S SELVAM vs INDIAN COUNCIL OF MEDICAL RESEARCH

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1 of 10
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CHENNAI BENCH
OA No. 310/00872 of 2021
.
th
DATED TUESDAY, THE 17 DAY OF NOVEMBER, TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
CORAM :
HON'BLE MS. VEENA KOTHAVALE, MEMBER (J)
HON'BLE MR. M.L. SRIVASTAVA, MEMBER(A)
BETWEEN
S.Selvam,
Driver
No.2/597, Sakthi Nagar,
II Cross street, Surveyor Colony,
Madurai- 625 007. ...Applicant
(Advocate: M/s. D.M. Sathya Kumar )
Versus
1. Union of India
represented by
The Assistant Director General (Admn)
Indian Council of Medical Research,
Ansari Nagar,
New Delhi-110029.
2. The Officer-in-charge,
Human Reproduction Research,
Medical College,
Madurai Medical College,
Madurai- 625 020;
3. The Officer-in-charge,
Human Reproduction Research,
Medical College,
Madurai Institute of VCRC,
Puducherry. . …….Respondents
(Advocate: Mr. M. Kishore Kumar, SPC )
CAV ON : 05 .10.2026

2 of 10
O R D E R
(Hon'ble Ms. Veena Kothavale, Member(J)

This Original Application is filed by the applicant under Section 19 of the
Administrative Tribunals' Act, 1985 seeking the following relief: -
"(i) To quash the order of the second respondent in Proceedings No.
No.74/186/2016-ECD-II dated 21.05.2019;
(ii) To consequently direct the respondents to count the length of
the service of the applicant form the date of his initial appointment
with all consequential benefits with arrears and Interest and
(iii) pass such further or other orders as may be deemed fit and
proper in the facts and circumstances of the case and thus render
justice.”
rd
2. The brief facts are that the applicant is presently working as Attendant in 3
st
respondent office at VCRC, Puducherry, which is a unit under ICMR (1 respondent).
nd
Earlier, the applicant was appointed as Driver in 2 respondent office at Madurai
Medical College on 14.08.1997 on temporary basis. The applicant had filed O.A.
No.307 of 2001 for regularization of his service before this Tribunal which was
disposed on 15.12.2001 with a direction to the respondents to frame a scheme and
prepare a list for absorption of persons like the applicant against the post of Driver or
Group "D" posts with reference to the length of service depending upon the
availability of vacancies in various units under the control of ICMR. The said

3 of 10
decision dated 15/12/2001 was confirmed by the Hon'ble Madras High Court in W.P.
No.25490 of 2002 vide order dated 25.08.2006 and by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
SLP (C) No.14953-14960 of 2007 vide order dated 26/10/2009. However, as the
said order was not implemented till 2013 for almost 12 years, the applicant was
constrained to file a Contempt Petition before the Hon'ble Madras High Court in
Contempt Petition No. 69 of 2012. The said Contempt Petition came be closed on
11.07.2013 after the respondents produced Office Memorandum dated 10.07.2013
stating that the applicant has been appointed as Attendant at VCRC, Puducherry.
While closing the Contempt Petition, it was observed by the Hon'ble High Court that
so far as the request of the applicant for posting at Madurai is concerned, it is open
for the applicant to make a representation seeking re-transfer to Madurai, which shall
be considered by the Respondents on its own merits.
3. The applicant was served with appointment order dated 17.07.2013 to the post
of Attendant at VCRC, Puducherry. The applicant made a representation dated
st
03.09.2013 requesting the 1 Respondent to appoint him as Driver at HRRC,
st
Madurai Medical College, Madurai. In response thereto, the 1 Respondent vide
letter dated 22.11.2013 directed the applicant to join the post offered to him and
informed that failure to do so would invite action as per rules. The applicant again
made a representation to the Respondent to release his salary for the month of
September 2013 to November 2013. When there was no reply, applicant filed O.A.
No. 47 of 2014 before this Tribunal which was disposed of by order dated 10.03.2014

