Archana Nagar vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh

Court
Madhya Pradesh High Court

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
1


IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON’BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK KUMAR SINGH
th
ON THE 17 OF NOVEMBER, 2026
WRIT PETITION No.24707 of 2024
CNR No.: MPHC010523832024
Archana Nagar
Versus
The State of Madhya Pradesh & others
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance:
Petitioner present in person
Shri B.D. Singh - Deputy Advocate General for the respondents/State.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reserved on : 08.10.2026
Delivered on : 17.11.2026
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
The petitioner has filed the instant petition questioning the legality, validity
and propriety of the impugned charge-sheet dated 16.06.2023 (Annexure P/3)
issued by respondent No. 4, whereby, a departmental inquiry was initiated against
her on three charges relating to Crime No. 637/2021 registered at Police Station
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
2


Gorakhpur. The petitioner further challenges the consequential impugned order
dated 10.08.2024 (Annexure P/13) passed by respondent No. 3, whereby, the
detailed reply submitted by the petitioner to the aforesaid charge-sheet was
rejected as non-satisfactory and directions were issued to proceed further with the
departmental inquiry.
2. The factual matrix of the present case is that the petitioner, who was
serving as an Inspector in the Madhya Pradesh Police Force was transferred to
District Jabalpur and posted as Station House Officer, Police Station Gorakhpur
on 21.08.2021. During the said posting, respondent No. 4 issued multiple
commendation and cash reward orders in favour of the petitioner. In the
intervening night of 01.11.2021 at about 11:00 – 11:30 PM, an incident of firing
occurred at Gorakhpur Market within the jurisdiction of P.S. Gorakhpur, in which
a street vendor, Ravi Prajapati, sustained a gunshot injury and was admitted to
Metro Hospital, Jabalpur for treatment. Upon receipt of hospital intimation on
02.11.2021, Sub-Inspector Ramakant Dwivedi of P.S. Gorakhpur proceeded to
Metro Hospital, recorded the statement of the injured victim’s mother, as the
victim was declared unfit to give a statement by the attending doctor and wrote a
Dehati Nalisi under Sections 307 and 34 of the IPC against unknown assailants.
On the basis of the said Dehati Nalisi, FIR No. 637/2021 was registered at P.S.
Gorakhpur on 02.11.2021 late at night around 9:30 PM.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
3


3. On the evening of 02.11.2021 at around 5:30–6:00 PM, owing to the illness
of the regular City Superintendent of Police (CSP), Gorakhpur, respondent No. 4
orally instructed Ms. Priyanka Shukla, IPS, the then CSP, Bargi Division,
Jabalpur, to look after the supervisory charge of Gorakhpur Division and inspect
the scene of the shooting. On the very next day, i.e., 03.11.2021, respondent No.
4 issued formal written order transferring the investigation of Crime No.
637/2021 from P.S. Gorakhpur and appointing Ms. Priyanka Shukla, CSP Bargi,
as the Investigating Officer of the case. In compliance with the said order of the
Superintendent of Police, the case diary of Crime No. 637/2021 was handed over
to CSP Bargi on 03.11.2021 at 07:56:38 PM, as recorded in Case Diary No. 2 and
Rojnamcha Sanha dated 03.11.2021. Subsequently, on 02.02.2022, CSP Bargi
Ms. Priyanka Shukla obtained police remand of two accused persons arrested in
Crime No. 637/2021, namely, Satyam Madari @ Satyam Rajak and Raja Soni @
Ashish Soni and lodged them at P.S. Gorakhpur. On 03.02.2022, CSP Bargi
submitted a complaint report to respondent No. 4 alleging that the petitioner had
interfered in her investigation by telephoning the victim’s brother, Anil Prajapati,
on the evening of 02.02.2022 and calling him and his mother, Smt. Parvati Bai to
P.S. Gorakhpur at 10:00 AM on 03.02.2022 for identification of the accused
without informing the Investigating Officer.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
4


