SRI T P MURALIDHAR vs SRI D SUDHAKAR GUPTA

Court
Karnataka High Court

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024




IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU

TH
DATED THIS THE 29 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026

R

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE TARA VITASTA GANJU

WRIT PETITION NO. 22058 OF 2024 (GM-CPC)

BETWEEN:

SRI. T.P.MURALIDHAR
S/O LATE MUNIYAPPA @ T.PAPANNA,
AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS,
st
RESIDING AT NO. 708, 1 FLOOR,
rd th
3 CROSS, 8 MAIN, ‘CAPITAL TRIO’
NEXT TO BENGALURU INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL
OF MUSIC AND FINE ART, HMT LAYOUT,
V.V.NAGAR, R.T.NAGAR POST,
BENGALURU-560 032.
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. PRASHANTH U.T., ADVOCATE)

AND:

1. SRI. D.SUDHAKAR GUPTA
S/O D.VENKATA NANJAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
th
NO. 30, 6 CROSS, MARUTHI ENCLAVE,
C.T.BED, BEHIND PROMED HOSPITAL,
nd
BANASHANKARI 2 STAGE,
BENGALURU-560 070.

2. SRI. AMRUTH KUMAR
FATHER NAME NOT KNOWN,
MAJOR,
RESIDING AT NO.16-50,
JAVILI STREET,
PALAMANER, CHITTOR DISTRICT,
ANDHRA PRADESH-517 408.
…RESPONDENTS











Digitally signed by
SUMATHY KANNAN
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA

1

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


(BY SRI. VISHNU HEGDE., ADVOCATE FOR R1 -
UNREPRESENTED
SRI. OMKARESHA., ADVOCATE FOR R2)

THIS W.P. IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO CALL FOR RECORDS IN
EX.NO. 1132/2020, PENDING ON THE FILE OF HON’BLE LVI
ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE (CCH-57)
BENGALURU. TO SET ASIDE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED:
11.07.2024 PASSED ON I.A.NO. 1 IN EX.NO. 1132/2020
PENDING ON THE FILE OF HON’BLE LVI ADDITIONAL CITY
CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE (CCH-57) BENGALURU (ANNX-L)
AND CONSEQUENTLY ALLOW THE I.A.NO.1 FILED UNDER
ORDER 21 RULE 90 OF CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE, 1908 IN
EX.NO. 1132/2020 ON THE FILE OF HON’BLE LVI ADDITIONAL
CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE (CCH-57) BENGALURU
(ANNX-H).

THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING IN
‘B’ GROUP, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:

CORAM: HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE TARA VITASTA GANJU

ORAL ORDER

1. The present petition seeks to challenge an order
dated 11.07.2024 passed by the LVI Addl. City Civil &
Sessions Judge, Bengaluru (CCH-57) (hereinafter referred
to the ‘Impugned Order’). By the Impugned Order, the
learned Trial Court has rejected I.A.No.1 filed by the
petitioner/Judgment Debtor under Order XXI Rule 90 of
2

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to
as the ‘CPC’).

2. This Court has briefly heard the petitioner/Judgment
Debtor as well as respondent No.2/auction purchaser
today as well as on the last date of hearing. Respondent
No.1/Decree Holder although served, remained
unrepresented. Given the pendency of this matter and the
interim directions granted by this Court on 23.08.2024 and
07.02.2025, this Court deems it apposite to hear and
decide the matter today.

3. This Court, after hearing the parties on 27.10.2026,
had passed the following order:
“1. The challenge in the present petition is to an order
dated 11.07.2024. By the Impugned Order, an
application under Order XXI Rule 90 of the CPC seeking
to set aside an auction, has been rejected.

2. Learned counsel for the petitioner has contended that
the provisions of Order XXI Rules 84 and 85 of the CPC
are mandatory in nature. He has further submitted that
the amounts which were paid by the respondent/auction
purchaser, were paid belatedly and not as per the
timelines as set out in these provisions.

3. It is the admitted case of the parties and it is also
recorded in the Impugned Order (paragraphs 28 and 29)
3

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


that the amounts were paid on 30.10.2023 and
23.11.2023 which is beyond the timeline as set out in
Order XXI, Rules 84 and 85 of the CPC. Thus, he
contends that the learned trial Court has erred in its
finding. Reliance in this behalf is placed on a judgment in
the case of Gas Point Petroleum India Limited vs.
Rajendra Marothi & Ors. ((2023) 6 SCC 391)).

