Rup Ram vs Raj Singh & Ors
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
112 RSA-6117-2014 (O&M)
Reserved on:19.08.2026
Pronounced on : 17.11.2026
RUP RAM ...APPELLANT
VERSUS
RAJ SINGH AND ANR. ...RESPONDENTS
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PARMOD GOYAL
Present: Mr. D.S. Matya, Advocate
for appellant.
Mr. P.R. Yadav, Advocate
for respondents.
*
PARMOD GOYAL, J.
Present appeal has been preferred by appellant-defendant
being aggrieved by judgment and decree dated 06.08.2013 passed by
learned Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Pataudi, Gurgaon,
whereby suit preferred by respondents-plaintiffs for specific performance
was decreed and by judgment and decree dated 14.08.2014 passed by
learned District Judge, Gurgaon, whereby first appeal preferred by
appellant-defendant was dismissed.
2. Respondents-plaintiffs in their suit for specific performance
had claimed that vide agreement to sell dated 02.09.2005, appellant-
defendant had agreed to sell land measuring 08 kanals duly described in
paragraph No.2 of the plaint to respondents-plaintiffs for total
consideration of Rs.3,64,000/- out of which Rs.3,44,000/- was paid as
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-6117-2014 -2-
earnest money in presence of witnesses at the time of execution of
agreement to sell and it was agreed that on receipt of balance
consideration of Rs.20,000/-, the sale deed would be executed on or
before 01.08.2006. However, on 01.08.2006, appellant-defendant failed
to turn up in the office of Sub-Registrar, Pataudi, whereas, respondents-
plaintiffs had remained present throughout the day and got their presence
marked by way of affidavit attested by Executive Magistrate. Thereafter,
on 04.08.2008, legal notice was served upon appellant-defendant calling
him to execute sale deed on 23.08.2006, however, again, appellant-
defendant had failed to turn up and presence of respondents-plaintiffs
was got marked. It was the case of respondents-plaintiffs that they
were/are ready and willing to execute their part of agreement and it is
appellant-defendant, who had failed to comply with conditions of
agreement to sell. Accordingly, possession by way of specific
performance was sought.
3. Appellant-defendant, vide his detailed written statement,
took number of preliminary objections as regards to maintainability of
suit, etc. and claimed that agreement dated 02.09.2005 was forged and
frivolous. It was also claimed that previously also, respondents-plaintiffs
had forged an agreement dated 03.09.2004 in respect of suit property,
wherein last date for execution of sale deed was fixed as 01.08.2005 and
in this regard, respondents-plaintiffs had issued a legal notice on
21.07.2005 through his counsel. Upon receipt of said notice, Panchayat
was convened wherein, respondents-plaintiffs accepted their fault and
agreed not to pursue the agreement dated 03.09.2004 as well as legal
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-6117-2014 -3-
notice dated 21.07.2005. Execution of agreement to sell as well as
receipt of earnest money was denied. Accordingly, dismissal of suit was
prayed for.
4. From the pleadings of the parties, following issues were
framed:-
“1. Whether the defendant has entered into an agreement
to sell dated 02.09.2005 with the plaintiff to sell the
suit property for Rs. 364000/- as alleged? OPP
2. If issue no.1 is proved whether defendant has
received Rs.344000/- as part payment/advance money
from the plaintiff as alleged? OPP
3. Whether plaintiff has been ready and willing to
perform his part of contract? OPP
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to possession of suit
property by way of specific performance of agreement
dated 02.09.2005? OPP
5. Whether the suit of plaintiff is not maintainable in the
present form? OPD
6. Whether the plaintiff has no locus standi and no
cause of action to file the present suit? OPD
7. Whether plaintiff has concealed true and material
facts from the court, if so its effect? OPD
8. Relief.
5. In order to prove due execution of agreement dated
02.09.2005, respondent-plaintiff No.2 himself appeared as PW2 and
examined attesting witnesses Bairam as PW1. Apart from examining
attesting witness, respondents-plaintiffs had also examined Clerk namely
Ashok Kumar as PW3 of Sh. Tejpal Singh Chauhan, Advocate, who had
issued legal notice. Respondents-plaintiffs had also placed on record
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-6117-2014 -4-
agreement to sell as Ex.P2, notice dated 21.07.2005 as Ex.P4, notice
dated 04.08.2006 as Ex.P5, postal receipt vide which notice dated
04.08.2006 was issued as Ex.P6 and jamabandi for the year 2002-2003
showing ownership of appellant-defendant over suit property as Ex.P7.
6. On the other hand, appellant-defendant had himself
appeared as DW1 and had tendered document Mark D1 and D2 which
were already on record as Ex.P4 and Ex.P5.
