haryana, Development and Panchayat
Department on 23.11.2005 that Shri Praveen Chaudhary may
be sent to the PW (B&R) Department on deputation basis.
Similar letter dated 23.11.2005 was also written by the
Transport Minister to the effect that Shri Praveen Chaudhary
should be sent on deputation to the PW(B&R) Department.
19
15.2. The Engineer-in-Chief, PW(B&R) Department in
his note dated 29.12.2005 stated that there is acute shortage
of Sub-Divisional Engineers in the PW(B&R) Department.
Referring to the case of Shri Pradeep Atri, he recommended
that services of Shri Praveen Chaudhary may be taken in the
PW(B&R) Department on deputation basis.
15.3. The Revenue Minister on 23.02.2006 reiterated his
recommendation for deputation of Shri Praveen Chaudhary to
the PW(B&R) Department against a vacant post.
15.4. An order was passed on 25.04.2006 by the Financial
Commissioner and Principal Secretary to the Government of
Haryana, Development and Panchayat Department placing the
services of Shri Praveen Chaudhary at the disposal of the
PW(B&R) Department on deputation for a period of one year
for which reason he was relieved from the Development and
Panchayat Department with immediate effect. It was
mentioned therein that the terms and conditions of deputation
would be issued separately. It is stated that pursuant to such
order, Shri Praveen Chaudhary joined in the PW(B&R)
Department on deputation on 02.05.2006.
20
15.5. Immediately, after the joining of Shri Praveen
Chaudhary in the PW(B&R) Department on deputation, the
Transport Minister addressed a communication dated
03.05.2006 to the Chief Minister requesting that Shri Praveen
Chaudhary should be permanently absorbed in the PW(B&R)
Department against a vacant post of direct recruitment quota.
It may be mentioned that the aforesaid communication of the
Transport Minister regarding absorption came just one day
after Shri Praveen Chaudhary joined the PW(B&R) Department
on deputation.
15.6. The Office of the Chief Minister issued a direction
on 04.05.2006 stating that the Hon’ble Chief Minister had seen
the note of the Transport Minister and that he desired that the
request for absorption of Shri Praveen Chaudhary should be
examined.
15.7. On 24.07.2006, the Financial Commissioner and
Principal Secretary to the Government of Haryana, PW(B&R)
Department informed the Engineer-in-Chief of the said
Department that the Government had approved the deputation
of Shri Praveen Chaudhary to the PW(B&R) Department on the
following three conditions:
21
(i) he will have no right or claim for his absorption in the
PW(B&R) Department;
(ii) he will submit an undertaking to the effect that he
will not claim any benefit of absorption in the
PW(B&R) Department or file any suit/writ in any
court in this regard; and,
(iii) he can be sent back at any time to his parent
Department on receipt of recommendation from the Staff
Selection Commission to fill up the direct quota posts of
Assistant Engineer (Civil)/Sub-Divisional Engineer.
15.8. On 25.09.2006, the Financial Commissioner while
conveying to the PWD Minister that there was no legal problem
in the absorption of Shri Pradeep Atri, also mentioned that
Shri Praveen Chaudhary who has been sent on deputation to
the PW(B&R) Department may also make a request for
permanent absorption in the PW(B&R) Department.
15.9. It appears that thereafter Shri Praveen Chaudhary
made a request to the Financial Commissioner and Principal
Secretary, Government of Haryana, Development and Panchayat
Department on 11.10.2006 seeking a no objection certificate for
22
his absorption in the PW(B&R) Department. On 18.10.2006, the
said Financial Commissioner and Principal Secretary sent a letter
to the departmental Minister stating that the Department should
have no objection to the absorption of Shri Praveen
Chaudhary.
15.10. A recruitment process was undertaken by the
Haryana Staff Selection Commission for recruitment to the
post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department.
Shri Pradeep Atri, Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia had
applied for the said post pursuant to the advertisement dated
07.05.2006. On 13.11.2006, the list of selected candidates was
published wherein the names of Shri Pradeep Atri, Shri Pankaj
Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia did not appear. In other words,
they did not qualify. It may be mentioned that Shri Praveen
Chaudhary did not even participate in this recruitment
process. On the next day i.e. on 14.11.2006, recommendation
was made by the Haryana Staff Selection Commission for
appointment of the selected candidates.
15.11. Member of Legislative Assembly (MLA) representing
the Bahadurgarh Constituency wrote to the Chief Minister on
19.03.2007 seeking absorption of Shri Praveen Chaudhary in
23
the PW(B&R) Department against a direct recruit quota
vacancy citing the example of Shri Pradeep Atri.
15.12. On 20.04.2007, PW(B&R) Department sent a
requisition to various departments of the Government of
Haryana for deputation of 10 suitable and willing Sub-
Divisional Engineers to the PW (B&R) Department.
15.13. It may be mentioned that on 09.05.2007, Shri
Praveen Chaudhary submitted a representation before the
Engineer-in-Chief, PW(B&R) Department seeking extension of
his deputation period for a further period of one year.
15.14. In the month of May, 2007 itself, Shri Praveen
Chaudhary made a request before the Engineer-in-Chief,
PW(B&R) Department conveying his consent for permanent
absorption in the PW(B&R) Department in view of the fact that
number of posts of Sub-Divisional Engineer/Assistant
Engineer (Civil) were lying vacant in the said Department. He
requested that his case for permanent absorption be
considered on similar lines as that of Shri Pradeep Atri.
15.15. On 11.07.2007, the Chief Minister approved
absorption of Shri Praveen Chaudhary in the PW(B&R)
24
Department citing the example of Shri Pradep Atri. However, it
was mentioned that such observation would be subject to the
approval of Haryana Public Service Commission/Haryana
Staff Selection Commission. It was also mentioned that
seniority of Mr. Praveen Chaudhary would be at the junior
most level not only amongst the Sub-Divisional Engineers who
were then posted in the Department but also lower than the
persons who might get posted against vacancies which had
arisen before 01.07.2006 as Shri Praveen Chaudhary was
being absorbed against one of the vacancies which had arisen
after 01.07.2006.
15.16. Commissioner and Secretary to the Government of
Haryana, PW(B&R) Department issued an order on 18.07.2007
stating that Governor of Haryana was pleased to absorb Shri
Praveen Chaudhary, Sub-Divisional Officer, Development and
Panchayat Department, then on deputation to the PW(B&R)
Department, in the latter Department as Sub-Divisional
Engineer (Civil) subject to the following conditions:
(i) it should be approved by the Haryana Public Service
Commission;
25
(ii) it would be subject to the decision/undertaking
given by the Department in various writ petitions
pending before the High Court relating to
appointment of Sub-Divisional Engineers in the
PW(B&R) Department;
(iii) confirmation of possession of degree of civil
engineering by a duly recognised University;
(iv) seniority of Shri Praveen Chaudhary would be at the
junior most level not only amongst the Sub-
Divisional Engineers who were then posted in the
PW(B&R) Department but also below persons to be
appointed against vacancies arisen before
01.07.2006 as Shri Chaudhary was being absorbed
against one of the vacancies which had arisen due
to retirement of Sub-Divisional Engineers after
01.07.2006; and,
(v) he would be posted against one of the vacancies of
direct recruits.
15.17. It may be mentioned that immediately after the
absorption of Shri Praveen Chaudhary, 28 officers were
26
promoted to the post of Sub-Divisional Engineer in the
PW(B&R) Department.
15.18. Haryana Public Service Commission on 06.08.2007
approved the absorption of Shri Praveen Chaudhary ostensively
in accordance with Rule 10 of the 1965 Rules. Consequent upon
the absorption of Shri Praveen Chaudhary in the PW(B&R)
Department, the lien of Shri Praveen Chaudhary with the
Development and Panchayat Department was suspended vide
order dated 24.08.2007 issued by the Financial Commissioner
and Principal Secretary to the Government of Haryana,
Development and Panchayat Department.
16. It may be mentioned that a number of writ
petitions, the lead writ petition being CWP No. 1606 of 2000
( Jai Prakash Vs. State), were filed by the selected candidates of
the PW(B&R) Department in the cadre of Sub-Divisional
Engineer following the recruitment processes undertaken by
the said Department questioning non-issuance of appointment
letters to them for various reasons. During pendency of the
said proceedings, an interlocutory application being CM No.
14464 of 2006 was filed seeking stay of fresh appointments on
the basis of recommendation of the Haryana Public Service
27
Commission following the 2006 recruitment process. The High
Court recorded an undertaking given by the State counsel that
appointment letters pursuant to the 2006 recruitment process
i.e. select list of 14.11.2006 would not be issued vide the order
dated 29.11.2006. On 03.12.2007, CWP No. 1606 of 2000 ( Jai
Prakash Vs. State) and the other connected writ petitions were
dismissed by the High Court leading to vacation of the
assurance of the State counsel recorded in the order dated
29.11.2006. Though Letters Patent Appeals were filed against
the dismissal of the writ petitions, being LPA No. 96 of 2008
and batch, those were, however, dismissed by the Division
Bench of the High Court on 14.07.2008.
16.1. Thereafter, 29 of the selected candidates of the
select list dated 14.11.2006 were issued appointment letters on
05.12.2007. They were appointed as Sub-Divisional Engineers
(2007 Batch) in the PW(B&R) Department.
17. Following the memo dated 18.10.2007 of the
Financial Commissioner and Principal Secretary to the
Government of Haryana, Development and Panchayat
Department, the Commissioner and Secretary to the
Government of Haryana, PW(B&R) Department issued order
28
dated 23.11.2007 stating therein that the Governor of Haryana
was pleased to take the 10 Sub-Divisional Officers (Civil),
Development and Panchayat Department, Haryana on
deputation to the PW(B&R) Department with immediate effect.
The 10 officers on deputation included Shri Pankaj Gaur at Sr.
No. 8 and Shri Arun Bhatia at Sr. No. 9. A request was made
to the Development and Panchayat Department to see to it that
the Sub-Divisional Officers (Civil) taken on deputation in the
PW(B&R) Department be relieved immediately from the
Development and Panchayat Department to enable them to
join the PW(B&R) Department.
17.1. Pursuant to the order of deputation dated 23.11.
2007, Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia joined the
PW(B&R) Department on deputation on 05.01.2008.
17.2. Just a month after joining the PW(B&R)
Department on deputation, Shri Pankaj Gaur submitted a
representation dated 16.02.2008 before the Commissioner and
Secretary, Government of Haryana, PW(B&R) Department
requesting that he be absorbed in the PW(B&R) Department
citing the examples of Shri Pradeep Atri and Shri Praveen
Chaudhary. It may be mentioned that the said representation of
29
Shri Pankaj Gaur was recommended by Shri Naresh Kumar, MLA
of Badli Constituency.
17.3. Similarly, Shri Arun Bhatia also submitted a
representation before the Financial Commissioner and Principal
Secretary, PW(B&R) Department, Haryana on 07.03.2008
requesting for his permanent absorption in the said Department.
17.4. Office of the Commissioner and Special Secretary,
PW(B&R) Department sought for comments of the Engineer-
in-Chief on the representation of Shri Pankaj Gaur on
10.03.2008. At this stage, the MLA of Narnaul Constituency
also made a request to the departmental Minister for
permanent absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur in the PW(B&R)
Department vide his endorsement dated 17.03.2008.
17.5. The Engineer-in-Chief reverted back to the
Commissioner and Secretary to the Government of Haryana,
PW(B&R) Department vide the letter dated 27.03.2008
referring to the note of the PWD Minister dated 17.03.2008
which is as under:
‘Please examine and put up proposal on file. How many
posts of SDOs are lying vacant in PW(B&R) Department.’
30
17.5.1. It was mentioned that the matter was examined in
detail following which it has been observed that entertaining
such kind of requests would increase litigation. Therefore, it
was opined that the request of Shri Pankaj Gaur should be
rejected. Further, a requisition had already been sent to the
Government for onward transmission to the Haryana Staff
Selection Commission to fill up 30 posts of Assistant Engineer
(Civil) pertaining to the direct recruitment quota. The case for
assigning current duty charge to the seniormost Junior
Engineer was under consideration of the Government.
17.6. In the meanwhile, the departmental Minister put
up a note on 05.06.2008 to the effect that Shri Arun Bhatia
who was on deputation to the PW(B&R) Department since
January, 2008 was performing his duties satisfactorily.
Therefore, the proposal for his absorption in the PW(B&R)
Department may be put up.
17.7. The Engineer-in-Chief, PW(B&R) Department in
his letter dated 29.07.2008 informed the Financial
Commissioner and Special Secretary to the Government of
Haryana, PW(B&R) Department that the matter regarding
permanent absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur, Shri Arun Bhatia
31
and another was considered in detail but it has been observed
that acceptance of such kind of request will increase litigation
at a later stage and will result in demoralisation of the
recruited staff. Therefore, the Engineer-in-Chief categorically
stated that the request of Shri Pankaj Gaur, Shri Arun Bhatia
and another for permanent absorption in the PW(B&R)
Department could not be recommended. Request was made to
bring this position to the notice of the departmental Minister.
17.8. The above view has been reiterated in subsequent
file notings also. Notwithstanding the clear view of the
Engineer-in-chief, the Financial Commissioner and Principal
Secretary to the Government of Haryana, PW(B&R) Department
in the file noting dated 21.08.2008 noted that both Shri Pankaj
Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia are M.Techs; there is no issue in
taking them in the PW(B&R) Department; otherwise, they
would be juniormost in so far inter se seniority was concerned
in the Development and Panchayat Department. It was
mentioned that the Engineer-in-Chief had also agreed with the
above in the ‘discussion’ on 21.08.2008 morning.
17.9. The PWD Minister agreed with the note of the
Financial Commissioner and Principal Secretary and approved
32
the same on 20.09.2008 in view of the reasons given. As noted
above, the two reasons given by the Financial Commissioner
and Principal Secretary for absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur and
Shri Arun Bhatia were that they were both M.Tech degree
holder and if they were repatriated back to the Development
and Panchayat Department, they would be the juniormost.
17.10. The MLA of Mahendargarh constituency who was
the Parliamentary Secretary to the Government of Haryana,
Incharge of Transport Department, also wrote to the Financial
Commissioner and Principal Secretary to the Government of
Haryana, PW(B&R) Department on 17.02.2009 requesting
absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur in the PW(B&R) Department.
17.11. PW(B&R) Department sought the approval of the
Haryana Public Service Commission on 23.06.2009 to the
absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia. In
response thereto, Haryana Public Service Commission wrote
back to the Financial Commissioner and Principal Secretary
to the Government of Haryana, PW(B&R) Department on
07.07.2009 stating that appointment by transfer in the
PW(B&R) Department was governed by Rule 10 of the 1965
Rules as per which the Government may, in ‘special
33
circumstances’, with the approval of the Public Service
Commission, appoint an officer to the service by transfer. It
was pointed out that as per Rule 10, appointment by transfer
in the PW(B&R) Department can be made in ‘special
circumstances’ only. A perusal of the papers received
alongwith the letter dated 23.06.2009 did not reveal the
existence of any ‘special circumstances’ that would justify the
absorption of the two officers. Therefore, it was requested that
the Public Service Commission should be intimated about the
‘special circumstances’ under which the absorption was proposed
to be made.
17.12. In response thereto, the Financial Commissioner
and Principal Secretary, PW(B&R) Department wrote to the
Secretary, Haryana Public Service Commission on 30.07.2009
informing that the absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri
Arun Bhatia were for the following special circumstances:
(i) both are M.Tech in the field relevant to roads and
building engineering;
(ii) they have been recruited through a proper process
by the Haryana Staff Selection Commission; and
34
(iii) they had spent time in the Department and they
have been found good in their work.
17.12.1. It was further stated that it was very difficult to
find M.Tech qualified persons as Sub-Divisional Engineers.
Therefore, it was requested to allow the two officers to be
absorbed in the PW(B&R) Department.
17.13. In the meantime, a list of 29 candidates
recommended by the Haryana Staff Selection Commission was
received whereafter the Government issued letter dated
19.08.2009 offering appointment to 25 such candidates for the
post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department
(the 2009 direct recruit batch).
