Subhash Chand (Through Pairokar) vs Central Bureau Of Investigation

Court
Delhi High Court

$~1
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
% Date of Decision: 17.11.2026
# CNR No. DLHC010357652026
+ BAIL APPLN. 3153/2026
SUBHASH CHAND (THROUGH PAIROKAR) .....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Bharat Chugh, Mr. Jai Allagh and
Mr. Maanish Mohan Choudhary,
Advocates

versus

CENTRAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION .....Respondent
Through: Ms. Rajni Gupta, SPP for CBI with
Inspector Abhijeet Shekhawat, ACB






CORAM: JUSTICE GIRISH KATHPALIA


J U D G M E N T (ORAL)


1. The accused/applicant seeks regular bail in case RC No.
0032026A0026, registered by Anti Corruption Branch of CBI, New Delhi
for offence under Section 61(2), BNS and Section 7, Prevention of
Corruption Act.


Bail Application No 3153/2026 Page 1 of 7 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
Digitally signed by GIRISH KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec45569af3962c6
fb4835d435f97626cacca, ou=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,CID -
7047638, postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d15570996b40f80
cbd2eee60402c487965ff801e26fa, cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.11.17 18:05:21 +05'30'
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:DIKSHA RAWAT
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:18:21

2. Broadly speaking, the accused/applicant, being head of the Narcotics
Cell of the Delhi Police was allegedly involved in extortion racket with the
help of his subordinates.
2. 1 The relevant factual matrix as per prosecution case is as follows. On
the basis of a written complaint dated 21.04.2026 lodged by the complainant
de facto , the CBI swung into action. In the said complaint, it was alleged
that five officials of Anti Narcotics Cell, Dwarka came to the residence of
the complainant de facto and despite her protests began search of the house
without any authority; that they took out a bag from their own vehicle and
placed the same inside her house claiming it to contain ganja and threatened
to falsely implicate her in a case under NDPS Act; that one of the those
police officials namely, HC Ajay Kumar told her that if she paid Rs.
25,00,000/-, no case would be registered against her and when she expressed
inability, one of those officials made a telephone call to a person named
Subhash ( allegedly the present accused/applicant ) and thereafter, they
reduced the demand to Rs.15,00,000/-, out of which Rs.5,00,000/- to be paid
on 21.04.2026.
2.2 For verification of the complaint, a WhatsApp call on speaker mode
was made by the complainant de facto to HC Ajay Kumar in presence of the
verifying officer and two independent witnesses. During that phone call, the
complainant de facto told HC Ajay Kumar that she had been able to arrange
only Rs.2,00,000/- towards part payment of bribe amount, which he


Bail Application No 3153/2026 Page 2 of 7 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
Digitally signed by GIRISH KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec45569af3962c6fb4835d4
35f97626cacca, ou=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,CID - 7047638,
postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d15570996b40f80cbd2eee6
0402c487965ff801e26fa, cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.11.17 18:05:41 +05'30'
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:DIKSHA RAWAT
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:18:21

instructed her to deliver on the same evening. The said telephone call was
recorded and after verification of the demand, a trap was laid.
2.3 On 21.04.2026 at about 07:07pm at the office of Anti Narcotics Cell
Dwarka, the trap laying officer Inspector Satyavir in presence of two
independent witnesses, the complainant de facto and witness of the
verification proceedings, laid the trap.
2.4 During the trap, HC Ajay Kumar demanded and accepted the bribe of
Rs.2,00,000/- from the complainant de facto and was caught red handed.
The currency recovered from HC Ajay Kumar tallied with the currency that
had been used for trap. Both hands of the HC Ajay Kumar on being washed
turned pink, thereby confirming his having handled the phenolphthalein
treated notes and the said report returned positive from CFSL.
Contemporaneous to the transaction, the trap proceedings were captured and
recorded, during which HC Ajay Kumar, at the time of accepting the bribe
stated: “ abhi Subhash Sahab se baat hui hai” and the complainant de facto
stated: “ mereko darr lagta hai.... Subhash sir se darr lagta hai”.
2.5 During the search of the premises of Anti Narcotics Cell in presence
of both independent witnesses, an unaccounted cash amount of
Rs.48,87,600/- was recovered from the area adjacent to the an immediately
below window of the restroom of the accused/applicant regarding which no
explanation came from the accused/applicant. Further, in the official room
of the accused/applicant, currency counting machine was found, but for that
also no explanation was advanced.


Bail Application No 3153/2026 Page 3 of 7 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
Digitally signed by GIRISH KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec45569af3962c6fb
4835d435f97626cacca, ou=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,CID -
7047638, postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d15570996b40f80cb
d2eee60402c487965ff801e26fa, cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.11.17 18:05:57 +05'30'
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:DIKSHA RAWAT
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:18:21

3. Against the above backdrop, it is contended by learned counsel for
accused/applicant that he has been falsely implicated in order to discourage
the other officials of Narcotics Cell, as the complainant de facto and her
family members are involved in a number of cases under the NDPS Act and
under the Excise Act. It is contended by learned counsel that the criminal
law does not recognize vicarious liability, so for the bribe demanded and
accepted by HC Ajay Kumar, no liability can be foisted on the present
accused/applicant. Learned counsel for accused/applicant contends that the
amount of Rs. 48,87,600/- was recovered from a public place and not from
person of the accused/applicant, so that recovery is of no consequence. It is
also contended that since no videography of the alleged recovery of money
was carried out, the investigation was faulty. Learned counsel for
accused/applicant also contends that since no seizure memo of the currency
counting machine was prepared, that fact raises doubts about truthfulness of
prosecution case.
4. Per contra, learned SPP for CBI strongly opposes the bail application
on the ground that the framing of charges is yet to be considered by the
learned trial court, so this is not an appropriate stage, looking into the
gravity of the offence. It is contended that the recovery of Rs. 48,87,600/-
was not from a public place but from window of the restroom attached with
the official room of the accused/applicant and the place of the alleged
recovery is not accessible to anyone except the accused/applicant. It is also
contended that during the trap proceedings, the investigating officer also
found a dummy CCTV Camera in the official room of the accused/applicant,


