Inderchand Kochar and another vs AVR Properties and Developers Pvt Ltd.,

Court
Madras High Court

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RESERVED ON
PRONOUNCED ON
30.07.2026
12.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE K.KUMARESH BABU
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026
AND
Arb.A.Nos. 1461 & 1462 of 2026
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No.370 & 373 of 2026
1.Mr.Inderchand Kochar
2.Mr.Jitesh Kumar Kochar ... Petitioners in Arb.O.P.No.370/2026
1.Mr.Dhanraj N Kochar
2.Mr.Jitesh Kumar Kochar ... Petitioners in Arb.O.P.No.373/2026
Vs.
1.M/s.A.V.R.Properties and Developers Pvt., Ltd.,
Rep., by its Managing Director,
No.1-C, Sorrento Enclave,
7/4, Sardar Patel Road,
Adyar, Chennai – 600 020.
2.Mr.J.Sekar ... Respondents in Arb.O.P.No.370
& 373 of 2026
PRAYER in Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) No.370 & 373 of 2026:- Arbitration
Original Petition filed under Section 11(5) of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 seeking to appoint a sole Arbitrator to enter upon reference and
decide the disputes between the parties in accordance with Clause 12 of the
Memorandum of Mortgage by Deposit of Original Title Deeds dated 24.11.2009
& 29.11.2010 entered into between the petitioners and the first respondent.
Arb.A.Nos. 1461 & 1462 of 2026
1.Mr.Inderchand Kochar
2.Mr.Jitesh Kumar Kochar ... Petitioners in Arb.A.No.1461/2026
Page 1 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
vs.
1.M/s.A.V.R.Properties and Developers Pvt., Ltd.,
Rep., by its Managing Director,
No.1-C, Sorrento Enclave,
7/4, Sardar Patel Road,
Adyar, Chennai – 600 020.
2.Mr.J.Sekar
3.The Special District Revenue Officer (LA),
Oragadam-Irungattukottai Expansion Scheme,
SIPCOT, Pillaippakkam Village,
Sriperumbudur Taluk,
Kancheepuram District – 602 105. ... Respondents in Arb.A.No.1461
& 1462 of 2025
PRAYER in Arb.A.No.1461 & 1462 of 2025:- Applications filed to grant an
order of interim injunction restraining the third respondent being the acquisition
authority from disbursing, releasing or paying any compensation amount, in
respect of the lands under acquisition situated at Maduramangalam village,
Sriperumbudur Taluk, Kancheepuram District being the mortgaged properties
morefully described in the schedule hereto, in favour of the first respondent or
the second respondent or anyone claiming under or through the first respondent
or the second respondent, pending disposal of the arbitration proceedings
proposed to be initiated by the applicants.
In both Arb.O.P.(COM.DIV.) & Applications:-
For Petitioner(s): Mr.K.V.Babu
for Mrs.Dipthi Munoth.A
For Respondent(s): Mr.Abdul Saleem Sr., Counsel for
Mr.N.Sakthivel for R1
Mr.Nithyaesh Nataraj for R2
Mr.K.Palaniappan for R3 in both Arb.Applns
Page 2 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
COMMON ORDER
The present Arbitration Original Petitions have been filed seeking this
court to appoint a Sole Arbitrator to enter upon reference and decide the
disputes between the parties in accordance with Clause 12 of memorandum of
Mortgage by Deposit of Original Title Deeds dated 24.11.2009 and 29.11.2010
entered into between the petitioners and the first respondent.
2. The Arb. Applications have been filed seeking an order of interim
injunction restraining the third respondent being the Acquisition Authority from
disbursing, releasing or paying any compensation amount, in respect of the
lands under acquisition situated at Maduramangalam Village, Sriperumbudur
Taluk, Kancheepuram District being the mortgaged properties morefully
st nd
described in the schedule thereto, in favour of the 1 respondent or the 2
st nd
respondent or anyone claiming under or through the 1 respondent or the 2
respondent, pending disposal of the arbitration proceedings initiated by the
Applicants.
