SRI PHILIP JACOB vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026






IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026


BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V SRISHANANDA

CRIMINAL PETITION No.14238 OF 2026
(482(Cr.PC)/528(BNSS)
BETWEEN:


SRI PHILIP JACOB
S/O THOMAS JACOB,
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS,
THEN PROPRIETOR OF M/S AMALAGIRIS,
ND
HAVING OFFICE AT 2 FLOOR,
ALFRAN PLAZA, M G ROAD,
PANJIM, GOA -403 001.

RESIDING AT AUXILIUM,
PALA P.O. LALAM,
KOTTAYAM,
KERALA -686 575
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. MURTHY D. NAIK, SENIOR ADVOCATE FOR SRI
JAYSHAM JAYASIMHA RAO, ADVOCATE)











Digitally signed
by R
MANJUNATHA
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA

AND:

THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
SIT, KARNATAKA LOKAYUKTA,
BENGALURU, REP. BY SPL. P.P.,
HIGH COURT BUILDING, AMBEDKAR VEEDI,
BENGALURU -560001.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI B.S.PRASAD, ADVOCATE)

THIS CRIMINAL PETITION IS FILED UNDER SECTION 482
CR.PC (FILED U/S 528 BNSS) PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


ORDER DATED 29.03.2025 PASSED BY THE XXIII ADDL. CITY
CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE AND SPECIAL JUDGE,
LOKAYUKTA AT BENGALURU (CCH-24) IN SPL.C.C.No.
598/2015, AT ANNEXURE-A, IN SO FAR AS THIS PETITIONER
IS CONCERNED.
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V SRISHANANDA

ORAL ORDER
Heard Sri Murthy D. Naik., learned Senior Counsel
appearing on behalf of Sri Jaysham Jayasimha Rao, learned
counsel for the petitioner.

2. Petition under Section 528 of Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 with the following prayer:
“Wherefore, the petitioner above named most
respectfully prays that this Hon’ble court be
pleased to:
(a) Set aside the order dated 29.03.2025
passed by the XXIII Additional City Civil and
Sessions Judge and Special Judge, Lokayukta at
Bengaluru (CCH-24) in Spl.C.C.No.598/2015 at
Annexure-A, insofar as this petitioner is
concerned; and,

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026



(b) Pass any such orders, directions etc., as this
Honourable Court deems fit, in the interest of
justice.”

3. Facts which are utmost necessary for disposal of
the present petition are as under:

3.1. Petitioner herein was ordered to be made as an
accused by order dated 29.03.2025 in a case registered by the
Lokayuktha against the original accused persons -
G.B.Shivakumar and G.S. Gopalakrishna, which was being
proceeded in Special C.C.No.598/2015.

4. After taking cognizance and the matter was being
adjudicated, learned Special Judge examined few witnesses
including the petitioner. Petitioner was examined as PW13.
Later on 30.08.2024 learned trial Judge noted that accused and
prosecution should assist the Court for modification/alteration
or framing of additional charges and listed the matter to
13.09.2024.

5. At that stage, the matter was adjourned from time
to time. By an order dated 29.03.2025, the learned Judge who
heard the parties perhaps on the question of alteration of
charge, without there being any application filed under Section

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


216 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, ordered for further
investigation. Said order under challenge is marked as
Annexure-A to the present petition. The relevant portion of the
order is in paragraph No.7 wherein direction was issued to
conduct further investigation, which is extracted hereunder for
ready reference.
“7. With the above observations, office is directed to
forward the true copy of this order to the Additional
Director General of Police, the SIT of Karnataka
Lokayukta, Bengaluru, to cause the further investigation
into the matter without giving scope for any lapses and
ensure the submission of additional final report to the
Court on or before 60 days from today.”

6. By virtue of the said order, Investigation Officer has
further investigated the matter and filed additional charge
sheet.

7. In furtherance to the directions issued by the
learned Trial Judge, a notice dated 18.09.2025 came to be
issued to the present petitioner under Section 91 and Section
160 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The same is marked at
an Anneuxre-J. Contents of the notice is extracted hereunder
for ready reference.

