MR. XAVIER NORONHA vs MRS. ALICE NORONHA

Court
Karnataka High Court

- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023


IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU


TH
DATED THIS THE 13 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

PRESENT

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH

AND

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 3124/2023 (IDA)

BETWEEN:

MR. XAVIER NORONHA
S/O LATE BAPTIST NORONHA,
AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS,
R/O SHON VILLA, PADIVANANGADY BONDEL,
MANGALURU 575 008.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. MARIO NOEL D ROZARIO., ADVOCATE)

AND:

MRS. ALICE NORONHA
W/O MR XAVIER PETER NORONHA
AGED 65 YEARS,
R/O SHON VILLA,
PADIVANANGADY BONDEL,
MANGALURU 575 008.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. SANATHKUMAR SHETTY K.,ADVOCATE)

THIS MFA FILED UNDER SECTION 55 OF INDIAN
DIVORCE ACT, AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE
DT.17.12.2022 PASSED IN MC NO.77/2021 ON THE FILE OF
THE COURT OF PRINCIPAL JUDGE, FAMILY COURT, D.K,
MANGALURU, PARTLY ALLOWING THE PETITION FILED UNDER
SECTION 10(1)(ix)(x), SEC.36 OF THE INDIAN DIVORCE ACT,
1869 AND SEC.22 OF THE PROTECTION OF WOMEN FROM
DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ACT, 2005, APPELLANT PRAYS TO SET
ASIDE THE SAME.










Digitally signed
by B VEENA
KUMARI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN

ORAL JUDGMENT

(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)

The present appeal has been filed under Section 55
of the Indian Divorce Act, 1869 impugning the judgment
and decree dated 17.12.2022 passed in M.C.No.77/2021
by Principal Judge, Family Court, D.K. Mangaluru ( 'Family
Court' ).

3. For the sake of convenience, the parties are
referred to by their respective rankings before the learned
Family Court.

I. Facts of the petitioner:
3. The petitioner and the respondent are husband
and wife. Their marriage was solemnised on 04.12.1980 at
St. Sebastian Church, Bendoor, Mangaluru, in accordance
with Christian customs and rites. They have two children,

- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

a daughter, Priya Sharmila, born on 24.04.1982, and a
son, Shawn Pritesh, born on 30.11.1992. The petitioner
was working as a teacher at Kengeri, Bengaluru, at the
time of marriage. According to her, from the very
inception of the matrimonial relationship, the respondent
subjected her to humiliation and harassment by making
derogatory remarks about her appearance and repeatedly
insulting her.

4. Petitioner alleged that respondent was an
alcoholic, demanded money from her, and subjected her
and the children to physical and mental cruelty whenever
he returned from abroad. She further stated that she had
to discontinue her employment at Kengeri and
subsequently worked at Mumbai, Kuwait and various
schools at Mangaluru, ultimately retiring in 2016.

5. The petitioner's allegations were not confined to
ordinary matrimonial disagreements. She specifically
alleged that the respondent, during his stay with the

- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

family at her parental house in 1984, subjected their
daughter to physical ill-treatment by making her walk
barefoot on thorns, placing red ants on her body and
pouring hot wax upon her. She further alleged that he had
maintained an illicit relationship with one Philomena
Mascarenhas, stolen her gold ornaments and, in the year
2010, mixed Harpic toilet cleaner in the dosa batter
prepared by her.

6. She also referred to an incident when the
respondent allegedly disconnected the electricity supply
when their daughter and her family were staying in the
house, and another incident in which he pressed a bamboo
stick against the neck of their son, causing a bleeding
injury.

7. According to her, the respondent returned to
India permanently after his retirement in February 2019
and started asserting rights over the house property at
Kavoor, which she claimed to have acquired from her own

- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

earnings. She had already instituted O.S. No.40/2019
seeking an injunction in respect of the property.