17.14. Following the same, the office of Engineer-in-Chief
wrote to the Financial Commissioner and Principal Secretary
to the Government of Haryana, PW (B&R) Department on
20.08.2009 stating that the Government in the PW(B&R)
Department had taken the services of 14 Sub-Divisional
Engineers (Civil) from the Development and Panchayat
Department on deputation basis with the condition that they
would be reverted back to their parent Department if they were
no longer required or candidates are recommended against
35
their posts. It was mentioned that out of the 14 officers on
deputation, only 9, whose names were mentioned in the said
letter, were in position. Since Government had issued
appointment letters to 25 candidates under the direct recruit
quota, Government was requested to repatriate the 9 Sub-
Divisional Engineers (Civil) to their parent Department i.e.
Development and Panchayat Department, Haryana at an early
date so as to facilitate the journey of the direct recruits. These
9 included Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Batia.
17.15. At this stage, it may be mentioned that the
recruitment of officers vide the Government letter dated
19.08.2009 (2009 recruits) was challenged before the High
Court in CWP No. 19993 of 2009 ( Kashmir Chand Kamboj Vs.
State of Haryana) on various grounds.
17.16. Notwithstanding the request letter of the Engineer-
in-Chief dated 20.08.2009, Haryana Public Service
Commission vide the letter dated 17.09.2009 informed the
Financial Commissioner and Principal Secretary, PW(B&R)
Department that it had considered the matter and had
approved the absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun
Bhatia, Sub-Divisional Officers, Development and Panchayat
36
Department in the PW(B&R) Department as proposed by the
Government. Following the same, Government of Haryana in
the PW(B&R) Department issued order dated 23.10.2009
absorbing Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia, Sub-
Divisional Engineers of the Development and Panchayat
Department on deputation to the PW(B&R) Department as
Sub-Divisional Engineers (Civil) subject to the following
conditions:
(i) their seniority shall be at the junior most level not
only amongst the Sub-Divisional Engineers who
were then posted in the PW(B&R) Department but
also lower than the candidates who would get
posted against the vacancies which had already
arisen;
(ii) they shall be posted against the vacancies of the
direct recruits;
(iii) their absorption would be subject to the
decision/undertaking given by the Department in various
writ proceedings pending in different courts including the
High Court relating to appointment of Sub-Divisional
Engineers in the PW(B&R) Department; and,
37
(iv) it would be subject to the confirmation of possession
of the degree of civil engineering by a duly
recognised university.
17.17. On 21.12.2009, Shri Praveen Chaudhary
submitted a representation before the Financial Commissioner
and Principal Secretary to the Government of Haryana,
PW(B&R) Department regarding fixation of his inter se
seniority. He requested that condition No. 4 of his absorption
order which said that he would be junior to all the direct
recruits who had joined the Department in December, 2007
should be deleted and he should be made senior to all the
candidates who had joined the Department after 18.07.2007
(i.e. the date of his absorption) by way of direct recruitment or
by way of promotion. In this connection, he referred to Rules
10, 11 and 12 of the 1965 Rules.
17.18. In the month of January, 2010, a tentative seniority list of
Assistant Engineers (Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department was prepared
in which Shri Pradeep Atri was placed at Sr. No. 17 above the
direct recruits who were appointed on 05.12.2007 (pursuant
to the 2006 recruitment). These direct recruits were placed at
Sr. Nos. 27 to 56 in the said seniority list and Shri Praveen
38
Chaudhary at Sr. No. 57. This was objected to by many of the
direct recruits appointed on 05.12.2007. In this regard, Seema
Dhankhar and others who were direct recruits appointed on
05.12.2007 submitted a representation to the Government on
27.01.2010 for correction of the seniority list opposing the
placement of Shri Pradeep Atri above the direct recruits.
17.19. The representation submitted by Shri Praveen
Chaudhary on 21.12.2009 regarding fixation of his inter se
seniority was rejected by the State Government keeping in view
the conditions of absorption dated 18.07.2007. This was
informed to the petitioner by the office of the Financial
Commissioner and Principal Secretary vide letter dated
22.03.2010.
17.20. Alleging non-consideration of their representation,
Seema Dhankhar and others approached the High Court by
filing CWP No. 8481 of 2010 which was however disposed of
by the High Court vide the order dated 11.05.2010 directing
the Government to consider the objections to the tentative
seniority list.
17.21. A tentative seniority list of Assistant Engineer
(Civil) as on 01.06.2010 was circulated by the Government on
39
02.07.2010. In the said seniority list, Shri Pradeep Atri was
placed at Sr. No. 39 below the direct recruits appointed on
05.12.2007 who were placed at Sr. Nos. 10 to 38. While Shri
Praveen Chaudhary was placed at Sr. No. 48, Shri Pankaj Gaur
and Shri Arun Bhatia were placed at Sr. Nos. 122 and 123
respectively.
17.22. In the meanwhile, the Special Secretary, PW(B&R)
Department made a detailed recommendation on 17.08.2010
on the subject of illegal appointment of Sub-Divisional
Engineers in the PW(B&R) Department. It was specifically
regarding the appointment of Shri Pradeep Atri brought on
deputation from the Development and Panchayat Department
to the PW(B&R) Department. Amongst other points, the Special
Secretary mentioned that in the entire process of absorption of
Shri Pradeep Atri, the Department did not mention any ‘special
circumstance’ on the basis of which Shri Pradeep Atri was
absorbed. It was pointed out that the mere fact that there was
an acute shortage of officers in the Department was no ground
to absorb Shri Pradeep Atri, more so, because by the time he
was absorbed, the select list was announced. He also pointed
out that the matter of absorption of Shri Pradeep Atri would
40
attain scandalous proportion because the Government could
be accused of making a backdoor entry for Shri Pradeep Atri
who otherwise failed to clear his PW(B&R) Department SDO
recruitment examination. He, therefore, proposed that Shri
Pradeep Atri be repatriated to the Development and Panchayat
Department on the following grounds:
(i) as per the 1965 Rules, direct recruitment would
mean an appointment by open competition but it
does not include an appointment made by
promotion and an appointment by transfer of an
officer already in service of a State Government or
of the Government of India;
(ii) he had not completed the probationary period in the
Development and Panchayat Department nor in the
PW(B&R) Department;
(iii) the vacancy against which he had to be absorbed
vide condition No. 4 of his absorption order had not
been finalised; and,
(iv) the conditions of deputation were contrary to Rule
2 of the 1965 Rules and as such he had not been
41
technically absorbed in the PW(B&R) Department.
Government had not issued any order mentioning
as against which vacancy Shri Pradeep Atri would
be absorbed.
17.23. In a note dated 11.09.2010, the Financial Commissioner
and Principal Secretary described the deputation of Shri Pradeep
Atri to the PW(B&R) Department as a backdoor entry. It was
pointed out that those who were directly recruited through the
same examination in which Shri Pradeep Atri had failed could
not be treated as junior to Shri Pradeep Atri. Therefore, the
seniority of Shri Pradeep Atri would have to be considered
below those who were directly recruited or promoted in the
year 2006.
18. Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Shri Pankaj Gaur and
Shri Arun Bhatia filed CWP No. 15083 of 2010 assailing,
amongst others, the seniority list dated 02.07.2010 by seeking
seniority over the direct recruits. Likewise, Shri Pradeep Atri
filed CWP No. 17474 of 2010 questioning the revised seniority
list.
18.1. In its counter affidavit filed by the State of Haryana
in the PW(B&R) Department to CWP No. 17474 of 2010, the
42
stand taken was that placement of Shri Pradeep Atri below that
of the 2006 direct recruits was in line with Rule 12(5) of the
1965 Rules. Similarly, State of Haryana in the PW(B&R)
Department in its counter affidavit filed to CWP No. 15083 of
2010 took the stand that Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Shri Pankaj
Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia having consented to the conditions
of absorption were estopped from questioning assignment of
their seniority position below the 2006 direct recruits. There
was no need for the writ petitioners to have been deputed to
the PW(B&R) Department or absorbed therein; these officers
had landed up in the PW(B&R) Department on their own
request. Therefore, they could not later on resile from the
conditions of their absorption.
18.2. The Special Secretary-cum-Chief Vigilance Officer
made a detailed note observing that there was no exceptional
circumstances for absorption of the deputationists i.e. Shri
Pradeep Atri, Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Shri Pankaj Gaur and
Shri Arun Bhatia. It was clearly discernible that it was simply
a case of pick and choose method adopted for such absorption.
If the Department was in dire need of Sub-Divisional Engineers,
it should have circulated the posts to be filled up by transfer
43
from the other departments and should have chosen from
amongst the applicants which is the laid down procedure.
Pointing out various lacuna in the deputation and absorption of
the above four officers, the Special Secretary-cum-Chief Vigilance
Officer advised that the Department should repatriate the four
officers to their parent Department.
18.3. In fact, there were similar file notings also where the
Chief Secretary, the Financial Commissioner and the PWD
Minister observed that the absorption of the deputed officers was
in conflict with the service rules.
19. It appears that pursuant to the query of the PW(B&R)
Department, the Development and Panchayat Department
informed the former vide letter dated 27.05.2011 that upon
absorption of the four officers in the PW(B&R) Department, the
lien of those officers was not retained in the parent Department.
20. CWP No. 7706 of 2011 (Abhishek Vs. State) was
filed by the direct recruits challenging the absorption of Shri
Pradeep Atri, Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Shri Pankaj Gaur and
Shri Arun Bhatia. To this, the State Government filed its
counter affidavit justifying their absorption on the ground
44
that there was shortage of Sub-Divisional Engineers in the
PW(B&R) Department which necessitated their absorption.
21. In between, on a note put up by the PWD Minister
dated 12.08.2011, the Honourable Chief Minister ordered on
24.08.2011 that the seniority of the Sub-Divisional Engineers
Class II be fixed strictly keeping in view the express provisions
of the statutory rules particularly Rule 12.
22. The final seniority list of Assistant Engineer (Civil)
in the PW(B&R) Department as on 24.08.2011 was issued on
02.09.2011. In this seniority list, Shri Pradeep Atri was placed
at Sr. No. 6, Shri Praveen Chaudhary at Sr. No. 44, Shri Pankaj
Gaur at Sr. No. 111 and Shri Arun Bhatia at Sr. No. 112. The
direct recruits who were appointed on 05.12.2007 were made
junior to Shri Pradeep Atri but senior to Shri Praveen Chaudhary,
Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia.
23. CWP No. 18075 of 2011 ( Sukhbir Singh Vs. State )
was filed before the High Court challenging the seniority
assigned to Shri Pradeep Atri. Likewise, CWP No. 18515 of
2012 ( Jagbir Singh Vs. State ) was filed by the 2006 direct
recruits assailing the absorption of and seniority assigned to
the deputed officers upon absorption.
45
24. It may be mentioned that Shri Pradeep Atri along
with the direct recruits of the 2006 selection were promoted as
Executive Engineer but the seniority of Shri Pradeep Atri vis a
vis the direct recruits was maintained i.e. Shri Atri was placed
above the direct recruits.
25. On 27.07.2015, the High Court disposed of CWP No.
19993 of 2009 ( Kashmir Chand Kamboj Vs. State of Haryana)
upholding the challenge to the recruitment of the 2009 direct
recruits on various grounds. However, in view of the fact that the
said recruits had already served for more than 5 years and that
posts of Assistant Engineer (Civil) were lying vacant, their
selection was not set aside.
26. Shri Praveen Chaudhury was also promoted as
Executive Engineer on 29.12.2016.
27. After several rounds of file notings, Shri Pankaj
Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia were given seniority in the cadre
of Assistant Engineer in the PW(B&R) Department with effect
from 05.01.2008. In the order dated 01.05.2017 passed by the
Additional Chief Secretary to the Government of Haryana,
PW(B&R) Department, it was mentioned that the Government
had decided to grant the benefit of seniority with all
46
consequential benefits to Shri Pankaj Gaur and to Shri Arun
Bhatia from the date of their joining the PW(B&R) Department
on deputation basis i.e. from 05.01.2008 as per Rule 12(5) of the
1965 Rules considering their continuous and uninterrupted
service.
28. CWP No. 15685 of 2017 ( Kamaldeep Singh Vs. State )
was filed before the High Court assailing the aforesaid order
dated 01.05.2017. Similarly, CWP No. 5465 of 2018 ( Nishant
Singh Vs. State ) was filed by the 2009 direct recruits assailing
the legality and validity of the order dated 01.05.2017.
29. In the meanwhile, Government of Haryana in the
PW(B&R) Department directed the Engineer-in-Chief to
prepare and circulate a revised tentative seniority list of
Assistant Engineer (Civil). Following the same, a tentative
revised seniority list was prepared on 29.09.2017 in which
Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia were placed at Sr. Nos.
2 and 3 respectively above the 2009 direct recruits.
29.1. Lot of correspondence took place following the
issuance of the aforesaid tentative seniority list. Objections were
raised by the 2009 direct recruits who were given a hearing.
However, the final seniority list of Assistant Engineer
47
(Civil)/Sub-Divisional Engineer (Civil) as on 01.07.2017 was
issued on 04.04.2018 where Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun
Bhatia were shown as senior to the 2009 direct recruits.
30. In the midst of such uncertainty, Shri Pradeep Atri
was promoted from the post of Executive Engineer (Civil),
PW(B&R) Department to the post of Superintending Engineer
in the said Department with effect from 01.10.2019 vide the
order dated 20.09.2019 issued by the Additional Chief Secretary
to the Government of Haryana, PW(B&R) Department.
31. Shri Praveen Chaudhary again submitted represe-
ntation dated 25.09.2019 before the Government seeking
seniority with effect from 02.05.2006 i.e. from the date of his
deputation to the PW(B&R) Department. This time, his
prayer was accepted by the Department on 01.10.2019
whereafter a tentative seniority list of Executive Engineers
(Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department as on 01.10.2019 was
issued on 03.10.2019 where Shri Praveen Chaudhary was
placed at seniority position No. 4 above the direct recruits.
Objections were called for from all the Executive Engineers
(Civil), whereafter the objections were heard. Thereafter, the
Additional Chief Secretary to the Government of Haryana,
48
PW(B&R) Department issued order dated 17.07.2020 granting
seniority to Shri Praveen Chaudhary with effect from
02.05.2006 i.e. from the date of his deputation instead of
18.07.2007 i.e. the date of absorption, in terms of Rule 12(5)
of the 1965 Rules. It was mentioned therein that Shri Praveen
Chaudhary would be placed below Shri Pradeep Atri. Following
the same, the tentative seniority list of Executive Engineers
(Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department as on 01.10.2019 was
prepared and circulated on 28.07.2020 in which Shri Praveen
Chaudhary was placed at Sr. No. 4 above the direct recruits
appointed on 05.12.2007.
32. CWP No. 11848 of 2020 ( Abhishek Vs. State ) was
filed by the direct recruits of the 2006 batch challenging the
tentative seniority list dated 28.07.2020. This tentative
seniority list was also challenged in CWP No. 2882 of 2020
( Hemant Kumar Vs. State). Similarly, CWP No. 858 of 2021
( Sukhbir Singh Vs. State ) was filed by the direct recruits of the
2006 batch challenging the aforesaid tentative seniority list.
33. Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia were
promoted to the post of Executive Engineer (Civil) vide the order
49
dated 23.08.2022 passed by the Additional Chief Secretary to
the Government of Haryana, PW(B&R) Department.
34. The following writ petitions were heard together by
the High Court:
(i) CWP No. 15083 of 2010 ( Praveen Chaudhary Vs.
State of Haryana);
(ii) CWP No. 7706 of 2011 ( Abhishek Vs. State of
Haryana);
(iii) CWP No. 18075 of 2011 ( Sukhbir Singh Vs. State of
Haryana);
(iv) CWP No. 18515 of 2012 ( Jagbir Singh Vs. State of
Haryana);
(v) CWP No. 15685 of 2017 ( Kamaldeep Singh Rana Vs.
