Chagna And Others vs State Of U.P.

Court
Allahabad High Court

AFR
Neutral Citation No. – 2026:AHC-LKO:82015-DB
Judgment Reserved : 28.09.2026
Judgment Delivered : 17.11.2026

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
LUCKNOW
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. - 192 of 1989
Chagna and others
…..Appellant(s)
Versus
State of U.P.
…..Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : V. Sahai, Alok Kumar Singh,
Awadhesh Kumar, Dheerendra
Kumar Singh, Gaurav Verma,
Nagendra Mohan, Sanjay Singh
Chauhan, Shams Vikas
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Govt. Advocate,
Court No. - 11
HON'BLE ABDUL MOIN, J.
HON'BLE PRAMOD KUMAR SRIVASTAVA, J.
(Dictated by Hon’ble Pramod Kumar Srivastava, J.)
1. Heard Sri Gaurav Verma, learned counsel appearing on behalf of
appellant no. 1 (Chugna), Sri Dheerendra Kumar Singh, learned counsel
appearing for appellant no. 2 (Ram Bharosey) and Sri Arunendra,
learned Additional Government Advocate (A.G.A.) appearing for the
State-respondent.
2. The instant Criminal Appeal under Section 374(2) of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as 'Cr.P.C.') has been
instituted assailing the impugned judgment and order of conviction and

2
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
sentence dated 28.02.1989 passed by the learned II Additional Sessions
Judge, Lakhimpur Kheri in consolidated Sessions Trial No. 59 of 1987
(State vs. Chugna) and Sessions Trial No. 225 of 1988 (State vs. Ram
Bharosey and Guddu), arising out of Case Crime No. 83 of 1986, under
Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860
(hereinafter referred to as 'IPC') and Section 504 IPC, Police Station
Singahi, District Lakhimpur Kheri.
3. By means of the impugned judgment and order, the learned trial
court convicted all three accused-appellants, namely Chugna, Ram
Bharosey and Guddu, under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC and
sentenced each of them to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for Life. All
three appellants were, however, acquitted of the charge under Section
504 IPC.
4. At the very outset, it is relevant to record that during the pendency
of the instant appeal before this Court, an inquiry report dated
13.11.2025 submitted by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Lakhimpur Kheri was received, communicating that appellant no. 3,
Guddu, son of Raju Kori, died about 15 years ago due to an accidental
fall from a tree. Consequently, vide order dated 28.07.2022 of this Court,
Criminal Appeal No. 192 of 1989 has already been abated in respect of
appellant no. 3 (Guddu). Hence, the present appeal survives and is being
adjudicated on merits exclusively with regard to appellant no. 1
(Chugna) and appellant no. 2 (Ram Bharosey).
Brief Facts of the Case
5. The prosecution story, in brief, is that the deceased, Ram Kishan,
son of Tulsi Ram, was a resident of Village Bhairampur, Police Station
Singahi, District Lakhimpur Kheri. Prior to the date of occurrence, the
deceased was employed as an ad-hoc forest watcher in the Dudhwa
National Park / Forest Department. While discharging his duties, the
deceased had caught the accused persons cutting and stealing forest
timber. On that account, an altercation had taken place and the accused
persons were taken to the Range Office, where they were let off upon

3
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
tendering an apology. Owing to this incident, the accused persons
harbored pre-existing enmity and grudge against the deceased.
6. On 04.10.1986, the deceased Ram Kishan along with his paternal
uncle Ram Sahay (PW-4, the informant) and his brother-in-law (sala)
Mishrilal (PW-1) had gone to the local Belrayan market to purchase
vegetables. After making purchases, at about 6:00 P.M. (at sunset), while
they were returning on foot from the forest pathway towards their village
Bhairampur, the accused persons—Ram Bharosey armed with a country-
made pistol (tamancha/katta) and Chugna and Guddu armed with knives
suddenly emerged from the jungle.
7. It is alleged that the accused persons initially hurled abuses at
Ram Kishan. Thereafter, accused Ram Bharosey discharged his country-
made pistol at Ram Kishan. The firearm projectile struck Ram Kishan on
the left side of his chest, causing him to fall to the ground. As per the
initial written report (tahreer, Exhibit Ka-1), once Ram Kishan collapsed,
all three accused persons assaulted him with knives. Upon alarms being
raised by PW-1 and PW-4, witnesses Jwala Singh (PW-2) and Roj Ali
(PW-3), who were also returning from the Belrayan market, rushed
towards the spot, whereupon the accused persons fled into the jungle.
8. The injured Ram Kishan was carried from the place of occurrence
towards Belrayan for medical treatment; however, he succumbed to his
injuries on the way near the Belrayan Range Colony. Leaving the
cadaver of the deceased on a Dunlop cart (bullock cart) in the compound
of the Range Office, informant Ram Sahay (PW-4) got a written report
scribed by one Shri Ram, carried it on foot to Police Station Singahi
(situated about six miles away) and presented it at 23:15 hours on
04.10.1986. On that basis, Chik FIR No. 69 of 1986 (Exhibit Ka-3) and
General Diary Entry No. 32 (Exhibit Ka-4) were registered under
Section 302 IPC against accused Chugna, Guddu and Ram Bharosey.
9. Following the registration of the FIR, the investigation was
entrusted to Station Officer Shakil Akhtar Khan (PW-7). Due to the
absence of light during the night, the inquest proceedings could not be

4
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
undertaken immediately. On the morning of 05.10.1986, starting at 07:00
A.M., S.O. Shakil Akhtar Khan conducted the inquest (panchayatnama,
Exhibit Ka-5) on the dead body of Ram Kishan lying on the Dunlop cart
at Belrayan. Along with the necessary police papers (Challan Lash
Exhibit Ka-7, Photo Lash Exhibit Ka-6, specimen seal and post-mortem
requisition), the dead body was dispatched for autopsy to the District
Hospital, Lakhimpur Kheri through Constables Rajkishore Verma and
Satish Chandra Pathak.
10. On 05.10.1986 at 05:00 P.M., Dr. S.K. Tewari (PW-5) conducted
the post-mortem examination on the cadaver of deceased Ram Kishan
and prepared the autopsy report (Exhibit Ka-2).
11. In the course of the investigation, the Investigating Officer
inspected the crime scene, collected samples of plain and blood-stained
earth along with one 12-bore empty cartridge (recovery memo Exhibit
Ka-12) and seized the blood-stained tahmad worn by the deceased
(recovery memo Exhibit Ka-10). The I.O. prepared the site plan (naksha
nazri, Exhibit Ka-11). The accused persons having absconded,
proceedings under Sections 82 and 83 Cr.P.C. were initiated against them
pursuant to warrants issued by the C.J.M., Lakhimpur Kheri and
attachments of their movable properties were executed (Fard Kurki
Exhibits Ka-22, Ka-23 and Ka-24). Subsequently, accused Chugna
surrendered before the court, while co-accused Guddu and Ram
Bharosey were arrested. Upon conclusion of the investigation, the I.O.
submitted charge-sheet Exhibit Ka-25 (P-11) against all three accused
under Section 302 IPC.
12. The cases were committed to the Court of Session, registered as
Sessions Trial No. 59 of 1987 (State vs. Chugna) and Sessions Trial No.
225 of 1988 (State vs. Ram Bharosey and Guddu) and consolidated for
trial, with S.T. No. 59 of 1987 being made the leading case. The learned
trial court framed formal charges under Sections 504 and 302 read with
Section 34 IPC against all the accused persons. The charges were read

