DR J MOHANAKRISHNAN vs Jipmer
- Court
- Central Administrative Tribunal
1 of 9
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CHENNAI BENCH
OA No. 310/00413 of 2021
.
th
DATED TUESDAY, THE 17 DAY OF OCTOBER, TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
CORAM :
HON'BLE MS. VEENA KOTHAVALE, MEMBER (J)
HON'BLE MR. M.L. SRIVASTAVA, MEMBER(A)
BETWEEN
Dr. J. Mohanakrishnan,
Junior Physiotherapist,
Department of Ortho Surgery, PMRC,
Jawaharlal Institute of Post Graduate medical Education & Research,
Puducherry- 605006.
...Applicant
(Advocate: M/s. M.R. Thangavel )
Versus
The Director,
Jawaharlal Institute of Post Graduate Medical Education & Research,
(JIPMER)
Dhanvanthri Nagar,
Puducherry-605006.
….Respondents
(Advocate: Mr. M.T. Arunan )
CAV ON : 05.10.2026
2 of 9
O R D E R
(Hon'ble Ms. Veena Kothavale, Member(J)
This Original Application is filed by the applicant under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 seeking to quash and set aside the impugned
order dated 22.11.2019 and to direct the respondent to grant ACP-1 with effect from
27.11.2008 and consequential monetary and accrued service benefits.
2. The facts as submitted by the applicant are that he was appointed to the post of
Junior Physiotherapist in the respondent Institution on 27.11.1996. The applicant is
serving in the same post without any promotion till date. The ACP scheme was
introduced on 09.08.1999 for the benefit of the employees who faced stagnation in
the same post for long without any progress in their career and the applicant had
become entitled for grant of ACP on completion of 12 years on 27.11.2008.
Meanwhile, the MACP Scheme was introduced in place of ACP vide DoP&T OM
dated 19.05.2009 with retrospective effect from 01.09.2008.
3. Applicant further states that number of employees had completed 12 years of
service in the same post between 01.09.2008 to 19.05.2009 and they were denied
ACP due to the retrospective application of the MACP scheme. Therefore, they
made several representations for grant of ACP instead of MACP and Writ Petitions
were filed before various High Courts and Administrative Tribunals in this regard. It
was held by the High Courts and Tribunals that any progression scheme for the
3 of 9
benefit of the employers is only for the benefit of the employees and cannot result in
loss to the employees on its implementation and such progression schemes cannot be
implemented retrospectively resulting loss to the employees.
4. The Hon'ble Madras High Court vide its order dated 14.02.2017 passed in W. P.
No. 33946 of 2014 had held as under: -
"10. Although it is a matter of record that MACP Scheme was
Introduced vide Memorandum dated 19.05.2009, but the same was
put into effect from 01.09.2008. In the instant case, admittedly,
before introduction of the MACP Scheme under the Office
Memorandum dated 19.05.2009, the applicants have completed 24
years of service and their right to get second financial upgradation
under the erstwhile ACP Scheme got crystalised and such right
cannot sought to be negated by bringing in a new Scheme with
retrospective effect. The purpose and spirit of the Career
Progression Scheme is only for the benefit of employees, who face
stagnation in their career. That purpose and spirit cannot be
defeated, if the benefit under the new Scheme is causing detrimental
to the interest of the employees. The intention between the Scheme
would not be as such. In any event, as a principle of purposive
interpretation, it has to be seen that what is more advantageous to the
employees is what should be preferred, since the Scheme being a
beneficial one, cannot be allowed to result in loss to the employees on
its implementation. Therefore, in all fairness and fitness of things,
till the introduction of MACP Scheme vide Office Memorandum dated
19.05.2009, the benefit which accrued to the employees under the
4 of 9
erstwhile ACP Scheme ought to have been made available."