State of Haryana);
(vi) CWP No. 5465 of 2018 ( Nishant Vs. State of
Haryana);
(vii) CWP No. 11848 of 2020 ( Abhishek Vs. State of
Haryana);
50
(viii) CWP No. 12882 of 2020 ( Hemant Kumar Vs. State of
Haryana);
(ix) CWP No. 858 of 2021 ( Sukhbir Singh Vs. State of
Haryana);
34.1. Vide the judgment and order dated 15.03.2023,
the High Court disposed of all the writ petitions in the following
manner:
(i) there was no justification for the deputation of these
four officers to the PW(B&R) Department;
(ii) there were no special circumstances for invoking
Rule 10 of the 1965 Rules and absorption of Shri
Pradeep Atri, Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Shri Pankaj
Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia was contrary to the
1965 Rules and was not bona fide. It amounted to
backdoor entry with persistent interference of
politicians clearly discernible.
(iii) therefore, the orders of deputation of these four
officers and their subsequent absorption in the
PW(B&R) Department are not valid in law and are
the product of political machinations;
51
(iv) though the High Court held the deputation to and
absorption of the above four officers in the PW(B&R)
Department in the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil)
as bad in law yet the High Court, considering the
fact that these officers had no longer lien in their
parent Department i.e. the Development and
Panchayat Department and that they had been
rendering service in the PW(B&R) Department for a
long time, took a sympathetic view not to disturb
their deputation and absorption as Assistant Engineer
(Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department. However, the High
Court clarified that the four officers would not be
allowed to have seniority over the direct recruits
appointed on 07.12.2009 or in the year 2009/persons
promoted against vacancies which arose before
01.07.2006 or in 2009 in the cadre of Assistant
Engineer (Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department;
(v) consequently, Shri Pradeep Atri and Shri Praveen
Chaudhary cannot be given seniority over any direct
recruit or promotee who were appointed against
vacancies which arose prior to 01.07.2006; and
52
(vi) the State was also not justified in giving seniority to
Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia over the
direct recruits or promotees who were appointed
against the vacancies which arose before 23.10.2009
i.e. the date of their absorption in the PW(B&R)
Department.
Submissions
35. Mr. Ranjeet Kumar, learned senior counsel
appearing for the appellants in the civil appeals arising out of
SLP (C) Nos. 12017-12018 of 2023 has assailed the impugned
judgment and order of the High Court to a limited extent. He
submits that the High Court having accepted the contention of
the appellants that the deputation and absorption of the four
officers were bad in law and were made for extraneous reasons
under political influence, ought to have terminated their
services; instead, the High Court has sustained their
absorption in the PW(B&R) Department. He submits that
exercising power under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
the High Court could not have sustained the illegal absorption
of the four officers; rather, the High Court should have
terminated their absorption in the PW(B&R) Department.
53
35.1. Mr. Kumar has taken the Court to various
correspondences which are on record to show that the
deputation of the four officers from the Development and
Panchayat Department to the PW(B&R) Department itself was
faulty. The basic principles underlying deputation were not
complied with. The deputations were made purely on the
request of the four officers. Proceeding further he submits that
while the deputation of the four officers itself was illegal, such
illegality was further magnified by the wholly unsustainable
action of the authority in the PW(B&R) Department in
absorbing them in the said Department. This is nothing but a
backdoor entry. High Court had rightly described such
appointment of the four officers by way of absorption as a
backdoor entry.
35.2. Mr. Kumar submits that appointment to all public
posts must follow a fair and transparent procedure. It must
meet the test of fairness and equality as envisaged in Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. Such backdoor entry
negates the principle of equal opportunity and fairness in
public employment.
54
35.3. It is contended that Shri Pradeep Atri, Shri Pankaj
Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia had appeared in the direct
recruitment examination to the post of Assistant Engineer
(Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department pursuant to the
advertisement dated 07.05.2006 but they did not qualify. Shri
Praveen Chaudhary had not even applied for such direct
recruitment process. These four officers have sought to do
indirectly what is not possible directly by first seeking transfer
on deputation and then absorption in the PW(B&R)
Department. These officers were successful in getting
appointment in the PW(B&R) Department by such method
though they were unsuccessful in the examination for direct
recruitment. Moreover, these four officers neither completed
the probation period in their parent Department nor in the
borrowing Department. This is clearly reflective of the mala
fide intent of the authority when it ensured that these four
officers were appointed by way of transfer on deputation and
thereafter absorbed in the PW(B&R) Department, in the
process giving a complete go-bye to all norms of fairness and
transparency.
55
35.4. It is the High Court’s own finding that the
deputation and subsequent absorption of these four officers
was unlawful. Such appointment was by backdoor method and
not on merit. There was clear manifestation of political
interference influencing the decision for deputation and
absorption. Having found this, the High Court clearly fell in
error in directing that the said four officers should be retained
in the PW(B&R) Department.
35.5. Adverting to the case of the appellants, learned
senior counsel submits that they were appointed after being
selected in a competitive examination on merit. By virtue of the
impugned judgment, Shri Pradeep Atri and Shri Praveen
Chaudhary would continue to retain their seniority position
over some of the appellants which is wholly untenable.
35.6 Learned senior counsel submits that the State had
also taken contradictory stand in the proceedings before the
High Court. It had taken a categorical stand in the counter
affidavit filed in CWP No. 15083 of 2010 that there was no need
for absorption of the four officers in the PW(B&R) Department
and that the deputation was carried out not on administrative
exigency but on the request of the said four officers.
56
Contradicting such stand, the State in its counter affidavit filed
in a subsequent writ petition i.e. in CWP No. 7706 of 2011
justified the deputation and absorption of the four officers on
the ground that there was acute shortage of officers in the
PW(B&R) Department. But the fact of the matter is that there
was no such shortage.
35.7. Even otherwise, the direction given by the High
Court qua seniority in the impugned judgment is self-
contradictory. The absorption order of Shri Praveen
Chaudhary, Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia clearly
stated that they would be junior in service to all persons
directly recruited in the PW(B&R) Department against
vacancies which had arisen before 01.07.2006. Such a
condition was not challenged by the deputationists and was
raised only at the time when the seniority list was prepared in
the year 2010. If the initial entry of these four officers was itself
illegal, it would be wholly unfair and unjust to allow them to
continue their service on absorption, that too, by retaining
their so-called seniority.
35.8. Since the very appointment (by way of absorption)
of the four officers was illegal, they could not have been
57
granted seniority over those who came through regular
recruitment. Grant of seniority to the four officers over
regularly recruited officers amounts to a premium on backdoor
entry.
35.9. Referring to Rule 6 of the 1965 Rules, learned
senor counsel submits that there are two modes of
recruitment: 50 per cent by way of direct recruitment and the
balance 50 per cent by way of promotion. Thus, it is clear that
there are only two modes of regular recruitment.
35.10. Adverting to Rule 12 of the said Rules, it is
submitted that appointment by way of transfer is not a regular
mode of recruitment but it can only be done in special
circumstances. As per Rule 12, Government may in special
circumstances with the approval of the Public Service
Commission, appoint an officer to the service by transfer. This
Rule itself provides that there must be some special
circumstances warranting deviation from the two modes of
recruitment i.e. direct recruitment and promotion. Insofar the
present case is concerned, no special circumstances are
discernible to justify such appointment of the four officers.
58
35.11. In the circumstances, Mr. Ranjeet Kumar, learned
senior counsel submits that this part of the impugned
judgment passed by the High Court, being wholly
unsustainable in law as well as on facts, is liable to be set
aside. The four officers may either be repatriated back to their
parent Department and if that is not possible, to terminate
their illegal appointment.
36. Mr. Patwalia, learned senior counsel appearing for
the appellant Shri Pradeep Atri in the civil appeals arising out
of SLP(C) Nos. 7506-7508 of 2023 submits that the High Court
was not justified in declaring the deputation as well as
absorption of the appellant in the PW(B&R) Department as
illegal, being influenced by political considerations. However,
since the High Court has not disturbed the absorption of the
appellant, to that extent, appellant is not aggrieved by the
judgment of the High Court. But insofar as seniority is
concerned, he submits that the decision of the High Court is
erroneous and is, therefore, contested by the appellant.
36.1. Mr. Patwalia has extensively referred to the file
notings placed on record to contend that it was a considered
decision of the authority to send the appellant on deputation
59
to the PW(B&R) Department. He further submits that the
authority had carried out extensive consultation including
with the Public Service Commission whereafter it was decided
that the appellant should be absorbed in the PW(B&R)
Department. Question of political considerations influencing
such decision did not arise at all; rather, there was no political
endorsement whatsoever.
36.2. Learned senior counsel has also made elaborate
submissions centering around the 1965 Rules including Rule
12(5) thereof and submits that decision of the High Court
holding that seniority position of the appellant should be
placed below the direct recruits is erroneous. He submits that
in the case of Shri Pradeep Atri, the State Government did not
invoke the proviso to Rule 12(5) to affix his seniority as in the
case of the other three officers who were granted seniority from
the date of deputation. In the case of Shri Atri, he was granted
seniority from the date of his absorption. Moreover, no
condition was imposed in his deputation or absorption order(s)
that he would be placed below the direct recruits in terms of
seniority.
60
36.3 According to Mr. Patwalia, the High Court has not
appreciated the fact that the directly appointed candidates are
seeking seniority from a date when they were not even borne
in the cadre. He submits that there exists no indefeasible right
in favour of selected candidates to seek appointment in the
PW(B&R) Department. This fact would be more clear from the
list of dates. While the appellant was appointed by way of
deputation (transfer) and absorption in the PW(B&R)
Department vide the order dated 06.10.2006, the direct
recruits were appointed in the said Department on
05.12.2007. Referring to Rule 12(1) of the 1965 Rules, he
submits that seniority is based on the date of appointment.
Since the appellant was appointed in the PW(B&R) Department
almost 14 months prior to the appointment of the direct
recruits, by no stretch of imagination can the latter be made
senior to the appellant.
36.4. Learned senior counsel submits that none of the
decisions relied upon by the High Court to answer the question
pertaining to seniority applies to the facts of the present case.
Those decisions are clearly distinguishable.
61
36.5. Much stress was laid upon Rule 12(1) of the 1965
Rules on the basis of which Mr. Singh submits that service in
the cadre will commence from the date of appointment.
Therefore, none can claim seniority prior to the date of
appointment. Adverting to the decisions of this Court in K.
1
Meghachandra Singh Vs. Ningom Siro and in Shripal Bhati Vs.
2
State of Uttar Pradesh , learned senior counsel submits that
law is well settled that a person is disentitled to claim seniority
from the date he was not borne in the service.
36.6. It is further submitted that the appellant is highly
qualified and his performance in the PW(B&R) Department was
found to be without any blemish. Therefore, the authority after
due consideration and consultation with all the stakeholders
decided to appoint the appellant in the said Department on
absorption. Such a power is traceable to Rule 10 of the 1965
Rules. Thus, appellant became a member of the service under
Rule 2(12) upon such absorption.
36.7. Learned senior counsel submitted that the
PW(B&R) Department had invoked Rule 10 of the 1965 Rules
1
(2020) 5 SCC 689
2
(2020) 12 SCC 87
62
in view of the ‘special circumstances’ that existed the time of
absorption of the appellant. It is clear from the file notings that
the authority was concerned with the severe shortage of staff
with no certainty of fresh recruitment. This, coupled with the
appellant’s qualification and unblemished service in the
Department, formed the ‘special circumstances’ justifying
appointment by way of transfer and absorption.
36.8. After a long narration of facts, learned senior
counsel submits that the High Court erred in not appreciating
that the appellant was appointed by way of deputation
(transfer) and absorption in the PW(B&R) Department for the
following reasons:
i. there was acute shortage of Sub-Divisional
Engineers (Civil) in the Department since there was a stay
on fresh recruitment due to pending litigation;
ii. due to shortage of Sub-Divisional Engineers in the
Department, official work was hampered;
iii. the acute shortage of engineers in the Department
and the inability of the Department to recruit fresh
63
engineers created a ‘special circumstance’ under Rule 10
of the 1965 Rules;
iv. appellant possessed the required qualification i.e.
a Bachelor’s degree in civil engineering for being recruited
to the post of Sub-Divisional Engineer in the PW(B&R)
Department;
v. appellant had already rendered service in the
Department following his deputation and was fully
conversant with the nature of work in the Department;
vi. appellant was absorbed after his representation to
the Government showing his willingness to work in the
PW(B&R) Department; amd,
vii. no objection certificate was issued by the parent
Department i.e. Development and Panchayat Department
to the initial deputation and the consequential absorption
of the appellant in the PW(B&R) Department.
36.9. According to Mr. Patwalia, the effect of the
impugned judgment would be that Shri Pradeep Atri despite
being in service prior to the direct recruits will be placed below
64
the 2014 direct recruits, and those direct recruits would be
granted notional retrospective seniority from a date prior to
them being borne in the cadre.
36.10. Mr. Patwalia finally submits that the High Court
has erred in assigning the seniority position of the appellant
below the direct recruits and this position needs to be rectified
by this Court. Therefore, he prays for interference in the
impugned judgment of the High Court to the aforesaid limited
extent.
37. Mr. Nidhesh Gupta, learned senior counsel
appearing on behalf of Shri Praveen Chaudhary, has laid great
emphasis on the 1965 Rules and submits that appointment by
transfer is recognised under the said rules as a mode of
appointment. He has referred to Rules 2(9)(b), 2(12) , 7(4) and
10 to contend that a conjoint reading of the aforesaid rules
would clearly show that appointment by way of transfer is an
accepted mode of appointment under the said rules.
37.1. Referring to Rule 12(5), more particularly to the
proviso thereto, he submits that though the substantive part
of sub-rule (5) says that an Assistant Engineer appointed by
way of transfer while normally would be placed junior to all
65
the officers appointed directly or by way of promotion in a
particular year, the Government may in the interest of service
and taking into consideration the circumstances of the case,
fix his seniority on adhoc basis. Adverting to the proviso, he
submits that seniority ‘thus fixed’ shall not be more favourable
than the seniority determined after allowing him credit for the
period of service rendered by him in the previous appointment
as Assistant Engineer or on a post of equivalent or greater
responsibility as may be determined by the Government.
Therefore, he submits that appointment of the answering
respondent Praveen Chaudhary by transfer cannot be
questioned as being impermissible under the 1965 Rules. In
this connection, he has placed reliance on a decision of this
3
Court in State of Rajasthan Vs. Anand Prakash Solanki .
37.2. Mr. Gupta submits that the deputation and
absorption of Shri Praveen Chaudhary in the PW(B&R)
Department in the cadre of Assistant Engineer is fully justified
in the facts and circumstances of the present case. He submits
that advertisement was issued on 07.05.2006 inviting
applications for 44 posts of Sub-Divisional Engineer (Assistant
3
(2003) 7 SCC 403
66
Engineer); though it has come on record that there were 59
vacancies available at that point of time but requisition was
sent for only 44 vacancies. In the meanwhile, 14 Assistant
Engineers were promoted to the post of Executive Engineer.
Therefore, 73 vacancies (59 + 14) became available in the said
Department. Infact, in a cadre strength of 82, there were 73
vacancies. That apart, since the year 1993, there had been no
direct recruitment to the cadre of Assistant Engineer (Civil).
The Engineer-in-Chief in the PW(B&R) Department cited the
acute shortage of engineers in the said Department as a reason
for taking the answering respondent on deputation. Thus, the
above factual position makes it abundantly clear that there
were legitimate reasons for sending the answering respondent
Shri Praveen Chaudhary on deputation to the PW(B&R)
Department.
37.3. The vacancy position became further acute when
in a writ proceeding arising out of CWP No. 16016 of 2000
which was filed by candidates who were selected in a selection
process conducted prior to the year 2000 and who had claimed
that it was they who were entitled to be appointed against the
said vacancies, the State Government gave an undertaking
67
before the High Court that the selected candidates for the post
of Sub-Divisional Engineer pursuant to the advertisement
dated 07.05.2006 would not be appointed. He submits that
the dispute in the said case pertained to the direct recruits
inter se and had nothing to do with the deputation of Shri
Praveen Chaudhary.
37.4. Learned senior counsel submits that the severe
shortage of Assistant Engineers continued to plague the
Department even after the deputation of the answering
respondent. Therefore, a request was made for accepting
atleast 20 Sub-Divisional Engineers (Assistant Engineers) with
degree in civil engineering to be taken on deputation. In terms
of Rule 10, the Government has the discretion to appoint an
officer to the service by way of transfer. In the present case,
the Government had decided to exercise the discretion as it
was satisfied that special circumstances did exist for
appointing the answering respondent to the service by way of
transfer.
