A.STALIN, vs V.KALAISELVI,

Court
Madras High Court

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT
Reserved on : 03-11-2026
Delivered on : 13-11-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MRS.JUSTICE THIRUMAGAL
CHANDRASEKAR
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
CNR:{HCMD010020252013}
1. A.Stalin,
S/o.Alagarsamy, Lakshmipuram Pudur,
Neerethan Village, Vadipatti Taluk, Madurai
District.
2. A.Chandrasekar,
S/o.Alagarsamy, Lakshmipuram Pudur,
Neerethan Village, Vadipatti Taluk, Madurai
District.
..Appellants / defendants
Vs
V.Kalaiselvi,
W/o.Venkatraman, Kattakulam Village, Vadipatti
Taluk, Madurai District.
... Respondent / Plaintiff
Prayer: Second Appeal filed under Section 100 CPC to set aside the
Judgment and decree in A.S.No.29 of 2010 dated 30.07.2012 on the file
of the Principal Sub Court, Madurai confirming the Judgment and decree
made in O.S.No.173 of 2008 dated 01.12.2009 on the file of the District
Munsif Cum Judicial Magistrate, Vadipatti.
__________
Page  1  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
For Appellants :Mr R.Saravanakumar
For respondent : Mr. S.Murugapandi
JUDGMENT
This Second Appeal has been filed against the Judgment and
decree dated 30.07.2012 in A.S.No.29 of 2010 on the file of the Principal
Sub Court, Madurai confirming the Judgment and decree dated
01.12.2009 made in O.S.No.173 of 2008 on the file of the District Munsif
Cum Judicial Magistrate, Vadipatti.
2. The Brief Facts of the case are as follows:
(i) The case of the plaintiff, in brief, is that the suit properties
comprise of two items and originally belonged to her father, Alagarsamy,
who acquired the same under a registered partition deed dated
20.08.2002. Under the said partition deed, the suit properties were
allotted to the share of Alagarsamy. Subsequently, by virtue of a
registered gift settlement deed dated 06.09.2002, Alagarsamy gifted the
suit properties in favour of the plaintiff. The plaintiff's brothers, namely,
Stalin and Chandrasekar, attested the said document as witnesses. It is
__________
Page  2  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
further stated that the wife of the deceased brother, Nehru, namely,
Laxmi Prabha, released whatever right she had in the suit properties in
favour of the plaintiff through a registered release deed dated 16.10.2003,
for valuable consideration.
(ii) According to the plaintiff, ever since the execution of the gift
settlement deed and the subsequent release deed, she has been in
possession and enjoyment of the suit properties by cultivating the lands
and constructing a house therein. The patta and other revenue records
were also transferred to her name. While so, on 15.09.2004, the
defendants, who are her brothers, along with their men, allegedly
attempted to interfere with her peaceful possession and enjoyment of the
suit properties, threatened to dispossess her from the house and further
threatened to destroy the standing paddy crops. Though the plaintiff sent
telegrams to the Superintendent of Police, Madurai Rural, and
subsequently lodged a complaint before the Inspector of Police,
Vadipatti, no effective action was taken. Hence, the plaintiff instituted the
suit seeking a decree of permanent injunction restraining the defendants
from interfering with her peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit
properties.
__________
Page  3  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
nd
(iii) The 2 defendant resisted the suit by filing a written
statement, which was adopted by the first defendant. They denied the
plaintiff's title and possession over the suit properties and contended that
the alleged gift settlement deed dated 06.09.2002 did not confer any right
upon the plaintiff. According to them, under the registered partition deed
dated 20.08.2002, only a life interest had been created in favour of
Alagarsamy Naidu in respect of the suit properties and the entire 'A'
Schedule properties therein, and therefore, he had no absolute right to gift
the suit properties to the plaintiff. They further contended that the alleged
attestation by the plaintiff's brothers would not confer any title upon her,
as the gift deed itself was invalid in law. They also disputed the validity
of the release deed executed by Laxmi Prabha, contending that she was
not competent to release the minor's property and that the said release
deed had subsequently been cancelled by a registered cancellation deed.
(iv). The defendants further denied that the plaintiff was in
possession and enjoyment of the suit properties and contended that
possession had never been delivered to her. They asserted that the house
situated in the suit properties had been constructed by them and not by
the plaintiff, and that the plaintiff had managed to transfer the patta and
other revenue records to her name by influencing the revenue officials on
__________
Page  4  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
the strength of the alleged invalid settlement deed. They also contended
that Alagarsamy Naidu and the minor Balaji were necessary parties to the
suit and that the suit was bad for non-joinder of necessary parties. On the
above grounds, the defendants sought dismissal of the suit with
exemplary costs.
