Magma Hdi General Insurance Co. Ltd vs Chhuttan Ahirwar
- Court
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
1 MA-10223-2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK AGARWAL
th
ON THE 16 OF NOVEMBER, 2026
MISC. APPEAL No. 10213 of 2025
CNR No.: MPHC010898292025
MAGMA HDI GENERAL INSURANCE C. LTD
Versus
RAMSWAROOP CHOUDHARY AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Aditya Narayan Sharma - Advocate for the appellant.
Shri Uday Kumar - Advocate for the respondent Nos.1 to 4.
WITH
MISC. APPEAL No. 10211 of 2025
CNR No.: MPHC010898252025
MAGMA HDI GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.
Versus
FAGGI BAI AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Shri Aditya Narayan Sharma - Advocate for the appellant.
Shri Uday Kumar - Advocate for the respondent Nos.1 to 3.
MISC. APPEAL No. 10223 of 2025
CNR No.: MPHC010898552025
MAGMA HDI GENERAL INSURANCE CO. LTD
Versus
CHHUTTAN AHIRWAR AND OTHERS
Appearance:
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: AMIT JAIN
Signing time: 19-11-
2026 18:39:27
2 MA-10223-2025
Shri Aditya Narayan Sharma - Advocate for the appellant.
Shri Uday Kumar - Advocate for the respondent Nos.1 to 4.
ORDER
Heard on I.A.No.405/2026, which is an application for condonation of
delay in filing of M.A.No.10213/2025.
For the reasons stated in the application supported with an affidavit,
the same is allowed.
The delay of five days' in filing of M.A.No.10213/2025 is condoned.
These appeals are filed by the Insurance Company being aggrieved of
award dated 13.9.2025 passed by learned 22nd Additional Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal, Jabalpur in M.A.C.C Nos.2812, 2967 and 3021 of 2022
allowing the claim petitions filed by the claimants.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the accident took place
on 1.3.2022 and the FIR was lodged on 18.4.2022. Drawing the attention of
this Court to Exhibit P/47, i.e., the Merg Intimation with regard to Deepak
Choudhary, it is pointed out that Deepak Choudhary was discharged from the
hospital on 16.4.2022 and later succumbed to his injuries. Deepak
Choudhary had not given any statement to the police with regard to the
offending vehicle. In Exhibit P/8, i.e. the Merg Intimation, it is mentioned
that Pradeep Choudhary had brought Sahdev Bhavedi, and similarly, Exhibit
P/31 reveals that it was Ajay, who had brought another deceased, Roshan
Ahirwar. Thus, it is submitted that none of the Merg Intimations points
towards the presence of the author of the FIR. Surendra Kumar Kulaste
(AW-4) has been wrongly treated as an eye-witness to the incident by the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: AMIT JAIN
Signing time: 19-11-
2026 18:39:27
3 MA-10223-2025
Claims Tribunal. Surendra Kumar Kulaste is a planted witness and his
testimony is liable to be discarded. There are several contradictions in his
testimony. Hence, prayer is made to set aside the impugned award and allow
the present appeals filed by the Insurance Company.
Learned counsel for the claimants submits that the Insurance Company
had examined Shri Jenson K. Pylo (NAW-1), who claimed himself to be an
Assistant Manager of Magma HDI General Insurance Company Limited.
Reading from his evidence, it is pointed out that this witness admits that the
Insurance Company had appointed an Investigator. The Investigator had filed
an investigation report. He had not produced any investigation report before
the Claims Tribunal. He admits in his cross-examination that the said
Investigator was one Miss Versha Burman. Jenson K. Pylo also admits that
the FIR was lodged after the Merg investigation. Thus, it is pointed out that
once the Insurance Company itself did not produce any evidence with regard
to the accident not having taken place with the offending vehicle and, on the
contrary, tried to suppress the investigation report, the benefit should accrue
in favour of the claimants. He places reliance on the judgment of the Apex
Court in Raj Kumar Das (deceased) through LRs versus National Insurance
Company Limited, 2026 ACJ 1235 wherein the Apex Court has set aside the
orders of the Claims Tribunal and the High Court holding that claims under
the Motor Vehicles Act are to be decided on the basis of the preponderance
of probabilities and that discrepancies which do not go to the root of the
occurrence cannot defeat the claim; when the police investigation, FIR,
charge sheet, medical evidence, and the claimant's consistent testimony
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: AMIT JAIN
Signing time: 19-11-
2026 18:39:27
4 MA-10223-2025
cumulatively establish the occurrence of an accident, minor inconsistencies
do not render the occurrence improbable; further, delay in lodging the FIR
cannot, by itself, lead to an inference that the accident did not occur, more so
when the police investigation culminated in a charge sheet and the finding of
the High Court was set aside.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and gone through the
record.
