State Of Punjab vs Gurwinder Singh Alias Jicky
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CRM-A-1251-2019 -1-
220 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CRM-A-1251-2019 (O&M)
Date of Decision: 11.11.2026
State of Punjab ..... Applicant
Versus
Gurwinder Singh @ Jicky .......Respondent
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH BHARDWAJ
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ROHIT KAPOOR
Present: Mr. Ekompal Sagoo, AAG, Punjab.
Rajesh Bhardwaj, J.
CRM-20063-2019
Prayer in the present application is for condonation of delay of
65 days in filing the appeal.
For the reasons mentioned in the application, the application is
allowed. Delay of 65 days in filing the appeal is condoned.
Main case
1. The applicant-State has filed the application under Section
378(3) Cr.P.C. for grant of leave to file an appeal against the impugned
judgment dated 17.11.2018 passed by learned Judge, Special Court,
Amritsar acquitting the accused-respondent of the charges framed against
him.
Facts of the case
2. Succinctly facts of the case are that on 09.05.2015, the police
party, while patrolling, was present near Sappan Wala Shivala, on the road
running along the canal towards Kot Mit Singh, when they noticed a young
person approaching on foot. On seeing the police party, he got perplexed
and tried to turn back as well as to throw something wrapped in a polythene
SHARMILA
2026.11.17 10:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticiy of this document
CRM-A-1251-2019 -2-
envelop from the right pocket of the pant. On suspicion, he was
apprehended by the police party. On asking, he disclosed his name to be
Gurwinder Singh @ Jicky (respondent). The polythene envelop carried by
him was checked in accordance with the rules. Upon checking the polythene
bag, intoxicant powder weighing 200 grams was recovered. Out of the
recovered contraband, a sample of 5 grams was drawn and sent to the FSL
for chemical examination. He failed to produce any licence regarding the
conscious possession of the same. Thus, the FIR was registered and he was
arrested on the spot. Investigation commenced. On completion of the
investigation, challan was presented and on framing of charges, the trial
commenced. To prove its case, the prosecution examined four witnesses and
besides this, documentary evidences were also produced. Thereafter,
statement of the accused under Section 313 Cr.P.C. was recorded. On
conclusion of the trial, learned trial Court after appreciating all the
evidence, found that the prosecution had failed to prove its case against the
accused beyond reasonable doubt. Thus, acquitted the accused from the
charges framed against him vide impugned judgment dated 17.11.2018.
Hence, aggrieved by the same, the applicant-State has approached this Court
by way of filing the present application for grant of leave to file appeal.
Arguments raised on behalf of the applicant
3. It has been vehemently contended by learned State counsel that
learned trial Court has passed the impugned judgment on the basis of the
conjectures and surmises and wrongly acquitted the accused. He has
submitted that learned trial Court erred in acquitting the respondent despite
the prosecution having duly established the recovery of 200 grams of
SHARMILA
2026.11.17 10:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticiy of this document
CRM-A-1251-2019 -3-
intoxicating powder containing Alprazolam from his possession. He
contends that on due compliance of mandatory provisions of the NDPS Act,
the recovery was effected, however, learned trial Court has failed to
appreciate the same. He submits that the testimonies of the official
witnesses, particularly PW-1 ASI Satnam Singh and PW-3 HC Joginder
Singh, duly corroborate the prosecution version and there is no reason to
disbelieve their statements merely because no independent witness was
joined at the time of recovery. He further contends that the respondent had
attempted to throw away the polythene envelop on seeing the police party
and, therefore, the recovery cannot be treated as one effected pursuant to a
personal search so as to attract the mandatory provisions of Section 50 of
the NDPS Act. He submits that the findings recorded by the learned trial
Court are based on misappreciation of evidence and the impugned
judgment, therefore, deserves to be set aside. He has relied upon the
judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Varinder Kumar Vs. State of
Punjab , passed in Criminal Appeal No.2450-2451 of 2010 on 11.02.2019.