(v). Before the trial Court, on the side of the plaintiff, P.W.1 was
examined and Exs.A1 to A17 were marked. On the side of the
defendants, D.Ws.1 and 2 were examined and Exs.B1 and B2 were
marked.
(vi). Upon consideration of the oral and documentary evidence, the
trial Court decreed the suit as prayed for. Aggrieved by the same, the
defendants preferred an appeal, which was dismissed by the first
appellate Court, thereby confirming the judgment and decree of the trial
Court.
3. Challenging the concurrent findings of the Courts below, the
appellants / defendants have preferred the present Second Appeal.
4. This Second Appeal is admitted by this Court on the following
substantial questions of law:-
__________
Page  5  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
a) Whether the courts below are right in granting
decree for injunction to the respondent/plaintiff is solely
relying on Ex.A2 settlement deed when Ex.A1 partition
prohibits such alienation by settlor himself.
b) Whether the courts below are right in decreeing the
suit for injunction, when Ex.A2 settlement deed was
admittedly cancelled under Ex.B2 cancellation deed dated
13.10.2004 and when the suit was filed in 2008.
5. Heard Mr. R. Saravanakumar, learned counsel appearing for the
appellants / defendants and Mr. S. Murugapandi, learned counsel
appearing for the respondent / plaintiff and perused the materials
available on record.
6. The respondent/plaintiff, the appellants/defendants 1 and 2, and
the deceased Nehru are the children of Alagarsamy. The suit properties
were allotted to Alagarsamy's share under the registered partition deed
dated 20.08.2002, marked as Ex.A1. The main dispute between the
parties is regarding the nature of the rights acquired by Alagarsamy under
Ex.A1 and the validity of the settlement deed executed by him in favour
of the respondent / plaintiff under Ex.A2.
__________
Page  6  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
7. A perusal of the recitals of Ex.A1 would reveal that the parties to
the partition deed had divided their ancestral properties into four
schedules, namely, A, B, C and D Schedules. Under the terms of the
partition deed, the properties described in the “A” Schedule were allotted
to the first party, namely, Alagarsamy. However, Alagarsamy shall enjoy
the “A” Schedule properties and derive income therefrom during his
lifetime, without creating any encumbrance, and that, after his lifetime,
the said properties shall devolve upon the sharers of the B, C and D
Schedules in equal shares, to be enjoyed by them with absolute rights.
However, the relevant recital in Ex.A1 specifically provides as follows:
" A 1
இதனடியில் கண்ட ஷெ ட்யூல் சொ த்துக்களை நம்மில் வது
M.R. ,
நபர் அழகர்சாமி ரெட்டியார் நாளது தே தி முதல் அடைந்தும்
அதில் வரும் வருமானங்களை மட்டும் அனுபவித்து வந்தும் ,
;
யாதொ ரு வில்லங்கங்கள் செய்யாமல் அனுபவித்து வந்தும்
மே ற்படியார் ஆயுளுக்குப் பின்பு மே ற்படி A ஷெ ட்யூல்
B, C, D
சொ த்துக்களை ஷெ ட்யூல்தாரர்கள் சமமாக அடைந்து
அதுமுதல் சர்வ சுதந்திர சகல பாத்தியமாய் ஆண்டு
."
அனுபவித்துக் கொ ள்ள வே ண்டியதெ ன்றும்
The above recital makes it clear that Alagarsamy was entitled to take
possession of the “A” schedule properties and enjoy only the income
derived therefrom during his lifetime, without creating any encumbrance.
It further stipulates that, after his lifetime, the “A” Schedule properties
shall devolve upon the sharers of the B, C and D Schedules in equal
shares, who shall thereafter enjoy the same with absolute rights. Thus, a
conjoint reading of the recitals of Ex.A1 makes it clear that Alagarsamy
__________
Page  7  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
was conferred only a life interest in respect of the “A” Schedule
properties and was not vested with absolute ownership or an unrestricted
right of alienation. The intention of the parties to the partition deed was to
restrict his enjoyment to his lifetime and to confer absolute rights upon
the respective sharers after his demise. Therefore, Alagarsamy could not
have conveyed a better title than what he had acquired under Ex.A1.