37.5. Reiterating the aforesaid submission, learned
senior counsel asserts that the State of Haryana also accepted
the existence of such ‘special circumstances’ when it
68
highlighted in an affidavit filed before the High Court that
there was an acute shortage of officers in the Department and
that the appointments were not being made for which the
ongoing projects were getting delayed due to shortage of
officers.
37.6. Referring to the decision of this Court in PM Bayas
4
Vs. Union of India , learned senior counsel submits that the
overall factual position in the present case fully justifies the
deputation and absorption of the answering respondent Shri
Praveen Chaudhary in the PW(B&R) Department as the
existence of ‘special circumstances’ justifying such
appointment were clearly discernible.
37.7. Mr. Gupta has also questioned the impugned
judgment and order of the High Cout in so far it condoned the
delay in challenging the deputation and absorption of the
answering respondent. In fact, he submits that there was a
considerable delay in challenging the deputation and
absorption of the answering respondent before the High Court.
Shri Praveen Chaudhary was sent on deputation on
4
(1993) 3 SCC 319
69
25.04.2006 and came to be absorbed in the PW(B&R)
Department on 08.07.2007. However, the writ petition
challenging the said appointment came to be filed after several
years in 2011 and 2012. The reasoning given by the High
Court while condoning such delay is ex-facie incorrect. In this
connection, he has placed reliance on the following decisions
of this Court:
5
(i) Rabindra Nath Bose Vs. Union of India ;
6
(ii) PS Sadasivaswamy Vs. State of Tamil Nadu ;
7
(iii) K.R. Mudgal Vs. RP Singh ; and
8
(iv) Shiba Shankar Mohapatra Vs. State of Orissa .
37.8. Assailing the reasoning given by the High Court,
he submits that if the reasoning of the High Court that no
cause of action had arisen prior to the grant of seniority to the
answering respondent over the direct recruits/promotees is
accepted, then there would be occasion for the related special
leave petitions to be entertained because as per the impugned
5
(1970) 1 SCC 184
6
(1975) 1 SCC 152
7
(1986) 4 SCC 531
8
(2012) 12 SCC 471
70
judgment and order, such seniority has been denied to Shri
Praveen Chaudhary.
37.9. Learned senior counsel once again reiterated that
ultimately it is for the concerned Government to take a
decision as to whether to absorb a deputationist or not. This
is the discretion available to the administrative authority and
the exercise of such a discretion by the concerned Government
should not be interfered with by a court of law.
37.10. Adverting to the meaning of the expression ‘special
circumstances’ as finding place in Rule 10 of the 1965 Rules,
learned senior counsel has referred to a decision of this Court
9
in Chief Engineering Vs. K.S. Brar and submits that presence
of ‘special circumstances’ is to be determined by the concerned
authority and should not be ordinarily interfered with by the
courts.
37.11. Referring to various file notings and documents
placed on record, Mr. Gupta submits that the facts
demonstrate that it is the answering respondent Shri Praveen
Chaudhary who has been discriminated against and
9
1988 Supp SCC 756
71
prejudiced from time to time. Inspite of the clear seniority of
the answering respondent, he was not given due seniority for
which he had filed CWP No. 15820 of 2010. It was only after
Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia were given seniority,
the representation of the answering respondent was accepted
whereafter he was granted his due seniority vide the order
dated 01.10.2019 with effect from the date on which the
answering respondent had joined the PW(B&R) Department as
Assistant Engineer (Civil) i.e. on 02.05.2006. Referring to Rule
12(1) of the 1965 Rules, Mr. Gupta submits that seniority of
the members of the service shall be determined by the order of
their appointment in service irrespective of their date of
joining. The only exception is provided in Rule 12(5) which
prescribes that ordinarily an Assistant Engineer appointed by
way of transfer would be junior to all the officers appointed
directly or by way of promotion in a particular year; however,
the Government may, in the interest of public service, fix his
seniority on an adhoc basis. The proviso to Rule 12(5) makes
it abundantly clear that seniority can be determined by giving
credit for the period of service rendered in the previous
appointment as Assistant Engineer. Therefore, the answering
72
respondent is entitled to seniority from 18.10.2005 i.e. the
date of his appointment in the Development and Panchayat
Department as Assistant Engineer (Civil); however, he has
been granted seniority in the PW(B&R) Department only from
the date of joining in the said Department. In this connection,
learned senior counsel has placed reliance on the following
decisions:
10
(i) K. Madhavan Vs. Union of India ; and
11
(ii) Sub Inspector Rooplal Vs. Lieutenant Governor .
37.12. Rule 12(1) indisputably determines seniority on
the basis of the order of appointment, the only exception being
provided is under sub-rule (5). He submits that a careful and
conjoint reading of Rule 12(1) and Rule 12(5) would make it
clear that normally a transferee Assistant Engineer would be
junior to all officers appointed directly or by way of promotion
in a particular year in the cadre. Placing the transferee as the
junior most officer would obviously be the worst case scenario
for the said transferee Assistant Engineer. Any rule which
seeks to place him junior to those who may be appointed in
10
(1987) 4 SCC 566
11
(2000) 1 SCC 644
73
subsequent years would be ex facie illegal, arbitrary and
violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
Delineating Rule 12(5), learned senior counsel submits that
the latter part of Rule 12(5) obviously permits fixation of
seniority on better terms than the first part of Rule 12(5) which
places a transferee Assistant Engineer junior to all officers
appointed in a particular year. The proviso while speaking of
the seniority ‘thus fixed’ refers clearly to the seniority fixed
under Rule 12(5). He submits that the fixation of seniority
mentioned in Rule 12(5) is a favourable fixation for the
Assistant Engineer. However, the outer limit is placed by the
proviso by ensuring that such an Assistant Engineer cannot
get the benefit of more than the period of service rendered in
previous appointment as Assistant Engineer. Thus, it is clear
that the two limits, namely, the worst case scenario and the
best case scenario, for the transferee are both provided under
Rule 12(5). The worst case is under the substantive provision
of Rule 12(5) and the best case is under the proviso to Rule
12(5).
37.13. Learned senior counsel submits that the direction
of the High Court in the impugned judgment and order stating
74
that the answering respondent would be entitled to seniority
only from 18.07.2007 i.e. the date of his absorption but at the
same time holding that he cannot get seniority over any direct
recruit or promotee appointed against vacancies which had
arisen prior to 01.07.2006, besides being contradictory, is also
against the settled principles of law as can be deciphered from
the decisions cited supra.
37.14. That apart, by way of the impugned judgment, the
High Court has granted seniority to the direct recruits from a
date on which they were not yet borne in the cadre of Assistant
Engineer (Civil). Though by the impugned judgment, seniority
has been granted to the direct recruits from 29.11.2006, they
were in fact appointed in the cadre of Assistant Engineer (Civil)
on 05.12.2007. The date 29.11.2006 is totally irrelevant for
the purpose of grant of seniority to the direct recruits. As a
matter of fact, on the said date, only an undertaking was given
by the State Government to the High Court that no
appointments would be made to the post of Assistant Engineer
following the recruitment process pursuant to the
advertisement dated 07.05.2006. On the said date, the direct
recruits had not even joined in the cadre. In addition to several
75
judgments of this Court which says that seniority cannot be
granted from an anterior date prior to joining, the same is also
contrary to the express language of Rule 12(1) itself which says
that seniority has to be granted from the date of appointment.
37.15. In the circumstances, Mr. Nidhesh Gupta, learned
senior counsel submits that it is extremely incongruous and
unjust that the High Court has denied the benefit of seniority
to the answering respondent from the date of appointment in
the PW(B&R) Department, not to speak of his appointment in
the Development and Panchayat Department; yet, the direct
recruits have been given seniority from the date when they
were not even borne in the cadre of Assistant Engineer (Civil)
in the PW(B&R) Department. He submits that though certain
conditions were laid down in the absorption order regarding
seniority, those would not be applicable; the statutory rules
i.e. the 1965 Rules would prevail over such administrative
order. Thus, seniority of the answering respondent would be
governed by Rule 12(5) and not by the conditions mentioned
in the absorption order.
37.16. He, therefore, submits that the High Court was not
justified in declaring the deputation and absorption of the
76
answering respondent Shri Praveen Chaudhary as illegal
though High Court did not disturb such appointment. He
further submits that the High Court fell in serious error in
disturbing the seniority assigned to the answering respondent
by the State. To that extent the impugned judgment and order
is liable to be interfered with.
38. Mr. Guru Krishna Kumar, learned senior counsel
appearing on behalf of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun
Bhatia, at the outset draws the attention of the Court to Rules
6 and 10 of the 1965 Rules. While Rule 6 speaks about the
modes of recruitment to the service for both cadre and ex-
cadre posts being 50 percent by direct recruitment and 50
percent by promotion, Rule 10 refers to appointment by way
of transfer. Specifically pointing out to Rule 10, he submits
that as per the said provision, the Government may, in ‘special
circumstances’, with the approval of the Commission, appoint
an officer to the service by transfer. A conjoint reading of the
two rules would show that three modes of appointment are
envisaged: direct recruitment, promotion and appointment by
transfer. Therefore, the contention of the appellants (Shri
Hemant Kumar and others) that the 1965 Rules do not
77
envisage appointment by transfer at all, particularly to the
post of Assistant Engineer/Sub-Divisional Engineer, if
accepted, would render Rule 10 otiose . This would also be
contrary to the settled principles of interpretation which says
that the statute would have to be read harmoniously so as not
to render any provision otiose .
38.1. Learned senior counsel submits that Rule 10 is a
specially crafted provision envisaging ‘special circumstances’
and ‘approval of the Commission’ to appointment to the service
by way of transfer. Contention of the direct recruits that there
were no ‘special circumstances’ in terms of Rule 10 of the 1965
Rules to justify the absorption of the deputationists is
untenable. Mr. Kumar submits that the following factors were
clearly taken into account by the PW(B&R) Department while
considering absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun
Bhatia:
(i) both Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia
possess M.Tech. in the relevant field;
(ii) they have been recruited through a proper process
by the Haryana Public Service Commission; and,
78
(iii) they have spent time in the Department and they
have been found good in their work.
38.2. Adverting to Rule 12, Mr. Kumar, learned senior
counsel, submits that determination of seniority of officers in
a cadre has to be done in terms of Rule 12 of the 1965 Rules.
After elaborately referring to Rule 12, he points out the salient
features of the said provision as under:
(i) Rule 12(1) provides for the manner of determination
of seniority of the members of the service but carves
out an exception as provided in sub-rule (5) of Rule
12; and
(ii) sub-rule (5) of Rule 12 relates specifically to an
officer appointed by way of transfer. Thus, the
provisions contained in Rules 12(1) to 12(4) relate to
determination of seniority of persons appointed
otherwise than by way of transfer.
38.3. In accordance with sub-rule (5) of Rule 12 in the
case of persons appointed by way of transfer as Assistant
Engineer, though they would be normally placed junior to all
officers appointed directly or by promotion as Assistant
79
Engineer in a particular year, the Government may in the
interest of public service and taking into consideration all
circumstances of the case, fix their seniority on an ad hoc
basis. Thus, the authority of the Government to fix the
seniority of the officers is hedged by three considerations: (i)
the particular year of appointment; (ii) in the interest of public
service; and (iii) all circumstances of the case. Rule 12(5),
therefore, permits the Government to fix the seniority of an
officer taking into consideration all relevant factors as
enumerated above.
38.4. Referring to the proviso, learned senior counsel
submits that an important qualification in such fixation is set
out in the proviso which is couched in negative language. It
says that the seniority so fixed shall not be more favourable
than the seniority determined after allowing the officer
(transferee) the credit for the period of service rendered by him
in his previous appointment as Assistant Engineer or
appointed to a post of equivalent or greater responsibility. A
true and proper reading of the proviso would show that the
Government can take into consideration the past service of an
officer in his previous appointment as an Assistant Engineer
80
before his appointment by transfer to consider his seniority. In
such circumstances, both Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun
Bhatia would be entitled to seek the benefit of the service
rendered by them as Assistant Engineer in the Development
and Panchayat Department.
38.5. In support of his above submission, Mr. Kumar
has referred to the decision of this Court in K.S. Brar. He
submits that this Court in K.S. Brar has in clear terms held
that for determining seniority, what one has to see is not Rule
10 but Rule 12(5) which in terms provides that any person
appointed to the post in the service in question by transfer can
be assigned seniority as of a date earlier than the date of
absorption provided that this is done in the interest of public
service.
38.6. Shri Guru Krishna Kumar, learned senior counsel
submits that without in any manner undermining the case of
Shri Pradeep Atri and Shri Praveen Chaudhary, there are
certain factual distinctions in respect of the case of Shri
Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia which sets apart their
deputation and absorption from the two officers. He submits
81
that the following may be treated as the distinguishing
features in respect of Shri Praveen Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia:
(i) deputation of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun
Bhatia was by requisition; 8 other Assistant
Engineers were deputed alongwith Shri Pankaj
Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia;
(ii) while considering absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur
and Shri Arun Bhatia, PW(B&R) Department had
also considered the absorption of one Shri K.K.
Bathla but rejected the same by assigning specific
reasons;
(iii) Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia had
completed their probation by the time they were
sent on deputation;
(iv) Haryana Public Service Commission had approved
the absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun
Bhatia prior to issuance of their absorption order;
(v) Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia have been
assigned their seniority position from the dates of
their deputation;
82
(vi) Shri Arun Bhatia does not have any political
recommendation; and,
(vii) Both Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia were
placed above the 2009 batch of direct recruits
whose selection process has been held to be illegal
by the High Court in CWP No. 19993 of 2009.
38.7. Learned senior counsel has categorically denied
any allegation of political interference in the absorption of Shri
Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia. In fact, he has termed
such allegations as wholly untenable. Since the direct recruit
petitioners had alleged mala fides and political interference in
the absorption and grant of seniority in favour of Shri Pankaj
Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia, it was incumbent upon them to
have specifically pleaded such allegations and they ought to
have impleaded the persons or public functionaries because of
whose political influence or interference, Shri Pankaj Gaur and
Shri Arun Bhatia came to be absorbed in the PW(B&R)
Department. Referring to the decision of this Court in Ratnagiri
12
Gas and Power Private Limited Vs. RDS Projects Limited , he
12
(2013) 1 SCC 524
83
submits that it is a well settled principle of law that whenever
allegations of mala fides are made, the person against whom
such allegations are made should necessarily be impleaded as
party to the proceeding so as to afford him an opportunity to
answer the charge.
38.8. Even in case of Shri Pankaj Gaur, the
recommendation of the MLA, Mahendergarh did not form the
basis of decision to absorb him and to grant seniority. In fact,
such recommendation came after the absorption proposal was
approved by the Department. A careful perusal of the file notes
would show that the recommendations of the elected
representatives did not form the basis of the decision to absorb
Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia. Admittedly, there
were no recommendations at all in the case of Shri Arun
Bhatia. The High Court made a broad brush without
considering the individual cases and the material on record.
38.9. In the circumstances, learned senior counsel
submits that the High Court fell in serious error in interfering
with the seniority assigned to Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun
Bhatia by the State Government. While High Court was also
wrong in terming their deputation and absorption as illegal
84
though the High Court did not interfere with the same.
Therefore, to the limited extent as indicated supra, the
impugned judgment and order of the High Court should be set
aside and quashed.
39. Mr. Bijender Chahar, learned Additional Solicitor
General appearing for the State of Haryana, submits that the
High Court erred in holding that absorption of the
deputationists was not bona fide and that the same was
contrary to the 1965 Rules as there were no ‘special
circumstances’ which justified such absorption. He submits
that the material on record clearly indicated that the PW(B&R)
Department was facing acute shortage of Assistant Engineers
(Civil) with huge number of vacancies. Requirement of work
and shortage of manpower are good reasons to make out a
case that ‘special circumstances’ did exist warranting
deputation and absorption of the four officers in the PW(B&R)
Department which was in terms of Rule 10 of the 1965 Rules.