It is well-settled law that the onus is on the claimant(s) to prove the
factum of the accident and also the vehicle with which the accident took
place.
In the present case, AW-1 Faggi Bai, wife of Sahdev Bhavedi, admits
that she is not an eye-witness to the incident. She was at home in Anuppur
when the accident took place. Her husband was working at Yadav Colony.
He was working with Wood. She admits that she had neither seen the
accident taking place nor knew as to with which vehicle the accident took
place. She states that her husband used to give her Rs.1,000/- per week and
later improvised her version by stating that her husband was giving her
Rs.25,000/- as his income was Rs.25,000/- to Rs.30,000/- per month. She
had not given any intimation to the police with regard to the incident. She
states that the police personnel had come to her house and recorded her
statement. She admits that after the accident, Surendra Kumar Kulaste had
informed her over the telephone, asking her to reach the Medical Hospital,
and when she reached the Medical Hospital, she saw her husband.
Milan Ahirwar (AW-2) states that he had given his evidence with
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: AMIT JAIN
Signing time: 19-11-
2026 18:39:27
5 MA-10223-2025
regard to his brother, Roshan Ahirwar. He had not seen the accident taking
place in front of him. He states that at about 9:00 AM, he had received a
phone call on his mobile asking him to reach the Medical Hospital and at
about 9:30 AM, he had reached the Medical Hospital, where he found his
brother to be unconscious. He admits that Surendra Kumar Kulaste and
Santram did not meet him at the Medical Hospital. His brother died on the
next day at about 12 noon. He had no information with regard to the
incident. He admits that he had not informed the police as to how and with
which vehicle, the accident took place or what was the number of that
vehicle. He admits that at the time of the postmortem of his brother, he was
present in the Hospital. He admits that some of the persons, who had brought
his brother to the Hospital, had given him the number of the offending
vehicle, but there is no explanation as to why he did not disclose that number
to the police personnel for a long duration, i.e. from 1.3.2022 till 18.4.2022.
AW-3 Pradeep Choudhary is the elder brother of Deepak Choudhary.
He had given evidence with regard to Deepak Choudhary. In Paragraph No.5
of his cross-examination, Pradeep Choudhary admits that he had not seen the
accident taking place in front of him. He admits that he had received
information from others about the incident. He states that he had no
information that his brother was admitted to Galaxy Hospital. He admits that
he had received a phone call from the police personnel on the date of the
accident, and thereafter, he had gone to Galaxy Hospital. Deepak Choudhary
was admitted to Galaxy Hospital for 9-10 days. Pradeep Choudhary admits
that he is illiterate.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: AMIT JAIN
Signing time: 19-11-
2026 18:39:27
6 MA-10223-2025
AW-3 Pradeep Choudhary states that it is an admitted fact that his
father, while giving his statement vide Exhibit P/55, had stated that Deepak
Choudhary was having a Shop dealing in Toys, Chauki and Belan, etc. On
his own, in Paragraph No.8 of his cross-examination, this witness states that
Deepak Choudhary was, in fact, a student and that whenever he got time, he
used to manage his Shop. He admits that at the time of the postmortem, he
was present in the Hospital. Thus, it is evident that the testimony of Surendra
Kumar Kulaste that Deepak Choudhary was working as a Carpenter is
contrary to the evidence of Pradeep Choudhary (AW-3), who states that
Deepak Choudhary was a student and was, in fact, running a toy business.