4. On 03.02.2022, respondent No. 4 passed an order temporarily attaching the
petitioner from P.S. Gorakhpur to Police Line, Jabalpur. On the very next day,
04.02.2022, respondent No. 4 placed the petitioner under suspension. The
petitioner challenged her attachment order in W.P. No. 3209/2022 and her
suspension order in W.P. No. 4664/2022 before this Court. By order dated
20.04.2023, a Coordinate Bench of this Court dismissed W.P. No. 3209/2022 and
by a separate order of the same date in W.P. No. 4664/2022, relegated the
petitioner to avail the statutory remedy of appeal against her suspension within
15 days, directing the appellate authority to decide her appeal on merits without
adverting to limitation and keeping in view the law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Ajay Kumar Choudhary vs. Union of India , (2015) 7 SCC
291 and the General Administration Department (GAD) guidelines against
keeping government servants under prolonged suspension. Pursuant to the liberty
granted by this Court on 20.04.2023, the petitioner submitted a comprehensive
appeal against her suspension on 01.05.2023 before the Deputy Inspector General
of Police (DIG), Jabalpur Range, specifically contending inter alia that she was
neither the Investigating Officer in Crime No. 637/2021 nor afforded any
opportunity of hearing prior to being condemned.
5. While the petitioner’s statutory appeal against suspension was pending
consideration before the DIG, respondent No. 4 issued the impugned charge-sheet
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
5


dated 16.06.2023 (Annexure P/3) levelling three charges against the petitioner in
connection with Crime No. 637/2021. Seven days after the issuance of the
impugned charge-sheet dated 16.06.2023, the Appellate Authority (DIG, Jabalpur
Range) passed the order dated 23.06.2023 (Annexure P/4) dismissing the
petitioner’s appeal against suspension, specifically relying upon the issuance of
the charge-sheet dated 16.06.2023 to negate her contention regarding Crime No.
637/2021.
6. Thereafter, the petitioner submitted applications dated 05.07.2023,
26.10.2023 and 08.02.2024 requesting copies of relevant documents to enable her
to submit an effective defence reply, in response to which partial documents were
supplied to her on 29.09.2023 and 26.02.2024, while reminders were issued to
her on 27.01.2024, 03.02.2024 and 15.02.2024. After withdrawing her earlier writ
petition (W.P. No. 6829/2024) on 02.04.2024 with liberty to file a properly
constituted petition, the petitioner submitted an exhaustive reply to the charge-
sheet on 04.06.2024. However, by the impugned order dated 10.08.2024
(Annexure P/13), respondent No. 3 rejected the petitioner’s reply by merely
stating that it was found unsatisfactory and directed that the departmental inquiry
proceed further. During the pendency of the present litigation, in a connected writ
petition challenging her prolonged suspension (W.P. No. 24705/2024), a
Coordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 15.10.2024 stayed the operation
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
6


of her suspension order dated 04.02.2022, observing that keeping a police officer
under suspension for an indefinite period of over two and a half years without
conclusion of the inquiry is improper.
7. It is contended by the petitioner that she was never the Investigating Officer
of Crime No. 637/2021. The FIR was registered late at night on 02.11.2021 at
9:30 PM on the Dehati Nalisi written by SI Ramakant Dwivedi and on the very
next day, i.e., 03.11.2021, respondent No. 4 passed an order appointing CSP
Bargi Ms. Priyanka Shukla as the Investigating Officer. It is submitted that
certified copies of the General Diary entries of P.S. Gorakhpur dated 03.11.2021
demonstrate that vide Rojnamcha Sanha No. 042 recorded at 05:06:19 PM on
03.11.2021, the initial Investigating Officer SI Ramakant Dwivedi had already
inspected the CCTV cameras at and around the scene of occurrence and secured
the CCTV footage from the camera installed in front of Kamna Fabric onto a pen
drive, prior to the petitioner handing over the case diary to CSP Bargi at 07:56:38
PM vide Rojnamcha Sanha No. 050. Consequently, it is submitted that charge
No. 3 is directly contrary to the police station’s own contemporaneous General
Diary record.
8. With respect to charges No. 1 and 2, petitioner submits that the imputation
in Paragraph No. 14 of the charge-sheet alleging that the petitioner had neither
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
7