7. It is the case of appellant-defendant that no agreement was
ever entered to sell the suit property as was claimed by respondents-
plaintiffs. Learned counsel for the appellant-defendant has made
reference to agreement dated 02.09.2005 Ex.P2 relied upon by
respondents-plaintiffs and has argued that the perusal of agreement
Ex.P2 in fact goes to show that same is result of fabrication and forgery.
He asserts that perusal of Ex.P2 goes to show that its first page is having
three thumb marks, one on the side of page, second in the middle of the
page over which conditions of agreement are typed and third is at the
bottom of the page. That none of the three thumb impressions on first
page carry the name of person whose thumb impression are recorded
therein. It is further asserted that it was also not mentioned that whether
it was left thumb impression or right thumb impression.
8. Learned counsel for the appellant-defendant has also made
reference to page No.2 of the agreement dated 02.09.2005 Ex.P2 and
asserted that again the agreement carries two thumb impressions without
there being any mention as to whom the thumb impressions belongs. It is
asserted that the first thumb impression on second page is over typed
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-6117-2014 -5-
matter, whereas second thumb impression is under the name of
appellant-defendant. However, it is not mentioned whether they are LTI
or RTI. It is also asserted that though the name and particulars of
attesting witness-Rajender Singh along with Bairam is clearly made out,
however, as far as attesting witness-Bairam is concerned, who was
examined by respondents-plaintiffs in support of their case, only his
name is mentioned, no address or any particulars with regards to him are
recorded. That it is not even clear as to whether it is his signatures or his
name simply written on the agreement. He further submits that the onus
to prove agreement was upon respondents-plaintiffs, and it was for them
to explain all the transactions arising from the agreement.
9. Learned counsel for the appellant-defendant has also made
reference to notice dated 21.07.2005 (Ex.P4) allegedly issued by Sh.
Tejpal Singh Chauhan, Advocate, who had subsequently issued notice
dated 04.08.2006 (Ex.P5) with regards to present agreement to sell dated
02.09.2005. It is asserted that from contents of notice Ex.P4/Mark D1, it
is clearly proved that earlier even as per respondents-plaintiffs an
agreement dated 03.09.2004 was entered for total amount of
Rs.2,80,000/-, out of which Rs.2,72,000/- was paid. The last date for
execution of said agreement was stated to be 01.08.2005. However, these
facts were not disclosed by respondents-plaintiffs while filing present
suit, nor it was disclosed as to why fresh agreement dated 02.09.2005
was got entered when the previous agreement for lesser amount of
Rs.2,80,000/- instead of Rs.3,64,000/- was already in favor of
respondents-plaintiffs and why they had not preferred to seek specific
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-6117-2014 -6-
performance of the said agreement. It is asserted that non-disclosure and
effort to suppress these facts clearly go to show that agreement Ex.P2 is
forged and fictitious.
10. Learned counsel for the appellant-defendant has also
pointed out that the appellant-defendant used to sign and never used to
thumb mark. He has made reference to written statement as well as
evidence recorded before learned Courts below wherein appellant-
defendant had appeared as DW1. He asserts that both written statement
as well as statement was signed by appellant-defendant and were not
thumb marked. He further asserts that the oral statements that appellant-
defendant had thumb marked the agreement in light of unmarked
multiple thumb marks on Ex.P2 were required to be proved by
examining handwriting expert by respondents-plaintiffs, which was not
done and therefore, due execution of agreement by appellant-defendant
is not established/proved.
11. On the other hand, learned counsel for respondents-
plaintiffs has argued that both the learned Courts by way of concurrent
finding of facts had concluded that agreement dated 02.09.2005 (Ex.P2)
was duly executed by none but appellant-defendant and therefore, the
findings of fact recorded by learned Courts below may not be interfered
by this Court in regular second appeal.
12. On consideration, I find that onus to prove due execution of
agreement to sell dated 02.09.2005 (Ex.P2) was upon respondents-
plaintiffs. The principle of law that High Court while appreciating
contentions raised in Regular Second Appeal cannot and should not
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-6117-2014 -7-
interfere with the findings of learned Courts below on facts lightly. It is
only in exceptional circumstance when the findings recorded by learned
Courts are found to be erroneous and perverse, then alone, the High
Court in Regular Second Appeal may interfere with the findings of facts
recorded by learned Courts below. The findings recorded by learned
Courts below can only be interfered by High Court in Regular Second
Appeal, if they are erroneous and perverse on account of non-
consideration of valid piece of evidence or on account of consideration
of invalid evidence or on account of misreading of document entirely
without going into the contentions and material available on record.
13. Before appreciating contentions raised on behalf of
appellant-defendant, therefore, it is necessary to have a look at
agreement to sell dated 02.09.2005 (Ex.P2), which is basis of present
litigation. Perusal of agreement dated 02.09.2005 (Ex.P2) in fact goes to
show that it is thumb marked at three places on its first page and also
carries two thumb marks on its second page. All the thumb marks on first
and second page are unmarked. It is not mentioned as to whom they
belong and as to whether they are LTI or RTI. All the five thumb
impressions on page one and page two of agreement to sell Ex.P2 are
stated to be that of appellant-defendant.
