SMT. NINGAJAMMA vs BASAPPASETTY H N
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 908 OF 2023 (INJ)
BETWEEN:
1. SMT.NINGAJAMMA
W/O LATE THAMMEGOWDA,
AGED ABOUT 80 YEARS,
2. SRI HARISHA
S/O LATE VENKATESH,
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
3. KUMARA
S/O LATE VENKATESH,.
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS,
ALL ARE R/AT HOSAKOTE VILLAGE,
CHUNCHANKATTE HOBLI,
SALIGRAMA TALUK - 571 603,
(PREVIOUSLY K.R. NAGAR TALUK)
MYSURU DISTRICT.
…APPELLANTS
Digitally signed
by ANUSHA V
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka
[BY SRI A.LOURDU MARIYAPPA, ADVOCATE]
AND:
1 . BASAPPASETTY H N.,
S/O LATE NANJAPPASETTY,
AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS,
MANAGER, SRI RACHAVATTI VEERABADRASWAMY
GADDIGE AND SRI NANJUNDESHWARA
KAMBI DEVARU OF HOSAKOTE,
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
CHUCHANAKATTE HOBLI,
SALIGRAMA TALUK - 571 603
MYSURU DISTRICT.
2 . SRI H B NANJAPPA
S/O BASAPPASETTY,
AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS,
R/AT HOSAKOTE VILLAGE,
CHUCHANAKTTE HOBLI,
SALIGRAMA TALUK - 571 603
(PREVIOUSLY K.R. NAGAR TALUK)
MYSURU DISTRICT.
3 . SMT.CHANDRAMMA
D/O LATE VENKATESH,
W/O KUMARA,
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
MARRURKAVULU,
KATTEMALALVADI POST - 571 134
HUNASUR TALUK,
MYSURU DISTRICT.
4 . SMT.SAVITHA
D/O LATE VENKATESH,
W/O SRINIVASA,
AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS,
R/AT NERALE VILLAGE,
BIDARAKKA POST,
HALLIMYSURU HOBLI,
HOLENARASIPURA TALUK - 573 211,
HASSAN DISTRICT.
…RESPONDENTS
[NOTE: DEF.NO.2 VENKATESH (DIED AS ON 21.07.2017) AND
DEF.NO.3 - SMT.BELLURAMMA (07.08.2007) AND DEF.NO.4 -
SMT.KAMALAMMA (01.04.2016) EXPIRED AND THUS DEF.NO.2,
3 & 4 ARE NOT MADE PARTY TO THIS SECOND APPEAL].
[BY SRI PRITHVIRAJ B.N., ADVOCATE FOR R2 (PH);
R1 & R3 - SERVED; V/O/D 5.12.2025 NOTICE TO R4 IS D/W]
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
THIS RSA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 100 OF CPC,
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 02.03.2023
PASSED IN RA NO.11/2015 ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR CIVIL
JUDGE AND JMFC, K.R.NAGARA, MYSORE DISMISSING THE
APPEAL AND CONFIRMING THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
DATED 06.04.2015 PASSED IN OS NO.38/2011 ON THE FILE
OF THE PRINCIPAL CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC, K.R.NAGARA.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR DICTATING JUDGMENT,
THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI
ORAL JUDGMENT
Challenging judgment and decree dated 02.03.2023
passed in RA no.11/2015 by Senior Civil Judge & JMFC, KR
Nagar, dismissing appeal, confirming judgment and decree
dated 06.04.2015 passed by Principal Civil Judge & JMFC., (Jr.
Dn.), KR Nagar, in OS no.38/2011, this appeal is filed.
2. Sri A Lourdu Mariyappa, learned counsel for
appellants submitted that Appeal was by defendant no.1 in OS
no.37/2002 filed by Kapini Shetty S/o Late HS Muddappa
Shetty and HB Rajanna S/o Basappa Shetty (plaintiffs no.1 and
2) for relief of declaration and permanent injunction, in respect
of four lands.