4 of 10
st st
directing the 1 Respondent to consider his representation. The 1 Respondent vide
order dated 23.04.2014 stated that the funds for the salary of the applicant was being
released and would be paid to the applicant at the earliest and further stated that the
applicant's request for posting as Driver at HRRC, Madurai could not be considered
in the absence of any regular post at HRRC, Madurai, and the same was declined.
Being aggrieved, the applicant filed O.A. No.1460 of 2014 for setting aside the order
dated 23/04/2014 and for a direction to issue regular appointment order for the post
of Driver at Madurai Medical College, Madurai with all consequential benefits, and
also for service regularisation. On the submissions made by the respondents that
there is no regular post in Madurai Medical College as it is a project center, the OA
came to be dismissed by this Tribunal vide order dated 23/09/2016. The applicant
st
made representations dated 09/03/2019 and 21/05/2019 requesting the 1 respondent
to count the length of his service from the initial appointment in the year 1997.
However, his request was rejected by the first respondent vide reply dated 21/05/2019
stating that the above issue has already been covered by OA. No.1460 of 2014 and
therefore the matter has to be treated as settled and no further correspondence in this
regard will be considered. Hence, this OA is being filed by the applicant for the
aforestated relief.
4. The respondents have filed their reply statement stating that the applicant had
earlier filed O.A No.307 of 2001 in which this Tribunal vide order dated 05/12/2001
had directed the respondents to consider the applicant for absorption against the post

5 of 10
of Driver or Group 'D' posts with reference to the length of service depending upon
the availability of vacancies in the units under the control of ICMR. However, there
was no direction in the said order to regularise the services of the applicant from his
initial date of appointment in the project and to pay arrears or benefits for his project
st
services. The order dated 05/12/2001 was challenged by the 1 respondent before
Hon'ble Madras High Court and Hon'ble Supreme Court, but the order of the Tribunal
was upheld by both the Courts. Accordingly, in compliance with the direction of this
Tribunal, the applicant was offered with the post of Attendant (Services) (erstwhile
Group "D" post) in ICMR-VCRC, Puducherry on 17.07.2013.
5. It is further stated by the respondents that initially the applicant refused to
accept the offer of appointment to the post of Attendant (Services) and report to duty
and instead submitted representations requesting to appoint him to the post of Driver
at HRRC, Madurai. Finally, after directions, he reported to duty on 03.03.2014 and
immediately applied for leave from 10.03.2014 to 30.06.2015 and continued to
remain absent with effect from 01.07.2015 to 07.11.2016 and only after the lapse of
two years from 10.03.2014 to 07.11.2016, the applicant reported to duty on
08.11.2016 at ICMR-VCRC, Puducherry. Meanwhile, the applicant had filed O.A
No. 1460 of 2014 before this Tribunal seeking appointment to the post of Driver at
Madurai Medical College, Madurai with all consequential benefits along with
regularisation of project services but the OA was dismissed by this Tribunal vide
order dated 23.09.2016 holding that there is no merit in the contentions raised in the

6 of 10
O.A. Therefore, the request of the applicant to count his length of services in the
project was not considered and the same has been intimated to the applicant vide
letter dated 21.05.2019. The said order is impugned in this OA and as the same has
no merit, prayed for dismissal of the OA.
6. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the applicant that O.Α. No.1460 of
2014 only dealt with the issue of transfer of the applicant from Puducherry to
Madurai, and did not deal with the issue of counting of the length of service of the
applicant. When similarly situated persons in the same institution and other
institutions who were involved in the order dated 25.08.2006 were regularized from
the initial date of appointment and had been paid with all arrears and terminal
benefits, the same ought to be extended to the applicant as well and the action of the
respondents to implement the same to the applicant only from 2013 is highly
discriminatory. Once applicant is regularized in service, the respondent should
consider the initial date of appointment to count the length of the service and grant
him all the benefits including the fixation of pay.
7. Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondents reiterated the averments
made in the reply and contended that O.Α. No.1460 of 2014 was filed by the
applicant not only for seeking appointment in the post of Driver at Madurai Medical
College, Madurai with all consequential benefits but also for regularisation of his
project services, which has been dismissed by this Tribunal stating that there is no