39.1. In so far seniority is concerned, learned Additional
Solicitor General submits that the High Court has failed to
appreciate the application of Rule 12 of the 1965 Rules which
provides the conditions for grant of seniority and in particular
85
Rule 12(5) which gives discretion to the Government to grant
seniority. The State Government has scrupulously followed the
provisions of Rule 12 while granting seniority to the four
absorbed deputationists. Therefore, the High Court was not
justified in interfering with the grant of seniority to Shri
Pradeep Atri, Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Shri Pankaj Gaur and
Shri Arun Bhatia by the State Government. In this connection,
he has referred to the decision of this Court in K.S. Brar which
clearly says that for determining seniority of a member of the
service, one has to follow Rule 12(5) of the 1965 Rules.
39.2. Learned Additional Solicitor General has also
assailed the grant of seniority to the direct recruits from an
anterior date by the High Court by referring to the decision of
13
this Court in K. Meghachandra Singh Vs. Ningom Siro which
categorically declares that direct recruits cannot claim
notional seniority from a date earlier than the date of joining
the service. A person is not entitled to claim seniority from a
date when he was not even borne in the service.
13
(2020)5 SCC 689
86
39.3. He submits that the High Court ought to have
considered that the deputation and subsequent absorption
(which is appointment by way of transfer) of Shri Pradeep Atri,
Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun
Bhatia in the PW(B&R) Department were based on Rule 10 of
the 1965 Rules and their seniority was correctly assigned by
the State Government by applying Rule 12(1) and Rule 12(5)
of the 1965 Rules. Concurrence of the Haryana Public Service
Commission was duly taken before passing the orders of
absorption.
39.4. While representation of some of the deputationists
were forwarded by local MLAs or Ministers, that did not have
any bearing on the ultimate decision taken by the State
Government to absorb the four deputationists. The competent
authority had duly considered all aspects of the matter and
had taken the decision to absorb the four deputationists in
accordance with law. Therefore, the observations made by the
High Court that there was political influence and interference
culminating in the absorption of the deputationists, is clearly
unwarranted.
87
39.5. He further submits that when appointment by way
of transfer is permitted by the statute, then no fault can be
found in the assignment of seniority to such officers from the
date of appointment of such officers in the transferred
department. He points out that the direct recruits who have
challenged the absorption and seniority assigned to Shri
Pradeep Atri, Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Shri Pankaj Gaur and
Shri Arun Bhatia had joined the PW(B&R) Department after
the appointment of the aforesaid four officers. Therefore, the
State Government was fully justified in assigning seniority to
the four officers above the direct recruits.
39.6. In such circumstances, learned Additional
Solicitor General appearing for the State of Haryana submits
that the finding recorded by the High Court that the
deputation of the four officers and their absorption were
illegal, is not justified and requires interference. He further
submits that interference by the High Court in the correct
assignment of seniority to the four officers by the State
Government is also wholly untenable and is liable to be set
aside and quashed.
88
40. Mr. Gurminder Singh, learned senior counsel
representing the appellants in the civil appeal arising out of
Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 8004 of 2023, has assailed
the impugned judgment of the High Court on the ground that
while the unequivocal conclusion of the High Court is that the
appointment of the four officers by way of absorption in the
PW(B&R) Department was obtained by exerting political
influence, both at the stage of deputation as well as
absorption, and that it was completely contrary to the 1965
Rules, yet the High Court by taking a ‘sympathetic view’
allowed the said officers to continue in service. He submits
that while exercising its powers under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, the High Court could not have directed
continuance of the illegal appointments.
40.1. He submits that the appellants have been directly
recruited to the post of Sub-Divisional Engineer/Assistant
Engineer in terms of Rule 6 of the 1965 Rules against the 44
vacancies advertised on 07.05.2006. However, the four officers
were appointed to the said post via the backdoor through
political interference. He submits and highlights the fact that
three of these officers viz. Shri Pradeep Atri, Shri Pankaj Gaur
89
and Shri Arun Bhatia had appeared for the direct recruitment
examination held pursuant to the advertisement dated
07.05.2006 but did not qualify. Shri Praveen Chaudhary did
not even appear. Thus, the four officers sought to do indirectly
what they could not do directly. In such circumstances, the
High Court ought to have terminated the services of the said
officers instead of sustaining it.
40.2. Mr. Singh submits that appointment to all public
posts must be fair and done through a transparent process
meeting the requirements of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India. Backdoor entry, such as the
appointments of the four officers, negates the principle of
equal opportunity and fairness in public employment.
40.3. While certainly the High Court has the power to
mould the relief in a proceeding under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, it certainly does not have powers similar
to the one conferred upon this Court by virtue of Article 142 of
the Constitution of India. Therefore, allowing the four officers
to continue in service after finding their appointments to be
illegal is wholly untenable.
90
40.4. Thus, the High Court clearly erred in taking a
‘sympathetic view’ to sustain the appointments even after
recording a finding that the absorption of the four officers as
Sub-Divisional Engineer in the PW(B&R) Department is a
backdoor entry, ignoring the law laid down by this Court in
14
M.P. State Cooperative Bank Limited Vs. Nanuram Yadav
wherein it has been held that those who come by the backdoor
should exit through that door.
40.5. Referring to Rule 6 of the 1965 Rules, Mr. Singh
submits that recruitment to the service is either through direct
recruitment (50 percent) or by way of promotion (50 percent).
Thus, there are only two modes of regular recruitment.
Adverting to Rule 12, he submits that appointment by transfer
is not a regular mode of recruitment but can only be done in
‘special circumstances’, that too, with the approval of the
Public Service Commission. In so far the present case is
concerned, there were no ‘special circumstances’ to justify
appointment of the four officers by way of transfer. While the
High Court agreed that the condition precedent as prescribed
14
(2007) 8 SCC 264
91
in Rule 12 was not satisfied, yet High Court did not interfere
with the illegal appointments of the four officers.
40.6. Learned senior counsel also submits that in all the
four cases of appointment by way of transfer, the probation
period of two years was not complete when the deputation was
sought for and granted.
40.7. Mr. Gurminder Singh has referred to the counter
affidavit filed by the State of Haryana before the High Court in
CWP No. 15083 of 2010 and submits that in the said affidavit,
the State had taken a categorical stand that there was no need
for absorption of the four deputationists in the PW(B&R)
Department and that the same was resorted to only on the
request of the four officers. Now the State cannot be permitted
to take a diametrically opposite stand justifying the deputation
and absorption of the four officers.
40.8. He, therefore, submits that the impugned
judgment and order of the High Court should be appropriately
interfered with by this Court.
41. Mr. V. Giri, learned senior counsel appearing for
the direct recruits of the 2009 batch submits that the direct
92
recruits of the 2009 batch have been compelled to approach
this Court because of the elaborate directions issued by the
High Court vide the impugned judgment and order
safeguarding the seniority of Shri Pradeep Atri and Shri
Praveen Chaudhary over the 2009 batch despite holding their
appointments to be illegal. Because of such directions of the
High Court, both Shri Atri and Shri Chaudhary had been given
promotion to the post of Chief Engineer subsequent to the
impugned judgment despite being illegal appointees. He
submits that there are only two posts of Engineer-in-Chief in
the PW(B&R) Department and considering the long tenures of
Shri Atri and Shri Chaudhary, with both of them holding the
post of Engineer-in-Chief, the 2009 direct recruit batch will be
left high and dry despite being regular appointees.
41.1. Mr. Giri submits that once the absorption of the
four officers have been found to be illegal by the High Court,
the sequitur is that they should be repatriated to their parent
Department. The direct recruits have questioned the
absorption and grant of seniority to the four officers in the
PW(B&R) Department and not their initial appointment in the
Development and Panchayat Department.
93
41.2. Mr. Giri submits that by protecting the illegal
absorption, the High Court has committed the very error it has
found fault with in the conduct of the State. Placing reliance
on the decision of this Court in Secretary, State of Karnataka
15
Vs. Umadevi , he submits that to perpetuate an illegality on
judicial sympathy is to compound the error.
41.3. Clarifying the position, Mr. Giri points out that
though the 2009 batch of direct recruits were not initially
agitating the absorption and grant of seniority to Shri Pradeep
Atri and Shri Praveen Chaudhary before the High Court, the
issue was at large from the year 2010 itself whereby in the writ
petition filed by Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Shri Pankaj Gaur
and Shri Arun Bhatia (CWP No. 15083 of 2010), the 2009
batch of direct recruits were the respondents; in CWP No. 7706
of 2011 ( Abhishek Vs. State ), the absorption of the
deputationists were under challenge at the instance of the
2007 batch of direct recruits.
41.4. Learned senior counsel asserts that even
assuming but not admitting that the illegal entrants are not to
15
(2006) 4 SCC 1
94
be repatriated, they still cannot assert a right to seniority over
the regularly selected officers. Placing reliance on a decision of
16
this Court in Nand Kumar Manjhi Vs. State of Bihar , learned
senior counsel submits that even if the service of the illegal
appointees are protected, such protection cannot be converted
to a seniority advantage over regularly recruited persons.
41.5. On the aforesaid grounds, learned counsel seeks
interference with the impugned judgment and order of the
High Court.
42. In his reply submissions, Mr. Ranjit Kumar
learned senior counsel submits that deputation of the four
officers is illegal. Their absorption in the PW(B&R) Department
is also illegal being contrary to Rule 10 of the 1965 Rules.
There were no ‘special circumstances’ for their absorption and
their absorption was a product of political machination. High
Court has clearly endorsed this position. Yet the High Court
has allowed the illegal appointments to continue.
42.1. In so far reliance placed by the learned senior
counsel appearing on behalf of the four officers on the
16
(2019) 14 SCC 67
95
judgment of this Court in K.S. Brar is concerned , he submits
that in the said case, the challenge to such absorption of
respondent No. 4 was given up by the petitioner. This Court
specifically recorded that it did not go into the question as to
whether such an appointment by transfer could be said to be
invalid or irregular merely because no ‘special circumstance’
has been recited in the order as the challenge to the order
appointing respondent No. 4 by transfer was specifically given
up by the petitioner. He reiterates that in the present case,
there were no ‘special circumstances’ to justify absorption of
the deputationists.
42.2. Summing up his arguments, Mr. Kumar submits
that the four deputationists have no reason to continue service
in the PW(B&R) Department. Their services are either to be
terminated or they should be repatriated back to their parent
Department. At the most, if at all they are to continue in the
PW(B&R) Department, then certainly they have to be placed
below the candidates who have entered the service through the
regular recruitment process.
96
Analysis
43. Submissions made by learned counsel for the
parties have received the due consideration of the Court.
44. Upon hearing learned counsel for the parties and
considering the materials on record, the following questions
arise for consideration of this Court:
(i) Whether the deputation of Shri Pradeep Atri, Shri
Praveen Chaudhary, Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri
Arun Bhatia from the Development and Panchayat
Department, Government of Haryana to the
PW(B&R) Department in the said Government in the
cadre of Assistant Engineer (Civil) is legal, valid and
justified?
(ii) Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of
the case, the absorption of the four deputationists
as Sub-Divisional Engineer/Assistant Engineer
(Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department is legal, valid and
justified?
(iii) If the answer to the above questions is in the
affirmative, then the further question arises as to
97
whether the seniority position assigned to the
aforesaid four officers by the State upon their
absorption in the cadre of Sub-Divisional
Engineer/Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the PW(B&R)
Department or reassigned by the High Court is
legal, valid and justified?
45. Before we proceed to answer the above questions
framed, it would be appropriate to briefly analyse the relevant
provisions of the 1965 Rules.
46. The Punjab Service of Engineers, Class II, P.W.D.
(Buildings and Roads Branch) Rules, 1965 (already referred to
as ‘the 1965 Rules’ hereinabove) has been made in exercise of
the powers conferred by the proviso to Article 309 of the
Constitution of India. The 1965 Rules has since been adopted
by the Government of Haryana.
46.1. Rule 2 is the definition clause of the 1965 Rules.
As per Rule 2(3), ‘Assistant Engineer’ means an officer in
charge of a Sub-Division and includes an officer holding a post
of equivalent responsibility in the PW(B&R) Department.
‘Cadre post’ has been defined in Rule 2(4) to mean a
permanent post in the service.
98
46.2. Rule 2(9) defines ‘direct appointment’ to mean an
appointment by open competition but does not include:
(a) an appointment made by promotion; and
(b) an appointment by transfer of an officer already in
service of a State Government or of the Government
of India.
46.3. ‘Ex cadre post’ has been defined in Rule 2(10) to
mean a temporary post of the same rank as a cadre post. Thus,
while cadre post means a permanent post in the service, ex
cadre post means a temporary post of the same rank as a cadre
post.
46.4. Before we go to Rule 2(12), it would be appropriate
to first deal with Rule 2(15) which defines ‘service’ to mean the
Haryana Service of Engineers, Class II, P.W.D. (Buildings and
Roads Branch). ‘Member of Service’ as defined in Rule 2(12)
means an officer appointed substantively to a cadre post and
includes:
(a) in the case of direct recruitment, an officer on
probation or an officer who, having successfully
99
completed his probation, awaits appointment to a
cadre post; and
(b) in the case of an appointment by transfer, an officer,
who is on probation or who having successfully
completed his probation awaits appointment to a
cadre post provided such officer does not have a lien
on a substantive post in any Government
Department.
46.5. This brings us to Rule 6 which deals with
recruitment to the service. As per sub-rule (1), recruitment to
the service for cadre and ex cadre posts shall be made in the
following manner :
(a) 50 percent by direct recruitment; and
(b) 50 percent by promotion.
46.5.1. It is not necessary to delve into the breakup of the
categories from which the promotion quota is required to be
filled up. However, we may refer to sub-rule (3) of Rule 6 which
says that till such time the direct recruits are not available or
for a period not exceeding six months, whichever is earlier, the
Government may fill up the vacancies in a stop gap
100
arrangement by way of promotion from the different categories
as provided in sub-rule (1). However, such a person shall be
liable to be reverted to his original cadre when a candidate
from the Haryana Public Service Commission is available and
the period of service rendered by such person shall not be
reckoned for the purpose of seniority.
46.6. Rule 7 which deals with qualification for being
appointed to the service provides in sub-rule (4) that in case
of appointment by transfer, the candidate must possess the
qualifications prescribed for the members of the service.
46.7. While Rule 8 deals with direct appointment and
Rule 9 deals with appointment by way of promotion, Rule 10
is appointment by transfer. This provision being relevant is
extracted hereunder:
Government may in special circumstances with the
approval of the Commission, appoint an officer to
the service by transfer.
46.8. As per Rule 11(1), officers appointed to the service
shall remain on probation for a period of two years and as per
Clause (b), in the case of an appointment by transfer, any
101
period of work in the rank of Assistant Engineer or above prior
to appointment to the service may, at the discretion of the
Government, be allowed to be counted towards the period of
probation fixed under this rule.
46.9. Seniority is dealt with in Rule 12. Sub-rule (1) says
that except as provided in sub-rule (5) of Rule 12 relating to
an officer appointed by transfer, the seniority of the members
of the service shall be determined by the order of their
appointment in service according to Rules 6, 8 and 9
irrespective of their dates of joining. Thus, Rule 12(1) says that
seniority of the members of the service shall be determined by
the order of their appointment. From this general rule, an
exception has been carved out in sub-rule (5) which says that
in the case of an officer appointed by transfer as an Assistant
Engineer, while normally he would be placed junior to all the
officers appointed directly or by promotion as Assistant
Engineer in a particular year, the Government may, in the
interest of public service and taking into consideration all
circumstances of the case, fix his seniority on an ad hoc basis.
There is a proviso to sub-rule (5) of Rule 12 which says that
the seniority thus fixed i.e. in terms of sub-rule (5) shall in no
102
case be more favorable than the seniority determined after
allowing the officer appointed by transfer credit for the period
of service rendered by him in his previous appointment as
Assistant Engineer or on a post which in the opinion of the
Government is of equivalent or greater responsibility; the
decision of the Government in this regard being final.
