AKASH AHMAD LONE TH.HIS FATHER vs UNION TERRITORY OF J AND K (HOME) AND OTHERS
- Court
- Jammu and Kashmir High Court
Serial No.05
Regular Cause List
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
Reserved on : 05.11.2026
Pronounced on : 17.11.2026
Uploaded on : 18.11.2026
Whether the operative part
or full judgment is pronounced: Full
LPA No. 101/2026 in [HCP No. 85/2025]
AKASH AHMAD LONE TH. HIS
FATHER.
…Appellant/Petitioner(s)
Through: Mr. G.N. Shaheen, Advocate with
Mr. Asif Nabi, Advocate.
Vs.
UT OF J&K AND OTHERS.
...Respondent(s)
Through: Mr. Jahangir Dar GA.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHD YOUSUF WANI, JUDGE
ORDER
17.11.2026
Sanjeev Kumar ‘J’:
01. This intra-court appeal under Clause 12 of the Letters Patent
filed by the appellant is directed against an order and
judgment dated 8th of May, 2026, passed by a Learned Single
Judge of this Court [(“the writ court”)] in HCP No. 85 of
2025, titled Akash Ahmad Lone versus Union Territory of Jammu
and Kashmir and Others , whereby the writ court has dismissed
a Habeas Corpus petition filed by the appellant to assail his
detention ordered by the District Magistrate, Pulwama, vide
LPA No. 101/2026 in HCP No. 85/2025 Page 1 of 8
its order bearing No. 14/DMP/PSA/25, dated 30th of April,
2025.
02. The impugned judgment has been challenged by the
appellant primarily on the ground that the writ court has not
appreciated that there was total non-application of mind on
the part of the detaining authority to arrive at the satisfaction
that the detention of the appellant was necessitated to
prevent him from indulging in activities prejudicial to the
security of the State, and that the writ court also failed to
appreciate that the right of the appellant to make an effective
representation against his detention was impaired because of
the supply of grounds of detention which were vague,
indefinite, and without material particulars.
03. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondents
would urge that all the grounds of challenge urged on behalf
of the appellant have been duly considered by the writ court,
and the writ court has, by reference to the original detention
record produced before it, come to the conclusion that all
procedural formalities and constitutional safeguards were
adhered to by the detaining authority, and therefore there
was no warrant for interfering with the order of detention
impugned in the writ petition.
04. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record, we are of the considered opinion that the judgment
passed by the writ court is not sustainable in law, in that the
LPA No. 101/2026 in HCP No. 85/2025 Page 2 of 8
writ court has not clearly appreciated the fact that the
grounds of detention served upon the appellant were devoid
of any definite particulars enabling the appellant to make an
effective representation.
05. A quick look at the grounds of detention served upon the
appellant would show that there is reference to an activity
attributed to the appellant that took place in the year 2023. It
is alleged that one militant, namely Yasir Parray, with the
help of one Pakistani handler, namely Ilyas Pakistani, was
contemplating to bring weapons in his truck from
Gurdaspur, Punjab, and that the appellant rendered
assistance and logistic support to them, like providing food,
shelter, and other information about the movement of police
and security forces. There is nothing more stated in the
grounds of detention as to whether Yasir Parray ever moved
to Punjab and even tried to bring weapons in his truck to the
State of Jammu and Kashmir. Whether or not there is any
report or FIR registered in any police station is also not
forthcoming from the grounds of detention. The allegations
which pertain to the year 2023, besides being vague and
indefinite, were also stale, in that neither any case was
registered against the appellant in the year 2023 for his
alleged activities, nor was he taken under preventive
detention under the J&K Public Safety Act.
LPA No. 101/2026 in HCP No. 85/2025 Page 3 of 8
06. There is also reference to the appellant having been taken in
preventive custody on 31st of October, 2024, and 11th of
April, 2025 under Section 126 BNSS, in which he was
probably asked to execute bonds for keeping peace and good
behavior. There is, however, nothing in the grounds of
detention to indicate that after the appellant submitted the
bonds for keeping peace and good behavior, he again
indulged in any unlawful activity prejudicial to the security,
integrity, or sovereignty of the State.
07. There is only a bald allegation that the appellant was
working as an Over Ground Worker (OGW) and providing
logistic support like shelter, food, and transportation, etc., to
the militants. Not even a single instance has been mentioned
as to where, when, and to whom such support was ever
provided. There is no reference even to intelligence inputs
received from any quarter.
08.