5
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
over and explained to the accused, who pleaded not guilty and claimed
to be tried.
Evidence on behalf of the prosecution
13. In order to substantiate its case and establish the guilt of the
accused persons beyond reasonable doubt, the prosecution produced and
examined following seven witnesses:
Table – A: Summary of Examined Witnesses
Witness No. Name & Particulars
P.W. 1 Mishrilal
P.W. 2 Jwala Singh
P.W. 3 Roj Ali
P.W. 4 Ram Sahay
P.W. 5 Dr. S.K. Tewari
P.W. 6 H.C. Virendra Kumar Singh
P.W. 7 S.O. Shakil Akhtar Khan
14. The prosecution further proved and exhibited several
contemporaneous documentary materials, which are tabulated hereunder:
Table – B: List of prosecution exhibits
Exhibit No. Description of Document / Material Object
Ex. Ka-1 Written Complaint (Tahreer)
Ex. Ka-2 Post-Mortem Examination Report
Ex. Ka-3 Chik First Information Report
Ex. Ka-4 General Diary Entry No. 32 (Kayami)
Ex. Ka-5 Inquest Report (Panchayatnama)

6
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
Exhibit No. Description of Document / Material Object
Ex. Ka-6 Photo Lash
Ex. Ka-7 Challan Lash
Ex. Ka-10 Seizure Memo of Blood-stained Tahmad
Ex. Ka-11 Site Plan (Naksha Nazri) of Spot
Ex. Ka-12 Seizure Memo of Earth & Spent Cartridge
Ex. Ka-22 Attachment Memo (Fard Kurki u/s 83 CrPC)
Ex. Ka-23 Attachment Memo (Fard Kurki u/s 83 CrPC)
Ex. Ka-24 Attachment Memo (Fard Kurki u/s 83 CrPC)
Ex. Ka-25 Charge-Sheet (P-11)
Material Ex. 56 Metallic Pellets (Chharre)
Depositions of Prosecution Witnesses
15. P.W. 1, Mishrilal (Brother-in-law of the Deceased): 15. In his
examination-in-chief, P.W. 1 deposed that the deceased Ram Kishan was
his brother-in-law (bahnoi). On the date of occurrence, he, along with
Ram Kishan and Ram Sahay (PW-4), were returning on foot from
Belrayan market. At sunset, near the forest boundary of Dudhwa
National Park, accused Ram Bharosey emerged holding a country-made
pistol and accused Chugna and Guddu emerged holding knives. Accused
Ram Bharosey fired upon Ram Kishan, hitting him in the left chest,
whereupon he collapsed. Thereafter, the accused persons inflicted knife
blows upon Ram Kishan.
16. In his cross-examination, P.W. 1 explicitly deposed: "
चाकुओंसेतीनों
2-2, 3-3 ". He
मुलजिमानने वारकियेथेऔरफिरमौकेसेभागलियेथे।
categorically admitted that the Investigating Officer recorded his
statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C. for the first time 14 to 15 days after

7
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
the incident. He further conceded that at the time of the incident,
visibility in the forest was restricted to merely 25–30 paces.
17. P.W. 2, Jwala Singh (Independent Witness): In his examination-
in-chief, P.W. 2 deposed that he was employed as a seasonal watcher in
the forest department. On the fateful evening, he was returning from the
market and was walking approximately 150 to 200 yards behind the
deceased, Mishrilal and Ram Sahay. Upon hearing the sound of a
gunshot, he rushed forward and arrived at the spot last. He saw Ram
Kishan writhing in pain on the ground and only saw accused Chugna
fleeing with a knife in hand, while he could not identify the other two
fleeing persons. He specifically denied seeing any accused assaulting or
stabbing the deceased. The prosecution declared this witness hostile.
18. In his cross-examination by the State, he denied giving any
statement to the police that Ram Bharosey fired or that Chugna and
Guddu inflicted knife blows in his presence. Significantly, the counsel
appearing for accused Chugna conducted no cross-examination of this
witness and the cross-examination on his behalf was recorded as NIL.
19. P.W. 3, Roj Ali (Independent Witness): In his examination-in-
chief, P.W. 3 deposed that on the date of occurrence, he and Jwala Singh
were walking approximately one furlong (approx. 200 meters) behind
Ram Kishan, Mishrilal and Ram Sahay. He heard a gunshot and upon
alarms being raised, he ran to the spot. He saw the three accused persons
fleeing; Chugna had a knife, while Guddu and Ram Bharosey were
carrying bags. He testified: "
मैंनेकिसीभीमुलजिमकोफायरकरतेऔरचाकुओंसे
". He claimed that he carried the bleeding body of
मारपीटकरतेनहींदेखा
Ram Kishan on his back to Village Bhairampur and his clothes were
drenched in blood. The prosecution declared this witness hostile.
Significantly, the counsel appearing for accused Chugna conducted no
cross-examination of this witness and the cross-examination on his
behalf was recorded as NIL.
P.W. 4, Ram Sahay (Informant / Paternal Uncle of the Deceased):

8
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
20. In his examination-in-chief, P.W. 4 reiterated the prosecution version
that while returning from Belrayan market, accused Ram Bharosey fired
from a katta, hitting Ram Kishan in the chest and after he fell down,
accused Chugna and Guddu inflicted knife blows upon him.
21. In his cross-examination, P.W. 4 made vital admissions: (i) He
admitted that in the FIR (Exhibit Ka-1), he had specifically narrated that
all three accused persons assaulted the deceased with knives after he fell.
When confronted with this contradiction, he offered an explanation
stating that since Ram Bharosey had grappled with the deceased after he
fell, he had stated that all three stabbed him. (ii) He admitted that the
forest was dense and visibility was poor: "
जंगलघनाथा।जंगलमेंदूरकीचीज़
" (iii) He admitted that as soon as the gunshot was fired,
नहींदिखाईदेतीथी।
he and Mishrilal fled in fear in different directions: "
हमलोगभीइधरउधर
, "
भागनेलगे कोईविशेषदिशानहींबतासकता।
P.W. 5, Dr. S.K. Tewari (Autopsy Surgeon):
22. P.W. 5, Dr. S.K. Tewari, proved the Post-Mortem Examination
Report (Exhibit Ka-2) and deposed that external examination revealed
that the deceased was a moderately built male, aged about 35 years. He
further testified that upon conducting the autopsy, he noted as many as
ten ante-mortem injuries on the cadaver of the deceased, including an
incised wound measuring 3 cm x 0.5 cm x bone-deep over the left
forehead, situated 3 cm above the left eyebrow; an abrasion measuring 1
cm x 0.5 cm just above the medial end of the left eyebrow; an incised
wound measuring 2 cm x 1 cm x bone-deep, located 2 cm behind the left
ear; and another incised wound measuring 1.5 cm x 1 cm x bone-deep,
situated 1 cm below the aforesaid injury. He next noted two abrasions,
situated 1 cm apart from each other, each measuring 3 cm x 0.5 cm over
the left side of the face; a through-and-through incised wound measuring
1.5 cm x 0.3 cm near the left extremity of the upper lip; and another
through-and-through incised wound measuring 1.5 cm x 0.3 cm over the
left extremity of the lower lip. He further deposed that he observed an
incised wound measuring 2 cm x 1 cm x bone-deep slightly to the left