46.10. Finally, under Rule 21, the Government has the
power to relax the operation of any of the rules of the 1965
Rules. As per sub-rule (1), where the Government is satisfied
that the operation of any of the rules causes undue hardship
in any particular case, it may, by order, dispense with or relax
the requirements of that rule to such extent and subject to
such condition, as it may consider necessary for dealing with
the case in a just and equitable manner.
47. Before we examine the legality and validity of the
deputation of the four officers from the Development and
Panchayat Department to the PW(B&R) Department, it will be
useful to analyse the concept of deputation. At this stage, it
may be noted that there is no mention of the word deputation
in the 1965 Rules; therefore, the 1965 rules does not deal with
deputation per se but deals with deputation in the sense of
103
transfer. In service jurisprudence, both the concepts of
deputation and transfer are distinct having their own
connotations but it appears that in the 1965 Rules, deputation
has been loosely identified or equated with transfer.
48. We may at this stage clarify that transfer and
appointment by transfer are two different concepts. While
transfer simpliciter means a change of posting (place of work),
ordinarily within the cadre, appointment by transfer is a
method of recruitment to a different service.
17
49. In State of Punjab Vs. Inder Singh , a two-Judge
Bench of this Court had examined the concept of deputation
and held that the concept of ‘deputation’ is well understood in
service law and has a recognized meaning. In simple terms,
deputation means service outside the cadre or outside the
parent department. Deputation would mean transferring an
employee to a post outside his cadre i.e. to another department
on a temporary basis and that after expiry of the period of
deputation, the employee has to come back to his parent
department. This Court clarified that there can be no
17
(1997) 8 SCC 372
104
deputation without the consent of the person so deputed so
that he knows his rights and privileges on the deputation post.
Relevant portion of the judgment is extracted hereunder:
18. The concept of “deputation” is well understood in
service law and has a recognised meaning. “Deputation”
has a different connotation in service law and the
dictionary meaning of the word “deputation” is of no
help. In simple words “deputation” means service
outside the cadre or outside the parent department.
Deputation is deputing or transferring an employee to a
post outside his cadre, that is to say, to another
department on a temporary basis. After the expiry of the
period of deputation the employee has to come back to
his parent department to occupy the same position
unless in the meanwhile he has earned promotion in his
parent department as per the Recruitment Rules.
Whether the transfer is outside the normal field of
deployment or not is decided by the authority who
controls the service or post from which the employee is
transferred. There can be no deputation without the
consent of the person so deputed and he would,
therefore, know his rights and privileges in the
deputation post……….
50. A three-Judge Bench of this Court in Umapati
18
Choudhary Vs. State of Bihar , again examined the concept of
18
(1999) 4 SCC 659
105
deputation and held that deputation can be aptly described as
an assignment of an employee (commonly referred to as the
deputationist) of one department or cadre or even an
organization (commonly referred to as the parent department
or lending authority) to another department or cadre or
organization (commonly referred to as the borrowing
authority). It has been held that since the necessity for sending
on deputation arises in public interest to meet the exigencies
of public service, the concept of deputation has invariably to
be consensual and involves a voluntary decision of the
employer to lend the services of his employee and a
corresponding acceptance of such services by the borrowing
employer. It also involves the consent of the employee to go on
deputation or not. Relevant portion of the judgment reads as
under:
8. Deputation can be aptly described as an assignment
of an employee (commonly referred to as the
deputationist) of one department or cadre or even an
organisation (commonly referred to as the parent
department or lending authority) to another department
or cadre or organisation (commonly referred to as the
borrowing authority). The necessity for sending on
deputation arises in public interest to meet the
exigencies of public service. The concept of deputation
106
is consensual and involves a voluntary decision of the
employer to lend the services of his employee and a
corresponding acceptance of such services by the
borrowing employer. It also involves the consent of the
employee to go on deputation or not. In the case at hand
all the three conditions were fulfilled. The University,
the parent department or lending authority, the Board,
the borrowing authority and the appellant, the
deputationist, had all given their consent for deputation
of the appellant and for his permanent absorption in the
establishment of the borrowing authority. There is no
material to show that the deputation of the appellant
was not in public interest or it was vitiated by
favouritism or mala fide………
51. Again in the case of Kunal Nanda Vs. Union of
19
India , a two-Judge Bench of this Court held that unless the
claim of the deputationist for permanent absorption in the
department where he works on deputation is based upon any
statutory rule, regulation or order having the force of law, a
deputationist cannot assert and succeed in any claim for
absorption. It has been clarified that the basic principle
underlying deputation itself is that the person concerned can
always and at any time be repatriated to his parent
department to serve in his substantive position at the instance
19
(2000) 5 SCC 362
107
of either the lending department or borrowing department.
There is no vested right in such a person to continue for long
on deputation or to get absorbed in the department to which
he had gone on deputation. Paragraph 6 of the aforesaid
judgment reads as under:
6. On the legal submissions also made there are no
merits whatsoever. It is well settled that unless the
claim of the deputationist for a permanent absorption
in the department where he works on deputation is
based upon any statutory rule, regulation or order
having the force of law, a deputationist cannot assert
and succeed in any such claim for absorption. The basic
principle underlying deputation itself is that the person
concerned can always and at any time be repatriated to
his parent department to serve in his substantive
position therein at the instance of either of the
departments and there is no vested right in such a
person to continue for long on deputation or get
absorbed in the department to which he had gone on
deputation…….
52. All the aforesaid judgments were analysed by a
two-Judge Bench of this Court in the recent decision in CBI
20
Vs. Ramesh Chander Diwan whereafter the Bench has held
that where exigency of public services requires the parent
20
2025 SCC Online SC 871
108
department (lending authority) to send its employee on
deputation to the receiving department (borrowing authority)
and such an arrangement is preceded by a consensus amongst
the three i.e. the lending authority, the borrowing authority
and the officer/employee concerned, the statutory rules do
normally provide for his repatriation. In such a case, there can
be no severance of relationship with the parent department.
This Court has held thus:
20. Where exigency of public service requires the parent
department (lending authority) to send its employee on
deputation to the receiving department (borrowing
authority) and such an arrangement is preceded by a
consensus among the three, i.e., the lending authority,
the borrowing authority and the officer/employee, the
statutory rules do normally provide for his repatriation.
In such a case, there can be no severance of relationship
with the parent department. However, during the period
the officer/employee is sent on deputation to the
receiving department, the parent department may fill up
the post vacated by the deputationist in accordance
with law under the category of ‘deputation vacancy’,
which also is not unknown in public service law, but it
is only for a limited period till the officer/employee is
repatriated.
53. From a careful analysis of the judicial precedents,
what transpires is that deputation is a recognized concept in
109
service jurisprudence. Deputation is ordinarily from one
department to another department. It is resorted to for
exigencies of public service. At the time of deputation, there
must be a consensus between the three stakeholders i.e. the
parent department, the borrowing department and the
officer/employee concerned. A deputationist per se has no
right to claim absorption in the borrowing department unless
the rules of the borrowing department provide for such
absorption. Therefore, by its very nature, deputation can only
be temporary. Once the exigency of public service or public
interest is met or achieved and there is no requirement for
continuing further with the deputation, a deputationist has to
be repatriated back to the parent department. At the time of
repatriation, no consent as such of the deputationist is
required because he cannot claim continuance of his
deputation period if the borrowing department is of the view
that there is no further requirement for the deputationist or
the deputation. In such an eventuality, he has to be
repatriated back to the parent department. Since as a concept
deputation envisages a temporary arrangement, the of the
lien
110
deputationist with the parent department is not severed
during the period of deputation.
54. Let us now deal with the individual cases of the
four officers.
55. After undergoing a regular recruitment process
and following recommendation of the Haryana Public Service
Commission, Shri Pradeep Atri was appointed on 06.12.2004
as Sub-Divisional Officer (Panchayati Raj) in the Development
and Panchayat Department, Government of Haryana alongwith
others. It was mentioned in the appointment order that he would
be on probation for a period of two years, which period could be
extended for a further period not exceeding one year, if considered
necessary.
56. After joining as Sub-Divisional Officer, which is
equivalent to the post of Assistant Engineer (Civil), Shri Pradeep Atri
wrote a letter to the Engineer-in-Chief of the PW(B&R) Department
on 14.07.2005 stating about his engineering degree and his work
as Sub-Divisional Officer in the Development and Panchayat
Department. He stated that he was keen to serve the PW(B&R)
Department to utilise his energy and potential in an effective
manner. He assured that he would prove to be an asset to the said
111
Department. Therefore, he requested the Engineer-in-Chief to call
him on deputation basis from his parent Department. Relevant
portion of his request letter dated 14.07.2005 reads as under:
Keeping in view of the above facts, I request that your
goodself will be kind enough to call me on deputation basis
from my parent Department i.e. Development & Panchayat,
Haryana.
56.1. At this stage, it may be mentioned that Shri Pradeep
Atri had just about completed eight months as a probationer in the
Development and Panchayat Department and without any
requisition from the PW(B&R) Department seeking officers on
deputation because of exigencies of public service, Shri Pradeep
Atri himself requested the Engineer-in-Chief of the PW(B&R)
Department to call him on deputation. As a probationary officer
serving in the Development and Panchayat Department, Shri
Pradeep Atri could not have addressed such a request letter directly
to the head of another department seeking deputation, bypassing
his own parent Department.
57. It appears that such request of Shri Pradeep Atri was
not considered by the PW(B&R) Department and was ordered to be
‘filed’ on 24.08.2005.
112
58. Even before completion of one month of such ‘filing’,
Shri Pradeep Atri again made a request to the PW(B&R)
Department on 12.09.2005 stating that he was very keen to serve
in the PW(B&R) Department. It was at that stage that a
departmental note was put up stating that about 50 posts in the
cadre of Sub-Divisional Engineer (Civil)/Assistant Engineer (Civil)
meant for direct recruitment were lying vacant; filling up of such
vacancies would take a long time. Therefore, it was suggested that
Shri Pradeep Atri’s case for deputation could be considered as a
short-term arrangement till the joining of the direct recruits.
Following the same, the case of Shri Pradeep Atri for deputation to
the PW(B&R) Department was accepted by a file noting dated
19.10.2005 purely as a stop gap arrangement, subject to the
condition that he could be sent back to his parent Department at
any time.
59. Thereafter, the Development and Panchayat
Department placed the services of Shri Pradeep Atri at the disposal
of the PW(B&R) Department on deputation for one year, relieving
him with immediate effect from the Development and Panchayat
Department the order dated 16.11.2005. It was mentioned
vide
therein that the terms and conditions of deputation of Shri Pradeep
113
Atri to the PW(B&R) Department would be issued separately.
Following the same, Shri Pradeep Atri joined the PW(B&R)
Department on 17.11.2005.
59.1. However, the terms and conditions of deputation of
Shri Pradeep Atri were never issued.
60. Following a regular recruitment process, Haryana
Public Service commission recommended the names of Shri Pankaj
Gaur, Shri Arun Bhatia and Shri Praveen Chaudhary among
others for appointment as Sub-Divisional Officer (Panchayati Raj)
in the Development and Panchayat Department, Government of
Haryana. Thereafter, alongwith the others, the aforesaid three
officers were appointed as Sub-Divisional Officer (Panchayati Raj)
vide the appointment letter dated 18.10.2005 issued by the
Financial Commissioner and Principal Secretary to the
Government of Haryana, Development and Panchayat Department.
In the said appointment letter, it was clearly mentioned that the
appointees including the above three officers would be on probation
for a period of two years which could be extended for a further
period not exceeding one year, if considered necessary.
61. Unlike the case of Shri Pradeep Atri, in the case of Shri
Praveen Chaudhary, just within one month of his appointment as
114
Sub-Divisional Officer (Panchayati Raj) in the Development and
Panchayat Department, the Revenue Minister, who in any case had
nothing to do either with the Panchayat Department or with the
P.W.D., wrote to the Financial Commissioner and Principal
Secretary to the Government of Haryana, Development and
Panchayat Department on 23.11.2005 stating that Shri Praveen
Chaudhary may be sent to the PW(B&R) Department on deputation
basis. Similar letter dated 23.11.2005, that is on the same day, was
also written by the Transport Minister who again had nothing to do
either with the Development and Panchayat Department or with
the PWD. This only goes to show that Shri Praveen Choudhury, an
officer of the rank of Sub-Divisional Officer in the Development and
Panchayat Department, that too on probation, had access to the
two ministers outside his Department and had approached them
for such recommendatory letters.
62. In view of such letters, the Engineer-in-Chief, PW(B&R)
Department submitted a departmental note dated 29.12.2005
stating that there was acute shortage of Sub-Divisional Engineers
in the PW(B&R) Department. Therefore, the services of Shri Praveen
Chaudhary may be taken in the PW(B&R) Department on
115
deputation basis with the condition that he could be sent back to
his parent Department at any time.
63. In the meanwhile, the Revenue Minister again
reiterated his request on 22.03.2006 for sending Shri Praveen
Chaudhary on deputation to the PW(B&R) Department.
64. It was under such circumstances that the Financial
Commissioner and Principal Secretary, Government of Haryana,
Development and Panchayat Department issued an order on
25.04.2006 placing the services of Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Sub-
Divisional Officer (Panchayati Raj) at the disposal of the PW(B&R)
Department on deputation for a period of one year. Accordingly,
Shri Praveen Chaudhary was relieved from the Development and
Panchayat Department to enable him to report to the PW(B&R)
Department. It was mentioned therein that the terms and
conditions of deputation of Shri Praveen Chaudhary would be
issued separately.
64.1. Pursuant to such order dated 25.04.2006, Shri
Praveen Chaudhary joined the PW(B&R) Department on
deputation as Sub-Divisional Engineer (Civil)/Assistant Engineer
(Civil) on 02.05.2006.
116
65. On 24.07.2006, Government of Haryana in the
PW(B&R) Department approved the deputation of Shri Praveen
Chaudhary, PW(B&R) Department. However, his deputation was
subject to the following three conditions:
1. he will have no right or claim for his absorption in the
PW(B&R) Department;
2. he will submit an undertaking to the effect that he will
not claim any benefit of absorption in the PW(B&R)
Department or file any suit/writ in any court in this
regard;
3. he can be sent back at any time to his parent
Department i.e. Panchayati Raj on receipt of the
recommendation from the Staff Selection Commission
to fill up the direct quota posts of AEs/SDEs.
65.1. Thus, it was made clear that Shri Praveen Chaudhary
upon his deputation to the PW(B&R) Department would have no
right or claim for his absorption in the said Department and in this
regard, he was required to submit an undertaking. Further, it was
clearly mentioned that Shri Praveen Chaudhary could be sent back
to his parent Department at any time upon receipt of
117
recommendation from the Staff Selection Commission for filling up
the direct quota vacancies in the said Department.
66. While Shri Pradeep Atri was still on deputation in the
PW(B&R) Department, he had participated in the regular
recruitment process which was undertaken by the Haryana Staff
Selection Commission for recruitment to the post of Assistant
Engineer (Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department pursuant to the
advertisement dated 07.05.2006. Likewise, Shri Pankaj Gaur and
Shri Arun Bhatia who were serving as Sub-Divisional Officer
(Panchayati Raj) in the Development and Panchayat Department
on probation had also applied for appointment to the post of
Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department and had
participated in the said recruitment process which was
undertaken by the Haryana Staff Selection Commission. On
13.11.2006, the list of selected candidates was published by the
Haryana Staff Selection Commission but the names of Shri
Pradeep Atri, Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia did not
appear in the select list which means that they were not selected.
We may also mention that Shri Praveen Chaudhary who was
appointed alongwith Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia as
Sub-Divisional Officer in the Development and Panchayat
118
Department did not even apply and participate in such
recruitment process.
67. The deputation case of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri
Arun Bhatia stand on a slightly different footing. It appears that on
20.04.2007, PW (B&R) Department sent a requisition for
deputation of 10 suitable and willing Sub-Divisional Engineers to
the PW (B&R) Department. It further appears that a memo dated
18.10.2007 was issued by the Financial Commissioner and
Principal Secretary to the Government of Haryana, Development
and Panchayat Department, pursuant to which the Commissioner
and Secretary to the Government of Haryana, PW (B&R)
Department issued order dated 23.11.2007 stating that the
Governor of Haryana was pleased to take the 10 Sub-Divisional
Officers (Civil) of the Development and Panchayat Department,
which included Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia, on
deputation to the PW (B&R) Department with immediate effect. A
request was made to the Financial Commissioner and Principal
Secretary to the Government of Haryana, Development and
Panchayat Department to ensure that the Sub-Divisional Officers
taken on deputation be relieved immediately to join the PW (B&R)
Department.
