Jolly Batoo vs Govt Of Nct Of Delhi And Ors
- Court
- Delhi High Court
$~
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+ Date of Decision: 10.09.2026
# CNR No. DLHC010429622026
+ LPA 713/2026 & CM APPL. 61620/2026
JOLLY BATOO .....Appellant
Through: Mr. Rakesh Khanna, Senior Advocate
with Mr. S.K. Gupta and Mr. Udit
Gupta, Advocates.
versus
GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI AND ORS .....Respondents
Through: Ms. Latika Choudhary, Advocate for
R-1.
Ms. Disha Choudhary, GP for UoI.
Mr. Siddharth Krishna Dwivedi,
Advocate for R-4 and R-5.
CORAM:
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TEJAS KARIA
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ. (ORAL)
CM APPL. 61621/2026 ( Exemption )
1. Exemption is allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
2. The Application stands disposed of.
CM APPL. 61619/2026 ( Condonation of Delay )
3. This is an Application filed on behalf of the Appellant seeking
condonation of delay of 71 days in filing the present Appeal.
4. For the reasons stated in the Application, the same is allowed. The
delay of 71 days in filing the present Appeal is hereby condoned.
5. The Application stands disposed of.
LPA 713/2026 Page 1 of 10
Signature Not Verified
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
Signing Date:16.09.2026
10:42:51
LPA 713/2026
6. The appellant, a directly recruited Post Graduate Teacher (PGT) in
Commerce, working with the respondent No.4 – Lady Irwin Senior
Secondary School (hereinafter referred to as ‘ the School ’), seeks to
challenge the judgment dated 27.02.2026 passed by the learned Single Judge
whereby W.P.(C) No. 16751/2024 instituted by the appellant has been
dismissed. The appellant also challenges the order dated 18.05.2026 passed
on the petition preferred by her seeking review of the said judgment dated
27.02.2026, which was also dismissed by the said order.
6.1 The challenge made by the appellant before the learned Single Judge
in the underlying writ petition related to seniority list of the PGT teachers in
the school issued in the month of March, 2022 (hereinafter referred to as
‘March 2022 seniority list’ ) where the appellant is shown at serial No.6
whereas respondent Nos. 6, 7, 8 and 9 have been shown at serial Nos. 1, 3, 4
and 5 respectively. The appellant had also challenged the promotion of
respondent No.7 on the post of Vice Principal vide Departmental Promotion
Committee’s ( ‘DPC’ ) recommendation dated 28.11.2024.
6.2 Prior to issuance of the March 2022 seniority list, a seniority list is
said to be in existence which was prepared in October, 2020 where the
appellant was shown senior to respondent Nos. 7, 8 and 9, however, she was
shown junior to respondent No.6. The seniority position of the appellant in
the said October, 2020 seniority list was at serial No.4 whereas the
respondent No.6, 7, 8 and 9 were shown at serial Nos.2, 10, 9 and 7
respectively.
6.3 The respondent No.4 – school is a recognised, Government aided and
LPA 713/2026 Page 2 of 10
Signature Not Verified
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
Signing Date:16.09.2026
10:42:51
privately managed school. The recruitment and terms and conditions of
service of employees of such schools are governed by the provisions
contained in Chapter XIII of Delhi School Education Rules, 1973
(hereinafter referred to as the ‘ 1973 Rules’ ). So far as the determination of
seniority of the employees in the school is concerned, the same is governed
by Rule 109 which is extracted herein below:
“ 109. Seniority
(i) There shall be a seniority roster for each grade and the names of the
employees appointed to posts in each grade shall be arranged in the roster
in accordance with this rule.
(ii) Seniority of employees shall be determined by the order of merit in
which they were selected for appointment to the concerned post, these
selected on an earlier occasion being ranked senior to those selected
later:
Provided that in a case where a joint seniority roster of employees of each
grade common to all schools used to be maintained by society or trust
running such schools prior to the commencement of these rules, inter-se-
seniority of all employees of such schools shall continue to be maintained
jointly.