Findings and analysis
4. We have heard learned counsel for the State and carefully gone
through the record. The prosecution's own case is that the respondent, on
seeing the police party, attempted to take out the polythene envelop from
the right pocket of his trousers and throw it away. Thus, the alleged
recovery was directly connected with the search of the person of the
respondent. In such circumstances, the investigating officer was required to
comply with the mandatory provisions of Section 50 of the NDPS Act by
apprising the respondent of his legal right to be searched before a Gazetted
SHARMILA
2026.11.17 10:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticiy of this document
CRM-A-1251-2019 -4-
Officer or a Magistrate. Admittedly, no such offer was extended to him. The
mere assertion that the respondent had attempted to throw away the envelop
would not dispense with the statutory requirement, particularly when the
prosecution version itself indicates that the envelope was taken out from the
pocket of the respondent. Learned trial Court has, therefore, rightly held that
there was non-compliance with Section 50 of the NDPS Act. It is further
evident from the record that the alleged recovery was effected at a
thoroughfare where several persons were passing by. Despite the
availability of independent witnesses, none was joined in the recovery
proceedings. The explanation furnished by the police officials that no
person agreed to join the investigation does not inspire confidence. Thus, it
was rightly observed that, in the absence of any independent corroboration,
the testimony of the official witnesses required closer scrutiny, especially in
view of the stringent punishment prescribed under the NDPS Act.
5. Another material circumstance is that ASI Satnam Singh, who
lodged the FIR, also conducted the entire investigation, including
preparation of the recovery memo, arrest memo and site plan and recording
of statements under Section 161 Cr.P.C. This circumstance, when
considered along with the other infirmities in the prosecution case, further
raises doubts regarding the fairness of the investigation.
6. Reliance can be placed on the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme
Court in The State of Himachal Pradesh vs. Surat Singh , passed in
Criminal Appeal No. 96 of 2018 on March 16, 2026, wherein it was held
that offering a “third option” of being searched by a Police Officer, apart
from a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate, is contrary to the mandatory
SHARMILA
2026.11.17 10:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticiy of this document
CRM-A-1251-2019 -5-
requirements of Section 50 of the NDPS Act, particularly where personal
search of the accused is also conducted. Relevant part of the judgment reads
as under:-
“17. Further a reading of the judgments of the trial Court and
the High Court also show that in the presence of Panchas, the
SHO merely asked all the three appellants for their search by
him and they simply agreed. This is reflected in the Panchnama.
Though in Baldev Singh's case, this Court has not expressed
any opinion as to whether the provisions of Section 50 are
mandatory or directory but "failure to inform" the person
concerned of his right as emanating from sub-section (1) of
Section 50 may render the recovery of the contraband suspect
and the conviction and sentence of an accused bad and
unsustainable in law. In Vijaysinh Chan Jadeja's case (supra),
recently the Constitution Bench has explained the mandate
provided under sub-section (1) of Section 50 and concluded
that it is mandatory and requires strict compliance. The Bench
also held that failure to comply with the provision would render
the recovery of the illicit article suspect and vitiate the
conviction if the same is recorded only on the basis of the
recovery of the illicit article from the person of the accused
during such search………..”
7. Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Ranjan Kumar Chadha vs.
State of Himachal Pradesh , passed on Criminal Appeal Nos.2239-2240-
2011 on 06.10.2023, held as under:-
“64. From the aforesaid discussion, the requirements envisaged
by Section 50 can be summarised as follows:
(i) Section 50 provides both a right as well as an
obligation.
The person about to be searched has the right to have his
search conducted in the presence of a Gazetted Officer or
Magistrate if he so desires, and it is the obligation of the
SHARMILA
2026.11.17 10:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticiy of this document
CRM-A-1251-2019 -6-
police officer to inform such person of this right before
proceeding to search the person of the suspect.