the investigation nor any pending CM Helpline complaint inquiry in Crime No.
637/2021 and yet summoned Anil Prajapati and Smt. Parvati Prajapati on
03.02.2022 is falsified by the official CM Helpline portal printout annexed with
the charge-sheet itself which shows that on 13.01.2022, CM Helpline Complaint
was transferred back to P.S. Gorakhpur and officially assigned to the petitioner
as the L-1 Officer for redressal. The petitioner further argues that the impugned
charge-sheet is a classic case of no evidence because neither Anil Prajapati nor
Smt. Parvati Prajapati ever lodged any complaint against the petitioner regarding
the alleged summoning on 03.02.2022. It is further contended that their
statements were never recorded during any preliminary inquiry and neither of
them has even been cited as a witness in the list of 13 prosecution witnesses
appended to the charge-sheet. It is thus submitted that even if the allegations are
taken at face value, summoning a complainant party to the police station does not
amount to misconduct or a violation of Regulation 579 of the M.P. Police
Regulations.
9. Lastly, it is submitted that the impugned charge-sheet dated 16.06.2023
was issued after an inordinate delay of 19 months without conducting the
independent preliminary inquiry ordered by respondent No. 4 on 27.04.2023 as
the Additional SP (City South) merely returned the file on 15.06.2023 stating no
fresh inquiry was required. Furthermore, respondent No. 3 passed the impugned
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
8


order dated 10.08.2024 mechanically, acting solely on the recommendation of
respondent No. 4 without considering a single ground or official record cited in
the petitioner’s detailed reply dated 04.06.2024.
10. Per contra , Ld. counsel appearing for the Respondents/State supported the
impugned action and placing reliance upon the order dated 31.08.2024 and the
subsequent clarifying order dated 17.10.2024 passed by a Coordinate Bench of
this Court in W.P. No. 24876/2024, Ld. counsel submits that the petitioner’s
challenge to an identical inquiry-initiation order dated 10.08.2024 and a charge-
sheet dated 07.07.2023 has already been dismissed by this Court. It is submitted
that in that order, the Coordinate Bench held that under Clause 228 of the M.P.
Police Regulations and analogous Rule 14(5) of the M.P. Civil Services
(Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1966 , the disciplinary authority is not
required to pass a speaking order while rejecting a delinquent officer’s statement
of defence and appointing an inquiry officer. Since the petitioner did not
challenge the order passed in W.P. No. 24876/2024, the legal issue regarding the
validity of the order dated 10.08.2024 has attained finality. It is further contended
that the scope of judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution against a
charge-sheet is extremely narrow and disputed questions of fact regarding the
merits of the charges cannot be adjudicated at the threshold stage prior to the
conclusion of the departmental inquiry.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
9


11. Referring to the pleadings and returns filed in connected W.P. No.
15336/2022 and W.P. No. 4664/2022 as well as applications moved by the
petitioner, Ld. counsel submits that the petitioner has a chequered service history,
she faces numerous complaints from citizens, lawyers and subordinate staff
resulting in multiple preliminary inquiries and has been deliberately
procrastinating the departmental inquiries initiated against her. On these
premises, the Ld. counsel prays for dismissal of the writ petition.
12. Heard the respective counsel and perused the record.
13. It is a well-settled rule of service jurisprudence that a writ Court exercising
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution does not ordinarily sit in appeal
over the correctness of charges at the threshold stage of a show-cause notice or
charge-sheet, as the issuance of a charge-sheet does not by itself infringe the
rights of a delinquent employee unless it is followed by an adverse final order.
However, this self-imposed restraint is subject to well-recognized exceptions
carved out by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. In State of Punjab vs. V.K. Khanna
and Others , (2001) 2 SCC 330 , the Hon’ble Supreme Court held in paragraph
No. 33 as under:
“ 33. While it is true that justifiability of the charges at the stage
of initiating a disciplinary proceeding cannot possibly be delved
into by any court pending inquiry but it is equally well settled that
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
10