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026



“The special Investigation Team, Karnataka Lokayukta,
Bangalore, has completed the investigation in
Cr.No.05/2015 and charge sheet has already been
submitted to the Hon’ble Court, which is under trial in
the court in Special C.C.No.534/2016. Further, the
Hon’ble Court has ordered a re-investigation and report
on the omission of the accused in the charge sheet by
the Hon’ble Court on 11.09.2025.
Therefore, the investigation of Cr.No.05/2015 has
been continued as per the order of the Hon’ble Court.
Therefore, you are hereby requested to produce the
documents pertaining to M/s Canara Overseas Limited,
M/s Tharak Minerals, M/s Frost International Pvt. Ltd.,
M/s Priyanka Agencies and M/S Suhana Minerals. The
Special Investigation Team, Karnataka Lokayukta,
Veterinary College Premises, Hebbal, Bangalore-560
024 has directed the undersigned Investigating Officer
to appear in person on 03.10.2025 at 2.00 pm with the
documents related to the purchase and sale of iron ore
with Frost International Private Limited.”

8. Petitioner said to have co-operated with the
Investigation Officer. Later on, a reminder letter-2 came to be
issued against the wife of the petitioner on 14.07.2026 who is

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


also a partner (sleeping partner) along with the present
petitioner.

9. It is at that stage, the petitioner has approached
this Court with the aforesaid prayer on following grounds.

The impugned order at Annexure-A is illegal, arbitrary,
Perverse and perfunctory and therefore deserves to be set
aside.

The Learned Special Court has passed the impugned order
solely on its hypothesis that there is involvement of other
Accused in the commission of the alleged offences and not
on the basis of any materials on record. An order directing
investigation/further investigation cannot be based on a
hypothesis.

The proposition of law that further investigation can be
ordered by a Trial Court only until commencement of trial
and not thereafter is well settled through the judgement of
the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Vinubhai Haribhai
Malavia and Ors. v. State of Gujarat and Anr.
reported in (2019)17 SCC 1. There relevant paragraphs
of the said judgment are reproduced hereunder for ready
reference:
"42. There is no good reason given by the Court in
these decisions as to why a Magistrate's powers to
order further investigation would suddenly cease
upon process being issued, and an accused
appearing before the Magistrate, while

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


concomitantly, the power of the police to further
investigate the offence continues right till the
stage the trial commences...."

This Hon'ble Court in identical circumstances in the case of
Arun Nagareddy V. State of Karnataka
[Crl.P.No.104402/2025] reported in NC:2026:KHC-D:5290
relying upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in
Vinubhai (supra) has held that after commencement of
trial, the only recourse for the Trial Court would be to
exercise powers under Section 319 CrPC, if necessary and
cannot order further investigation. This Hon'ble Court has
further held that it would be improper to force the
investigating officer to give a finding contrary to his earlier
finding i.e. by implicating persons as accused who were
earlier dropped.

In the case at hand, when the Learned Special Court
passed the impugned order at Annexure- A, the trial had
reached an advances stage and as many as 15 witnesses
had already been examined. Thus, at such belated stage,
the Learned Special Court could not have ordered further
investigation. Therefore, the impugned order at Annexure -
A deserves to be quashed.

The Special Court erred in directing the Respondent to
further investigate and submit the additional report to the
court within two months, as this is against the principles of
the well- settled law that the court has no jurisdiction to
direct the police to file additional final report.

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026



It is an established principle of law that, it is in the
absolute realm of the investigating agency to either file a
charge- sheet or a B-report. Direction to file of a report of a
particular kind cannot be passed by a court.


The Special Court erred in directing the Respondent to file
an additional final report while deciding the necessity to
frame additional charge and alteration of charge. Hence,
the order dated 29.03.2025 passed by the Special Judge at
Annexure-A is liable to be quashed.


The Special Judge failed to appreciate the fact that the
investigating agency had dropped the Petitioner from the
array of accused and had arraigned him as CW-18. Further
the Special court had accepted the said report by taking
cognizance of the same. The impugned order has virtually
recalled / reviewed the earlier order accepting the final
report.

The Special Judge completely lost sight of the fact that the
charge-sheet / final report filed under 190 (1) (b) of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, filed by the Respondent
stating that prima-facie no case was made out against the
Petitioner was accepted and the Special Court had
exercised its jurisdiction and considered whether on the
materials placed along with the final report, a prima-facie
case was made out to take cognizance. Having exercised
its jurisdiction, the Special Court could not have passed the
impugned order at Annexure-A without careful scrutiny and
proper exercise of judicial mind.

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026



The Special Court failed to appreciate the fact that the final
report was accepted in the presence of the investigating
officer after hearing him. Hence, the various observations
made at Annexure-A are all unwarranted and baseless.