9
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
side on the chin; an incised wound measuring 3 cm x 1 cm x bone-deep
underneath the left jaw incised wound 2 cm x 1 cm bone deep below left
side of chin and multiple firearm wounds of entry grouped together in
an area of 8 cm x 7 cm on the left side upper chest, just above the nipple,
having a central aperture measuring 2 cm x 1 cm x chest cavity deep,
which was surrounded by multiple small entry wounds, each measuring
approximately 0.3 cm x 0.3 cm of variable depth.
23. On internal examination, the left pleura, left lung and pericardium
were found lacerated and 56 small metallic pellets along with 2 pellets
from the heart wall were extracted. The thoracic cavity contained 1.5
litres of fluid blood. Dr. Tewari categorically opined that the cause of
death was shock and haemorrhage resulting from ante-mortem firearm
injuries (Injury No. 10). Significantly, the cross-examination of Dr.
Tewari on behalf of accused Chugna was recorded as NIL. In cross-
examination by counsel for Ram Bharosey, the doctor admitted that the
knife injuries were incised wounds and not punctured or penetrating
wounds.
24. P.W. 6, H.C. Virendra Kumar Singh (Head Moharrir):
P.W. 6 proved the Chik FIR (Exhibit Ka-3) and GD Entry No. 32
(Exhibit Ka-4).
25. P.W. 7, S.O. Shakil Akhtar Khan (Investigating Officer):
P.W. 7 deposed regarding the steps taken during the investigation,
including preparation of the inquest report (Exhibit Ka-5), recovery of
the 12-bore spent cartridge (Exhibit Ka-12) and submission of the
charge-sheet.
26. In his cross-examination, P.W. 7 made significant admissions,
stating that he recorded the statement of the alleged eyewitness Mishrilal
(PW-1) under Section 161 Cr.P.C. on 19.10.1986, which was after an
unexplained delay of nearly 15 days from the date of the incident. He
further categorically admitted that witness Roj Ali (PW-3) had never
stated to him during investigation that he had carried the deceased Ram

10
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
Kishan on his back or that his clothes were soaked with blood, nor did he
observe any blood stains on the clothes of Roj Ali. He next admitted that
in the site plan (Exhibit Ka-11), he did not record the distance of the
forest boundary from the spot, nor did he indicate the path from which
the assailants emerged. He also admitted that no blood drops were found
on the pathway between the place of occurrence and Village Bhairampur.
27. Statements of Accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C. & Defence
Plea
After the closure of prosecution evidence, the incriminating
circumstances appearing against the accused persons were put to them
under Section 313 Cr.P.C.. All the accused-appellants denied the
allegations in toto, termed the prosecution evidence false and asserted
that they had been falsely implicated due to enmity stemming from the
forest timber incident. They chose not to lead any evidence in defence.
Submissions of the learned counsel for the parties
(I) Submissions on behalf of Appellant No. 1 (Chugna)
28. Sri Gaurav Verma, learned counsel appearing on behalf of
appellant no. 1 (Chugna) submitted that no specific role of assault has
been established against appellant no. 1 by any reliable independent
evidence, inasmuch as the independent witnesses, namely Jwala Singh
(PW-2) and Roj Ali (PW-3), who were allegedly present near the spot,
turned hostile and categorically refused to support the prosecution
version of the assault. At the most, their evidence only indicates that they
saw appellant Chugna running away from the spot, which by itself
cannot establish his participation in the homicidal assault. He further
submitted that the specific allegation of knife assault rests solely upon
the uncorroborated testimonies of close relatives, namely PW-4 (uncle)
and PW-1 (brother-in-law), whose statements suffer from material
improvements and contradictions, particularly when in the FIR (Exhibit
Ka-1), PW-4 had explicitly stated that all three accused persons inflicted
knife blows, whereas before the court, PW-4 contradicted his own FIR
by exonerating Ram Bharosey from the knife assault, while PW-1

11
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
persisted in deposing that all three accused inflicted knife blows and
such fatal contradictions completely demolish the credibility of the
ocular version.
29. He next submitted that the medical evidence completely excludes
any fatal injuries attributable to the knife, as the autopsy surgeon, Dr.
S.K. Tewari (PW-5), unequivocally established that the sole cause of
death was shock and haemorrhage resulting from the firearm injury to
the chest (Injury No. 10), which was attributed exclusively to Ram
Bharosey, whereas the incised wounds found on the face and chin
(Injuries No. 1 to 9) were merely superficial/bone-deep, did not
penetrate any internal vital organ and were incapable of causing death in
the ordinary course of nature. Further submission of learned counsel for
the appellant is that there is complete absence of evidence establishing
common intention under Section 34 IPC, as there is not a shred of
evidence to show any prior meeting of minds or pre-arranged plan to
commit murder and in the absence of proof that Chugna shared a
common intention with Ram Bharosey to commit murder, he cannot be
vicariously convicted under Section 302 IPC with the aid of Section 34
IPC.
30. He next submitted that there has been a patent failure to ensure
effective legal aid to appellant no. 1, resulting in violation of Article 21
of the Constitution of India, inasmuch as appellant Chugna remained an
indigent person incarcerated throughout the trial and was represented by
an Amicus Curiae appointed by the court, who conducted the defence in
a perfunctory and nominal manner by conducting NIL cross-examination
of PW-2, PW-3, PW-5 (Doctor) and PW-6 and merely asking four
innocuous questions of PW-1, which failure to provide effective legal
representation has caused grave prejudice to the appellant, thereby
vitiating the trial. Learned counsel for the appellant lastly submitted that
the alleged weapon of offence (knife) was never recovered by the
investigating agency and moreover, the site plan (Exhibit Ka-11)
demonstrates that the witnesses were situated at Point 'B', approximately
one furlong (200 meters) away from Point 'A' and at 6:30 P.M. in the