in the event there is an element of malice or mala fide, motive
involved in the matter of issue of a charge-sheet or the authority
concerned is so biased that the inquiry would be a mere farcical
show and the conclusions are well known then and in that event
law courts are otherwise justified in interfering at the earliest
stage so as to avoid the harassment and humiliation of a public
official. It is not a question of shielding any misdeed that the Court
would be anxious to do, it is the due process of law which should
permeate in the society and in the event of there being any
affectation of such process of law that law courts ought to rise up
to the occasion and the High Court, in the contextual facts, has
delved into the issue on that score. On the basis of the findings no
exception can be taken and that has been the precise reason as to
why this Court dealt with the issue in so great a detail so as to
examine the judicial propriety at this stage of the proceedings.”
[Emphasis Supplied]
14. Similarly, in Zunjarrao Bhikaji Nagarkar vs. Union of India , (1999) 7
SCC 409 , the Hon’ble Supreme Court underscored that disciplinary proceedings
cannot be initiated lightly or on the basis of vague suspicion and there must exist
a reasonable, objective basis in material on record to proceed against an
employee. Where a charge-sheet is shown to have been issued with a closed mind,
without conducting the mandated preliminary fact-finding inquiry or in direct
contravention of the State’s own unimpeachable official records, judicial review
under Article 226 is not excluded.
15. Adverting to the heavy reliance placed by the respondents/State on the
Coordinate Bench order dated 31.08.2024 and modified order dated 17.10.2024
in W.P. No. 24876/2024, a careful reading of the said order demonstrates that it
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
11


is wholly distinguishable on facts and does not govern the controversy in the
present petition. In W.P. No. 24876/2024, the challenge pertained to a charge-
sheet dated 07.07.2023 arising out of the complaint of one Prakash Patel, wherein
the petitioner faced two grave charges of financial extortion and corruption under
Paras 64(2), 64(10) and 582 of the M.P. Police Regulations. The imputation of
charges in that case alleged that when Prakash Patel was nabbed for gambling on
01.09.2021 and 27.01.2022, the petitioner demanded Rs.15,000/- and ₹8,000/- for
releasing him which was corroborated during a full-fledged preliminary inquiry
by the statements of witnesses Sachin Jatav and Mukesh as well as bank account
statements confirming ATM withdrawals of Rs. 10,000/- on 01.09.2021 and Rs.
8,000/- on 27.01.2022. In complete contrast, the impugned charge-sheet dated
16.06.2023 in the present petition levels no allegation of bribery, financial
demand or pecuniary gain whatsoever and pertains solely to alleged procedural
lapses and summoning of the complainant party in Crime No. 637/2021.
16. Furthermore, in paragraphs No. 6 and 7 of the order in W.P. No.
24876/2024, the Coordinate Bench held that where specific, triable charges of
corruption supported by preliminary inquiry findings and bank records are
framed, the disciplinary authority at the stage of considering the employee’s
statement of defence under Clause 228 of the M.P. Police Regulations or
analogous Rule 14(5) of the M.P. Civil Services (CCA) Rules, 1966 , is only
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
12


required to form an opinion as to whether triable issues remain for inquiry and is
not required to pass a detailed speaking order rejecting the defence on merits lest
it prejudice the Inquiry Officer. That ratio presupposes the existence of a legally
valid, prima facie sustainable charge-sheet that discloses triable issues. Even
under Rule 14(5)(a) of the Rules of 1966, the disciplinary authority is statutorily
obligated to consider the written statement of defence to determine whether the
charges ought to be inquired into or dropped. Where a charge-sheet is
demonstrated to be factually contradicted by the department’s own
contemporaneous General Diary and portal logs and the preliminary inquiry
ordered by the disciplinary authority itself was never conducted, the threshold
defect vitiates the charge-sheet itself and the consequential order dated
10.08.2024 cannot be insulated from judicial scrutiny merely by invoking order
passed in W.P. No. 24876/2024.
17. Charge No. 3 in the impugned charge-sheet dated 16.06.2023 reads as
follows:
“3- . 637/21 307, 34
थाना गोरखपुर के अपराध क धारा भाद ǒ व ǔ जसक ȧ
02.11.2021 ,
कायमी Ǒ दनांक को क ȧ गयी जो गंभीर Ǒ क è म का
16
अपराध था ǔ जसम Ʌ इनके Ʈ ारा घटना के घ Ö टे प Ʊ ात भी अ £ ात
. . . .
आरो ǒ पय ɉ क ȧ पहचान के िलए सी सी ट ȣ å ह ȣ कैमरा नह ȣ ं Ǒ दखवाए
. . . . ,
गये तथा ǒ ववेचना म Ʌ सी सी ट ȣ å ह ȣ फुटेज Ĥ ा Ư नह ȣ ं Ǒ कये गये ता Ǒ क
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
13