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
3. In plaint, it was stated that Sri Rachavatti
Veerabhadraswamy Gaddige ‘ Gaddige ’ and Sri
Nanjundeshwara Kambi Devaru were situated in Hosakote
village. It was stated that lands were purchased in names of its
devotees (1) Rachashettaru S/o Nanjappa Shetty, (2) Nanjappa
Shetty @ Muddappa Shetty S/o Sannappa Shetty, (3) Adappa
Shetty S/o Somashetty and (4) Veerabhadra Shetty S/o
Vishakantashetty under registered sale deed dated 08.06.1931
from Sri Doddegowda S/o Doddegowda and Marigowda S/o
Doddegowda. It was stated that said lands were ‘ sarvamanya’ ,
only boundaries without extents were mentioned in sale deed
and purchasers put in possession. Subsequent survey
settlement led to assignment of Sy.no.176/1 to extent of 39
guntas, Sy.no.177/1 to extent of 29 guntas, Sy.no.178/2 to
extent of 11 guntas and Sy.no.179/01 to extent of 1 Acre 5
guntas, totally measuring 3 Acres 4 guntas of Hosakote village,
Chunchanakatte Hobli, KR Nagara Taluk (‘ suit properties ’). It
was stated that from date of purchase, suit properties were
managed by said four persons. It was stated by efflux of time
plaintiff no.1 as son of Nanjappa Shetty @ Muddashetty
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
(purchaser no.2) was looking after Gaddige and its properties,
while plaintiff no.2 as Archak of Gaddige was cultivating lands.
4. Such being case, defendant no.1 being a powerful
woman, in collusion with revenue officials got her name entered
in respect of suit properties under MR no.24/1992-93 dated
03.06.1993, even though she did not have any manner of right,
title and interest over them. Plaintiff no.1 as Manager of
Gaddige filed RA no.50/1998-99 before Assistant
Commissioner, Hunsur and successfully challenged mutation,
which was set-aside with direction to Tahsildar to pass
considered order afresh. Thereafter, Tahsildar passed orders on
15.06.2001 refusing mutation. Aggrieved defendant no.1 filed
RA no.54/2001-02 before Assistant Commissioner, Hunsur.
5. However after filing appeal, defendant no.1 and
others began obstructing plaintiffs’ enjoyment of suit properties
illegally. Asserting that predecessors of plaintiffs namely HS
Muddappashetty and Rajappa Shetty had filed OS no.400/1970
for declaration, possession and mandatory injunction against
Sannamma (vendor of defendant no.1), Shivamma and
Thimmaiah and obtained decree of declaration of title over suit
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
properties in favour of Gaddige for mandatory injunction on
24.11.1973 and relief of possession was denied, present suit
for relief of permanent injunction against defendants, was filed.
6. On service of summons, defendant no.1 and 2 filed
common written statement denying suit properties as belonging
to Gaddige/plaintiffs. They asserted that defendant no.1 had
purchased suit properties from Sannamma @
Sannakkayyamma under registered sale deed dated
14.10.1981 and was put in possession. And against mutation
entering her name in revenue records, Kapanishetty filed
revenue appeal, which was allowed with direction for fresh
enquiry. When, Tahsildar refused mutation, defendant no.1
filed appeal.
7. Meanwhile, OS no.37/2002 was filed. During its
pendency initially plaintiff no.1 and later Vishakanta Shetty
impleaded in his place also died. Therefore, Chandrappa Shetty
filed application and came on record.
8. It was stated that after filing of written statement
by defendants and with sole intention to drag proceedings,
plaintiffs withdrew said suit. In meanwhile, revenue
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
proceedings concluded with order to bring revenue records as
per decree in civil suit. But, in collusion with Tahsildar, plaintiffs
got their names mutated and began interfering with possession
of defendants in name of Gaddige. Defendants denied existence
of Gaddige in suit properties and about plaintiffs owning them.
They alleged that filing of suit was with intention to knock off
suit properties. Defendant no.1 specifically asserted to be in
possession and cultivation of suit properties for growing
Tobacco. And denying plaintiff no.1 as Manager and defendant
no.2 as Archaka of Gaddige, prayed for dismissal of suit.
9. Based on pleadings, trial Court framed following:
ISSUES
1. Whether plaintiffs prove that they are in actual
possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule
properties as on the date of filing the suit?