The Special Court indulged in judicial over-activism in as
much it is well-settled principles of law that the court while
considering the question of cognizance, has right to
disagree with the opinion of the investigating officer and
either reject the same or order further investigation or
agree with the report of the investigating officer. In this
case, the Special Court not having done so, cannot
undertake exercise of reviewing / recalling its own order of
accepting the final report of the investigating officer by
making unfounded observations against the investigating
officer and the accused.

The notice issued by the Respondent based on the order at
Annexure-A passed by the Special Court is also without
jurisdiction. The notice at Annexure - H clearly states that
the Respondent Police are reinvestigating into the matter
pursuant to the order at Annexure - A, which is absolutely
illegal.

It is trite law that, reinvestigation can only be ordered by
constitutional courts such as this Hon'ble Court and the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in exercise of inherent powers. The
Special Court lacks such powers and thus cannot trigger a
reinvestigation.

The reinvestigation being done by the Respondent Police
jeopardizes the rights and liberties of the Petitioner since

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


pushes him to suffer the ordeal of an investigation yet
again, moreso an illegal investigation.

The Special Court has completely lost sight of the well-
settled law regarding the cognizance, as laid down by the
Honourable Supreme Court in the case of Abhinandan Jha
V. Dinesh Mishra, reported in 1967 SCC OnLine SC
107. For ready reference, paragraph Nos.15, 16, 17, 18,
19 and 20, of the said judgment is re-produced herein
below:-
"15. Then the question is, what is the position,
when the Magistrate is dealing with a report
submitted by the police, under Section 173, that
no case is made out for sending up an accused for
trial, which report, as we have already indicated,
is called, in the area in question, as a `final
report'? Even in those cases, if the Magistrate
agrees with the said report, he may accept the
final report and close the proceedings. But there
may be instances when the Magistrate may take
the view, on a consideration of the final report,
that the opinion formed by the police is not based
on a full and complete investigation, in which
case, in our opinion, the Magistrate will have
ample jurisdiction to give directions to the police,
under Section 156(3), to make a further
investigation. That is, if the Magistrate feels, after
considering the final report, that t he investigation
is unsatisfactory, or incomplete, or that there is
scope for further investigation, it will be open to

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


the Magistrate to decline to accept the final report
and direct the police make further to investigation,
under Section 156(3). The police, after such
further investigation, may submit a charge-sheet,
or, again submit a final report, depending upon
the further investigation made by them. If
ultimately, the Magistrate forms the opinion that
the facts, set out in the final report, constitute an
offence, he can take cognizance of the offence,
under Section 190(1)(b) notwithstanding the
contrary opinion of the police, expressed in the
final report.

In this connection, the provisions of Section 169 of the
Code, are relevant. They specifically provide that even
though, on investigation, a police officer, or other
investigating officer, is of the opinion that there is no case
for proceeding against the accused, he is bound, while
releasing the accused, to take a bond from him to appear,
if and when required, before a Magistrate. This provision is
obviously to meet a contingency of the Magistrate, when he
considers the report of the investigating officer, and
judicially takes a view different from the police.

We have to approach the question, arising for consideration
in this case, in the light of the circumstances pointed out
above. We have already referred to the scheme of Chapter
XIV, as well as the observations of this Court in Rishbud
and Inder Singh case [(1955) 1 SCR 1150] that the
formation of the opinion as to whether or not there is a
case to place the accused on trial before a Magistrate, is

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


left to the officer in- charge of the police station. There is
no express power, so far as we can see, which gives
jurisdiction to pass an order of the nature under attack nor
can any such powers be implied. There is certainly no
obligation, on the Magistrate, to accept the report, if he
does not agree with the opinion formed by the police.
Under those circumstances, if he still suspects that an
offence has been committed, he is entitled,
notwithstanding the opinion of the police, to take
cognizance, under Section 190(1)(c) of the Code. That
provision, in our opinion, is obviously intended to secure
that offences may not go unpunished and justice may be
invoked even where persons individually aggrieved are
unwilling or unable to prosecute, or the police, either
wantonly or through bona fide error, fail to submit a report,
setting out the facts constituting the offence. Therefore, a
very wide power is conferred on the Magistrate to take
cognizance of an offence, not only when he receives
information about the commission of an offence from a
third person, but also where he has knowledge or even
suspicion that the offence has been committed. It is open
to the Magistrate to take cognizance of the offence, under
Section 190(1)(c), on the ground that, after having due
regard to the final report and the police records placed
before him, he has reason to suspect that an offence has
been committed Therefore, these circumstances will also
clearly negative the power of a Magistrate to call for a
charge-sheet from the police, when they have submitted a
final report. The entire scheme of Chapter XIV clearly
indicates that the formation of the opinion, as to whether