4. Learned counsel for the respondent requests for two
days' time to place his judgments on record as well….”


4. Learned counsel for the petitioner/Judgment Debtor
has relied on Rules 84 to 86 of Order XXI of the CPC to
submit that the since the provisions were not followed and
the mandatory timelines were breached, the Executing
Court had no option but to declare the sale to be a nullity.
Reliance in this behalf is placed by learned counsel on the
judgments of the Supreme Court in the cases of Manilal
Mohanlal Shah and Others Vs. Sardar Sayed Ahmed
1
Sayed Mahmad and Another ; Gas Point Petroleum
2
India Limited Vs. Rajendra Marothi and Others as
well as Balram Son of Bhasa Ram Vs. Ilam Singh and
3
Others . Learned counsel further submits that in the

1
(1954) 1 SCC 724
2
(2023) 6 SCC 391
3
(1996) 5 SCC 705
4

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


event that the auction is conducted and the auction
purchaser is not the decree holder, the Court is required to
strictly adhere to the mandatory timelines as are set out in
Order XXI Rules 84 and 85 of the CPC.

6. Learned counsel for the respondent No.2/Auction
purchaser on the other hand has submitted that 25% of
the amount as requisite under Order XXI Rule 84 of the
CPC and thereafter the balance of 75% of the amount has
also been paid. He submits that since all the amounts have
been paid, the Impugned Order does not suffer from any
infirmity. In this regard, reliance is placed on the
4
judgment of Rosali V Vs. Taico Bank and Others and
5
Ramkaran Gupta Vs. J.S. Exim Limited and Others .

7. It is necessary to set out certain undisputed facts in
this matter. A spot sale proclamation was directed by the
Executing Court in Execution No.1132/2020 on 30.08.2023
scheduling a spot sale on 05.10.2023. On 05.10.2023, the

4
(2009) 17 SCC 690
5
(2012) 13 SCC 568
5

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


spot sale of the suit schedule property was conducted. The
respondent No.2 (who is a third party purchaser) made a
bid in a sum of Rs.1,08,00,000/- and was declared the
highest bidder in the spot sale. The 25% of the bid
amount was deposited by respondent No.2 on 27.10.2023.
Subsequently on 23.11.2023, the balance 75% was
deposited by respondent No.2.

8. The learned Executing Court after noticing these
deposits, found that even though Order XXI Rule 85 CPC
states that the full amount of purchase money shall be
th
paid to the Court before the Court closes on the 15 day
from the sale of the property, relying on the inherent
powers of the Court under Section 151 of the CPC, held
that the Court can accept these amounts and since the
auction purchaser/bidder has complied with the order,
there is no default on his side. The Executing Court has
also held that even though there is a lapse of more than 3
years, the decree has not been satisfied and that there are
6

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


no grounds to hold that there is irregularity in the conduct
of the sale of the schedule property.

9. The counsel for the petitioner/Judgment Debtor has
vociferously argued that the Impugned Order cannot be
sustained in view of the settled legal position. In this
regard, he has relied upon the judgments of the Supreme
Court in the Manilal Mohanlal Shah, the case of Gas
Point Petroleum as well as Balram Son of Bhasa Ram .

10. At this stage, it is apposite to set out the relevant
provisions in issue namely, Order XXI Rules 64, 72, 84,
85, 86 and Rule 90 of the CPC which are extracted below:
“64. Power to order property attached to be sold
and proceeds to be paid to person entitled.- Any
Court executing a decree may order that any property
attached by it and liable to sale, or such portion
thereof as may seem necessary to satisfy the
decree, shall be sold, and that the proceeds of such
sale, or a sufficient portion thereof, shall be paid to the
party entitled under the decree to receive the same.
xxx xxx xxx


72. Decree-holder not to bid for or buy property
without permission. --(1) No holder of a decree in
execution of which property is sold shall, without the
express permission of the Court, bid for or
purchase the property.

7

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


(2) Where decree-holder purchases, amount of
decree may be taken as payment. -- Where a
decree-holder purchases with such permission, the
purchase-money and the amount due on the decree
may, subject to the provisions of section 73, be set
off against one another, and the Court executing the
decree shall enter up satisfaction of the decree in whole
or in part accordingly.

