DR. SANTOSH BHARDWAJ vs SMT. BHORLAXMI BHARDWAJ

Court
Chhattisgarh High Court

Page 1 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}

CGHC010404192025 2026:CGHC:47331-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Judgment reserved on: 04-11-2026
Judgment delivered on: 17-11-2026
Judgment (Full) uploaded on: 17-11-2026
Digitally
signed by
SAIFAN
KHAN
FA(MAT) No. 346 of 2025
{Arising out of judgment and decree dated 25-08-2025, passed in Civil
SAIFAN
KHAN
Suit No.17A/2024 (Santosh Kumar Bhardwaj v. Smt. Bhorlaxmi
Bhardwaj) by the Family Court, Bilaspur (CG)}
Dr. Santosh Bhardwaj, S/o Gorelal Bhardwaj, aged about 41 years,
R/o MIG 09, Face-1, Rajendra Prasad Nagar, Niharika, PS Rampur,
District Korba (C.G.)
(Plaintiff)
... Appellant
Versus
Smt. Bhorlaxmi Bhardwaj, W/o Santosh Bhardwaj, aged about 38
years, R/o MIG 195, Geetanjali City, Face-2, Sarkanda, PS Sarkanda,
Tehsil & District Bilaspur (CG)
(Defendant)
... Respondent
For Appellant : Mr. Sunil Verma, Advocate.
For Respondent No.1 : Mr. Tarun Dansena, Advocate.
Division Bench: -
Hon'ble Shri Parth Prateem Sahu and
Hon'ble Smt. Sushma Sawant, JJ.
CAV Judgment
Sushma Sawant, J.
1. Invoking the appellate jurisdiction of this Court under Section 19(1) of
the Family Courts Act, 1984, the appellant herein/plaintiff father

Page 2 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}
Dr. Santosh Bhardwaj has preferred this appeal challenging the
judgment & decree dated 25-8-2025 passed by the Principal Judge,
Family Court, Bilaspur, District Bilaspur in Civil Suit No.17-A/2024
( Dr. Santosh Bhardwaj v. Smt. Bhorlaxmi Bhardwaj ), by which
the application filed by the appellant herein/plaintiff father under
Sections 7 & 10 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 , for
custody of the minor son, namely, Aarav Bhardwaj , has been rejected
finding no merit.
2. The aforesaid challenge has been made on the following factual
backdrop: -
(For the sake of convenience, parties hereinafter will be referred
as per their status shown and ranking given in the civil suit before the
Family Court.)
-:Factual Matrix:-
-:Admitted Facts:-
3. It is an admitted fact that the marriage between the appellant/plaintiff
father Dr. Santosh Bhardwaj and the respondent/defendant Smt.
Bhorlaxmi Bhardwaj was solemnized on 23.01.2011 at Korba,
Chhattisgarh, and the minor son namely, Aarav Bhardwaj was born
from the said wedlock. It is also admitted that ,the said marriage was
dissolved by a decree of divorce dated 29.04.2023. It is further admitted
that, in the Lok Adalat held on 13.05.2023 before the Family Court, the
parties agreed that the appellant/plaintiff father would pay
maintenance of ₹15,000/- per month for the minor son namely,

