Bharatiya Pratiraksha Mazdoor Singh vs M/o Defence

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016



Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi

O.A. No.1751/2016
M.A. No.3362/2017

Order reserved on : 08.09.2026
Order pronounced on: 26.10.2026


Hon’ble Dr. Chhabilendra Roul, Member (A)
Hon’ble Mr. Rajveer Singh Verma, Member (J)


Bharatiya Pratiraksha Mazdoor Sangh
An all India federation of Defence Workers
2-A, Navin Market, Kanpur-1, U.P.
Through its General Secreaty
Sh. M.P. Singh
Aged about 59
S/o Late Babu Ram Singh Working as Labotary Technician
Ordance Factory Kanpur, U.P.

2. T.D. Joshi
S/o Sh. M.D. Joshi
Aged about 50 years R/o 1/583, Sector-1,
Vasundhara, Ghaziabad (U.P.)
Working as Labotary Technician
Ordance Factory Muradnagar, Ghaziabad, U.P.

3. Dashrath Uttam
S/o Late Faqir Lal Uttam,
Aged about 59 years
R/o 40A, MIG Vishwa Bank Colony,
Barra Karrahi Road, Kanpur, U.P.
Working as Labotary Technician
Ordance Factory Kanpur, U.P.

4. Mrs. Kumkum Gupta
W/o Late Shyam Prakash Gupta
Aged about 48 years
R/o G-I, 470 Armapur Estate, Kanpur, U.P.
Working as Labotary Technician
Ordance Factory Kanpur, U.P.


Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR

2
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016


5. Raj Kumar James Chester
S/o Late Sukhdas Chester
Aged about 61 years
R/o Plot No. 38, Ghandi Gram
P.O. Harjinder Nagar, Kanpur, U.P.
Retired as Labotary Technician

6. Angel Parvez
S/o Late Chunni Lal
Aged about 54 years
R/o 149, South Vansathli, Ballupur
Dehradun, Uttarakhand
Working as Labotary Technician
Ordance Factory Rajpur Dehradun,U.K.
...Applicants

(By Advocate : Shri Ramesh Rawat, Shri Sudarshan Rajan,
Ms. Kashish and Ms. Srishthi Thapliy al)

Versus

1. Union of India,
through the Secretary,
Ministry of Defence,
Sena Bhawan, New Delhi.

2. Ordnance Factory Board,
represented by Director General of
Ordnance Factories,
Ministry of Defence,
Government of India,
10A, S.K. Bose Road, Kolkatta.

3. Director General Health Services,
Ministry of Defence, Government of India,
10A, S.K. Bose Road, Kolkotta.

4. Ministry of Finance
Department of Expenditure
North Block, New Delhi
...Respondents
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR


(By Advocate : Dr. Ch. Samsuddin Khan)

3
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016


ORDER
By Hon’ble Mr. Rajveer Singh Verma, Member (J) :-

The applicants have approached the Tribunal under
section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985,
seeking the following relief(s) :-
“(a)This Hon’ble Tribunal may be graciously pleased to declare
that all the applicants herein and the members of the First
Applicant, holding the post of Lab Technicians are entitled to
the higher grade Pay of Rs.4200/- in the existing post on the
basis of the Revised Recruitment Rules, they having alternate
qualifications as contained in the 1989 Recruitment Rules, on
the strength of the DoPT OM dated 31-03-2010 and also as per
the judgment in the case of Ajay Jhadav Vs. Government of Goa
(Supra).
(b) Direct the respondents to grant the cost of the litigation to the
applicants.
(d) pass such other suitable order or orders as the Tribunal may
deem fit to meet the ends of justice.”

