Harjit Singh vs Jasbir Kaur Manchanda & Anr
- Court
- Delhi High Court
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
% Reserved on : 20.08.2026
Pronounced on : 20.11.2026
Uploaded on : 21.11.2026
# CNR No. DLHC010340772010
+ FAO 84/2010 & CM APPL. 2178/2014
HARJIT SINGH .....Appellant
Through: Mr. N. K. Kantawala, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Siddharth
Vardhman, Ms. Sangeeta
Gulati, Mr. A.M. Nair, and Mr.
Nishant Kantawala, Advocates
versus
JASBIR KAUR MANCHANDA & ANR .....Respondents
Through: Mr. Ajay Majithia, Advocate
for Respondent Nos. 1 & 2
Mr. Brijesh Oberoi and Mr.
Daksh Oberoi, Advocates
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT
1. The present appeal has been preferred under Section 384 read
with Section 299 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 against the
judgment dated 04.12.2009, vide which the probate petition was
allowed and letter of administration was directed to be issued in favour
of the propounder of the concerned Will, i.e. respondent no. 1 herein.
2. The probate petition was preferred by late Ms. Jasbir Kaur ,
Signature Not Verified
FAO 84/2010 Page 1 of 9
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:40:26
whereby she propounded the registered Will dated 24.03.1998
(hereinafter the “subject Will”) statedly executed by her father, Sh.
Trilochan Singh Manchanda (hereinafter the “testator”), who expired
on 14.07.1998.
In the petition, the propounder claimed that a DDA plot
admeasuring 613 sq. yds. bearing no. C-63/3, Okhla Industrial Area,
Phase-II, New Delhi was allotted to the testator, who entered into a
partnership with his 3 sons in the name of M/s New Era Offset
Printers , with each having a 25% share in the partnership, and a
Partnership Deed was executed on 13.02.1980.
Vide the subject Will, the testator bequeathed his 25% share in
the aforesaid partnership firm, including its factory, land, and building
at the aforesaid address, in favour of the propounder, who was his
unmarried daughter.
3. In the probate proceedings, as no executor was appointed, the
propounder sought grant of a letter of administration and examined
two of the attesting witnesses, namely Sh. Rakesh Kumar and Sh.
Surinder Pal , in support of the petition. Out of the testator’s three
sons, only the appellant, Sh. Harjit Singh , filed objections, whereas Sh.
Sukhwant Singh gave no objection, and Sh. Surinder Singh did not file
any objections.
4. The Probate Court framed the following issues:-
“ 1 Whether the deceased Sh. Trilochan Singh had any right to
execute the Will dated 24.3.98? OPP
2 Whether the deceased Sh. Trilochan Singh had validly executed
the Will dated 24.3.1998 while in sound disposing mind? OPP
3 Relief. ”
Signature Not Verified
FAO 84/2010 Page 2 of 9
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:40:26
5. In support of the petition, the propounder examined herself as
PW-1, along with the said two attesting witnesses as PW-2 and PW-3.
On the other hand, the appellant, being the sole objector, examined
himself as RW-2, and one Dr. A. S. Ahluwalia , who had treated the
testator, as RW-1. While answering the issues in favour of the
propounder, the Probate Court allowed the underlying probate petition
vide the impugned judgment.
6. Learned Senior Counsel for the appellant, while questioning the
correctness of the impugned judgment, raises three-fold contentions.
Firstly, it is contended that the testator, at the time of execution of the
subject Will, was not of sound and disposing mind, and thus, could not
have executed a document which he did not understand. Secondly, it is
contended that Sh. Sukhwant Singh , the eventual beneficiary (in whose
favour the propounder executed a Will dated 30.06.1999 and a Release
Deed dated 30.07.2010), was present at the time of execution of the
subject Will and actively participated in it, and thus, the alleged
execution cannot be said to be wilful and voluntary. Lastly, while
referring to Sections 5 and 14 of the Indian Partnership Act, 1932
(hereinafter the “Partnership Act”), as well as Clause 13(c) of the
Partnership Deed, it is contended that the property of the partnership
firm could not have been bequeathed by the testator, and thus, the
bequest made by him was illegal. Reliance in this regard is placed
upon the decision of the Supreme Court in Addanki Narayanappa &
1
Anr. Vs. Bhaskara Krishtappa & Ors. .
