SATYAJIT MANDAL vs HOUSING AND URBAN AFFAIRS
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench: New Delhi
O.A. No.3502/2025
M.A. No.2498/2026
th
This the 28 day of October, 2026
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjit More, Chairman
Hon’ble Dr. Anand S. Khati, Member (A)
SATYAJIT MANDAL [Retd.]
Executive Engineer (Elect.),
Central Public Works Department,
Aged about 64 years,
S/o Sh. Naran Chandra Mandal,
R/o Flat No. 4303, Ashoka Enclave, Plot 8A,
Sector-11, Dwarka, Delhi – 110075.
…Applicant
(By Advocate: Mr. Rohan Taneja)
Versus
1. UNION OF INDIA
Through its Secretary,
Ministry of Housing & Urban Affairs,
Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi – 110011.
2. CENTRAL PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
Through its Director General,
Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi – 110011.
…Respondents
(By Advocate: Mr. Jalaj Agarwal)
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV
2
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
ORDER (ORAL)
Per: Justice Ranjit More, Chairman:
Since the pleadings are complete, with the consent of
learned counsel for the respective parties, the present O.A.
has been heard at the admission stage itself.
2. The applicant joined the office of respondent No. 2 in
the year 1984 as a Junior Engineer (Elect.). He
subsequently served as an Executive Engineer (Elect.) and
retired from service on 31.08.2021.
3. On 05.06.2025, the Vigilance Unit of respondent No. 2
issued a memorandum calling upon the applicant to
submit his response regarding the alleged lapses
committed by him in the execution of work under
Agreement No. 11/E/CBMB M-33/2020-2021. The
applicant submitted his reply to the said memorandum on
24.06.2025, followed by a supplementary reply dated
10.07.2025.
4. Thereafter, upon obtaining the sanction of the Hon’ble
President on 27.08.2025, the respondents issued the
Memorandum of Charge dated 27.08.2025 against the
applicant.
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV
3
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
5. Aggrieved by the issuance of the Memorandum of
Charge and the Presidential Order dated 27.08.2025, the
applicant has approached this Tribunal seeking the
following reliefs:
“A. Quash the Memorandum of Charge dated 27.08.2025
bearing F. No. 10/V-21/(A-26)/2023-VS.1 (Part-3);
B. Quash the Presidential Order dated 27.08.2025 bearing F.
No. 10/V-21/(A-26)/2023-VS.1 (Part-3);
C. Quash all consequential proceedings emanating out of the
Memorandum of Charge dated 27.08.2025 bearing F. No.
10/V-21/(A-26)/2023-VS.1 (Part-3);
D. Grant all consequential benefits to the Applicant along with
compensatory interest”
6. Mr. Taneja, learned counsel for the applicant, submits
that, in similar circumstances, this Tribunal, vide order
dated 09.04.2026 passed in O.A. No. 4057/2024 and
connected matter, has dealt with the issue in question.
7. In support of the claim of the applicant, the learned
counsel for the applicant has argued that in the relevant
sanction order of the President of India, the disciplinary
authority/the authority by which the departmental
proceedings shall be conducted has not been
mentioned/named nor the place of proposed inquiry has
been mentioned. Learned counsel submits that as the
name of the disciplinary authority has not been disclosed,
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV
4
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
it is in violation of Rule(2)(c)(iii) of the CCS (Pension) Rules,
2021 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Rules’). In support of
his arguments, he has placed reliance on the law laid down
by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Sunny Abraham
Versus Union of India reported in (2021) 20 SCC 12, the
judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in the case of
Union of India Versus Ritu Chaudhary reported in 2019
SCC OnLine Del 12063, judgment of this Bench of the
Tribunal in O.A. No. 2465/2021 tiled Harish Chander Pal
Versus ESIC And Anr. dated 05.12.2025 and the judgment
of the Hon’ble High Court of Calcutta in Dr. Sunirmal
Sarkar Versus Union of India and Ors. dated 08.05.2023
reported in 2023 SCC OnLine Cal 3702.