(ii) Where, the person to be searched declines to exercise
this right, the police officer shall be free to proceed with
the search. However, if the suspect declines to exercise
his right of being searched before a Gazetted Officer or
Magistrate, the empowered officer should take it in
writing from the suspect that he would not like to
exercise his right of being searched before a Gazetted
Officer or Magistrate and he may be searched by the
empowered officer.
(iii) Before conducting a search, it must be
communicated in clear terms though it need not be in
writing and is permissible to convey orally, that the
suspect has a right of being searched by a Gazetted
Officer or Magistrate.
(iv) While informing the right, only two options of either
being searched in presence of a Gazetted Officer or
Magistrate must be given, who also must be independent
and in no way connected to the raiding party.
(v) In case of multiple persons to be searched, each of
them has to be individually communicated of their right,
and each must exercise or waive the same in their own
capacity. Any joint or common communication of this
Section 50
right would be in violation of .
Section 50
(vi) Where the right under has been exercised,
it is the choice of the police officer to decide whether to
take the suspect before a Gazetted Officer or Magistrate
but an endeavour should be made to take him before the
nearest Magistrate.
Section 50
(vii) is applicable only in case of search of
person of the suspect under the provisions of the NDPS
Act, and would have no application where a search was
conducted under any other statute in respect of any
offence.
(viii) Where during a search under any statute other than
the NDPS Act, a contraband under the NDPS Act also
happens to be recovered, the provisions relating to the
NDPS Act shall forthwith start applying, although in
Section 50
such a situation may not be required to be
complied for the reason that search had already been
conducted.
(ix) The burden is on the prosecution to establish that the
Section 50
obligation imposed by was duly complied
with before the search was conducted.
SHARMILA
2026.11.17 10:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticiy of this document
CRM-A-1251-2019 -7-
(x) Any incriminating contraband, possession of which is
punishable under the NDPS Act and recovered in
Section 50
violation of would be inadmissible and cannot
be relied upon in the trial by the prosecution, however, it
will not vitiate the trial in respect of the same. Any other
article that has been recovered may be relied upon in any
other independent proceedings.”
113. Similarly, in a recent judgement, this Court in Dayalu
Kashyap v. State of Chattisgarh reported in (2022) 12 SCC 398 ,
held that an extended view of Section 50 cannot be given to include a
polythene bag containing narcotics being carried by the accused. This
Court rejected the argument that as three options were given to the
accused to get himself searched from the officer which was in violation
of Section 50, the search conducted, even of the polythene bag, ought
to be vitiated. It was held as under:-
“4. The learned counsel submits that the option given to the
appellant to take a third choice other than what is prescribed as
the two choices under sub-section (1) of Section 50 of the Act
is something which goes contrary to the mandate of the law and
in a way affects the protection provided by the said section to
the accused. To support his contention, he has relied upon the
judgment of State of Rajasthan v. Parmanand (2014) 5 SCC
345, more specifically, SCC para 19. The judgment in turn,
relied upon a Constitution Bench judgment of this Court in
State of Punjab v. Baldev Singh, (1999) 6 SCC 172 to conclude
that if a search is made by an empowered officer on prior
information without informing the person of his right that he
has to be taken before a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate for
search and in case he so opts, failure to take his search
accordingly would render the recovery of the illicit article
suspicious and vitiate the conviction and sentence of the
accused where the conviction has been recorded only on the
basis of possession of illicit articles recovered from his person.
The third option stated to be given to the accused to get himself
searched from the Officer concerned not being part of the
statute, the same could not have been offered to the appellant
and thus, the recovery from him is vitiated.