Viewed thus, it can be safely said that the grounds of
detention, on the basis of which the appellant was taken in
preventive detention, are totally vague, indefinite, and
lacking material particulars. It is because of such vague,
indefinite, ambiguous, and insufficiently specific grounds
that the appellant has been deprived of his right to make an
effective representation to the competent authority against
his detention.
LPA No. 101/2026 in HCP No. 85/2025 Page 4 of 8
09. The constitutional requirement envisaged under Article 22(5)
of the Constitution of India is not merely that the detenue
should be informed of the grounds of detention, but the
grounds of detention must be communicated with sufficient
clarity and particulars to enable the detenue to understand
the allegations and effectively controvert them. The grounds
would be vague, indefinite, and ambiguous if they do not
disclose the specific date, time, and place of the alleged
activities; where the nature and particulars of the alleged
prejudicial activities are not indicated; or where the specific
role attributed to the detenue with sufficient clarity is not
indicated.
10. In the instant case, we have, on the reading of the grounds
of detention, come to a conclusion that the grounds of
detention were general in nature and did not indicate the
material particulars constituting activities attributed to the
appellant and perceived by the detaining authority as
prejudicial to the interest of the security of the State.
11. In the case of Mohammad Yousuf Rather versus State of Jammu
and Kashmir , AIR 1979 Supreme Court 1925, a three-judge
bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court enunciated the
principle underlying Article 22(5) of the Constitution in the
following words:
LPA No. 101/2026 in HCP No. 85/2025 Page 5 of 8
“A law providing for preventive detention and action taken
under such a law, to pass muster, have to satisfy the
requirements of both Articles 19 and 22 of the Constitution of
India. The interpretation of Article 22(5) consistently
adopted by this Court is, perhaps, one of the outstanding
contributions of the Court in the cause of human rights. The
law is now well settled that a detenue has two rights under
Article 22(5) of the Constitution: (1) to be informed, as soon
as may be, of the grounds on which the order of detention is
based, that is, the grounds which led to the subjective
satisfaction of the detaining authority, and (2) to be afforded
the earliest opportunity of making a representation against
the order of detention, that is, to be furnished with sufficient
particulars to enable him to make a representation which, on
being considered, may obtain relief to him. The inclusion of
an irrelevant or non-existent ground among other relevant
grounds is an infringement of the first of the rights, and the
inclusion of an obscure or vague ground among other clear
and definite grounds is an infringement of the second of the
rights. In either case, there is an invasion of the
constitutional rights of the detenue entitling him to approach
the Court for relief. The reason for saying that the inclusion
of even a single irrelevant or obscure ground among several
relevant and clear grounds is an invasion of the detenue's
constitutional right is that the Court is precluded from
adjudicating upon the sufficiency of grounds, and it cannot
substitute its objective decision for the subjective satisfaction
of the detaining authority...”
LPA No. 101/2026 in HCP No. 85/2025 Page 6 of 8
12. From the above exposition of law, it is evident that the test is
whether the detenue was placed in a position to
meaningfully and effectively controvert the allegations, and
not merely whether the grounds were physically served. It is
thus imperative that the grounds of detention must contain
sufficient particulars and relevant material so as to enable the
detenue to understand the basis of his detention and to
effectively controvert the same. Where the allegations are
couched in vague, indefinite, or general terms without
disclosing the necessary particulars of the alleged activities,
the detenue is left guessing as to the precise allegations
which he is required to meet. Such a situation would
necessarily frustrate the very object of affording an
opportunity to the detenue to make a representation and
would render the constitutional safeguard illusory. The
inevitable consequence would be an infringement of the
fundamental right granted under Article 22(5) of the
Constitution, thereby vitiating the order of detention.
13. Viewed thus, we find merit in this appeal, and the same is
accordingly allowed . The judgment impugned passed by the
writ court is set aside. The detention of the appellant made
by the District Magistrate, Pulwama, vide order No.
14/DMP/PSA/25 dated 30th of April, 2025, is held bad and
quashed. Respondents shall release the detenue forthwith
from preventive detention if not required in any other case.
LPA No. 101/2026 in HCP No. 85/2025 Page 7 of 8
(MOHD YOUSUF WANI) (SANJEEV KUMAR)
JUDGE JUDGE
SRINAGAR
17.11.2026
“Shaista-PS”
Whether the Judgment is Speaking Yes
Whether the Judgment is Reportable Yes
LPA No. 101/2026 in HCP No. 85/2025 Page 8 of 8