3) Where a decree-holder purchases, by himself or
through another person, without such permission, the
Court may, if it thinks fit, on the judgment-debtor or any
other person whose interests are affected by the sale, he
application of the by order set aside the sale; and the
costs of such application and order, and any deficiency of
price which may happen on the re-sale and all expenses
attending it, shall be paid by the decree-holder.

xxx xxx xxx

84. Deposit by purchaser and re-sale on default.—

(1) On every sale of immovable property the
person declared to be the purchaser shall pay
immediately after such declaration a deposit of
twenty-five per cent on the amount of his
purchase-money to the officer or other person
conducting the sale, and in default of such deposit,
the property shall forthwith be re-sold.

(2) Where the decree-holder is the purchaser and is
entitled to set-off the purchase-money under rule 72, the
Court may dispense with the requirements of this rule.

85. Time for payment in full of purchase money. —

The full amount of purchase-money payable shall
be paid by the purchaser into Court before the
Court closes on the fifteenth day from the sale of
the property:

Provided that, in calculating the amount to be so paid
into Court, the purchaser shall have the advantage of
any set-off to which he may be entitled under rule 72.

86. Procedure in default of payment. —In default of
payment within the period mentioned in the last
8

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


preceding rule, the deposit may, if the Court thinks fit,
after defraying the expenses of the sale, be
forfeited to the Government, and the property shall
be re-sold, and the defaulting purchaser shall
forfeit all claim to the property or to any part of the
sum for which it may subsequently be sold.

xxx xxx xxx

90. Application to set aside sale on ground of
irregularity or fraud. — (1) Where any immovable
property has been sold in execution of a decree, the
decree-holder, or the purchaser, or any other person
entitled to share in a rateable distribution of assets, or
whose interests are affected by the sale, may apply to
the Court to set aside the sale on the ground of a
material irregularity or fraud in publishing or
conducting it.

(2) No sale shall be set aside on the ground of
irregularity or fraud in publishing or conducting it unless,
upon the facts proved, the Court is satisfied that the
applicant has sustained substantial injury by reason of
such irregularity or fraud.

(3) No application to set aside a sale under this rule shall
be entertained upon any ground which the applicant
could have taken on or before the date on which the
proclamation of sale was drawn up.

Explanation.—The mere absence of, or defect in,
attachment of the property sold shall not, by itself, be a
ground for setting aside a sale under this rule.”

[Emphasis Supplied]


11. The Supreme Court while dealing with the mandatory
nature of these provisions, in the case of Manilal
Mohanlal Shah, has held that under Order XXI Rule 72
CPC, a decree-holder cannot purchase the property in an
9

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


execution auction without the express permission of the
Court. Where such permission is granted, the decree-
holder is entitled to set-off the purchase money against
the decretal amount. However, where the decree-holder
purchases the property without such permission, the Court
has the discretion to set aside the sale on an application
made by the judgment-debtor or any other person whose
interests are affected by the sale. The Supreme Court
further held that the rule for deposit of 25% is mandatory
and not directory unless the purchaser is a decree holder.
Otherwise, if the deposit is not made in time, the Court
has the discretion to forfeit the deposit. The relevant
extract of this judgment, is set out below:
“8. The scheme of the Rules quoted above may be
shortly stated. A decree-holder cannot purchase
property at the court-auction in execution of his
own decree without the express permission of the
court and that when he does so with such
permission, he is entitled to a set-off, but if he
does so without such permission, then the court
has a discretion to set aside the sale upon the
application by the judgment-debtor, or any other
person whose interests are affected by the sale (Rule
72). As a matter of pure construction this provision
is obviously directory and not mandatory — See Rai
Radha Krishna v. Bisheshar Sahay [Rai Radha Krishna v.
10

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


Bisheshar Sahay, 1922 SCC OnLine PC 30 : (1921-22) 49
IA 312 : (1922) 16 LW 190]. The moment a person is
declared to be the purchaser, he is bound to
deposit 25% of the purchase money unless he
happens to be the decree-holder, in which case the
court may not require him to do so (Rule 84).

9. The provision regarding the deposit of 25% by the
purchaser other than the decree-holder is
mandatory as the language of the rule suggests.
The full amount of the purchase money must be
paid within fifteen days from the date of the sale
but the decree-holder is entitled to the advantage
of a set-off. The provision for payment is, however,
mandatory.… (Rule 85). If the payment is not made
within the period of fifteen days, the court has the
discretion to forfeit the deposit, and there the
discretion ends but the obligation of the court to
re-sell the property is imperative. A further
consequence of non-payment is that the defaulting
purchaser forfeits all claim to the property.… (Rule 86).

