Gandadhipa Sahu vs State Of Odisha

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 544
Non-Reportable

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. OF 2026
(@ Special Leave Petition (Crl.) No. 21118 of 2025)



Gandadhipa Sahu
...Appellant
Versus
State of Odisha & Ors.
...Respondents



J U D G M E N T

K. VINOD CHANDRAN, J.

Leave granted.
2. Suicide for sure, whether on volition or driven to it by the
husband and in-laws, was the question posed before the trial
court. The husband and the in-laws were the accused charged
of continuous torture and harassment on demands of dowry.
The trial court acquitted the accused of the charges under
Section 304-B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (the IPC) finding
that there is no evidence on the aspect of demand of dowry
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
Deepak Guglani
Date: 2026.05.26
15:17:25 IST
Reason:
and that the letter produced, alleged to be a demand made by
Page 1 of 8
Crl. A. @ SLP(Crl.) 21118/2025

the father-in-law, A2, was not proved. However, relying on the
oral testimony of PW2 to PW5 and the letters said to have been
written by the deceased to her brother, PW3, and her father,
torture was found to have been meted out to the deceased by
the accused for non-fulfilment of unlawful demands. The
finding was despite holding that there were only general and
omnibus statements made without any specific or definite
instances or the particular day or time having been pointed
out. The trial court convicted the accused and sentenced the
accused to three years rigorous imprisonment (RI) and a fine
of Rs.5,000/- with default sentence of three months RI under
Section 498-A read with Section 34 of the IPC, as also under
Section 4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961 (the DP Act), with
no separate sentence passed under the DP Act.
3. At the outset, we notice that the conviction under the DP
Act is inconsistent with the finding of the trial court that there is
no demand of dowry established. It is also bewildering that the
trial court entered a conviction under Section 498-A of the IPC
on general and omnibus allegations raised, without specific
substantiation. The High Court having considered the
Page 2 of 8
Crl. A. @ SLP(Crl.) 21118/2025

evidence affirmed the conviction of the accused but modified
the sentence to six months of RI for A1 and one month and 15
days respectively for A2 and A3; both were also released
under Section 4 of the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958, on
execution of a bond for the fine amount, their conduct kept
under supervision of the Probation Officer for three months.
4. We have heard Sri Kailash Vasdev, learned Senior
Counsel appearing for the appellant who alone has chosen to
file the appeal and Ms. Ankita Chaudhary, learned State
Counsel.

5. The High Court rightly found that in the totality of the
circumstances, the conviction under Section 4 of the DP Act
cannot be sustained. The High Court also found that though
there were no specific or definite instances pointed out, which
alone would bring the case under the mischief of Section 498-A
of the IPC, still convicted the accused on the ground of “certain
particulars regarding the cruelty meted out to her having come
out in the evidence”. We have thus to examine the evidence
insofar as the charge alleged of torture and harassment, which
again we have to emphasize is not relating to any demand
Page 3 of 8
Crl. A. @ SLP(Crl.) 21118/2025

made of dowry, which was found to be non-existent by the trial
court, thus acquitting the accused under Section 304-B of the
IPC.
6. That the death occurred by suicide is clear from the
evidence of the Doctor, PW11 and PW9, a neighbour. PW9
deposed that she was holding the child of the deceased while
standing near her when suddenly she consumed something
from a bottle. PW9 snatched away the bottle, when the liquid
splashed on her, which she realized was a pesticide. PW9
swooned on the spot and only later, she came to know that her
neighbour had died. PW11 spoke of the frothy discharge from
the mouth and nose and cyanosis of the nails and lips found in
the postmortem, stated to be clear symptoms of poisoning. The
death was by suicide, whether impelled by the conduct of the
husband or not is the question posed.
7. For finding the allegation under Section 498-A, the trial
court relied on the evidence of PW2 to PW5 and the letters
produced as Exts. 6 & 7 which were alleged to have been
written by the deceased to her father and brother. Here, we
have to notice that PW2 to PW5 spoke about demands of
Page 4 of 8
Crl. A. @ SLP(Crl.) 21118/2025

dowry, instances when their sister returned to her family and
then after mediation in which the village elders participated,
having returned to her marital home on the assurance of the
husband to ensure that the acts complained of would never be
repeated.
8. As was noticed by the trial court and the High Court, we
too find that the testimony regarding demand of dowry was
general and omnibus. PW3, the brother speaks of the
deceased having spoken of the demand of dowry and torture
on that count, ten days after her marriage when her father
visited her. Subsequently, she gave birth to a child in her
paternal home and refused to go to her marital home. A Samaj
was convened in which the husband assured that there would
be no such complaints hereafter.
9. PW5, a cousin of the deceased speaks of six people
having participated in the mediation among which the name of
PW6 figures but the Investigating Officer, PW10 states that
PW6 had never spoken of the Samaj or his participation, in the
statement before police. PW6 hence was disbelieved by the
trial court and the High Court. PW3, PW2 & PW5 were the
Page 5 of 8
Crl. A. @ SLP(Crl.) 21118/2025

brother and cousin brothers of the deceased whose allegations
were omnibus in nature; neither was there the specific
demands spoken of nor the persons who made such demands
pointed out or specific instances testified, as rightly found by
the High Court. An independent witness examined, PW4 said
that he was a part of the Samajam convened but he is not one of
the six persons spoken of by PW5.
10. Much reliance was placed on Exts. 6 and 7, the letters
alleged to have been written by the deceased. PW3 deposed
that he produced them before the police. However, PW10, the
I.O and the witnesses to the seizure, PW6 and PW8 spoke of
the same having been produced by the father. The trial court
specifically noticed that there was no date seen from the
letters. PW3 stated before court that the letters were received
by post and the postal covers were handed over to the I.O. The
I.O denied it and more importantly took no steps to ascertain
whether the handwriting is of the deceased. The contents of
the letter, extracted in vernacular and English in the impugned
orders again are vague and no clear case of harassment or
torture comes out, though there is an indication of discord
Page 6 of 8
Crl. A. @ SLP(Crl.) 21118/2025

between the two families. Abiding dismay at the conduct of
both the families, comes out; but not the reason behind it, even
if the letters are believed. In the totality of the circumstances,
especially the proof of the handwriting having not been
established as of the deceased, no reliance can be placed on
the alleged letters.
11. We are conscious of the fact that to attract Section 498-A,
there need not be a demand of dowry, since any unlawful
demand made by the husband or his family is covered under
Explanation (b). Explanation (a) of Section 498-A also brings in
any mindless action, willful in nature, driving the wife to
commit suicide under ‘cruelty’. But the evidence led by way of
oral testimony, here, does not put forth any unlawful demand
or such mindless acts of physical or mental torture as rightly
found by the High Court. Why then the conviction, is the
vexing question.
12. The evidence led, both the oral testimony and the
documents, fall short of establishment of the crime under
Section 498-A which compels us to acquit the appellant herein.
The appeal stands allowed reversing the impugned judgments
Page 7 of 8
Crl. A. @ SLP(Crl.) 21118/2025

of both the trial court and the High Court and acquitting the
appellant/accused. The accused shall be released forthwith if
not released on orders passed by us on the last date of
hearing, subject to his continued incarceration not being
required in any other case.
13. The appeal is allowed with the above directions.
14. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.






……….……………………. J.
(SANJAY KUMAR)





………….…………………. J.
(K. VINOD CHANDRAN)

NEW DELHI;
MAY 26, 2026.
Page 8 of 8
Crl. A. @ SLP(Crl.) 21118/2025