14. Evidence of Bairam (PW1), who claims himself to be
attesting witness, in fact goes to show that in his testimony he had stated
that at the time of execution of agreement the same was thumb marked
by appellant-defendant and thereafter, he along with respondent-plaintiff
No.2 Jaibir purchaser and Rajender Singh had signed the same. Perusal
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-6117-2014 -8-
of Ex.P2 also goes to show that though its first page carries three thumb
marks alleged to have been made by appellant-defendant, but it does not
carry signatures of either Jaibir or Raj Singh alleged purchasers,
(respondents-plaintiffs) or of any of the attesting witnesses. Further,
second page of Ex.P2 shows that the two unmarked thumb marks are
present and both are stated to be of appellant-defendant. One of the
thumb marks is below his name whereas second thumb mark is on the
last line of the agreement, which shows that either thumb mark was
made over the typed matter or matter was typed after thumb mark.
Similarly, page No.1 of agreement which carries three unmarked thumb
impressions allegedly stated to be of appellant-defendant which are made
firstly on left side of the typed matter, secondly in the middle of the page
over typed matter and thirdly on the bottom of the page No.1 of the
agreement Ex.P2.
15. Perusal of records further go to show that while filing
written statement, appellant-defendant had signed his written statement
in Hindi. He also appeared as DW1 and had duly signed his statement in
Hindi and not at any place had he thumb marked any document. Perusal
of evidence of Ashok Kumar (PW3), Clerk of Tejpal Singh Chauhan,
Advocate, who was examined to prove notice dated 04.08.2006 issued
by Sh. Tejpal Singh Chauhan (Ex.P5) in fact goes to show that in his
cross examination he had duly admitted that notice dated 21.07.2005
(Ex.P4) was duly issued by their office and was signed by Tejpal Singh
Chauhan, Advocate. From the said admission and Ex.P4, therefore,
appellant-defendant has succeeded in proving that prior to agreement
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-6117-2014 -9-
dated 02.09.2005 (Ex.P2), there existed another agreement dated
03.09.2004 in which the suit land which is subject matter of agreement
dated 02.09.2005 i.e. 08 Kanals, was agreed to be sold for Rs.2,80,000/-,
out of which Rs.2,72,000/- stood paid and remaining Rs.8,000/- was
payable at the time of execution of sale deed. Last date for execution of
sale deed was fixed as 01.08.2005. However, it is also clearly made out
from plaint that neither notice dated 21.07.02005 nor particulars of
agreement dated 03.09.2004 were ever pleaded by respondents-plaintiffs
while seeking specific performance of agreement dated 02.09.2005. It is
also not mere co-incidence that last date under agreement dated
03.09.2004 was 01.08.2005 i.e. on day when stamp paper for agreement
dated 02.09.2005 (Ex.P2) was purchased. Agreement Ex.P2 goes to
show that though the agreement was entered on 02.09.2005, however,
stamp paper on which it was written was purchased on 01.08.2005.
16. While filing written statement, appellant-defendant has
specifically taken a stand that agreement dated 02.09.2005 is forged and
fabricated and similar attempt was made earlier by respondents-plaintiffs
by fabricating another agreement dated 03.09.2004 for which
respondents-plaintiffs had issued legal notice. However, when
respondents-plaintiffs had objected to same before the Panchayat, the
said agreement was cancelled by respondents-plaintiffs and subsequently
after one year he again raised the same issue by forging another
agreement dated 02.09.2005.
17. It is on the basis of above noted factual aspects that learned
counsel for the appellant-defendant has argued that the learned Courts
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-6117-2014 -10-
below have erred in concluding that respondents-plaintiffs had
discharged their onus to prove agreement dated 02.09.2005 as both the
learned Courts have failed to take in consideration any of the above facts
while appreciating the evidence and recording finding on issue No.1 in
favor of respondents-plaintiffs.
18. As held above, the onus to prove due execution of
agreement dated 02.09.2005 was upon respondents-plaintiffs.
19. On consideration of above noted facts, I am in concurrence
with learned counsel for appellant-defendant that initial onus to prove
agreement dated 02.09.2005 to be genuine and having been executed by
appellant-defendant has not been discharged by respondents-plaintiffs
and learned Courts below have wrongly concluded this fact in favor of
respondents-plaintiffs without taking in consideration the evidence
available on record. If the evidence available on record is considered and
appreciated, then the only conclusion which can be drawn in present case
is that respondents-plaintiffs have failed to discharge their onus to prove
agreement dated 02.09.2005 (Ex.P2). Even by applying standard of proof
of preponderance of probabilities, which is to be applied in civil cases,
the findings on issue No.1 cannot be recorded in favor of respondents-
plaintiffs as respondents-plaintiffs had failed to dispel suspicious
circumstances with which agreement dated 02.09.2005 (Ex.P2) is
surrounded.