12
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
month of October inside a dense jungle, it was physically impossible to
observe the specific role of wielding a knife from a distance of 200
meters, which cumulative deficiencies render the prosecution case highly
doubtful against appellant no. 1.
(II) Submissions on Behalf of Appellant No. 2 (Ram Bharosey)
31. Sri Dheerendra Kumar Singh, learned counsel appearing on behalf
of appellant no. 2 (Ram Bharosey), submitted that the prosecution failed
to establish the identity of the shooter beyond reasonable doubt. He
argued that the FIR was lodged after immense deliberation and
consultation and the alleged motive regarding cutting forest wood was
trivial, especially when the matter had already been compounded before
the Forest Ranger. He further contended that independent witnesses PW-
2 and PW-3 did not support the shooting by Ram Bharosey and the
presence of PW-1 and PW-4 at the spot was highly doubtful, given the
fact that PW-1's statement was recorded after an unexplained delay of 15
days.
32. Learned counsel for the appellants also placed reliance upon the
judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court and High Courts in Sovaran
Singh Prajapati vs. State of U.P. (2025 SCC OnLine SC 351 : 2025
INSC 225), Tarun Sharma vs. State of Haryana (2025 INSC 1139)
and Raj Kumar @ Suman vs. State (NCT of Delhi) ((2023) 7 SCC
615 : 2023 INSC 520) contending that where direct fatal role is
attributed to another accused and the injuries attributed to the co-accused
are non-vital/superficial without any pre-arranged concert or common
intention, constructive liability under Section 302/34 IPC cannot be
fastened upon such co-accused.
(III) Submissions of Learned A.G.A. Appearing for the State
33. On the other hand, Sri Arunendra, learned A.G.A. appearing on
behalf of the State-respondent, vehemently contended that the
prosecution has successfully proved its case against the appellants
beyond all reasonable doubt. He submitted that the presence of PW-1
(Mishrilal) and PW-4 (Ram Sahay) on the spot was completely natural

13
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
and probable, inasmuch as they were returning together with the
deceased from the weekly Belrayan market after purchasing household
provisions and merely because they happen to be close relatives of the
deceased, their testimonies cannot be brushed aside or discarded out
rightly. In this regard, he placed reliance upon the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Gulab vs. State of U.P. (2021
SCC OnLine SC 1211) to contend that relationship is not a ground to
discard the ocular account if the testimony of such an interested witness
otherwise inspires confidence.
34. He further submitted that even though the independent witnesses,
namely PW-2 (Jwala Singh) and PW-3 (Roj Ali), were declared hostile
by the prosecution, their evidence cannot be effaced from the record in
toto and the same clearly corroborates the core of the prosecution case to
the effect that they heard the gunshot and immediately saw the accused
persons running away from the place of occurrence armed with weapons.
In support of this contention, learned A.G.A. placed reliance upon the
decision of the Apex Court in C. Muniappan & Ors. vs. State of Tamil
Nadu ((2010) 9 SCC 567) to submit that the settled legal proposition
permits reliance upon that part of the testimony of a hostile witness
which supports the prosecution story and further that mere lapses or
defective investigation on the part of the Investigating Officer cannot be
made a ground to extend the benefit of acquittal to the accused.
35. He next submitted that the non-recovery of the weapon of offence
(knife) is not fatal to the prosecution case, as the direct ocular testimony
of the eyewitnesses is fully available on record and fortified his
submission by citing the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Om Pal vs. State of U.P. (2025 INSC 1262) and Gulab (supra) .
Further submission of learned A.G.A. is that the ocular account stands
fully corroborated by the medical evidence, inasmuch as the 12-bore
empty cartridge recovered from the crime scene (Exhibit Ka-12)
squarely matches with the 56 small metallic pellets extracted from the
thoracic cavity of the deceased during autopsy and in this context, he
placed reliance upon Jagdish Narain & Anr. vs. State of U.P. ((1996) 8

14
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
SCC 199) to argue that the discharge of a firearm from close range
clearly establishes homicidal intent.
36. Learned A.G.A. lastly submitted that all three accused persons,
armed with lethal weapons including a firearm and knives, ambushed the
deceased together in a pre-planned manner and fled together into the
jungle after executing the crime, thereby fully attracting the mandate of
Section 34 IPC regarding shared common intention and therefore, the
learned trial court has committed no error whatsoever in convicting and
sentencing the appellants under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC
and the appeal, being devoid of merit, is liable to be dismissed.
Points for Determination
37. Upon hearing the learned counsel for the parties and perusing the
record, the following points emerge for determination in this appeal:
I. Whether the prosecution has succeeded in establishing the
charges under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC against
the appellants beyond reasonable doubt?
II. 38. Whether the failure of the court-appointed
Amicus Curiae to cross-examine material prosecution
witnesses (PW-2, PW-3, PW-5 and PW-6) caused grave
prejudice to appellant no. 1, thereby vitiating the trial?
III. Whether the findings and conviction recorded by the
learned trial court are sustainable in the eyes of law?
38. As all the aforesaid points for determination are intrinsically
interlinked, they are being taken up and considered collectively.
Discussions, Reasons and Conclusion Thereof
39. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the rival
submissions advanced by learned counsel for the parties and thoroughly
scrutinized the original trial court record.
40. At the outset, it is averred that deceased Ram Kishan was
employed as an ad-hoc forest watcher in Dudhwa National Park. While

15
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
he was discharging his duty, the deceased had caught accused persons
cutting and stealing forest timber. On that account, an altercation had
also taken place between them. The accused persons were taken to the
Range Officer, where they were let off upon tendering an apology.
Owing to that incident, the accused persons had enmity and a grudge
against the deceased.
41. Here, it is expedient to mention that motive is not a sine qua non
for the commission of a crime. Moreover, it takes a back seat in a case of
direct ocular account of the commission of the offence by a particular
person. In a case of direct evidence, the element of motive does not play
such an important role as to cast any doubt on the credibility of the
prosecution witnesses even if there be any doubts raised in this regard. If
the eyewitnesses are trustworthy, the motive attributed for the
commission of crime may not be of much relevance. Failure to prove
motive or absence of evidence on the point of motive would not be fatal
to the prosecution case when the other reliable evidence available on
record unerringly establishes the guilt of the accused. In this context,
reference may profitably be made to the series of authoritative
pronouncements rendered in Sanaullah Khan Vs. State of Bihar [2013
(81) ACC 302 (SC)], Subal Ghorai Vs. State of W.B. [(2013) 4 SCC
607], Deepak Verma Vs. State of H.P. [2012 (76) ACC 794 (SC)],
Durbal Vs. State of U.P. [2011 CrLJ 1106 (SC)], Brahmaswaroop Vs.
State of U.P. [AIR 2011 SC 280], Dharnidhar Vs. State of U.P. [2010
(6) SCJ 662], State of U.P. Vs. Nawab Singh [2005 SCC (Criminal)
33], Rambabujha Vs. State of U.P. [2003 (46) ACC 892 (Allahabad –
D.B.)], Shivraj Bapuray Jadhav Vs. State of Karnataka [(2003) 6
SCC 392], aur Thaman Kumar Vs. State of Union Territory of
Chandigarh [(2003) 6 SCC 380].
42. Keeping in view the above propounded legal propositions, as the
prosecution case rests upon entire ocular evidence and the prosecution
had adduced the motive with regard to commission of crime, which is
corroborated by the oral evidence, therefore, it cannot be said that the
prosecution could not assert and establish the motive for commission of