2. Whether plaintiffs prove the interference by the
defendants?
3. Whether plaintiffs are entitled for the relief
claimed?
4. What order or decree?
10. In trial, plaintiff no.2 deposed as PW.1 and got
marked Exs.P1 to P40. While defendant no.1 and two others
deposed as DWs.1 to 3 and got marked Exs.D1 to D9.
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
11. On consideration, trial Court answered issues no.1
to 3 in affirmative and issue no.4 by decreeing suit. Since
defendant no.3 died during pendency of suit, defendants no.1,
2, 4 to 8 filed RA no.11/2015 on various grounds including that
judgment and decree by trial Court was contrary to evidence on
record and capricious, that trial Court did not consider fact that
khata of suit properties were never stood in name of Gaddige,
that when title was in dispute, suit for bare injunction was not
maintainable, that defendant no.1 was claiming interest over
suit properties under registered sale deed and impugned
judgment and decree was passed without plaintiffs proving
their possession or interference by defendants. It was also
contended that suit was without cause of action and filed in
personal capacity not as representative suit etc. and as such
untenable. On said grounds sought for allowing appeal and for
dismissal of suit.
12. Based on same, first appellate Court framed
following:
POINTS
1. Whether the impugned judgment and decree
dated 06.04.2015 passed by the trial Court in
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
OS no.38/2011, in decreeing the suit is against
law, facts, evidence and probabilities of the
case and as such it is liable to be interfered with
by this Court?
2. What order?
13. On consideration, points no.1 was answered in
negative and point no.2 by dismissing appeal. Challenging
concurrent erroneous findings, this appeal was filed.
14. At outset, it was submitted when subject matter of
OS no.38/2011 was suit properties belonging to Gaddige, suit
filed by plaintiffs in individual capacity was not maintainable. It
was submitted earlier suit i.e. OS no.400/1970 was also in
respect of suit properties and filed in representative capacity,
present suit filed without leave under Order I Rule 8 of Civil
Procedure Code, 1908 ( CPC ), ought to have been dismissed as
not maintainable. In support of said submission learned counsel
relied on decisions of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Brigade
Enterprises Ltd. v. Anil Kumar Virmani , reported in (2022)
4 SCC 138 and this Court in Kotak Mahindra Bank Ltd. v.
The Commercial Bank Retired Employees Association &
Ors. , reported in 2025 SCC OnLine Kar 16606 wherein it was
held compliance with Order I Rule 8 of CPC was mandatory.
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
15. It was further submitted though in OS
no.400/1970, relief of declaration and mandatory injunction
was granted, relief of possession was refused on ground that
only Archaks were entitled for enjoyment of suit properties and
plaintiffs therein were not Archaks. It was submitted that
Sannamma was wife of Archak – Veerabhadrashetty and who
came into possession and enjoyment of suit properties after his
death. Sannamma executed Ex.D1-registered sale deed in
favour of defendant no.1 herein. Consequently, defendant no.1
had valid title over suit properties and suit for injunction
against a person having title would not be maintainable.
16. It was submitted when plaintiffs were not in
possession present suit would not be maintainable. In support
of his submission learned counsel relied on decision of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Vasantha v. Rajalakshmi , reported in
(2024) 5 SCC 282 . It was submitted that both Courts failed to
take note of and appreciate reason behind rejection of relief of
possession in OS no.400/1970.
17. It was further submitted both Courts erred in
relying on Exs.P18 to P21 and Ex.P24 to P35 - orders of
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
Tahsildar and Assistant Commissioner for holding plaintiffs
being in possession of suit properties even when they had not
attained finality. It was submitted RP no.70/2009-10 filed
before Deputy Commissioner (DC) challenging said orders, was
disposed of subjecting revenue entries to final decree in
pending suit.
18. It was submitted that reliefs sought in OS
no.37/2002 was initially for declaration of title and for
permanent injunction. Plaintiffs later filed IA no.7/2009 for
permission to amend plaint by deleting prayer for declaration.