Page 3 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}
Aarav Bhardwaj and that he would be entitled to meet the minor son
every Sunday as per the terms of the settlement.
-:Case of the Appellant herein/Plaintiff- father before the
Family Court:-
4. The case of the appellant herein/plaintiff father before the Family
Court, in brief, is that his minor son, namely, Aarav Bhardwaj,
was born on 22.05.2013 and is presently in the custody and
guardianship of his maternal grandfather, Tikaram Ratre, and
maternal grandmother, Sarojini Ratre, both of whom are
approximately 75 years of age and residents of M.I.G. 195, Geetanjali
City, Phase-II, Police Station Sarkanda, Tehsil and District Bilaspur,
Chhattisgarh, because the minor's mother, namely,
respondent/defendant Bhorlaxmi Bhardwaj, is employed in
government service as a Doctor at the Community Health Centre (CHC),
Police Station Khamhariya, District Bemetara, and has consequently left
the minor in the care and custody of her parents, i.e., the maternal
grandparents of the minor.
5. It is further averred by the appellant/plaintiff father that the
respondent/defendant mother has never complied with the
settlement arrived at in the Lok Adalat. Instead, she has left the minor
in the care and custody of her aged parents and proceeded to
Khamhariya, District Bemetara, in connection with her government
employment. It is pleaded that the maternal grandparents, being
approximately 75 years of age, are not physically capable of providing
proper care and attention to the minor. It is also averred that the

Page 4 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}
respondent/defendant mother has failed to make adequate
arrangements for the proper education of the minor, Aarav Bhardwaj,
thereby adversely affecting his future. For want of proper guidance and
educational support, the minor secured a 'C' grade in Class V, which has
caused serious concern to the appellant/plaintiff.
6. It is further pleaded that the appellant/plaintiff father is fully capable of
taking care of the minor's overall welfare, including his health, medical
treatment, education and other needs. He is a qualified person holding a
degree in B.A.M.S. and is a Doctor by profession, having sufficient
income and financial capacity to provide the minor with proper
education and a secure future. On these grounds, the appellant/plaintiff
father sought his appointment as the legal guardian of the minor and a
direction for handing over the minor's custody to him, with visitation
rights to the respondent/defendant mother.
-:Written Statement/Reply of Respondent herein/Defendant-
mother before the Family Court:-
7. The respondent/defendant mother, in her reply to the application,
pleaded that the minor had been left in the care and custody of his
maternal grandparents for his convenience and proper upbringing, so
that he would not suffer any inconvenience during her official duties.
She further pleaded that the minor's future would remain insecure in
the custody of the appellant/plaintiff, as he, being a Doctor, remains
occupied with his professional duties and is unable to devote adequate
time and attention to the minor. She asserted that she is capable of
providing proper care, upbringing and education to the minor.

Page 5 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}
8. It was further pleaded that the minor is presently residing with the
respondent/defendant, who is properly looking after him and ensuring
his education. She also averred that the appellant/plaintiff has not been
regularly paying the agreed maintenance of ₹15,000/- per month and
that she has filed an application under Section 125(3) of the Code of
Criminal Procedure before the competent Court, which is pending
adjudication. She accordingly maintained that she alone is taking care
of the minor's food, education and other necessities and that entrusting
his custody to the appellant/plaintiff would not be in his welfare and
best interests.
9. The respondent/defendant, in her additional pleadings, further stated
that the minor is residing in a joint family comprising his maternal
grandparents, maternal uncle and maternal aunt, where he is receiving
proper care and enjoying a better standard of living. She stated that the
minor is studying in Class VI at Loyola School, Bilaspur , and that
his continued residence with her is essential for his welfare, as a child
requires the care and affection of his mother. She further pleaded that
the appellant/plaintiff, despite depositing maintenance, makes no
inquiries regarding the minor's welfare and provides no financial
assistance towards his medical treatment, medicines, school fees or
other expenses. She also alleged that the appellant/plaintiff files
applications on false grounds to harass her, keeps another woman with
him and, being occupied with his professional duties, is unable to
provide proper care and attention to the minor. It was further pleaded
that the appellant/plaintiff's parents are also aged and incapable of