वे ǒ ववेचना क ȧ वा è त ǒ वक त Ø य ɉ को छुपाकर Ǒ कसी अ Û य को झूठे
”
आरोप ɉ म Ʌ आरो ǒ पत कर सक Ʌ ।
18. To test whether charge No. 3 has any factual or legal foundation, the
undisputed chronology and contemporaneous official records of P.S. Gorakhpur
must be examined. As recorded in paragraph No. 5 of the impugned charge-sheet
itself, Crime No. 637/2021 under Sections 307, 34 of the IPC was registered on
02.11.2021 and its initial investigation and Dehati Nalisi were conducted by Sub-
Inspector Ramakant Dwivedi of P.S. Gorakhpur. The certified copy of the
General Diary of P.S. Gorakhpur obtained under the Right to Information Act
(Annexure D-1 to I.A. No. 21321/2024) contains Rojnamcha Sanha No. 042
dated 03.11.2021 recorded at 05:06:19 PM by the initial Investigating Officer,
Sub-Inspector Ramakant Dwivedi who is cited as prosecution witness No. 8 in
the impugned charge-sheet. In the said General Diary entry, SI Ramakant
Dwivedi contemporaneously recorded the steps taken by him in the investigation
of Crime No. 637/2021. Barely two hours and fifty minutes after SI Ramakant
Dwivedi recorded Rojnamcha Sanha No. 042 confirming that the CCTV cameras
at and around the crime scene had been viewed and the footage from the camera
in front of Kamna Fabric had been secured in a pen drive, the petitioner recorded
Rojnamcha Sanha No. 050 on 03.11.2021 at 07:56:38 PM as well as Case Diary
Entry No. 2 at Page 37 of the petition, handing over the entire case diary of Crime
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
14


No. 637/2021 to CSP Bargi Ms. Priyanka Shukla in compliance with SP
Jabalpur’s Order No. 585/2021 dated 03.11.2021.
19. Significantly, in the Return filed by the Respondents, more than two
months after the petitioner placed the certified Rojnamcha entries on record on
18.11.2024, the Respondents have not disputed the genuineness or accuracy of
Rojnamcha Sanha. Once the police station’s own contemporaneous online
General Diary establishes beyond a shadow of doubt that the initial Investigating
Officer, SI Ramakant Dwivedi had already inspected the CCTV cameras around
the spot and preserved the CCTV footage from in front of Kamna Fabric in a pen
drive before the investigation was transferred to CSP Bargi at 07:56 PM, the
allegation in Charge No. 3 that CCTV cameras were not checked and CCTV
footage was not obtained is rendered patently false and perverse. It is evident that
neither the complainant officer (CSP Bargi) nor the disciplinary authority
(respondent No. 4) bothered to peruse Rojnamcha Sanha No. 042 of their own
police station before framing charge No. 3.
20. Charges No. 1 and 2 of the impugned charge-sheet dated 16.06.2023 are
interlinked as:
“1- . 637/21 307, 34
थाना गोरखपुर के अपराध क धारा भाद ǒ व ǔ जसक ȧ

ǒ ववेचना त × का० नगर पुिलस अधी ¢ क बरगी संभाग जबलपुर के Ʈ ारा
.
क ȧ जा रह ȣ थी। इसके बावजूद भी त × का थाना Ĥ भार ȣ गोरखपुर सु Į ी
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
15