On rejection of application, plaintiffs approached this Court in
WP no.21105/2010 and WP no.21607/2010, which allowed IA
for amendment but with liberty to defendants to file additional
written statement. In pursuance thereof, plaintiffs deleted
prayer for declaration and retained suit only for permanent
injunction. It was submitted, in their additional written
statements, defendants no.1 and 2 had urged specific
contention about maintainability of suit for bare injunction
without prayer for declaration. It was submitted, both Courts
failed to frame issues/point on said contention or consider it.
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
Concurrent error would give rise to substantial question of law
as per ratio laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of
Anathula Sudhakar v. P. Buchi Reddy (Dead) by LRs &
Ors reported in 2008 (4) SCC 594.
19. It was further submitted, both Courts failed to
notice that while plaintiffs merely produced copies of title deed
(Ex.P1) whereas defendant no.1 produced original registered
Sale Deed (Ex.D1). Moreover, neither survey numbers nor
extent was mentioned in Ex.P1 whereas Ex.D1 did not suffer
from any such defect. That apart Ex.D1 dated 14.10.1981
being ’30-year-old document’, would attract presumptive value
under Section 90 of Evidence Act, 1872 (EA). Even such failure
would give rise to substantial question of law.
20. It was submitted, from date of sale by Sannamma
on 14.10.1981, defendant no.1 was in possession for more
than 40 years. In view of above, suit for bare injunction against
defendants in settled possession would not be maintainable.
Even said aspect was lost sight of by both Courts.
21. It was lastly submitted that judgment and decree
by first appellate Court suffers from non-application of mind as
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
it did not re-appreciate entire material on record in light of
pleading and evidence as required under Section 96 of CPC.
Hence, following substantial questions of law would arise for
consideration:
1. When defendants denied plaintiffs’ title over
suit properties and relief of possession even
in earlier suit was denied, whether suit for
bare injunction without prayer for declaration
or possession was maintainable ?
2. When as per plaintiff suit properties belonged
to Gaddige which is a Trust, whether suit
filed by plaintiffs in individual capacity was
maintainable?
3. Whether both Courts erred in ignoring claim
of defendant no.1 over suit properties was
under registered sale deed?
22. And prayed for answering same in favour of
defendants while allowing appeal.
23. On other hand, Sri Prithviraj BN., learned counsel
for plaintiff no.2 opposed appeal. At outset, it was submitted
that substantive rights over suit properties were already
adjudicated on basis of Ex.P1 - sale deed dated 08.06.1931 in
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
OS no.400/1970, declaring that suit properties belonged to
Gaddige and were to be enjoyed only by Archak of Gaddige. It
was submitted, relief of possession was declined in said suit
only on ground that suit properties were to be enjoyed by
Archak who actually performs Pooja and plaintiffs were not
Archak. But, in year 1977-78, plaintiff no.2 was appointed as
Archak and took over possession of suit properties and
Devaramane from Sannamma who was defendant no.1 in OS
no.400/1970. It was submitted, entire claim of defendant no.1
was based on Ex.D1 - sale deed dated 14.10.1981 incidentally
executed by very same Sannamma, who did not derive title
over suit properties. Therefore, she could not convey valid title
over suit properties in favour of defendants.
24. It was submitted Exs.D2 to D6 - RTCs of suit
properties from 1981 to 1993 showed names of Sanna
Akkayamma, Muddappa Shetty, Appanna Shetty & Adappa
Shetty in column no.9. Consequently, neither Sannamma or
Sanna Akkayamma had exclusive ownership or possession over
suit properties. Therefore, claim of title by defendant no.1 on
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
basis of sale deed executed by only Sannamma would be
defective. Hence, defendants are not bonafide purchasers.
25. Apart from above, fact that for more than 10 years
after Ex.D1 – sale deed, defendant no.1 did not attempt to get
her name entered in revenue records, would also cast grave
doubt on claim of being bonafide purchaser. And though during
year 1992-93, her name was entered as per MR 24/1992-93,
same was behind back of plaintiffs and immediately on coming
to knowledge of plaintiffs, it was challenged, got set-aside and
name of HM Kapini Shetty, Manager of temple was got entered
vide MR 42/2001-02.