10. It is not denied that the purchasers had not obtained
any decree on foot of their mortgage and the claim of Rs
1,20,000 which they put forward before the execution
court had not been adjudicated upon or determined. The
mortgagees, one of whom is a pleader, applied on the
day of the sale claiming a set-off on foot of the
mortgage. The Court without applying its mind to the
question immediately passed the order allowing the set-
off. This claim was obviously not admissible under the
provisions of Rule 84 which applies only to the decree-
holder. The court had clearly no jurisdiction to allow a
set-off. The appellants misled the court into passing a
wrong order and obtaining the advantage of a set-off
while they knew perfectly well that they had got no
decree on foot of the mortgage and their claim was
undetermined. There was default in depositing 25%
of the purchase money and further there was no
payment of the full amount of the purchase money
within fifteen days from the date of the sale. Both
the deposit and the payment of the purchase
money being mandatory under the combined effect
of Rules 84 and 85, the court has the discretion to
11

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


forfeit the deposit but it was bound to re-sell the
property with the result that on default the
purchaser forfeited all claim to the property. These
provisions leave no doubt that unless the deposit and the
payment are made as required by the mandatory
provisions of the rules, there is no sale in the eye of the
law in favour of the defaulting purchaser and no right to
own and possess the property accrues to him.”

[Emphasis Supplied]

11.1 This judgment has been relied upon in the judgment
of Gas Point Petroleum case in which the factual matrix
is very similar to the facts of the present case. In the Gas
Point case, the property in question was put to auction on
18.10.2011 and the auction purchaser deposited 25% of
the amount on 03.11.2011 and the balance 75% of the
amount was deposited on 04.11.2011. The Supreme Court
after examining these timelines and the provisions of the
Act, found that there is non-compliance of Order XXI, Rule
84 and 85 of the CPC and thus held that the sale was a
nullity since the timelines were not followed. The relevant
extract of this judgment is set out below:
“ 23. While considering the issue involved in the present
appeal with respect to non-compliance of the relevant
provisions of CPC, the relevant provisions of CPC are
required to be referred to, namely, Order 21 Rules 64,
84, 85 and 86, which read as under:
12

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


“ Order XXI
Execution of Decrees and Orders
xxx xxx xxx

24. As per Order 21 Rule 84, on every sale of
immovable property the person declared to be the
purchaser shall pay immediately after such
declaration deposit of twenty-five per cent on the
amount of his purchase money and in default of
such deposit, the property shall forthwith be
resold.

25. As per Order 21 Rule 85, the full amount of
purchase money payable shall be paid by the
purchaser into court before the court closes on the
fifteenth day from the sale of the property. Thus, as
per the aforesaid provisions, the purchaser has to
deposit 25% of the sale amount immediately on
declaring to be the purchaser and the full amount of the
purchase money shall have to be paid by the purchaser
into the court before the court closes on fifteenth
day from the sale of the property.

26. In the present case admittedly the purchaser,
Respondent 1 deposited 25% of the amount on 3-11-
2011 and did not deposit 25% of the amount as
required under Order 21 Rule 84 immediately. The
auction-purchaser was required to deposit 25% of
the amount the day on which he was declared
purchaser i.e. 18-10-2011. Even the balance 75%
of the amount has not been deposited as required
under Order 21 Rule 85. The full amount of the
purchase money in the present case has been deposited
on 4.11.2011 i.e. after the period prescribed /
provided under Order 21 Rule 85. Therefore, there
is non-compliance of Order 21 Rule 84 and Rule 85
CPC.

27. In light of the aforesaid facts, few decisions of this
Court on Order 21 Rules 84 and 85 are required to be
referred to and considered.

28. In Manilal Mohanlal Shah [Manilal Mohanlal
Shah v. Sardar Sayed Ahmed Sayed Mahmad,
13

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


(1955) 1 SCR 108 : AIR 1954 SC 349] , it is
observed and held that the provision regarding the
deposit of 25% of the amount by the purchaser
other than the decree-holder is mandatory and the
full amount of the purchase money must be paid
within fifteen days from the date of the sale. It is
further observed and held that if the payment is
not made within the period of fifteen days, the
Court has the discretion to forfeit the deposit, and
there the discretion ends but the obligation of the
Court to resell the property is imperative.