1
1966 SCC OnLine SC 6
Signature Not Verified
FAO 84/2010 Page 3 of 9
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:40:26
7. Learned counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, defends
the impugned judgment and submits that the objections raised were
rightly rejected by the Probate Court. It is submitted that the testator
was not suffering from any serious ailment and was of sound disposing
mind. Referring to Section 42(c) of the Partnership Act read with
Clause 13(c) of the Partnership Deed, he further submits that the
partnership admittedly continued even after the death of the testator.
The testator bequeathed his 25% share in the firm in favour of the
propounder, who is one of his legal representatives, and as such, she
acquires right and interest in the partnership. Reliance is placed on
2
Pentakota Satyanarayana & Ors. Vs. Pentakota Seetharatnam & Ors.
and Parvathi Nairthi (Dead) & Ors. Vs. Laxmi Nairthy (Dead)
3
Through LRs. & Ors. .
8. This Court has heard detailed submissions on behalf of the
parties and carefully perused the written submissions as well as the
record of the case.
9. The first contention raised on behalf of the appellant pertains to
whether the testator was of sound and disposing mind at the time of
executing the subject Will. In this regard, it is further contended that
the testator had 3 sons whose exclusion is not explained. Further, the
testator’s ill-health was admitted not only by the propounder but also
by Dr. Ahluwalia , who was his treating doctor. It is also claimed that
in September 1995, the testator had suffered a paralytic attack.
10. The propounder, in her deposition, had refuted the contentions
2
(2005) 8 SCC 67
3
2026 SCC OnLine SC 911
Signature Not Verified
FAO 84/2010 Page 4 of 9
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:40:26
questioning the mental ability of the testator at the time of execution of
the subject Will. However, learned Senior Counsel has placed great
emphasis on the deposition of Dr. Ahluwalia . Accordingly, this Court
proceeds to examine the testimony of Dr. Ahluwalia .
11. In his evidence by way of affidavit, Dr. Ahluwalia stated that he
was looking after the testator from the year 1991 till his death in July
1998. He deposed that the testator was suffering from diabetes
mellitus, hypertension, myocardial infarction, and effects of
congestive cardiac failure, and that in the last year of his life, he
developed neurological complications of diabetes in the form of
amnesia and degenerative disorders of the brain. He further deposed
that for the last one year before his death, the testator was bed-ridden
and was suffering from periodic loss of memory, and was not in a
sound and disposing mind.
12. However, in his cross-examination, Dr. Ahluwalia admitted that
he had never issued any certificate that the testator was suffering from
mental or neurological loss of memory or any other ailment, and
volunteered that there was never any such need. He further admitted
that he had noticed the testator having loss of memory only twice or
thrice, that it was a result of his diabetic problems, and that there was
no necessity to advise him to consult a specialist for it.
13. Taking note of this very testimony, the Probate Court held that
even if it was presumed that the testator had developed diabetic
problems in the last year of his life, it was not established that on
24.03.1998, particularly at the time of execution of the subject Will, he
had lost his memory. It further noted that even as per Dr. Ahluwalia ,
Signature Not Verified
FAO 84/2010 Page 5 of 9
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:40:26
the testator’s loss of memory used to be temporary or occasional. This
Court finds no reason to differ with the said finding. Apart from the
testimony of Dr. Ahluwalia , there is no medical document on record to
show that the testator suffered from loss of memory. Even going by his
testimony, the loss of memory was noticed only on 2-3 occasions and
was temporary, so much so that Dr. Ahluwalia himself did not find it
necessary to refer the testator to a specialist. There is nothing on
record to establish that such a condition existed on or near the date of
execution of the subject Will.
14. Insofar as the exclusion of the testator’s sons is concerned, a
gainful reference may be made to the decision in Parvathi Nairthi
( supra ), wherein the Supreme Court held as under:-
“ 34. … Mere exclusion of the natural heirs from the
property of the testator, by itself, cannot be construed as a
suspicious circumstance so as to invalidate a Will outrightly. A
testator is legally entitled to dispose of his property according to
his own wishes, and unless the exclusion is accompanied by
suspicious circumstances affecting the genuineness or due
execution of a Will, such exclusion alone does not render a Will
invalid. … ”
The exclusion of natural heirs, by itself, does not render the
subject Will suspicious. In view of the above, the first contention is
rejected.