8. On the other hand, Mr. Jalaj Aggarwal, learned
counsel for the respondents has vehemently opposed the
claim of the applicant. He has argued that the relevant
format of sanction categorically mentions that the
disciplinary authority shall be appointed as per Rule 14 (5)
of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, and accordingly, the
proceedings shall be concluded in accordance with the
relevant provisions of the CCS (CCA) Rules.
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV
5
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
9. We have considered the submissions made by the
learned counsels for the parties and we have also gone
through the pleadings available on record.
10. Rule 8(2)(c)(i) and (iii) of the Rules read as under:-
“8(2)(c) The departmental proceedings, if not instituted while
the Government servant was in service, whether before his
retirement, or during his re-employment, -
(i) shall not be instituted save with the sanction of the
President in Format 2;
(ii) shall not be in respect of any event which took place more
than four years before such institution; and
(iii) shall be conducted by such authority and in such place as
the President may direct and in accordance with the procedure
applicable to departmental proceedings in which an order of
dismissal from service could be made in relation to the
Government servant during his service:
Provided that for the purpose of instituting departmental
proceedings under this sub-rule, a memorandum of charges
shall be communicated to the pensioner concerned in Format
3.”
11. On bare perusal of the aforesaid provision of Rule
8(2)(c)(i), it is apparent that if departmental proceeding is
instituted while the government servant was not in service,
the same shall not be instituted without the sanction of the
competent authority to pass the order under Sub Rule 1 in
format 2.
12. In terms of provisions of Rule 8(2)(c)(iii), a
memorandum of charges shall be communicated to the
pensioner concerned in format 3.
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV
6
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
13. For the sake of clarity, format 2 and format 3 referred
to in the aforesaid Rules are reproduced as under:-
“Format 2 of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules,
2021 reads as follows:
"FORMAT 2
(See Rule 8)
Sanction for instituting departmental proceedings after
retirement
No............................
Government of India
Ministry/Department of..............................
Dated the..................................................
ORDER
WHEREAS it has been made to appear that Shri/Smt./Km
..............................................while serving as......................in
the Ministry/ Department...........................from ............. .......
........to...............................was .........................(here specify
briefly the imputations of misconduct or misbehavior in respect
of which it is proposed to institute departmental proceedings):
NOW, THEREFORE, in exercise of the powers conferred on him
by sub-clause (i) of clause (c) of sub-rule (2) of Rule 8 of the
Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 2021, the President
hereby accords sanction for institution of the departmental
proceedings against the said Shri/Smt./Km
....................................
The President further directs that the said departmental
proceedings shall be conducted in accordance with the
procedure laid down in Rules 14 and 15 of the Central Civil
Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965, by
...............................(here specify the authority by whom the
departmental proceedings should be conducted) at
.......................... (here specify the place at which the
departmental proceedings would be conducted).
By order and in the name of the President*
---------------------------------
(Name and designation of the competent authority)*
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV
7
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
* To be signed by an officer in the appropriate
Ministry/Department authorized under Article 77 (2) of the
Constitution to authenticate orders on behalf of the President.
No...............
Copy forwarded to Shri/Smt./Km............................................
Copy also forwarded to Shri/Smt.Km......................................"
Format 3 of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules,
2021 reads as follows:
"FORMAT 3
(See Rule 8)
Memorandum for instituting departmental proceedings after
retirement
No............................
Government of India Ministry of ...............
Department of..............................
Dated the..................................................
MEMORANDUM
In pursuance of the sanction accorded by the President under
Rule 8 of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 2021, for
instituting departmental proceedings against
Shri/Smt./Km............................, vide Ministry/Department
of.............................Order No.....................................,
dated,.................................it is proposed to hold an inquiry
against the said Shri/Smt./Km....................... in accordance
with the procedure laid down in Rules 14 and 15 of the Central
Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965.