5. Since the applicant had completed 12 years of service on 27.11.2008 without
any promotion and the MACP was introduced only later, i.e., on 19.05.2009, he had
become entitled for the benefit of ACP-1 on 27.11.2008 itself, prior to the
introduction of MACPS on 19.05.2009. Therefore, the applicant made
representation to the respondent on 07.12.2018 for grant of ACP-1. The respondent,
after seeking clarification from the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, vide
communication dated 22.11.2019, informed that since the benefit of the ACP scheme
has been discontinued w.e.f. 01.09.2008, grant of ACP in the case of applicant and
two others does not arise as their date of completion of 12 years of service falls after
01.09.2008. In response to his subsequent representation dated 05.06.2020,
respondent vide communication dated 03.07.2020 has negated grant of ACP benefits
to him and hence he has filed this OA for the aforestated relief.
6. By way of reply, the respondent stated that the applicant was appointed to the
post of Junior Physiotherapist on 27.11.1996. The ACP Scheme was introduced on
09.08.1999 to provide financial benefits to employees who stagnated without
promotion for a period of 12 years and 24 years and MACP Scheme was introduced
vide DoPT OM dated 19.05.2009 to give financial benefits to employees who
stagnated without promotion for a period of 10 years, 20 years and 30 years in their
service. On introduction of MACP Scheme w.e.f. 01.09.2008, the ACP Scheme
5 of 9
ceased to operate. The applicant completed 12 years of service on 27.11.2008 in the
said post without any promotion and since this was after the implementation of
MACP Scheme, he was eligible to avail the benefits of financial assistance under the
MACP Scheme and not the ACP Scheme. Accordingly, the applicant has been given
benefits as per the MACP Scheme which replaced the ACP Scheme and his Grade
Pay was enhanced from Rs.4200/- to Rs.4600/- w.e.f. 01.09.2008, the date of effect of
MACPS, even before completing 12 years of service and further to Rs.4800/- w.e.f.
11.12.2016 on completion of 20 years of service.
7. It is further stated that the Madras High Court judgment dated 14-02-2017
passed in W.P. No.33946 of 2014 is not applicable to the respondent who was not a
party to it, and the said judgment has been challenged by the respondents therein
before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in SLP No.010811-010813/2018 which is still
pending. The representation dated 07.12.2018 submitted by the applicant was taken
up by the respondent with the Administrative Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
for clarification on 23.02.2019, 09.04.2019 & 14.08.2019 and the Ministry has
clarified vide letter dated 27.09.2019 that since the ACP Scheme had been
discontinued w.e.f. 01.09.2008, the guidelines issued by DoP&T on MACP may be
followed. Based on the communication from the Ministry, the respondent has
informed the applicant by letter dated 22.11.2019 that grant of ACP to the applicant
and two others does not arise as they had completed 12 years of service after the
MACP was introduced w.e.f 01.09.2008. The applicant is given full benefits under
6 of 9
the MACP Scheme which replaced ACP Scheme as per the policy decision of the
Government of India and has already been granted MACP-I & II in the Grade Pay of
Rs.4600/- and Rs.4800/- respectively. Therefore, prayed for dismissal of the O.A.
8. We have heard the submissions made by the counsel on both sides and perused
the record.
9. It is observed that the issue in question is no more res integra and has been
settled by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in its decisions in Union of India and others vs
Ex. HC/GD Virender Singh in SLP (C) No.16442 of 2021 and Union of India and
others vs M V Mohanan Nair [(2020) 5 SCC 421 .
10. The following observations made by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in M V
Mohanan Nair's case (Supra) is relevant. It has observed as under: -
"9. In order to bring systematic changes in the existing scheme of ACP
so that all employees irrespective of existing hierarchical structure in their
organisations/cadre get the same benefit, MACP was recommended by the
Sixth Central Pay Commission which was accepted by the Government with
certain modifications vide its Office Memorandum dated 19.05.2009.
Under the Sixth Central Pay Commission, revised pay structure has been
implemented with effect from 01.01.2006; whereas benefits of ACP Scheme
have been allowed till 31.08.2008. Vide Office Memorandum dated
19.05.2009, the Government of India introduced the MACP Scheme, in
supersession of the ACP Scheme w.e.f. 01.09.2008.
