Nikhilesh vs Board Of Revenue And 37 Others
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
Reserved.
A. F. R.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
WRIT - B No. - 2994 of 2026
Nikhilesh
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
Board Of Revenue And 37 Others
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s) : Aishwarya Pratap Shahi, Sumit Suri
Counsel for Respondent(s) : C.S.C., Pradeep Singh, Prashant Kumar
Tripathi
Court No. - 50
HON'BLE ASHUTOSH SRIVASTAVA, J.
Heard Sri Nipun Singh, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Sri A.P.
1.
Shahi, learned counsel for the petitioner, learned Standing Counsel for the
State-respondents as also Sri R. C. Singh, learned Senior Counsel assisted
by Sri Prashant Kumar Tripathi, learned counsel for the respondent No. 3.
Sri Pradeep Singh, learned counsel has accepted notice of the writ petition
on behalf of respondent Nos. 33, 34, 35 and 36.
The writ petition has been filed questioning the legality, propriety and
2.
correctness of the order dated 17.6.2026 passed by the Board of Revenue,
UP, Lucknow in Revision No. 1927 of 2026 computerized No.
R20261667001927. A further writ in the nature of Mandamus
commanding the respondent No. 2 i.e. the Sub Divisional Magistrate,
Tehsil Gyanpur, District Bhadohi to decide the case being Case No.
T202316670407051 (Nikhilesh Vs State of UP and others) under Section
144 of the U.P. Revenue Code, 2006 (hereinafter referred to as the “Code,
2006”) within a time frame fixed by this Court has been prayed for.
The facts giving rise to the controversy involved in the writ
3.
WRIB No. 2994 of 2026
2
petition briefly stated shorn of any unnecessary details is that the
petitioner instituted a Suit under Section 144 of the Code, 2006 seeking
declaration of rights in respect of agricultural holdings detailed in the
plaint together with consequential reliefs on the strength of an oral family
settlement arrived at between the parties on 21.5.1985. The necessity of
institution of the suit arose after the contesting respondents denied the
family settlement and asserted hostile rights over the petitioner's share in
the joint family property which fell to the share of the petitioner and he
was in actual physical possession and beneficial enjoyment thereof. The
declaration sought in the suit also included declaration that the sale deeds
dated 16.2.2008 and 6.8.2010 were void and not binding on the
plaintiff/petitioner. Consequential correction of the revenue records and
other reliefs were prayed for in the suit under Section 144. The institution
of the suit was objected to by the respondent No. 3 by filing an
application principally founded on objections as to limitation,
maintainability of the suit, alleged absence of notices, valuation, cause of
action etc. The said application of the respondent No. 3 was opposed by
the petitioner. The Sub Divisional Magistrate vide order dated 20.3.2026
rejected the application of the respondent No. 3 holding that the plaint
disclosed triable issues and that the objections raised could not be
adjudicated without evidence. The order dated 20.3.2026 rejecting the
application objecting to the maintainability of the suit was interlocutory in
nature and no appeal lay against such an order. The respondent No. 3
however assailed the order dated 20.3.2026 in appeal under Section 207
of the Code, 2006 before the Commissioner, Vindhyachal Division,
Mirzapur even though a revision lay against such an order. The
Commissioner passed an order dismissing the appeal vide order dated
WRIB No. 2994 of 2026
3
12.5.2026 consequently upholding the order passed by the Sub Divisional
Magistrate dated 20.3.2026 at its threshold without issuing notices to the
respondents in the appeal including the petitioner. Aggrieved by the order
dated 12.5.2026 the respondent No 3 assailed the same in revision before
the Board of Revenue which revision has been allowed by the order dated
17.6.2026 impugned in the writ petition.
4. Sri Nipun Singh, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner
raises a legal submission as regards the maintainability of the appeal
before the Commissioner as also the revision before the Board of
Revenue inviting the attention of this Court to the provisions of Section
207 of the Code, 2006 under which provision the appeal had been
preferred by the contesting respondent No 3 to submit that Section 207
makes provision of first appeal against a final order or decree passed in
any suit, application or proceeding by any party aggrieved. Sri Nipun
Singh, learned Senior Counsel contends that the order dated 20.3.2026
passed by the Sub Divisional Magistrate cannot by any standards be
regarded as final order so as to fall within the scope of Section 207
inasmuch as the order merely rejects an application taking objection to the
maintainability of the suit under Section 144 of the Code, 2006. The order
neither adjudicated the rights of the parties nor finally disposed of the suit
and is in the nature of an interlocutory order against which no appeal lay.
It is contended that the order passed by the Sub Divisional Magistrate also
does not fall within the scope of Section 207 (2) of the Code, 2006 so as
to make the appeal maintainable. The Commissioner, dismissed the
appeal vide order dated 12.5.2026 on the ground of maintainability.