The enquiry shall be conducted by...............................(here
specify the authority by whom the departmental proceedings
are to be conducted in accordance with the Presidential
sanction) at ................................ (here specify the name of the
place where proceedings are to be conducted). 2. The
substance of the imputations of misconduct or misbehavior in
respect of which the inquiry is proposed to be held is set out in
the enclosed statement of articles of charge (Annexure I). A
statement of the imputations of misconduct or misbehaviour in
support of each article of charge is enclosed (Annexure II). A
list of documents by which, and a list of witnesses by whom,
the articles of charge are proposed to be sustained are also
enclosed (Annexures III and IV).
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV
8
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
3. Shri/Smt./Km...............................is directed to submit
within 10 days of the receipt of this Memorandum a written
statement of his/her defence and also to state whether he/she
desires to be heard in person.
4. He/she is informed that an inquiry will be held only in
respect of those articles of charge as are not admitted. He/she
should, therefore, specifically admit or deny each article of
charge.
5. Shri/Smt./Km. .......................................is further informed
that if he /she does not submit his/her written statement of
defence on or before the date specified in para 3 above, or does
not appear in person before the inquiring authority or
otherwise fails or refuses to comply with the provisions of Rules
14 and 15 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, or the
orders/directions issued in pursuance of the said Rules, the
inquiring authority may hold the inquiry against him/her ex
parte.
6. The receipt of this Memorandum may be acknowledged.
By order and in the name of the President
--------------------------------------------
(Name and designation of the competent authority)*
* To be signed by an officer in the appropriate
Ministry/Department authorized under Article 77 (2) of the
Constitution to authenticate orders on behalf of the President.
OR
----------------------------------------
(Name and designation of the authority which has been
directed by the President to conduct the departmental
proceedings)
To Shri/Smt./Km.............................................
.....................................
ANNEXURE - I
Statement of articles of charge framed against
Shri/Smt./Km.................................................. (name of the
retired Government servant) formerly.......................................
Article - I
That the said Shri/Smt./Km.............................................while
functioning as ........................ ................ during the
period....................
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV
9
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
Article - II
That during the aforesaid period and while functioning in the
aforesaid office, the said Shri/Smt./Km....................................
Article - III
That during the aforesaid period and while functioning in the
aforesaid office, the said Shri/Smt./Km..................................
ANNEXURE – II
Statement of imputations of misconduct or misbehaviour in
support of the articles of charge framed against
Shri/Smt./Km.................... (name of the retired Government
servant) formerly......................................
Article I
Article II
Article - III
ANNEXURE - III
List of documents by which the articles of charge framed
against Shri/Smt./Km. .........................................(name of
retired Government servant) formerly...............................are
proposed to be sustained.
ANNEXURE - IV
List of Witnesses by whom the articles of charge framed against
Shri/Smt./Km. .............................. (name of the retired
Government servant) formerly........................................are
proposed to be sustained.”
14. The impugned memorandum dated 27.08.2025 reads
as follows:
“In pursuance of the sanction accorded by the President under
Rule 8 of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 2021, for
instituting departmental proceedings against Shri Satyajit
Mandal Executive Engineer (E) retired, PWD (PIMS ID:
SMA10081961JEEL011984) vide Ministry’s Order of 10/V-
21/(A-26)/2023/VS.I (Part-3), dated 27/08/2025, it is
proposed to hold an inquiry against the said Shri Satyajit
Mandal Executive Engineer (E) retired PWD in accordance with
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV
10
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
the procedure laid down in Rules 14 and 15 of the CCS (CCA)
Rules, 1965. The inquiry shall be conducted at New Delhi.
2. The substance of the imputation of misconduct in respect of
which the inquiry is proposed to be held is set out in the
enclosed statement of article of charge (Annexure-I). A
statement of imputation of misconduct is enclosed (Annexure-
II). A list of documents by which, and a list of witnesses by
whom, the articles of charge are proposed to be sustained are
also enclosed (Annexure-III & IV).