7 of 9
17. As noted above, under the Sixth Pay Commission, scales of pay of
various hierarchies namely Lower Division Clerk and Upper Division
Clerk are all placed in the Pay Band-I i.e. Rs.5200-20200, of course with
different Grade Pay. When the respondents are enjoying the benefit of the
Sixth Pay Commission by getting higher pay scale, they should go by the
Scheme in accepting what it gives on the financial upgradation; but the
respondents are claiming the best of the benefits from both the ACP and
MACP Schemes. The respondents have already been granted the beneficial
pay upgradation as per the prevailing rules of MACP Scheme on the
recommendation of the Sixth Central Pay Commission. The previous ACP
Scheme was withdrawn and superseded by MACP Scheme with effect from
01.09.2008 based on the recommendation of the Sixth Central Pay
Commission. Under MACP Scheme, the respondent can only claim
immediate next Grade Pay and not the corresponding Grade Pay in
promotional hierarchy.
27....Though ACP and MACP Schemes are intended to provide relief
against stagnation, both the Schemes have different features. Pay scales
under the Sixth Pay Commission and the MACP Scheme are stated to be
more beneficial since it extends to the employees with time intervals with
higher pay bands and various facilities which were not available under the
ACP Scheme including the three financial upgradations in shorter time
span. In any event, MACP Scheme has not been challenged by the
respondents. As rightly contended by the learned ASG, the respondents
cannot be permitted to cherry-pick beneficial features from the erstwhile
ACP Scheme and also take advantage of the beneficial features in the
MACP Scheme.
11. In Ex. HC/GD Virender Singh's case (Supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court
observed as under: -
8 of 9
6. In M.V. Mohanan Nair (supra), the argument to adopt
“purposive interpretation” or to apply the principle of ‘equal pay for
equal work’ for grant of financial upgradation to the pay in the next
promotional post as under the ACP Scheme, viz. financial
upgradation to the next grade pay in the hierarchical pay scale, was
rejected as financial upgradation cannot be equated with promotion.
On merits, it has been held that the financial upgradation envisaged
as per the MACP Scheme is not a case of hostile discrimination. The
MACP Scheme is not irrational, unjust and prejudicial to a section of
the employees, but a well-considered decision which has taken all
material and relevant factors into consideration. Prescription of pay
scales and incentives are a matter of decision taken by the
government which, when based upon the recommendation of an expert
body like the Central Pay Commission, should carry weight and the
courts should be reluctant to substitute the policy with their own
views on what would be more equitable and just. It is to be noted that
the MACP Scheme postulates grant of three financial upgradations
after a period of 10, 20 and 30 years, whereas the ACP Scheme had
postulated grant of only two financial upgradations after a period of
12 and 24 years of regular service. Thus, the claim for grant of
financial upgradation in the grade pay of the promotional hierarchy
st
was rejected . Further, with effect from 1 September 2008, the
ACP Scheme stands superseded by the MACP Scheme as a matter
of government policy and hence, the employees, on and from the
date of implementation of the MACP Scheme, cannot claim any
benefit of the ACP Scheme. To hold so, this Court referred to the
th th
Joint Committee meetings held on 15 September 2010, 15 March
th th
2011 and 27 July 2012, which were followed by a letter dated 4
November 2013. Minutes of these meetings reveal that some
9 of 9
alternatives, including giving of individual option to choose
between the ACP Scheme and MACP Scheme, were considered but
not favoured as impracticable.
(emphasis supplied)
12. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has clearly held that the ACP Scheme which is now
superseded by MACP Scheme is a matter of Government policy. Interference with the
recommendations of the expert body like Pay Commission and its recommendations for the
MACP, would have serious impact on the public exchequer. The recommendations of the
Pay Commission for MACP Scheme has been accepted by the Government and
implemented. There is nothing to show that the Scheme is arbitrary or unjust warranting
interference.
13. In the light of the decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court referred to above, we do
not see any merit in this OA and accordingly, it is dismissed with no order as to cost.
(M.L. Srivastava) (Veena Kothavale)
Member(A) Member(J)
17.11.2026
asvs
Digitally signed by ASAPU
SRINIVASA VIDYASAGAR
Date: 2026.11.20 17:01:28
+05'30'
A.S.V. Sagar
P.S., CAT,
Chennai Bench.