xxx xxx xxx

30. The decision of this Court in Manilal Mohanlal Shah
[Manilal Mohanlal Shah v. Sardar Sayed Ahmed Sayed
Mahmad, (1955) 1 SCR 108 : AIR 1954 SC 349] fell for
consideration before this Court in the subsequent
decision in Rosali V. [Rosali V. v. TAICO Bank,
(2009) 17 SCC 690 : (2011) 2 SCC (Civ) 626] In
the said decision this Court interpreted the word
“immediately” in Order 21 Rule 84. In the said
decision, this Court considered para 11 of the decision in
Manilal Mohanlal Shah [Manilal Mohanlal Shah v. Sardar
Sayed Ahmed Sayed Mahmad, (1955) 1 SCR 108 : AIR
1954 SC 349] in para 20 as under : (Rosali V. case
[Rosali V. v. TAICO Bank, (2009) 17 SCC 690 : (2011) 2
SCC (Civ) 626] , SCC p. 695)

“20. What would be the meaning of the term
“immediately” came up for consideration before this
Court, as noticed hereinbefore, in Manilal Mohanlal
Shah [Manilal Mohanlal Shah v. Sardar Sayed Ahmed
Sayed Mahmad, (1955) 1 SCR 108 : AIR 1954 SC 349]
wherein it was held : (AIR pp. 351-52, para 11)

‘11. Having examined the language of the relevant
rules and the judicial decisions bearing upon the
subject we are of opinion that the provisions of
the rules requiring the deposit of 25 per cent of
the purchase money immediately, on the person
being declared as a purchaser and the payment
of the balance within 15 days of the sale are
mandatory and upon non-compliance with these
provisions there is no sale at all. The rules do not
14

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


contemplate that there can be any sale in favour of a
purchaser without depositing 25 per cent of the
purchase money in the first instance and the balance
within 15 days. When there is no sale within the
contemplation of these rules, there can be no question
of material irregularity in the conduct of the sale. Non-
payment of the price on the part of the defaulting
purchaser renders the sale proceedings as a complete
nullity. The very fact that the Court is bound to resell
the property in the event of a default shows that the
previous proceedings for sale are completely wiped out
as if they do not exist in the eye of the law. We hold,
therefore, that in the circumstances of the present
case there was no sale and the purchasers acquired no
rights at all.’ ”

31. Applying the law laid down by this Court in
the aforesaid decisions to the facts of the case on
hand, it is evident that there is non-compliance of
mandatory provisions of Order 21 Rule 84 and
Order 21 Rule 85 and therefore, the sale was
vitiated.”

[Emphasis Supplied]

11.2 The Supreme Court in Balram Son of Bhasa Ram
case has, while discussing Manilal case, has interpreted
the word ‘immediately’ which occurs in Rule 84 of Order
XXI of the CPC to hold that these words imply that the
provision is mandatory and non-compliance with these
provisions means that there is no sale at all. It was further
held that the provision of Rule 85 of Order XXI of the CPC
15

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


being mandatory, its non-compliance renders the sale
proceedings a nullity in the following terms:
“6. In Manilal Mohanlal Shah v. Sardar Sayed
Ahmed Sayed Mahamad [(1955) 1 SCR 108 : AIR
1954 SC 349] this Court examined the scheme of
the provisions of Rules 84, 85 and 86 of Order 21
Code of Civil Procedure and held as under: (SCR pp.
112-17)

xxx xxx xxx

Having examined the language of the relevant rules and
the judicial decisions bearing upon the subject we are of
opinion that the provisions of the rules requiring the
deposit of 25 per cent of the purchase money
immediately on the person being declared as a
purchaser and the payment of the balance within
15 days of the sale are mandatory and upon non-
compliance with these provisions there is no sale
at all. The rules do not contemplate that there can be
any sale in favour of a purchaser without depositing 25
per cent of the purchase money in the first instance and
the balance within 15 days. When there is no sale within
the contemplation of these rules, there can be no
question, of material irregularity in the conduct of the
sale. Non-payment of the price on the part of the
defaulting purchaser renders the sale proceedings
as a complete nullity. The very fact that the Court
is bound to resell the property in the event of a
default shows that the previous proceedings for
sale are completely wiped out as if they do not
exist in the eye of law. We hold, therefore, that in
the circumstances of the present case there was no
sale and the purchasers acquired no rights at all….