Bail Application No 3153/2026 Page 4 of 7 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
Digitally signed by GIRISH KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec45569af3962c6fb4835
d435f97626cacca, ou=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,CID - 7047638,
postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d15570996b40f80cbd2eee
60402c487965ff801e26fa, cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.11.17 18:06:12 +05'30'
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:DIKSHA RAWAT
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:18:21

which was being used to extort money from the victims. Further, it is
submitted that the accused/applicant even destroyed his mobile phone and
tried to mislead the investigating officer by stating that he had thrown the
mobile phone in a drain, so the same could not be recovered. As regards the
seizure memo pertaining to the currency counting machine, it is submitted
by learned SPP that since the same was not seized, there was no purpose to
prepare any seizure memo.
5. In rebuttal, learned counsel for accused/applicant submits that the
accused/applicant had handed over his Apple phone to the Investigating
Officer, so there was no reason for him not to hand over his Samsung phone
as well. It is also contended that even the Samsung phone of the
accused/applicant had been taken away by the Investigating Officer during
the trap proceedings itself, though without issuing any memo or receipt.
6. To begin with, it has to be kept in mind that at the relevant time, the
accused/applicant was heading the Anti Narcotics Cell, Dwarka and his
immediate subordinate was caught red handed while accepting bribe that
had been demanded by him through HC Ajay Kumar. As mentioned above,
the investigation also reveals that in the course of trap proceedings, there
was repeated reference to the accused/applicant by name. That being so, the
gravity of offence becomes significantly vital in the present case.
7. Then comes the recovery of Rs.48,87,600/- attributed to the
accused/applicant, which money has not been explained by the
accused/applicant. The argument advanced on behalf of the


Bail Application No 3153/2026 Page 5 of 7 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
Digitally signed by GIRISH KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec45569af3962c6fb4
835d435f97626cacca, ou=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,CID -
7047638, postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d15570996b40f80cbd
2eee60402c487965ff801e26fa, cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.11.17 18:06:29 +05'30'
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:DIKSHA RAWAT
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:18:21

accused/applicant that the said amount was recovered from a place
accessible to public does not convince in view of the material on record and
forming part of the chargesheet that the said place was accessible only to the
accused/applicant. According to the same, the restroom from window
whereof the money was recovered was attached to the office room of the
accused/applicant, key whereof remained with the Duty Officer for being
used by the accused/applicant only, according to statement of the Duty
Officer.
8. It would also be significant to note that consequent upon further
detailed investigation by the CBI, a case for disproportionate assets also
stands registered against the accused/applicant, which also significantly adds
to the gravity of the offence alleged against the accused/applicant in view of
his official position.
9. Further, the CBI also found an antecedent demand of Rs.20,00,000/-
made by the accused/applicant on 18.03.2026 in connection with the
detention of daughter of the complainant de facto under the NDPS Act.
10. So far as the alleged destruction of Samsung mobile phone is
concerned, I do not find any convincing explanation from the side of the
accused/applicant. I find it unbelievable that the accused/applicant despite
being such a senior police officer would be so gullible that he would
handover his mobile phone to the Investigating Officer without any receipt
or memo issued by the Investigating Officer.


Bail Application No 3153/2026 Page 6 of 7 pages
GIRISH
KATHPALIA
Digitally signed by GIRISH KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4afec45569af3962c6fb4835d43
5f97626cacca, ou=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,CID - 7047638,
postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d15570996b40f80cbd2eee60
402c487965ff801e26fa, cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.11.17 18:06:44 +05'30'
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:DIKSHA RAWAT
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:18:21

11. The co-accused HC Ajay Kumar also has not been granted bail till
date and he, as mentioned above, being subordinate of the present
accused/applicant was acting on his instructions according to the CBI.
12. At this stage, I must also add a cautious rider that the above
observations have been recorded for the limited purposes of analyzing the
rival arguments for consideration of bail. The learned trial court shall take an
independent view on the basis of material on record.
13. Considering the overall circumstances described above, especially the
dominant and powerful position held by the accused/applicant as head of the
Anti Narcotics Cell and the extortion allegedly committed at his behest by
his subordinate Head Constable, I do not find it a fit case to grant bail to the
accused/applicant at this stage.
14. Therefore, the bail application is dismissed.
15. A copy of this order be immediately transmitted to the concerned Jail
Superintendent for informing the accused/applicant.



GIRISH KATHPALIA
(JUDGE)
NOVEMBER 17, 2026/ as
Digitally signed by GIRISH KATHPALIA
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,
2.5.4.20=8401dd889b27a77b2f65ffffe4af
ec45569af3962c6fb4835d435f97626cacc
a, ou=HIGH COURT OF DELHI,CID -
7047638, postalCode=110003, st=Delhi,
serialNumber=d3e86796451ec45c07b5d
15570996b40f80cbd2eee60402c487965f
f801e26fa, cn=GIRISH KATHPALIA
Date: 2026.11.17 18:07:03 +05'30'
GIRISH
KATHPALIA


Bail Application No 3153/2026 Page 7 of 7 pages
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:DIKSHA RAWAT
Signing Date:17.11.2026
18:18:21