8. On these allegations, petitioner instituted M.C.
No.77/2021 under Sections 10(1)(ix) and 10(1)(x) of the
Indian Divorce Act, 1869 ( 'Divorce Act' ), read with
Section 22 of the Protection of Women from Domestic
Violence Act, 2005 ( 'DV Act' ), seeking dissolution of
marriage, permanent alimony of Rs.50,00,000/- and
compensation of Rs.50,00,000/-.

II. Defence of the respondent:
9. The respondent admitted the marriage and the
birth of the two children, but denied the allegations of
cruelty, harassment and desertion. His specific case was
that the parties had lived a happy matrimonial life for
nearly forty years and that he had worked abroad, initially
in Iraq and thereafter in Saudi Arabia, to maintain the
family.

- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

10. He contended that he had regularly sent his
earnings to the petitioner and the children and had also
handed over blank signed cheques and his ATM card to
meet household expenses. According to him, the petitioner
had worked in various schools and had also gone to
Kuwait, where she earned money. He further stated that,
in 1991-92, both of them had purchased 20 cents of land
at Bondel and that he had contributed substantially
towards construction of the house, though the property
stood in the petitioner's name.

11. The respondent specifically denied having
subjected the petitioner or the children to any physical or
mental cruelty. He contended that the petitioner, at the
instigation of her sister and brother-in-law, had instituted
O.S. No.40/2019 to deprive him of his legitimate rights in
the house property. He stated that, because of the
strained relationship, he went to stay at the house of his
cousin Gilbert at Neermarga on 10.10.2019 and thereafter
started residing at his sister's house.

- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023


12. He further pleaded that, at the age of 72 years,
he had no independent shelter except the house property
at Bondel and that he genuinely desired to resume
matrimonial life with the petitioner. Accordingly, he
instituted M.C. No.69/2021 under Section 32 of the Indian
Divorce Act, 1869, seeking restitution of conjugal rights
and opposed the wife's petition for divorce.

III. Issues framed by the Family Court:
13. Since M.C. No.77/2021 filed by the wife and M.C.
No.69/2021 filed by the husband arose out of the same
matrimonial relationship and involved common questions,
the Family Court clubbed both proceedings and conducted
a common trial.

14. The Family Court framed the following issues:
1. Whether the petitioner/wife proves that
the respondent/husband has deserted her
for atleast two years immediately
preceding the presentation of the
petition?

2. Whether the petitioner/wife further
proves that the respondent/husband

- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

treated her with cruelty as to cause a
reasonable apprehension in her mind that
it would be harmful or injurious to reside
with him?

3. Whether the respondent/husband proves
that the petitioner/wife without
reasonable excuse has withdrawn from
his society?

4. Whether the petitioner/wife is entitled for
the permanent alimony?

5. Whether the petitioner/wife is entitled for
compensation?


6. What Order?


IV. Judgment of the Family Court:
15. By judgment dated 17.12.2022, the Family
Court, partly allowed M.C. No.77/2021. On appreciation of
the evidence of PW.1 and PW.2, the Court found that the
allegations of cruelty were supported by the testimony of
the daughter, who had personally spoken about the ill-
treatment meted out to her and her mother during the
respondent's visits from abroad. The Court particularly
noticed the incident relating to mixing of Harpic in the
dosa batter.

- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

16. During his cross-examination, RW.1, while
denying the allegation that he had mixed the said
substance, came forward with a new version that the
petitioner herself had mixed it. The Court found this
explanation difficult to accept, particularly because no
such defence had been taken in his objections. It held that
the circumstances and the probabilities supported the
wife's version. The Court also noticed the admission of
RW.1 regarding disconnection of electricity supply when
the daughter and her family were staying in the house.

17. Another circumstance which weighed with the
Family Court was the mobile message dated 01.01.2019,
marked as Ex.P8, sent by the respondent to the petitioner.
During cross-examination, RW.1 admitted that he had sent
the message. The contents of the message, containing
abusive expressions and a threat that the petitioner would
not see her son again, were considered along with the
other evidence.

- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

18. The Family Court held that the language
employed was not a mere expression of anger arising out
of an ordinary domestic disagreement, but reflected the
manner in which the petitioner was being treated. It
consequently concluded that the wife had established
cruelty and that there was reasonable apprehension in her
mind that it would be harmful or injurious to continue
living with the respondent.

19. However, the Family Court declined to accept the
ground of desertion, as the evidence did not conclusively
establish that the husband had deserted the wife for the
statutory period of two years immediately preceding the
petition. It also rejected the husband's petition in M.C.
No.69/2021 for restitution of conjugal rights, holding that
he had failed to establish that the wife had withdrawn
from his society without reasonable excuse. While refusing
permanent alimony of Rs.50,00,000/- under Section 36 of
the Indian Divorce Act, the Court took note of the age and
financial circumstances of both parties, the wife's

- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

retirement and savings of Rs.10,00,000/-, and the support
available to her from their children.

20. Nevertheless, considering the acts of domestic
violence established on record, it awarded Rs.5,00,000/-
as compensation under Section 22 of the Protection of
Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, and litigation
costs of Rs.20,000/- payable by the husband. Accordingly,
the marriage solemnised on 04.12.1980 was dissolved on
the ground of cruelty, while the claims for divorce on the
ground of desertion and permanent alimony were rejected.

21. Aggrieved by the judgment and decree dated
17.12.2022 passed in M.C. No.77/2021, the respondent-
husband, who is the appellant herein, has challenged the
same in the present appeal .

V. Grounds urged in the appeal:
22. It is contended that the Family Court failed to
properly appreciate the evidence and that the allegations
of cruelty were accepted without sufficient documentary

- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

proof, except the marriage certificate and the material
relied upon by the wife. The respondent further contends
that the Family Court erred in placing reliance upon the
testimony of PW.2, who is their daughter, without properly
appreciating her relationship with the respondent and the
strained circumstances between them. It is also urged that
the Court failed to consider his contribution towards the
purchase of the 20 cents of land at Bondel and
construction of the residential house, and that the dispute
concerning O.S. No.40/2019 had materially affected the
matrimonial relationship.

23. The respondent alleges that the finding
regarding the Harpic incident and the mobile message has
been recorded without proper appreciation of the
surrounding circumstances and his explanation in cross-
examination. He further contends that, having regard to
the advanced age of both parties, the Court ought to have
considered the possibility of their living together during
the remaining years of their lives, particularly when he had

- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

instituted M.C. No.69/2021 seeking restitution of conjugal
rights.

24. The award of Rs.5,00,000/- towards
compensation and Rs.20,000/- towards litigation expenses
is also questioned on the ground that he is a senior citizen
with limited financial means and no independent source of
income after retirement. On these grounds, the
respondent seeks setting aside of the judgment and
decree and dismissal of M.C. No.77/2021.

25. We have heard the learned counsel Sri. Mario
Noel D Rozario and learned counsel Sri. Sanathkumar
Shetty K., appearing for the parties.

26. Upon consideration of the pleadings, the
records placed before this Court and the submissions
advanced on behalf of the respondent and petitioner, the
following point arises for our consideration:
"Whether the respondent has made out any
ground warranting interference with the order
dated 17.12.2022 passed by the learned

- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

Principal Judge, Family Court, D.K. Mangaluru
in M.C. No.77/2021?"

VI. Reasons and Analysis:
27. We have carefully examined the pleadings, the
evidence of PW.1 and PW.2, the cross-examination of
RW.1 and the documents placed on record. The marriage
between the parties was solemnised on 04.12.1980 at St.
Sebastian Church, Bendoor, Mangaluru. They have two
children, a daughter born on 24.04.1982 and a son born
on 30.11.1992. The matrimonial relationship has to be
examined in the background of nearly four decades of
married life, during which the wife was required to bring
up the children, pursue her employment and manage the
family, while the husband was working abroad, initially in
Iraq and thereafter in Saudi Arabia.