119
68. Pursuant to the order of deputation dated 23.11.2007,
Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia joined the borrowing
Department i.e. the PW (B&R) Department on 05.01.2008.
69. Before proceeding to the next stage i.e. the stage of
absorption of the deputationists, we may now analyse the legality
of the deputation of the above four officers.
70. Insofar Shri Pradeep Atri is concerned, just after
eight months of his appointment as a Sub-Divisional Officer in
the Development and Panchayat Department and while
undergoing the probation period, he directly made a request
to the Engineer-in-Chief of the PW (B&R) Department on
14.07.2005 seeking deputation to the said Department. As a
probationary officer serving in the Development and
Panchayat Department, Shri Atri could not have addressed
such a request letter directly to the head of another
department for taking him on deputation to such department,
by-passing his own parent Department. This is not only in
violation of service discipline but completely alien to the very
concept of deputation itself. There was no requisition from the
PW (B&R) Department seeking officers on deputation for
exigencies of public service. His own Department i.e. the
120
Development and Panchayat Department did not forward his
name for being taken on deputation in the PW (B&R)
Department. Therefore, the very initiation of the deputation
process qua Shri Pradeep Atri is in violation of the principles
governing deputation.
71. Therefore, very rightly, such request of Shri
Pradeep Atri was not considered by the PW (B&R) Department
and was accordingly ‘filed’.
72. We have already noticed above that even before
completion of one month of such ‘filing’, Shri Pradeep Atri
again made a request to the PW (B&R) Department on
12.09.2005 reiterating his request for taking him on
deputation, saying that he was ‘very keen’ to serve the PW
(B&R) Department. It was thereafter that a departmental note
came to be put up saying that there were vacancies in the
cadre of Sub-Divisional Engineer (Civil)/Assistant Engineer
(Civil) meant for direct recruitment which would take a long
time to be filled up and, therefore, the request for deputation
of Shri Atri was accepted by the PW (B&R) Department but
purely as a stop gap arrangement, subject to the condition that
he could be sent back to his parent Department at any time.
121
It is interesting to note at this stage that all this while, the
parent Department of Shri Pradeep Atri i.e. the Development
and Panchayat Department was nowhere in the picture. It was
only after acceptance of the request of Shri Pradeep Atri for
deputation by the PW (B&R) Department that the parent
Department placed the services of Shri Pradeep Atri at the
disposal of the PW (B&R) Department on deputation for a
period of one year. However, as already noted above, the terms
and conditions governing the services of Shri Pradeep Atri on
deputation was never issued.
73. Thus it is apparent that the process of deputation
of Shri Pradeep Atri was severely flawed. It was his initiative to
go on deputation whereafter the required note to justify such
deputation was put up by the borrowing Department keeping
his parent Department completely in the dark. This is no
deputation and cannot be sustained in the eye of law.
74. Coming to the case of Shri Praveen Chaudhary,
just within one month of his appointment as Sub-Divisional
Officer (Panchayat Raj) in the Development and Panchayat
Department, that too, on probation, the Revenue Minister
wrote to the Financial Commissioner and Principal Secretary
122
of the Development and Panchayat Department on 23.11.2005
that Shri Praveen Chaudhary should be sent to the PW (B&R)
Department on deputation. On the same day i.e. on
23.11.2005, similar letter was written by the Transport
Minister.
75. Both the Revenue Minister and the Transport
Minister had nothing to do either with the Panchayat
Department or with the PWD. They could not have known that
there were exigencies of public service in the PW(B&R)
Department warranting deputation, that too, of a solitary
officer. It is thus apparent that Shri Praveen Chaudhary, an
officer of the rank of Sub-Divisional Officer in the Development
and Panchayat Department, who was then on probation, had
approached the two ministers who were not his departmental
ministers and obtained recommendatory letters. This is a clear
case of service indiscipline insofar Shri Praveen Chaudhary is
concerned and could not have been countenanced. This also
reflects gross political interference.
76. Perhaps, because of such ministerial intervention,
the Engineer-in-Chief of the PW (B&R) Department put up a
departmental note on 29.12.2005 highlighting the acute
123
shortage of Sub-Divisional Engineers in the said Department
and stating that because of such shortage of officers, the
services of Shri Praveen Chaudhary could be taken in the PW
(B&R) Department on deputation, subject to the usual
condition of repatriation at any time. Even thereafter, the
Revenue Minister again reiterated his request on 23.03.2006
for sending Shri Praveen Chaudhary on deputation to the PW
(B&R) Department. It was then that services of Shri
Chaudhary was placed by the parent Department at the
disposal of the borrowing Department on deputation basis vide
the order dated 25.04.2006. Shri Praveen Chaudhary upon
being relieved by his parent Department joined the PW (B&R)
Department on deputation on 02.05.2006. While approving
the deputation of Shri Chaudhary by the Government on
24.07.2006, it was made clear that Shri Chaudhary would
have no right or claim for his absorption in the PW (B&R)
Department.
77. From the above it is evidently clear that all the
principles governing deputation were completely abandoned in
the case of Shri Praveen Chaudhary. The process for his
deputation was initiated by two ministers, obviously on being
124
approached by Shri Choudhary, who had nothing to do with
the working of either of the two departments. It is evident to
the naked eye that the need for deputation was created
subsequently by highlighting vacancies and shortage of
officers in the borrowing Department.
78. We, therefore, have no hesitation in holding that
the very deputation of Shri Pradeep Atri and Shri Praveen
Chaudhary was completely vitiated and suffered from manifest
illegality.
79. Though the deputation case of Shri Pankaj Gaur
and Shri Arun Bhatia stands on a better footing than the cases
of Shri Pradeep Atri and Shri Praveen Chaudhary inasmuch
as the move for deputation was initiated by the borrowing
Department on 20.04.2007 sending requisition for 10 Sub-
Divisional Engineers to be taken on deputation in the PW
(B&R) Department. It was thereafter that the parent
Department i.e. the Development and Panchayat Department
forwarded a list of 10 Sub-Divisional Officers (Civil), including
Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia, to the PW (B&R)
Department for being taken on deputation. Following the
same, order dated 23.11.2007 was issued by the PW (B&R)
125
Department taking the 10 Sub-Divisional Officers (Civil) of the
Development and Panchayat Department, including Shri
Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia, on deputation to the PW
(B&R) Department.
80. However, like the cases of Shri Atri and Shri
Chaudhary, in the case of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun
Bhatia also, the grounds cited to justify taking the officers on
deputation was the vacancies in the cadre of Sub-Divisional
Engineer and consequential shortage of officers affecting
official work. At this stage we may refer to Rule 6 (3) of 1965
Rules. We have already noted that as per sub-rule (1),
recruitment to the service shall be made in the ratio of 50% by
direct recruitment and 50% by way of promotion. Rule 6(3)
says that till such time the direct recruits are not available or
for a period not exceeding six months, whichever is earlier, the
Government may fill up the vacancies as a stop gap
arrangement by way of promotion from the different categories
as provided in sub-rule (1). However, it is clarified that such
promoted persons shall be liable to be repatriated to their
original cadre when direct recruits become available.
Therefore, in the face of Rule 6 (3) of the 1965 Rules, there
126
would not have been any justification for acceptance of the
four officers, who were still on probation in their parent
Department, to be taken on deputation in the PW (B&R)
Department. In fact, the State of Haryana in its counter
affidavit to CWP No.17474 of 2010 filed before the High Court,
though in the context of assignment of seniority of the four
officers, made a categorical statement that there was no need
for the four officers to have been deputed to the PW (B&R)
Department or absorbed therein (we will deal with the
absorption case in the succeeding paragraphs). It was stated
on oath before the High Court that these four officers had
landed up in the PW (B&R) Department on their own request.
81. In such circumstances, we are of the view that the
deputation of Shri Pradeep Atri and Shri Praveen Chaudhary
is clearly illegal. The deputation of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri
Arun Bhatia may not be vitiated by the blatant illegality as
noticed in the cases of Shri Atri and Shri Chaudhary, but it is
still faulty in as much as it is contrary to Rule 6(3) of the 1965
Rules. However, that by itself may not be sufficient to hold the
deputation of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia as
illegal.
127
82. We may now turn to the circumstances leading to
absorption of the four deputationists in the PW(B&R)
Department.
83. Just three months after Shri Pradeep Atri had
joined the PW(B&R) Department on deputation, he made a
request through the Engineer-in-Chief on 24.02.2006 that he
should be absorbed in the said Department. He cited the
availability of vacancies and his keenness to serve the said
Department. His request for absorption was thereafter
processed. In the meanwhile, a requisition was sent to the
Haryana Staff Selection Commission on 03.03.2006 to initiate
recruitment process for filling up 44 vacancies of Sub-
Divisional Engineer in the PW(B&R) Department which led to
issuance of the advertisement dated 07.05.2006.
84. The Joint Secretary of the Department made a file
noting on 17.04.2006 stating that Rule 10 of the 1965 Rules
permitted appointment by way of transfer under special
circumstances. Though the process for filling up vacancies
through the direct recruitment process was being initiated, it
would take some time. Therefore, he was of the view that Shri
Pradeep Atri could be absorbed in the PW(B&R) Department.
128
85. Ultimately, the Finance Commissioner conveyed to
the P.W.D. Minister on 25.09.2006 that there was no legal
impediment to the absorption of Shri Pradeep Atri in the
PW(B&R) Department. However, he pointed out that prior
approval of the Staff Selection Commission should be taken.
86. On 06.10.2006, Shri Pradeep Atri was absorbed in
the PW(B&R) Department against one of the vacancies of Sub
Divisional Engineer (Civil) under the direct recruitment quota
(arising on 01.07.2006). The absorption was however made
subject to the approval of the Haryana Public Service
Commission/Haryana Staff Selection Commission.
87. Haryana Public Service Commission vide the
communication dated 14.11.2006 approved the absorption of
Shri Pradeep Atri in the PW(B&R) Department.
88. It may be mentioned at this stage that the process
for absorption (appointment by way of transfer) of Shri Pradeep
Atri in the PW(B&R) Department was initiated by Shri Pradeep
Atri himself and not by the Department. It was Shri Atri who
tried to justify his absorption by citing large number of
vacancies and his keenness to serve the PW(B&R) Department.
129
What is also important to note is that he was absorbed
(appointed by transfer) against a direct quota vacancy.
89. Rule 9 defines direct recruitment to mean an
appointment by open competition. It specifically excludes
appointment by promotion and appointment by transfer. We
also find that Rule 6 provides for only two modes of
recruitment to the service i.e. 50 percent by direct recruitment
and 50 percent by promotion. At this stage, we may also
mention about Rule 10 which we have extracted supra. Rule
10 provides that the Government may in ‘special
circumstances’ with the approval of the Commission (Haryana
Public Service Commission), appoint an officer to the service
by transfer. Thus, Rule 10 provides that in ‘special
circumstances’, the Government may appoint an officer to the
service by way of transfer with the approval of the
Commission. Such an appointment i.e. appointment by
transfer is not a regular mode of appointment envisaged under
the 1965 Rules. We say this because Rule 6 provides for only
two modes of recruitment i.e. by direct recruitment and by
promotion, both in the ratio of 50 percent. Therefore, there is
no place where an officer appointed by way of transfer can be
130
accommodated while considering that 100 percent of the
vacancies are to be filled up only by direct recruitment and
promotion (50 percent each). Rule 2(9) and Rule 9 rule out
appointment by transfer within the ambit of direct
recruitment. In such circumstances, Shri Pradeep Atri could
not have been appointed by way of transfer against a vacancy
earmarked for direct recruitment. But one of the conditions
imposed in the absorption order of Shri Pradeep Atri was that
he would be absorbed against one of the resultant vacancies
of direct recruitment quota arising on 01.07.2006 due to
retirement of senior officers which is clearly contrary to Rule
2(9) and Rule 9 of the 1965 Rules.
90. We refrain from entering into any analysis of Rule
12 because at this stage we are not discussing seniority. We
are only discussing the scope of an appointment by transfer
and the justification for it in terms of Rule 10.
91. Though learned senior counsel appearing for Shri
Pradeep Atri, Shri Patwalia vehemently argued that acute
shortage of Sub-Divisional Engineers (Civil) in the Department
with there being stay on fresh recruitment due to pending
litigation with the resultant hampering of official work due to
131
shortage of Sub-Divisional Engineers created ‘special
circumstances’ within the meaning of Rule 10 of the 1965
Rules which clearly justified the absorption of Shri Pradeep
Atri (appointment by transfer), we are not impressed by such
a contention as the process was already underway for filling
up of 44 vacancies of Sub-Divisional Engineer in the PW(B&R)
Department. Any exigency could have been met by resorting to
Rule 6(3) of the 1965 Rules. As regards stay on fresh
recruitment in the pending litigation, we may mention that it
was an undertaking given by the State before the High Court
that the Government would not make recruitment from the
select list during pendency of the litigation. We are afraid these
factors would not create ‘special circumstances’ to warrant
absorption by invoking Rule 10. Reliance placed on the
decision of this Court in K.S. Brar, in our view, is also of no
avail.
91.1. In K.S. Brar , challenge was made to the
appointment of respondent No. 4 as Assistant Engineer under
Rule 10 of the 1965 Rules as the order of appointment by
transfer did not refer to any ‘special circumstance’. However,
this Court did not go into the question as to whether such an
132
appointment could be said to be invalid or irregular merely
because no ‘special circumstance’ was recited in the order as
the challenge to the order appointing respondent No. 4 by
transfer was specifically given up by the petitioner. This Court
proceeded to examine the question of seniority in which
context it said that for determining seniority, what one has to
see is not Rule 10 but Rule 12(5) of the 1965 Rules.
92. ‘Special circumstances’ in our understanding
means something which is more than normal or routine.
Accrual of vacancies in a cadre is a routine phenomenon; this
is not something which is unusual or abnormal. The so-called
stay was not granted by the High Court but was a statement
made by the State before the High Court. These circumstances
cannot be termed as special within the meaning of Rule 10.
We will analyse ‘special circumstances’ more in detail a little
later. Therefore, the absorption of Shri Pradeep Atri in the
PW(B&R) Department, styled as appointment by transfer, is
contrary to Rule 10 of the 1965 Rules and cannot be
sustained. Considering the manner in which Shri Atri came on
deputation to the PW(B&R) Department and thereafter came
to be absorbed is a clear case of backdoor entry. We may also
133
mention that neither did Shri Pradeep Atri satisfactorily
complete his probation in his parent Department i.e. in the
Development and Panchayat Department nor could he
complete such probation upon deputation before absorption
in the PW(B&R) Department. Without satisfactorily completing
his probation period, he successfully managed to get himself
absorbed in the PW(B&R) Department. At this stage, it may be
pointed out that in the recruitment process, which was
undertaken by the Haryana Staff Selection Commission on the
requisition of the PW(B&R) Department for direct recruitment
to the post of Sub-Divisional Engineer (Civil)/Assistant
Engineer (Civil) pursuant to the advertisement dated
07.05.2006, Shri Pradeep Atri had participated but was
unsuccessful; he did not qualify. After he had failed in the
direct recruitment process, he managed to get appointment in
the same post in the said Department by such absorption,
thus achieving indirectly what he could not achieve directly.
93. In such circumstances, we have no hesitation to
hold that there were no ‘special circumstances’ for invoking
Rule 10 of the 1965 Rules and appointing Shri Pradeep Atri in
the PW(B&R) Department by transfer (by way of absorption).