2. The brief factual matrix of the case is that under SRO
18(E) dated 04.05.1989, the Recruitment Rules for non-
industrial Group C paramedical staff in Ordnance and
Ordnance Equipment Factories were notified. The post of
Laboratory Technician was placed in the pay scale of 1320-
2040. The prescribed essential qualifications included
alternate options: a B.Sc. with Chemistry and 5 years of
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
clinical laboratory training, or Matriculation/equivalent
with Physics and Chemistry along with a Diploma in

4
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

Clinical Laboratory Technique/Practice conferred by a State
Medical Faculty, or for ex-servicemen, a Class 1 or Class 2
Laboratory Technician certificate .
th
3. Following the recommendations of the 5 CPC, the
pay scale of Laboratory Technicians was revised from
Rs.1320-2040/- to Rs.1400-2300/- and subsequently
replaced by the scale of Rs.4500-7000/-. The Ministry of
Defence notified SRO 88 dated 03.08.2005 amending the
Recruitment Rules. Under these amended rules, the direct
recruitment qualification was revised to a B.Sc. in
Biochemistry, Microbiology, Life Science, or equivalent,
along with a Diploma in Medical Laboratory Technology,
one year of laboratory experience, and working knowledge
of computers.
4. On 31.12.2010, the Department of Personnel and
Training issued an OM laying down guidelines for
amending recruitment rules. Paragraph 3.1.3 of Part III
explicitly provided that existing incumbents holding feeder
posts on a regular basis prior to the revision of eligibility
service or qualifications would retain their eligibility and
not be adversely affected by the new rules.
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
5. In an earlier round of litigation in O.A. No. 2660/2012
filed by the applicant association, the Tribunal vide order

5
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

dated 11.10.2013 directed the respondents to take a final
decision regarding representations filed for pay parity,
observing that existing incumbents were not debarred from
consideration for higher scales merely because recruitment
rules had been revised.
th
6. Following the implementation of the 6 CPC,
replacement pay structures were introduced and vide a
communication dated 15.10.2014, the Department of
Defence Production conveyed the approval of the
Department of Expenditure to revise the pay scale of
Laboratory Technicians working in Ordnance Factory
Hospitals from Grade Pay 2800 in Pay Band 1 to Grade Pay
4200 in Pay Band 2 with effect from 01.01.2006. However,
a condition was attached that the higher scale would
strictly be granted only to those possessing the
qualifications laid down under the 2005 Recruitment Rules.
The Ordnance Factory Board issued instructions to all
factory units conveying the decision dated 15.10.2014. This
decision resulted in employees with alternate qualifications
getting lesser grade pay of Rs.2800 and few Lab
Technicians who fulfilled the qualifications as per 2005 RRs
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
being marched over them by getting Rs.4200 Grade Pay.

6
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

7. The affected Laboratory Technicians and individual
factory management units submitted representations and
service details pointing out that senior employees recruited
prior to 2005 were being denied Grade Pay 4200 and placed
in Grade Pay 2800 solely due to the new qualification
criteria, despite performing identical duties. On 06.07.2015
the Department of Expenditure approved a cadre
restructuring for Medical Laboratory Staff in four Central
Government hospitals, granting Grade Pay 4200 to Medical
Lab Technologists. On 17.08.2015 the Office of the
Principal Controller of Accounts (Factories), Kolkata,
advised that employees lacking the revised qualifications
under SRO 88 of 2005 could not be granted Grade Pay
Rs.4200/-. Further, representations submitted by one Shri
T.D. Joshi, Lab Technician, on 26.10.2015 and 14.11.2015
requesting grant of Grade Pay 4200/- w.e.f. 01.01.2006
remained unanswered, leading to the filing of the present
Original Application.
8. In support of their claim, the applicants relied upon
the judgment of the Supreme Court of in Ajay Jadhav v.
Government of Goa (1999) 9 SCC 4, wherein it was held
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
that existing incumbents recruited under prior rules
possessing alternate qualifications cannot be discriminated
against or denied identical revised pay scales when