Page 6 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}
looking after the minor. On these grounds, she prayed for dismissal of
the application.
-:Proceedings before the learned Family Court:-
10. The Family Court after appreciating oral and documentary evidence
available on record, framed following issues and answered the issues as
under:-
S.No. Issues Finding
1. Whether the welfare and
proper development of the
minor child, Aarav Bhardwaj,
would be ensured if he
remains in the custody of the
plaintiff?
“NO”
2. Whether the welfare and
proper development of the
minor child, Aarav Bhardwaj,
are being ensured in the
custody of the defendant?
“Yes”
3. Whether the Applicant is
entitled to obtain custody of
the minor child, Aarav
Bhardwaj, from the
defendant?
“No”
4. Relief and Costs? “As per sub-paragraph (1) of the
operative portion of the
judgment.”
-: Details of evidence and documents available before the
amily Court:-
Evidence led by appellant/plaintiff:-
11. Before the Family Court, though appellant/plaintiff father Santosh
Bhardwaj has examined himself as PW-1, however no documents
has been exhibited in evidence.

Page 7 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}
Evidence led by respondent/defendant:-
12.Similarly, on behalf of the respondent/defendant, she herself-
Bhorlaxmi Bhardwaj has examined herself as DW-1 and exhibited
as many as two documents Exs.D-1 & D-2 which were admitted in
evidence.
-:Finding and Judgment of Family Court :-
13.Parties were given opportunity to adduce evidence and after completion
of trial, the suit/application of the appellant herein/plaintiff father has
been dismissed vide Judgment dated 25.08.2025 , being aggrieved
against which, this appeal has been filed on the following grounds:-
(i) That, the impugned order of the learned court below is
arbitrary, illegal and contrary to the law applicable to the facts and
circumstances of the case.
(ii) That, the learned court below has failed to appreciate the
evidence as well as material available on record and impugned order
passed by the court below is perverse and contrary in the eye of law.
(iii) That, the learned Court below has failed to properly appreciate
the statement of the appellant/plaintiff recorded before it.
(iv) That, the learned family court below has passed the judgment
in mechanical manner for the reason that the impugned order is not
based on correct appreciation of facts and is based on perverse
findings hence cannot be allowed to sustain.
(v) That, the learned family court failed to appreciate that the
respondent was not able to prove that he was subjected to cruelty and

Page 8 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}
any wilful desertion by the respondent/mother and mother of Aarav
Bhardwaj.
(vi) That, the respondent/mother was not allowing the
appellant/father to meet his minor son.
(vii) That, the learned family court without properly appreciating
the evidence and material available on record, reject the application
filed by the appellant/father.
(viii) That, the learned Family Court has failed to properly appreciate
the pleadings and evidence on record and has also not considered the
written arguments advanced on behalf of the appellant. Hence, the
impugned order is liable to be set aside.
(ix) That, the learned Court below has failed to consider the settled
position of law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court that, while
adjudicating a matter, the Court must endeavour to advance
substantial justice to all the parties and that procedural technicalities
should not come in the way of doing substantial justice or perpetuate
an illegality arising from the impugned judgment.
-: Proceeding before the Appellate Court :-
14.Heard on the Appeal. In the context of the appeal and arguments,
evidence and documents, available on record of the Family Court were
examined.
15.It is pertinent to mention that, on the date of final hearing, both the
parties were directed to remain present before this Court along with the
minor. Accordingly, both parties appeared along with the minor, and

Page 9 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}
this Court heard the submissions of both parties as well as interacted
with the minor.
-:Points for Determination:-
16. Considering the entire facts of the case, the following two points would
emerge for determination of the issue: -
1. Whether the appellant/plaintiff father has made out
sufficient grounds for his appointment as guardian of the
person of the minor son, namely, Aarav Bhardwaj, under
Section 7 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890?
2. Whether the impugned order passed by the learned
Family Court calls for interference in the present appeal?
-:Argument of the Appellant/Plaintiff Father:-
17. Learned counsel for the appellant/plaintiff father , in line with the
grounds raised in the memo of appeal, has advanced detailed
submissions assailing the findings recorded by the learned Family
Court. The appellant/plaintiff, father while personally appearing before
this Court, additionally emphasised that the respondent/defendant
mother frequently travels to another city in connection with her
employment and, therefore, is unable to provide adequate care and
attention to the minor. He further submits that the minor is not under
proper supervision and control of his maternal grandparents and that
his educational standard is continuously deteriorating. It is, therefore,
submitted that the welfare and future of the minor would be better
served by entrusting his custody to the appellant/plaintiff father.