3. The facts giving rise to the present case is that the first respondent a
private limited company engaged in a real estate business and development
activities had borrowed two loans by the way of mortgage from the first
petitioner herein, who is engaged in the business of real estate and finance for a
sum of Rs.1.5 Crores and Rs.3 Crores, pursuant to which two Memorandums of
Page 3 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
Mortgage by Deposit of Original Title Deeds dated 24.11.2009 and 29.11.2010
were entered upon respectively by both the parties. The first respondent herein
had been irregular in making their payments towards the interest and further
continuously requested grace period for repaying the mortgage loans. Thereafter
the first respondent vide its letter dated 12.01.2021 had informed the petitioners
that the first respondent had entered into Sale Agreement dated 02.08.2014 with
the second respondent with respect to the entire property situated in
Maduramanagalam Village which is inclusive of the properties, those listed in
both the Mortgage Deeds. Thereafter the disputes arose between the parties and
the petitioners had filed the present Arbitration Original Petitions invovking the
Arbitration Clause present in the Mortgage Deeds dated 24.11.2009 and
29.11.2010..
4. Heard Mr.K.V.Babu learned counsel appearing for Mrs.Dipthi
Munoth.A learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Petitioners/ Applicants,
Mr.Abdul Saleem learned Senior Counsel for Mr.N.Sakthivel learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the first respondent, Mr. Nithyaesh Natraj learned
counsel for second respondent, in both the Arbitration Original Petitions and the
Arbitration Application and Mr.K.Palaniappan learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the third respondent in Arbitration Application.
5. Mr.K.V.Babu learned counsel for the petitioners, would submit that the
Page 4 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
first petitioner was approached by the first respondent, with whom the petitioner
had a long standing business relationship and acquaintance, for financial
assistance in two subsequent years, namely, sum of Rs.1.50 Crores in the year
2009 and Rs.3.00 Crores in the year 2010. Thereafter the first petitioner had
loaned the said amounts by the way of mortgage with an agreed interest rate at
18% per annum on the Principal Amount and additional interest on arrears at
the rate of 12% per annum. Pursuant to which the first petitioner had entered
into two Memorandums of Mortgage by the Deposit of Original Title Deeds
(hereinafter referred to as the ‘Mortgage Deeds’) dated 24.11.2009 and
29.11.2010 for the loan amounts of Rs.1.50 Crore and Rs.3.00 Crores
respectively. He submits that the first respondent had neither paid the interests
to the loan amounts regularly nor had repaid the principal loan amounts, instead
the first respondent had always sought for time extensions and grace periods
from the petitioner, which was also granted by the petitioner owing to the long
standing business relationship between them.
6. Thereafter to the utter shock and dismay of the petitioners the first
respondent had sent a letter dated 12.01.2021, informing the petitioners that the
respondent had entered into a Sale Agreement dated 02.08.2014 with the second
respondent, with respect to the entire immovable property situated in the
Maduramangalam Village, which included the properties listed in both the
Mortgage Deeds dated 24.11.2009 and 29.11.2010. The said letter further
Page 5 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
discloses that the first respondent had further received an advance amount of
Rs.2 Crores and a General Power of Attorney dated 06.01.2016 was executed in
favour of the second respondent, registered as Doc.No.56 of 2016. The letter
had further stated that the first respondent had verified the mortgage accounts
and instructed the second respondent to settle the outstanding loan amount and
deduct the same from the sale consideration. He submits that the first
respondent further undertook to repay the loan either by itself or through the
second respondent on or before 31.12.2023.