7
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

qualifications are subsequently revised. The applicants
submitted that depriving regular employees appointed
under the 1989 rules of Grade Pay 4200 violates the
principle of equal pay for equal work and contravenes DoPT
guidelines.
9. The respondents, on the other hand, submitted that
the restriction of Grade Pay Rs.4200/- in Pay Band 2 is in
strict compliance with government directives and statutory
recruitment rules. It is submitted that in order to upgrade
the technical competence and standard of paramedical staff
across Ordnance Factory Hospitals, SRO 88 dated
03.08.2005 was notified in supersession of the 1989 rules.
The new rules prescribed higher essential educational
qualifications, specifically a B.Sc. in specified biological
sciences along with a Diploma in Medical Laboratory
th
Technology. Following the 6 CPC recommendations, the
general replacement pay structure for the post of
Laboratory Technician was fixed in Pay Band 1 with Grade
Pay 2800. Upon detailed review, the Ministry of Finance,
Department of Expenditure, agreed to upgrade the pay
scale for Laboratory Technicians in Ordnance Factory
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
Hospitals to Grade Pay Rs.4200/- in Pay Band 2 with
retrospective effect from 01.01.2006. However, this
financial benefit was explicitly conditional upon the

8
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

candidate strictly possessing the upgraded educational
qualifications prescribed under SRO 88 of 2005.
10. On 17.10.2014, the Ordnance Factory Board issued
directives to all field units to implement the upgraded
Grade Pay of Rs.4200 only after verifying that the
incumbent fulfilled the mandatory qualifications laid down
in SRO 88 of 2005. 17.08.2015, the Principal Controller of
Accounts (Factories), Kolkata, confirmed that under the
explicit terms of the Ministry of Defence letter dated
15.10.2014, incumbents lacking the qualifications
prescribed under SRO 88 of 2005 are not eligible for Grade
Pay 4200. The respondents contended that the decision to
grant a higher grade pay of Rs.4200/- is an executive policy
decision tied directly to higher professional entry
qualifications. Those employees who do not meet the
mandatory criteria under SRO 88 of 2005 remain properly
placed in Grade Pay Rs.2800/-, and, therefore, no illegal
discrimination or administrative error has occurred. It is
submitted that the RRs of 1989 have been superseded by
the RRs published on 03.08.2005 and the respondents
have pre actively taken up the issue for grant of upgraded
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
scale to all the Laboratory Technicians, however, MOF and
DOE have not agreed to the same.

9
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

11. It is submitted that paragraph 3.1.3 of part 3 of the
DOP&T OM pertains to eligibility service for promotion from
feeder grade and the same is not relevant in any context to
the present matter.
12. In rejoinder, the applicant submitted that the
alternate qualifications prescribed under the 1989 rules
were treated as fully equivalent for all operational and
functional purposes. For over so many years, all Laboratory
Technicians performed identical duties and held equal
status regardless of whether they entered service with a
B.Sc. degree or matriculation with diploma/certificate
qualifications. SRO 88 dated 03.08.2005 amended the
recruitment qualifications prospectively and it did not and
could not invalidate the original appointment or parity
enjoyed by existing incumbents who were duly recruited
under the earlier statutory rules.
13. The stipulation inserted by the respondents restricting
Grade Pay Rs.4200/- only to those possessing 2005
qualifications creates an artificial and unconstitutional
divide within a single cadre. Senior technicians who have
rendered decades of service are placed in Grade Pay
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
Rs.2800/-, whereas junior recruits performing the exact
same duties receive Grade Pay Rs.4200/-. In analogous

10
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

Central Government hospitals, cadre structures were
revised to grant higher grade pay to existing laboratory
personnel to establish parity.

14. We have heard learned counsel for the parties at
length and have perused the pleadings and the documents
placed on record.

15. On the pleadings, the following questions arise for
determination:

(i) Whether the present Original Application is barred in
view of the order dated 11.10.2013 passed by this Tribunal
in O.A. No. 2660/2012, or by limitation;

(ii) What is the nature of the decision conveyed by the
Ministry of Defence vide MoD ID No. 50(7)/2012-
D(Estt./NG) dated 15.10.2014 and implemented by the
Ordnance Factory Board vide letter dated 17.10.2014, and
whether the condition requiring possession of the
qualifications prescribed under SRO 88 dated 03.08.2005
is a valid basis for confining Grade Pay Rs. 4200 to a
section of the Laboratory Technicians;
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR

(iii) Whether the applicants are entitled to Grade Pay Rs.
4200 on the strength of the DoP&T Office Memorandum

11
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

dated 31.12.2010, the judgment in Ajay Jadhav v.
Government of Goa (supra), or the cadre restructuring of
Medical Laboratory Staff in Central Government hospitals;
and (iv)What relief, if any, the applicants are entitled to.