5. Sri Nipun Singh, learned Senior Counsel next contends that the
WRIB No. 2994 of 2026
4
proceedings before the Board of Revenue are ex-facie not maintainable
inasmuch as the Board of Revenue failed to consider the aspect that the
revision before it was not maintainable under Section 210 of the Code,
2006 inasmuch as a Second Appeal is provided against an order passed in
First Appeal under Section 207 of the Code, 2006 under Section 208. It is
submitted that the remedy against the appellate order passed by the
Commissioner, the statutory remedy available under the Code 2006 is the
remedy of Second Appeal under Section 208. It is accordingly submitted
that the Revision before the Board of Revenue was not maintainable.
6. Sri Nipun Singh learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner vehemently
contends that the order passed by the Board of Revenue dated 17.6.2026
is liable to be set aside on the following amongst other grounds.
i) The Board of Revenue failed to consider that the Appeal
preferred by the contesting respondent No. 3 was itself not
maintainable and omission by the Board of Revenue to take
note of the fact has vitiated the order passed by the Board of
Revenue.
ii) The order passed by the Board of Revenue is wholly without
jurisdiction being contrary to the statutory scheme of the Code,
2006 by entertaining the revision instead of the Second Appeal
provided under Section 208 of the Revenue Code, 2006.
iii) The Board of Revenue while passing the impugned order
failed to appreciate that the order dated 20.3.2026 passed by
the Sub Divisional Magistrate merely rejected the application
of the respondent No. 3 questioning the maintainability of the
WRIB No. 2994 of 2026
5
suit and directing that the trial should proceed on merits. The
order was not liable to be interfered with in exercise of
revisional jurisdiction by the Board of Revenue particularly
when the order was not assailable in statutory appeal before the
Commissioner and consequently, the revision emanating
therefrom was also not maintainable.
iv) The Board of Revenue while rendering the impugned order
completely ignored the fact that while considering an
application for rejection of the plaint or an application
regarding the maintainability, the averments contained in the
plaint alone are required to be taken as correct without
embarking upon an adjudication of the probable defence or
disputed questions of fact. The omission has vitiated the order
passed.
7. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner thus contends that the
impugned order passed by the Board of Revenue is liable to be quashed
and the writ petition deserves to be allowed as prayed.
8. Per-contra, Sri R.C. Singh, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Sri
Prashant Kumar Tripathi learned counsel for the respondent No. 3, has
tried to justify the order passed by the Board of Revenue and submits that
the order passed by the Board of Revenue is just and proper and does not
suffer from any infirmity warranting any interference by this Court.
9. Shri R. C. Singh, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the contesting
respondent No. 3, in rebuttal, to the submissions made by Shri Nipun
Singh, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner on the
WRIB No. 2994 of 2026
6
maintainability of the appeal before the Commissioner, Vidhyachal
Division, Mirzapur against the order of the Sub Divisional Magistrate
rejecting the application of the respondent No. 3 regarding maintainability
of the proceedings under Section 144 of the Code, 2006 submits that the
order rejecting the application was in the nature of final order and as such,
the appeal was very much maintainable.
10. Further on the question of maintainability of the revision before the
Board of Revenue, he has invited the attention of this Court to the memo
the revision, which has been brought on record as Annexure-8 to the writ
petition, to submit that the revision under Section 210 of the Code, 2006
was preferred against the order dated 20.3.2026 passed by the Sub
Divisional Magistrate, Tehsil Gyanpur, District Bhadohi in proceedings
under Section 144 of the Code, 2006 as well as the order dated 12.5.2026
passed by the Commissioner, Vindhyachal Division, Mirzapur in appeal
under Section 207 of the Code, 2006. He further submits that since the
revision was preferred against the order of the Sub Divisional Magistrate
dated 20.3.2026, the same was very much maintainable. He has invited
the attention of the Court to the provision of Section 210 of the Code,
2006 to submit that U.P. Revenue Code, 2006 empowers the Board of
Revenue as also the Commissioner to call for the records of any suit or
proceeding decided by any subordinate Revenue Court for the purpose of
any order passed in suit or proceedings or may pass such order in the
case, as it thinks fit.
11. On the question as to the assailability of the order passed by the
Commissioner in proceedings under Section 207 of the Code, 2006, he
concedes that the order passed by the Commissioner under the aforesaid
WRIB No. 2994 of 2026
7
section, the Second Appeal would lie to the Board of Revenue under
Section 208 of the Code, 2006. He otherwise justifies the order passed by
the Board of Revenue and submits that the writ petition does not warrant
any interference and deserves to be dismissed at the threshold.
12. I have heard learned counsel for the parties at some length and have
considered their respective submissions.