(iii) Inter-se-seniority between direct recruits and promotees shall be
determined according to the rotation of vacancies between direct
recruities and promotees which shall be based on the quota of vacancies
reserved for direct recruitment and promotion respectively in the
recruitment rules.
(iv) Inter-se-seniority of employees of any grade shall be determined by
the managing committee in accordance with the rules applicable to the
employees of corresponding posts appointed in the Government schools:
Provided that in a case where a joint seniority roster of employees of
each grade common to all schools used to be maintained by the society or
trust running such schools prior to the commencement of these rules, such
inter-se-seniority shall be determined by such society or trust.
Explanation:- In this rule the word 'grade' means a post or a group of
posts created for work of the same nature in a school:
Provided that where posts arc created for work of the same nature in
different schools run by the same society or trust all such posts shall be
deemed to be in a single grade, if they were treated as such by the society
or trust prior to the commencement of these rules.”
7. As per the afore-quoted provisions for determination of seniority,
LPA 713/2026 Page 3 of 10
Signature Not Verified
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
Signing Date:16.09.2026
10:42:51
Rule 109(ii), in unambiguous terms, provides that seniority of employees
shall be determined by the order of merit in which they were selected for
appointment to the post in question. It further states that those selected on an
earlier occasion shall be ranked senior to those selected later.
8. Sub-Rule (iii) of Rule 109 further provides that the inter-se seniority
between direct recruits and promotees shall be determined in accordance
with the rotation of vacancies between direct recruits and promotees which
shall be based on the quota of vacancies reserved for direct recruitment and
promotion respectively in the recruitment rules. Sub-Rule (iv) provides that
as far as inter-se seniority of employees of any grade is concerned, the same
shall be determined by the managing committee of the School, in
accordance with the rules applicable to the employees of corresponding
posts appointed in the Government schools.
9. So far as seniority position of respondent No.6 – Ms. Jyoti Singh vis-
à-vis the seniority of the appellant is concerned, since Ms. Jyoti Singh was
appointed as PGT on 01.07.2003 and the appellant was appointed as PGT on
13.08.2008, as such, applying Rule 109(iii) which provides that those
selected on an earlier occasion shall be ranked senior to those selected later,
it is crystal clear that there does not appear to be any dispute in relation to
seniority of the appellant vis-à-vis respondent No.6 – Ms. Jyoti Singh.
10. The respondent No.7 – Ms. Sharda Verma was initially appointed as
Trained Graduate Teacher ( ‘TGT’ ) in the school on 25.02.1988 whereafter
she was promoted as PGT on 14.07.2008. Thus, the respondent No.7 is a
PGT teacher whose date of retirement is 31.03.2026. She has, thus, retired
from the services of the school.
11. The claim put forth by the appellant before the learned Single Judge
LPA 713/2026 Page 4 of 10
Signature Not Verified
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
Signing Date:16.09.2026
10:42:51
claiming her placement in the seniority list over and above respondent No.7
was based on the assertion that the respondent No.7 was promoted against
the vacancy of the recruitment year 2008-09 whereas the appellant was
recruited directly against the vacancy in the recruitment year 2007-08 and,
therefore, she should have been placed in the seniority list over and above
respondent No.7. The learned Single Judge, however, on detailed
discussion, has held that Rule 109 does not provide for conferment of
seniority merely because recruitment process was initiated earlier or because
the interview/selection took place earlier. The learned Single Judge has
further recorded that the said Rule provides for inter-se seniority between
direct recruits and promotees to be fixed in accordance with the rotation of
vacancies between direct recruits and promotees based on quota of
vacancies reserved for direct recruitment and promotion, however, the
appellant had utterly failed to establish her case in respect of her claim
relating to seniority vis-à-vis respondent No.7 for the reason that respondent
No.7 was promoted as PGT by the DPC held on 14.07.2008 whereas the
appellant was appointed vide appointment letter dated 13.08.2008.