Question (i): Maintainability and limitation

16. O.A. No. 2660/2012 was filed by the first applicant
Association along with four Laboratory Technicians of the
Ordnance Factory Hospital, Kanpur, one of whom was Shri
Tara Dutt Joshi, whose representations dated 26.10.2015
and 14.11.2015 are referred to in paragraph 7 above. In
that O.A., the prayer was for the higher scale to all
Laboratory Technicians irrespective of their qualifications.
The Tribunal did not adjudicate the entitlement. It noticed
th
that the 5 CPC had recommended two scales, one for
Laboratory Technicians with the upgraded qualification of
B.Sc. with a Diploma in Medical Laboratory Technology and
another for those with the earlier qualification, and
observed that the Pay Commission had not debarred
existing incumbents from consideration for the higher scale
where they possessed the required qualification. The
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
respondents were directed to take a final decision on the
representations within three months.

12
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

17. The decision dated 15.10.2014 was taken thereafter.
It granted Grade Pay Rs. 4200 with effect from 01.01.2006
but confined it to incumbents possessing the qualifications
under SRO 88 of 2005. The present challenge is directed
against that condition, and against its reiteration by the
Principal Controller of Accounts (Factories), Kolkata on
17.08.2015. These are fresh decisions which were not, and
could not have been, an issue in O.A. No. 2660/2012. The
earlier order, therefore, does not operate as res judicata .
Since the claim relates to the rate of pay drawn month after
month, the grievance is in the nature of a continuing
wrong, and the O.A., filed in 2016, is within time so far as
the claim to the grade pay itself is concerned, though any
monetary consequence would be governed by the settled
principle that arrears are ordinarily restricted to a period of
three years preceding the filing of the application (Union of
India v. Tarsem Singh, (2008) 8 SCC 648). Question (i) is
answered in favour of the applicants.

Question (ii): Nature of the decision dated 15.10.2014
and validity of the qualification condition.

18. The OFB letter dated 17.10.2014 records that the
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
competent authority has agreed to revise the pay scale of
the post of Laboratory Technician in the hospitals of the

13
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

DGOF organisation from PB-1 with Grade Pay Rs. 2800 to
PB-2 with Grade Pay Rs. 4200 w.e.f. 01.01.2006, and in the
same breath directs the units to ensure that only those
Laboratory Technicians who possess the qualifications
under SRO 88 of 2005 are given the revised scale. The
same position was recorded on behalf of the Official Side
before the National Anomaly Committee in its meeting held
on 09.06.2015, and by the Principal Controller of Accounts
(Factories) on 17.08.2015. The applicants contend that the
revision being of the post, the condition is an executive
restriction which cannot be engrafted on the pay of the
post. The respondents contend that the higher grade pay is
a policy decision tied to the higher entry qualification.

19. The question whether educational qualification can
justify different pay for persons in the same cadre
performing the same work is not res integra . In State of
Mysore v. P. Narasinga Rao , AIR 1968 SC 349, a
Constitution Bench considered a cadre of Tracers in which
matriculates and non-matriculates had been in one scale,
and which was thereafter divided into a higher scale for
matriculates and a lower scale for non-matriculates,
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
though both did the same work. The Hon’ble High Court

14
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

had found discrimination. Reversing that view, the
Supreme Court held (at page 412 of the SCR):

"In our opinion, therefore, higher educational qualifications
such as success in the S.S.L.C. examination are relevant
considerations for fixing a higher pay scale for tracers who
have passed the S.S.L.C. examination and the classification
of two grades of tracers in the new Mysore State, one for
matriculate tracers with a higher pay scale and the other for
non-matriculate tracers with a lower pay scale is not violative
of Arts. 14 or .16 of the Constitution."