16
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
crime. Though it is not necessary in a case of direct evidence, as held in
the above rulings, therefore, we do not find any substance in the
argument or contentions raised by the learned counsel for the appellants
in this regard.
43. The foremost question that requires determination is the actual
cause of death of deceased Ram Kishan. The autopsy was conducted by
Dr. S.K. Tewari (PW-5), who proved the post-mortem report (Exhibit
Ka-2). A perusal of Exhibit Ka-2 and the testimony of PW-5 reveals that
the deceased sustained two distinct sets of injuries: (a) Firearm Injury
(Injury No. 10): Multiple firearm entry wounds on the left upper chest,
cavity deep, fracturing ribs, extensively lacerating the pleura, left lung
and pericardium, resulting in 1.5 litres of fluid blood in the chest cavity,
from which 56 small metallic pellets and 2 pellets from the heart were
retrieved. Dr. Tewari unequivocally opined that the cause of death was
shock and haemorrhage resulting from this chest firearm injury. (b)
Incised/Slash Wounds (Injuries No. 1 to 9): These injuries were situated
on the forehead, eyebrows, ear, lips, chin and mandible. In his cross-
examination, Dr. Tewari admitted that these were incised wounds and
not punctured or penetrating wounds. Crucially, internal examination of
the head and neck showed that the skull, brain and major blood vessels
were completely intact and healthy (NAD). Not a single internal vital
organ or major blood vessel in the neck or face was severed.
44. The medical evidence demonstrates that the cause of death of the
deceased was shock and haemorrhage resulting from ante-mortem
injuries. It is neither the case of the appellant-convicts nor is there any
material on record to infer that the alleged ante-mortem injuries were
suicidal or accidental in nature. The nature and site of the injuries found
on the person of the deceased clearly demonstrate that the death of the
deceased was homicidal, which stands fully corroborated by the ocular
evidence of the eyewitnesses. Thus, it can be safely concluded that the
death of the deceased was homicidal.

17
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
45. Now, it has to be seen as to who was responsible for causing the
death of the deceased and whether appellant-convicts Chugna and
Guddu, who are alleged to have inflicted blows with knives, are also
responsible for causing the death of the deceased.
46. Applying the settled legal principles to the present case, it is clear
from the record that a dispute arose out of an altercation in the forest
regarding timber cutting, which had already been settled before the
Forest Ranger. As per the recitals of the FIR, accused Chugna and
Guddu were armed with knives, while Ram Bharosey was armed with a
country-made pistol. Accused Ram Bharosey fired a single shot on Ram
Kishan from his country-made pistol and thereafter the remaining
accused persons inflicted blows with knives on him.
B. Principles Governing Joint Liability & Common Intention Under
Section 34 IPC
47. The crucial legal issue is whether appellant no. 1, Chugna, can be
held constructively liable under Section 302 IPC with the aid of Section
34 IPC. Section 34 of the IPC embodies the principle of joint liability in
the doing of a criminal act. To attract Section 34 IPC, two essential
conditions must be satisfied: (i) there must be a common intention to
commit the criminal act and (ii) there must be participation of the
accused in the commission of the offence in furtherance of that common
intention.
48. In this regard, it would be apposite to refer to the authoritative
pronouncement of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pandurang v. State of
Hyderabad ((1954) 2 SCC 826), wherein the Apex Court in paragraph
30 observed as under:
"30. Now in the case of Section 34 we think it is well
established that a common intention presupposes prior
concert. It requires a pre-arranged plan because before a man
can be vicariously convicted for the criminal act of another, the
act must have been done in furtherance of the common
intention of them all : Mahbub Shah v. King Emperor [Mahbub

18
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
Shah v. King Emperor, 1945 SCC OnLine PC 5 : (1944-45) 72
IA 148 at p. 154] , IA pp. 153-54. Accordingly there must have
been a prior meeting of minds. Several persons can
simultaneously attack a man and each can have the same
intention, namely, the intention to kill and each can
individually inflict a separate fatal blow and yet none would
have the common intention required by the section because
there was no prior meeting of minds to form a pre-arranged
plan. In a case like that, each would be individually liable for
whatever injury he caused but none could be vicariously
convicted for the act of any of the others; and if the
prosecution cannot prove that his separate blow was a fatal
one he cannot be convicted of the murder however clearly an
intention to kill could be proved in his case : Barendra Kumar
Ghosh v. King Emperor [Barendra Kumar Ghosh v. King
Emperor, 1924 SCC OnLine PC 49 : (1924-25) 52 IA 40 at p.
52] (at p. 49) and Mahbub Shah v. King Emperor [Mahbub
Shah v. King Emperor, 1945 SCC OnLine PC 5 : (1944-45) 72
IA 148 at p. 154] . As their Lordships say in the latter case :
(IA p. 154)"
49. Similarly, in Jai Bhagwan v. State of Haryana ((1999) 3 SCC
102), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held:
"10. To apply Section 34 IPC apart from the first thing that
there should be two or more accused, two factors must be
established: (i) common intention and (ii) participation of the
accused in the commission of an offence. If a common
intention is proved but no overt act is attributed to the
individual accused, Section 34 will be attracted as essentially
it involves vicarious liability but if participation of the
accused in the crime is proved and a common intention is
absent, Section 34 cannot be invoked. In every case, it is not
possible to have direct evidence of a common intention. It has
to be inferred from the facts and circumstances of each case."

19
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
50. In addition to the above, it would also be apposite to recapitulate
the landmark decision of the Privy Council in the case of Mahbub Shah
vs. King Emperor (Privy Council Appeal No. 64 of 1944, reported in
AIR 1945 PC 118), wherein it was held as under:
"The essence of the joint liability under section 34 of the
Indian Penal Code is to be found in the existence of a
common intention animating the accused leading to the
doing of a criminal act in furtherance of such intention. It
must be shown that the criminal act was done by one of
accused persons in the furtherance of the common intention
of all. 'Common intention' within the meaning of the section
implies a pre-arranged plan and to convict the accused of an
offence applying the section it should be proved that the
criminal act was done in concert pursuant to the pre-
arranged plan. The inference of common intention within the
meaning of the term in section 34 should never be reached
unless it is a necessary inference deducible from the
circumstances of the case. Same or similar intention must
not be confused with common intention."
51. Reiterating and expounding the aforesaid principle, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in the case of Krishnamurthy @ Gunodu and Others vs.
State of Karnataka (reported in (2022) 7 SCC 521), approving its
earlier decision in Surendra Chauhan vs. State of Madhya Pradesh
((2000) 4 SCC 110), observed as under:
"22. ... The essence of Section 34 is simultaneous consensus of
the minds of persons participating in the criminal action to
bring about a particular result. Such consensus can be
developed on the spot and thereby intended by all of them. The
existence of a common intention can be inferred from the
attending circumstances, the nature of the weapon used, the
site of the injuries and the conduct of the accused before,
during and after the occurrence."