अच ना [ नागर के Ʈ ारा Ĥ करण के आहत के भाई अिनल Ĥ जापित को गलत

जानकार ȣ देकर ǒ ववेचना के िलए बुलाया। अथा त [ थाना Ĥ भार ȣ के

अिधकार ɉ का Ǿ पयोग करना पाया गया जो पुिलस रे Ê यूलेशन के पैरा
दु
579
का उ ã लंघन है।
2-
इनके Ʈ ारा इस Ĥ करण म Ʌ ǒ ववेचक न होते अपने अिधकार ɉ से परे
हुए

जाकर इस Ĥ करण म Ʌ ह ȣ थाना गोरखपुर म Ʌ अिनल Ĥ जापित एवं Į ीमती
03.02.2023
पाव ती [ Ĥ जापित को अनािधकृत Ǿ प से Ǒ दनांक को सुबह
10.00 01.00 ,
बजे से दोपहर बजे तक बुलाकर अनाव æ यक बैठाया गया
”
जो Ǒ क ǒ विध अनु Ǿ प कार [ वाई नह ȣ ं है।
21. A perusal of the imputation of charges and the underlying reports of CSP
Bargi dated 03.02.2022 and 21.04.2022 reveals the exact factual premise on
which charges No. 1 and 2 are founded. In her report dated 21.04.2022, CSP Bargi
stated that Smt. Parvati Bai Prajapati had lodged a CM Helpline complaint on
10.11.2021 regarding the non-arrest of the accused in Crime No. 637/2021, which
was transferred to Police Station Bargi on 24.11.2021 and therefore there was no
question of the said CM Helpline complaint showing on the portal of Police
Station Gorakhpur . In this respect, paragraph No. 14 of the impugned charge-
sheet states that on 11.11.2021, 15.12.2021 and 21.01.2022, the complaint was
transferred to CSP Bargi, and concludes that the petitioner had no official role or
complaint inquiry regarding the case. Despite this, she improperly summoned
individuals to the police station, interfering in the investigation and detaining
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
16


them unnecessarily solely to close a complaint lodged on the CM Helpline, likely
for personal gain.
22. However, when this Court peruses the official printout of CM Helpline
Complaint No. 15819675 which is part of the prosecution’s own documents
annexed with the charge-sheet, the entire edifice of paragraph No. 14 of the
charge-sheet and CSP Bargi’s reports is demolished by the department’s own
record. While the CM Helpline complaint was earlier forwarded to P.S. Bargi in
November and December, 2021, on 12.01.2022 and 13.01.2022, Sub-Inspector
Vinod Pathak of P.S. Bargi recorded on the portal that the complaint did not
pertain to his jurisdiction and remarked on 13.01.2022 that the complaint is linked
to an existing criminal case bearing Crime No. 637/2021 at the P.S. Gorakhpur
so the inquiry should appropriately be conducted by that same station.
Immediately consequent to the said remark, on 13.01.2022, the CM Helpline
portal officially transferred the complaint back to P.S. Gorakhpur and designated
the petitioner by name as the Level-1 (L-1) Resolution Officer. Furthermore, the
subsequent portal entries dated 21.01.2022, 25.01.2022 and 04.02.2022 explicitly
record that the inquiry into CM Helpline Complaint No. 15819675 was being
conducted by the Station House Officer, P.S. Gorakhpur and that because the L-
1 officer could not get the complainant’s statement recorded within the stipulated
timeframe despite repeated phone calls to mobile number 9753199328, the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
17