3. Shri Satyajit Mandal Executive Engineer (E) retired, PWD is
directed to submit within 15 days of the receipt of this
Memorandum a written statement of his defence and also to
state whether he desires to be heard in person.
4. He is informed that an inquiry will be held only in respect of
those articles of charge as are not admitted. He should,
therefore, specifically admit or deny each article of charge.
5. Shri Satyajit Mandal Executive Engineer (E) retired, PWD is
further informed that if he does not submit his written
statement of defence on or before the date specified in para 3
above, or does not appear in person before the inquiry
authority or otherwise fails or refuses to comply with the
provisions of Rules 14 & 15 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, or
the orders/directions issued in pursuance of the said Rules,
the inquiry authority may hold the inquiry against him ex-
parte.
6. A copy of Central Vigilance Commission advice contained in
OM No. 2024/W&H/CPWD/VIG_CASE/16 dated 19.08.2025 is
enclosed herewith.
7. The receipt of this memorandum may be acknowledged.”
15. The sanction referred to the impugned charge
memorandum (Annexure A-2 Page 325) reads as follows:
“WHEREAS, it has been made to appear that Shri Satyajit
Mandal, Executive Engineer (E), retired, while serving as
Executive Engineer (E) DHC&ND, PWD Delhi (PIMS ID:
SMA10081961JEEL011984), in the Public Works Department,
GNCTD, Delhi from 15.1.2018 to 31.08.2021 committed
irregularities in execution of work beyond the yardstick and
proposing the execution of extra item.
NOW, THEREFORE, in exercise of the powers conferred on him
by sub-clause (i) of Clause (c) of sub-rule (2) of Rule 8 of the
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV
11
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 2021, the President
hereby accords sanction to the departmental proceedings
against the said Shri Satyajit Mandal, Executive Engineer (E)
retired.
The President further directs that said departmental
proceedings shall be conducted in accordance with the
procedure laid down in Rules 14 and 15 of the CCS (CCA)
Rules, 1965 at New Delhi.”
16. On perusal of the impugned memorandum and the
sanction, it is apparent that the same are not in
consonance with the format/form 2 and 3 as mandated
under the provisions of Rule 8(2)(c)(i) and (iii) above.
17. The Hon’ble High Court of Calcutta in the case of
Sunirmal Sarkar (Supra) has ruled in para 55 as under:-
“55. The moment the CCS Pension Rule was framed in exercise
of power under Article 309 of the Constitution, the provisions
thereunder had acquired and received a flavor with a statutory
sanction. When such statute envisaged a specific provision,
any action taken in exercise of such provision must be taken
strictly in adherence thereto and not in any other mode
whatsoever and any action taken in any mode without
compliance of such specific statutory provision would be
expressly forbidden in law. Accordingly, any action taken
without compliance of specific provisions of the said Rule,
would be vitiated in law and wholly without jurisdiction. The
moment a statutory provision is engrafted in terms of Article
309, the same cannot be treated merely as subjected to an
executive function of the President under Article 77 of the
Constitution of India but would be an exercise under a specific
statute.”
18. The initiation of proceedings against a retired person
came before this Tribunal for consideration in the case of
Harish (supra) and the Tribunal, while allowing the O.A., in
paras 13 and 14 has ruled as under:-
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV
12
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
“13. There is nothing on record to suggest that the sanction for
instituting departmental proceedings after retirement of the
applicant was according to the format as mentioned in para 8
above. Further in the order dated 05.10.2021 it has been
stated that in the 216th meeting held on 04.10.2019 Standing
Committee approved the modalities for conducting disciplinary
proceedings under Rule 9 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, in which
it was mentioned that the sanctions of the Chairman, Standing
Committee shall be obtained for initiation of the Departmental
Proceedings against the charged official. The issue of delegation
of power of the Central Government to the Chairman has been
adjudicated in OA No. 378/2022 (supra) wherein in para 23 of
the said order as mentioned in para 11 above, the Standing
Committee has never taken approval of the Central
Government and, therefore, in view of the judgments of the
Hon'ble Apex Court, referred to hereinabove, the delegation
being claimed in favour of the Director General, ESIC or the
Chairman of the ESIC is no delegation in the eyes of law. Thus,
in view of the aforesaid facts, Regulation, Law and discussion,
we are of the view that the impugned order deserve to be
quashed and set aside. Even if for the sake of argument we
accept that the power of the Hon’ble President of India to
initiate departmental proceedings after retirement has been
validly delegated to the Chairman, Standing Committee (which
was held to be not delegated) how such a decision taken on
04.10.2019 shall be made applicable retrospectively to the
applicant who retired on 30.04.2017. In other words, when the
applicant retired on 30.04.2017, how can the decision dated
04.10.2019 be applicable in the case of the applicant?
14. In view of the decisions of this Tribunal and the decision of
the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in this matter and also in view
of the statutory position laid down to seek sanction of the
competent authority to institute departmental proceedings after
retirement and the procedure to be followed to seek such
sanction has not been followed in this matter. The OA deserves
to be allowed.”
19. Furthermore, from all the aforesaid Rules and also in
view of the settled law that where statute requires certain
things to be done in a certain way, those things must be
done in that way or not all. The other methods of
performance are necessarily forbidden. We draw support in
this regard from the law settled by the Hon’ble Apex Court
in the case of A.R. Antulay vs. Ramdas Sriniwas Nayan
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV
13
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
& Anr. reported in (1984) 2 SCC 500 (p.22) wherein it is
settled law that where a statute requires to do certain thing
in a certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not
at all.
20. As we have recorded above that the sanction has not
been issued by the competent authority in accordance with
the provisions of the aforesaid Rules by not disclosing the
identity of the authority by which the departmental
proceedings shall be conducted in the matter. In the light of
the aforesaid binding precedents, we find that the
impugned memorandum and sanction are not sustainable
in law.
21. With regard to the submission made by the learned
counsel for the respondents that it is mentioned in the
relevant orders that the proceedings shall be in accordance
with the provisions of Rule 14(15) of the CSS (CCA) Rules,
no prejudice has been caused to the applicant and
therefore, interference of this Tribunal is not warranted, is
of no help to the respondents.
22. The sanction has been given by invoking the
provisions of Rule 8 of the CCS (CCA) Pension Rules, 2021
and once such provision requires the things to be done in a
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV
14
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
particular manner, in view of the binding precedents
referred to hereinabove, the same were required to be done
in that manner only and not otherwise.
23. In view of the aforesaid, the O.A. is allowed with the
following directions:-
i. The impugned sanctions and memorandum are
set aside.
ii. The applicant shall be entitled for consequential
benefits in accordance with the rules and
instructions on the subject.
iii. The aforesaid directions shall be complied with
by the respondents within a period of eight
weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy
of this order.
iv. The respondents shall be at liberty to initiate
proceedings against the applicant if they are so
advised, however, in accordance with the
relevant rules, instructions and law on the
subject.
24. Pending M.As, if any, stand disposed of accordingly.
However, in the facts and circumstances, there shall be no
order as to costs.
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV
15
Item No.29 (C-1) O.A. No.3502/2025
25. In view of the above order passed in the present O.A.,
M.A. No. 2498/2026 also stands disposed of.
(Dr. Anand S. Khati) (Justice Ranjit More)
Member (A) Chairman
/yy/
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central
Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL Bench, PostalCode=110001, L=Central
Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="61/35,
COPERNICUS MARG, NEW DELHI 110001", Phone=
83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931beb be6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf0ddf,
SERIALNUMBER= 875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596d46
b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1abc3, [email protected], CN=
YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I agree to the terms defined by the placement of my signature in this
document Location:
YAKSH
YADAV