Therefore, the appellant cannot claim seniority from a date prior to a date
when she was not even born in the cadre. Admittedly, the appointment of
the appellant was made on 13.08.2008 as PGT teacher whereas respondent
No.7 was promoted to the post of PGT on 14.07.2008 and in absence of any
material establishing a breakdown of rota-quota rule, in our opinion, the
claim of the appellant vis-à-vis respondent No.7 has rightly been rejected by
the learned Single Judge.
12. As far as appellant’s claim of seniority over and above the seniority
position of respondent Nos.8 and 9, we may note that the appellant as also
LPA 713/2026 Page 5 of 10
Signature Not Verified
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
Signing Date:16.09.2026
10:42:51
the respondent Nos.8 and 9 are directly recruited PGT working in the
school. In the selection process, the respondent No.8 had secured 77.4/100
marks, respondent No.9 had secured 54.7/100 marks whereas the appellant
had secured 53.9/100 marks.
13. Rule 109(ii) clearly provides that seniority of employees shall be
determined by the order of merit in which they were selected for
appointment to the concerned post. Applying the said Rule, since
respondent No.8 had secured the highest marks amongst the incumbents, i.e.
77.4/100 marks, she has been placed over and above the appellant as also the
respondent No.9. The respondent No.9 had secured 54.7/100 marks which
is more than the marks obtained by the appellant who secured 53.9/100
marks and, therefore, in terms of the said rule, respondent No.9 has been
rightly placed over and above the appellant. All these three incumbents
were issued the appointment letters on the same date i.e. 30.07.2008. They
were subjected to the same selection process and since respondent Nos. 8
and 9 had secured higher merit position in the said selection list as compared
to the merit position of the appellant, in terms of Rule 109(ii) of the 1973
Rules they have been placed above the appellant in the seniority list issued
in March, 2022.
14. The learned counsel for the appellant, has, however, drawn our
attention to the October, 2020 seniority list where the time of interview of
these three incumbents is also mentioned, according to which, the appellant
was interviewed at 09:30 A.M., respondent No.8 was interviewed at 10:00
A.M. and respondent No.9 was interviewed at 01:30 P.M. On this basis, it
has been submitted on behalf of the appellant that since the appellant was
selected prior in time, i.e. on an earlier occasion, as compared to respondent
LPA 713/2026 Page 6 of 10
Signature Not Verified
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
Signing Date:16.09.2026
10:42:51
Nos. 8 and 9, therefore, she should be placed over and above respondent
Nos. 8 and 9 in the seniority position.
15. To buttress the aforesaid submission, reliance has been placed by
learned counsel for the appellant on Clause 2.1 of the Instructions and
Guidelines issued by the Department of Personnel and Training,
Government of India ( ‘DoPT’ ) which was circulated vide circular dated
11.11.2010.
16. Clause 2.1 of the said Instructions and Guidelines is in respect of
seniority of direct recruits, according to which, relative seniority of direct
recruits has to be determined in the order of merit in which they are selected
on the recommendation of UPSC or other selecting authorities. It further
provides that persons appointed as a result of an earlier selection will be
senior to those appointed as a result of subsequent selection. Clause 2.1 of
the Instructions and Guidelines on seniority issued by the DoPT vide circular
dated 11.11.2010 is extracted herein below:
“2.1. SENIORITY OF DIRECT RECRUITS
The relative seniority of all direct recruits is determined by the order of
merit in which they are selected for such appointment on the
recommendations of the U.P.S.C. or other selecting authority, persons
appointed as a result of an earlier selection being senior to those
appointed as a result of subsequent selection. The relative seniority that
used to be determined earlier according to the date of confirmation and
not the original order of merit, (in case where confirmation was in an
order different from the order of merit indicated at the time of their
appointment), in accordance with the general principles of seniority, has
been discontinued w.e.f. 4.11.1992 (O.M. No. 20011/5/90-Estt (D) Dated
4.11.1992). The general principles of seniority therefore stands modified
to that extent.”
17. It has been argued that the said Instructions clearly state that persons
appointed as a result of an earlier selection shall be senior to those appointed
on the basis of subsequent selection and since selection of the appellant took
LPA 713/2026 Page 7 of 10
Signature Not Verified
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
Signing Date:16.09.2026
10:42:51
place prior in point of time as compared to the selection of respondent Nos.