13. I find substance in the submissions of Shri Nipun Singh, learned
Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner on question that the order
passed by the Sub Divisional Magistrate dated 20.3.2026 whereby the
application on behalf of respondent No. 3 regarding maintainability of the
suit or proceedings under Section 144 of the Code, 2006 stood rejected,
cannot be regarded as a final order adjudicating the rights of the parties
inasmuch as, the suit or proceedings under Section 144 are yet to be
decided. In such circumstances, the order cannot be said to be assailable
in an appeal. The order passed by the Sub Divisional Magistrate dated
20.3.2026 is in fact in the nature of an order passed under Order 7 Rule 11
CPC wherein rejection of the plaint is sought. If the said application is
allowed, the order passed is assailable in appeal, otherwise, the order
rejecting the application is assailable in a revision. Thus, the submission
of Shri Nipun Singh that the appeal filed by the respondent No. 3 before
the Commissioner, Vindhyachal Division, Mirzapur cannot be said to be
maintainable has substance.
14. Now, coming to the question about the maintainability of the revision
before the Board of Revenue, the Court finds that the revision under
Section 210 of the Code, 2006 was preferred assailing the order of
the Sub Divisional Magistrate dated 20.3.2026 as well as the order passed
WRIB No. 2994 of 2026
8
by the Commissioner in appeal. As per the provisions of the Code, 2006,
an order passed by the Commissioner under Section 207 would be
assailable in a second appeal before the Board of Revenue under Section
208 of the Code, 2006 and no revision would be maintainable. However,
in the instant case, since the revision was filed assailing the order of
the Sub Divisional Magistrate, in the opinion of the Court, the revision
was maintainable under Section 210 of the Code, 2006.
15. Now, the Court proceeds to test the order passed by the Board of
Revenue dated 17.6.2026 passed exercising revisional jurisdiction
conferred to it under Section 210 of the Code, 2006.
16. Having gone through the impugned order passed by the Board of
Revenue, the Court finds that it failed to consider that the appeal preferred
by the revisionists before the Commissioner against the order of the Sub
Divisional Magistrate was itself not maintainable.
17. The Court further finds that the Board of Revenue has exercised its
jurisdiction not vested in it by law while upsetting concurrent order
passed by the Sub Divisional Magistrate and the Commissioner. In the
opinion of the Court, the Board of Revenue ought to have first examined
the maintainability of the appeal before the Commissioner and then
proceed to decide the revision. It is settled principles of law that
jurisdiction cannot be conferred by consent, waiver or acquiescence and,
therefore, the Board of Revenue before entering into the merits of the
controversy ought to have gone into the question as to whether the
appellate order sought to be revised in revision had been passed in
proceedings maintainable under the law.
WRIB No. 2994 of 2026
9
18. Perusal of the impugned order passed by the Board of Revenue
reveals that the Board of Revenue has travelled beyond the permissible
limits in exercise of revisional jurisdiction inasmuch as, it proceeded to
frame entirely new issues which neither formed the basis of
maintainability of application nor was adjudicated by the Authorities
below. In the opinion of the Court, the Board of Revenue while exercising
revisional jurisdiction could not have converted itself into a Court of first
instance. The Board of Revenue while exercising revisional jurisdiction
has ventured into the merits of the declaratory suit under the guise of
deciding a revision arising out of an order rejecting the application raising
issues regarding maintainability of the suit.
19. The Board of Revenue while exercising revisional powers could not
have usurped the jurisdiction available exclusively with the Trial Court.
The Board of Revenue appears to have entered into disputed questions
relating to the existence, validity and legal effect of the oral family
settlement and has virtually recorded findings on the evidentiary value
thereof even before the parties were put to trial and parties afforded
opportunities to lead evidence in respect of their respective claims. The
Board of Revenue under the impugned order has virtually dismissed the
declaratory suit without permitting the petitioner to establish his case
through evidence thereby depriving the petitioner of a valuable
substantive rights to have his claim adjudicated in accordance with law.
The impugned order thus suffers from manifest illegality and has resulted
in grave injustice to the petitioner.
20. In view of above and in the considered opinion of the Court, the
impugned order passed by the Board of Revenue dated 17.6.2026 in
WRIB No. 2994 of 2026
10
Revision No. 1927 of 2026 (Computerized Case No. R20261667001927)
cannot be sustained and is accordingly set aside.
21. The writ petition stands allowed .
22. The declaratory suit under Section 144 of the Code, 2006 pending
between the parties is directed to be concluded expeditiously preferably
within a period of six months from the date of service of certified copy of
the order of this Court, without granting any adjournment to either of the
parties, strictly, in accordance with law.
23. No order as to costs.
(Ashutosh Srivastava,J.)
November 16, 2026
Ravi Prakash
Digitally signed by :-
RAVI PRAKASH
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad