Hukam Chand vs Rajesh @ Banti And Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CR-8415-2026 (O&M) -:1:-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
( 1111 )
CR-8415-2026 (O&M)
Date of decision: 16.11.2026
Hukam Chand ...Petitioner
Versus
Rajesh @ Banti and others ...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIRINDER AGGARWAL
Present:- Mr. Vikas Singh Chawra, Advocate and
Mr. Gaurav Chhonkar, Advocate
for the petitioner.
-.-
VIRINDER AGGARWAL , J . (Oral)
1. The present revision petition has been preferred under Article
227 of the Constitution of India, invoking the supervisory jurisdiction of
this Court, assailing the order dated 06.10.2026 (Annexure P-1), passed by
the Civil Judge, Bhiwani, whereby the application filed by the petitioner
seeking directions to respondent-defendants No. 1 to 3 to furnish their
specimen signatures for the purposes of comparison has been dismissed.
2. The petitioner instituted a civil suit seeking a declaration that,
being successors-in-interest of Manohar Lal, the petitioner and respondent
Nos. 1 to 3 are joint owners in possession of the suit property to the extent
th
of 1/4 share each. The petitioner’s case is founded upon a family
settlement dated 22.04.2011, purportedly arrived at amongst the four
brothers, whereby each brother was allotted 150 square yards out of the
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.16 16:24
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
CR-8415-2026 (O&M) -:2:-
suit property. Under the terms of the said settlement, the petitioner, along
with respondent No. 1, was also required to pay a sum of Rs. 4 lakh to
respondent Nos. 2 and 3.
2.1. During the course of the trial, defendant No.1-Rajesh @ Banti
appeared as DW-1 and disputed the execution of the family settlement
dated 22.04.2011, alleging that the signatures of respondent Nos. 1 to 3
appearing thereon were forged and fabricated. Consequently, the
genuineness of the family settlement and the authenticity of the signatures
appended thereto assumed significance and became a material aspect of
the controversy requiring adjudication. In view of the said denial, the
petitioner moved an application dated 29.09.2026, seeking directions to
respondent Nos. 1 to 3 to furnish their specimen signatures for the purpose
of comparison with the signatures appearing on the disputed family
settlement. The said application, however, came to be dismissed vide the
impugned order.
3. It is contended on behalf of the petitioner that the necessity of
obtaining specimen signatures arose only upon DW-1 disputing the
signatures appearing on the family settlement during the course of his
testimony. Placing reliance upon the decision of a Coordinate Bench of
this Court in Paramjit and Another vs. Jai Parkash and Another, CR-
3032-2021, decided on 18.05.2026 (PHHC:077973) , learned counsel
submits that an opportunity to lead rebuttal evidence was granted therein,
as the defendant had denied his signatures for the first time during cross-
examination, whereas, prior thereto, the execution of the agreement had
merely been denied. On the strength of the aforesaid precedent, it is urged
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.16 16:24
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
CR-8415-2026 (O&M) -:3:-
that the petitioner ought not to be deprived of an opportunity to establish
the genuineness of the family settlement, particularly when the specific
denial of the signatures emerged during the defendant's testimony.
4. A perusal of the impugned order, however, reveals that the
Trial Court proceeded on the premise that the petitioner's entire case was
founded upon the memorandum of family settlement dated 22.04.2011
and, therefore, the burden of proving Issue No. 1 rested upon the
petitioner. It was observed that, to discharge the said burden, the petitioner
was required to establish the authenticity of the signatures of respondent
Nos. 1 to 3 appearing on the disputed document by leading evidence in
affirmative. The Trial Court further held that rebuttal evidence could be
permitted only in respect of issues the burden of proof whereof rested
upon the defendants, and that the petitioner, being the plaintiff, could not
be permitted to lead evidence in rebuttal to counter the evidence adduced
by the defendants on an issue which the petitioner was himself required to
prove. The Trial Court also took note of the fact that the petitioner had
availed as many as 25 opportunities to lead evidence in affirmative,
including several opportunities granted as a last chance, before the
petitioner's evidence was ultimately closed on 06.03.2026.
4.1. The authority relied upon by the petitioner is clearly
distinguishable on facts and does not advance the case sought to be
canvassed. In Paramjit’s case (supra), the signatures appearing on the
disputed writing had not been specifically disputed at the initial stage, and
the denial emerged for the first time during cross-examination. The factual
position in the present case is materially different. A perusal of the written
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.16 16:24
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
CR-8415-2026 (O&M) -:4:-
statement filed by respondent-defendants No. 1 to 3 (Annexure P-4),
particularly the averments contained in paragraph 7 of the reply on merits,
unequivocally demonstrates that the execution of the alleged family
settlement had been specifically denied from the outset. It was
categorically pleaded that no such compromise had ever been arrived at
and that the writing dated 22.04.2011 was false and fabricated.
4.2. Thus, the petitioner-plaintiff was, from the very inception of
the proceedings, fully aware that the execution and authenticity of the
alleged family settlement were specifically disputed by the defendants.
The onus of establishing the genuineness of the said document, which
constitutes the very foundation of the petitioner's claim, therefore, squarely
rested upon the petitioner-plaintiff. It was incumbent upon the petitioner to
discharge that burden by leading appropriate evidence in affirmative,
including, if so advised, the examination of a handwriting expert to
establish the authenticity of the disputed signatures. Having failed to avail
that opportunity despite repeated chances, the petitioner cannot now seek
to introduce, under the guise of rebuttal evidence, material which was
required to be adduced in the first instance to establish his own case.
4.3. The Trial Court has, therefore, rightly declined the application,
as rebuttal evidence cannot be permitted to serve as a substitute for
evidence which the petitioner was obligated to lead in affirmative to
discharge the initial burden of proof. The reliance placed upon the
aforesaid judgment is, consequently, misplaced and does not render the
impugned order legally unsustainable. This Court finds no illegality,
perversity or material infirmity in the order passed by the Civil Judge
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.16 16:24
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document
CR-8415-2026 (O&M) -:5:-
warranting interference in exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India. Accordingly, the present revision
petition, being devoid of merit, is dismissed .
5. It is clarified that the observations made herein are confined
strictly to the adjudication of the present proceedings and shall not be
construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of the underlying
dispute or as prejudicing the rights, claims or contentions of either party in
any other proceedings.
6. In view of the final disposal of the principal matter, all
pending miscellaneous applications, if any, also stand disposed of. No
further orders are warranted.
( VIRINDER AGGARWAL )
16.11.2026 JUDGE
Gaurav Sorot
Whether reasoned / speaking? Yes / No
Whether reportable? Yes / No
GAURAV SOROT
2026.11.16 16:24
I attest to the accuracy and integrity
of this document