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


or not there is a case to place the accused for trial, is that
of the officer in-charge of the police station and that
opinion determines whether the report is to be under
Section 170, being a 'charge-sheet', or under Section 169,
'a final report. It is no doubt open to the Magistrate, as we
have already pointed out, to accept or disagree with the
opinion of the police and, if he disagrees, he is entitled to
adopt any one of the courses indicated by us. But he
cannot direct the police to submit a charge-sheet, because,
the submission of the report depends upon the opinion
formed by the police, and not on the opinion of the
Magistrate. The Magistrate cannot compel the police to
form a particular opinion, on the investigation, and to
submit a report, according to such opinion. That will be
really encroaching on the sphere of the police and
compelling the police to form an opinion so as to accord
with the decision of the Magistrate and send a report either
under Section 169, or under Section 170, depending upon
the nature of the decision. Such a function has been left to
the police under the Code.

We have already pointed out that the investigation, under
the Code, takes in several aspects, and stages, ending
ultimately with the formation of an opinion by the police as
to whether, on the material covered and collected, a case is
made out to place the accused before the Magistrate for
trial, and the submission of either a charge-sheet, or a final
report is dependent on the nature of the opinion, so
formed. The formation of the said opinion, by the police, as
pointed out earlier, is the final step in the investigation,

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


and that final step is to be taken only by the police and by
no other authority.

The question can also be considered from another point of
view. Supposing the police send a report viz. a charge-
sheet, under Section 170 of the Code. As we have already
pointed out, the Magistrate is not bound to accept that
report, when he considers the matter judicially. But can he
differ from the police and call upon them to submit a final
report, under Section 169? In our opinion, the Magistrate
has no such power. If he has no such power, in law, it also
follows that the Magistrate has no power to direct the
police to submit a charge- sheet, when the police have
submitted a final report that no case is made out for
sending the accused for trial. The functions of the
Magistracy and the police, are entirely different, and
though, in the circumstances mentioned earlier, the
Magistrate may or may not accept the report, and take
suitable action, according to law, he cannot certainly
infringe upon the jurisdiction of the police, by compelling
them to change their opinion, so as to accord with his view.

Therefore, to conclude, there is no power, expressly or
impliedly conferred, under the Code, on a Magistrate to call
upon the police to submit a charge-sheet, when they have
sent a report under Section 169 of the Code, that there is
no case made out for sending up an accused for trial."

The said judgment of the Honourable Supreme Court,
reported in the case of Abhinandan Jha Vs. Dinesh
Mishra, reported in 1967 SCC OnLine SC 107 has been
followed in the case of Minu Kumari and another Vs.

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


State of Bihar and others, reported in (2006) 4 SCC
359 . For ready reference, paragraph No.10 of Minu
case, is extracted herein below:-
Kumari's
" . In Abhinandan Jha v. Dinesh Mishra
10
[(1967) 3 SCR 668 : AIR 1968 SC 117 : 1968 Cri
LJ 97] this Court while considering the provisions
of Sections 156(3), 169, 178 and 190 of the Code
held that there is no power, expressly or impliedly
conferred, under the Code, on a Magistrate to call
upon the police to submit a charge-sheet. when
they have sent a report under Section 169 of the
Code that there is no case made out for sending
up an accused for trial. The functions of the
Magistrate and the police are entirely different,
and the Magistrate cannot impinge upon the
jurisdiction of the police, by compelling them to
change their opinion so as to accord with his view.
However, he is not deprived of the power to
proceed with the matter. There is no obligation on
the Magistrate to accept the report if he does not
agree with the opinion formed by the police. The
power to take cognizance notwithstanding
formation of the opinion by the police which is the
final stage in the investigation has been provided
for in Section 190(1)(c)."

The above being the position of law, the impugned order
vide Annexure-A, passed by the Special Court is bad in law
and palpably erroneous and is passed without application of
mind and hence the same is liable to be quashed and

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


consequentially the notice issued by the respondent at
Annexure-H is liable to be quashed.”