7. The learned counsel submits that the above act of the first respondent
of entering into an unregistered Sale Agreement and Registered General Power
of Attorney with a second respondent, in regard with the properties listed under
both the Mortgage Deeds dated 24.11.2009 and 29.11.2010, without any prior
information to the petitioners amounts to gross violation of the Terms of
Mortgage and Breach of the covenant in the Mortgage Deeds which expressly
states that the mortgager shall not sell or alienate or encumber the mortgaged
properties in whatever manner until the mortgage loans are cleared in all aspects
and until then the petitioners will have the charge over the mortgaged
properties. The learned counsel further submits that the second respondent
entering into the alleged Sale Agreement, without even verifying the original
Title Deeds, which were all along in the custody of the petitioners since the
execution of the said Mortgage Deeds, shows that the transaction between both
Page 6 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
the respondents 1 and 2 are not bonafide and the respondents have colluded
among themselves to defeat the legal rights of the petitioners. He further
submits that no prudent buyer would enter into a Sale Agreement and pay a
huge amount of money as an advance without even verifying the original Title
Deeds. The learned counsel contends that since the alleged Sale Agreement
dated 02.08.2014 is unregistered, it does not create any rights over the second
respondent, overriding the petitioners’ mortgagee rights. Further the said
Agreement has been executed in violation of the Mortgage Deeds which
prohibits the alienation of the properties under the mortgage without the
mortgagee’s consent and hence the same is not binding upon the petitioners
8. It is further submitted that upon the receipt of the letter dated
12.01.2021, the respondents jointly undertook to settle the mortgage and sought
some more time. Further in the year 2022, the second respondent accompanied
by one of his staff/ employee had visited the petitioners’ office to check the
Original Title Deeds of the mortgaged properties, which proves that the second
respondent was fully aware of the subsisting mortgage, which has been created
much prior to the alleged Sale Agreement between the respondents 1 and 2. He
further submits that without the knowledge of the petitioners the Government of
Tamil Nadu had initiated land acquisition proceedings for the New SIPCOT
Industrial Park Scheme, which ultimately covered the mortgaged properties of
the first respondent. Thereafter, the Petitioners came to know of the aforesaid
Page 7 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
acquisition proceedings only through a notice R.C.No.03/2024/MM (Gen.)
dated 15.05.2025, issued by the Acquisition Authorities and published in the
newspaper, namely, The Times of India on 21.05.2025, inviting objections to
the acquisition of lands situated in Madhuramangalam Village. The petitioners,
vide letter dated 21.05.2025, submitted their objections to the Acquisition
Authority asserting their mortgagee rights over the acquired properties. Pursuant
thereto, summons dated 19.06.2025 were issued for an enquiry on 27.06.2025,
directing the production of the original documents. As the summons were
received only a day prior, the petitioners through email had sought an
alternative date and undertook to appear with all requisite documents.
Thereafter, pursuant to the same summons dated 22.09.2025 were issued, the
petitioners appeared before the Acquisition Authority on 07.10.2025 and
submitted a detailed reply, objecting to the release of compensation to the first
respondent or anyone claiming under or through it, on the grounds of their
subsisting equitable mortgages over 1.48 acres and 16.93 acres of land, created
by deposit of title deeds under Mortgage Deeds dated 24.11.2009 and
29.11.2010, respectively. Accordingly, the petitioners lawfully retained custody
of the original title deeds relating to the mortgaged properties. The petitioners in
their reply had further stated that they are willing to return the original title
deeds and release the mortgages upon discharge of the outstanding loan
amounts by the first respondent through demand drafts drawn in favour of the
both petitioners.
Page 8 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
9. The learned counsel submits that the outstanding amount payable by
the first respondent towards the petitioners as per the Mortgage Deeds dated
24.11.2009 and 29.11.2010, along with the interests stands calculated as Rs.5
Crores and Rs.7 Crores. It is submitted that subsequent to the enquiry dated
07.10.2025 by the Acquisition Authority, it had come to the petitioners’
knowledge that the second respondent herein had filed a Section 9 Application
in O.A.No.393 of 2025, before this court and had obtained an order of interim
injunction dated 21.04.2025 against the Acquisition Authority restraining them
from disbursing the compensation amounts, claiming rights upon properties
under acquisition on the basis of the alleged unregistered Sale Agreement dated
02.08.2014. He submits that the second respondent had fraudulently approached
this court and had obtained the interim injunction by suppressing the material
facts that the petitioner holds equitable mortgage over the subject properties by
the virtue of the Mortgage Deeds dated 24.11.2009 and 29.11.2010, pursuant to
which the Original Title Deeds of the subject properties are in the custody of the
petitioners. He contends that the rights of the petitioners are much prior to that
of the second respondent’s rights which is allegedly created due to the
unregistered Sale Agreement entered between the respondents 1 and 2. It is
submitted that the second respondent had played fraud upon the court by
suppressing the aforesaid facts, inspite of having the knowledge of the
subsisting mortgage debt over the properties, thereby establishing that the
Page 9 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
respondents 1 and 2 are in collusion and connivance with each other to defeat
the legitimate rights of the petitioners.