20
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
52. We have also perused the decisions relied upon by the learned
counsel for the appellants, namely Sovaran Singh Prajapati ( supra ),
Tarun Sharma ( supra ) and Raj Kumar @ Suman ( supra ). In those
cases, the co-accused were exonerated of the charge under Section
302/34 IPC because the evidence therein clearly established that they
neither shared any common intention with the main assailant nor was
there any pre-concert and the fatal act was committed by an individual
accused on the spur of the moment beyond the scope of any common
design. However, the legal position is that the applicability of Section 34
IPC depends upon the peculiar facts and circumstances established in
each case. Where, as in the instant case, the accused emerged together
armed with lethal weapons (firearm and knives) and repeatedly assaulted
the victim on vital parts even after he collapsed, the ratio of Sovaran
Singh Prajapati ( supra ), Tarun Sharma ( supra ) and Raj Kumar @
Suman ( supra ) is clearly distinguishable on facts and does not come to
the rescue of the appellan ts.
C. Appreciation of Ocular Testimony & Role of Appellants
53. PW-1, Mishrilal, who was examined as an eyewitness to the
occurrence, deposed that on the fateful day, he, deceased Ram Kishan
and informant Ram Sahay were returning together from the Belrayan
market. As they reached near the boundary of the Dudhwa National Park
forest, the accused persons, namely Ram Bharosey, Chugna and Guddu,
suddenly emerged from the jungle. Out of them, Ram Bharosey was
armed with a country-made pistol, while Chugna and Guddu were armed
with knives. They started hurling abuses and accused Ram Bharosey
shot gunfire on Ram Kishan, which struck him on the left side of his
chest, causing him to fall down. Thereupon, the other accused persons
inflicted knife blows on him. In his cross-examination, he stated that
Ram Bharosey fired upon the deceased and the other accused persons
inflicted two to three knife blows on Ram Kishan. He reiterated that
Guddu and Chugna were having knives, while Ram Bharosey was armed
with a country-made pistol and when Ram Kishan fell down after

21
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
sustaining the firearm injury, Guddu and Chugna inflicted knife blows
on him.
54. Although PW-1, Mishrilal, is a real brother-in-law of the deceased
Ram Kishan as stated by him in examination-in-chief, that does not
mean that the testimony of any relative who had witnessed the incident
with his naked eyes could not be given importance. He has clearly stated
that he very well knows the accused persons Chugna, Guddu and Ram
Bharosey @ Bharosey. Accused Chugna had close friendship with the
remaining accused persons Guddu and Bharosey. He also stated that as a
watcher, it was the duty of deceased Ram Kishan to look after his area in
the jungle, to save the theft of wood and forest produce, to save the
forest from fire and to do his job effectively, he used to wander and
patrol in the jungle. Prior to this incident, the accused persons had cut
down woods from the jungle and the deceased made a complaint against
them to the Forest Ranger and also beat Guddu; therefore, they had
enmity towards him.
55. PW-1 was cross-examined deeply to check his veracity, wherein
he stated that when they were returning from Belrayan market, they were
moving side by side after some gap. When he had seen the accused
persons at first instance, they were present at a distance of three hands
('teen haath ki doori'). He repeated that suddenly Ram Bharosey fired
from gun which struck the chest of the deceased Ram Kishan and when
the deceased fell down, then the accused persons assaulted him with
knives. Here, it is also notable that this witness was cross-examined over
several days; therefore, it was natural for some minor deviation to occur
in his testimony. On being further cross-examined, he stated that only
Ram Bharosey was having a country-made pistol, while Guddu and
Chugna were armed with knives and Ram Bharosey had fired,
resultantly deceased Ram Kishan fell down, then Guddu and Chugna
inflicted knife blows, but Ram Bharosey did not inflict knife blows.
56. On behalf of accused Chugna, nothing substantial was suggested
or elicited in the cross-examination of this witness which could

22
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
demonstrate that he was not present at the time of the incident or that he
had not inflicted blows. The accused were having were deadly and lethal
weapons, which clearly demonstrates their intention. After the deceased
sustained the firearm injury, accused Chugna and Guddu inflicted
repeated knife blows on him. If they had no intention to kill the deceased
or if there was no prior concert among them, then no occasion would
have arisen to inflict repeated knife blows after the deceased had already
collapsed upon sustaining a gunshot injury. Here, it is also to be made
clear that all the injuries inflicted with the knives were found on the
upper vital parts of the body of the deceased, including the forehead,
cheek, lips, chin and mandible. Thus, the lethal weapons used and the
seats of the injuries on the body clearly demonstrate their intention. One
more aspect of the matter is that to determine participation in the
commission of an offence with common intention, the separate intensity
of each individual weapon is not to be considered in isolation; rather, it
has to be seen in totality. The fact that the persons who were armed with
knives inflicted repeated blows on the fallen victim demonstrates their
shared common intention to cause his death. Thus, in view of the law
cited above, on a perusal of the testimony of the witnesses and attending
circumstances, it stands firmly established that in causing the death of
the deceased, there was a shared common intention of the accused
persons.
D. Analysis of Contradictions, Conduct of Witnesses & Minor
Discrepancies
57. Learned counsel for the appellants emphasized on the
inconsistencies which occurred in the testimony of the prosecution
witnesses. As per the FIR, the armed persons inflicted blows with knives
and the deceased fell down. PW-1, who was examined as an eyewitness,
deposed in his evidence in examination-in-chief that after the deceased
fell on the ground, the accused persons inflicted knife blows. But during
cross-examination, he stated that only Ram Bharosey was armed with a
country-made pistol, while Guddu and Chugna were having knives;
accused Ram Bharosey shot with a gun on Ram Kishan, resultantly he

23
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
fell down and then Guddu and Chugna inflicted knife blows on him and
Ram Bharosey did not inflict a knife blow.
58. Here, it is to be made clear that contradictions and inconsistencies
which do not corrode the core or genesis of the prosecution case cannot
be given much importance.
59. In the case of Ramesh Harijan vs. State of U.P. ((2012) 5 SCC
777) , the Hon'ble Apex Court held that normal discrepancies in evidence
are bound to occur due to human fallibility and unless they affect the
core of the prosecution case, the testimony of a witness cannot be
rejected.
60. Similarly, in C. Muniappan vs. State of Tamil Nadu (2010 (6)
SCJ 822 : (2010) 9 SCC 567) , the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that if
there are no material discrepancies or contradictions in the testimony of
a witness, his evidence cannot be disbelieved merely on the basis of
some normal, natural, or minor contradictions, inconsistencies,
exaggerations, or embellishments.
61. The distinction between material discrepancies and normal
discrepancies is that while minor discrepancies do not corrode the
credibility of a party's case, material discrepancies do so. In the present
case, where this witness was cross-examined at length on several dates,
some deviation was naturally bound to occur. However, he remained
consistent on the material fact that accused Chugna and Guddu inflicted
knife blows, while accused Ram Bharosey discharged the firearm. There
is no deformity or contradiction regarding the specific role of accused
Ram Bharosey firing from the country-made pistol and accused Chugna
and Guddu using knives. Therefore, the minor inconsistencies which
occurred between the recitals of the FIR and the oral depositions have
got no much importance, as they do not corrode the prosecution case.
62. Ram Sahay, PW-4, who is the informant and author of this case,
has also claimed to be an eyewitness of this incident. He deposed that on
the fateful day, he was returning from Belrayan market along with Ram
Kishan and Mishrilal at about 6:00 P.M. When they reached the