The present case is a classic case, where liberty of the
petitioner is being unnecessarily curtailed, as a result of the
impugned order at Annexure-A and consequent notice by
the Respondent-SIT at Annexure-H. Hence, the same
needs to be interjected by this Honourable Court by
exercising under Section- 482 of Cr.PC., (Now Section 528
of BNSS, 2023), as the petitioner is left with no other
alternative and efficacious remedy to protect his
fundamental right under Article-21 of the Constitution of
India.”

10. Sri Murthy D. Naik, learned Senior Advocate
reiterating the grounds urged in the petition, would contend
that ordering for further investigation by the learned Trial
Judge is without jurisdiction, especially after having taken
cognizance and commenced the trial.

11. He would further contend that such a course
adopted by the learned Trial Judge depicts the prejudicial mind
of the Court with regard to the role said to have been played by
the present petitioner.

12. He also points out that the learned Trial Judge has
passed the order based on assumptions and presumptions
inasmuch as in the impugned order, the learned Trial Judge has

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


observed that, for transportation of huge quantity of iron ore
there would be coordination from different Government
departments and involvement of private persons.

13. Therefore ordered for further investigation which is
beyond the scope of trial, especially when the learned Trial
Judge has heard the arguments of the parties suo motu on the
question of modification/alteration of charge.

14. Sri Naik would further contend that, at any rate,
while hearing the arguments on the alteration of charge
perhaps while exercising the power under Section 216 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, could not have ventured to pass
the impugned order directing further investigation. Therefore
sought for quashing of the impugned order.

15. Per contra, Sri B.S.Prasad, learned counsel
appearing for Lokayuktha while supporting the impugned order,
would contend that pursuant to the order passed by the learned
Trial Judge, further investigation has been conducted and
charge sheet is also filed. Therefore, challenge has rendered
infructuous.

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026



16. He would further contend that the petitioner can
very well appear before the learned Trial Judge and seek such
remedy that is available to him under the provisions of Code of
Criminal Procedure. Therefore, present petition needs to be
dismissed.

17. Sri Prasad would also contend that directions issued
by the Trial Court is to be obeyed by the Investigation Agency.
Therefore no fault can be attributed to the Investigation Agency
and thus sought for dismissal of the petition.

18. In reply, Sri Murthy D. Naik would contend that if
the order of the learned Trial Judge is held to be incorrect or
beyond the jurisdiction, such an order is to be treated as illegal
and any further proceedings that has taken place is to be
construed as an action which is not supported in the scheme of
Code of Criminal Procedure. Therefore, it has no validity at all
and thus the petition prayer has not rendered infructuous and
sought for passing suitable orders.

19. Having heard the arguments of both sides this
Court perused the material on record meticulously.

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026



20. On such perusal of the material on record, it is just
and necessary for this Court to cull out Section 216 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure which reads as under:
“ 216. Court may alter charge.- (1) Any Court may alter
or add to any charge at any time before judgment is
pronounced.
(2) Every such alteration or addition shall be read and
explained to the accused.
(3) If the alteration or addition to a charge is such that
proceeding immediately with the trial is not likely, in the
opinion of the Court to prejudice the accused in his
defence or the prosecutor in the conduct of the case the
Court may, in its discretion, after such alteration or
addition has been made, proceed with the trial as if the
altered or added charge had been the original charge.
(4) If the alteration or addition is such that proceeding
immediately with the trial is likely, in the opinion of the
Court to prejudice the accused or the prosecutor as
aforesaid, the Court may either direct a new trial or
adjourn the trial for such period as may be necessary.
(5) If the offence stated in the altered or added charge
is one for the prosecution of which previous sanction is
necessary, the case shall not be proceeded with until
such sanction is obtained, unless sanction had been

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


already obtained for a prosecution on the same facts as
those on which the altered or added charge is founded.”

21. On careful reading of the above provision, there can
be alteration of the charge by the Court even after
commencement of the trial, for that matter at any stage of the
trial. Such power of the Trial Court cannot be doubted.

22. But, at any stretch of imagination, such power
cannot be used for ordering of further investigation.

23. Under the scheme of Code of Criminal Procedure,
power to further investigate an incident or a crime ordinarily
and inherently rests with the Investigation Agency under
Section 173(8) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

24. However, it is a recent practice that the
Investigation Officers would approach the Court which has
taken the cognizance about the charge sheet already filed in a
given case and seek permission to further investigate the
matter.