28. The wife, in her petition in M.C. No.77/2021,
has narrated several specific incidents of ill-treatment.
These are not allegations confined to the ordinary wear
and tear of matrimonial life. She stated that, from the

- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

beginning of the marriage, the husband used to insult her
by referring to her complexion and physical appearance,
calling her short, dark and unfit for marriage, and even
telling her that she should work as a prostitute and earn
money. Such remarks, when repeatedly made by a
husband to his wife, cannot be brushed aside as casual
expressions arising out of domestic differences. They
affect the dignity of the person and the very foundation of
the matrimonial relationship.

29. What is more disturbing is the evidence
concerning the treatment meted out to the children. The
wife specifically narrated that, when the husband stayed
with the family at her parental house in 1984, he made
their young daughter walk barefoot on thorns, placed red
ants on her body and poured hot wax from a candle,
causing pain. PW.2, the daughter, entered the witness box
and supported her mother's version. She spoke about the
manner in which the respondent treated her and her
brother, including beating them with household articles

- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

and a belt, abusing them and subjecting them to
humiliation.

30. She also spoke about the husband's conduct
whenever he returned from abroad. During cross-
examination, though PW.1 and PW.2 were subjected to
questioning at length, nothing material was elicited to
discredit their evidence regarding these incidents. The
Family Court had the advantage of recording their
evidence and assessing their testimony. We find no reason
to take a different view, particularly when their evidence is
consistent on the material aspects.

31. The incident concerning mixing of Harpic toilet
cleaner in the dosa batter is of particular significance. The
wife alleged that, in the year 2010, the respondent had
mixed the said substance in the batter prepared by her
and, later, expressed disappointment that neither she nor
the children had died after consuming it. This allegation
was specifically put to RW.1 during his cross-examination.

- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

He denied having mixed Harpic in the batter, but
surprisingly came forward with a different explanation that
the wife herself had mixed the substance. This explanation
assumes importance because no such specific defence had
been taken in his statement of objections.

32. If, according to him, the wife had herself mixed
a dangerous chemical in the food prepared for the family,
one would reasonably expect him to have pleaded that
fact at the earliest opportunity. He did not do so. The
explanation emerged only during cross-examination. The
Family Court was therefore justified in drawing an adverse
inference from this changed version and in holding that
the probabilities supported the wife's case. We find no
infirmity in that appreciation. An allegation of this nature
cannot be treated lightly, particularly when it concerns the
safety of the wife and children within their own home.

33. There is yet another circumstance which lends
considerable support to the wife's case. She produced the

- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

photograph of the mobile phone message as Ex.P8, along
with the certificate under Section 65B of the Evidence Act
marked as Ex.P9. The message was sent by the
respondent on 01.01.2019. During his cross-examination,
RW.1 admitted that he had sent the said message to his
wife. The contents are as follows:
“U Bastard fucking woman I'll see that U will go
to hell perhaps U will never see your son
again.”

34. The respondent attempted to explain that he
had sent the message because he was waiting outside the
house, hungry, and the wife had not opened the door
despite his repeatedly pressing the calling bell. Even
accepting that there was some disagreement on that
occasion, the language employed in the message cannot
be justified.

35. A husband may become angry; matrimonial
differences do arise. But threatening his wife that she
would never see her son again, while using such abusive
and degrading expressions, is not an ordinary reaction to a

- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

domestic disagreement. The admission of RW.1 is clear.
The Family Court was right in considering the message not
as an isolated exchange of words, but along with the other
incidents spoken to by the wife and her daughter.

36. The evidence regarding disconnection of
electricity also deserves notice. The wife and PW.2 stated
that, when their daughter had delivered a child and was
staying in the matrimonial house, the respondent
deliberately disconnected the electricity supply, compelling
the family members to remain without electricity for two
days. During cross-examination, RW.1 admitted that there
was such a disconnection, though he denied his
involvement in it. He did not, however, furnish any
satisfactory explanation as to why the electricity supply
had been disconnected on that occasion.