8 and 9, she should be placed senior. It is stated that the appellant was
interviewed at 09:30 A.M on 12.06.2008, whereas respondent No.8 was
interviewed at 10:00 A.M. on 09.07.2008 and respondent No.9 was
interviewed at 01:30 P.M on 12.06.2008, therefore, the appellant, applying
the said guideline, shall be treated to be senior to respondent Nos.8 and 9.
18. The aforesaid submission, in our considered opinion, is absolutely
misconceived for the reason that Clause 2.1 of the Instructions and
Guidelines on Seniority issued by the DoPT provides that inter-se seniority
of direct recruits will be determined in the order of merit with a further
provision that persons appointed as a result of earlier selection will be senior
to those appointed as a result of subsequent selection, however, that would
not mean that in the course of the same selection if a candidate is
interviewed or subjected to selection on an earlier date or at a prior point in
time on the same date, such a candidate has to be placed over and above
those who were subjected to selection or interviewed at a later date or at a
later point in time on the same date.
19. The phrases ‘earlier selection’ and ‘subsequent selection’ occurring in
Clause 2.1 of the Guidelines have been used in relation to two different
selections conducted pursuant to two different recruitment processes and not
in relation to the same selection conducted pursuant to the same recruitment
process. In other words, if a recruitment process is initiated by issuing an
advertisement, the eligible candidates may be subjected to selection or
interviewed on different dates and in such a situation there inter-se seniority
will be determined on the basis of their merit position obtained by them in
the selection process which may span a period of more than a day or week or
LPA 713/2026 Page 8 of 10
Signature Not Verified
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
Signing Date:16.09.2026
10:42:51
even a month.
20. The applicability of Clause 2.1 of the Instructions and Guidelines on
Seniority issued by the DoPT is only in case the candidates are subjected to
selection process or interview conducted on the basis of two different
recruitment processes initiated by issuance of two different advertisements.
21. In a situation where two different selection processes are undertaken
pursuant to two different recruitment processes by issuing two different
advertisements, the employee selected pursuant to the selection process
initiated at an earlier point in time will be senior to the one who is selected
on the basis of selection conducted at a later point of time. The provisions
of Clause 2.1, thus, cannot be stretched to be applied to a situation where
two different candidates are subjected to selection or interview in the same
selection process initiated on the basis of same recruitment.
22. Accordingly, the aforesaid submission made by learned counsel for
the appellant merits rejection which is hereby rejected.
23. It is also to be noticed that Rule 109(ii) of the 1973 Rules is couched
almost in similar language as Clause 2.1 of the Instructions and Guidelines
on Seniority issued by the DoPT. Rule 109(ii) provides that those selected
on an earlier occasion shall be ranked senior to those selected later. This
too, however, would only apply in a situation where selections are held on
different occasions based on two different selection process initiated on the
basis of two different recruitment processes. Accordingly, the provisions of
Clause 2.1 of the Instructions and Guidelines on Seniority issued by DoPT
vide its circular dated 11.11.2010 do not lend any credence to the
submission made in this regard by learned counsel for the appellant.
24. No other substantial ground was urged on behalf of the appellant
LPA 713/2026 Page 9 of 10
Signature Not Verified
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
Signing Date:16.09.2026
10:42:51
while arguments were made in this appeal.
25. For the reasons aforesaid, we do not find any good ground to interfere
with the impugned judgment dated 27.02.2026 passed by the learned Single
Judge in W.P.(C) No. 16751/2024. We also do not find any irregularity so
as to interfere with the order dated 18.05.2026 passed by the learned Single
Judge on the petition seeking review of the judgment dated 27.02.2026.
26. Resultantly, the appeal is hereby dismissed.
27. There will be no order as to costs.
DEVENDRA KUMAR UPADHYAYA, CJ
TEJAS KARIA, J
SEPTEMBER 10, 2026
N.Khanna
LPA 713/2026 Page 10 of 10
Signature Not Verified
Digiltally Signed
By:SREERAM L
Signing Date:16.09.2026
10:42:51