25. Perhaps, it is by way of abundant caution and
insulated with a Court order.

26. As such, whether a Trial Court which has already
taken cognizance and commenced the trial can order for further

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


investigation is the moot question to be decided in the case on
hand.

27. In order to appreciate the same, it is just necessary
for this Court to cull out Section 173(8) of the Code of Criminal
Procedure which reads as under.
“ 173.Report of police officer on completion of
investigation-
(1) xxx xxx xxx
(2) xxx xxx xxx
(3) xxx xxx xxx
(4) xxx xxx xxx
(5) xxx xxx xxx
(6) xxx xxx xxx
(7) xxx xxx xxx
(8) Nothing in this section shall be deemed to
preclude further investigation in respect of an offence
after a report under sub-section (2) has been forwarded
to the Magistrate and, where upon such investigation,
the officer in charge of the police station obtains further
evidence, oral or documentary, he shall forward to the
Magistrate a further report or reports regarding such
evidence in the form prescribed; and the provisions of
sub-sections (2) to (6) shall, as far as may be, apply in
relation to such report or reports as they apply in
relation to a report forwarded under sub-section (2).”

28. On careful reading of the above provision, it is to be
noted that Investigation Agency with new/fresh facts/evidence,

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026


either oral or documentary, may apply for further investigation
based on such fresh evidence.

29. The Court, in such circumstances, will have to
consider the fresh evidence which may have some bearing on
the pending trial for fresh investigation.

30. It is settled principles of law and requires no
emphasis that for re-investigation or fresh investigation, power
is not vested with the Trial Court. Such a power has been
vested with the higher Courts viz., High Court or the Supreme
Court guidedly.

31. If a given set of circumstances do warrant re-
investigation or fresh investigation, higher Courts are not
precluded from ordering re-investigation or fresh investigation
to unearth the truth in the incident.

32. However, ordering re-investigation or fresh
investigation is thus outside the scope of Section 173(8) of the
Code of Criminal Procedure. Therefore, further investigation
can always be related only to the power vested in the Court
under Section 173(8) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026



33. In the case on hand, with the above legal
requirements in the back ground, what was being considered
by the Trial Court was to alter/modify the charge.

34. Such power is only under Section 216 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure as referred to supra.

35. Without there being any order on alteration
modification of the charge or framing fresh charge against the
existing charge sheeted accused persons, if the Trial Court is of
the opinion that further investigation is to be conducted having
regard to the magnitude of the fraud involved in the matter,
the same is definitely outside the scope of the learned Trial
Judge. More so, when cognizance has been taken and trial had
been commenced.

36. In the case on hand, petitioner has already been
examined as a witness on behalf of the prosecution as PW-13.
Whims and fancies of the learned Trial Judge cannot be the
basis for ordering for further investigation.

37. Therefore, the order impugned in the case on hand
necessarily needs to be set aside.

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026



38. As a consequence thereof, further investigation and
charge sheet filed by the Investigation Agency needs to be
quashed by exercising the power vested in this Court under
Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

39. Having said thus, it is the apprehension of the
counsel for Lokayuktha that this Order will have bearing/impact
on other matters as well.

40. Such an apprehension cannot be countenanced in
law inasmuch as, at the cost of a judicial order without any
reason or rhyme or an order without jurisdiction or
competence, cannot be allowed to be sustained only on the
ground that the order quashing such orders will have impact on
the other matters.

41. At the same time, if the prosecution agency is of
the opinion that there are fresh facts or fresh evidence
available which would point out guilt towards a particular
person who is not named as an accused in a given criminal
trial, necessary steps are to be taken by the prosecution in that
regard in accordance with law.

- 25 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62791
CRL.P No. 14238 of 2026


CNR: KAHC010643712026



42. Such an observation by this Court would quell all
apprehensions of the prosecution as well.

43. Accordingly, from the above discussion, the
following:
ORDER

i. Petition allowed .

ii. Consequently, impugned order dated
29.03.2025 passed in Spl.C.C. No.598/2015 on
the file of the XXIII Additional City Civil and
Sessions Judge and special Judge, Lokayukta
at Bengaluru, (CCH-24) is hereby quashed .

iii. Further consequence thereof, the charge sheet
filed against the present petitioner pursuant to
the impugned order is also quashed .

iv. Pending applications, if any, stand consigned to
record.
Sd/-
(V SRISHANANDA)
JUDGE
MR paragraphs 1 to 4
kcm paragraphs 5 till end.
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 92
CT:VRR