5. In the conspectus of the facts of the case, we find that the
recoverywas in a polythene bag which was being carried on a
kanwad. The recovery was not in person. The learned counsel
seeks to expand the scope of the observations made by seeking
to contend that if the personal search is vitiated by violation of
Section 50 of the NDPS Act, the recovery made otherwise also
SHARMILA
2026.11.17 10:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticiy of this document
CRM-A-1251-2019 -8-
would stand vitiated and thus, cannot be relied upon. We
cannot give such an extended view as is sought to be contended
by the learned counsel for the appellant.” (Emphasis supplied)”
8. As per the law settled, the appeal against conviction and that
against acquittal rests entirely on different pedestal. As per the criminal
jurisprudence, every accused is presumed to be innocent until proven guilty.
As per the law settled by Hon'ble Supreme Court, once the accused is
acquitted by the Court of law, there lies double presumption of innocence in
his favour. Hence, an Appellate Court should not disturb the findings of
acquittal arrived at by the trial Court in a cavalier manner and it is only in
case of perversity of the findings, the Appellate Court should interfere in the
acquittal order passed by the trial Court. In Jafarudheen and others vs
State of Kerala 2022 SCC Online SC 495, it is held that Appellate Court
has to be relatively slow in reversing order of trial Court rendering acquittal,
relevant para of the same reads thus:
“25. While dealing with an appeal against acquittal by
invoking Section 378 of the Cr.P.C., the appellate Court has to
consider whether the trial Court's view can be termed as a
possible one, particularly when evidence on record has been
analyzed. The reason is that an order of acquittal adds up to the
presumption of innocence in favour of the accused. Thus, the
Appellate Court has to be relatively slow in reversing the order
of the Trial Court rendering acquittal. Therefore, the
presumption in favour of the accused does not get weakened
but only strengthened. Such a double presumption that enures
in favour of the accused has to be disturbed only by thorough
scrutiny on the accepted legal parameters.”
9. In Sadhu Saran Singh Vs. State of U.P. and others , AIR
2016 Supreme Court 1160, learned Appellate Court has held as under:-
SHARMILA
2026.11.17 10:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticiy of this document
CRM-A-1251-2019 -9-
18. Generally, an appeal against acquittal has always been altogether
on a different pedestal from that of an appeal against conviction. In
an appeal against acquittal where the presumption of innocence in
favour of the accused is reinforced, the appellate Court would
interfere with the order of acquittal only when there is perversity of
fact and law. However, we believe that the paramount consideration
of the Court is to do substantial justice and avoid miscarriage of
justice which can arise by acquitting the accused who is guilty of an
offence. A miscarriage of justice that may occur by the acquittal of
the guilty is no less than from the conviction of an innocent. This
Court, while enunciating the principles with regard to the scope of
powers of the appellate Court in an appeal against acquittal, in the
case of Sambasivan and Others V. State of Kerala , (1998) 5 SCC
412, has held :
“The principles with regard to the scope of the powers of the
appellate Court in an appeal against acquittal are well settled.
The powers of the appellate Court in an appeal against
acquittal are no less than in an appeal against conviction. But
where on the basis of evidence on record two views are
reasonably possible the appellate Court cannot substitute its
view in the place of that of the trial Court. It is only when the
approach of the trial Court in acquitting an accused is found to
be clearly erroneous in its consideration of evidence on record
and in deducing conclusions therefrom that the appellate Court
can interfere with the order of acquittal”.
10. There is no dispute regarding the law as relied upon by learned
State counsel, however, in the facts and circumstances of the present case,
the same is distinguishable.
11. Weighing the facts and circumstances of the present case on the
anvil of law settled, this Court finds no perversity in the order passed by the
trial Court. In view of the above, no case for grant of leave to appeal is
SHARMILA
2026.11.17 10:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticiy of this document
CRM-A-1251-2019 -10-
made out. Consequently, the present application filed by the State under
Section 378(3) Cr.P.C. seeking leave to file appeal, is hereby dismissed.
(RAJESH BHARDWAJ)
JUDGE
(ROHIT KAPOOR)
JUDGE
11.11.2026
Whether Speaking/Reasoned : Yes/No
sharmila
Whether Reportable : Yes/No
SHARMILA
2026.11.17 10:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticiy of this document