10. Thereafter the petitioners had no other choice other than to invoke the
Arbitration Clause No.12 present in both the Mortgage Deeds dated 24.11.2009
and 29.11.2010, which stipulates that all the disputes, differences and claims
arising out of the aforesaid Mortgage Agreements shall be settled by Arbitration
according to the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. Pursuant to the same
the petitioners had triggered the Arbitration by issuing a section 21 noticed
dated 27.10.2025, nominating the learned Retd. District Judge Mr.D.Arulraj as
the Sole Arbitrator. However the notice to the first respondent had returned with
an endorsement “Refused” on 31.10.2025 and the notice was duly served upon
the second respondent on 30.10.2025 and same did not invoke any response.
Since there was no consensus reached among the parties for the appointment of
the Sole Arbitrator, the petitioners had approached this court and had filed the
present Arbitration Original Petitions separately in respect to each Mortgage
Deed, seeking to appoint a Sole Arbitrator to enter upon reference and decide
the disputed between the parties.
11. It is submitted that inorder to protect their rights over the subject
properties, pending the arbitration proceedings, the petitioners had filed the
present application in Arb.Appln.No.1462 of 2025 seeking the interim
Page 10 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
injunction restraining Acquisition Authority, who had been impleaded as the
third respondent in therein, from disbursing, releasing or paying any
compensation amount in respect of the subject properties of the lands under
acquisition situated at Maduramangalam Village, either in favour of the first

respondent or the second respondent or anyone claiming under or through the
first respondent or the second respondent, pending disposal of the arbitration
proceedings initiated by the petitioners/ applicants. In view of the foregoing
submissions, the learned counsel prays that this Court to allow both Arbitration
Original Petitions by appointing an arbitrator and allow the Arbitration
Application by restraining the third Respondent therein from dealing with the
subject properties in any manner until the arbitral proceedings are concluded.
12 . Per Contra, opposing the aforesaid arguments Mr.Abdul Saleem
learned Senior Counsel for the first respondent would submit that the present
Original Petitions are liable to be dismissed in limine on the ground of
limitation, since the entire claim of the Petitioners allegedly rests upon a two
individual sets of Promissory Notes and their respective Mortgage Deeds dated
24.11.2009 and 29.11.2010.  It is submitted that the notice dated 27.10.2025,
allegedly issued under Section 21 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, to
invoke arbitration was issued nearly 16 years after the alleged transaction. The
learned counsel submits that, under Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963, the
period of limitation is three years from the date on which the right to apply
Page 11 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
accrues. Further, even if the Petitioners rely upon Article 62 of the Limitation
Act, the maximum limitation period of 12 years had expired in the year of 2021.
Accordingly, the learned counsel contends that the claims are ex-facie time-
barred and constitute deadwood, thereby making the present Arbitration
Original Petitions liable to be dismissed and the appointment of a Sole
Arbitrator ought to be declined on this ground alone.
13. The learned Senior counsel further submits that the alleged letter
dated 12.01.2021, relied upon by the Petitioners, is a fabricated document,
purportedly created in a desperate attempt to overcome the bar of limitation
which had already expired. He categorically contends that the First Respondent
Company never executed the alleged Promissory Notes or the Mortgage Deeds
dated 24.11.2009 and 20.11.2010, for sum of Rs. 1.50 Crores and Rs. 3 Crores,
respectively. It is submitted that the financial dealings with the Petitioners’ firm
were undertaken by the Managing Director of the First Respondent in his
individual capacity and not on behalf of the first respondent company. He
further submits that, during February 2017 the First Respondent availed a loan
to a sum of Rs. 1 Crore from the Petitioners and handed over the original title
deeds relating to the subject properties along with the parent documents
pertaining to 34 acres of land situated at Maduramangalam Village, solely by
way of the security for the aforesaid loan.
Page 12 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
14. He submits that when the SIPCOT land acquisition process
commenced on March 2025, and the Petitioners realized that the compensation
amount would be directly credited to the first Respondent's account and had
hatched a criminal conspiracy to attain the same. The learned counsel submits
that the Petitioners had conspired to misuse the original documents, which had
been in their possession since 2017, by fabricating backdated and bogus
Mortgage Deeds dated 24.10.2009 and 29.11.2010 along with Promissory
Notes, to unlawfully claim inflated principal sums of Rs. 1.5 Crores and Rs. 3
Crores, respectively, together with interest at 8%, with the ulterior motive of
usurping the SIPCOT compensation. He further contends that the forgery
committed by the Petitioners is evident on the face of the record, as they have
allegedly forged the signature of the Managing Director of the First Respondent
and fabricated a counterfeit rubber stamp/seal of the First Respondent
Company.