24
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
Bhairampur jungle, suddenly Chugna, Ram Bharosey and Guddu
emerged out. Of them, Ram Bharosey was armed with a country-made
pistol, while Chugna and Guddu were having knives. They hurled abuses
at Ram Kishan and Ram Bharosey inflicted a gunshot injury on him.
When he fell down, Chugna and Guddu inflicted knife blows on him. He
also stated that he had got scribed the written tahreer (Exhibit Ka-1)
from one Shri Ram, who wrote on his dictation and the same was given
to the police station.
63. PW-4 further stated that the deceased was his nephew, who was on
duty as a watchman in the jungle. Prior to this incident, deceased Ram
Kishan had caught accused Chugna and Guddu cutting wood, had beaten
them and made a complaint to the Forest Ranger. On being cross-
examined, he stated that Ram Bharosey had not been caught cutting
wood on that earlier occasion and that Guddu used to cut wood. Here,
some minor discrepancy has occurred with regard to the cutting of wood
by the accused persons, but it is not so significant that their presence and
specific roles in the present incident can be doubted. He categorically
stated that Ram Bharosey fired the gun and at that time, Ram Bharosey
was 8 to 10 paces away from him. When deceased Ram Kishan fell
down, the remaining two accused persons used knives to inflict injuries
on the deceased, whereas Ram Bharosey did not use a knife. Guddu and
Chugna were having knives and he had stated this fact in the FIR.
Chugna and Guddu were close friends for the past 3 to 4 years. Chugna
had inflicted 2 to 3 knife blows. PW-4 also stated that he could not make
an endeavour to defend the deceased, since he himself had to run to save
his own life.
64. Now, the question arises that when the deceased was being caused
injuries, why this witness and the other accompanying witness did not
come forward to protect him.
65. In this regard, the law is very much clear. In the case of Rana
Pratap and Others vs. State of Haryana ((1983) 3 SCC 327) , the

25
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
Hon'ble Supreme Court, while dealing with the natural behaviour and
conduct of eyewitnesses, held as under:
"6. ... Every person who witnesses a murder reacts in his own
way. Some are stunned, become speechless and stand rooted
to the spot. Some become hysteric and start wailing. Some
start shouting for help. Others run away to keep themselves as
far removed from the spot as possible. Yet others rush to the
rescue of the victim, even going to the extent of counter-
attacking the assailants. Every one reacts in his own special
way. There is no set rule of natural reaction. To discard the
evidence of a witness on the ground that he did not react in
any particular manner is to appreciate evidence in a wholly
unrealistic and unimaginative way."
66. This witness has stated that when Ram Kishan fell down after
sustaining the gunshot, he and the other witnesses started wandering and
running here and there and could not confront the armed assailants. This
conduct does not negate his presence on the spot as the law is very much
clear. Thus, there is no infirmity or material contradiction regarding the
specific role of accused Ram Bharosey firing from the pistol and accused
Chugna and Guddu using knives. The minor discrepancies occurring in
their testimony are not of such a nature which could corrode the core of
the prosecution case, rather there is uniformity in their statements with
regard to mode and active participation of accused persons, which is
convincing and establishes their common intention to eliminate the
deceased.
67. In so far as the submission of learned counsel for the appellants
with regard to the delayed examination of witnesses during investigation
is concerned, here it is made clear that if the Investigating Officer has
committed any error or delay in conducting the investigation, that does
not adversely affect the prosecution case. Where in the trial the witnesses
have deposed their evidence, then if any delay was caused by the I.O. in
recording their statements during investigation, their testimony on this

26
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
basis cannot be doubted, particularly when the informant, who is also an
eyewitness, promptly lodged the FIR, supported the prosecution case and
specifically named the witnesses in the report.
68. In this regard, in the case of Firoz Khan Akbarkhan v. State of
Maharashtra, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 627, the Hon’ble Apex Court has
held that delayed examination of a witness by the Investigating Officer
cannot be a ground to discard his otherwise credible and trustworthy
ocular account. The relevant observations are reproduced herein below: -
“Insofar as the delay of 2/3 days in recording the statements of
the eye-witnesses under Section 161 of the Criminal Procedure
Code, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Code’) is
concerned, the said delay has been thoroughly explained by the
witnesses, including the Investigating Officer, to the effect that
there were riots in the area. On this score, the Investigating
Officer was involved in maintaining law and order in the
affected area. In the attendant facts and circumstances, the
course of action adopted by the police cannot be termed
unjustified and no adverse inference can be drawn on this
count. No doubt that Court has laid down that an inordinate
delay in recording witness statements can prove to be fatal for
the prosecution, as pointed out by three learned Judges in
Ganesh Bhavan Patel v. State of Maharashtra, (1978) 4 SCC
371; however, therein, the delay in recording statements of the
material witnesses was accompanied by a delay in registering
of the FIR and the surrounding circumstances, which led the
Court to hold that there was a ‘a cloud of suspicion on the
credibility of the entire warp and woof of the prosecution
story.’ In Jagjit Singh v. State of Punjab, (2005) 3 SCC 689 and
State of A.P. v. S Swarnalatha, (2009) 8 SCC 383, the Court
held in favour of the convict/accused, as the inordinate delays
therein could not be sufficiently explained. Delay of about 27
days, in a case where communal violence had broken out, was
held not fatal, in Lal Bahadur v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2013) 4

27
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
SCC 557. Delay of over 2 years in recording witness
statements was deemed not fatal, when explained, in Baldev
Singh v. State of Punjab, (2014) 12 SCC 473. Delay in
recording witness statements was held not fatal per se in Sunil
Kumar v. State of Rajasthan, (2005) 9 SCC 283 and V K
Mishra v. State of Uttarakhand, (2015) 9 SCC 588. Delay in
recording statements of witnesses was held to have cast serious
doubts on the prosecution version in Shahid Khan v. State of
Rajasthan, (2016) 4 SCC 96 and Jafarudheen v. State of
Kerala, (2022) 8 SCC 440. It was held, in Goutam Joardar v.
State of W. B., (2022) 17 SCC 549, by a Coordinate Bench that
‘there was some delay in recording the statements of the
eyewitnesses concerned but mere factum of delay by itself
cannot result in rejection of their testimonies.’ Per our
understanding, Ganesh Bhavan Patel (supra) is not an
authority to contend that delay in recording witness statements
is always fatal to the prosecution's case. Thus, stricto sensu,
delay in recording witness statements, moreso when the said
delay is explained, will not aid an accused. Of course, no hard-
and-fast principle in this regard ought to be or can be laid
down, as delay, if any, in recording statements will have to be
examined by the Court concerned in conjunction with the
peculiar facts of the case before it. Our reading of the above
shall apply on all fours to delays in the context of Section 164
of the Code.”
E. Evidentiary Value of Hostile Witnesses (PW-2 & PW-3)
69. Now, coming to the evidence of the witnesses who were declared
hostile, the law is very clear in this regard.
70. In the case of Siddhartha Vashisht @ Manu Sharma vs. State
(NCT of Delhi) ((2010) 69 ACC 833 : (2010) 6 SCC 1), it was held that
if the prosecution witness has turned hostile, the court may rely upon so