15. Coming to the second contention, it is contended that Sh.
Sukhwant Singh , the eventual beneficiary, was present at the time of
execution of the subject Will and actively participated in it, and thus,
its execution cannot be said to be wilful and voluntary. In support of
this contention, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant has relied
Signature Not Verified
FAO 84/2010 Page 6 of 9
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:40:26
upon the affidavit of the propounder herself, wherein she stated that on
24.03.1998, Sh. Sukhwant Singh had accompanied the testator and the
attesting witnesses to the office of the Sub-Registrar.
16. In this regard, it is noted that the bequest under the subject Will
was made in favour of the propounder, who undisputedly had not
accompanied the testator at the time of its execution. It is a different
matter that more than 15 months after the execution of the subject
Will, the propounder executed a Will dated 30.06.1999 in favour of
Sh. Sukhwant Singh , and thereafter, also executed a Release Deed
dated 30.07.2010 in his favour.
17. A gainful reference in this regard may also be made to
Pentakota Satyanarayana ( supra ), wherein the Supreme Court held as
under:-
“ … Even in a case where active participation and
execution of the Will by the propounders/beneficiaries was there, it
has been held that that by itself is not sufficient to create any doubt
either about the testamentary capacity or the genuineness of the
Will. It has been held that the mere presence of the beneficiary at
the time of execution would not prove that the beneficiary had
taken prominent part in the execution of the Will. … ”
Accordingly, the second contention, being misplaced, is
rejected.
18. Coming to the last contention, it is contended that the property
in question had become the property of the partnership firm, and thus,
in view of Sections 5 and 14 of the Partnership Act, and Clause 13(c)
of the Partnership Deed, the testator could not have bequeathed the
same in favour of the propounder.
19. Learned counsel for the respondents has sought to meet the said
Signature Not Verified
FAO 84/2010 Page 7 of 9
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:40:26
contention by relying upon Section 42(c) of the Partnership Act, under
which a firm is dissolved by the death of a partner, unless the partners
have contracted otherwise. It is submitted that Clause 13(c) of the
Partnership Deed is such a contract, and thus, the partnership did not
dissolve upon the death of the testator. The testator bequeathed his
25% share in the firm in favour of the propounder, who is one of his
legal representatives, and as such, she acquires right and interest in the
partnership.
20. However, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant has relied
upon Addanki Narayanappa ( supra ), wherein the Supreme Court held
as under:-
“ 7. … The whole concept of partnership is to embark upon a
joint venture and for that purpose to bring in as capital money or
even property including immovable property. Once that is done
whatever is brought in would cease to be the trading asset of the
person who brought it in. It would be the trading asset of the
partnership in which all the partners would have interest in
proportion to their share in the joint venture of the business of
partnership. The person who brought it in would, therefore, not be
able to claim or exercise any exclusive right over any property
which he has brought in, much less over any other partnership
property. … ”
In the present case, the subject property was allotted by the
DDA to the testator. Further, that the testator was a partner in the firm
was not denied. The challenge to the title and ownership of the testator
is not within the scope of the present appeal, but is required to be
agitated before the concerned Court in appropriate proceedings. It is
trite law that a Probate Court is solely concerned with determining the
genuineness and due execution of the Will in question and the
testamentary capacity of the testator, and does not adjudicate upon
Signature Not Verified
FAO 84/2010 Page 8 of 9
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:40:26
questions of title or ownership qua the bequeathed properties. The
grant of letter of administration, therefore, cannot be denied on the
ground of legal ownership of the property.
21. It is clarified that the observations made hereinabove qua the
last contention are only prima facie and meant for the purpose of
deciding the present appeal, and the same shall not have any bearing
on any proceedings that may be held later on.
22. Considering all the above, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the impugned judgment does not suffer from any
perversity or illegality warranting interference. Accordingly, the
present appeal, being devoid of merit, is dismissed.
23. The pending application is also disposed of in the above terms.
(MANOJ KUMAR OHRI)
JUDGE
NOVEMBER 20, 2026
sn/nb
Signature Not Verified
FAO 84/2010 Page 9 of 9
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
Signing Date:21.11.2026
17:40:26