14. The learned senior counsel submits that a bare perusal and
comparison of the first Respondent's authentic Company Seal affixed on its
Original registered Sale Deeds of the year 2008 alongside the Company Seal
affixed on the disputed, unregistered Mortgage Deeds dated 24.11.2009 and
29.11.2010 would reveal glaring discrepancies, as the font, alignment, and
Page 13 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
dimensions of the seal appearing on the Mortgage Deeds differ entirely from
those of the genuine seal of the first Respondent Company. The learned counsel
contends that, irrespective of the foregoing, the First Respondent Company has
no concern with the personal financial transactions of its Managing Director. He
further submits that a perusal of the Promissory Notes dated 24.11.2009 and
29.11.2010 would reveal that the same were executed in the individual capacity
of the Managing Director and that the name of the First Respondent Company
was subsequently inserted therein.
15. The learned Senior Counsel vehemently contends that the very
existence of the underlying contract in the documents dated 24.11.2009 and
29.11.2010 is a blatant forgery and hence, the arbitration clause embedded in it
is non-est in the eyes of law and that there is no valid arbitration agreement
between the parties as mandated under Section 11(6A) of the Act. It is
submitted that the Managing Director of the First Respondent has already
lodged a criminal complaint dated 24.12.2025 before the Commissioner of
Police, Greater Chennai Police, Vepery, against the Petitioners and their family
members, alleging forgery of the Mortgage Deeds and Promissory Notes dated
24.11.2009 and 29.11.2010 along with the fabrication of the letter dated
12.01.2021. The learned counsel submits that the complaint was forwarded to
the Deputy Commissioner of Police, Central Crime Branch (CCB), for inquiry
Page 14 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
and a CSR receipt bearing No. C.No. 1520/CCB/COP/Visitors/2025 dated
24.12.2025 was issued to the Managing Director of the first respondent.
 
16. The learned Senior Counsel contends that since the documents
forming the very basis of the present Arbitration Original Petitions are under
investigation before the CCB for alleged forgery, this Court ought not to act
upon such disputed documents while exercising jurisdiction under Section 11.
He further submits that the present Original petitions are intended to interfere
with the ongoing legal proceedings between the First and Second Respondents,
while the petitioners had willfully suppressed the fact that the respondents 1 and
2 are already engaged in contentious litigation concerning the lands in the
Maduramanagalam Village. It is submitted that the first Respondent along with
one Mr. Mu. Subramanian had entered into a Sale Agreement dated 02.08.2014
with the Second Respondent purely for marketing the plots, under which the
second Respondent paid an advance of Rs. 11 Crores to both the first
Respondent and Mr. Mu. Subramanian but had failed to pay the balance
consideration. It is submitted that subsequently the second Respondent filed
O.A. No. 393 of 2025 and obtained an interim injunction on 21.04.2025
restraining the SIPCOT, namely the acquisition Authority who is also the third
respondent in the present Arbitration Application from disbursing
compensation.
Page 15 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
17. The learned Senior counsel further submits that the disputes arising
out of the Agreement dated 02.08.2014, are currently pending adjudication
before the learned Arbitral Tribunal headed by Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sanjib
Banerjee, Former Chief Justice, Madras High Court & Meghalaya High Court.
In the aforesaid ongoing Arbitration, the first Respondent has already filed a
detailed Reply Statement and the Counter Claim seeking damages to the tune of
Rs. 66,09,13,959/- against the second Respondent for breach of contract. It is
further submitted that the Petitioners' sudden appearance in late 2025, namely
after 16 years of unexplained silence and relying upon fabricated Mortgage
Deeds allegedly executed in the years 2009 and 2010, is a malafide attempt to
create confusion, unlawfully claim the SIPCOT/ third respodnent’s
compensation and obstruct the ongoing arbitration proceedings before Hon'ble
Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee. It is further submitted that the conduct of the
Petitioners in preparing a forged Mortgage Deeds, Promissory notes and
fabricating a bogus company seal and using these forged documents as genuine
to obtain interim injunctions and to stake a false claim over the SIPCOT
compensation amount attracts severe penal consequences namely under the
Section 318(4), Section 336, Section 338 and Section 340.