Surendra Kumar Kulaste (AW-4) states that Sahdev Bhavedi, Deepak
Choudhary and Roshan Ahirwar were working with him. He admits in
Paragraph No.3 of his cross-examination that he had not received any
summons or order from the Court to lead his evidence. He states that his
Lawyer had informed him that he was required to give evidence before the
Court. This witness in Paragraph No.5 though states that he had given
intimation to the police about the incident and that the police had reached the
place of the incident, no reason is given as to why the FIR was not lodged for
over 48 days. This witness in Paragraph No.7 of his cross-examination
admits that Pradeep Choudhary is known to him and is his friend and then on
his own states that Pradeep Choudhary was present at the place of the
incident. This witness could not give the colour and description, etc. of the
offending vehicle. He has even denied lodging of the FIR though in the FIR
(Exhibit P/5), his name is mentioned as the author of the FIR recorded on
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: AMIT JAIN
Signing time: 19-11-
2026 18:39:27
7 MA-10223-2025
18.4.2022. He admits in Paragraph No.10 of his cross-examination that he
does not know as to which company's vehicle was the offending vehicle. He
states that he does not know after how many days of the incident, Deepak
Choudhary died. This witness, in Paragraph No.7 of his cross-examination,
states that Pradeep Choudhary, the elder brother of Deepak Choudhary, is his
friend. He had not gone to the police station to lodge the report. He states
that if his name is mentioned in Exhibit P/5, i.e. the FIR then it is wrongly
mentioned. He admits that in Exhibit P/4 i.e. the Final Report in Column
No.13, his name is mentioned as the complainant and the Panchayat Lash
Sakshi.
When Surendra Kumar Kulaste (AW-4) was present at the time of
preparation of the Lash Panchayatnama then he was obliged to give details of
the accident including the number of the offending vehicle. There is no
explanation for the studied silence on the part of this witness in not divulging
the number of the offending vehicle, despite the twin facts that he knew the
elder brother of Deepak Choudhary, namely, Pradeep Choudhary, and that he
also states that all the three deceased were working with him as Carpenters at
a Coaching Centre. He admits that had he informed the police that he had
seen the incident then his name would have been mentioned as an eye-
witness in the Final Report.
However, fact of the matter is that the name of Surendra Kumar
Kulaste (AW-4) is not mentioned as an eye-witness to the incident. Surendra
Kumar Kulaste (AW-4) admits that all the three deceased were his friends
and that he had come to the Court to give evidence to facilitate the payment
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: AMIT JAIN
Signing time: 19-11-
2026 18:39:27
8 MA-10223-2025
of compensation. He admits in Paragraph No.11 that he was giving evidence
at the request of the family members of the deceased. He admits that he is
deposing as per the version of the family members of the deceased. Thus, it
is evident that Surendra Kumar Kulaste is not an eye-witness but is a planted
witness. Despite knowing the elder brother of Deepak Choudhary, namely,
Pradeep Choudhary, and also stating that all the three deceased were working
with him, his conduct in not informing the police about the offending vehicle
for a long duration of 48 days is doubtful.
Milan Ahirwar (AW-2) clearly states in Paragraph No.4 of his cross-
examination that he had not met Surendra Kumar Kulaste and Santram at the
Medical Hospital. Contrary to this, Surendra Kumar Kulaste (AW-4) states
that he had taken both Roshan Ahirwar and Sahdev Bhavedi to the Hospital
leaving behind Deepak Choudhary, who was helped by others. This conduct
is also doubtful because Deepak Choudhary's elder brother was stated to be a
friend of Surendra Kumar Kulaste and leaving Deepak Choudhary behind at
the place of the incident while taking the two other persons, particularly
when this fact is not corroborated by the evidence of their relatives, who had
reached the Hospital, leaves no iota of doubt that Surendra Kumar Kulaste
(AW-4) is not an eye-witness and is a planted witness.