Page 10 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}
-:Argument of Respondent/Defendant Mother:-
18. Learned counsel for the respondent/defendant mother submits that the
learned Family Court has rightly rejected the application seeking
appointment of the appellant/plaintiff as guardian of the minor. The
respondent/defendant,mother while personally appearing before this
Court, submitted that she is properly looking after the minor and that
there is no deficiency in his care, upbringing or education. She further
stated that she has never restrained the appellant/plaintiff father from
meeting or interacting with the minor. Hence, no ground is made out
for interference with the impugned order and the appeal deserves to be
dismissed.
-: Finding and Analysis of the Appellate Court :-
19.Points for determination Nos.1 and 2 are taken up together for
consideration, as they are interconnected.
20. It is evident from the record that both the parties have adduced oral as
well as documentary evidence in support of their respective cases.
However, upon perusal of their pleadings and evidence, it is apparent
that, pursuant to the settlement arrived in the Lok Adalat on
13.05.2023, the appellant/plaintiff father was already granted visitation
rights to meet the minor son every Sunday. It further appears from the
documents Ex.D.-1 and Ex.D.-2 that certain unpleasant situations had
also arisen between the parties during the course of such meetings.
21.Thus, despite having visitation rights to meet and interact with the
minor, the appellant/plaintiff father has instituted the present

Page 11 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}
proceedings seeking his appointment as guardian of the minor under
Section 7 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, along with a
prayer for entrustment of the minor's custody to him. Therefore, the
present dispute between the parties is not confined merely to the
appellant/plaintiff father's visitation rights but essentially concerns the
guardianship and custody of the minor.
22. It is well-settled by the Hon’ble Supreme Court that, in matters
concerning the custody of a minor or appointment of a guardian, the
paramount consideration is the welfare and best interests of the child,
and not the preferential or legal rights of either parent. In this regard, in
Nil Ratan Kundu v. Abhijit Kundu , (2008) 9 SCC 413, the
Supreme Court has reiterated that the welfare of the child is the
paramount consideration in determining questions of custody and
guardianship. Accordingly, while considering an application under
Section 7 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, the Court is
required to be guided primarily by the welfare of the minor.
23. In addition to the aforesaid settled principle, the Hon'ble Supreme
Court, in Nil Ratan Kundu v. Abhijit Kundu , (2008) 9 SCC 413,
has also, in paragraph 52 , specifically elucidated the approach to be
adopted by the Court while deciding complex questions relating to the
custody of a minor. The relevant paragraph is reproduced hereinbelow:
“52. In our judgment, the law relating to custody of a child is
fairly well settled and it is this: in deciding a difficult and
complex question as to the custody of a minor, a court of law
should keep in mind the relevant statutes and the rights

Page 12 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}
flowing therefrom. But such cases cannot be decided solely by
interpreting legal provisions. It is a human problem and is
required to be solved with human touch. A court while dealing
with custody cases, is neither bound by statutes nor by strict
rules of evidence or procedure nor by precedents. In selecting
proper guardian of a minor, the paramount consideration
should be the welfare and well-being of the child. In selecting a
guardian, the court is exercising parens patriae jurisdiction
and is expected, nay bound, to give due weight to a child's
ordinary comfort, contentment, health, education, intellectual
development and favourable surroundings. But over and
above physical comforts, moral and ethical values cannot be
ignored. They are equally, or we may say, even more
important, essential and indispensable considerations. If the
minor is old enough to form an intelligent preference or
judgment, the court must consider such preference as well,
though the final decision should rest with the court as to what
is conducive to the welfare of the minor. ”
24. In the light of the aforesaid settled principles, it would be appropriate to
examine the facts and circumstances of the present case. In the present
matter, the appellant/plaintiff father has questioned the
respondent/defendant mother's ability to provide proper care and
attention to the minor on the ground that she remains occupied with
her government employment and is required to travel to another place
in connection with her official duties. However, the said circumstance,
by itself, cannot be considered sufficient to conclude that the
respondent/defendant mother is unable to look after the minor.