20. Agreement dated 02.09.2005 is thumb marked at five
places, however, all the five thumb marks are unmarked and no name as
to who had put them is mentioned. It is also not mentioned whether they
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-6117-2014 -11-
are LTI or RTI. It was for the respondents plaintiffs to explain that the
five thumb impressions which were taken on two pages of Ex.P2 were
that of appellant-defendant. It was respondents-plaintiffs to explain as to
how one of the thumb marks had appeared in the center of the page,
upon which typed conditions were mentioned. Similarly, no explanation
had come forth as to why one of the thumb marks on second page is also
on the last line of the agreement. This fact is further compounded by the
fact that one of the attesting witness-Rajender Singh has been fully
described and under his name description signatures are shown to have
been appended. Whereas in the case of second of second attesting
witness-Bairam who was examined as PW1 by respondents-plaintiffs
only his name is mentioned, neither his particulars i.e. address etc. have
been mentioned nor it is clear whether it was his name or his signatures.
Another fact which is required to be noted is that one of the purchasers
i.e. Raj Singh had not signed Ex.P2 though he is one of the respondents-
plaintiffs i.e plaintiff No.1 in present proceedings. It is also clear from
perusal of Ex.P2 that first page of agreement carries three unmarked
thumb impression which are stated that of appellant-defendant, however,
no signatures of any of the co-purchasers or attesting witnesses are
present on first page. I am in agreement with contention raised on behalf
of learned counsel for appellant-defendant, that in view of fact that in
written statement, respondents-plaintiffs had clearly stated agreement to
sell Ex.P-2 to be forged and fabricated and had signed the written
statement, it was incumbent upon respondents-plaintiffs to prove thumb
impressions on Ex.P-2 by taking specimen thumb impressions of the
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-6117-2014 -12-
appellant-defendant by examining finger print expert. Failure to do so, in
fact, would be failure to prove the agreement by cogent evidence.
21. Once the agreement has been denied and asserted to be
forged and fabricated, the onus to prove due execution is upon
respondents-plaintiffs becomes more stringent. It was for respondents-
plaintiffs to prove agreement dated 02.09.2005 to be genuine one by
leading cogent evidence. In the facts and circumstances of the present
case noted above, the mere oral assertions that appellant-defendant had
thumb marked the agreement as stated by PW1 and PW2 cannot be taken
as sufficient proof of due execution of agreement. In such cases, when
agreement is denied and is thumb marked, especially when agreement is
surrounded by suspicious circumstances as is made out in present case,
as it carries five unmarked thumb impressions of seller on two pages, out
of which upon two typed matter has been recorded, mere oral assertion
of PW-1 and PW-2 cannot be accepted and additional fact that
respondents-plaintiffs have failed to disclose about previous execution of
agreement dated 03.09.2004 creates serious doubt over its due execution.
Further, it was the duty of respondents-plaintiffs to explain as to why the
previous agreement, which was for lesser amount of Rs.2,80,000/- out of
which Rs.2,72,000/- stood paid, was not pressed for specific
performance. Reasons as to why after issuing notice dated 21.07.2005,
another stamp paper dated 01.08.2005 was purchased when last date for
execution of sale deed under agreement dated 03.09.2004 was
01.08.2005.
22. In the light of above noted facts and circumstances, non-
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
RSA-6117-2014 -13-
examination of scribe-Ishwar Singh, non-explanation of purchase of
stamp paper on 01.08.2005 during the pendency of previous agreement
and then execution of fresh agreement on 02.09.2005 without there being
any reference to previous agreement either in pleadings or in agreement
Ex.P2, also attain significance.
23. Facts and circumstances noted above if are taken in
consideration, it is clearly made out that learned Courts below had erred
in concluding due execution of agreement by ignoring evidence available
on record. The findings of learned Courts below are totally erroneous
and perverse being against evidence on record and cannot be sustained.
None of the above facts were considered and discussed by learned
Courts below. In the present case, respondents-plaintiffs had failed to
prove due execution of agreement dated 02.09.2005. Therefore, the
finding of learned Courts below on issue No.1 is set aside. It is held that
agreement dated 02.09.2005 is forged one and therefore, respondents-
plaintiffs are not entitled to specific performance of same. Suit preferred
by respondents-plaintiffs is liable to be dismissed. Appeal preferred by
appellant-defendant is allowed. Suit is accordingly, dismissed.
24. Pending application(s), if any, is/are disposed of
accordingly.
(PARMOD GOYAL)
JUDGE
17.11.2026
Sunil Chander/Ravinder
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
RAVINDER DHANIA
2026.11.17 16:30
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document