complaint escalated to the L-2 officer (SP, Jabalpur) on 25.01.2022 while still
requiring action and status reporting from the SHO, P.S. Gorakhpur as late as
04.02.2022.
23. The above unimpeachable entries from the prosecution’s own CM Helpline
log expose a fundamental contradiction at the heart of charges No. 1 and 2.
Contrary to CSP Bargi’s assertion that the complaint was not showing on the
portal of P.S. Gorakhpur after 24.11.2021 and contrary to paragraph No. 14 of
the charge-sheet alleging that the petitioner had no complaint inquiry related to
this case pending with her, the petitioner was officially designated on the CM
Helpline portal from 13.01.2022 onwards as the L-1 Officer responsible for
contacting the complainant Smt. Parvati Bai on mobile number 9753199328, used
by her son Anil Prajapati and recording her statement to redress the grievance.
Even the CDR summary annexed with the charge-sheet reflects calls made from
the official CUG number of SHO Gorakhpur (9479994071) to the complainant’s
number (9753199328). When the departmental portal itself mandated the
petitioner as the L-1 Officer to summon the complainant party and record their
statements for disposal of CM Helpline Complaint No. 15819675, her act of
calling the complainant party to the police station in connection with that case
cannot on the face of the record be characterized as an unauthorised act without
jurisdiction.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
18


24. Furthermore, both charges No. 1 and 2 revolve around what the petitioner
allegedly told Anil Prajapati over the telephone and how Anil Prajapati and Smt.
Parvati Prajapati were allegedly called and made to sit unnecessarily at Police
Station Gorakhpur from 10:00 AM to 01:00 PM on 03.02.2022. Yet, neither Anil
Prajapati nor Smt. Parvati Prajapati ever made any written complaint against the
petitioner regarding the incident of 03.02.2022; their statements were never
recorded by any preliminary inquiry officer; and most astonishingly, neither Anil
Prajapati nor Smt. Parvati Prajapati is even included in the List of 13 Prosecution
Witnesses appended to the impugned charge-sheet.
25. In the absence of any statement or testimony of Anil Prajapati and Smt.
Parvati Prajapati, the allegation regarding what transpired between the petitioner
and Anil Prajapati remains unverified hearsay and framing a major penalty
charge-sheet without examining or citing the primary witnesses to the transaction
is unsustainable in law.
26. The reason why such glaring factual contradictions crept into the impugned
charge-sheet becomes immediately apparent when one examines the procedural
history immediately preceding its issuance on 16.06.2023. The record
demonstrates that the genesis of the controversy was a complaint report dated
03.02.2022 submitted by Ms. Priyanka Shukla, the then CSP Bargi, to respondent
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
19


No. 4. In her report dated 21.04.2022, CSP Bargi explicitly stated that she did not
deem it necessary to seek any written explanation from the petitioner before
submitting her adverse report. Evidently recognizing that CSP Bargi was the
complainant/reporting officer and that an independent preliminary inquiry was
required to verify the allegations and afford the delinquent officer an opportunity
of explanation, respondent No. 4 vide official letter dated 27.04.2023, directed
Shri Sanjay Kumar Agrawal, Additional Superintendent of Police, City (South),
Jabalpur (PW-13), to conduct a preliminary inquiry into the allegations regarding
Crime No. 637/2021 and submit an inquiry report. However, a perusal of the letter
dated 15.06.2023 submitted by the Additional SP, City (South), Jabalpur, reveals
that no preliminary inquiry whatsoever was conducted by him. Instead of
examining the official records of P.S. Gorakhpur, recording the statements of
Anil Prajapati and Smt. Parvati Prajapati or calling for the explanation of the
petitioner, the Additional SP simply returned the original file to respondent No.
4 with a three-paragraph letter dated 15.06.2023 stating that because the then CSP
Bargi had already submitted detailed reports with documents on 03.02.2022 and
21.04.2022, there is no need to conduct an inquiry again in this matter.
27. On the very next day, respondent No. 4 accepted this complete abdication
of inquiry by the Additional SP (City South) and issued the impugned charge-
sheet by copying the allegations from CSP Bargi’s letters dated 03.02.2022 and
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
20