28
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
much of his testimony which supports the case of the prosecution and is
corroborated by other evidence.
71. Similarly in Veer Singh vs. State of U.P. ((2014) 2 SCC 455) and
Shyamal Ghosh vs. State of West Bengal ((2012) 7 SCC 646), it was
held that the evidence of a hostile witness cannot be rejected outrightly
and both parties are entitled to rely on such part of his evidence which
assists their case.
72. Keeping in mind the law propounded by the Apex Court in the
above rulings, on a perusal of the record, it reveals that two witnesses
who were examined as eyewitnesses, namely PW-2 and PW-3, turned
hostile.
73. Jwala Singh (PW-2) deposed that at the time of the alleged
incident, he was on the duty of watcher in Dudhwa National Park. On
that fateful day, he, Ram Kishan, Mishrilal, Ram Sahay and Roj Ali had
gone to the Belrayan market and were returning. On way back, they
were behind each other. He heard gunfire and Ram Sahay made an
alarm. He rushed towards the place of occurrence and saw that the body
of Ram Kishan was lying, who was writhing in pain (chhatpata raha tha).
He also stated that he had seen a knife in the hand of accused Chugna
who was fleeing away and two other miscreants were also fleeing, but he
could not identify them.
74. On being cross-examined after being declared hostile, he denied
the statement given to the I.O. during investigation. Thus, from his
testimony, it reveals that although he had not seen the initial firing by
Ram Bharosey, he had seen accused Chugna having a knife and two
other persons fleeing from the spot while the deceased was lying there,
meaning thereby, even if we do not give importance to his testimony as
an eyewitness, his testimony is admissible as circumstantial evidence.
Thus, this part assists the prosecution.
75. In the same manner, Roj Ali (PW-3) stated that he heard the
gunshot and saw the accused persons fleeing from the spot, with Chugna
carrying a knife. Thus, the testimony of both these witnesses cannot be

29
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
rejected outrightly. That portion of their testimony which corroborates
the presence of the accused at the crime scene, their possession of
weapons and their flight immediately after the incident provides
corroboration to the prosecution case and assists the prosecution.
F. Legal Aid Representation & Non-Recovery of Weapon
76. So far as the submission of learned counsel for appellant no. 1
regarding the failure of the court-appointed Amicus Curiae to cross-
examine certain witnesses is concerned, from a perusal of the record, it
emerges that appellant no. 1 was duly represented by an advocate
provided through legal aid. The testimony of the witnesses of fact was
thoroughly tested in cross-examination by the learned counsel appearing
on behalf of co-accused Ram Bharosey, whose interest was identical on
the point of occurrence, time, place and identity of the assailants.
Furthermore, no failure of justice or specific prejudice has been
demonstrated to have been caused to the appellant. Mere brevity or
economy in cross-examination by an advocate cannot vitiate an
otherwise proved and established trial.
77. So far as the non-recovery of the knife and country-made pistol is
concerned, it is a settled proposition of law that non-recovery of the
weapon of offence is not fatal to the prosecution case where the charge is
established by cogent and reliable direct ocular testimony, supported by
medical evidence. In this regard, in the case of Mrityunjoy Biswas vs.
Pranab @ Koti Biswas and another (AIR 2013 SC 3334 : (2013) 12
SCC 796, the Hon'ble Apex Court held that when there is ample
unimpeachable ocular evidence corroborated by medical evidence, mere
non-recovery of weapon from the accused does not affect the
prosecution case relating to murder. In the present case, the ocular
testimony of PW-1 and PW-4 is fully corroborated by the post-mortem
report (Exhibit Ka-2), which recorded as many as nine incised and slash
wounds on the face, chin and neck of the deceased, alongside the fatal
firearm entry wound on the chest.
Findings & Conclusions of the Court

30
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
78. Thus, upon a holistic consideration of the entire facts,
circumstances and evidence available on record, we find that the
prosecution has successfully established its case beyond all reasonable
doubt against both appellant no. 1 (Chugna) and appellant no. 2 (Ram
Bharosey). All the accused persons, armed with deadly weapons,
ambushed the deceased together in the jungle pursuant to prior enmity,
executed the crime jointly by firing upon him and inflicting repeated
knife blows on vital parts of his body and fled together. Their shared
common intention to commit the murder of Ram Kishan stands firmly
established within the meaning of Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code.
The learned Trial Court has meticulously analyzed the evidence in its
correct legal perspective and the findings of conviction recorded by the
Trial Court suffer from no illegality, infirmity, or perversity. Therefore,
no interference is warranted by this Court with the impugned judgment
of conviction and sentence.
ORDER
79. In view of the aforesaid discussion, the present Criminal Appeal is
hereby dismissed.
80. The impugned judgment and order of conviction and sentence
dated 28.02.1989 passed by the learned II Additional Sessions Judge,
Lakhimpur Kheri in Sessions Trial No. 59 of 1987 (State vs. Chugna)
and Sessions Trial No. 225 of 1988 (State vs. Ram Bharosey and
Guddu), convicting and sentencing the appellants, namely Chugna
(Appellant No. 1) and Ram Bharosey (Appellant No. 2), to undergo
Rigorous Imprisonment for Life under Section 302 read with Section 34
of the Indian Penal Code, is hereby upheld and affirmed. The appeal in
respect of Appellant No. 3 (Guddu) has already abated vide earlier order
of this Court on account of his death.
81. As per the record, appellant no. 1, Chugna, is currently lodged in
jail. He shall remain in custody to serve out the remaining sentence of
life imprisonment awarded to him.

31
CRLA No. - 192 of 1989
82. As per the record, appellant no. 2, Ram Bharosey, was released on
personal bond and undertaking in October 2023. His personal bond and
bail bonds are hereby cancelled and his sureties are discharged. He shall
be taken into custody forthwith to serve out the remaining sentence of
life imprisonment awarded to him.
83. Any application pending in this criminal appeal shall also stand
disposed of accordingly.
84. Let the original trial court record along with a certified copy of
this judgment and order be transmitted forthwith to the learned trial
court, Lakhimpur Kheri for immediate necessary and strict compliance.
(Pramod Kumar Srivastava,J.) (Abdul Moin,J.)
November 17, 2026
Haseenuddin
Digitally signed by :-
HASEENUDDIN
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad,
Lucknow Bench