The Court also made clear (at page 411) that the selective
test must bear a reasonable relation to the suitability of the
candidate for the post or for public service. The
Constitution Bench in Mohammad Shujat Ali v. Union of
India , (1975) 3 SCC 76, likewise accepted educational
qualification as a permissible basis of classification while
cautioning that its validity depends on its nexus with the
nature and purpose of the classification.

20. The principle has been applied to Laboratory
Technicians by the jurisdictional High Court. In Delhi
Medical Technical Employees Association (Regd.) v.
Union of India , W.P.(C) 12205/2019, decided on
03.02.2026, the Hon'ble Delhi High Court upheld the
th
orders of this Tribunal declining the 5 CPC scale to
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
Laboratory Technicians of the MCD, whose recruitment
qualification was matriculation, on parity with Central
Government Laboratory Technicians, whose qualification

15
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

was a B.Sc. degree. The Hon'ble High Court held in
paragraph 14:
"Such a distinction in the entry-level academic requirements
constitutes an 'intelligible differentia'. It is well-settled that a
difference in prescribed minimum qualifications is a valid
ground for classification."

and, rejecting the very contention urged before us in
rejoinder, held in paragraph 17:
"The contention that the recommendations of the 5th CPC
regarding qualifications were only prospective also does not
advance the Petitioners' case. The implementation of Pay
Commission recommendations is a matter of policy, subject to
adoption by the competent authority and alignment with
existing recruitment rules and cadre structures."

21. Learned counsel for the applicants sought to
distinguish that judgment on the ground that it concerned
two different employers, whereas the present case concerns
a single cadre under one employer. The distinction does not
avail the applicants, since Narasinga Rao (supra) itself
was a case of a single cadre divided on the basis of
educational qualification. We are also unable to accept that
the condition is unrelated to the object of the revision. The
th
5 CPC, as noticed in O.A. No. 2660/2012, recommended
the higher scale for Laboratory Technicians with B.Sc. and
a Diploma in Medical Laboratory Technology and placed
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
those with the earlier qualification in the lower scale. SRO
88 of 2005 gave effect to that recommendation by
prescribing the upgraded qualification, and the decision

16
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

dated 15.10.2014 attached the upgraded pay to it. The
differentiation thus has its source in the recommendation
of the expert body and bears a rational relation to the
object of upgrading the professional standard of the cadre,
which is the object pleaded by the respondents in
paragraph 11 of their reply.

22. We are also conscious of the limits of judicial review
in matters of pay. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has
consistently held that equation of posts and fixation of pay
scales are primarily for the Executive and expert bodies,
and that Courts and Tribunals interfere only where the
decision is shown to be arbitrary, mala fide or vitiated by a
grave error ( State of U.P. v. J.P. Chaurasia , (1989) 1 SCC
121; Union of India v. Dineshan K.K. , (2008) 1 SCC 586;
Union of India v. Indian Navy Civilian Design Officers
Association , (2023) 19 SCC 482). The doctrine of equal pay
for equal work, though a constitutional goal flowing from
Articles 14, 16 and 39(d) ( Randhir Singh v. Union of
India , (1982) 1 SCC 618), requires identity in all relevant
respects, including qualifications and mode of recruitment,
and not merely in the duties performed ( State of Punjab v.
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
Jagjit Singh , (2017) 1 SCC 148 ; State of Bihar v. Bihar
Secondary Teachers Struggle Committee , 2019 INSC

17
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

680). On the material before us, the condition attached to
the decision dated 15.10.2014 cannot be termed arbitrary.