Page 13 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}
25. Significantly, the appellant/plaintiff father is also a Doctor by
profession, and the evidence on record indicates that he is engaged in
professional practice at both Korba and Raipur . Thus, the
circumstance of professional engagements and consequent paucity of
time is not confined to the respondent/defendant mother alone.
Therefore, the aforesaid ground does not constitute a sufficient basis for
appointing the appellant/plaintiff father as guardian and disturbing the
existing arrangement.
26. The appellant/plaintiff father has also raised an objection regarding the
alleged deterioration in the educational standard of the minor.
However, no cogent documentary evidence has been brought on record
to establish that the minor's academic performance has deteriorated or
that his education is being neglected by the respondent. A mere
reference to the grade obtained by the minor in a particular academic
session, without any supporting material demonstrating neglect or
adverse impact upon his education, cannot be treated as sufficient
ground for changing his existing arrangement of care and upbringing.
27. It is also relevant that the minor is now of an age where he is capable of
expressing an intelligent preference. On the date of final hearing, the
minor appeared before this Court along with his
mother(respondent/defendant) and, upon interaction, expressed his
unwillingness to go with his father.
28. Although the preference of the minor cannot, by itself, be the sole
determining factor, the same deserves due consideration along with the

Page 14 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}
other circumstances of the case. Further, keeping in view the paramount
consideration of the welfare of the minor, it is noteworthy that, in the
present case, no such material has been brought on record to establish
that the respondent/mother is neglecting the minor or that his physical,
educational or emotional welfare is being adversely affected while
residing with her.
29. On the contrary, the minor, who is presently about 14 years of age, has
expressed his unwillingness to reside with his father. At this age, he is
sufficiently mature to understand the circumstances and the
relationship between his parents. In such circumstances, abruptly
changing his custody merely on the appellant/plaintiff father's
apprehension, unsupported by any cogent material, that the minor is
not being properly looked after, may adversely affect the minor's mental
and emotional well-being.
30. Merely to satisfy the appellant/plaintiff father's desire for custody, it
would not be appropriate to expose an adolescent child to such
emotional distress, particularly when the respondent/defendant mother
has no objection to the appellant/plaintiff father meeting and
interacting with the minor. Thus, no sufficient ground is made out to
disturb the existing custody arrangement in the absence of any
demonstrated advantage to the welfare of the minor.
31. In the present case, no sufficient ground has been established
warranting the appointment of the appellant as guardian under Section
7 of the Act or the consequential transfer of custody of the minor to him.

Page 15 of 15
IN
{FA(MAT)No.346/2025}
The learned Family Court, therefore, cannot be said to have committed
any illegality or material irregularity in rejecting the application.
Accordingly, this Court finds no sufficient ground to interfere with the
impugned order.
-:Final Conclusion :-
32. Consequently, the appeal, being devoid of merit, is and the
dismissed
impugned order passed by the learned Family Court is hereby affirmed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
33. However, since the respondent/defendant mother has expressed no
objection to the appellant/plaintiff father exercising his visitation rights,
the appellant/plaintiff father shall be at liberty to meet and spend time
with the minor on special occasions, such as the minor's birthday,
festivals and during long vacations, subject to the minor's prior
willingness and mutual convenience of the parties, keeping in view the
minor's educational schedule and comfort.
34. A decree be drawn up accordingly.
Sd/- sd/-
(Parth Prateem Sahu) (Sushma Sawant)
JUDGE JUDGE
s@if