8. While so, Alagarsamy executed the registered settlement deed
dated 06.09.2002 in favour of his daughter, the respondent/plaintiff,
which was marked as Ex.A2. The relevant recital in Ex.A2 reads as
follows:
" ,
நீ என்னுடைய மகள் உன் பெயரில் எனக்குள்ள அன்பினாலும்
அபிமானத்தாலும் உன் வாழ்க்கை வசதிக்கும் ஆதரவுக்கும் உன்
20-08-02
பிற்கால நலன் கருதியும் ல் என் பாகத்திற்காக கிடைத்து
நான் அடைந்து அனுபவித்து வருகிற எ ஷெ ட்யூல் சொ த்துக்களில்
சில அயிட்டமாகிய இதனடியில் கண்ட சொ த்துக்களை நான்
இதன்மூலம் தானமாக எழுதிக்கொ டுத்து பாத்தியப்படுத்தி
வை த்துக்கொ டுத்துள்ளபடியால் அடியிற்கண்ட சொ த்துக்களை நீ
நாளது தே தி முதல் சுவாதீனம் அடைந்து என்றெ ன்றும் சர்வ சுதந்திர
பாத்தியமாய் உன் இஷ்டம்போ ல் ஆண்டு அனுபவித்து
,
கொ ள்வீர்களாகவும் உன் பெயர்க்கு பட்டா ஆகம்படி இத்துடன்
."
மாறுதல் மனுவும் கொ டுத்துள்ளே ன்
9. From the above recital, it is evident that Alagarsamy purported
to settle certain items of the “A” Schedule properties in favour of the
respondent / plaintiff, declaring that she would take possession thereof
and enjoy the same with absolute rights from the date of execution of the
settlement deed. However, when the settlor himself had been conferred
__________
Page  8  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
only a life interest under Ex.A1, he had no authority to convey absolute
ownership in favour of the respondent / plaintiff under Ex.A2.
Consequently, Ex.A2 cannot confer any absolute title upon the
respondent / plaintiff beyond the limited interest held by Alagarsamy
under Ex.A1. The fact that the appellants / defendants had attested Ex.A2
would not, by itself, validate a settlement deed executed beyond the rights
of the settlor.
10. Subsequently, the wife of the deceased Nehru, namely, Laxmi
Prabha, executed a registered release deed dated 16.10.2003 in favour of
the respondent/plaintiff, which was marked as Ex.A3. However, the said
release deed was subsequently cancelled by Laxmi Prabha, on behalf of
the minor, under the cancellation deed marked as Ex.B2. The validity and
legal effect of the said cancellation deed need not be independently
adjudicated in the present suit, which is one for bare injunction, except to
the extent that the rival claims are relevant to determine the nature of the
respondent / plaintiff's possession.
11. The trial Court, upon consideration of the oral and documentary
evidence, found that the respondent/plaintiff was in possession and
enjoyment of the suit properties on the date of institution of the suit and
__________
Page  9  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
also on the date of the alleged cause of action. The trial Court further
found that the respondent / plaintiff alone was cultivating the lands and
was in possession of an extent of 2½ cents of the suit properties. It also
took note of the alleged attempt made by the appellants/defendants to
interfere with her possession and to destroy the standing crops. The
complaint lodged by the respondent / plaintiff before the Vadipatti Police
Station was also considered by the trial Court while appreciating the
evidence relating to the alleged interference.
12. On the basis of the above findings, the trial Court decreed the
suit for permanent injunction. The first appellate Court, on reappreciation
of the oral and documentary evidence, concurred with the findings of the
trial Court and dismissed the appeal. The first appellate Court proceeded
on the footing that, in a suit for bare injunction, the primary consideration
is the actual possession of the respondent / plaintiff as on the date of
institution of the suit and that, where possession is established by cogent
evidence, the question of title need not necessarily be adjudicated in
detail.
13. This Court is of the considered view that the question of title
and the question of possession are two distinct aspects which require
__________
Page  10  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
separate consideration. In the present case, though Alagarsamy had
executed Ex.A2 settlement deed in favour of the respondent/plaintiff, the
recitals of Ex.A1 clearly indicate that he had been granted only a life
interest in the “A” Schedule properties. Therefore, the settlement deed
executed by him purporting to convey absolute rights in favour of the
respondent / plaintiff cannot confer any absolute title upon her and is
ineffective to that extent. Nevertheless, the absence of a valid title under
Ex.A2 would not, by itself, disentitle the respondent / plaintiff from
seeking protection of her established possession.
14. It is a settled principle of law that even a person who is in
settled possession of immovable property, though without title, cannot be
dispossessed otherwise than by due process of law. A person in
established possession is entitled to protect such possession against
unlawful interference, even as against a person claiming a better title,
until he is evicted in accordance with law. Therefore, a suit for bare
injunction is maintainable where the respondent / plaintiff establishes
actual and peaceful possession of the suit property and apprehends
unlawful interference therewith.