37. Similarly, the wife spoke about the incident in
which the respondent allegedly pressed a bamboo stick
against the neck of their son, resulting in a bleeding

- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

injury, and thereafter attempted to attribute the injury to
the child himself. These incidents, when considered
separately, may invite explanations. But the Court is
required to consider the cumulative effect of the evidence.

38. The repeated insults to the wife, ill treatment of
the children, the incident involving Harpic, the admitted
mobile message and the electricity disconnection together
would disclose a course of conduct which cannot be
regarded as normal matrimonial and civilised behaviour.
The respondent's conduct, as established from the
material on record, created a reasonable apprehension in
the mind of the wife that continuing to reside with him
would be harmful and injurious to her.

39. The respondent, in his objections and evidence,
attempted to explain the matrimonial discord by
contending that the wife had acquired the house property
at Bondel in her own name despite his contribution
towards its purchase and construction. He also alleged

- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

that she had instituted O.S. No.40/2019, seeking an
injunction, at the instigation of her sister and brother-in-
law, in order to deprive him of his rights in the property.
He further contended that he had gone to reside at the
house of his cousin Gilbert at Neermarga on 10.10.2019
because the relationship had become strained.

40. It is true that the parties are also litigating over
the house property. But the pendency of O.S. No.40/2019
does not explain or erase the specific incidents of cruelty
established in the matrimonial proceedings. The
respondent subsequently instituted M.C. No.69/2021
under Section 32 of the Indian Divorce Act, seeking
restitution of conjugal rights. That petition was also
considered along with M.C. No.77/2021. The Family Court,
having regard to the evidence of the parties, held that the
respondent had failed to establish that the wife had
withdrawn from his society without reasonable excuse and
accordingly dismissed his petition. The matter was

- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

referred to the Mangaluru Mediation Centre, but the
mediation failed.

41. The desire expressed by the husband to resume
matrimonial life, by itself, cannot outweigh the evidence of
the maltreatment meted out to the wife and children. A
request for restitution must be considered in the light of
the conduct of the spouse making such a request.

42. On an overall consideration, we are of the
opinion that the Family Court has not proceeded on mere
assumptions or on the uncorroborated allegations of the
wife. It has examined the testimony of PW.1 and PW.2,
the admissions made by RW.1 in cross-examination, the
message at Ex.P8, the certificate at Ex.P9 and the other
documents produced by the parties.

43. The respondent's admission that he sent the
abusive message, his explanation regarding the Harpic
incident, and his admission regarding disconnection of
electricity were all taken into account. The Family Court

- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

has also made a distinction between the grounds of cruelty
and desertion. While it declined to grant divorce on the
ground of desertion for want of proof of the statutory
period, it found the ground of cruelty established.

44. The decree dissolving the marriage dated
04.12.1980 was therefore granted under Section 10(1)(x)
of the Divorce Act. The claim for permanent alimony under
Section 36 was rejected after considering the age, savings
and financial circumstances of both parties, whereas
compensation of Rs.5,00,000/- was awarded under
Section 22 of the DV Act, and litigation costs of
Rs.20,000/- were also granted.

45. The findings are supported by the evidence on
record. We do not find any perversity, misreading of
evidence or legal infirmity warranting interference with the
judgment and decree dated 17.12.2022 insofar as M.C.
No.77/2021 is concerned. The grounds urged by the
respondent-husband are rejected. Accordingly, the
following:

- 24 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:57761-DB
MFA No. 3124 of 2023


CNR: KAHC010223962023

ORDER
dismissed
1. The appeal is .


2. The judgment and decree dated 17.12.2022
passed by the Family Court in M.C.
No.77/2021, dissolving the marriage on the
ground of cruelty and awarding
compensation of Rs.5,00,000/- and
litigation costs of Rs.20,000/-, are hereby
affirmed
.

In view of dismissal of the appeal, pending
interlocutory application, I.A.No.1/2024 does not survive
for consideration, hence stands disposed of.



Sd/-
(D K SINGH)
JUDGE

Sd/-
(H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)
JUDGE
BVK
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 19