RASHID BASHIR PIR vs UNION TERRITORY OF J AND K AND ANR. (HOME)

Court
Jammu and Kashmir High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
Reserved on: 05.11.2026
Pronounced on: 20.11.2026
Uploaded on: 20.11.2026
Whether the operative part or full judgment is
pronounced: Full

HCP No.215/2025
RASHID BASHIR PIR
...PETITIONER(S)/APPELLANT(S)
Through: - Mr. I. Sofi, Advocate.
Vs.
...RESPONDENT(S)
UT OF J&K & ANOTHER
Through: - Mr. Faheem Nissar Shah, GA.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1) Impugned in this petition is the detention order bearing
No. 19-DMK/PSA of 2025 dated 03.05.2025, issued by District
Magistrate, Kupwara, whereby the detenue, namely, Rashid
Bashir Pir , has been placed under preventive detention for
preventing him from indulging in the activities which are
detrimental to the security of the UT of Jammu & Kashmir.
2) In the petition, it has been contended that the detention
of the detenue is in violation of the provisions of the
Constitution and J&K Public Safety Act. It has been contended
that the procedural safeguards have not been complied with in
the instant case, inasmuch as whole of the material which
formed basis of the impugned detention order has not been
HCP No.
215/2025

Page
1
of
5

supplied to the petitioner. It has also been contended that the
detaining authority has not applied its mind independently
while passing the impugned order and that the grounds of
detention are verbatim reproduction of dossier. It has been
stated that the impugned order has been passed on the basis
of stale grounds. It has also been contended that the petitioner
had made a representation before the respondents but the
same has not been considered by them as no result of
consideration has been conveyed to the petitioner.
3) The respondents, in their counter affidavit, have
contended that while issuing the impugned detention order, all
the statutory requirements and constitutional guarantees have
been fulfilled and complied with by the detaining authority. It
is pleaded that the detention order and grounds of detention
along with the material relied upon by the detaining authority
were handed over to the detenue and the same were read over
and explained to him. It has been further contended that the
detenue was informed that he can make a representation to
the government as well as to the detaining authority against
his detention. It is also averred in the reply affidavit that all
statutory requirements and constitutional guarantees have
been fulfilled and complied with by the detaining authority.
The respondents have produced the detention record to lend
support to the stand taken in the counter affidavit.
HCP No.
215/2025

Page
2
of
5

4) I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
record of the case.
5) Learned counsel for the petitioner, while seeking
quashment of the impugned order, projected various grounds
but his main thrust, during the course of arguments, was on
the ground that the grounds of detention are vague, cryptic
lacking in material particulars, which prevented the detenue
from making an effective and suitable representation against
his detention
6) In the above context, it will be profitable to extract the
relevant portions of the grounds of detention, which read thus:
“….As per recent reports received from sister
agencies, you have again indulged in
subversive activities….”
“….you have been involved in activities
inimical to the security of the UT of Jammu &
Kashmir and in view of the police assessment
that the ordinary punitive law of the land is not
sufficient to curb your subversive
activities…..”
7)
A perusal of the above quoted extracts of the grounds of
detention clearly shows that the same are vague lacking in
material particulars. In the grounds of detention, the details of
alleged subversive and inimical activities and the particulars
of the period when the detenue again allegedly indulged therein
are also not given in the grounds of detention. Thus, the
grounds, being vague lacking in material particulars, the
detenue could not have made an effective representation
HCP No.
215/2025

Page
3
of
5

against his detention. Article 22(5) mandates that each ground
for detention must be individually specified so as to ensure
transparency and accountability in the detention process. The
grounds must not be vague, indefinite or general. Vague
allegations make it impossible for the detenu to understand
the reasons and effectively challenge the detention.
8) A Division Bench of this Court in the recent case titled
“ Imran Rashid Rather vs. UT of J&K ” 2024 LiveLaw (JKL)
351 has, while deliberating upon the effect of vagueness of the
grounds of detention on the subjective satisfaction of the
detaining authority, observed as under:-
“Therefore, this Court holds that vague and non-
specific grounds of detention firstly, violates the
fundamental right to life and personal liberty of the
detenue under article 21 of the constitution as it
summarily curtails the liberty of the citizen based
on the subjective satisfaction of the executive
which is an exceptional power as against the
general law relating to arrest and detention.
Secondly, it deprives the detenue of giving a
specific rebuttal to the grounds of detention which
may satisfy the detaining authority or the
Government that his detention is unlawful and
compels him to answer the grounds of detention
as "it is incorrect" or "it is false" etc. Thirdly, vague
and generalised grounds in the order of detention,
smacks of arbitrariness on the part of the detaining
authority rendering the subjective satisfaction
arrived at as violative of article 14 of the
constitution and fourthly, vague and non-specific
grounds raise the impression that the same has
been done deliberately in order to deprive the
detenu of giving a precise rebuttal. Malafide in fact
may be difficult to establish as they must be
pleaded with specific facts, but the lack of
bonafides 1State of Bihar Vs. P.P. Sharma,1992
Supp(1) SCC 222, paragraph 49 - State of Punjab
Vs. Gurdial Singh, (1980) 2 SCC 471, paragraph 9 -
Pooja Batra Vs. Union of India and others, (2009) 5
SCC 296, paragraphs 18,40 and 41 may be
presumed where the executive act results in the
HCP No.
215/2025

Page
4
of
5

deprivation of personal liberty from a detention
order based on vague grounds. In such cases, the
lack of bonafides is to be presumed due to a
cavalier or casual exercise of the authority to
detain the citizen without any specific ill will or
personal animosity. The lack of bonafides is on
account of failure to take due care and act without
introspection, blindly on the report of the SP
without insisting on supporting material which
justifies the deprivation of liberty.”
9) From the above analysis of the law, it is manifest that
vagueness of grounds of detention strikes at the root of the
subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority thereby
vitiating the order of detention. On this ground alone, the
impugned order of detention is liable to be set aside.
10) For the afore-stated reasons, the petition is allowed and
the impugned detention order is quashed. The respondents are
directed to release the petitioner from the preventive custody
forthwith, provided he is not required in connection with any
other case.
11) The detention record be returned to learned counsel for
the respondents.
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
Srinagar:
20.11.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”


Whether the judgment is reportable: Yes/No

HCP No.
215/2025

Page
5
of
5