18. The learned Senior Counsel further contends that the present case
Page 16 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
warrants an inquiry under Section 379 of the BNSS Act, 2023, for the alleged
perjury and forgery committed by the Petitioners to obstruct the course of
justice. He submits that the Petitioners are guilty of suppressio veri and
suggestio falsi, n amely suppressing the true facts and making false claims and
are misusing the judicial process to extort money and unlawfully claim
compensation for properties which are already the subject matter of arbitral
proceedings. In view of the foregoing submissions the learned senior counsel
prays this court to dismiss both the present Arbitration Original Petitions along
with the present Arbitration Application, with exemplary costs and direct the
Registrar of this Court to initiate criminal proceedings / inquiry against the
Petitioners under Section 379 of the BNSS Act 2023 for offenses committed
under Sections 318, 336, 338, and 340 of the BNS Act 2023 for fabricating
documents and using them as genuine before this Court.
19. The learned counsel appearing for the second respondent also made
submissions on the same line as submitted by the learned Senior counsel
appearing first respondent and hence, the submissions made by the learned
counsel appearing for the second respondent is not recorded for brevity.
20. The learned counsel appearing for the acquisition body in the
Arbitration Applications had submitted an award, since the dispute between the
Page 17 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
applicants and the other respondents with regard to disbursement of the
compensation, it is for them to approach the appropriate authority for
substantiate in their rights to receive the compensation and such claim would
also be made before the competent authority.
21. I have considered the submissions made by the learned counsels
appearing on either side and perused the materials placed on record.
22. Two Original Petitions have been filed by the respective petitioners
seeking for an appointment of an Arbitrator, which had been primarily contested
by the respective counsels on the merits of the claims apart from the
respondents raising objections on the grounds of limitation. Even though, the
learned Senior counsel appearing on behalf of the first respondent had relied
upon a judgment made by this Court in Arb.O.P.(Comm.Div) No.834 of 2024,
dated 19.12.2024, this Court in an earlier case (of which I was an author), had
held that the said judgment had been rendered, without taking note of the
subsequent judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the cases of SBI General
Insurance Co.Ltd., vs. Krish Spinning (Civil Appeal No.7821 of 2024) . In that
regard, this Court is of the view that the issue of limitation as raised by the
learned counsels appearing on the respondents 1 & 2 in O.Ps., could only be
decided by the Arbitrator. The Court under Section 11 petition is only required
Page 18 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
to see whether the petition had been filed before the Court within a period of
three years from the date of invocation of Section 21 and in that regard, this
Court is of the view that the present Arbitration Petitions under Section 11 is
well within the period of limitation. The issue on merits cannot be adjudicated
as has been reiterated by the Hon'ble Apex Court and could be only left to the
learned Arbitrator to decide on the same including the question of limitation of
the claim made by the respective parties.

23. It is an admitted fact that the lands have been acquired for public
purposes by the third respondent in the Arbitration Applications. The third
respondent had also been made aware of the disputes with regard to claim of
compensation for the acquired lands and in that regard, this Court believes that
the third respondent would abide itself with the provisions relating to disputed
claims over the compensation and could act accordingly.
24. Considering the fact that with the dispute between the first and second
respondents already arbitral proceedings had been initiated and appointment had
also been made by this Court whereby Hon'ble Mr.Justice Sanjib Banerjee had
also been appointed and since the issues that is sought to be raised by the parties
touch upon the issues that are pending arbitration before the learned Arbitrator,
this Court deems it fit to appoint Hon'ble Mr.Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Former
Page 19 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
Chief Justice of Megalaya (Mobile Number- 9836268256) residing at Greater
Kailash I, C-96, New Delhi, as an Arbitrator to enter upon reference in the
disputes raised by the petitioners in the respective O.Ps. The Arbitrator is
entitled to fix his own fees.
25. Accordingly, the Original Petitions stand allowed as indicated above
and the Arbitration Applications are disposed of with liberty to the respective
parties to adjudicate their claims for receipt of compensation before the
appropriate forum. However there shall be no order as to costs.
12.11.2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
Pbn
Page 20 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )

Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026 &
Arb.A.Nos.1461 & 1462 of 2026
K.KUMARESH BABU J.
Pbn
A Pre-delivery order made in
Arb O.P(COM.DIV.) Nos.370 & 373 of 2026
AND
Arb.A.NOs. 1461 & 1462 of 2026
12.11.2026
Page 21 of 21
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:46:45 pm )