23. That, however, does not conclude the matter. The
applicants were appointed on a regular basis under the
statutory rules notified vide SRO 18(E) dated 04.05.1989,
which recognised the alternate qualifications they possess
as equally valid entry routes. The upgraded grade pay has
been given effect from 01.01.2006, that is, from a date
anterior to the decision dated 15.10.2014 and to the
representations of the applicants. The result, as pleaded in
paragraph 13 above and not disputed by the respondents,
is that Laboratory Technicians senior in the cadre are
drawing Grade Pay Rs. 2800 while their juniors on the
same post draw Grade Pay Rs. 4200. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Jai Prakash Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh
(decided in September 2026) has reiterated that a junior on
the same post being paid more than a senior requires
justification with reference to valid factors such as
qualifications for the post, source of recruitment,
experience and responsibility. In the present case, the
justification offered is the difference in qualification, which,
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
as held above, is a permissible factor. The disparity is,
therefore, not illegal, but it is an anomaly in the cadre
which the respondents themselves have been unable to

18
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

resolve, as is evident from their averment that the issue of
grant of the upgraded scale to all Laboratory Technicians
was taken up but not agreed to by the Ministry of Finance
and the Department of Expenditure. The appropriate forum
for removing such an anomaly is the expert or anomaly
machinery and not this Tribunal, as held by the Hon'ble
Delhi High Court in paragraph 21 of its judgment dated
03.02.2026.

Question (iii): The DoP&T OM dated 31.12.2010, Ajay
Jadhav, and parity with Central Government hospitals.

24. Reliance on paragraph 3.1.3 of Part III of the DoP&T
OM No. AB.14017/48/2010-Estt.(RR) dated 31.12.2010 is
misplaced. That paragraph is headed "Retention of existing
eligibility service" and provides that where the eligibility
service for promotion is enhanced and the change is likely
to affect persons holding feeder posts on a regular basis, a
note preserving the existing eligibility service for them
"could be included in the revised rules". It concerns
eligibility service for promotion, is enabling in nature, and
has no bearing on the pay of the post. The objection of the
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
respondents recorded in paragraph 11 above is well
founded. We note, however, that paragraph 3.1.4.1 of the

19
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

same OM, under the heading "Consideration of the
incumbents while upgradation", provides in clause (ii):
"Where all posts in a particular grade have been granted a
higher replacement pay scale/ grade pay, as per upgradation
recommended by the 6th CPC, suitability of the incumbents
need not be assessed for granting them the higher replacement
scale/ grade pay."

This clause speaks of upgradations recommended by the
th
6 CPC and of assessment of suitability. The upgradation
in the present case flows from a decision of the Department
of Expenditure taken in 2014 on the reference arising out
of O.A. No. 2660/2012, and paragraph 3.1.4.2 of the OM
separately provides that assessment continues to be
necessary in cadre reviews and restructuring not covered
th
by the 6 CPC recommendations. The OM, therefore does
not on its own force entitle the applicants to the grade pay.
It is nonetheless a relevant consideration which the
respondents have not shown to have been examined while
restricting the upgraded scale of the post to a section of its
incumbents.

25. In Ajay Jadhav v. Government of Goa , Civil Appeal
No. 5043 of 1999, decided on 14.09.1999, [1999] Supp. 2
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
SCR 371, the appellant was a teacher holding a Post
Graduate Diploma, which was one of the alternate
qualifications prescribed for the post, and was denied the

20
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

Grade-I scale on the basis of a later circular confining it to
holders of a Post Graduate Degree. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court allowed the appeal because teachers having the same
qualification were being paid the higher scale and the
circular had already been set aside by the Hon’ble High
Court at the instance of three similarly placed teachers and
a judgment accepted by the State. The Court observed (at
page 376):
"There has been no reply to this submission of the appellant
as to how other teachers with the same qualification are
getting higher pay-scale of Grade-I Teacher. It appears to us
that it is a clear case of discrimination."


26. The decision thus rests on unexplained discrimination
among persons holding the same qualification. It does not
lay down that incumbents appointed on alternate
qualifications are entitled to a pay scale subsequently
linked to a higher qualification. No material has been
placed before us to show that any Laboratory Technician
holding only the 1989 alternate qualifications has been
granted Grade Pay Rs. 4200 as the replacement scale of the
post. The judgment is, therefore, distinguishable on facts.