134
His absorption in the PW(B&R) Department is contrary to the
1965 Rules and is thus illegal and untenable.
94. Let us now take the case of Shri Praveen
Chaudhary. We have already noted supra that Shri Praveen
Chaudhary, a probationer in the Development and Panchayat
Department, had initiated the move for his deputation to the
PW(B&R) Department within one month of his appointment in
the aforesaid Department as a Sub-Divisional Officer
(Panchayati Raj) through the Revenue Minister and the
Transport Minister. Ultimately, he was sent on deputation to
the PW(B&R) Department pursuant to which he joined the said
Department on deputation on 02.05.2006. On the very next
day of joining on deputation i.e. on 03.05.2006, the same
Transport Minister who had initiated the process for sending
Shri Praveen Chaudhary on deputation this time wrote to the
Chief Minister with the request that Shri Praveen Chaudhary
should be permanently absorbed in the PW(B&R) Department
against a vacant post of direct recruitment quota. As the
proposal was processed, the Financial Commissioner and
Principal Secretary, PW(B&R) Department in his letter dated
24.07.2006 referred to the deputation order of Shri Praveen
135
Chaudhary and pointed out that such deputation was
conditional upon Shri Choudhary not having any right or not
making any claim to absorption in the PW(B&R) Department.
However, in his note to the P.W.D. Minister dated 25.09.2006,
the Financial Commissioner pointed out that like Shri Pradeep
Atri, Shri Praveen Chaudhary could also make a request for
his permanent absorption in the PW(B&R) Department. It was
only thereafter that Shri Praveen Chaudhary formally made a
request to his parent Department on 11.10.2006 seeking no
objection to his absorption in the PW(B&R) Department.
95. We have already noted that pursuant to the
requisition made by the PW(B&R) Department, advertisement
dated 07.05.2006 was issued for filling up 44 vacancies in the
post of Sub-Divisional Engineer (Civil)/Assistant Engineer
(Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department. Shri Praveen Chaudhary
did not even apply and participate in such recruitment
process.
96. In the meanwhile, the MLA of Bahadurgarh
Constituency wrote to the Chief Minister on 19.03.2007
seeking absorption of Shri Praveen Chaudhary in the PW(B&R)
136
Department against a direct recruit quota citing the example
of Shri Pradeep Atri.
97. Ultimately, vide order dated 18.07.2007 issued by
the Commissioner and Secretary, PW(B&R) Department, Shri
Praveen Chaudhary was absorbed in the said Department
against a vacancy earmarked for direct recruits.
98. The same illegalities as are discernible in the case
of Shri Pradeep Atri have also vitiated the absorption of Shri
Praveen Chaudhary, termed as appointment by transfer.
Additionally, political influence and interference in the case of
Shri Praveen Chaudhary is writ large. Just like his deputation
was initiated by the Revenue Minister and Transport Minister,
within one day of him joining the PW(B&R) Department on
deputation, the Transport Minister initiated the process of
absorption. It was left to the Financial Commissioner and
Special Secretary to point out to the P.W.D. Minister that Shri
Praveen Chaudhary could also make a request for permanent
absorption in the PW(B&R) Department. Therefore, in addition
to the flaws which have vitiated the absorption of Shri Pradeep
Atri, absorption of Shri Praveen Chaudhary is further vitiated
by unwarranted political influence and interference. Though
137
Shri Nidhesh Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for Shri
Praveen Chaudhary vehemently argued that ‘special
circumstances’ did exist warranting absorption of Shri
Praveen Chaudhary which was endorsed by the State, we are
not inclined to accept such a contention for the reasons cited
supra. We are of the view that shortage of officers in a
department cannot be construed to be a ‘special circumstance’
within the meaning of Rule 10 of the 1965 Rules.
99. Therefore, for the aforesaid reasons, absorption of
Shri Praveen Chaudhary in the PW(B&R) Department, termed
as appointment by transfer, is wholly illegal and cannot be
sustained.
100. In so far Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia
are concerned, they had joined the PW(B&R) Department on
deputation on 05.01.2008. Just one month after joining the
said Department on deputation, Shri Pankaj Gaur submitted
a representation dated 16.02.2008 before the Commissioner
and Secretary of the said Department with the request that he
should be absorbed in the PW(B&R) Department citing the
examples of Shri Pradeep Atri and Shri Praveen Chaudhary.
Interestingly, such representation of Shri Gaur was
138
recommended by Shri Naresh Kumar, MLA of Badli
Constituency. Likewise, Shri Arun Bhatia also submitted a
representation before the Financial Commissioner and
Principal Secretary, PW(B&R) Department on 07.03.2008
seeking his permanent absorption in the said Department.
101. When the process was initiated by the PW(B&R)
Department on the request of the aforesaid two officers for
their permanent absorption, the MLA of Narnaul constituency
also made a request to the P.W.D Minister on 17.03.2008
seeking permanent absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur.
102. It was clearly pointed out at the departmental level
that such kind of request should not be entertained. Moreover,
it was pointed out that already requisition was sent to the
Haryana Staff Selection Commission for recruitment to the
vacant posts of Assistant Engineer (Civil) pertaining to the
direct recruitment quota. It was highlighted that there was no
justification for such absorption.
103. Out of the blue, the Departmental Minister put up
a note on 05.06.2008 stating that Shri Arun Bhatia who was
on deputation to the PW(B&R) Department was performing
satisfactorily. Therefore, his case for absorption should be
139
considered. It is evident that the minister would not have
issued such a letter unless approached. This is thus not only
an instance of undue political interference but service
indiscipline as well.
104. It was however pointed out by the Engineer-in-
Chief of the PW(B&R) Department on 29.07.2008 that
acceding to such a request will increase litigation and also
result in demoralisation of the recruited staff. Therefore, he
categorically stated that such request for absorption should be
rejected.
105. Notwithstanding such a clear view and categorical
stand of the Engineer-in-Chief, the Financial Commissioner
and Principal Secretary put up a note on 21.08.2008 to the
effect that Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia are M.Techs
and that there should be no issue in absorbing them in the
PW(B&R) Department. He expressed the concern that if these
two officers were repatriated, they would be the juniormost in
their parent Department. It appears that the Engineer-in-Chief
was ‘persuaded’ to accept such a line of reasoning of the
Financial Commissioner and Principal Secretary in the
140
discussions stated to have been held in the morning of
21.08.2008.
106. Such grounds advanced by the Financial
Commissioner and Principal Secretary that both Shri Pankaj
Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia were M.Tech. degree holders and
if they were repatriated back to their parent Department, they
would be the juniormost, found favour with the PWD Minister,
who already had recommended absorption of Shri Arun
Bhatia, and led to absorption of the above two officers. In the
meanwhile, the MLA of Mahendergarh Constituency who also
happened to be the Parliamentary Secretary, In Charge of
Transport Department, made a request on 17.02.2009 for the
absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur.
107. As noticed above, ‘the special circumstances’ in
terms of Rule 10 of the 1965 Rules which were highlighted to
justify absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia
were:
(i) both are M.Tech. degree holders;
(ii) both were recruited through a proper process by the
Haryana Staff Selection Commission; and
141
(iii) they had spent time in the PW(B&R) Department
and they were found to be good in their work.
108. ‘Special circumstances’ is not a defined expression
in so far as the 1965 Rules are concerned. Therefore, we have
to fall back upon the popular parlance test. In paragraph 92
above, we have already stated that ‘special circumstances’
would mean something which is more than normal or routine.
th
P. Ramanatha Aiyar’s Advanced Law Lexicon, 6 Edition,
defines ‘special’ to mean designed for a particular purpose;
exceptional in character, quality or degree; appointed or
employed for a particular purpose or occasion, relating to a
single thing. Concise Oxford Dictionary has explained the
word ‘special’ to mean out of the ordinary, peculiar or specific
and not general.
109. What Rule 10 of the 1965 Rules therefore
contemplates is that an appointment by transfer is to meet a
special situation, may be an exigency of public service which
cannot wait an appointment by direct recruitment or an
appointment by way of promotion, the only two modes of
regular recruitment as contemplated under Rule 6(1) of the
1965 Rules which would be time consuming. It may so
142
happen that for a particular project, specialised hands or a
person or persons with certain specific qualifications or talent
or skill are required. Rule 10 is meant for such an exigency
and in the process to overcome the barrier posed by Rule 6
whereby 100 percent of the vacancies are to be filled up either
by direct recruitment or by promotion (50 percent each,
making up the entirety of 100 percent).
110. Various authorities had also understood the
concept of ‘special circumstances’ as we have analysed
hereinabove. Infact, when its approval was sought for on the
proposal for absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun
Bhatia, the initial response of the Haryana Public Service
Commission as can be deciphered from its letter dated
07.07.2009 was that the materials on record did not reveal the
existence of any ‘special circumstances’ that would justify
absorption of the aforesaid two officers.
110.1. When it came to the absorption of Shri Pradeep
Atri, the Special Secretary, PW(B&R) Department was quite
emphatic in his views as expressed in his communication
dated 17.08.2010 stating that it was illegal as no ‘special
143
circumstances’ existed for such absorption. According to him,
the mere fact that there was an acute shortage of officers in
the Department was no ground to absorb Shri Atri. Observing
that the Government could be accused of making back-door
appointment while absorbing Shri Atri which could attain
scandalous proportions, he proposed repatriation of Shri
Pradeep Atri to his parent Department.
110.2. The Financial Commissioner and Principal Secretary,
PW(B&R) Department also described the deputation and
absorption of Shri Pradeep Atri, as a back door entry because
Shri Atri could not clear the direct recruit examination for the
post of Assistant Engineer (Civil) but by the aforesaid method
he got appointed to the very same post of Assistant Engineer
(Civil) by transfer.
110.3. The Special Secretary-cum-Chief Vigilance Officer
also observed that there were no exceptional circumstances
justifying absorption of the four deputationists. Therefore, he
advised that these four officers should be repatriated to their
parent Department.
111. Ultimately, upon approval of the Haryana Public
Service Commission, the Government of Haryana, PW(B&R)
144
Department issued order dated 23.10.2009 absorbing Shri
Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia in the PW(B&R)
Department making it clear that their appointment on transfer
was against vacancies of the direct recruits.
112. The illegalities which have vitiated the absorption
of Shri Pradeep Atri and Shri Praveen Chaudhary are also
clearly visible in the case of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun
Bhatia. Political influence is clearly manifest in the process of
absorption, more particularly in the case of Shri Pankaj Gaur.
Even in the case of Shri Arun Bhatia, the departmental
Minister had intervened endorsing his request for absorption
on the ground that he was performing his duties satisfactorily.
The Minister concerned would not have had any occasion to
make such an endorsement, that too, for a lowly ranked officer
in the rank of Assistant Engineer which is quite low in the
hierarchy unless he was approached. This is not only violative
of service discipline but smacks of political hobnobbing. Such
kind of blatant political interference and favouritism cannot be
countenanced. Merely because the two officers were M.Tech.
degree holders and they were performing well and would be
the juniormost if repatriated to their parent Department
145
cannot constitute ‘special circumstances’ within the meaning
of Rule 10 to justify their appointment by transfer.
113. We are, therefore, of the view that the High Court
is justified in holding that absorption of Shri Pankaj Gaur and
Shri Arun Bhatia in the PW(B&R) Department is illegal being
contrary to Rule 10 of the 1965 rules. Further, the High Court
is fully justified in holding that the absorption of Shri Pradeep
Atri, Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri
Arun Bhatia in the PW(B&R) Department is the product of
political machination by them, rendering the same invalid in
law.
114. Though the High Court held the deputation and
absorption of Shri Pradeep Atri, Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Shri
Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia as bad in law, yet it did not
repatriate them to their parent Department on the ground that
they did not have any lien on their parent Department. High
Court also did not terminate their services on the ground that
they had rendered service for more than 18 years since 2005
and terminating their service at this stage would result in their
hardship. Therefore, taking a sympathetic view, the High
Court did not disturb their deputation and absorption as
146
Assistant Engineer (Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department but did
not grant them the seniority assigned to them by the
Government. The High Court held as under:
Though we are of the opinion that the very deputation
and absorption of the private respondents in PWD (B&R)
Department as Asst. Engineers is bad in law, it is brought
to our notice that they do not have lien in their parent
department i.e. the PR Department.
Therefore, in the normal course we would have had to
direct their termination from service.
But since they had been in service since 2005, they
would suffer hardship if their services are terminated now,
18 years later.
Therefore taking a sympathetic view, we are not
inclined to disturb their deputation and absorption as
Asst. Engineers in PWD (B&R) Department at this stage,
but they will not be allowed to have seniority contrary to
the main part of Rule 12(5) or the conditions of their
absorption i.e. they cannot be seniors to direct recruits
appointed on 07.12.2007 or in 2009 /persons promoted
against vacancies which arose before 1.7.2006 or in 2009
in the cadre of Asst. Engineers in PWD (B&R) Department.
115. We are afraid the High Court fell in grave error in
allowing the aforesaid four officers to continue their services
in the PW(B&R) Department even after declaring their
deputation and absorption as illegal and bad in law. Illegality
147
means something which is contrary to law; something which
is wrong right from the inception. It is void ab initio . Illegality
cannot be cured and made legal and valid by lapse of time.
Illegality, which is distinct and different from irregularity,
cannot be regularized by taking a sympathetic view on the
ground of long continuance in service. This position has been
explained by a Constitution Bench of this Court in Uma Devi .
If the appointment itself is in infraction of the rules, in this
case the 1965 Rules, it is an illegality. Such an illegality cannot
be cured by resorting to the novel method of absorption which
has been explained as appointment by transfer.
115.1. In so far extinguishment of lien in the parent
Department is concerned, it is no doubt true that when an
employee becomes permanent in another service, his lien in
the past service would stand extinguished. Analysing the
concept of lien , a two-Judge Bench of this Court in Ramlal
21
Khurana Vs. State of Punjab explained that lien is not a word
of art; it just connotes the right of a civil servant to hold the
post substantively to which he is appointed. Generally, when
a person with against a post is appointed substantively to
lien
21
(1989) 4 SCC 99
148
another post, he acquires a lien against the latter post. Then
the lien against his previous post automatically disappears;
the principle being that no Government servant can
simultaneously have two liens against two posts in two
different cadres. Therefore, if the deputation and absorption of
the above four officers are terminated, being illegal, and they
are directed to be repatriated back, then their lien against the
substantive posts held by them in their parent Department
would stand revived.
Conclusions
116. Reverting back to the questions framed in
paragraph 44 supra, in so far question (i) is concerned, we are
of the opinion that the deputation of Shri Pradeep Atri and
Shri Praveen Choudhury is illegal whereas the deputation of
Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia is irregular. Question
(ii) is answered entirely in the negative as we are of the
unhesitant view that the absorption of all the above four
deputationists as Assistant Engineer (Civil) /Sub-Divisional
Engineer (Civil) in the PW(B&R) Department is illegal and void.
Since we are holding their absorption as illegal and void and
are directing their repatriation, it is not necessary to delve into
149
question (iii) to examine their seniority on an analysis of Rule
12(5) of the 1965 Rules.
117. Thus, having regard to the discussions made
hereinabove, we hold and declare that the deputation of Shri
Pradeep Atri and Shri Praveen Choudhury is illegal whereas
the deputation of Shri Pankaj Gaur and Shri Arun Bhatia is
irregular. We further hold and declare that the absorption of
Shri Pradeep Atri, Shri Praveen Chaudhary, Shri Pankaj Gaur
and Shri Arun Bhatia in the PW(B&R) Department is illegal,
non est and void. The same is accordingly set aside and
quashed. Consequently, their continuance in the PW(B&R)
Department on deputation has become wholly untenable. The
above four officers are therefore directed to be repatriated back
to the Development and Panchayat Department, Government
of Haryana where their cadre and seniority will be determined
by the authority of the said Department placing them
immediately above the candidates who were junior to them in
order of seniority in the cadre of Sub-Divisional Officer
(Panchayati Raj).
118. In view of the above, the decision of the High Court
vide the impugned judgment and order dated 15.03.2023 not
150
to disturb the services of the aforesaid four officers in the
PW(B&R) Department is hereby set aside. Consequential
directions from Serial No. 4 onwards are accordingly set aside.
119. All the civil appeals are disposed of in the aforesaid
terms.
……………………………J.
[MANOJ MISRA]
……………………………J.
[UJJAL BHUYAN]
NEW DELHI;
AUGUST 18, 2026.
151