21.04.2022 and just seven days thereafter, on 23.06.2023, the Appellate Authority
dismissed the petitioner’s pending suspension appeal on the ground that a charge-
sheet dated 16.06.2023 had now been issued to her in respect of Crime No.
637/2021.
28. This procedure adopted by the respondent authorities suffers from two fatal
legal flaws: First, once the Disciplinary Authority consciously exercised its
discretion on 27.04.2023 to order a preliminary inquiry by an independent
superior officer into the complaint made by CSP Bargi, the designated Inquiry
Officer could not abdicate that mandate by treating the complainant’s own
unilateral reports as a completed preliminary inquiry. Treating the accuser’s
complaint as a self-contained preliminary inquiry report, specially when the
accuser admits she never sought any explanation from the delinquent officer,
offends basic principles of natural justice and administrative fair play. Had the
Additional SP (City South) conducted the preliminary inquiry as directed on
27.04.2023, the contemporaneous Rojnamcha entry showing seizure of the
CCTV footage and the CM Helpline log dated 13.01.2022 showing the
petitioner’s designation as L-1 Officer would have immediately come to light.
Second, even when the petitioner brought these materials on record in her
exhaustive reply dated 04.06.2024 (Annexure P/12), respondent No. 3 failed to
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
21


apply his mind to the unimpeachable official records and mechanically passed the
impugned order dated 10.08.2024 rejecting her reply as unsatisfactory.
29. Before parting with the merits, this Court also notes that the respondents
have annexed a voluminous compilation (Annexure A-2) comprising returns and
documents from other writ petitions viz. W.P. No. 15336/2022 and W.P. No.
4664/2022, detailing other complaints and past service incidents involving the
petitioner. However, as settled by the Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Mohinder Singh Gill vs. The Chief Election Commissioner, New Delhi ,
AIR 1978 SC 851 , the validity of an order by a statutory functionary must be
judged by the reasons and charges mentioned therein and cannot be supplemented
or validated by importing extraneous grounds or unrelated allegations through
affidavits in Court. Separate departmental proceedings have already been
initiated by the respondents in respect of those distinct complaints such as the
charge-sheet dated 07.07.2023 in Annexure P/5 and the charge-sheet upheld in
W.P. No. 24876/2024 in Annexure A-1 which will be adjudicated on their own
merits. The existence of other proceedings cannot validate a charge-sheet in the
present matter that is patently vitiated by non-application of mind to the
department’s own official records and the abdication of the ordered preliminary
inquiry.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
22


30. Having held that the impugned charge-sheet dated 16.06.2023 (Annexure
P/3) and the consequential order dated 10.08.2024 (Annexure P/13) are
unsustainable and liable to be quashed, the question remains as to whether the
respondents should be permanently foreclosed from examining the matter or
granted liberty to proceed afresh in accordance with law. It is a settled principle
of administrative law that where a disciplinary action is set aside on account of
procedural infirmities, non-consideration of vital official records and failure to
conduct a proper preliminary inquiry, the Court ought not to usurp the executive
function of the Disciplinary Authority but should remit the matter by granting
liberty to the competent authority to proceed afresh strictly in accordance with
law, if so advised. Accordingly, while quashing the impugned charge-sheet dated
16.06.2023 and the consequential order dated 10.08.2024, this Court deems it just
and proper to reserve liberty to the respondents to take action afresh in accordance
with law, subject to first conducting an independent preliminary inquiry and duly
considering the official records of the department.
31. Consequently, the impugned charge-sheet dated 16.06.2023 issued by
respondent No. 4 is hereby, quashed. As a result thereto, the impugned order
dated 10.08.2024 passed by respondent No. 3 is also quashed. Liberty is reserved
to the respondents to proceed afresh in the matter strictly in accordance with law,
if so advised.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91146



WRIT PETITION NO. - 24707-2024
23


32. It is made clear that this order relates exclusively to the impugned charge-
sheet dated 16.06.2023 (Annexure P/3) and the consequential order dated
10.08.2024 (Annexure P/13) pertaining to Crime No. 637/2021 and nothing
observed herein shall affect or prejudice any other independent charge-sheets or
disciplinary inquiries pending against the petitioner.
33. In view of the aforesaid, the writ petition stands allowed .
34. There shall be no order as to costs.

(VIVEK KUMAR SINGH)
JUDGE
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ASHISH KUMAR
LILHARE
Signing time: 17-11-2026
17:14:47