When these facts are taken into consideration then it is evident that the
claimants were required to prove the factum of the accident and also the
vehicle with which the accident took place, which they have failed to prove,
therefore, the claim petitions and the impugned award deserve to be set
aside.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: AMIT JAIN
Signing time: 19-11-
2026 18:39:27
9 MA-10223-2025
I am conscious of the fact that in Ravi versus Badrinarayan & Others,
(2011) 4 SCC 693, the Apex Court has dealt with the issue of delay in
lodging of the FIR. However, the facts of that case were different. The
informants were either attending to the injured or participating in the death-
related rituals and, therefore, could not inform the police in time. Under such
circumstances, the Apex Court has held that delay in lodging of the FIR is
not fatal. The Apex Court in Paragraph Nos. 17, 18, 19 and 20 has held as
under:-
''17. It is well settled that delay in lodging the FIR cannot be a ground
to doubt the claimant's case. Knowing the Indian conditions as they are, we
cannot expect a common man to first rush to the police station immediately
after an accident. Human nature and family responsibilities occupy the mind
of kith and kin to such an extent that they give more importance to get the
victim treated rather than to rush to the police station. Under such
circumstances, they are not expected to act mechanically with promptitude in
lodging the FIR with the police. Delay in lodging the FIR thus, cannot be the
ground to deny justice to the victim.
18. In cases of delay, the courts are required to examine the evidence
with a closer scrutiny and in doing so the contents of the FIR should also be
scrutinised more carefully. If the court finds that there is no indication of
fabrication or it has not been concocted or engineered to implicate innocent
persons then, even if there is a delay in lodging the FIR, the claim case
cannot be dismissed merely on that ground. The purpose of lodging the FIR
in such type of cases is primarily to intimate the police to initiate
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: AMIT JAIN
Signing time: 19-11-
2026 18:39:27
10 MA-10223-2025
investigation of criminal offences.
19. Lodging of FIR certainly proves the factum of accident so that the
victim is able to lodge a case for compensation but delay in doing so cannot
be the main ground for rejecting the claim petition. In other words, although
lodging of FIR is vital in deciding motor accident claim cases, delay in
lodging the same should not be treated as fatal for such proceedings, if
claimant has been able to demonstrate satisfactory and cogent reasons for it.
There could be a variety of reasons in genuine cases for delayed lodgement
of FIR. Unless kith and kin of the victim are able to regain a certain level of
tranquillity of mind and are composed to lodge it, even if, there is delay, the
same deserves to be condoned. In such circumstances, the authenticity of the
FIR assumes much more significance than delay in lodging thereof supported
by cogent reasons.
20. In the case in hand, the Claims Tribunal as well as the High Court,
committed grave error in not appreciating the mental agony through which
Suresh was passing, whose son was severely injured. In the light of the
aforesaid discussion, we are of the considered opinion that MACT as well as
the High Court committed error in coming to the conclusion that lodging the
FIR belatedly would result in dismissal of the claim petition.''
However, none of the aforesaid circumstances have been brought on
record, and none of the claimant witnesses as discussed hereinabaove are
eye-witnesses to the incident. The conduct of Surendra Kumar Kulaste (AW-
4) is highly improbable. After having admitted his friendship with Pradeep
Choudhary, i.e. the elder brother of Deepak Choudhary and also admitting
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: AMIT JAIN
Signing time: 19-11-
2026 18:39:27
11 MA-10223-2025
the fact that all the three deceased were working with him at a Coaching
Centre as Carpenters, though it has come on record that Deepak Choudhary
was not involved in carpentry work but was selling wooden toys apart from
pursuing his studies, leaves no iota of doubt that the offending vehicle was
subsequently planted with a view to claim compensation.
When tested in the light of the judgment of the Apex Court in Ravi
versus Badrinarayan & Others (supra), since the FIR was lodged by Surendra
Kumar Kulaste (AW-4), he was required to explain the delay in lodging of
the FIR especially when he was neither related to the deceased persons nor
was busy in the death-related rituals.
Accordingly, these appeals are allowed and the impugned award dated
13.9.2025 passed by learned 22nd Additional Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Jabalpur in M.A.C.C Nos.2812, 2967 and 3021 of 2022 allowing
the claim petitions filed by the claimants is set aside.
Let record of the Claims Tribunal be sent back forthwith.
(VIVEK AGARWAL)
JUDGE
amit
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: AMIT JAIN
Signing time: 19-11-
2026 18:39:27