15. In the present case, the trial Court, on appreciation of the
__________
Page  11  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
evidence, has categorically found that the respondent/plaintiff was in
possession of the suit properties on the date of institution of the suit and
on the date of the alleged interference. The first appellate Court has also
affirmed the said finding. The appellants/defendants, having failed to
dislodge the concurrent finding regarding the respondent / plaintiff's
possession, cannot seek to defeat the suit for bare injunction merely by
disputing the validity of the settlement deed or by asserting a superior
title.
16. If the appellants/defendants claim absolute title over the suit
properties and seek recovery of possession from the respondent/plaintiff,
their appropriate remedy is to institute a separate suit for declaration of
title and recovery of possession, in accordance with law. The question of
title can be effectively adjudicated in such proceedings, wherein the
parties would have an opportunity to establish their respective claims on
the basis of the partition deed, settlement deed and other relevant
documents. The present proceedings, being confined to a suit for bare
injunction, do not warrant a final adjudication of the competing claims of
title.
17. In this regard, the learned counsel appearing for the
__________
Page  12  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
respondent/plaintiff placed reliance upon the judgment of this Court
reported in 2009 (3) CTC 493 , in the case of R. Pannerselvam v. A.
Subramanian and another , wherein it was held that, in a suit for bare
injunction, the primary consideration is the proof of possession and that
the question of title need not ordinarily be gone into when there is clear
evidence establishing the plaintiff's possession. It was further held that
even a trespasser in established possession is entitled to seek an
injunction against forcible dispossession, as such dispossession can be
effected only by following due process of law. He also relied upon the
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in 2021 (1) MLJ (Civil)
580, in the case of A. Subramanian and another v. R. Pannerselvam , in
support of the proposition that a person who establishes possession of the
suit property can maintain a suit for bare injunction to protect such
possession.
18. The principles laid down in the above decisions are applicable
to the facts of the present case. It is true that a person in settled
possession, even without title, is entitled to protection against forcible
dispossession. However, a distinction has to be drawn between a case
where the plaintiff merely seeks to protect established possession and a
case where the plaintiff's own pleadings disclose a substantial cloud over
__________
Page  13  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
title, which necessitates a declaration of title as an appropriate relief. In
the present case, notwithstanding the dispute regarding the validity of
Ex.A2 and Ex.A3, the concurrent findings of the Courts below establish
that the respondent/plaintiff was in possession of the suit properties on
the relevant dates.
19. Therefore, the invalidity or ineffectiveness of Ex.A2, insofar as
it purports to confer absolute title upon the respondent/plaintiff, would
not automatically extinguish her right to protect her established
possession by seeking a decree of permanent injunction. Equally, the
cancellation of the release deed under Ex.B2, by itself, would not
establish that the appellants / defendants were in possession of the suit
properties or that they were entitled to dispossess the respondent /
plaintiff otherwise than by due process of law.
20. In view of the above discussion, this Court finds that the Courts
below were justified in granting the relief of permanent injunction on the
basis of the respondent / plaintiff's established possession, without finally
adjudicating the rival claims of title. The appellants/defendants are at
liberty to work out their remedies by instituting appropriate proceedings
for declaration of title and recovery of possession, if so advised, in
__________
Page  14  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
accordance with law. Accordingly, the substantial questions of law are
answered against the appellants/defendants.
21. In the result, the Second Appeal is dismissed, confirming the
judgment and decree passed by the Courts below. There shall be no order
as to costs.
13-11-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
T. RAJAPRABA
To
1. The Principal Sub Court, Madurai.
2. The District Munsif Cum Judicial Magistrate, Vadipatti.
3. The Section Officer, VR Section, Madurai Bench of Madras High
Court, Madurai.
__________
Page  15  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
__________
Page  16  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
THIRUMAGAL CHANDRASEKAR, J.,
T. RAJAPRABA
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
13-11-2026
__________
Page  17  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )

2026:MHC:4569
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
SA(MD) No. 538 of 2013
THIRUMAGAL CHANDRASEKAR, J.,
This Second Appeal is admitted on the following substantial
questions of law:-
a) Whether the courts below are right in granting
decree for injunction to the respondent/plaintiff is solely
relying on Ex.A2 settlement deed when Ex.A1 partition
prohibits such alienation by settlor himself.
b) Whether the courts below are right in decreeing the
suit for injunction, when Ex.A2 settlement deed was
admittedly cancelled under Ex.B2 cancellation deed dated
13.10.2004 and when the suit was filed in 2008.
03.11.2026
trp
__________
Page  18  of  18
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
( Uploaded on: 16/11/2026 01:24:05 pm )