7. It is to be noted that the argument that it is only
a material irregularity in the sale to attract Rule 90
instead of Rule 85 was expressly rejected; and it
was clearly held that Rule 85 being mandatory, its
non-compliance renders the sale proceedings a
complete nullity requiring the executing court to
proceed under Rule 86 and property has to be
16

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


resold unless the judgment-debtor satisfies the
decree by making the payment before the resale.
The argument that the executing court has
inherent power to extend time on the ground of its
own mistake was also expressly rejected. In our
opinion the contentions of the learned counsel for the
appellant are fully negatived by this decision of the
Court.

[Emphasis Supplied]

12. The learned counsel for the respondent has relied
upon the judgment in the Ram Karan Gupta case to
submit that the Supreme Court found that the auction in
the case of Ram Karan Gupta was not vitiated in view of
the dates of deposit. This Court is unable to agree. In the
Ram Karan Gupta case, the facts reflect that the auction
sale was held on 08.10.2010 and the auction purchaser
deposited 25% on 08.10.2010 and the balance was
deposited on 23.10.2010. Thus the auction purchaser
deposited 25% immediately on the very day of the sale
and remaining 75% within the next 15 days. Since the
timelines were adhered to, the Supreme Court found that
the auction sale had become absolute and could not be set
aside. The relevant extract is set out thus:
17

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


“3. Decree-holders filed execution petition and vide order
dated 20-11-2009, the auction-sale was scheduled to be
held on 9-1-2010. However, objector/judgment-Debtor 2
Shri Ram Karan Gupta (the appellant herein) moved an
application seeking stay of auction-sale scheduled to be
held on 9-1-2010 and a joint application was moved by
the decree-holders and judgment-debtors, wherein it was
disclosed that judgment-Debtor 2 had agreed to
purchase the suit property, as such, the auction-sale be
adjourned. Later on, judgment-Debtor 2 failed to comply
with the terms and conditions of the compromise and,
therefore, a fresh process for auction-sale was issued
and the auction-sale was scheduled to be held on 4-7-
2010. Due to various reasons, it did not materialise.
Later, auction-sale was scheduled to be held on 8-
10-2010 and the auction was completed and the
auction-purchaser M/s J.S. Exim Ltd. (the first
respondent herein) was found to be the highest
bidder for a bid amount of Rs 9.60 crores. The
auction-purchaser deposited Rs 2.40 crores by way
of 27 demand drafts of even date towards 25% of
the bid amount. The court auctioneer placed on
record the record of the auction proceedings held
on 8-10-2010.

4. Later, the auction-purchaser moved an application for
depositing the remaining 75% of the sale price/bid
amount of the suit property and the application was
allowed and 75% of the sale amount was deposited
by the auction-purchaser on 23-10-2010 in State
Bank of India, Tees Hazari Court, Delhi.

xxx xxx xxx

6. The auction-purchaser refuted all those
contentions and submitted that 25% of the bid
amount was deposited on the date of auction after
conclusion of the auction-sale proceeding and the
remaining 75% of the bid amount was deposited
on 23-10-2010. Further, it was pointed out that the
auction-purchaser had got prepared the demand drafts of
Rs 2.50 crores in the name of the court auctioneer. But,
later on, it was disclosed by the court auctioneer that the
demand drafts should be issued in the name of the
competent authority, consequently, the auction-
18

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


purchaser got prepared the said demand drafts on 8-10-
2010 and handed over the same to the court auctioneer.
Further, it was also pointed out that the words occurring
“shall pay” and “immediately” do not mean that 25% of
the bid amount should be paid at the fall of the hammer.
Further, it was also pointed out that the auction-sale
could be set aside only on the ground of material
irregularity or fraud that had resulted in substantial
injury to the applicant.

7. The executing court elaborately considered the
various contentions raised by the parties and
perused the documents and took the view that the
auction-purchaser had deposited 25% of the bid
amount as mandated by Order 21 Rule 84 CPC.
Further, it was also held that the remaining 75% of
the bid amount was also deposited by the auction-
purchaser on 23-10-2010 in terms of Order 21 Rule 85
CPC. The Court, therefore, rejected the objection
raised by the appellant-judgment-debtor and
confirmed the auction, vide its order dated 24-3-
2011.