7 of 10
merit in the contentions raised in the OA.
8. We have considered the submissions made by the learned counsel on both sides
and perused the records.
9. It is observed that the applicant was earlier appointed as Driver in Madurai
Medical College on 14/08/1997 on temporary basis and his services were terminated
on completion of the project. He had challenged his termination before this Tribunal
by filing O.A. No.307 / 2001, seeking direction to the respondents to reinstate him in
st
any of the vacancies under the control of the 1 respondent (ICMR) in the post of
Driver. The said OA was disposed of with a direction to the respondents to frame a
scheme and prepare a list for absorption of persons like the applicant against the post
of Driver or Group D posts with reference to the length of service depending upon the
availability of the vacancies in various units under the control of ICMR. Though the
st
said order was challenged by the 1 respondent before the Hon'ble Madras High
Court and the Supreme Court, the order passed by this Tribunal was upheld. As no
action was taken by the respondent, the applicant filed Contempt Petition No.
69/2012 before the Hon'ble Madras High Court. As the respondents produced Office
Memorandum dated 10/07/2013 stating that applicant will be appointed as Attendant
(Service) in VCRC, Puducherry against a regular post which is lying vacant, the
Contempt Petition was closed by the Hon'ble High Court with the observation that it
is open for the applicant to make a representation seeking re-transfer to Madurai

8 of 10
which shall be considered by the respondents on its own merits.
10. It is stated by the respondents that the offer of appointment to the post of
Attendant (services) in ICMR-VCRC, Puducherry was initially refused by the
applicant and he did not report to duty, but submitted representation demanding to
appoint him to the post of Driver at HRRC, Madurai. However, he reported for duty
on 03.03.2014 and immediately applied for leave and remained absent for a period of
two years from 10.03.2014 upto 07.11.2016. During this period, he filed OA No.
1460/2014 before this Tribunal seeking direction for regular appointment in the post
of Driver at Madurai Medical college with all consequential benefits as well as for
service regularization. It is observed that the respondent had stated that there is no
vacant post of Driver at HRRC Madurai and the post requested by the applicant is a
temporary and contractual post in a project and since it is not a permanent post, a
person in regular job cannot appointed on a temporary or contractual post which is
extended on year to year basis on project funds. Accordingly, O.A. No. 1460/2014
was dismissed by this Tribunal vide order dated 23.09.2016 holding that there is no
merit in the contentions raised in the OA.
11. Thereafter, the applicant gave representations dated 09.03.2019 and 03.05.1990
seeking to count the length of his service from his initial date of appointment in the
st
year 1997 which was rejected by the 1 respondent vide order dated 21.05.2019. It is
stated in the order that in OA 1460/2014, the applicant had also sought for

9 of 10
regularization of his project services and the said OA came to be dismissed by the
Tribunal vide order dated 23.09.2016 holding that there is no merit in the contentions
st
raised in the O.A.. Therefore, the 1 respondent has held that the issue may be treated
as settled and no more correspondence shall be entertained in this regard. In this OA,
the applicant has challenged the said order seeking for a direction to count the length
of his service from the date of his initial appointment in 1997.
12. However, it is seen that the applicant was terminated on 01.03.2001 from
service on 01.03.2001 on completion of the project work in ICMR and thereafter,
only in 2013, he was absorbed in the post of Attendant (Services) in VCRC,
Puducherry on the direction of this Tribunal. Therefore, it cannot be said that the
applicant has been in continuous employment from the date of his initial appointment
from 1997. Since there was a break in his service, he is not entitled for the relief
claimed.
13. It is observed that W.P. No. 16463 of 2024 was filed by one Mr. T. Kumar
before the Hon'ble Madras High Court seeking for direction to count the length of
his service from the date of his initial appointment for retirement benefits and
pensionary benefits. The said T. Kumar was respondent No.2 in W.P. No. 2557 of
2002 which is covered by the common order dated 25/08/2006 passed by the Hon'ble
Madras High Court and he is similarly placed as the applicant herein. The Hon'ble
Madras High Court vide its order dated 11/02/2026 has held that he is not entitled for

10 of 10
counting the length of his service from the date of his initial appointment as he was
earlier disengaged as a Driver in a project and subsequently he was absorbed against
vacancies in the year 2012 and hence there was a break in his service. As the
circumstances of applicant's case is very much similar to that of T.Kumar, and there
is a break in his service also, as he was terminated on 01.03.2001 and subsequently
absorbed in Group D post as Attendant (Services) in 2013, we are of the view that
rejection of his request for counting the length of his service from the initial
appointment in the year 1997 was rightly rejected by the respondents.
14. In view of the above, we do not see any merit in this OA and hence it is
dismissed with no order as to costs.

(M.L. Srivastava) (Veena Kothavale)
Member(A) Member(J)
17.11.2026
asvs
Digitally signed by
ASAPU SRINIVASA
VIDYASAGAR
Date: 2026.11.20
17:06:34 +05'30'
A.S.V. Sagar
P.S., CAT,
Chennai Bench.