26. And though in present suit plaintiffs had initially
sought relief of declaration & injunction, relief of declaration
was deleted with permission of Court. Moreso as declaration
was already given in OS no.400/1970 against Sannamma. It
was submitted Exs.P3 to P10 - RTCs would show that as on
date of suit, possession was with plaintiffs and Ex.P11 was
receipt for having paid land revenue since year 2001-02. On
contrary, defendants did not produce even a single record to
show payment of land revenue. It was submitted, Ex.P12 -
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
Patta Book stood in name of HM Kapinishetty. Further, DW.3
admitted about plaintiffs' possession over suit properties. Thus,
plaintiffs established their lawful possession over suit
properties. On contrary, defendants neither established title nor
possession.
27. It was submitted as defendant no.1 was claiming
title and possession under sale deed executed by Sannamma
who had already suffered decree of declaration of title in earlier
suit and therefore, she had no title, whereas plaintiffs were
claiming title not only on basis of registered sale deed but also
on basis of earlier decree, adage ‘possession follows title’ used
by Hon'ble Supreme Court in Anathula Sudhakar ’s case
( supra ), would aptly apply to present case. And as both Courts
had concurrently held in favour of plaintiffs by referring to
entire material and as no substantial question of law would
arise for consideration, there was no merit in appeal and
sought for dismissal.
28. Heard learned counsel, perused impugned
judgment, decree and records.
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
29. From above, it is seen that this Appeal under
Section 100 of CPC is by defendants no.1, 5 and 8, who after
death of Defendant no.2, 3 and 4 represented their estate as
LRs. While defendants no.6 and 7 arrayed as respondents
remained served unrepresented.
30. As noted above, appeal is against concurrent
findings. In instant case, defendants claim title over suit
properties and opposed suit for bare injunction. Defendants'
source their title from Sannamma under Ex.D1 – sale deed
executed on 14.10.1981. But with regard to very same suit
properties, said Sannamma suffered decree dated 24.11.1973
in OS no.400/1970 wherein it was declared that suit properties
belonged to Gaddige and were to be enjoyed by Archak. In
fact, Sannamma is wife of Archak – Veerabhadrashetty who
was one of four persons in whose names suit properties were
purchased and said Veerabhadrashetty was enjoying suit
properties as Archak and did not have any alienable right over
suit properties. As a direct consequence, it has to be held that
claim of title or about lawful possession of defendants would
not sustain in law. Ex.D1 is admittedly executed after decree in
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
OS no.400/1970 and it is settled law that a person without title
cannot confer better title than what he had. Even Exs.D.2 to
D.9 show Sannamma’s name jointly with Muddappashetty,
Annappashetty and others.
31. While passing impugned judgment and decree, trial
Court noted that, Ex.P2 - Mutation Register Extract and Exs.P3
to P10 - RTCs, Ex.P11 - Tax Paid receipt and Ex.P12 - Patta
Book of suit properties bore name of HN Kapini Shetty, to
conclude that plaintiff had established his lawful possession.
And very claim of defendants to have title and possession over
suit properties would amount to interference.
32. While answering point no.1 about judgment and
decree passed by trial Court suffering from perversity, first
appellate Court re-appreciated evidence and noted that name
of HN Kapini Shetty appeared in Ex.P2 – Mutation Register
Extract, Exs.P3 to P6 – RTC Extracts for year 2001-02, Exs.P7
to P10 – RTC Extracts for year 2008-09, Ex.P11 – Tax Paid
receipt for year 2001 and Ex.P12 – Patta Book to concur with
findings of trial Court. Consequently, contention about violation
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62614
RSA No. 908 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010245642023
of Order XLI Rule 31 of CPC i.e. failure to reappreciate material
on record by first appellate Court would not be substantiated.
33. From above, both Courts have held claim of title
and possession over suit properties by defendants is held to be
unsustainable and findings are concurrent on appreciation of
entire material. Contentions urged herein are as if in regular
appeal and appellants failed to point out any substantial
question of law arising for consideration. Hon’ble Supreme
Court in case of Hardial Singh v. Balbir Kaur and Anr.,
reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC 311 , held that even gross
errors cannot be ground for interference in second appeal.
dismissed
34. Hence, appeal is devoid of merit and as
such.
Sd/-
(RAVI V HOSMANI)
JUDGE
YKL,GRD
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 44