27. The applicants also rely on the cadre restructuring of
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
Medical Laboratory Staff in four Central Government
hospitals approved by the Department of Expenditure on

21
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

06.07.2015. That restructuring relates to a different cadre
under a different Ministry, effected through a separate
cadre review with its own recruitment rules. Parity cannot
be claimed across cadres on that basis alone, as held by
the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in its judgment dated
03.02.2026. The manner in which existing incumbents of
that cadre were placed in the restructured grades is,
however, a relevant input for the respondents when
examining the anomaly in the cadre of Laboratory
Technicians in Ordnance Factory hospitals.

Question (iv): Relief

28. In view of the foregoing discussion, the applicants who
do not possess the qualifications prescribed under SRO 88
dated 03.08.2005 are not entitled to the declaration sought
in prayer (a). At the same time, the record discloses that (a)
the upgraded grade pay has been granted to the post with
effect from 01.01.2006, (b) the condition has produced a
situation where senior incumbents appointed under the
statutory rules of 1989 draw lower grade pay than their
juniors on the same post, (c) paragraph 3.1.4 of the DoP&T
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
OM dated 31.12.2010 and the treatment of existing
incumbents in the cadre restructuring of 06.07.2015 have
not been shown to have been considered, and (d) this

22
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

Tribunal had, as far back as 11.10.2013, observed that it
would be desirable to incentivize the acquisition of the
higher qualification by existing staff, a course which the
respondents do not appear to have adopted. The
respondents themselves have stated that they had taken up
the grant of the upgraded scale to all Laboratory
Technicians. In these circumstances, a direction for a
reasoned re-examination is warranted.

29. Accordingly, the Original Application is disposed of
with the following directions:

(i) The prayer for a declaration that all the applicants
and the members of the first applicant are entitled to Grade
Pay Rs. 4200 irrespective of their qualifications is declined.

(ii) Such of the applicants as possessed, on 01.01.2006,
the qualifications prescribed under SRO 88 dated
03.08.2005 shall, if not already so placed, be granted Grade
Pay Rs. 4200 in PB-2 with effect from 01.01.2006, with
consequential benefits, in terms of the decision dated
15.10.2014.

(iii) Such of the applicants as have acquired, or may
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
hereafter acquire, the qualifications prescribed under SRO
88 dated 03.08.2005 shall be granted Grade Pay Rs. 4200

23
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

(now the corresponding Level in the Pay Matrix) with effect
from the date of acquisition of the qualification.

(iv) Respondent No. 1, in consultation with the
Department of Expenditure and the Department of
Personnel and Training, shall examine afresh the case of
the remaining incumbents who were regularly appointed
under the Recruitment Rules notified vide SRO 18(E) dated
04.05.1989, taking into account the observations made in
this order, the provisions of paragraph 3.1.4 of Part III of
the DoP&T OM dated 31.12.2010, the manner in which
existing incumbents were placed in the cadre restructuring
of Medical Laboratory Staff approved on 06.07.2015, and
the anomaly of senior incumbents drawing lower grade pay
than their juniors on the same post, including by placing
the matter before the Departmental Anomaly Committee if
so advised. A reasoned and speaking order shall be passed
and communicated to the applicants within a period of four
months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this
order.

(v) In case the decision under direction (iv) results in
Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR
grant of any benefit, the monetary benefit shall be
restricted to the period commencing three years prior to the
date of filing of this Original Application.

24
Item 38 (C-V)
OA No.1751/2016

(vi) If the applicants remain aggrieved by the decision so
taken, they shall be at liberty to assail it in appropriate
proceedings in accordance with law.
30. All pending MAs, if any, shall stand disposed of. There
shall be no order as to costs.


(Rajveer Singh Verma) (Dr.Chhabilendra Roul)
Member (J) Member (A)


‘rk’

Digitally signed by
RACHNA KAPOOR
RACHNA KAPOOR