xxx xxx xxx

10. Shri Ranjit Kumar, learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the appellant, submitted that the auction-purchaser
had not complied with the mandatory provisions of Order
21 Rules 84 and Rules 85 CPC, inasmuch as he did not
deposit 25% of the bid amount immediately on the
fall of the hammer. It was pointed out that 25% of
the bid amount was deposited only on 11-10-2010
and non-compliance with the abovementioned
statutory provisions has vitiated the auction-sale. In
support of his contentions, reliance was placed on the
judgments of this Court in Manilal Mohanlal Shah v.
Sardar Sayed Ahmed Sayed Mahmad [AIR 1954 SC 349]
and Balram v. Ilam Singh [(1996) 5 SCC 705 : AIR 1996
SC 2781] .
xxx xxx xxx

13. Shri C.A. Sundaram, learned Senior Counsel
appearing for the respondent, submitted that this Court
shall not interfere with the concurrent findings rendered
by the courts below. The learned Senior Counsel
19

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


submitted that the auction-purchaser deposited
25% of the bid amount on 8-10-2010 and further
deposited the remaining amount i.e. 75% of the
bid amount on 23-10-2010. The learned Senior
Counsel pointed out that the mandate of Order 21
Rules 84 and Rules 85 CPC was complied with in
letter and spirit and the court auctioneer was
satisfied that the entire amount had been paid. The
learned Senior Counsel submitted that the word
“immediately” occurring in Order 21 Rule 84 CPC
was expanded by this Court in Rosali V. v. Taico
Bank [(2009) 17 SCC 690 : (2011) 2 SCC (Civ) 626 :
AIR 2007 SC 998] . It was pointed out that, in the
present case, 27 drafts of Rs 2.40 crores had been paid
to the court auctioneer on 8-10-2010, which is reflected
in the report of the court auctioneer dated 8-10-
2010. The balance amount was also deposited in
accordance with Order 21 Rule 85 CPC. The learned
Senior Counsel submitted that there is no bona fide in
the offer made by the appellant and, if, had any
genuine interest for avoiding the sale, the amount
offered should have been deposited before the
confirmation of sale and within the time stipulated
in Order 21 Rule 92(2) CPC.

14. We are in full agreement with the order passed
by the executing court as well as the High Court
that the auction-purchaser had deposited 25% of
the amount on 8-10-2010. When the auction is for
such a large amount, running in crores of rupees, nobody
can expect the auction-purchaser to pay the amount in
cash on the fall of the hammer. So far as the instant case
is concerned, facts would reveal that the auction-
purchaser had paid Rs 2.40 crores, may not be in cash,
but by way of drafts on 8-10-2010 and the balance
amount i.e. 75 % of the bid amount was also paid
on 23-10-2010, consequently, in our view, the
auction-purchaser had complied with the
provisions of Order 21 Rules 84 and Rules 85 CPC.

xxx xxx xxx

18. Order 21 Rule 92 CPC provides for confirmation
of sale, as also setting aside the sale, which reads
as follows:
20

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


“ 92. Sale when to become absolute or be set
aside .—(1) Where no application is made under Rule
89, Rule 90 or Rule 91, or where such application is
made and disallowed, the court shall make an order
confirming the sale, and thereupon the sale shall
become absolute:

Provided that, where any property is sold in execution
of a decree pending the final disposal of any claim to,
or any objection to the attachment of, such property,
the court shall not confirm such sale until the final
disposal of such claim or objection…”

xxx xxx xxx

23. We have already indicated that the rule is in
the nature of a concession shown to the judgment-
debtor, so he has to strictly comply with the
requirements thereof and a sale will not be set
aside unless the entire amount specified in sub-
rule (1) is deposited within 60 days from the date
of the sale and, if it is beyond 60 days, the Court
cannot allow the application. We have already found
that the appellant-judgment-debtor did not pay the
amount within the stipulated time and he only made an
application on 1-12-2010 without depositing the amount
and hence the Court cannot entertain such an application
and bound to confirm the sale which, in this case, the
Court did on 23-10-2010.”

[Emphasis Supplied]

13. In the present case, in view of the fact that the
mandatory timeline of depositing the entire purchase
th
money before the 15 day from the sale of the property
has not been adhered to by respondent No.2/auction
purchaser. Given the settled legal position, the auction so
held cannot be sustained.
21

HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:60257
WP No. 22058 of 2024


CNR: KAHC010450842024


14. Accordingly, the petition is allowed. The Impugned
Order and consequently the auction is set aside. All
pending applications stand closed.
Digitally signed by
TARA VITASTA GANJU
Location: HIGH COURT
OF KARNATAKA


(TARA VITASTA GANJU)
JUDGE
KS
List No.: 2 Sl No.: 4






22